Douglas Murray and Jonathan Pageau | EP 290
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 июн 2024
- Jonathan Pageau, Douglas Murray, and Dr Jordan B Peterson discuss our hierarchies of perception, existence, faith, and whether meaning is a self evident truth or something intangible that is sought in vain.
Jonathan Pageau is a French-Canadian liturgical artist and icon carver, known for his work featured in museums across the world. He carves Eastern Orthodox and other traditional images, and teaches an online carving class. He also runs a RUclips channel dedicated to the exploration of symbolism across history and religion.
Douglas Murray is a British political commentator and author. In 2007 he founded a think tank called the Center for Social Cohesion, which later became part of the Henry Jackson Society. Currently he is an associate editor for the magazine the Spectator, where he became somewhat infamous after organizing a competition in which entrants were invited to submit offensive poems about Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, with a top prize of £1,000. He has authored five books, the most recent of which being “The War on the West.”
Dr Peterson's extensive catalog is available now on DailyWire+: utm.io/ueSXh
-Links-
For Douglass Murray:
Website: douglasmurray.net/
(Book) The War on the West: www.amazon.com/War-West-Dougl...
(Book) The Strange Death of Europe: www.amazon.com/Strange-Death-...
For Jonathan Pageau:
Icon Carving: www.pageaucarvings.com
Podcast: www.thesymbolicworld.com
RUclips Channel: / jonathanpageau
-Chapters-
(0:00) Coming Up
(1:10) Intro
(4:18) A Precondition for a Rational World View
(10:29) The Battle of Conceptions
(14:55) Perceived Unity and the Glass
(21:58) Do Science and Religion Overlap?
(29:41) The Hierarchy of Perception and Action
(38:45) The Bible Was Not Written Forensically
(48:25) Using the Least Possible Thing to Describe the Realness of Everything
(57:07) Are We Meaning-Seeking Beings, or is There Meaning?
(1:05:56) To What Degree Does Something Exist Prior to Elaboration?
(1:12:04) The Cause of Demoralization in Our Society
(1:17:58) The Advantage of Organized Religion
// SUPPORT THIS CHANNEL //
Newsletter: mailchi.mp/jordanbpeterson.co...
Donations: jordanbpeterson.com/donate
// COURSES //
Discovering Personality: jordanbpeterson.com/personality
Self Authoring Suite: selfauthoring.com
Understand Myself (personality test): understandmyself.com
// BOOKS //
Beyond Order: 12 More Rules for Life: jordanbpeterson.com/Beyond-Order
12 Rules for Life: An Antidote to Chaos: jordanbpeterson.com/12-rules-...
Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief: jordanbpeterson.com/maps-of-m...
// LINKS //
Website: jordanbpeterson.com
Events: jordanbpeterson.com/events
Blog: jordanbpeterson.com/blog
Podcast: jordanbpeterson.com/podcast
// SOCIAL //
Twitter: / jordanbpeterson
Instagram: / jordan.b.peterson
Facebook: / drjordanpeterson
Telegram: t.me/DrJordanPeterson
All socials: linktr.ee/drjordanbpeterson
#JordanPeterson #JordanBPeterson #DrJordanPeterson #DrJordanBPeterson #dailywireplus #Science #Religion #Christianity #Bible #OrganizedReligion #Faith #DouglasMurray #Jonatha Pageau
When you see Jonathan looking around, listening and talking, you can see how much he enjoys these talks. Murray gives the challenge and Jordan is in heaven. We are truly privileged to witness this conversation.
@@bartonlee3594 that is extraordinary since he referred to a book written in 2022 in the video. Time travel perhaps? "Fled" is not what you do by driving to an airport and sitting on a flight. Your multiple comments about "Russia" and "addiction" would indicate obsession. Get help for yourself.
The aesthetics of this video are on point whoever was in charge of that ✨🙌
@@bartonlee3594 now this is a false narrative 😅😅
@@bartonlee3594 So he can't have problems or what lmao ,
@@bartonlee3594 the comment you are replying to is about Jonathan Pageau. Who is this “he” you refer to? There has been zero discussion about drug addiction in these comments nor in the video until you bring it up… makes me wonder as to who is this “he” you are referring to? Happy politicking.
Peterson, Murray AND Pagaue???!! We are blessed!! 🙏✝️
I was thinking the exact same thing. We are extremely blessed to live in such wonderful times. It's easy to think otherwise but if we truly listen to those who are the wisest amongst us we will know that these are the best times to be alive. 🙏
A great trio
Pageau
☦️
As a lifelong atheist/agnostic raised in the presbyterian church, it wasn’t until a very close family member who was Antiochian orthodox just recently passed away that I started to feel my inner architecture shift towards some longing curiosity towards orthodoxy. For whatever reason, talks like this one and others involving Jonathan Pageau have completely blown me wide-open, kicked down the doors and started remodeling my inner architecture. I’ve never been this kind of person at all, but I found myself weeping tears of joy/relief on my commute to work this morning as I listen to this. Thank you, gentlemen. Now starts my real work.
Amazing❤ Glory to God!! Orthodoxy is the one and true church of Christ. ❤
Welcome brother
Why were you an Atheist in the first place, with respect it can’t have been because of your critical thinking skills so I’m interesting how you ended up in that position.
Shed a tear myself near the end and though of the oddity of it. The conversation was beautiful art imho.
wish you luck!
50 years as a Christian…and It’s insane to me that this is the best sermon I’ve ever heard!
Amen.
That's weird.
That's RUclips.
@@thedeifiedjulius2310 can you elaborate ?
@@vinegarpisser2992 He's using a term popularly talked about with Neitzche. He's basically saying he was a christian for 50 years and regrets it. That its teachings produces a kind of hatred of the self, hence the "ressentinent morality" term. Envy and hatred producing a "self-abasement" behavior.
As a minister for over 12 years, in a time where one's efforts seem questionable, this conversation brought great reassurance to the value of my chosen pursuits and profession. Thank you.
Yes but to what end? As you say minister I suppose you are of a Protestant denomination
@alex flood I would love to hear your (a minister’s) response to this video clip below. Thx in advance ❤️
The “Anti-Christ” was never some mysterious man who was to rise to power deceiving everyone, but rather the “liberal fantasy” embodied as the “institution,” wearing the mask of care and presuming to do for people what we can do for each other - “love thy neighbor”.
ruclips.net/video/jsW8UQgFOBI/видео.html
Is the resurrection literal?
@@heads_together_crypto2422 without the resurrection, there is no Christianity. Plenty of eyewitnesses accounts to corroborate this claim. Many of the eyewitnesses chose to give up their lives at the hand of the Romans instead of denying what they saw.
@@heads_together_crypto2422 very
Keep getting Jonathan talking to all these new people. He's the best.
Check out his talk with Dr Ian mcgillchrist and thank me later.
@@thebigredwagon That was VG+ interview 👍
@Sen Dog probably fair to say that is one aspect/feature of God…and not a description of him.
@Sen Dog would you consider yourself a Christian? (I’m not claiming you’re not. as a Christian I’ve just never understood it that way as it seems to limit God because he is also beyond all being and ultimately ineffable)
@Sen Dog I’m not one to school anyone, I’m a seeker as well. , was more just curious the perspective you were coming at it from because I hadn’t heard Christian folks describe God in that way (although pageau does use similar descriptors at times but would say still different enough that this sounded unique)
Douglas Murray, regarding your notion that “there’s nothing in life that matters” I would say, submit your life to Jesus and see what happens to your life. God is everywhere. He’s in nature, He’s in the daily human experience, He’s in the human suffering, He’s in all things, but people don’t want or can’t see Him which is sad.
There was a time when I thought philosophy, psychology, metaphysics had all the answers to life and they fascinated me. Thirty years ago I was going through very hard times in my life and I couldn’t get out of it, then I thought of God. So I knelt down and cried out to Him to show me the way to find peace and … He reached out to me right away. I felt His presence and a tremendous sense of peace and I KNEW in my heart that I found what I was looking for: GOD. God is so simple and yet so profound. No use in philosophical explanations and attempts to find a meaning to life and to human existence. He is the only source!
Great talk. Douglas is not only a sharp & eloquent peer, but also astoundlingly thoughtful, adaptive & creative. His closing monologue is ridiculously powerful.
The way Jordan recognizes and respects Jonathan's wisdom is so beautiful to watch. Douglas was a brilliant guest and posed all the right questions.
You mean the way he cuts Jonathan off constantly and proceeds to talk just to hear himself talk? lol
They are all rhetoricians, obviously. Nothing they said is even the accepted creed and doctrine of single church in the world. They are just trying to invent a religious metaphysical basis for the current Christian conservative worldview, which they all like and admire for its outcomes and not for its beliefs.
Basically, at best jordan peterson is ready to call all religious stories as mere stories written by ancient hebrew psychologists who somehow knew jungian psychoanalysis.
None of them is a true christian, you know it, I know it(Even though I am a muslim) and every christian theologian of every church knows it.
They have good intentions in the sense that they want to save people from nihilism and skepticism that comes from modernity. But their attempt is not genuine nor true. Nobody believes in religion for rational reasons, no matter how much jordan peterson tries to REINVENT AND REINTERPRET AND REVISIT religion. Religious belief doesn't start from rationality nor rationalizations.
Nobody will stop having intercourse before marriage or outside marriage because of "the weird fictional true" rationalization forbids it. People do that only if the hell and heaven are true, so true that the fear of hell and the want of heaven should direct your actions.
The miracles of prophet jesus (PBUH) were not stories mr. jordan peterson, if they were stories, the belief in them becomes optional.
If all religion is PRAGMATIC AND PSYCHOLOGICALLY useful fictions, then why should it have authority ? Why can't everyone be free to make his own fictions, which might be more pragmatic and psychologically useful ?
If the pragmatic and psychologically useful fictions of a social justice/mystic leftist group provides them more moral certainty and lessens then existential angst, then why should they believe in your rationalizations ?
And then there is more to say about psychoanalytic justifications for your beliefs. Psychoanalysis is in itself a pseudo-scientific endeavor and is just a reading of effects of cultural/social/material life on human thinking, not a discovery of true human nature.
You cannot erect your new religion from a pseudoscience.
The Christianity of st. Augustin, st. peter, st. thomas aquinas and martin luther king is THE CHRISTIANITY. What you people are doing is just making a new religion out of thin air for "pragmatic" reasons. And trying to become NEW PROPHETS OF IT.
The virgin birth is true, in literal sense, and I bear witness to its truth.
@@saimbhat6243 you’re envy is showing.
@@JIMMYUNKNOWN See, your personal attacks don't convey much.
@@saimbhat6243 funny I was going to say the same about yours, despite the sheep’s clothing.
Getting married this weekend and baptized into the Orthodox Church this Pascha. God willing. Thank you so much gentleman. I was on a very very dark path. Redemption is very real to me now thanks to these holy ideas. I have nothing but love and admiration for you men and all your difficult and courageous work. Please keep moving forward with zeal.
What was so dark, if I (we) may ask? And how did you come to Christ? Just learning! ;-)
Good on you bro! Always great to hear people on a good path.
Congratulations on your marriage and journey of faith.
My priest was pointing out how differently Orthodox define “faith” this past Sunday, and it’s an insight that Murray really needs to ponder.
Blessings, brother. May your marriage be a truly holy union.
This is in all honesty the best and highest level of discussion on multiple levels that I heard in my entire Life.
Thank you Jordan, Jonathan and Douglas! You have my absolute respect 🙏
I feel like I'm starving in my doctoral program and you three, with your fascinating discussions, makes my brain feel actually engaged, fed, and excited. Excellent discussion, all of you! Lovely to see different points of view coming together to discuss such tough and fascinating ideas.
I feel the exact same way! Thanks for your comment, I feel a little less alone ;)
What a sad commentary it is that you are in a doctoral program, yet starving for intellectual stimulation. This is why Frank Zappa said, if you want an education, go to the library. If you want to get laid, go to college.
Yup sounds like a typical university
We live in amazing and confusing times, when we pay big $$$ for a piece of paper that doesn’t necessarily provide what we thought it represented, but we can find world class discussions of serious topic for free.
JP is the only person that makes me feel more intelligent and more stupid at the same time.
very good description!
I think that’s the definition of a great teacher.
Which JP?
That means it's working!
@@DerekJFiedler Jordan Pageau
It's a blessing that we are able to listen to great conversations like this.
Agreeed
listening to their point of views about education; coming from someone that's not educated, or have good knowledge, makes me feel bad as person cause l'm doing cleaning a job, and l'm not educating myself...but off topic, but, l'm blessed as well man
@Sen Dog well said
@@lukehart7225 you are participating where you are- much more intelligent than those educated and doing nothing with it.
@Sen Dog ---How do you know that good art discovers patterns beyond the physical. What does that even mean? Show me something that is "beyond physical". What evidence do you have apart from saying that art discovers it? Then you come up with some new definition for God that I've never heard of and finally you give us some false dichotomy by giving us a choice between two made up concepts. Sorry, but what a word salad this is.
I love how Peterson and Pageau slowly scooted closer on the couch over the course of the conversation haha
Its like the love Jesus had for his deciples.
Jordan did not Pageau. I noticed that too but I didn’t think it was worth commenting on.
My three ABSOLUTE FAVORITE speakers... it was a joy.
I can sit and listen to Jordan Peterson all day long. I truly believe he will go down in history as one of the most important Men of our time. God bless you Jordan, and your wonderful family. 🙏👁️
Listen up, sunshine... turn off the tube and go clean your room!
@Ben C I am currently listening to this while working. Your argument is invalid.
@@malvolio01 Will do. Just finished laundry, got the rhoomba out suckering and got the dishes lined up next.
I like all of these people, such a panel.. But they're wrong about proving The Bible.. PROPHECY PROVES THE BIBLE
@@malvolio01 I just finished trimming a rose bush and tree in the front yard. Fixed a flat tire on an old car and cooked lunch for my wife. Anything else you'd like to order me to do?
It’s incredible to me that Dr. Peterson looks even better now than he did before he was sick. Truly incredible.
🙏
Money and knowledge
Because he's a Boss.
Lil help: sick with what?
Stop eating excessive sugars, grains, seeds, and leaves. Our gut isn’t adapted for the exuberant amount of indigestible plant matter the world at large would have you believe is healthy.
This conversation has helped me to realize God has been so graceful and merciful in the midst of my agony.
Praise God for his blessing on me.
This is just brilliant. Thank you gentlemen. I have been losing my faith of late and this thoughtful conversation amongst three incredible people may be restoring much more than that in me
I came to believe in God about a year ago.
It became clear to me that humans have always been searching for truth, and that truth always seems to point toward goodness.
John 8:32, John 14:6, psalm 51:6,
John 1:1....
All these speak to our desire to know the Truth, which I believe to be the fundamental aspect of humanity. One either seeks the truth, or avoids it all costs, those that seek the truth are humble, practice kindness, and see the obviousness that there is some kind of spiritual force for good. Those who avoid truth, tend to be self-centered, callous, and cold.
I came to realize that one believes in Goodness, or God, or one is evil...or inspired by the devil
Why lose Faith? I believe God formed the Universe through Naturalist means. I love God and I accept Science.
Douglass was a perfect choice, very good with expressing ideas! And he asks the best questions 👍🏻 another round of these three together would be great!
Did you notice, first he asks "Is Chritianity exhausted force or unexhausted force" and quite soon after that says "one of the revolutions of Christian tradition is that everybody has an intrinsic value"? Can't we derive from the two statements: "Is the idea of people having intrinsic value an exhausted force or not?"
I don't know why, but I misspelled the word "intrinsic value" repeatedly "intrinsic meaning". Intrinsic meaning feels to hint at action more than intrinsic value, later feels to imply to something static.
Some branches of Judaism see people as co-creators of the world. That line of thinking offers intrinsic meaning as well as value.
In a world full of disarray, disagreement, and distress, this conversation is an oasis for this soul.
3 deep thinkers with different world views, discussing the most core existential questions of life, while maintaining respect and being of equal conversational reciprocity. If conversations like this became commonplace, mankind's progression would be much more meaningful than just simple expansion and "advancement".
Without these core meanings, every other pursuit of mankind will be unsustainable.
Bravo to these gentlemen 🙏
It's the work OF the values allowing them to do so.
It's the fruit picked directly from the vine.
*and offered to the other
The general human population isn't smart enough for that.
Well said
I love finding that one comment that speaks for me too. 👍
A terrific episode - I thoroughly enjoyed this conversation. Jordan as always insightful and deep, Douglas Murray razor-sharp & very wise. Jonathan P., relatively new to me, yet a thoughtful man with astute contributions. Thank you gentlemen 🌱
Three of the greatest Western intellectuals of our era. It's a great privilege to be able to listen to this discussion.
I love seeing older men so engaged with the big questions. There is something so deeply reassuring about older men who have not lost their vitality, who continue to leap with their faith toward truth and beauty.
O the innocence of youth
@A.T. I'm 30. These men are all older than me. Hence why I referred to them as "older men" and not "old men".
@A.T. Jordan Peterson is 60. That's 10 years away from 70. Would you say he is an older man or not?
I see Douglas Murray, I click.
Ikr! He doesn’t do nearly enough interviews to suit me
I have listened to this 3 times already and I get something new each time. Thank you for having this discussion! ❤
3rd listen
I go to church because it gives me a sense of calm and peace, listening to the word gives me a sense of security and sanity. Having a church community, helps me grow, keeps me grounded, accountable for my actions, and incentivizes me to be a better person. Learning good morals, discipline and how to live a better life it’s why I am part of a church and follow tradition, I believe this is very important for everyone so that we stay away from depression and the psychologists. I am grateful to God for this 🙏🏻🙌🏻
Jonathan is clearly a genius. I know a lot of people might see him as a third wheel in some sense. To me, he has my full respect. He is thinking well beyond what most people give him credit for. Jonathan, if you see this I want you to know, I see you brother. “Fractals”
@@Nah_Bohdi I don't know that he is a scholar. I don't think Jonathan would consider himself that. He is an Icon carver. An artist. An Orthodox Christian. A wonderful partner and conduit in these kinds of conversations.
@@triscat Yes, Jonathan is indeed very attentive. Which is why I would strongly agree with you, he is a fantastic conversationalist.
I would suggest that Jordan is lucky to have come across Jonathan! I really do believe that Jonathan is helping him!! I believed that from the very beginning they were in touch!
@@Nah_Bohdi You must not know his background. His bachelor's degree is in art, and he has no academic degree in religion or theology. He's well-read but definitely not a scholar. And his perspective is different from JBP's in many important ways.
He's not a genius, he's an artist in the true sense of the word. He has the same kind of brain and education as me. He sees very far and deeply into things and he makes conncections and recognises patterns that others don't see but he struggles with the details. And then his knowledge of Orthodoxy provides his style of thinking and perceiving with a rich and solid foundation.
Aren't we all so privileged to listen to conversations like this for free!
Thank you all three for a brilliant discussion. I learn more about myself listening to you all.
I’ve listen to this five times I keep reverting back to it because it is such a powerful conversation. May I suggest a part two between the three of you gentlemen sometime in the future. Thank you again all of you for your work and your light in the dark.
Thank you to the three of you. Wonderful conversation. So grateful to live in a time that I can listen to intelligent educated men at my leisure.
@Sen Dog religion is delusion.
Jordan laying out the general lessons to be learned (or some of them) from the Bible is just awesome to listen. He's like Beethoven with words; very pleasing to listen to.
Yes. He is the Beethoven of truthful speach.
Just don't get him started on Pinocchio...and DEFINITELY don't tell him about the remake!
@@somedandy7694 So true! How do we hide the remake info from Jordan? He is going to flip when he finds what they did to it
I wish I knew all he knows and could communicate half as well.
@Sen Dog This line belongs in an epic anime battle.
I've been catching more and more of Douglas Murray (on Pierce Morgan usually), and I like what I hear out of him. I don't agree with him on many things, but I appreciate his practical approach. "We have to get down to brass tacks…" in the midst of an interesting but esoteric/abstract conversation on "fiction" and mythic archetypes. Very good conversation.
Time for a part 2 of this discussion!
The practice of belief is less like practicing for athletic excellence and more like living out your love for others with actions that strive towards their best good. The thing Jordan keeps missing is that the object of our love/worship/practice is REAL. He made us for real, mutual relationship with Him. It's not just an aiming to a theoretical Best and Highest. The best and highest is a real, living Being who loves us.
I see so much of this type of discussion where philosphers, writers, cultural commentators try to make sense of the current chaos in the world and in society, and openly admit that it is evidently a consequence of removing God and religion from society (as they discuss here), and yet, as Douglas Murray puts it, they get 99% of the way there, but can't reconcile that last 1%, which is essentially 100%. I hope they eventually manage to take that last "leap of faith".
Well said.
Douglas Murray, possibly the greates guest of all time for this podcast.
With his manners you could cut out the last three words honestly. :D
This conversation was for me one of the most inspiring from you Jordan! (and I have listen to a lot) The combination of the three of you is a perfect match! When Pagaue is talking beautifuly about mysteries of life, Douglas can bring the conversation down to earth in such a interseting way. Can't wait for the next one!
PogO*
Douglas Murray is brilliant. My first time listening to him, I am finding in myself realizations and self-awareness that I have not yet come across before.
You must be joking; he’s a pompous ignoramus
When I hear this talk, I realize how accurate it is to see JBP as the great seeker. My hope is that by the end of this decade Canada 🍁 will have a different government and, probably over his objections, nominate him for the Nobel Peace Prize in Humanities. This superstar will be honored for his contribution to a better human condition. We have all benefited. ❤
Justin Timberfake has got to go
@@axidhaus lol are purposefully using the wrong name??
@@okami425 Not sure if you misunderstood, but I'm pretty sure that it's a barely disguised derogatory name for Justin Trudeau, not a criticism leveled against any of the men in this video.
@@okami425Justin Turdeau
I agree, once the PC party loses Poilievre on or before the end of this decade we will be in a better position to have a change in government. In the mean time it looks like the Liberals will likely win the next election in 2025 and govern until 2029. Let's hope by that time that a good Conservation leader comes forward.
Gotta love Douglas Murray and his clarity to define.
I find Murray to be more clever than profound. Pageau I is the deeper thinker.
@@richardkuyper300 I tend to agree with you except it's disappointing, for me in any case, that Pageau doesn't effectively communicate the more orthodox concerns of the Eastern Church in this episode. And this coming from a working artist of Eastern Icons, and whose brother has wriiten a great book on the symbolism of Genesis. Murray is the cleverer and more effective speaker here IMO. As an Anglican, he has a keen view on symbolism. Note how he goes into Poets around 1:09. Poetry is the closest we come to understanding the Transcendent. Nothing however beats the actual practice of Contemplative Prayer.
Pageau's full smile can uplift anyone's mood
I actualy saw Jonathan in one of my latest psilocybin trips. Out of nowhere, his face with that wide smile, and I came to realize in that moment how much of God's grace Jonathan has in his smile... That's rather a weird comment, I know
I loved how I could see his brain processing a 'quip' with that smile.
Jordan please keep doing live events if you can, I am in the UK and want see you in person, it would mean the world - currently I'm poor, but going to do everything I can to see and watch you live. Thank you for everything that you have done and continue to do.
Douglas Murray presented keen insight throughout. Please have him back on.
Our three Wise Men for the post modern age. The arc of the Star in the heavens still points the way. What a blessing to listen to these men weave their words and wisdom.
Hear hear! Beautifully written comment.
@@Nah_Bohdi uh what??
@@countdooku75 In the days immediately following HM Queen Elisabeth II's death, there were sightings and videos of what was suspected to be a meteorite streaking across the sky as it burned up on entry to the atmosphere. I'm guessing that's what @Nah Bohdi was referring to, but could be wrong.
Thank you. This was amazing synchronicity ~ covering so many areas I’ve been considering this week.
Jonathan is such a beautiful person. Brilliant to hear Douglas in dialogue like this. Very inspiring indeed.
That insight at 1:01:57 - "Is there anything more real than pain?...The Meaning that overcomes pain is more real than the pain and that's actually what meaning is." Pure gold.
Yet meaning does not need to come with pain. Its not 'pure gold' its word salad. It sounds deep yet it means nothing.
@@darrylelam256 @Darryl Elam I dont know how you can say its word salad and that it means nothing. Genuine people dont do or say things that mean nothing. They aren't just making this stuff up. I almost want to say that youre just making stuff up when you say, "Yet meaning does not need to come with pain", but I think I know what youre saying, and its not meaningless, you just misunderstand what they were saying. I replied to your comment on my comment thread, and coming from that, it seems to me you simply dont have the full context, you dont understand what they are actually saying. If you did understand, and you still disagreed, that doesnt then mean that what they said was meaningless word salad, it could just mean that what they said was wrong.
@@danielgalvez7953 "Genuine people dont do or say things that mean nothing." And they aren't genuine people, what part of that aren't you understanding?
"you just misunderstand what they were saying" Nope, pain is NOT part of meaning, what they said was not only pointless but F'ing stupid. Things are ether real or not real, there is no such thing as 'more real'. Meaning that doesn't come with pain is just as real as meaning that comes with pain. Meaning has NOTHING to do with pain.
Meaning definition
Noun: what is meant by a word, text, concept, or action.
adjective: intended to communicate something that is not directly expressed.
Notice how pain it NOT part of that. Overcoming pain dos NOT make what is meant by a word, text, concept, or action more real. Not having to overcome pain does NOT make a meaning less real. Its the same level of real. This is nothing but word salad meant to convince you that they are really smart people when in truth they have nothing of value to say. They do that because that's how they make their money, its a con job to get you to buy his books, 23 of them and/or support him financially in other ways.
@@darrylelam256 Why dont you think they are genuine people? Just because they sell books? I hope not, that'd be ridiculous. They are pretty smart: they are at least above average, its not your IQ that determines whether you're worth listening to it's whether you have anything meaningful to say, whether you're sharing a useful understanding that the listeners lack. And being able to say things concisely as they do in this video is very useful. Its not like they haven't expanded on these ideas in other videos, they have, so these ideas are not meaningless, there is a great deal of context you clearly lack. There are tons of videos where Peterson goes into more detail about these ideas, they are not just empty words. If you disagree with what Peterson has to say in those videos, then fine, you disagree, but they are not empty words deprived of meaning. Besides I dont support him financially at all, most of their listeners dont.
And Notice how Google's definition of meaning you pulled has nothing to do with the other way people use meaning, like in the question, "what is the meaning of life." If that google definition was all there was, then that question would be as simple as looking up the definition of the word life. Clearly, they are not using the word "meaning" with that definition you pulled in mind. In this case it is right to say they are using jargon, specialized words that outsiders wouldn't understand.
@@danielgalvez7953 "Why dont you think they are genuine people?" Because they aren't. Ask JP if he believes in a god, not only will he not answer, he will insult your intelligence by claiming that you don't know what believe means.
"Just because they sell books?" How do you think he makes his money and he makes a lot of money.
" its not your IQ that determines whether you're worth listening" I didn't say sh!t about IQ so why the F are you bringing it up? Are you trying to build a strawman?
"it's whether you have anything meaningful to say" And that should be magically 'more true' if they had to overcome pain? Or are they just full of sh!t?
"There are tons of videos where Peterson goes into more detail about these ideas" And he is making money off those videos where he does nothing but talk word salad.
"And Notice how Google's definition of meaning you pulled has nothing to do with the other way people use meaning" Nope. You clearly are too stupid top understand that they are broad definitions yet the still fits how people use the word.
"like in the question, "what is the meaning of life."" Yes a completely BS question that assumes that there is a magical meaning to life and YES it still fits the definition that I used. Noun: what is meant by a word, text, concept, or action. and in this unbelievably stupid question of 'what is the meaning of life' the brainless fools are asking what is this life meant for, what is the reason for this life. And its faulty from the get go because it baselessly assumes that life was put here for a reason, that we are meant to do something.
"Clearly, they are not using the word "meaning" with that definition you pulled in mind." And that's where you are wrong, but thanks for displaying you ignorance.
"In this case it is right to say they are using jargon, specialized words that outsiders wouldn't understand." Nope, they are using specialized words to make word salad. Lots of talking that means nothing.
“Fairy tales are MORE than true. Not because they tell us dragons exist. But because they tell us dragons can be beaten” ~G.K. Chesterton
Douglas brought this together beautifully with his final words. That was a wonderful close to a wonderful conversation. Thanks guys.
@@hairypawter8475 BAD BOT
@@hairypawter8475 Say what?
@@hairypawter8475 lmfao indeed. Dude calls himself a christian atheist and is gay. What is this sorcery? Was it really the wrong part who lost ww2?
I could listen to these 3 talk for days. What a great conversation.
Absolutely beautiful. Yes, we should do this again. Brilliant, gentlemen. Thank you.
Always excited to see Murray on anyone’s show.
Me too!!!! Same with Greg Lukianoff as well
I am completely overwhelmed by this conversation, in a great way! God bless you three men!♥️♥️♥️
I feel like this conversation fueled my heart, brain and soul.
I listened to this while driving home from my weekly visit to my older brother. I loved Douglas’ last statement- maybe that is what we need, something that transcends the natural. I related with Jordan’s comment that we are still living out the scriptures- I feel that in my own life. And I agree with Johnathan that yes, these things really happened.
Actually the probability that it happened in reality is 0.I will never understand why people have to build their worldview on obvious lies.We can and should acknowledge that we dont have the answers, but to pretend that the answers are obvious, foolish lies is remarkably stupid.This is closest to a mindset of a gambling addict.Those people never say, OK this is an ilusion, l have to start over without it, but rather always keep that "just one more time" theory in their minds.Its simple, story of resurrection is a flat out lie, story of Moses also, story that Mohammad was give Quran by angel too... Those are evident lies and what guys like Peterson and Pageu do is trying to convince people to further entranch in lies.
Jordan.. you are a blessing to the world. An enlightened thinker shining light through a dark time
This man is producing more crossovers than Marvel could ever dream of.
I love it when JP talks,it makes you really wanna listen and I'm a bad listener,I got bored really quick and my attention is easily distracted,so I like this about him,somehow he can make you listen without you noticing it,and I ended up finishing the whole video and learning a lot,so thank you for that sir!
Excellent it nearly makes me consider setting aside my prejudices and actually attending church or at least giving it another try
This is such a beautiful conversation. I think the “leap” Jordan and Douglas struggle with is actually having a RELATIONSHIP with the transcendent/divine. It’s not simply about believing, but embodying as Jonathan (and the church) says. If you remain in the sphere of “fiction” and “ethical systems,” you are like an actor that can only study and appreciate acting, but cannot walk out on stage and actually take your part in the play.
Great comment. Something I'm encountering now. I've always believed but haven't sufficiently stepped on to the stage.
Agreed, as I similarly commented above. I love listening to this kind of discussion, but in the end, it's not something that can be rationalised, or arrived at by mental gymnastics.
Somewhat ironically, they discuss how the (or a) divine or "meta-being" must necessarily exist for anything else to make sense, in order to make any sort of value judgment, and to derive order from the chaos of our universe, but this seems to miss the obvious (to me) conclusion that solely rational thought cannot allow us to comprehend a divine being in a different plane of existence.
They are still blinded by their intellect. Faith is much more than a subject one can study in school. In fact the more ‘knowledge’ one has, the harder or further away from the absolute truth they are obtaining
Embody like Mother Teresa who didn't believe in medicine or birth control and thought suffering was a way to heaven? Like that? Pft.
@Emma Shalliker Claims like that against St. Theresa have been debunked. Cynical people try to tarnish the legacy of good people. Also, Jordan Peterson advocates very strongly for facing suffering as a path to self-improvement. There is a huge difference between telling people to suffer and acknowledging that it is inevitable and the way you face it matters.
The reason why fictional classics resonate so clearly and eternally is because there is something in it that reflects the Truth God created us to need to understand. The more clearly it reflects this, the more timeless and satisfying it feels to us
Thank you for this invaluable discussion! I got very deep realizations from it like faith as an antidote to resentment (JBP); a very clarifying concept of art as a participatory experience beyond irony and satire (JP); and DM's assessment on Andy Warhol's only ability to pose questions. As a fine artist, I am profoundly aware of the state of our culture from watching how art became just non-transcendent and uninspiring objects of consumption for the individual totally disconnected of the communal purpose. I'm looking forward to the next conversation. Thank you again.
Just want to say thank you to all that made this talk happen. Past and present. I am now closer to my true self and better in and for this world because of it. Thanks again, Rob
this needed to be 3+ hours long!
God bless all of you gentleman. thank you for enlightening and entertaining us.
Easily the best conversation on the internet. What a joy to have this pocket of those still reaching for the divine despite the madness of the modern world. May Christ bless us all.
So powerful....thank you gents for doing what you do so beautifully! And a little pause here and there to let the PHENOMENOLOGICAL IMPACT settle in would help take these conversations to the next level. Thank you Thank you.....
Perhaps the greatest summary of the Pageau, Peterson, Veravaeke discussion to date, at time of posting. So powerful.
This is, without hyperbole, the ONLY conversation I’m interested in. Bless them.
This is a great conversation... but i'd rather listen to "Pass me not, oh gentle Savior"
What?
@@jakeschwartz2514 what?
Jordan Peterson is so wise he tells you what you already know, before you realize you’ve known it all along.
As a matter of fact, he has articulate many things I believed to be true, or rather, ideas I was starting to develop and think through.
@@adampindell absolutely same here sir !
Ironically, this comment did exactly the same thing lol
Sorry, not beautiful
Yes, he’s brilliant!
What a great conversation! Thank you so much. Your podcast keeps me going and makes me enjoy my boring tasks and commutes.
What an excellent conversation "What will survive of us is love" wow
Wouldn't be surprised if Jordan and Jonathan become two of the greatest intellectuals of the 21st century.
Our Tolkien and Lewis
„What rules, you sons of bitches?“ „Up yours, woke moralists! We‘ll see who cancels who!“ Truly one of the minds of our time
He’s one of the most idiotic intellectuals of our time, that’s for sure.
@@famatu And of course you will back that up with evidence? Or do you just feel like he is so it must be true
@@famatu so you get your take of him based on meme clips. Says alot about your attention span...
You can see and feel the passion in the conversation. Brilliant stuff. Thank you!
These 3 resonate in a perfect harmony. An amazing discussion !
Their willingness to explore the questions that most would run from was enlightnening.Thank you.
I absolutely love these conversations.
Since partnering with the Daily Wire, the production and aesthetics with your videos have been second to none Jordan. Very much excited to see what potential you have in the years to come with the full support of DW to realize your vision and have fascinating conversations.
Thanks for putting this conversation together. What a breath of fresh air in a world of banality.
This conversation is literally awesome; it put my hairs on end!
Listening to this conversation with echoes of the Orthodox Metropolitan Kallistos Ware's lectures on Personhood, the Jesus prayer etc.... still in my ears - this is holding me so firmly in the Christian faith. Unimaginable bliss.....
"Like the Big bang for instance??"
Almost had a public coffee spitting incident.. Thanks for that johnathan because you said what I was thinking!!! Love this interaction.. We need SOOOOOO much more of this!!!💚💚💚
Ditto
Yea i liked that.
Difference being anyone who "believes" the big bang theory would drop it if a more concrete explanation was discovered. Jonathan would still think the world was created 6,000 years ago.
@@tornasukiii745 and if something could do a better job of what religion does, in jonathan's mind, then he would drop it. ps suddenly making Jonathan a literalist where he is not is lazy.
@@tornasukiii745 I don’t think he’s ever said that he argues for a creationist interpretation of how old the universe is
Dr. Peterson, every now and again I come back to your channel to thank you for saving me.
Thank you gentlemen.
Pageau deserves so much more attention.
I do find all of life to be circling around a drain hole but each orbit I call out to Christ. Praying for you.
Really appreciate how Douglas can be skeptical of but not disrespectful to believers. Really feels like most atheists/agnostics/non-believers in the scene can't discuss faith without taking unfair cheap shots. Love this conversation.
Jordan and douglas. Two of my heroes. Well done!
This is it. The conversation I needed to learn from.
1:11 a mother sees and feels this kind of surreal, beyond miraculous love when her newborn is placed into her arms for the very first time. It's a moment of love like no other.
This made an hour and half feel as if it were but a moment. Thanks for the excellent dialogue!
Jonathan's cheeky smiles are wholesome
Thank you Jonathan for finally answering Douglas Murray’s question.
Blown away at this conversation. Thank you.
This conversation is beautiful.
What a feast of wholesome content for us to digest. Better than loaves and fishes for our well-being. We are so blessed that these brilliant speakers can share with us all that wisdom and truth. One day I hope that some of the circuit team will come down under for face to face interaction for our edification. Praying that I might live that long.😥
@Sen Dog So Jordan Peterson is saying that a hurtful mother that puts her children out into the world and get broken and hurt; is better then a kind mother, that holds us, and protects 57:10
I could go for a loaf of fish right now.
@@lukehart7225 she is not a hurtful mother but a wise one who knows that her children can't fulfill their potential as humans if they don't take on the perennial human task of contending with reality/suffering/meaning and try to find, and actualize, their own mission in this world. That's something no parent can do for us. Mothers prepare us in part, hopefully, but they can't fulfill the child's mission and potential. They break the child's spirit if they try to hold them back from all risk and danger. They have to let go -- but it's painful for them to do so (the mothers) so some unwisely don't, and damage their children by that clinging.
Please do this again. What an excellent talk. Thank you!
I’m always so grateful that I can be privy to these incredible conversations. I’m also amazed that I can follow them most of the time!
Really looking forward to “We who wrestle with God”
- Jacob…
👏👏👏ENCORE! ❤❤❤ WOW WOW WOW I thank God for these three gentlemen. That I am privelidged enough to witness this conversation is truly RUclips at its best. Thank you gentlemen I will be listening agaim and again to this conversation for some time to come.
Heartfelt thanks to all of you. Awesome info & debate.
Douglas Murray’s clarity is incredible.
Thank you so much Prof Peterson and your Guests! I think I understand why they are two of your favourite people😀