Pakistani Reacts to How this border transformed a subcontinent | India & Pakistan
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 фев 2025
- #NewsViews&Updates #Vox
Credits:
Channel Name: Vox
Channel Link: / @vox
Video Title: How this border transformed a subcontinent | India & Pakistan
Video Link: • How this border transf...
Email us @ newsviewsandupdates@gmail.com
Iman and Moazzam Channel Link: / @imanandmoazzamvlogs
FaceBook Page Link:
/ imanandmoazzam
Instagram :www.instagram....
/ mozam_butt_1
This video is made on the demand of our Subscribers.
If you have any issue with our video kindly message at Newsviewsandupdates@gmail.com. We will remove the video.
Disclaimer : Our channel #NewsViews&Updates is created to give our opinion,views and reactions over different videos to entertain People .
__________________
Copyright Disclaimer : Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
News,Views & Update
Subscribe to our other channel: / @mjentertainment3698
It was cause of MD Ali Zinnah
He was the one who wanted a separate nation of Islam. Don't you both dare to say or think that it was Indians Idea
You can check this history on Google
And this partition was his karma
Ya but the British put in Ali Jinnah's mind of seperation Of Hindu, Muslim
@@firstname1192 un log ne kya kar diya bro? They did their best to unite India.
@SFG way sorry to say esaa nahi tha bas dono inhe manane me fail hue kyunki British NE jinaah ko chatni chata di thi
@@greyy_097 no one put any things in jinnah s mind he wanted to be pm. Read British chronicles in British Iibraries in new Delhi or London facts are stronger than fiction.
@@arvindkumarray2613 don't be bitter at least India is not doing terror.
This video made me all emotional as well. I'm from West Bengal, India. My grandparents had to leave their home which was in present day Bangladesh and had to move to India. They were also refugees and started from the scratch in India. With great struggle they built their family here. I grew up listening to the stories of partition. We should realise that our roots are same. Sending love and respect for sharing this positivity. We need this. Keep up the good work. 🌼
Same here we were from dhaka
@@rahulmojumder6936 we are from Faridpur and Sylhet.
My grand grandfather Was Haradhan singh converted in Islam and became # Haradhan Ahmed,Born in British India, Village-Samindari
District-Layalpur( Faislabad)
Province-Punjab( British INDIA now pakistab)😢😢
Lalach me ya dar kar
Converted willfully or by compulsion of partition. Many families who can't able to move out had to accept Islam, this is told to me by one Pakistani.
Do you wish to come back to India into your roots one day if possible?
He must be threatened by local Muslims or lured by. That’s Islam actually just force others to convert
So hows yours and your families life there, do you feel secured n do u have full freedom, please let me know the truth from you brother , from arunachal Pradesh northeast india
I feel the same emotion as you. I hope there will be a time when both the sides politicians will be friends and will open the way for people to love each other again.
My maternal grand father Late Girija Nanda Ghosh Mazumdar hailed from Village Bar atiya./ Ghoor/Manickvanj
Ya mohammad aili jina ka kaam hai
It's British which lead to this partition with there divide and conquer tactics
Us time Md ali zinnah ne apne muslim league k vaje say alg country k maang ki iss vaje say asa hua..
Partition destroyed everything!😧
Not really. Without partition India would have been suffering from islamic extremism and violence.
@@shuvamchatterjee8611 without partition , United India wouldn't even have a neighbour constantly causing border skirmishes
Only Md.Ali Jinnah was responsible for partition .
19:20 NO.. Iman/Moazzam. Read more about Radcliffe line. Boundaries were created by taking all sides into agreement. A Commission called Boundary Commission was formed which had 4 members (2 muslims, 1 hindu, 1 sikh) for Punjab Border and 4 members (2 muslims and 2 hindus) for Bengal Border. British were not at fault here. In Last 1-2 Years before 1947, they tried their best to stop partition, but eventually submitted to the demands of All India Muslim League because AIML was making the Separate Country demand since 1939. British never wanted partition.
Last line is wrong about British never wanted partition! Actually British didnt give a f**k about partition!
@ if that was the case, they wouldn't have formed boundary commission and would have left hindus and muslims to deal with. in the backdrop of world war II, the new labour party govt of clement attlee was extremely conscious about its image and it wanted to leave india with minimum damage and with smooth transfer of power. but muslim league vs congress conflict had started coming on roads with violence b/w hindus and muslims common by 1947 March. and they had to run from india asap as they were not able to handle things.
@ my point was they didn't want partition of india. when you are saying that they didn't care, i said they cared because they cared their image. there are letters b/w attlee and mountbatten which subscribe to this intense desire of british labour party govt that "prevent partition as much you can". the attitude of mountbatten and lord wavell who was viceroy before mountbatten frustrated jinnah and his party. jinnah didn't believe that britishers will partition india and hence he resorted to measures like Direct Action Day and interference in Constituent assembly thru AIML members led by Liyaquat Ali Khan
Britishers ko clean chit kya apko nahi pata ki jinnah britishers ka hi stoog tha. Uski katputli tha. Divide and rule britishers ka hi sidhant tha. It was muslim league and jinnah and britishers milibhagat
@@FM-ng6yu I cannot come there because I live in USA! lol. So eat ur own shit dude haha.
Partition happened because of political ambitions and power hunger of jinnah, Nehru and Gandhi
Not gandhi
@@akshay_wakodikar right he was a saint
@@AishikMitra Not a saint, but better than the other leaders. It's cool for us to criticize him..
@@akshay_wakodikar yes definitely, that is why petition of Bhagat Singh was rejected... He was a great man who only wanted his position to be stain free
@@AishikMitra Dude..read his history with broad mindset. Dont be conservative..
हमने IIT,IIM बनाएं पाकिस्तान तुमने हक्कानी,लष्कर ए तैयबा बनाए हमने विश्व को बुध्द, गांधी दिए भारत महान 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Baaki sab thik hai. Par Gandhi koi Mahan nai tha 🤣
@@chintan925 RSS ppl spotted..
@@chintan925 Sahi bola
It is not correct to blame the politicians of today for the divide. Partition was created due to one section of people because of their religious compunctions.
Indian politicians are only safe guarding the interests and security of the country. What choice they have in the face of constant adversity from outside?
Mai nahi manta politician ki nafrat felate hai.... esa mante hai woh apane aapse juth bolate hai.. pyar nafrat logo ke dilo mai hoti hai.....rahi bat aapki to aapke purkhone hi two nation theory base part kiye the.... aapko nahi rona chahiye...
With u mate ...
Alma iqbal ne di thi
True
@@AZAD_DIMAG_AZAD_KHYAAL woh sabse bada hypcrt tha.... sare jahase achha bhi likha aur milli tarana mai... chino arab hamara bhi
Yaaa its true
Establishment of Muslim League probably was the first seed of division..
And then Hindu maha Sabha
It was only Muhammad Ali Jinnah who wanted a different country for Muslims.
One man's greed (Jinnah)has torn a nation into two... And what has PAK become now, is there to see... credit goes to their leaders & military heads... PAK initiated all the wars against India and it's their own shameless admission... It fosters & harbors extremists as a policy...and does proxy wars for monetary benefits...India patiently bared the brunt over the years... now it knows that a rogue nation like PAK, does not understand normal language, it needs a tough treatment. And It's really sad to see what PAK leadership and their "establishment" are doing to their own people.
23:00 Really appreciate your views here Iman, this is because there is a huge influence of Sufism in Subcontinent Islam. And that is why many Subcontinent Muslim homes have an affinity towards their roots. In Delhi, Nizamuddin Auliya Dargah lights Diwali Lamps every year, as per their Sufism ideals, but same practice is not acceptable under Salafi and Wahabi Islam.
Mohammad ali jinnaha ki wajah se portion hua tha.
@shri kadrekar history check karo usane hi british kaha tha
All thanks to jinah ji for these disasters👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Please don't put ji before Jinnah. He was the main culprit of partition.
Manish Shukla mai jha rhta hu vha apne se bade ko ase hi bolte hai sorry agr apko bura laga to
You two are really warm-hearted people. Keep spreading the message of love and mutual-respect. Jai Hind!
Ek baar UNSC mei permanent seat mil jae. Pok to agle din ki hum wapas le lenge.
Nahi chahea bhai pok, kuch nahi hai waha,ulta sarkar ka kharcha hoga
@@Tir2002 Bhai tumhari jameen pe koi kabja kr lega tb bhi tum esa hi bolega ?
Who came with 2 nation theory?
Lahore was supposed to be in India after partition because at that time Lahore"s maximum population was hindu
26:05 Dil se Pyaar Jahan Hota Hai, Waheen Ikhtalafaat Khul Kar Saamne Rakhe Jaate hain.... Par Ye Ikhtalaafat Qatl-Khoon Ki Had Tak Nhi Jaane Chahiye...!!
Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳 jai shree ram 🚩🕉️
You are 200 % right Iman ye hamari weakness hai ki hum Europeans ki tarah nahi hai lekin hum aaj nahi to kal unko tough competition denge
Britisher ka koi agenda nahi tha muslmanoka gazwa e hind ka agenda tha jo aaj bhi hai....british ne goliya marke part nahi kiye.....aapane aapse kab taq juth bologe....
Thik hua jyada Jihadis hota to overload ho jata.
In fact most of the Pakistani punjab districts were Hindus populated
26/11
🙏
Try to read history. It was not britishers but the jehadi mindset caused partition. What’s going on Kashmir ? Once Muslims get majority they want to impose their faith on others. Why Hindus were forced to left their homeland Kashmir ? Due to britishers? I am not telling that all are same but majority are . Respect other religions and peace will prevail on earth
Arvind Kumar ray as long as they don’t oppose jehadis yes you are right all are same
21:04
Suddenly India me Democracy aa jati and
Indirectly Hindu ek tarah se Dominated Ho jate
And
Ye un logo ko bardasht nahi jo ye samajhte hai ki
Hamne Hindu pe rule kiya hai
There are 58 Islamic majority countries and a bit of them are secular by constitution...India is secular because we have Hindu majority...if islam will come into majority in India that day it will be an Islamic Country...
i am indian muslim but its not like i am taking my country's side the truth is its all because of jinnah and muslim league they want muslim coutry not seccullar country
Bro right
Guys u are right but Jinnah was first in favour of partition......Gandhiji opposed the partition but later accept because he dont want to give any chance to british to divide and rule again
I just literally cried watching this . its really a horror story of our history
1857 ke freedom strugle mein Hindu Muslim Unity ki misaal bani thi...but phir ek aadmi paida huaa Mohammad Ali Jinnah...jisko lagne lagaa ki Hindu Muslim do alag kaum hain aur ek saath nahi rah sakte...
Jinnah main culprit of partition of our Great india🇮🇳
Md Ali Jinnah want partition, Gandhi opposed it but Britisher is in favor of jinna.
But Nehru was not against it ok first read in detail then talk ok
@@namanbansal4033 There was no option for Nehru or Gandhi so first you read and talk ok
Participation happened because of one religion, wherever this religion took entry same thing start. Now a days in Europe country
Ask Md Ali Zinnah😂😂 he wanted a Islam majority country.
U r ri8 bro but one thing I didn't understand why do they feel insecure of other religions.
It was cause of md.Ali Jinnha
Brits never wanted to divide India. That was not in their intention. Mr. Jinnah demanded a separate Muslim country and that made highness of Britain to apoint Lord Mountbatten to redraw the map.
Jinnhhas Grandfather was a Hindu Thakkkar From Gujrat
This video tells you everything youths need to understand for both countries
Sahi kaha ....Jinnah ko kuch pata hi nahi tha ... Jinnah ko partition pasand tha....
We will take back kartarpur sahib soon from u
Pure video mei Jinnah ko hi nai dikhaya !! What an irony !! Hadd hai
Partion jinnah mistake because he asked for a muslim country
There's a book "Keeping the jewel in the crown, the British betrayal of India" by Walter Ried. Try reading it if u get time. Many shocking nd untold truths of the partition will leave u stunned..we all have been fooled for all these years
I'm asking out of curiosity, can you guys explain what you guys have been taught at school regarding the pre independence period. ? Just curious to know that's why!
I have great respect for both of u..but plz don't take me negatively..let me tell u..i have gone through the books of diffrent historians, onething i can tell u with conviction that it was the ill- will of Jinnah and Allama iqbal,who once had written Sare jahan se achha..to divide India on religion line..otherwise partition would have never happened..
Jinnah ji se puch na chaiye tha kyu aap dusra country chaiye..aur agar aap ko rights chaiye the toh Nehru ji baat kar le the..........
akele britishers partition me involved nhi tey Mohammed Ali zinha , Jawhar lal Nehru , Mahamta gandhi , Congress , Muslim league sub involved tey
U know what I m sad about....I'm sad because people of india also believe that this is all India's fault and their current leaders fault....and not even try to listen the story of the other side...what they have done to us...but pakistanis obviously don't believe us...why do they..
That's the sad part.... people don't want to read or listen to past history they only know what's happening in present and on the basis of that they make thinking about one country and simply forget the other story.
This was an unfortunate sad event in the history of mankind. I pray all souls of Hindus, Muslims, Sikhs and others who have been affected by this partition, get peace. Extreme nationalism, patriotism and religious fervor destroys humanity.
Agar aapko ye sab dekh kar dukh hota hai to aap Partition ko condemn kariye aur kahiye ki Jinnah galat tha....Two nation theory bakwaas thi...
Can we unit ones again
Like Germany ,
Imagine when we are united we lead the world in all fields
🇮🇳🇧🇩🇵🇰
Great word man...
Unite it is do remember both East and West Germany had same religion.
If you unite you too will be on f list as pak is on terror list you will be on it to.
Yesss
I LOVE TWO COUNTRY PEOPLE 💕 NO FITTING WORLD IS ONE🌎🙏
blood of indians evrywrrr......❤️❤️❤️
You have touched a very sensitive topic. Kudos for your courage & Best Wishes. I can easily imagine what the Comment Box is going to be like. 😑
Exactly
if u belong to any state of this u will end up with tears
Why video took the sharp left turn...where was Jinnah who was the root cause of this partition, nxt time don't go for these one sided videos
U think western people will drive neutral and not take the left turn !
In the west they won’t criticise pak or Muslims but every1 opens their mouth for India !
It was all Churchil’s plan...Jinna and Nehru were just playing in the hands of British
You both are so honest &humble... ❤ from Maharashtra..
7:40 Cyril Radcliffe didn't know much about India before he arrived, but it will be wrong to say that he was completely naïve. He Studied Indian Cartography for Two Months, and Boundary Commission under him included 8 People - 4 Muslims, 3 Hindus and 1 Sikh. They assisted him in drawing the map. But, I don't understand why Teja Singh, the only Sikh involved in Boundary Commission, couldn't get Kartarpur in India, as it is very important Sikh Site and just 4 kms from Boundary.
mam hum log padh chuka ye sab pehla hi goverment exam ki taiyari krna wala hoge unko pta hai ye sab . gussa es baat pa aata hai kya jarurat thi new desh bnana ki pehla bhi to sab sath m tha ek dum kya hua ki jinnaa ne bola ki hma naya desh chahiye.
ROFL no difference between that British guy who drew the map and this vlogger 🤣🤣🤣
Don't blame British for partation rather it was Ali-jinnah and the Radcliffe line was given by a commision (recommended Muslim league+Indian National Congress+ Sikh prominent leaders) unfortunate Lahore was given to Pak. due to lack of cities where other side West Bengal was Hindu majority according to 1931 Census!
And during war 1965 Indian Captured another Sikh Holy place which is in Pak right now but its retrieve happened due to Tashkent Agreement.
This is pure bigotry.
They found no speech from Imran khan blaming India.
24:08 Iman saying "Saubhagya" and Moazzam translating it to "Khushkismati". Moazzam bhai.. humko hindi aati hai, why are you translating it in Urdu?? 😂😂🤣
I cried my heart out too !! I wish you guys were here !! We all can go chill out together 🙂🙂😃
Partition Jinnah ne karwaya tha.Raaj Karna tha usse new country banake.
This vlogger might seem biased towards Indian narrative to Pakistani.
Sirf Britishers ki galti nahi hai unko alag Gina hai ye kisne bataya socho jara
Dekhiya Pehale jo India thi uski batt kuch allag thi 200 saal tak britsh hukumat ki par sochne bali batt yea hai ki jitne bhi karntikari or Mahan mahan insanone apne jaan kurban kardia kitne masumoke jaan challii gayi hajaro ki taddat main par un sabhi ne apne jaan kurban kia tha appne dash ko ajjad karne ke liya naki hukumat karne ke liya naki alagalag dash bana ne keliya par us time kya huya ki sabhi saar par kursika lallaj hukumat ka lallaj ka booth sabar tha ,chahe bo md.alli jinna ho ya neherru ji ar Gandhi ji bhi mupe talla laggake chabi fak diya tha, ya sab sunke kabhi gussa bohot atahai,aj bhi hamlog sab in Pabitra atmaoka appman karrahe hai jin logo ne apne anebale kal keliya ek sundar sapna dhakha tha apna kurbani diya tha,,,jai hind🇵🇰❤️🇮🇳❤️🇧🇩
AGAR POLITICIANS CHAHE TO AAJ BHI WAPIS EK HO SAKTE HAI..SABKO PATA HAI YE SAB BRITISHERS NE KIYA THA..PAR HUMARE POLITICIAN YE HONE NAI DENGE
Bharat(Hindu) ne division nahi kiya, aapke leaders ko Hindu ke sath rehena pasand nahi tha. Hum to abhibhi Muslimoke sath rehete hai
Ya mate .. partition ... My whole maternal side .. grand dad and grand mom had to move from mirpur to jammu ... Have heard enough wat hand stories of what happened.. how it happened... Wat done is done mate ... Partition is a reality .. we all have accepted it ...
This is an amazing video. Thx for sharing. 🙏
Like shashi tharoor said " how will u know where u are going unless you know where u came from ".
If british wasnt there we all will be one😥
Jinnah & Nehru were responsible....as simple as that.
hazaro saal ka culture tha humara,tum tum nahin the main main nahin tha,tab sirf hum the,is partition ne sab kuchh khatam kar diya.main aap dono ka reaction dekh raha tha jo ki mere reaction ka photo copy tha.hindu ........ muslim........21st century main...........
Kya ab ham dobara ek hokar nhi reh skte
Ek baar ekthe ho jao to Angrejo ki Aankhe khul jaayegi
Hindustan ko Britisher ne nae alag kia .
Kuch muslim katter the wo alag hona chahte the.wo mil ke mae rahna chahte the.
Love from India.
We can’t blam on any one leader but galati to sabki he...kisi ki jyada to kisi ki kam lekin taali to do hatho se hi bajti he
Mohammed ali jinnah is the main reason 😂
One MAN one PEN divided US!!!
Hope sare muslim chale gaye hote. Hum to sath rahna chahte thai lekin thik hai oh alag hue to sab chale gaye hote to
Kindly review Vasuki Tal Kedarnath from Spiritual Journeys RUclips channel.
All this because Jinnah wanted his own country.
This is the best video you are posted before.... 12 saal pakistani ke saath kaam kiya hey... Mr. Gul Muhammed... He still. Remember me, wo lahore ka. Hey
Why you are not talking on terror?
It's heartbreaking!!!
Who wants seprate country for muslims ?
You both are trying to make fool Indian subscribers by your emotional quotes, try to speak in hindi...
for the success of this you tube channel....
Hm to gulami jhel rhe the muglo ki bhut atayachar kiya jajiya tax tk lgaye sn 1326 se 47 tk 40 crore Hinduo ne apni jane di h is Dhrti k liye jb angraj aaye to jo Sultan bne hue the unka b no. Lgne lga or is bich hindu powerful hote gye muslmano ko lga ab hm raaj nhi kr payenge isliye btwara kiya or uske baad ye ab pak naam se nya desh chla rhe h yha b ek na ek din bdlaav aayega kyu ki muslmaan to apno k b nhi hote ye mano ya na mano pr yhi sch h or ek baat smj nhi aati ye log kisi ko sun na kyu nhi chahte
It was Muslim leaders who want separate nation.
Communities living hundreds of year together, suddenly started saying we can't live with "one community" and demanded separate country.
Utterly ridiculous thinking.
Ham beshak alag 1947 mei hua ha but Britisher ka plan Hama alag karna ka 1942-43 mei hi ban gaya tha