Personally, I don't see Garry as a "Sexy beast", but I really like Garry's protective-older brother with Ib. However, at the same time, even though Mary did some bad things, like you said, she doesn't really know any better, and she only wants to be friends, which I really like. The drawing of her, Ib, and Garry on the wall in one of the house in the sketchbook was very touching, personally. Yes, I'm one of those people who likes everybody. Go on, hate me. We need a "Everybody together" end
9CirnotheGenius9 One of the only things that will never happen (Sorry to be rude but if you do reply, I’ll be surprised since this comment is 4yrs. From now.)
As much as I love everyone I think that a perfect ending would kind of ruin this sense of consequence that "not everybody will be happy" and that sometimes you HAVE to hurt others as much as you don't want to
I agree that Mary is cute, and I can relate to her in many ways, so she's definitely my favourite character from Ib. I was really depressed when I realized that Garry and Ib's ending together was meant to be the ''true'' end...it felt like the author of the game saw Mary as a mere painting, but to me she was so much more. But I must remind you that Mary is not a yandere, she's what we call a yangire. She doesn't kill because of love, but because of other feelings.
I know i replied extremely late, but Together forever ending just like Promise of reunion are the only endings where you have pictures during ending scene, I think there's something with that.
Maybe it’s because in the endings Mary and Garry get their ideal after stories Think about it, marry probably doesn’t want ib to remember Garry so she and ib can live their happy family life without regret so in together forever it’s as if nothing ever happened and Mary is ib’s sister. And in promise of reunion Garry probably got attached to Ib in a protective brotherly way and wanted to make sure he could assure her safety after they got out by remembering her, that’s why memory crannies would’nt have been ideal because Garry with his memories of ib in the painting world would’ve ignored her if she didn’t make it out somehow. So that’s why those endings stick out
All "gaps" have to be filled. There needed to be one trapped painting inside father's gallery, and two free people outside, in the 'real' world... I wanted to get out with Ib!
I like that there are people who like everybody. I guess I liked Garry in-game but then the fangirls ruined him for me, and I'm glad to see that there are people who have the ability to like them both. That should be the main goal in the game--to learn to understand everybody else's goals and just get along, try to get out TOGETHER instead of being driven apart. It's too bad it's impossible.
This version sounds like something that would be found more in Alice: The Madness Returns or in an old funhouse that ends up darker than it seems. Not Ib. But I still really like this version!!
I honestly love Mary! Even when she's in yandere mode, she's really cute! I don't care if she wants to kill Ib or Garry, she'll always be my favorite yandere forever...
Wow this is so underviewed. I feel as if the melody could be stronger though in the beginning with the glass instrument like sound, and the violin. The pizzicato was a nice touch as well.
Hi! I feel great! So many people out there want to be my friend! They told me we would eat sweets and play and draw together... I'm so happy! And how are you?
Wow... I like... Love this one! x___x You did an awesome job here dabeat! I really do love it and I'll probably listen to this for a long, long time. ♥
Mmm, they're all based on RPG Maker, have amazing storylines, and startling climaxes. Some people consider them as "legendary," because it's quite uncommon to be able to find stories and puzzles with such storylines and plots. Since Ib, The Witch's House, and Mad Father have a lot in common (In mortal peril, some jumpscares, and messed up endings) they're often mixed up as a trio of (sort of) the same things. Nonetheless, they're all worth playing, so that's why people group them together.
I'm glad there are more people who think so. I really get tired of people going ''Oh Garry, you awesome sexy beast!'' and hating on Mary. Seriously HOW WAS SHE SUPPOSED TO KNOW BETTER!? þ.þ People can be so shallow.
That'd be a bit of a tough one... Ellen has her spells, being a witch and all, Mary (I'm guessing) would be very resilient against attacks unless her picture frame was attacked, and Aya... She has a chainsaw. ... If we knew a bit more, it'd be easy to figure out, but just from only what we've seen, I think Aya would win. Chainsaw.
Mary ''killed'' Garry because of loneliness and a will to break free from it, she probably thought this was the only time anyone was ever going to enter her gallery/art Hell. She had a lust for true happiness that she'd bottled up for way too long, so her character is related to the yandere trope but not the same.
I agree. I like how open-ended the game is in many ways, but it's extremely annoying to see so many people go on about what a bitch Mary is, and how ''hot'' Garry is (which I don't get at all). Mary is either insane or overly sweet and innocent-like. It either takes some thought or reading the diary entry and all that, which some people fail to notice. :/ There's Kyokoon64, who I absolutely adore. Her reaction to Mary was almost depressing.
I love this! May I please use it in my video? I want to make a remix with a lot of different versions and see what I get and this is beautiful. May I please use it?
Hmm, I see. Thanks for the new vocab word. And yes, I also have the same thoughts. I was disappointed that the author made Mary either "die" or live, becoming widely hated. It would've made it better if he offered more of the back story at the end of the game (much like the two extra endings, A Painting's Demise and Welcome to the World of Guertena), instead of just "How to Make Friends" and the diary entries of when she wanted to get out, and had to take a person from outside to do it.
Worded it poorly. What I meant to ask was which one would survive the same deadly supernatural event. Ellen wouldn't have access to magic, being Viola now and all. But she might have studied it enough to know how to unravel a curse like the one surrounding Mary. Mary... She's dead. Though in Together Forever she'd (likely) be a human. Unless every copy of her painting can house her (Weeping Angel-esq). Aya is crazy and would probably want to turn Mary and 'Viola' into dolls. But that chainsaw...
Ever get the true ending? Aya ends up just like him. And she uses the chainsaw for a good half of the game. In short: I wasn't referring to the Mad Father. On a side note: Ever notice how anyone that's referred to as 'The Doctor' or 'Doctor' in media is always evil (Mad Father, Cave Story, etc.)? Unless it's THE The Doctor. He's someone you'd definitely want around when things turn sour.
Well according to many people apparently only 2 can get out because Only Eve and Garry were took there, no paintings are allowed to escape because of ??????????.
She didn't just hate her, but even after reading her diary she dismissed her as the ''evil one''. (I love her HetaOni, by the way.) Garry was interesting, but I didn't feel an emotional connection to him at all. When Garry died, I didn't really care
...Mary let me explain what a Yandere is....it's someone (usually a girl) who will kill for their loved ones...Also Mary can I have a hug *tears up* I-I-I just...I can't stand why most people don't like you...I..I want to be your friend! I want you to get out with Ib...I'll even take your place in that hell that's called your home. Mary...Get out have a life with Ib, just promise me you two will get together when you're both 18. My sacrifice won't be in vain that way.
Uh... What's with the sudden appearance accounts based off of the 'RPG Maker Trio's' antagonists all over RUclips? First Ellen, now this. Hey wait... I wonder who'd win in a fight, Aya, Ellen (post body switch), or Mary?
Very interesting...I mean...I would guess Aya would win, having her chainsaw, but I would have to guess it would have to depend on where they're fighting. If it happens to be in the "Witch's House" Or Ellen's house...Ellen would have the upper hand and probably take Aya down. But Mary's picture frame would have to be protected all the time two of them are clashing, like is Ellen is keeping Mary busy and Aya makes her way to her frame. Game.Set.Match for Mary. Then it depends on the other two.
Though yeah, I know what you mean by some fangirls ruining things for everyone. Maybe this game didn't have a "everybody wins" just to make us suffer. Or maybe there's a super secret ending that is "everybody wins", only it's something ridiculous like you have to step on a certain space when you play the game, or you have to read books in a certain order.
..... @mary Hey mary! wanna be friends my other friends left me but i love to draw i have tons of dolls we can play with i have a sketch book we can draw in and we can have fun and laught and play and be best friends! ( from dane rose my ib oc she is part painting :D)
I've only seen Kyokoon64 play HetaOni. Did she absolutely hate Mary? I'll see if I have enough time to watch her Let's Play! of Ib. I only like Garry's personality, he's really nice to Ib. Plus, he talks like a lady, which is a tad funny. But his purple streaks of seaweed hair are interesting too.
wellcome to my world thats painted in sadness theres no light or sound that you see or hear who are you stranger with the red rose in your hand i like you from the start so lets play bla bla bla is he your true night in the shine armer he repersents the one who ctated bla bla lba so why do you wand to go with this man bla bla bla wellcome to her world thats covered with ashs bla bla all she wanted her father and now she burns in her ashs alone the end
![[Music box Cover] Ib OST - Puppet (Mary's Theme)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/coiYgHmZnXo/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Music box Cover] Ib OST - Puppet (Mary's Theme)](/img/tr.png)
Personally, I don't see Garry as a "Sexy beast", but I really like Garry's protective-older brother with Ib.
However, at the same time, even though Mary did some bad things, like you said, she doesn't really know any better, and she only wants to be friends, which I really like. The drawing of her, Ib, and Garry on the wall in one of the house in the sketchbook was very touching, personally.
Yes, I'm one of those people who likes everybody. Go on, hate me.
We need a "Everybody together" end
9CirnotheGenius9 One of the only things that will never happen (Sorry to be rude but if you do reply, I’ll be surprised since this comment is 4yrs. From now.)
I am just like you!
agreed
she's my personal favorite lmao
As much as I love everyone I think that a perfect ending would kind of ruin this sense of consequence that "not everybody will be happy" and that sometimes you HAVE to hurt others as much as you don't want to
I like the way this song is orchestrated. The music itself shows a little girl, but the way its played shows there is a danger when you are with her.
I agree that Mary is cute, and I can relate to her in many ways, so she's definitely my favourite character from Ib. I was really depressed when I realized that Garry and Ib's ending together was meant to be the ''true'' end...it felt like the author of the game saw Mary as a mere painting, but to me she was so much more.
But I must remind you that Mary is not a yandere, she's what we call a yangire. She doesn't kill because of love, but because of other feelings.
I know i replied extremely late, but Together forever ending just like Promise of reunion are the only endings where you have pictures during ending scene, I think there's something with that.
Maybe it’s because in the endings Mary and Garry get their ideal after stories
Think about it, marry probably doesn’t want ib to remember Garry so she and ib can live their happy family life without regret so in together forever it’s as if nothing ever happened and Mary is ib’s sister.
And in promise of reunion Garry probably got attached to Ib in a protective brotherly way and wanted to make sure he could assure her safety after they got out by remembering her, that’s why memory crannies would’nt have been ideal because Garry with his memories of ib in the painting world would’ve ignored her if she didn’t make it out somehow.
So that’s why those endings stick out
"He loves me(pluck),loves me not(pluck),he loves me~! Yay!"
-Mary
Garry... I didn't mind him at first... But when he found out, he wanted to take Ib away from me! That's why I was so upset...
All "gaps" have to be filled. There needed to be one trapped painting inside father's gallery, and two free people outside, in the 'real' world... I wanted to get out with Ib!
Im over here, Ib.
I like that there are people who like everybody. I guess I liked Garry in-game but then the fangirls ruined him for me, and I'm glad to see that there are people who have the ability to like them both. That should be the main goal in the game--to learn to understand everybody else's goals and just get along, try to get out TOGETHER instead of being driven apart. It's too bad it's impossible.
guertena got it right lmao
*Hugs back and smiles* How about tomorrow? Mary can come, too, if you like.
I-Ib? Is that you? You came back for me! B-but... How?
*Takes bunny and laughs* Now if only Garry was here. :)
I LOVE IT!!!
When I close my eyes, I can imagine dancing the waltz with a puppet, a magician, a ring master, or a villain
It isn't that bad... I'll get to see my father...
0.o
Mm-mm-Mary....
there should be an Ib anime.
I'd watch it.
I wonder what ending they'd choose though... probably Promise of Reunion
Nord maybe ... yes ... maybe not ...
This sounds like a waltz to me, not that I really know what one sounds like. I really like it, it's a good remix!
Yeah! When I close my eyes, I can imagine dancing the waltz with a puppet, a magician, or a villain
kittygirl123100 same here! But I think of Dr. Jonathan Crane aka Scarecrow(from batman begins) :3
For me, I mostly end up thinking of Undertaker from Black Butler
You sound like my friend.
really? her name?
It's like carousel music
Of course! Promise!
OMFG you did an AMAZING job on this. 😄 keep it up :3
Hmm? Well..
Why not.. I guess I could if Ib could go too.
This version sounds like something that would be found more in Alice: The Madness Returns or in an old funhouse that ends up darker than it seems. Not Ib. But I still really like this version!!
Guertena's gallery is kind of like a funhouse x)
Yay! Friends! :)
Yay! I'm so glad to hear that! Just... what's a ya-ya... yan... dere?
it's when you attempt to cover your friends with red paint using a pallete knife knife mary, don't do that
Oooh! So pretty!
Why is this underviewed?!?! THIS NEEDS MORE VIEWS..
I honestly love Mary! Even when she's in yandere mode, she's really cute! I don't care if she wants to kill Ib or Garry, she'll always be my favorite yandere forever...
Wow this is so underviewed.
I feel as if the melody could be stronger though in the beginning with the glass instrument like sound, and the violin. The pizzicato was a nice touch as well.
Hi! I feel great! So many people out there want to be my friend! They told me we would eat sweets and play and draw together... I'm so happy! And how are you?
Wow... I like... Love this one! x___x You did an awesome job here dabeat! I really do love it and I'll probably listen to this for a long, long time. ♥
ahh i love this version. it is very nice and well put together.
Holy damn this is awesome x_x I think I'm gonna be listening to this all month
Hmm... I wonder that too.
Thank you so much! You did such a great job! :'D I think I'll use this for my blog :)))
Haven't you seen the extra ending seen? Aya grows up to be like her father and makes dolls out of humans as well~
I like it.
Mary, 'yandere' means a character who is violent but shows affection towards the main character. In this case, the main character is Ib
Really nice job I love it
Mmm, they're all based on RPG Maker, have amazing storylines, and startling climaxes. Some people consider them as "legendary," because it's quite uncommon to be able to find stories and puzzles with such storylines and plots.
Since Ib, The Witch's House, and Mad Father have a lot in common (In mortal peril, some jumpscares, and messed up endings) they're often mixed up as a trio of (sort of) the same things.
Nonetheless, they're all worth playing, so that's why people group them together.
You are the cutest yandere character!
Oh! I like doing these things! I'll be your friend...!
I'm glad there are more people who think so. I really get tired of people going ''Oh Garry, you awesome sexy beast!'' and hating on Mary. Seriously HOW WAS SHE SUPPOSED TO KNOW BETTER!? þ.þ People can be so shallow.
I personally would love it if ib was an anime but I think its my fav song either way I'm a ib lover who here agrees
-DarkTyler
Hi, Mary.
I love this.
That'd be a bit of a tough one...
Ellen has her spells, being a witch and all,
Mary (I'm guessing) would be very resilient against attacks unless her picture frame was attacked,
and Aya... She has a chainsaw.
...
If we knew a bit more, it'd be easy to figure out, but just from only what we've seen, I think Aya would win. Chainsaw.
Mary ''killed'' Garry because of loneliness and a will to break free from it, she probably thought this was the only time anyone was ever going to enter her gallery/art Hell. She had a lust for true happiness that she'd bottled up for way too long, so her character is related to the yandere trope but not the same.
Welcome to the World of Guertena 😭😭😭😭😭😭🔥🔥🔥👍👍👍
Mary,here i got this for you ^^ well made it.*gives her a doll of herself with a yellow rose with it* ^^
Oh gosh.
Bring out the popcorn!
WHY ARE YOU CALLING THE FATHER AYA?!?!?!?! JEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEZ
...Can I hug you, Dabeatmaster?
Hey! *Hugs* When are we going to eat some Macaroons together?
I agree. I like how open-ended the game is in many ways, but it's extremely annoying to see so many people go on about what a bitch Mary is, and how ''hot'' Garry is (which I don't get at all). Mary is either insane or overly sweet and innocent-like. It either takes some thought or reading the diary entry and all that, which some people fail to notice. :/ There's Kyokoon64, who I absolutely adore. Her reaction to Mary was almost depressing.
You just spoiled it to me! And I had almost all the gems, too...
This old doll house I have became my new house that I live m life. And now I feel one with the dead in it. Spectacular. .)
-R.
Sure! ^^ I hope we get to be good friends too.
In the true end, well...Aya ends up becoming like her father, killing people and turning then into dolls XD
I love this! May I please use it in my video? I want to make a remix with a lot of different versions and see what I get and this is beautiful. May I please use it?
Hmm, I see. Thanks for the new vocab word. And yes, I also have the same thoughts. I was disappointed that the author made Mary either "die" or live, becoming widely hated.
It would've made it better if he offered more of the back story at the end of the game (much like the two extra endings, A Painting's Demise and Welcome to the World of Guertena), instead of just
"How to Make Friends" and the diary entries of when she wanted to get out, and had to take a person from outside to do it.
Worded it poorly. What I meant to ask was which one would survive the same deadly supernatural event.
Ellen wouldn't have access to magic, being Viola now and all. But she might have studied it enough to know how to unravel a curse like the one surrounding Mary.
Mary... She's dead. Though in Together Forever she'd (likely) be a human. Unless every copy of her painting can house her (Weeping Angel-esq).
Aya is crazy and would probably want to turn Mary and 'Viola' into dolls. But that chainsaw...
Ever get the true ending? Aya ends up just like him. And she uses the chainsaw for a good half of the game.
In short: I wasn't referring to the Mad Father.
On a side note: Ever notice how anyone that's referred to as 'The Doctor' or 'Doctor' in media is always evil (Mad Father, Cave Story, etc.)? Unless it's THE The Doctor. He's someone you'd definitely want around when things turn sour.
Ah... So pretty! Thank you! ...Will you be my friend, too?
Well according to many people apparently only 2 can get out because Only Eve and Garry were took there, no paintings are allowed to escape because of ??????????.
That is something I'll tell you when your older
Underviewed!
Aw Mary, I wan to be your friend! So we won't be lonley~!
....Holy shit....Hi Garry! Want some ice cream?
That's what it's supposed to be :)
poor Mary i think i am going to cry ;A; Aya Drevis loves you Mary.i will be your friend ;A;
Ib!! :D *gives you a bunny* Bunnies forevah!!!!! :3
She didn't just hate her, but even after reading her diary she dismissed her as the ''evil one''.
(I love her HetaOni, by the way.)
Garry was interesting, but I didn't feel an emotional connection to him at all. When Garry died, I didn't really care
...Mary let me explain what a Yandere is....it's someone (usually a girl) who will kill for their loved ones...Also Mary can I have a hug *tears up* I-I-I just...I can't stand why most people don't like you...I..I want to be your friend! I want you to get out with Ib...I'll even take your place in that hell that's called your home. Mary...Get out have a life with Ib, just promise me you two will get together when you're both 18. My sacrifice won't be in vain that way.
The percussion is a bit loud, and the key seems a bit off in the beginning, but it's not bad.
Uh...
What's with the sudden appearance accounts based off of the 'RPG Maker Trio's' antagonists all over RUclips? First Ellen, now this.
Hey wait... I wonder who'd win in a fight, Aya, Ellen (post body switch), or Mary?
i
Very interesting...I mean...I would guess Aya would win, having her chainsaw, but I would have to guess it would have to depend on where they're fighting. If it happens to be in the "Witch's House" Or Ellen's house...Ellen would have the upper hand and probably take Aya down. But Mary's picture frame would have to be protected all the time two of them are clashing, like is Ellen is keeping Mary busy and Aya makes her way to her frame. Game.Set.Match for Mary. Then it depends on the other two.
* makes it rain macaroons* Like a boss B) free candy
@Mary Guertena Yay! We'll be best friends forever right!?...:]
You should go with her Mary :)
Where we can download this remix, please ? :)
Though yeah, I know what you mean by some fangirls ruining things for everyone.
Maybe this game didn't have a "everybody wins" just to make us suffer.
Or maybe there's a super secret ending that is "everybody wins", only it's something ridiculous like you have to step on a certain space when you play the game, or you have to read books in a certain order.
..... @mary Hey mary! wanna be friends my other friends left me but i love to draw i have tons of dolls we can play with i have a sketch book we can draw in and we can have fun and laught and play and be best friends! ( from dane rose my ib oc she is part painting :D)
Apologies. I hadn't, and still haven't seen it. Yet. *Dramatic lightning*
I've only seen Kyokoon64 play HetaOni.
Did she absolutely hate Mary? I'll see if I have enough time to watch her Let's Play! of Ib.
I only like Garry's personality, he's really nice to Ib. Plus, he talks like a lady, which is a tad funny. But his purple streaks of seaweed hair are interesting too.
*mouth full of macaroons* GENTLEMEN
Congratz......? o.o'
At the very beginning, the instrument choice sounds like the Checkered Tile Path from Yume Nikki
you have seen the true ending, right??
Mary! I need a friend! I want to play dolls, color, and dance with someone!
I don't know...
I made lyrics to this ^^
I hope you don't mind that I used this for a cover! I just finished it today
soundcloud.com/saku-chan-5/puppet-thank-you-for-50-followers
is it just me or do the bells sound really off tune at the beginning?...
Leave me alone...I've had a very, very tough day...
I hope your day is better today :)
hmmmmm
Sorry but there is no way of knowing what ending you'll get till you get it. (that made no sense sorry=/)
anyone have a link to the picture?
Yangire, perhaps?
~Twili Destiny~ no
iTunes!!!
where is Garry Ib?
wellcome to my world thats painted in sadness theres no light or sound that you see or hear who are you stranger with the red rose in your hand i like you from the start so lets play bla bla bla is he your true night in the shine armer he repersents the one who ctated bla bla lba so why do you wand to go with this man bla bla bla wellcome to her world thats covered with ashs bla bla all she wanted her father and now she burns in her ashs alone the end