karevik is very good but roy is the real god...the tommy`s voice is very nice but roy has more voice styles..roy could reach higher tones..tommy doesn't risk making loud voices..he's too perfectionist and he gets stuck on it..but is really good too
Es un hecho que aunque Tommy en grabaciones de estudio da la talla, en directo se queda corto. Don't you cry es una cancion llena de sentimiento que bien cantada te pone la piel de gallina, y es capaz de conmoverte hasta la lagrima. Con Karevik la cancion es mas vacia de sentimiento , no te toca el alma del mismo modo. Roy Khan la lloraba mas que cantarla, por eso la hacia tan profunda.. Puede que Karevik fuera la mejor eleccion para Kamelot, no digo que no, pero tuve la suerte de verlos en el 2005, en su gira del Black Halo...cuando Khan cantaba de verdad y no se iba apagando por los escenarios de medio mundo...y sin duda algo se ha perdido en el camino...
Yo creo que más allá del sentimiento, Tommy hace una especie de falsetto en las notas más altas dónde Roy llegaba y daba la estocada "sentimental" que conmueve...Las comparaciones son odiosas, pero KAMELOT salió bien parada con Tommy, no como Nightwish que después de Tarja les costó encontrar a alguien similar...
Great performance by the way. Tommy was awsome! Even if I'm keep getting tired about the setlist. Don't get me wrong: I love those songs but they are always the same since TBH tour (most of it). They should really change. Yeah, I know they have to satisfy most of the people but usually people who are at concerts know 80% of the songs, am I wrong? They have masterpieces they don't play anymore like Memento Mori, Moonlight, PoetryForThePoisoned, Nights of Arabia, Elisabeth, Hunter's Season, Necropolis ( and Prodigal Son. I totally love it)
Simone Bianchi I agree with you, but Memento Mori, Moonlight, Nights of Arabia and elizabeth at least were play sometime ago, but other jewels like Three Ways to Epica, Lost and the Dammed, Human Stain, and Snow still totally missed on live
Sad to hear. I haven’t seen Kamelot live since their tour with Leaves Eyes back in 2009. Sad to hear that Lost and Damned is no longer in the set list! One of my favorite Kamelot songs of all time.
I don’t own any Tommy-era Kamelot records, but I have to say this gives me the opposite feeling. Maybe I need to give the post-Khan records a more honest spin. Tommy maybe can’t sing the classics in the original, higher key, but he still makes them sound good, even a half step down like this.
oh yes i watched and many more i wanted to give tommy a fare go roy has incredible depth and vibrato to his vocals which im sorry to say Tommy is sadly lacking,and as i said before tommy tends to shout rather than sing in the upper range.
While its true Tommy has a rather perfect voice, that always sounds...well...perfect, rarely flat, rarely shaky, rarely anything that isn't super polished, I still don't get the shouting part. Yes, he does that plenty, but he CAN get the quiet, higher range as well. Case in point: He does it here.
As a long term Khan Fan, i can tell, tommy sticked this one, emotions and singing skills are at the top! Kudos Tommy!
Totally agree
thank you tommy karevik you save kamelot.
Flawless falsetto for a live performance. Kudos.
A little sad as I miss my dad, but the end made me smile.
Great song! I miss my dad too. Tommy is the best choice.
Same here, makes me think of my late dad and smile with a tear.
Que voz linda e que melodia maravilhosa, da uma paz ouvi-la❤
Mas a letra é de uma tristeza ímpar 😢
This is so beautiful...brings tears to my eyes. If anyone could pull this off its Tommy...and Also Nicoletta Rosellini. OH and Simone Simmons
It is so beautiful and I love Tommy and the his voice😍😍😍
Wonderful Tommy!
Perfection 🤘🤘🤘🤘👌
Good job, but the emotion and high technique showed by Khan unfortunately is very special and very hard to be reproduced. Anyway, it was a good job.
this is a brilliant song! Tommy is the best
roy khan is best
TOMMY IS THE BEST
karevik is very good but roy is the real god...the tommy`s voice is very nice but roy has more voice styles..roy could reach higher tones..tommy doesn't risk making loud voices..he's too perfectionist and he gets stuck on it..but is really good too
Kamelot is very lucky to have had two of the best singers in all of metal. They are both incredible in different ways.
Es un hecho que aunque Tommy en grabaciones de estudio da la talla, en directo se queda corto.
Don't you cry es una cancion llena de sentimiento que bien cantada te pone la piel de gallina, y es capaz de conmoverte hasta la lagrima.
Con Karevik la cancion es mas vacia de sentimiento , no te toca el alma del mismo modo.
Roy Khan la lloraba mas que cantarla, por eso la hacia tan profunda..
Puede que Karevik fuera la mejor eleccion para Kamelot, no digo que no, pero tuve la suerte de verlos en el 2005, en su gira del Black Halo...cuando Khan cantaba de verdad y no se iba apagando por los escenarios de medio mundo...y sin duda algo se ha perdido en el camino...
Yo creo que más allá del sentimiento, Tommy hace una especie de falsetto en las notas más altas dónde Roy llegaba y daba la estocada "sentimental" que conmueve...Las comparaciones son odiosas, pero KAMELOT salió bien parada con Tommy, no como Nightwish que después de Tarja les costó encontrar a alguien similar...
It's good that they don't touch the "Abandoned"
Woa we totally suck at this song yesterday :'(
Sadly I had no voice left at that point
Lol, yeah. My voice was broken by then. Not the mention yesterday the whole day. :D
Great performance by the way. Tommy was awsome! Even if I'm keep getting tired about the setlist. Don't get me wrong: I love those songs but they are always the same since TBH tour (most of it). They should really change. Yeah, I know they have to satisfy most of the people but usually people who are at concerts know 80% of the songs, am I wrong?
They have masterpieces they don't play anymore like Memento Mori, Moonlight, PoetryForThePoisoned, Nights of Arabia, Elisabeth, Hunter's Season, Necropolis ( and Prodigal Son. I totally love it)
Simone Bianchi
I agree. But I was surprised they played My Confession. And I still agree. Nights of Arabia are missing.
Simone Bianchi I agree with you, but Memento Mori, Moonlight, Nights of Arabia and elizabeth at least were play sometime ago, but other jewels like Three Ways to Epica, Lost and the Dammed, Human Stain, and Snow still totally missed on live
Sad to hear. I haven’t seen Kamelot live since their tour with Leaves Eyes back in 2009. Sad to hear that Lost and Damned is no longer in the set list! One of my favorite Kamelot songs of all time.
He is my new god
Where is Roy? 🤔😐😩
He is singing amazing new songs with Conception! Check them out, all their new stuff is gold
I think khan is better. Just my opinion
khan is better
This song should only be for Khan!!
MuffinJinReturns why Anthem?
I don’t own any Tommy-era Kamelot records, but I have to say this gives me the opposite feeling. Maybe I need to give the post-Khan records a more honest spin. Tommy maybe can’t sing the classics in the original, higher key, but he still makes them sound good, even a half step down like this.
1 song Tommy should avoid
Awful tommy tends to shout when he cant reach the high notes, not his fault his doesn t have the vocal range and the rich tones of roys voice
I'm unsure if you're kidding. Did you even seriously WATCH this or just comment? Cause he gets that quiet, whispery notes pretty much spot on.
oh yes i watched and many more i wanted to give tommy a fare go roy has incredible depth and vibrato to his vocals which im sorry to say Tommy is sadly lacking,and as i said before tommy tends to shout rather than sing in the upper range.
While its true Tommy has a rather perfect voice, that always sounds...well...perfect, rarely flat, rarely shaky, rarely anything that isn't super polished, I still don't get the shouting part. Yes, he does that plenty, but he CAN get the quiet, higher range as well. Case in point: He does it here.
wel we must agree to disagree you have your opinion and i have mine
That's fine and all. But in this case, NOT shouting. Seriously. Listen. not shouting. Not loud. Not screaming. Not shouting o.o
Increíble lo que voy a decir, pero Simone canta mejor esta canción...
😷