Who Are China's Vanishing Muslims? | History of the Uyghur 1884-2021 feat. Hikma History

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 июн 2021
  • Get MagellanTV here: try.magellantv.com/historywit... & get an exclusive offer extended to our viewers: an extra month FREE. MagellanTV is a new kind of streaming service run by filmmakers with 2,000+ documentaries! Check out our personal recommendation and MagellanTV’s exclusive playlists: www.magellantv.com/explore/hi...
    The Uyghur people live largely in the Chinese Autonomous Community of Xinjiang, and are just one of several groups of Muslims indigenous to China. In this video I explore the history of the Uyghur people and their relationship with central Chinese power from the Qing government, through the Republic of China and the People's Republic of China and the present-day Xinjiang Conflict.
    Hikma History's Video on Ughur History c. 554-1884:
    • Who Are The Uyghurs? H...
    Raid the Merch Market: teespring.com/en-GB/stores/hi...
    Go Fund My Windmills (Patreon): / historywithhilbert
    Join in the Banter on Twitter: / historywhilbert
    Enter the Fray on Facebook: / historywhilbert
    Indulge in some Instagram..?(the alliteration needs to stop): / historywithhilbert
    Send me an email if you'd be interested in doing a collaboration! historywithhilbert@gmail.com
    #Uyghur #China #Uigher

Комментарии • 1,6 тыс.

  • @historywithhilbert146
    @historywithhilbert146  3 года назад +274

    Hi everyone apologies this one is up so late there was a lot of work to do! Please check out Hikma History's excellent first part to this video with his episode on the earlier history of the Uygher people:
    ruclips.net/video/i4GQx3srO-4/видео.html

    • @HikmaHistory
      @HikmaHistory 3 года назад +10

      Thanks my man, awesome to collab with you as usual!

    • @BrorealeK
      @BrorealeK 3 года назад

      @UCp97t_lSABlKqE3kmx-bHig Sorry he wasn't fooled by fascist propaganda.

    • @StephenMortimer
      @StephenMortimer 3 года назад +5

      11:11 FIFTH COLUMN !!

    • @StephenMortimer
      @StephenMortimer 3 года назад +3

      @Tian Wong WUMAO tears ??

    • @jackcavendish8900
      @jackcavendish8900 3 года назад +5

      @Tian Wong which part of the video is false?

  • @illeagle9560
    @illeagle9560 3 года назад +672

    The 5 races flag does not symbolize all 55 recognized ethnic groups, it's only the 5 largest groups

    • @LuKing2
      @LuKing2 3 года назад +142

      The largest non-Han ethnic group (Zhuang) isn't even represented lol

    • @someperson3390
      @someperson3390 3 года назад +33

      @@LuKing2 y i k e s

    • @caleblott399
      @caleblott399 3 года назад +8

      I thought the black was to represent the rest of the ethnic groups (Because when you mix all the colors you get black)? Or am I thinking of a different flag.

    • @illeagle9560
      @illeagle9560 3 года назад +39

      @@caleblott399 nah black is Tibetans. Here's the explanation pulled from wiki
      This principle emphasized harmony between what were considered the five major ethnic groups in China, as represented by the colored stripes of the Five-Colored Flag of the Republic: the Han (red); the Manchus (yellow); the Mongols (blue); the "Hui" (white); and the Tibetans (black).[5]

    • @illeagle9560
      @illeagle9560 3 года назад +11

      @@caleblott399 Tibet is black and on the bottom because they're the least favored ethnic group of the Han leadership

  • @ironwolf2244
    @ironwolf2244 3 года назад +353

    I may not be a Muslim, but I believe all have the right to their Spiritual beliefs.
    - in related history, I wished the Tocharians survived, but they were wiped out by Turkish tribes and the Xiongnu confederation.

    • @constantineergius1626
      @constantineergius1626 3 года назад +23

      i concur that statement i also want to fight communists

    • @aimanmarzuqi4804
      @aimanmarzuqi4804 3 года назад +4

      Thanks bro, also cool profile picture you got there

    • @ironwolf2244
      @ironwolf2244 3 года назад +15

      @@aimanmarzuqi4804 It's actually not my art. I'm not sure who designed it. But it represents Tyr, one of the Norse gods of war, and the god of martial Justice. Hence the sword symbolism in the image.

    • @_robustus_
      @_robustus_ 3 года назад +41

      Uygürs absorbed a bunch of whatever Tokharians were still in Xinjiang. And a lot of Tokharians migrated to Afghanistan centuries earlier. That’s why there’s a place called Tokharistan there. Comparing what happened millennia ago to what’s going on now isn’t always useful.

    • @constantineergius1626
      @constantineergius1626 3 года назад +16

      @@aimanmarzuqi4804 the comment section is filled with tankies

  • @macaronisushi4512
    @macaronisushi4512 3 года назад +354

    I'm so sad to hear about you upcoming disappearance and subsequent deletion of all social media

  • @satyr1349
    @satyr1349 3 года назад +456

    Terribly important topic overshadowed by other events recently ofc.
    There have been many cultural genocides throughout history (along with full out genocides). It would seem there is still no abatement to this crime to be seen in the 21st century.

    • @oscarosullivan4513
      @oscarosullivan4513 3 года назад +22

      Cultural genocides can be quiet genocides

    • @MrTaxiRob
      @MrTaxiRob 3 года назад +17

      @manny022 those things are happening too. And those things are also genocide according to the UN.

    • @deezeed2817
      @deezeed2817 3 года назад +25

      This is just utter propaganda and lies by the UK and US. They support genocide in Palestine and Yemen yet are nonstop promoting a non existent “genocide” in xinjiang. They continue to push this propaganda non stop

    • @MrTaxiRob
      @MrTaxiRob 3 года назад +11

      @Albert Felsen ok Zionist

    • @monkusaugustus4017
      @monkusaugustus4017 3 года назад +4

      @manny022 bruh, they are doing that

  • @FreaKCSGOHacker
    @FreaKCSGOHacker 3 года назад +310

    Hey guys, I can practice my [REDACTED] and have no complaints about how the government treats me! I have no issues with the gov owning everything of mine, even my [REDACTED]. I have no complaints! Since I own nothing.

    • @mrmoth26
      @mrmoth26 3 года назад +9

      The government doesn't own everything in the PRC though and you are allowed to own stuff there.

    • @mingyuhuang8944
      @mingyuhuang8944 2 года назад

      I wonder how this guy came up with the idea that the ughyers are "vanishing" when the ughyer population has skyrocketed and infant mortality greatly reduced whilst the top earning, most famous female celebrity/model in China is also a ughyer.
      Great videos, but this one's a blunder. Feeds into the fake narrative creative by western media

    • @cookiecola5852
      @cookiecola5852 2 года назад +2

      Buddy T_T
      Maybe instead of ranting on the internet about stuff you likely know noting about, go and visit

    • @EquaYonah
      @EquaYonah 2 года назад +7

      @@mingyuhuang8944 Xi isn't gonna fuck you bro.

    • @sharne1577
      @sharne1577 2 года назад +3

      @@mingyuhuang8944 did you watch the video that not the point

  • @harriwhipp7949
    @harriwhipp7949 3 года назад +124

    Another great video my bro! Please keep the content coming , I can’t wait to see what you produce in the coming years! Just to let you know @ 14:45 you say 1 million and 3 million but on the screen it show 300,000,000 & 100,000,000. thanks for the video again mate !

  • @bigballsbarry4837
    @bigballsbarry4837 3 года назад +485

    “This morning, the RUclipsr known as ‘history with Hilbert’ has been found dead in his home from a believed suicide by 9 gunshots to the back of the head”

    • @badluck5647
      @badluck5647 3 года назад +125

      That is more Russia's way of doing things. China will just call Google to have him demonetized.

    •  3 года назад +47

      @@badluck5647 and after making him disapear from social media making him disapear IRL

    • @noelthorley3248
      @noelthorley3248 3 года назад +33

      @@badluck5647 No that would be the Clinton way,,, er sorry,,, you're right, the Clinton way is suicide by hanging in a suicide watch cell where the cameras fail for some strange reason.

    • @michaelporter2103
      @michaelporter2103 3 года назад +11

      Honestly if anything he's getting state departmrnt money for promoting this New Cold War propaganda. There is no genocide in Xinjiang.

    • @badluck5647
      @badluck5647 3 года назад +24

      @@noelthorley3248 McAfee didn't kill himself

  • @icysaracen3054
    @icysaracen3054 3 года назад +207

    Hilbert is Jabzy cool cousin.

    • @GerSanRiv
      @GerSanRiv 3 года назад +8

      Jazby hasn't been cool in years.

    • @GandalftheWise
      @GandalftheWise 3 года назад +1

      @@GerSanRiv even worse Jazby. Said now animates HIMSELF in the videos looking all creepy

    • @jabbatheslutt3603
      @jabbatheslutt3603 3 года назад +5

      @@GandalftheWise what’s yalls issue with jabzy?

  • @barbaralucas1220
    @barbaralucas1220 3 года назад +8

    I see a history with Hilbert video,I automatically click like and watch. Brilliant thanks Hilbert

  • @Hayanomie
    @Hayanomie 3 года назад +8

    So glad you appeared in my recommendations. Thank you for raising your voice on the matter ❤️ kindly speak about Syrians and our revolution as well

  • @B.tt.ne_A
    @B.tt.ne_A 3 года назад +10

    I'm loving these recent history videos.

  • @moucharachikha1235
    @moucharachikha1235 3 года назад +6

    Thank you for covering such important topic.

  • @pattobyo
    @pattobyo 3 года назад +38

    This was a great video! I would love to see more on the same topic. The more we spread knowledge about this topic, the less people will be able to ignore it.

  • @krealyesitisbeta5642
    @krealyesitisbeta5642 3 года назад +180

    China: “They will not respect your religion or your way of life!”
    Uyghurs: “Neither will you.”

    • @ajramirez77
      @ajramirez77 2 года назад +11

      They probably would've had their own state if they joined the USSR smh

    • @carljohnson2194
      @carljohnson2194 2 года назад +5

      Exactly

    • @tvc6886
      @tvc6886 Год назад

      Id quicker respect communist china than a m*slim state.

    • @OilFinder3001
      @OilFinder3001 3 месяца назад

      ​@@ajramirez77so you support the genocides there?

    • @phlegmconnoisseur2241
      @phlegmconnoisseur2241 2 месяца назад

      Bro there’s 20 million Muslims in China.

  • @theveira2562
    @theveira2562 3 года назад +11

    Good to see people talking about the Uyghurs. As a socialist, I hate seeing tankies play defense for China when they get called out for their horrific bullshit

  • @SuperPassionflower
    @SuperPassionflower 2 года назад +11

    thank you for this. Together with the video by Hikma H. on the topic of the Uyghur People. this is very learnful and informative, I've subscribed now to your channel and visit more than once in times to come. Peace!

  • @kabochaVA
    @kabochaVA 3 года назад +254

    14:46 "...there are at least a million people"
    Shows 100,000,000. That's 100x more. 😐

    • @Spicygamer_57
      @Spicygamer_57 3 года назад +24

      When the statistics are cartoonishly exaggerated

    • @Matt_The_Hugenot
      @Matt_The_Hugenot 3 года назад +4

      Glad I'm not the first.

    • @TheUnamzingAtheist
      @TheUnamzingAtheist 3 года назад +50

      He said what he meant. He wrote it wrong.

    • @Richard-yy8tn
      @Richard-yy8tn 3 года назад +15

      @@TheUnamzingAtheist oh you mean the 1 million figure that was extrapolated by interviewing 6 people from the Uyghur Congress? And then multiplying it by the population. LMFAO what a joke of a research that would not even pass a community level college sources.

    • @devinlastnamenotneeded8521
      @devinlastnamenotneeded8521 3 года назад +20

      @@Richard-yy8tn Chill man it was obviously a typo lmao

  • @user-is1lo9dx2i
    @user-is1lo9dx2i 3 года назад +207

    Hilbert'social credit point:0

  • @iacobibrasiliensium2139
    @iacobibrasiliensium2139 3 года назад +27

    Great video as always!
    And taking your offer to suggest new topics could you talk about the tupi and Guarani minorities in Brazil post independence? It's a topic that is not often discussed outside of Brazil or even in it for that matter

  • @AttaBek1422
    @AttaBek1422 3 года назад +42

    It’s so gut wrenching and upsetting to me as an Arab Muslim seeing what’s happening to my Uyghur brothers in East Turkestan (or Uyghurstan depending on what you prefer). I only wish our leaders across the Muslim world would actually grow a spine and a pair and stand up for our brothers against their tribulation. How can leaders like Erdogan, Imran Khan and Khameini decry Israeli ethnic cleansing of Palestinians yet take CCP money and not ask questions? We are a global community of 1.6 billion people and if we understood that we wouldn’t need to align ourselves with this false choice of either pro west or east.
    Anyways that’s enough ranting. Thank you Hilbert for this very informative video.

    • @samuelademeso9041
      @samuelademeso9041 2 года назад

      Arab Christian: bitch please

    • @AttaBek1422
      @AttaBek1422 2 года назад +1

      @@samuelademeso9041 ‘MUH MENA CHRISTIANS’ please take your broken record and put it where the sun don’t shine. MENA Christians are at least 100 times better off than POC Christians in Europe and America

    • @durudcapacity7458
      @durudcapacity7458 Год назад

      Yousef Atta, Leaders of Muslim countries including PALESTINE, OIC, ISIS, Al qaeda, Hezbollah, Hamas and others are Concubines of China....Xi Jinping and all members of CCP central committee must face Nuremburg Style Justice and Execution for China's Uyghur Genocide, Tibetan Genocide, Manchurian Genocide, Yellow Uyghur Gansu Genocide, Kazakh Aksay Genocide and extermination of non-Chinese ethnic groups in war criminal China's army unlawfully occupied Vast Uyghuristan (Eastern Turkestan), Tibet, Manchuria, Yellow Uyghur Gansu, Kazakh Aksay, Koknoor, Guangxi Zhuang region,Yunnan and non-Chinese territories.
      There was no China and no Chinese in the world in entire world history. Communist Soviet Russia created CCP in 1921. CCP created China on 1 October 1949. Since 1949 war criminal China's army unlawfully invaded into Eastern Turkestan, Tibet, Southern Mongolia, Manchuria, Yellow Uyghur Gansu, Kazakh Aksay, Koknoor, Guangxi Zhuang Region, Yunnan, Ningxia Hui region and other territories.
      Since ancient times Mandarin language is the language of Manchu-Eastern Turk elites on the plains of Yellow River. Since 1954, Mandarin language is the official language of New born China.
      Mandarin language is not Fictional Chinese language.
      In fact in real world there is no such thing "Chinese ethnic group, Chinese DNA, Chinese language, Chinese culture, Chinese medicine, Chinese food, Chinese civilization ...". Chinese is fictional concept.
      Since 1954, China have Created Fictional "Chinese civilization" and Fictional "Han-Chinese" by unlawfully mix up the cultures of many totally different nations on the plains of Yellow River, YANGTZE RIVER, shores of Pacific ocean, East Asia, etc.
      In China, Han-Chinese are CCP. Han-Chinese eats everything moving around, zero hygiene, zero civilization, zero morality. They are Masters of deception, cheat, lie, spy, steal, hack, copy, troll, murder, deny.
      All Han-Chinese are RECENT illegal invaders, war criminals, terrorists, thieves in war criminal China's army unlawfully occupied Vast Eastern Turkestan, Tibet and all non Chinese territories.
      In fact Han-Chinese do not belong to Eastern Turkestan, Tibet, Southern Mongolia, Manchuria, Yellow Uyghur Karasu (aka Gansu), Koknoor (aka Qinghai), Kazakh Aksay.
      All terrorists are 100 Percent Han-Chinese in China unlawfully occupied Eastern Turkestan, Tibet and non Chinese territories.
      In fact The world's biggest single issue in 2022 is China's Uyghur Genocide in war criminal China's army unlawfully occupied UYGHURISTAN (Eastern Turkestan) of Uyghur Nation.
      We have worked as Foreign Experts for China's government for over 20 years. We are masters of Mandarin language. We are experts of China. We travelled all over China.
      We travelled all over war criminal China's army unlawfully occupied Ten Countries: UYGHURISTAN (Eastern Turkestan), Tibet, Southern Mongolia, Manchuria, Yellow Uyghur Karasu (aka Gansu after 1952), Kazakh Aksay, Koknoor (aka Qinghai after 1952), Ningxia Hui Republic, Guangxi Zhuang Region, Yunnan, Cantonia.
      China's Uyghur Genocide is going on in war criminal Chinese army unlawfully occupied UYGHURISTAN (Eastern Turkestan). Because Eastern Turkestan is very rich in all kinds of natural resources, naturally very diverse and vast.
      Chinese wanted to totally exterminate Uyghur Nation and Chinese wanted to take over Eastern Turkestan from Uyghur Nation.
      Since ancient times, the world's second biggest Gobi Desert has totally isolated Eastern Turkestan in the Far West and China in the Far East of Asia.
      Uyghurs DO NOT LIVE IN CHINA in East Asia. Uyghurs live in own Natural Territory Eastern Turkestan in Central Asia.
      Eastern Turkestan of Uyghur Nation is not "Xinjiang" of China.
      Uyghur Nation is not "Ethnic minority of China ".
      Uyghur Nation is not "Chinese Muslims ".
      Uyghur Nation has nothing to do with Han-Chinese and China.
      China is a country in far East of Asia. East Turkestan is a country in Central Asia.
      East Turkestan has nothing to do with Han-Chinese.
      Size of Eastern Turkestan is bigger than the combination of Europe's biggest Four Countries - Germany, France, Britain and Italy.
      East Turkestan is the world's biggest producer of rare earth materials, uranium, jade, gold, silver, cotton, tomatoes, garlic, silk, cashmere, green, raisins, Grapes, wool, leather, meat, marble, etc.
      East Turkestan is one of the world's biggest producer of coal, salt, petrol, natural gas, mika, and many others.
      Uyghur Nation was the Riches Nation in the world before China's illegal invasion into Eastern Turkestan on 20 October 1949.
      China has been robbing Trillions of US dollars of energy, food, raw materials, uranium, rare earth materials, Jade, gold, fresh bottled water, fresh bottled air, Uyghur Organs, Uyghur blood, Uyghur flesh, and many goods from Chinese army unlawfully occupied Eastern Turkestan of Uyghur Nation.
      Poor China, over 1.4 Billion hungry Chinese and millions of junk factories in China cannot survive without Robbing TRILLIONS of US dollars of natural resources from natural resources extremely rich, naturally very diverse and vast Eastern Turkestan of Uyghur Nation.
      Since late 2016 China unlawfully cut off all telephone connections, Internet connections, postal services and travel for all Uyghurs in between Eastern Turkestan and rest of the world.
      China has kicked out all foreigners from East Turkestan of Uyghur-Turk Nation and China DO NOT ISSUE VISA FOR FOREIGNERS TO TRAVEL TO EASTERN TURKESTAN.
      China do not let foreigners with China's Visa to travel to East Turkestan to meet up with Uyghurs without Han-Chinese state agents under strict surveillance.
      Only China paid foreign criminals with Han-Chinese State security agents together go to Eastern Turkestan to make propaganda videos for Chinese government to cover up China's Uyghur Genocide.
      Even China paid foreign criminals cannot travel to Eastern Turkestan to meet up with Uyghurs without Han-Chinese state agents under strict surveillance. All pictures and videos are strictly controlled by Chinese government.
      All "HAPPY UYGHUR VIDEOS " on RUclips are "Made in China" by China' state security agents with China paid foreign criminals.
      China do not let Uyghurs from Eastern Turkestan freely travel to China.
      China do not let Uyghurs from Eastern Turkestan to travel to any other countries.
      China do not let Uyghurs from other countries to go to Eastern Turkestan to meet up with their parents and family
      China do not let Uyghurs escape from East Turkestan to other countries. Many Uyghurs are shot dead on the way escape from East Turkestan to other countries. Uyghurs cannot be refugees in neighbouring Pakistan.
      China do not let foreigner to talk to Uyghurs without Han-Chinese state security agents in Chinese army unlawfully occupied Eastern Turkestan.
      Strict SURVELANCE and strict Family planning are only applied to Uyghur Nation in Chinese army unlawfully occupied Eastern Turkestan.
      Chinese illegal invaders have no family planning in Eastern Turkestan.
      War criminal China has been unlawfully transferring millions of own Han-Chinese from extremely poor Chinese villages in China to Eastern Turkestan, Tibet and all non Chinese territories to destroy local people.
      War Criminal Chinese government and China paid foreign criminals are producing disinformation campaign Worldwide to cover up China's Uyghur Genocide, China's Uyghur Organ Harvesting, China's Uyghur Concentration mass murder camps, China's crime against humanity, China's war crime, China's erase Uyghur Nation in Chinese army unlawfully occupied East Turkestan of Uyghur Nation.
      Many over 80 years old Uyghurs are locked up in "China's Uyghur Re-education mass murder camps" in Chinese army unlawfully occupied Eastern Turkestan.
      Many Uyghur children are locked up in " China's Uyghur Concentration Re-education camps " in Chinese army unlawfully occupied Eastern Turkestan.
      China did not lock up Han-Chinese Terrorists in "China's Re-education camps " in Eastern Turkestan.
      Since 1964, War criminal China Tested 46 Nuclear Bombs on Defenceless Uyghur Civilians in Chinese army unlawfully occupied East Turkestan of Uyghur Nation.
      China's Uyghur Forced Sterilisation, Forced Abortion and Organ Harvesting industry are booming.
      China do not let Uyghurs access Internet, smart phone, international phone call and postal services.
      CHINA UNLAWFULLY CUT OFF ALL TELEPHONE CONNECTIONS, INTERNET CONNECTIONS, POSTAL SERVICES AND TRAVEL FOR ALL UYGHURS IN BETWEEN UYGHUR EAST TURKESTAN AND REST OF THE WORLD.
      From 2015, China do not issue Tourist Visa for foreigners to travel to Eastern Turkestan.
      China has exterminated all Uyghurs who has spoken with foreign tourists in Eastern Turkestan in the past.
      China do not let Uyghurs to talk to Foreigners without Han-Chinese state security agents in Eastern Turkestan.
      China do net let Journalists from democratic Countries to go to Eastern Turkestan to meet up with Uyghurs without Han-Chinese state agents.
      China do not let UN officials to go to Eastern Turkestan to meet up with Uyghurs without Han-Chinese state agents.
      China's disinformation campaign Worldwide to cover up China's Uyghur Genocide are going on in all countries.
      China has bribed all top leaders of all Muslim countries including PALESTINE, OIC, ISIS, Al qaeda, Hezbollah, Hamas, Taliban.
      Except Turkey, Albania and Bosnia, All Muslim countries including PALESTINE have officially supported China's Uyghur Genocide at the UN HRC assembly in every session. Leaders of those Muslim countries including PALESTINE must face Nuremburg Style Justice and Execution for supporting China's Uyghur Genocide in war criminal China's army unlawfully occupied Eastern Turkestan of Uyghur Nation.
      Independence and Self Governing for Eastern Turkestan, Tibet, Taiwan and Hong Kong......=×@v...

    • @user-ul6mq1jd8f
      @user-ul6mq1jd8f Год назад +1

      Talk about yourself

    • @user-ul6mq1jd8f
      @user-ul6mq1jd8f Год назад +1

      العرب بالجزيره العربيه فقط اما انتم يالشوام لستم عرب

  • @google_admin1
    @google_admin1 11 месяцев назад +5

    Chinese were too soft and friendly that they didn’t massacre most of indigenous ppl in Xinjiang like British and other European did in Australia, Tasmania, New Zealand, American continent. If they did what Europeans did they wouldn’t have been criticized or been asked for accepting their independence

  • @Komokoto
    @Komokoto 2 года назад +4

    Thank you for making this video, it was very eye opening, i only heard about them in the news a couple of years ago but didn't know much more than what little seeped in the news, and now nothing is said about them 😞

  • @GarlicToast
    @GarlicToast 2 года назад

    Thanks for doing this video!

  • @Kincoran
    @Kincoran 3 года назад +11

    There was a tremendous amount of information in this video that I hadn't ever come across before; all of it important to be able to get a decent understanding of the situation. Thanks for putting the time into this!

    • @comradekenobi6908
      @comradekenobi6908 3 года назад

      Based WARHAMMER fan????

    • @Kincoran
      @Kincoran 3 года назад

      @@comradekenobi6908 pardon?

    • @comradekenobi6908
      @comradekenobi6908 3 года назад

      @@Kincoran nah I just see in your channel that you have an interest in Warhammer :)

    • @Kincoran
      @Kincoran 3 года назад

      @@comradekenobi6908 :D

  • @kazakhdoge1822
    @kazakhdoge1822 3 года назад +138

    Hilbert, thank you for doing this video and raising awareness about the plight of Uyghurs in Xinjiang. It seems that you've certainly done your research, considering that you pronounce "Uyghur" correctly, unlike many other Western commentators I've seen who pronounce it like "Wee-gars", which just hurts my ears. Also, many testimonies and evidence about the repressions in Xinjiang were collected from Kazakhs (they're persecuted too) and Uyghurs from the region who had Kazakh citizenships. Unfortunately our government is much less enthusiastic to help them because they prefer economic trade over human rights violations in Xinjiang. Plus, we live in a dictatorship too, where public dissent is rarely tolerated.

    • @aidanlutz8106
      @aidanlutz8106 2 года назад +8

      It’s not only Kazakhs and Uyghurs, China wants to create a Han state.

    • @LyuChen94
      @LyuChen94 2 года назад

      @@aidanlutz8106 🙃🙃🙃

    • @gtm9755
      @gtm9755 2 года назад +6

      “Xinjiang “ is an colonial name of East Turkestan,

    • @williamthebonquerer9181
      @williamthebonquerer9181 Год назад +1

      @@gtm9755 east Turkistan is an English term XD. It's like when south Africa band afrikans and replaced it with English post apartheid

    • @gtm9755
      @gtm9755 Год назад +5

      @@williamthebonquerer9181 u have no idea what u talking about, pls go home and sleep

  • @AskTorin
    @AskTorin 3 года назад +1

    Thanks for this, Hil

  • @rickdymanus7680
    @rickdymanus7680 3 года назад +1

    SO naar jou man Hilbert, goede content en een goed hart

  • @isaacgriffin5690
    @isaacgriffin5690 3 года назад +12

    Another great video!
    Your videos are so informative, I learn more from them then most other documentaries on the same subject.
    Keep up the great work!

  • @alansmithee8831
    @alansmithee8831 3 года назад +34

    Hello Hilbert.
    I used to stay up all hours too when a student. One late night programme I used to watch was the Silk Road by a Japanese team showing how diverse this area was. I remember I was by coincidence painting Scythian wargames figures and had just realized the Tsung Nu were originally in this area. I always was interested in the topics you are studying, but chose science thinking about a job at the end of studying, so I wish you good luck and keep doing what you love.
    Have you ever looked at China's ancient western expansion and whether this contributed to the end of the Roman empire as steppe people moved west? I am still on catch up with years of videos to check out on your channel.

    • @LeonStuart1899
      @LeonStuart1899 Год назад

      Alan ..yesss I love that series ..absolutely amazing ..it still on yt if you want watch ..

  • @dianebode6551
    @dianebode6551 2 года назад +2

    Thank you for your good work on presenting these two videos presenting Uyghur History and the current genocide. All of us need to wake-up!!!

  • @PrawdziwyWarszawiak
    @PrawdziwyWarszawiak 3 года назад

    Thanks for making the video

  • @kaiserreichempireofohio834
    @kaiserreichempireofohio834 3 года назад +39

    6:34 oh good lord those borders….

  • @ShubhamMishrabro
    @ShubhamMishrabro 3 года назад +93

    Now you mentioned dzungar genocide. A video on it will very interesting

    • @_robustus_
      @_robustus_ 3 года назад +11

      …..to be preceded by a video on who the Dzungars were in the 1st place. Not everyone is as well read as we are😉

    • @mothercoconuts3923
      @mothercoconuts3923 2 года назад

      @@_robustus_ Dzungars are a branch of Oirads, basically Mongols but not really. Qing was a Manchu dynasty btw

  • @fullytokd
    @fullytokd 2 года назад +2

    Great cause, thanks for the video 👍

  • @MrTilldaddy
    @MrTilldaddy 3 года назад +58

    Hilbert proves yet again how based he is.

  • @Artur_M.
    @Artur_M. 3 года назад +25

    Thank you for covering this topic in such depth. It might be just a detail, but I particularly appreciate how you pronounced the word Uyghur. I assume that it's a more correct way of pronouncing it, than what I usually hear from the English speakers.

    • @ParagonCS
      @ParagonCS 3 года назад +3

      it's a different approach to pronunciation rather than turkic and most reporters you hear will say the word with the chinese way. uyghurs themselves would pronounce the word as ooy-ghour.
      this would be the way a turkic person would pronounce the word forvo.com/word/uyghur/#ug

    • @gtm9755
      @gtm9755 Год назад

      Right pronunciation “ ooyghoor, or ooighoor”

  • @wm1389
    @wm1389 2 года назад +3

    Bro, your videos are awesome. Just a small suggestion: make periodic update videos, 1-2 minutes long about topics already covered. Thanks. Jazakallah.

  • @trollgemomo3823
    @trollgemomo3823 3 года назад

    Love the video!

  • @aklale1349
    @aklale1349 2 года назад

    Thank you so much for your this true video ☺️💙💐

  • @veldrensavoth7119
    @veldrensavoth7119 3 года назад +34

    I’m so glad I finally know how to pronounce them

  • @Mongol_Invasion
    @Mongol_Invasion 3 года назад +13

    Very nice video Hilbert. You actually pronounced Uighur correctly unlike many talking heads on tv

    • @toilet_cleaner_man
      @toilet_cleaner_man Год назад

      he has excellent arabic/other islamic language pronunciation, other videos on islamic militas and terror groups are examples.

  • @kcio3erene307
    @kcio3erene307 Год назад +1

    good video. helps with basics but not fully detailed areas

  • @lesliecas2695
    @lesliecas2695 2 года назад +27

    Hilbert, I have always found Islam to be interesting from the standpoint of the different sects and whether they "get along with each other" or not. The Uyghurs are Muslim yet they do not seem to get any support from the "Muslim World" which is vast. A video about Muslim's differences would be excellent. Thank you.

    • @boygenius538_8
      @boygenius538_8 2 года назад +31

      It’s not theological in this case. Normal Muslim people have a great deal of sympathy for Uyghurs and any oppressed Muslims (or oppressed people in general). The government’s don’t have the balls to get off of china’s glory hole. Pakistan, Saudi Arabia are examples of that. It’s even happening with Palestine, with UAE and Israel makin sham peace deals. It’s not about religion anymore , it’s geopolitics, economics, and greed.

    • @lalitthapa101
      @lalitthapa101 2 года назад +3

      Its Cause China is a big player.
      If it was a country like nauru doing it,youd have all the Islamic countries forming a coalition and invading the country.
      But its China and its holds a lot of power and politics is dirty in the end and prioritizing interests over humanity is something politicians excel in

    • @muhammadadeel8639
      @muhammadadeel8639 Год назад

      This is because most muslim countries were colonized by West, not China. Israel being the last western colony left in muslim world. Plus china generally supports muslim countries against Western hegemony. Once western hegemony is over, muslims will consider china as big an enemy as West

    • @durudcapacity7458
      @durudcapacity7458 Год назад

      @@boygenius538_8 Islamic?....Xi Jinping and all members of CCP central committee must face Nuremburg Style Justice and Execution for China's Uyghur Genocide, Tibetan Genocide, Manchurian Genocide, Yellow Uyghur Gansu Genocide, Kazakh Aksay Genocide and extermination of non-Chinese ethnic groups in war criminal China's army unlawfully occupied Vast Uyghuristan (Eastern Turkestan), Tibet, Manchuria, Yellow Uyghur Gansu, Kazakh Aksay, Koknoor, Guangxi Zhuang region,Yunnan and non-Chinese territories.
      There was no China and no Chinese in the world in entire world history. Communist Soviet Russia created CCP in 1921. CCP created China on 1 October 1949. Since 1949 war criminal China's army unlawfully invaded into Eastern Turkestan, Tibet, Southern Mongolia, Manchuria, Yellow Uyghur Gansu, Kazakh Aksay, Koknoor, Guangxi Zhuang Region, Yunnan, Ningxia Hui region and other territories.
      Since ancient times Mandarin language is the language of Manchu-Eastern Turk elites on the plains of Yellow River. Since 1954, Mandarin language is the official language of New born China.
      Mandarin language is not Fictional Chinese language.
      In fact in real world there is no such thing "Chinese ethnic group, Chinese DNA, Chinese language, Chinese culture, Chinese medicine, Chinese food, Chinese civilization ...". Chinese is fictional concept.
      Since 1954, China have Created Fictional "Chinese civilization" and Fictional "Han-Chinese" by unlawfully mix up the cultures of many totally different nations on the plains of Yellow River, YANGTZE RIVER, shores of Pacific ocean, East Asia, etc.
      In China, Han-Chinese are CCP. Han-Chinese eats everything moving around, zero hygiene, zero civilization, zero morality. They are Masters of deception, cheat, lie, spy, steal, hack, copy, troll, murder, deny.
      All Han-Chinese are RECENT illegal invaders, war criminals, terrorists, thieves in war criminal China's army unlawfully occupied Vast Eastern Turkestan, Tibet and all non Chinese territories.
      In fact Han-Chinese do not belong to Eastern Turkestan, Tibet, Southern Mongolia, Manchuria, Yellow Uyghur Karasu (aka Gansu), Koknoor (aka Qinghai), Kazakh Aksay.
      All terrorists are 100 Percent Han-Chinese in China unlawfully occupied Eastern Turkestan, Tibet and non Chinese territories.
      In fact The world's biggest single issue in 2022 is China's Uyghur Genocide in war criminal China's army unlawfully occupied UYGHURISTAN (Eastern Turkestan) of Uyghur Nation.
      We have worked as Foreign Experts for China's government for over 20 years. We are masters of Mandarin language. We are experts of China. We travelled all over China.
      We travelled all over war criminal China's army unlawfully occupied Ten Countries: UYGHURISTAN (Eastern Turkestan), Tibet, Southern Mongolia, Manchuria, Yellow Uyghur Karasu (aka Gansu after 1952), Kazakh Aksay, Koknoor (aka Qinghai after 1952), Ningxia Hui Republic, Guangxi Zhuang Region, Yunnan, Cantonia.
      China's Uyghur Genocide is going on in war criminal Chinese army unlawfully occupied UYGHURISTAN (Eastern Turkestan). Because Eastern Turkestan is very rich in all kinds of natural resources, naturally very diverse and vast.
      Chinese wanted to totally exterminate Uyghur Nation and Chinese wanted to take over Eastern Turkestan from Uyghur Nation.
      Since ancient times, the world's second biggest Gobi Desert has totally isolated Eastern Turkestan in the Far West and China in the Far East of Asia.
      Uyghurs DO NOT LIVE IN CHINA in East Asia. Uyghurs live in own Natural Territory Eastern Turkestan in Central Asia.
      Eastern Turkestan of Uyghur Nation is not "Xinjiang" of China.
      Uyghur Nation is not "Ethnic minority of China ".
      Uyghur Nation is not "Chinese Muslims ".
      Uyghur Nation has nothing to do with Han-Chinese and China.
      China is a country in far East of Asia. East Turkestan is a country in Central Asia.
      East Turkestan has nothing to do with Han-Chinese.
      Size of Eastern Turkestan is bigger than the combination of Europe's biggest Four Countries - Germany, France, Britain and Italy.
      East Turkestan is the world's biggest producer of rare earth materials, uranium, jade, gold, silver, cotton, tomatoes, garlic, silk, cashmere, green, raisins, Grapes, wool, leather, meat, marble, etc.
      East Turkestan is one of the world's biggest producer of coal, salt, petrol, natural gas, mika, and many others.
      Uyghur Nation was the Riches Nation in the world before China's illegal invasion into Eastern Turkestan on 20 October 1949.
      China has been robbing Trillions of US dollars of energy, food, raw materials, uranium, rare earth materials, Jade, gold, fresh bottled water, fresh bottled air, Uyghur Organs, Uyghur blood, Uyghur flesh, and many goods from Chinese army unlawfully occupied Eastern Turkestan of Uyghur Nation.
      Poor China, over 1.4 Billion hungry Chinese and millions of junk factories in China cannot survive without Robbing TRILLIONS of US dollars of natural resources from natural resources extremely rich, naturally very diverse and vast Eastern Turkestan of Uyghur Nation.
      Since late 2016 China unlawfully cut off all telephone connections, Internet connections, postal services and travel for all Uyghurs in between Eastern Turkestan and rest of the world.
      China has kicked out all foreigners from East Turkestan of Uyghur-Turk Nation and China DO NOT ISSUE VISA FOR FOREIGNERS TO TRAVEL TO EASTERN TURKESTAN.
      China do not let foreigners with China's Visa to travel to East Turkestan to meet up with Uyghurs without Han-Chinese state agents under strict surveillance.
      Only China paid foreign criminals with Han-Chinese State security agents together go to Eastern Turkestan to make propaganda videos for Chinese government to cover up China's Uyghur Genocide.
      Even China paid foreign criminals cannot travel to Eastern Turkestan to meet up with Uyghurs without Han-Chinese state agents under strict surveillance. All pictures and videos are strictly controlled by Chinese government.
      All "HAPPY UYGHUR VIDEOS " on RUclips are "Made in China" by China' state security agents with China paid foreign criminals.
      China do not let Uyghurs from Eastern Turkestan freely travel to China.
      China do not let Uyghurs from Eastern Turkestan to travel to any other countries.
      China do not let Uyghurs from other countries to go to Eastern Turkestan to meet up with their parents and family
      China do not let Uyghurs escape from East Turkestan to other countries. Many Uyghurs are shot dead on the way escape from East Turkestan to other countries. Uyghurs cannot be refugees in neighbouring Pakistan.
      China do not let foreigner to talk to Uyghurs without Han-Chinese state security agents in Chinese army unlawfully occupied Eastern Turkestan.
      Strict SURVELANCE and strict Family planning are only applied to Uyghur Nation in Chinese army unlawfully occupied Eastern Turkestan.
      Chinese illegal invaders have no family planning in Eastern Turkestan.
      War criminal China has been unlawfully transferring millions of own Han-Chinese from extremely poor Chinese villages in China to Eastern Turkestan, Tibet and all non Chinese territories to destroy local people.
      War Criminal Chinese government and China paid foreign criminals are producing disinformation campaign Worldwide to cover up China's Uyghur Genocide, China's Uyghur Organ Harvesting, China's Uyghur Concentration mass murder camps, China's crime against humanity, China's war crime, China's erase Uyghur Nation in Chinese army unlawfully occupied East Turkestan of Uyghur Nation.
      Many over 80 years old Uyghurs are locked up in "China's Uyghur Re-education mass murder camps" in Chinese army unlawfully occupied Eastern Turkestan.
      Many Uyghur children are locked up in " China's Uyghur Concentration Re-education camps " in Chinese army unlawfully occupied Eastern Turkestan.
      China did not lock up Han-Chinese Terrorists in "China's Re-education camps " in Eastern Turkestan.
      Since 1964, War criminal China Tested 46 Nuclear Bombs on Defenceless Uyghur Civilians in Chinese army unlawfully occupied East Turkestan of Uyghur Nation.
      China's Uyghur Forced Sterilisation, Forced Abortion and Organ Harvesting industry are booming.
      China do not let Uyghurs access Internet, smart phone, international phone call and postal services.
      CHINA UNLAWFULLY CUT OFF ALL TELEPHONE CONNECTIONS, INTERNET CONNECTIONS, POSTAL SERVICES AND TRAVEL FOR ALL UYGHURS IN BETWEEN UYGHUR EAST TURKESTAN AND REST OF THE WORLD.
      From 2015, China do not issue Tourist Visa for foreigners to travel to Eastern Turkestan.
      China has exterminated all Uyghurs who has spoken with foreign tourists in Eastern Turkestan in the past.
      China do not let Uyghurs to talk to Foreigners without Han-Chinese state security agents in Eastern Turkestan.
      China do net let Journalists from democratic Countries to go to Eastern Turkestan to meet up with Uyghurs without Han-Chinese state agents.
      China do not let UN officials to go to Eastern Turkestan to meet up with Uyghurs without Han-Chinese state agents.
      China's disinformation campaign Worldwide to cover up China's Uyghur Genocide are going on in all countries.
      China has bribed all top leaders of all Muslim countries including PALESTINE, OIC, ISIS, Al qaeda, Hezbollah, Hamas, Taliban.
      Except Turkey, Albania and Bosnia, All Muslim countries including PALESTINE have officially supported China's Uyghur Genocide at the UN HRC assembly in every session. Leaders of those Muslim countries including PALESTINE must face Nuremburg Style Justice and Execution for supporting China's Uyghur Genocide in war criminal China's army unlawfully occupied Eastern Turkestan of Uyghur Nation.
      Independence and Self Governing for Eastern Turkestan, Tibet, Taiwan and Hong Kong......₩¥€×vv....

    • @Akhjar7161
      @Akhjar7161 Год назад +1

      Mainly because the news from that region is so rare and contact between Uyghur Muslims and other Muslims are so rare.

  • @jakubkundzik3367
    @jakubkundzik3367 3 года назад +7

    It's actually 5th column. The term was first used by general Franco, claiming that besides 4 columns of his regular troops, there is a fifth one behind enemy lines

  • @Res-5000
    @Res-5000 3 года назад +35

    damn this was really interesting, I'd love to see a continuation.

  • @LimeyRedneck
    @LimeyRedneck Год назад

    Here from Hikma History 🤠💜

  • @viperking6573
    @viperking6573 Год назад

    Good job Hilbert!

  • @onecertainesquire486
    @onecertainesquire486 3 года назад +3

    Wonderful Video! Out of interest, how will the funds of the video given out help the people it goes to exactly? Not trying to be rude or overly cynical, I’m just interested in how it’ll work!

  • @chiron14pl
    @chiron14pl 2 года назад +9

    The Chinese approach to eliminating Uyghur cultural identity reminds me of the humorous meme (though the cultural genocide is not humorous but horrific), "The floggings will continue until morale improves." Punitive measures only stimulate either sullen silence or overt resistance.

  • @adnanhussain1460
    @adnanhussain1460 2 года назад +1

    plain information with good initiative

  • @umarsukhera1912
    @umarsukhera1912 2 года назад

    Great video

  • @Andeimir
    @Andeimir 3 года назад +82

    Thank you for bringing attention to the Uyghur's plight, Hilbert.
    For further introduction, I recommend the episode Jocko and Darryl Cooper did on them in their podcast The Unraveling, episode 14: A Melting Pot On Boil.
    As a side note, while I do commend your attempt at pronouncing their endonym, the gh is similar-ish to the Arabic letter غ, and written with it. To my non-Uyghur/Turkic and non-Arab ear it's still a tad different, somewhere in the voiced uvular fricative to voiced velar approximant range.

  • @Ye-Hu
    @Ye-Hu 3 года назад +56

    You killed my people!
    CCP: Do you have the slightest idea how little that narrows it down?

    • @Adsper2000
      @Adsper2000 3 года назад +2

      @Albert Felsen I can’t imagine why they would be prone to radicalism when under the boot of a government who would do something like this to them.
      Maybe if self-determination meant anything in China, none of this would’ve happened.

    • @Adsper2000
      @Adsper2000 3 года назад +1

      @Albert Felsen Muslims in what is now Eastern China have been fighting against the Chinese government for centuries.
      The foreign terror groups probably encouraged things by a large margin, but these recent radical Uygher movements have simply adopted modern Islamism to motivate an already existing conflict for independence that’s been going on for generations.

    • @Adsper2000
      @Adsper2000 3 года назад +6

      @Albert Felsen Meant Western China, not Eastern China.
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dzungar-Qing_Wars
      (The Dzungar were not Muslim but represent the historical struggle of the peoples inside this region)
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ten_Great_Campaigns#Campaign_in_Altishahr_(Third_campaign)
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revolt_of_the_Altishahr_Khojas
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Āfāqī_Khoja_Holy_War
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xinjiang_under_Qing_rule#Ush_rebellion
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dungan_Revolt_(1862-1877)
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qing_reconquest_of_Xinjiang
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dungan_revolt_(1895-96)
      (The Dungans were not the same people as the Uyghers, but they showcase the struggle of Muslims in this region)
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_East_Turkestan_Republic
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kumul_Rebellion
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charkhlik_revolt
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_rebellion_in_Xinjiang_(1937)
      en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ili_Rebellion
      Being anti-China is not pro-Trump. Fuck Trump. Being anti-China is pro-human.

    • @StoneEdge555
      @StoneEdge555 3 года назад +1

      @@Adsper2000 leaving a reply to steal yo research :)

    • @comradekenobi6908
      @comradekenobi6908 3 года назад

      Great Leap Forward

  • @dianebode6551
    @dianebode6551 2 года назад

    Thank you!!!!!

  • @jie1379
    @jie1379 3 года назад +63

    I would translate xingjiang as new territory/ land. It makes more sense in Chinese

    • @ou6775
      @ou6775 2 года назад

      Wtf

    • @windk3730
      @windk3730 2 года назад

      "New" since Han Dynasty in 200 BC if you know any bit of chinese history

    • @windk3730
      @windk3730 2 года назад +1

      @@pquumm sure thanks for the ted talk. Now you do realize this video is intended to fool a western audience into believing the "genocide" lies fabricated by US state dept?

    • @sinoroman
      @sinoroman 2 года назад

      @@pquumm true, it's old territory for the ethnic han, but new territory for the ethnic manchu (small details can hint at the bigger picture)

    • @figtree_video_archive
      @figtree_video_archive 2 года назад

      @@pquumm Oh no, just don't get kidnapped by Chinese spies ordered by Xinnie the Pooh

  • @rayz6659
    @rayz6659 3 года назад +4

    A small bug, from 09:05 to 09:22 the picture seems to be 天池(Tian Chi) which is located in North East province of Jinlin, you probably need the image of 天山(Tian Shan/Tengri Tagh) that is located in Xinjiang.

    • @refatiabulizi6575
      @refatiabulizi6575 2 года назад

      You are wrong, Xinjiang also has a tian chi

    • @rayz6659
      @rayz6659 2 года назад +1

      @@refatiabulizi6575 You are right, I was wrong. Turns out there are 3 - 4 Tian Chi in China.

  • @user-wg9um2jn7q
    @user-wg9um2jn7q 5 месяцев назад

    Hey! I love the work but I would appreciate it if we could reach out to the sources you have used in your research, thanks!

  • @m.p.baldnessdyslexic88
    @m.p.baldnessdyslexic88 3 года назад +1

    I am sharing this

  • @cantetik7223
    @cantetik7223 3 года назад +6

    Thank you so much for this video love from Turkey!

    • @TheBarser
      @TheBarser 3 года назад +5

      He should totally talk about the Armenian genocide also

    • @weyjosh5213
      @weyjosh5213 3 года назад +1

      Just like China both your nations love genocide

    • @comradekenobi6908
      @comradekenobi6908 3 года назад

      @@weyjosh5213native American Genocide too

  • @masterelitant6065
    @masterelitant6065 3 года назад +7

    thank you for making a video about the suffering of those people

  • @sfnzmi
    @sfnzmi 3 года назад +4

    Thank you for talking about this Hilbert

  • @rekadd
    @rekadd 3 года назад +16

    id like a video on tibet. its interesting how communism is supposed to be anti imperialist but they also really dont like decolonizing places the previous state invaded.

  • @adamabdulkarim_
    @adamabdulkarim_ 3 года назад +58

    killing and slave, being carried out in modern way.
    I’m living in Europe, My father detained in Chinese concentration camp right now, they took my father because he went to abroad and practicing his religion.

    • @yukleung6600
      @yukleung6600 3 года назад +7

      yea right lol

    • @appelanseeofbogalusa5235
      @appelanseeofbogalusa5235 3 года назад

      I’m sorry to hear that :-/

    • @deezeed2817
      @deezeed2817 3 года назад +6

      More lies and slander

    • @comradekenobi6908
      @comradekenobi6908 3 года назад +11

      Bruh what are these replies
      May God help you and your family brother

    • @comradekenobi6908
      @comradekenobi6908 3 года назад

      @Vladilena Milizé you have ottoman songsm playlist and yet you support Uyghur genocide ??????

  • @backattackjack3857
    @backattackjack3857 3 года назад +13

    You said “one million” but wrote “one hundred million”

  • @usfreedomsmith3077
    @usfreedomsmith3077 3 года назад +2

    Dude your amazing for this you should go a step more and keep news of this alive and in the algorithm

  • @christineanderson5029
    @christineanderson5029 2 года назад +1

    Thank you

  • @superfish0012
    @superfish0012 3 года назад +64

    Bad title IMO, Hilbert. They’re not vanishing, they’re *actively being vanished*.

    • @jimmywest8684
      @jimmywest8684 3 года назад +1

      Let's say you're right. What would you do as a head of state?

    • @lobstered_blue-lobster
      @lobstered_blue-lobster 3 года назад +12

      @@jimmywest8684 If you ask me, I wouldn't oppress them I would treat them like citizens and respect their rights as humans and wouldn't interfere with their culture.

    • @jimmywest8684
      @jimmywest8684 3 года назад +2

      @@lobstered_blue-lobster but what if their instance for independence threatens an initiative that your country's economy rests on?

    • @bobpobcf9723
      @bobpobcf9723 3 года назад +9

      @@jimmywest8684 What would I do. put a crap ton of tariffs on China. Encourage a crap ton of other countries to follow your example You know like a certain president. I would ban chinese nationals from going to school in US Colleges. College students used as spies were caught stealing intellectual property and information in Ivy league schools. I would push for US based companies to move there factories to places where we know they give a crap about the environment and treating its workers right. If all the European countries keep sucking up to China I would stop paying for NATO because we pay for everyone and the level of appeasement is enough to make Neville Chamberlain blush
      I would also not have a chinese spy as my personal driver or not sleep with a chinese spy like certain US politicians. I would not say “I wont condemn whats going on to the Uyghur’s and HongKong cause the have different cultural norms” like a certain president

    • @lobstered_blue-lobster
      @lobstered_blue-lobster 3 года назад +2

      @@jimmywest8684 wow that is a really good question that is unfortunately not easy to answer...my decision has to be moral tho so in this case the good thing to do is to convince them to compromise and stay maybe camapigns for why a "united world is better than a divided one" it is gonna be a hard time convincing everyone and will definitely costly but hey if it is beneficial and my country and her people are stablized with this union than it is worthwhile.

  • @turnmeondeadman4221
    @turnmeondeadman4221 3 года назад +34

    Lebron James and John chena disliked this

    • @Premta_
      @Premta_ 11 месяцев назад

      Bro how tf do you know

  • @isaacsantana6560
    @isaacsantana6560 2 года назад

    Nice video

  • @inhumanhyena
    @inhumanhyena Год назад

    Appreciate the vid. Certainly an interesting topic. I'm curious to what extent they are repressing them religiously. I've heard the Hui people are practicing Islam comfortably.

  • @ek5273
    @ek5273 3 года назад +13

    History with Hilbert didn't kill himself

  • @marcrubin8844
    @marcrubin8844 3 года назад +11

    Thanks for this video..How sad but true, the world is seeing people yet again in concentration camps..why is it that history keeps repeating itself..😭😭

  • @abedjarjanazy1178
    @abedjarjanazy1178 3 года назад +1

    Great work Hilbert :) I salute you

  • @notsogaychansei1344
    @notsogaychansei1344 3 года назад

    fascinating!

  • @joshll2007
    @joshll2007 3 года назад +34

    I appreciate the fact that you covered the history of terrorist attacks in xinjiang a detail that always gets glossed over in western news reports on the subject......

    • @oscarosullivan4513
      @oscarosullivan4513 3 года назад +1

      I agree measures like that are over reactions across the world

    • @VMohdude-
      @VMohdude- 3 года назад +8

      Justified terrorism if you ask me

    • @respawnentertainment2446
      @respawnentertainment2446 3 года назад +6

      @@VMohdude- Your comment has been screenshotted and sent to the FBI's anonymous tipline This thread has been reported to the FBI for intention to incite terrorism.
      Accounts remaining will be traced through their corresponding IP address. Warning: You can and will be prosecuted if your account remains in this thread after the 24 hour period. For more information visit: www.FBI.gov Or call the FBI Thank you for your time and cooperation.

    • @oscarosullivan4513
      @oscarosullivan4513 3 года назад +1

      The Chinese are like the London government during the Troubles the best recruiter for such groups

    • @ParagonCS
      @ParagonCS 3 года назад +1

      @@respawnentertainment2446 ruclips.net/video/4wX2xBOuzRg/видео.html

  • @yin6287
    @yin6287 3 года назад +6

    *looks at the title and thumbnail*
    Me: "yep its going to be chaos."

  • @samsimmons6023
    @samsimmons6023 3 года назад

    Good job

  • @emmanuelflores1557
    @emmanuelflores1557 3 года назад +19

    Please also do Tibet!! 🙂

  • @bennruda11
    @bennruda11 3 года назад +14

    Yeah, a million or so is 6 digits after the 7th number, not 10 digits

  • @isaacsantana6560
    @isaacsantana6560 2 года назад +2

    Nice

  • @mysteriousdude280
    @mysteriousdude280 3 года назад +1

    And you'll hear people saying if they were in Nazi Germany, they'll be against the Nazis. While right now, they're trying their best to ignore or overlook this predicament

  • @yasinjamal7517
    @yasinjamal7517 Год назад +3

    free our brothers, free uighur muslims

  • @bensmith6987
    @bensmith6987 2 года назад +7

    Quite elaborative and convicting explanations. What is ironic is all Islamic countries betrayed Uighurs because no economic interest in protecting Uighurs. Uighurs are kind, honest and friendly people; they have done no harm to any other countries. Hope world strives to save them.

    • @howardbealethemadprophetof3361
      @howardbealethemadprophetof3361 2 года назад

      Yeah, no doubts on it. But they profess that "faith" and that's a problem.

    • @kky-jd3xj
      @kky-jd3xj Год назад

      Well, there are multiple Uyghur terrorist groups that have killed hundreds, and that's part of the reason why the conflict is happening. But I guess it's justified, and the majority of Uyghur's don't participate in the violence.

  • @N330AA
    @N330AA 3 года назад +1

    Good vid, but did you mean 5th columnists and not 3rd columnists?

  • @davidchunkyonion
    @davidchunkyonion Год назад

    Good video but massive typo on the number allegedly in camps.

  • @edwardblair4096
    @edwardblair4096 3 года назад +21

    Your graphic showing the number of people interned says 100 million before changing to 300 million, but your verbal count was 1 and 3 million.

  • @jamescopenhaver720
    @jamescopenhaver720 3 года назад +34

    I hope the Uyghurs can stay strong and keep their culture alive, the west needs to stand up to china far more

    • @jimmywest8684
      @jimmywest8684 3 года назад +10

      The West is economically beholden to China. Do you really think a bunch of Karens and Kens will want to trade everything in their house just so a Muslim group they have no connection gains autonomy on the other side of the world?

    • @samuelademeso9041
      @samuelademeso9041 3 года назад +10

      Oh I wish china would stand up for the native Americans, Australian aboriginal, qubecers and the Catalinans against the so called land of the free that have done far more damage to them.
      At least for the ughers they not an endangered species unlike the ones I mentioned, and their culture is actually being encouraged and preserved by the CCP
      I can ffing for the natives American in America an Canada or the Australian aboriginals

    • @RebelHound
      @RebelHound 3 года назад +5

      all we gotta do is stop buying from Chinese megacorps. localise production again. but since it’s not convenient it just doesn’t happen

    • @jimmywest8684
      @jimmywest8684 3 года назад +1

      @@RebelHound it’s not inconvenient. It’s impossible. The west doesn’t have the manufacturing know how to make cheap modern consumer goods and no one in the west is willing to assemble laptops every day for $1/hour.
      On top of that, how many Chinese mega corporations can you actually name? China doesn’t sell itself straight to the consumer, it sells itself to any American company that doesn’t want to go bankrupt.

    • @LarryWater
      @LarryWater 3 года назад +10

      The US is only interest in Muslim if they have oil.

  • @constantineceasar
    @constantineceasar 3 года назад +2

    RUclips actually monitized this? Good for youtube!

  • @chrisjansson4540
    @chrisjansson4540 3 года назад

    Thanks

  • @inuken9561
    @inuken9561 2 года назад +3

    How did you get the 1 million - 3 million numbers?

  • @ganjafi59
    @ganjafi59 3 года назад +3

    The people who are targeted in Xinjiang are the Uyghurs, Kazakhs, Kyrgiz and the Hui people. People are being put in detention camps for the following reasons.
    being a “Muslim who had a beard”
    saying “God is great” at a funeral
    being able to read the Quran
    performing religious activities without a permit
    working as Muslim clergy
    having Islamic digital content on one’s phone or computer
    performing a religious wedding ceremony
    praying
    performing traditional funeral rites
    giving a sermon
    allowing employees to listen to sermons
    having previously participated in the Hajj
    enrolling one’s child in religious classes
    studying Islam at an Egyptian university
    traveling to or living in predominantly Muslim countries
    having a deceased family member who was a Uyghur religious scholar
    having a family member who performed religious activities and
    posting about Islam on the messaging service WeChat
    The persecution and Sinization of Muslims in Xinjiang is spreading to other parts of China too.
    Here are sources if interested.
    www.cecc.gov/publications/commission-analysis/hui-muslims-and-the-%E2%80%9Cxinjiang-model%E2%80%9D-of-state-suppression-of#_edn2

    • @kiro9291
      @kiro9291 2 года назад

      I'm incredibly disinterested in reading a source that is from the congress of an anti-China country

  • @pedrorexSWG
    @pedrorexSWG 3 года назад +1

    Please do indegenous people next

  • @teovu5557
    @teovu5557 Год назад +2

    The confusing history of the "Uyghurs".
    1.Uyghurs are a Turkic people from Mongolia who migrated to western china in the 8th century ad after being pushed out by the Kirghiz(another turkic group).
    2.They Uyghurs who were strongly east asian looking mixed with the Indo-European natives of the region and formed a new mixed race people with Uyghur Turkic replacing the Indo-European languages.
    3.The Uyghurs loss a series of wars and left western china to Gansu region as the Ganzu Uyghur kingdom and Kocho kingdom. Where they live today as the Yugur people(uyghur people).
    4.The Karluk Turks of the karakhanid khanate moved in and replaced the Uyghurs, and during Communist period the Chinese renamed the Karluks as "Uyghurs" even though the Yugurs are the actual Uyghurs. The Chinese did the same with the Pamiri people(East Iranian group native to China) renaming them as Chinese Tajiks even though they are not Tajiks.

    • @albishani
      @albishani Год назад

      they migrated in 9th not 8th century, and the 'ad' after century isn't needed since of course it's not bc, like correcting comments on youtube 😀

  • @MrFearDubh
    @MrFearDubh 3 года назад +31

    In the video you say that between 1 million and 3 million Uyghurs are in internment camps but you show the numbers 100 million and 300 million. You may want to correct that.

    • @christophergraves6725
      @christophergraves6725 3 года назад +3

      Yes. Also, the narrator confuses 'further' and 'farther.' That's nit-picking but those mistakes are present in the video.

    • @KikogamerJ2
      @KikogamerJ2 2 года назад

      There is 10 million uygurs buddy you are reaching levels of brainwashed previous not belived to be possible

    • @m136dalie
      @m136dalie 2 года назад +1

      @@KikogamerJ2 reading comprehension

  • @oihanlarranegi472
    @oihanlarranegi472 3 года назад +14

    6:33 jesus, that's a horrible map of europe right there

    • @tacomuncher
      @tacomuncher 3 года назад +5

      Holy fuck that's disgusting, why does france have Catalonia in 1939 lol

    • @TheBarser
      @TheBarser 3 года назад

      Damn that is a horrible map lol.

    • @TheBarser
      @TheBarser 3 года назад

      @@tacomuncher as a Danish person I hate how Germany got southern borders like its the 1911 map

    • @tacomuncher
      @tacomuncher 3 года назад

      @@TheBarser yeah and china is literally just an ocean like tf

  • @brandonk.4864
    @brandonk.4864 3 года назад +1

    Great balanced video

  • @bilals8188
    @bilals8188 2 года назад +1

    God bless you

  • @Veriox22
    @Veriox22 3 года назад +35

    The chinese be like: We do a little trolling.

  • @stumccabe
    @stumccabe 3 года назад +27

    Question: how do the Uyghurs pronounce "Uyghur"? I'm used to "Wee - ger"; the Dutch pronunciation sounds wrong to me.
    Good video -.thanks.

    • @MrX-tm8fy
      @MrX-tm8fy 3 года назад +1

      I was wondering the same thing! I guess it's like how hilbert pronounces it because it's the first time I hear it pronounced that way. In french, we would say it more like Wee - Goor

    • @kazakhdoge1822
      @kazakhdoge1822 3 года назад +12

      "Wee-ger" is a bad pronunciation of "Uyghur". OP's pronunciation is a much closer to the original.

    • @MrX-tm8fy
      @MrX-tm8fy 3 года назад +4

      @@kazakhdoge1822 Oooh a Kazakh Doge? Very nice! Much Borat! 😉

    • @honkbonk84
      @honkbonk84 3 года назад

      the dutch "g = ch" sounds super irritating though. i would guess the most accurate in english would bei "ooy-ghoor"? Judging from how Turks pronounce it.

    • @honkbonk84
      @honkbonk84 3 года назад

      @Albert Felsen You obviously had more exposure to people who might know how it´s actually pronounced, but as Turks do not have a dutch g sound, i feel like arabic is as good of a reference for turkic languages as it is for dutch :)