Allah brought me here. I always thought that the mainstream islam was different from the quran. Everything was so complicated. It have been asking Allah to help me understand quran better and I ended up here.
Salam Moses, I am am American revert. I read the Quran in English and fell in love with the word of God. I then read Bukari/Muslim and took classes that said my following was wrong. My certainty in Allah existed, but the more I “followed” the more distant I became. Your work is helping me a great deal. Thank you
Salam, I've great sympathy for converts who end up joining yet another religion far from the Quran. Keep reading, keep pondering the Quran. So long you're honest, Allah will give you guidance
Dear brother in Islam, please keep away from any books other than the Qur'an. Do not read the translation of the Qur'an but rather learn Arabic and understand the Qur'an by yourself because on the day of judgement you'll be asked about yourself. Believe in Allah and day of judgement and do good deeds as well as give charity. The rest is just added points if any. Bless you
Brother Mosa, You are doing a lot. You are one and only person in this world who is explaining this way. I have never seen such a person like you. You are really a gem and should be protected by Muslims. May Allah protect you and keep you fit and healthy for us. You cover your topic from all sides and do not leave any question to ask. Thanks brother.
@@AlMosesPhD ... RESPONSE..क्या उन्होंने उन चीज़ों पर विचार नहीं किया जो अल्लाह ने पैदा की हैं? उनकी परछाइयाँ दायीं और बायीं ओर झुकती हैं, अल्लाह को सजदा करती हैं, जबकि वे [अर्थात् वे रचनाएँ] विनम्र हैं। 16/48 And to Allāh prostrates whoever is within the heavens and the earth, willingly or by compulsion, and their shadows [as well] in the mornings and the afternoons. और अल्लाह ही को सज्दा करता है, चाह या न चाह, वह जो आकाशों तथा धरती में है और उनकी प्रछाईयाँ[ भी प्रातः और संध्या1। 13/15 मैंने उसे तथा उसकी जाति को पाया कि सज्दा करते हैं सूर्य को अल्लाह के सिवा और शोभनीय बना दिया है, उनके लिए शैतान ने उनके कर्मों को और उन्हें रोक दिया है सुपथ से, अतः, वे सुपथ पर नहीं आते 27/24 [और] इसलिए वे उस अल्लाह को सजदा नहीं करते, जो आकाशों और धरती के भीतर छिपी बातों को निकालता है और जानता है जो कुछ तुम छिपाते हो और जो कुछ घोषित करते हो - 27/25 JANAAB / NABI AS , NE PRACTICALLY SAJDA ,SALAH , NAMAZ KA TARIQA BATAYA HAI UMAAT KO...{AAP SUNAAH KE MUNKIR HO } हे ईमान वालो! अल्लाह की आज्ञा का अनुपालन करो और रसूल की आज्ञा का अनुपालन करो तथा अपने शासकों की आज्ञापालन करो। फिर यदि किसी बात में तुम आपस में विवाद (विभेद) कर लो, तो उसे अल्लाह और रसूल की ओर फेर दो, यदि तुम अल्लाह तथा अन्तिम दिन (प्रलय) पर ईमान रखते हो। ये तुम्हारे लिए अच्छा[ और इसका परिणाम अच्छा है 4/59 ..
Salamun. Check marvelous quran. Learn from the likes of moses. Get 2nd opinion, 3rd opinion and make up ur final decision. We all be judged by our intellect.
Subhaan Allah. Brother Moses, Brilliant to see true scholars who are giving us TRUE QURANIC ISLAM. Throughout history, even in the 19th and 20th century there have been scholars who have tried to bring us back to the Quran. Even the great Poet Allama Iqbal knew that the prayer of the Muslims was not bringing about change! We can pray all day long, but, as the Quran states: Allah does not change the condition of a people, until, they, themselves change. Another veese: Man gets nothing, but what he strives gard for. In other words, no amount of praying will get you what you want!.But the true adoption of Aqeemu salat can change the whole planet!!
@@AlMosesPhD Indeed Another great Allama, who was consulted by Qaid e Azam Jinnah was Allama Pervez. He was asked by Jinnah to formulate the basis for the Government for the newly formed Pakistan. Allama G. Pervez came in for a lot of backlash from the mullahs! Their backwards mentality clashed with the " Quranic" Allama Pervez. He was called a kafir by the mullahs. In my humble opinion he was one of the great scholars of the 20th century.
You are courageous but of course backed up with the relevant quranic logical reasoning. May Allah continue to guide us. PS. It shall be awesome if yours is synergised with Dr Hany Achtan of the Marvellous Quran which I have been enamoured two years since. Salamualaikum
Salamun Alaikum, your brother in learning Quran from Indonesia. I love the way you presented Quranic material. I did the same way when learn The Quran. Your method of providing: propositions, etc really enriches me. Thank you
Salamun ruan. Ada 1 yt channel paling keren (maaf ya en musa) marvelous quran oleh dr hani atchan. Demi Allah, dia benar2 jujur dgn alquran. Tuan nilaikan sendiri. Sukran.
Musa abd wall.. Faqamu meaning not literally repair.. But he made it standing without falling.. So standing.. Whatever he did restore but standing position..
Great initiative Brother! If you can announce the day for us to join please. Short and informative video with discussion at the end will be better opportunity to ask further questions to clear up our understanding. May Allah reward you for your hard work Brother.
Salaam brother Moses Again very well done, I do like this format. As a suggestion maybe a video on difference between Deen Islam vs mazhab (religion's) to add to the salat series? Thanks
More och more students of the Qur'an discover God given "self-declaritive" quality of the Kitab. This has been the forgotten tool. Thanks to you. May God increase your knowledge. I hope that you can add more effort to translate more of your videos in english.
Salaam dear brother im new to youre videos but in 20 years of reversion i alweyes had a big problem with ahadith and never accepted them. i apreciate youre efforts and many things you said are my interpretation also, other topics and details i will need to check. As a portuguese (old andalus) citizen i would sugest you keep doing youre videos in english , even knowing that english is a "limited vocabulary language" , but in that case you will reach more brothers and sisters.. or simply make it in urdu and add subtitles. If you need help to translate to portuguese or spanish i can help you. May allah reward you with the best of this and the best in next life.
Salamun alaik almousesji , I got your reply that you don't know about "Ahmedisa rasoolallah" So I suggest you to go to youtube channel "NABA 7" to have all information revealed by creator through Ahmedisa rasoolallah, before it's too late and you would be blamed to be ignorant, With best wishes from a well wisher brother.
Sorry, I had to listen at a later time. A side note. In the beginning you said not to add anything to the Quran, I agree with you, the majority add Amin at the end of Fatiha,
Salam, here you are saying that in 62/9, Allah is saying on the day of gathering and not ‘day of Juma’ but the way it is written this word is actually seems ‘ day of Juma’ because if it is gathering or collecting then see 75/9 which is actually saying on combining or gathering or making together sun and the moon, AS Ansari says it is Day of Juma, please explain further.
Wonderful job ✔️ this is continuing the series , hope we see you continuing the subject. One thing is your presentation was different, not as interactive as previous work. Some sort of lacking coherence. These are just friendly comments! Salamun Alykum
@@AlMosesPhD salamun alykum brother. Sorry for replying you late. Actually voice was breaking. Please check your mic and jacks. May be need some dusting. Otherthan that no issue at all. Waiting to hear this weeks topic !!!
Salaam. I don't understand the two way connections you are talking about. I always understood establish salat and zakat as meaning to establish salat ( the divine order and Zakat the economic order of welfar) when it's established vices and corruption will be eradicated. Am I wrong? Every prophet came to establish Allah's system of Islam..
Salamunalaikum Brother Moses, I appreciate you sharing your in depth findings in English. May Allah reward you for your efforts. Perhaps I have missed your explanation in the 'zikr' as Allah's System (refer to time 28:40). In the books of translation, 'zikr' = the remembrance of Allah. Another translation by Dr Hany Atchan, 'zikr' = the stories in the Quran. Can you guide me on the meaning of 'zikr' based on your research. Thank you.
SA, I'll cover zikr properly one day. Yes, it can be the stories of the Quran as well but their overall purpose is still rememberance / prominence of Allah and His system.
Deen means System of Allah per your lecture. if you insert ' System of Allah in the second part of the Aya 10:105, translation becomes 'never be of those who add/remove to Allah's System'. My question is ' are we capable of adding/removing/changing Allah's System'? If not then, why Allah say this?
Brother, during your interview with Edip yeskiel, why you didn't interrupt and correct him when he stated,salah consists of standing, rukuh, sujood and so on according to Qur'an?
sometimes people conflate `salaah` and `ibadaah` how would you deconstruct this? in 27:20 you've explained it in urdu in the past but i don't speak it.
I'm not quite sure what you mean by 'two-way communication'. Do you mean dialogue? Relationships? Fellowship? I'm not clear on what communication we need to uphold or maintain.
Salam, great lecture, just one question, in my understanding deen is Allah's system and zikr is the remembrance of Him, please explain how and why did you translate zikr as system. May Allah reward you for your work.
Answer to your question on verse 20:14 as I earlier mentioned, the Jews pray the SAME ritual way. Check the Jewish foremost book on prayer by Haslim Doyen. Or google it to see many such videos of Jews praying just as Muslims do.
We are 'not' to follow any so-called books of God written by men. Nothing but the Quran. Same goes for the 'culture' or 'rites' of any culture. Either way, we're all free to do / believe what we want brother
@@AlMosesPhD I ONLY follow the Quran as guide. I sift through Shakespeare, hadith, Bible and any other book on a find-some-good, reject falsehood basis. That said, we have one sunnah. The sunnah of Allah, which is the same sunnah our predecessors were all given as Quran clearly says (See Qur’an 40:85, Qur’an 33:38, Quran 41:43, Quran 33:62, and Quran 17:77) SO as expected you can find all the rituals Mohammed (p) was given in the practice of serious orthodox Jews and written about in the Bible, Torah and lost gospels. You only have to look to see it. Or google "Do orhtodox jews bow and prostrate like Muslims". Thanks.
There is nothing like salaat jumuah in the Quran . But Quran mentioned salaat fajr, salaat Wustah and salaat ishai...Does it mean we should reconnect with Allah system three times in a day ?
@@knowledgeistreasure yes, that's what I feared would happen. Extra work on a professional video which slows down the production vs a few audio issues in live
I have a question. If Namaaz doesn’t exist so where did this very very very strong concept came from ???? . If someone never prays but no one can deny this fact .. in khana Kaba 5 times namaaz is prayed, if we see whole world Namaaz is Always the biggest and powerful priority.. so why didn’t Arabic people understood this?? Or we may be not understanding this properly?? Or there maybe some hidden signal available regarding namaz? If you can record this answer with very detail first in In Urdu and English both please.. thanks
I have a thousand questions for you. It's unfortunate that I can't see you face to face and that typing questions is the only way. I do understand where you are coming from but as always either you're complicating the simple or you don't understand these concepts enough to give simple and concise answers to simple questions. What is salat and zakat...
Firstly, good job with the presentation. Secondly, I find myself concurring with almost everything you presented here. Thirdly, I have come to the realization that the true meaning of "Aqeemo" is in the word itself. I am sure you and almost everybody with a thinking mind are aware that the same 3 root letters "Qaf-Waw-Miim" is also for the English equivalent "People" or the Arabic "qawm!" Now, it does not matter if you want to use "stand/establish/restore/repair" but the main thing is that is all about "standing/establishing/restoring/repairing" to the people/system. For example, "repairing the wall that is about to collapse" is using your knowledge to make the wall that you are repairing to unobtrusively fit the existing wall. So, "aqeemo al-salat" is simply reciting the Quran, and keeping it pure and untainted, to the people! Thus, ensuring peace, prosperity and security to the people who believe in the Word/Command of God, i.e. the Quran. Easy peasy lemon squeezy! Verily, this Quran is made easy for you. salam.
Dear Brother Moses , what is the history of undertaking the Salah in the way fiqh have been doing it , are those who are imam and from Arab completely misleading the ummah, what do we do to connect with Allah, did resul not pray this way, what is then god asking us when he says they remember their lord in the hour leaving the comfort of their bed
Apni marzi ki translation kr k logon ko gumrah na jrain.jb Quran ma open ahkanat hain .phir ghuma phira kr q logon ko ghalat side pr le kr ja rahe hain.
Salamun brother. I hear that musa u stresses as nabi whereas isa u stresses as rasul. May u share ur advanced understanding ofnabi and rasul. I prefer the understanding that rasul is a delivery person of divine messege/messeges whereas nabi is an interpreter of that messege/messeges. See surah maryam whereby zakaria said to her 'i am a rasul to u'. See surah yusuf whereby yusuf ex prison inmate say he will be a rasul to bring yusuf messege to the king. Sukran brother. May Allah guides us as we have strived to be guided.
@@AlMosesPhD insyaAllah. I am a non arab. I understand the quran thru govt endorsed translation. I hv doubted hadith a very long time ago. I found dr hani, brother joseph, said mirza and the likes. Somehow their understanding differ. For the time being i prefer dr hani understanding. I am looking forward to hearing from u. Sukran. We are all seeking knowledge from our sustainer. We will be judged according to our intellect. I will not hold u responsible for ur words. May Allah guides us for we hv strived to be guided.
@@tiaratiarasam1886 that's the right approach. We're all humans and thus will always have differrence of understanding. Best we can do is be honest to ourselves
What is your proof/evidence to show that the Prophet, his companions and his later followers did not follow the so called "ritual prayer" 5 times a day?
Brother Moses, I didn't mean to cause any offense. But just to say that since we all regard our Rasul (PBUH) to be the principal source of our guidance, alongside the holy Book, your interpretation of Salat/namaz must hold against the practice he and his companions and followers adopted. My question/comment had nothing to do with history as such, but to be educated about any evidence in his and his companions'/followers' practice of Salat, whether 'ritualistic' or otherwise. I maintain an open mind on the issue, following your commentary/interpretation.
@@Maazi12345 I understand your position, thanks for clarifying. Rasul Muhammad wasn't/isn't the source of guidance--it was/is/will be Allah and His risala through the rasul. Re the historic / cultural practice of namaz we see, I'd like to cover it off in the last video of the series
@@WaqasAfzali-e8p In total there are around 67 verses in the Quran about Salat. The Quran also says, “Establish regular prayer: for prayer restrains from shameful and unjust deeds, and remembrance of Allah is the greatest (thing in life).”
@@baqirhemraj7639 nope. "Salat" doesn't mean prayer. "Establish prayer" doesn't actually mean anything. You don't establish prayer. You perform it. Salat is adherence and connection between entities. According to the Quran, birds do salat as well.
@@baqirhemraj7639 nope. "Salat" doesn't mean prayer. "Establish prayer" doesn't actually mean anything. You don't establish prayer. You perform it. Salat is adherence and connection between entities. According to the Quran, birds do salat as well.
Brother i respect your efforts 'but if you read 4-102 ALLAH is telling the prophet during times of war to be cautious of the enemy and this ayah clearly states the prophet and believers are instructed to perform a ritual SALAT. Also ALLAH says in 4-103 'that SALAT is prescribed on the believers on specified times 'and also ALLAH says in 4=101 that if your traveling through the land 'then shorten your SALAT. Now 'i ask you brother 'how can you shorten 'following closely or connecting 'brother i used to also believe there was no ritual SALAT 'but after further study 'i have come to know that there is a ritual aspect in QURAN. The word SALLU can mean contact, connect. follow closely 'but when ALLAH says AQEEMOO SALAT 'ALLAH is referring to a ritual SALAT. The SALAT has two aspects in QURAN the physical SALAT and phycological SALAT 'standing position for the phycological side is 'one monotheism and the physical position is when you stand to perform a ritual SALAT . The bowing position phycological is being humble to the verses of ALLAH and not disputing with verses of ALLAH and the physical side when you bow to perform SALAT. The phycological prostration is accepting and implementing and believing the QURAN 'and physical is when your in your Sujjoood. Brother there are two sides to follow the QURAN physically and phytologically 'you are only following the phycological SALAT 'and leaving out the physical part. When the word SALLU is used in QURAN 'you have to understand the context and then use the root meaning of the word to fit in with the context. The word following closely and connect or contact 'must be applied in most verses 'but when ALLAH says establish SALAT 'you have to perform the ritual SALAT 'and the format we have to get for the SALAT is from the standing place of ABRAHIM in surah 2-125 'which is located in MECCAH. But when performing SALAT 'i can grantee you all imams around the world when leading the SALAT 'will only recite the verses of ALLAH 'never HADITH. But when sitting down bowing 'you the believer will only recite the QURAN silently and complete your SALAT. The difference between the believers and the MUSHRICKS 'is simply 'we the believers will recite the QURAN when bowing sitting in SALAT and the MUSHRICKS will start to praise ABRAHIM and MUHAMAD peace be to both. Brother 'do further study and research the QURAN and i promise you god willing 'you will understand. Peace be with you.
Brother, from the beginning of the series, I have mentioned that I will cover the so called 'war' situation verse and the so-called 'shortening' of it. There is no war or a strange ritual salat being carried out a prescribed times there. In the upcoming videos, both of these ayat will be covered inshallah.
All the examples you gave, the wall, the deen, the word can also be Establish, as with Establish your self to the upright system. Which is what we say of salat, "establish salat". DO you have any other evidence?
I don't see how aqeem as salat translated as establish the salat (ritual prayers) doesn't serve the purpose of connection between God and people as well as between people and other people. It in fact does that, and I believe you are undermining the importance of ritual prayer in almost any religion as well as the importance of congregating in the place (Masjid) for that purpose. It is quite possible that Salah in the way you translate it to connect entities does refer to the prayers also. How would you reconcile this, "establish the salah at the declining of the sun, and into the night and the reading of the Fajr...." or "do not let them enter your place of undress in set times..... After salat Al eshaa..." or "when the call to Salah is made on the day of jumuah, then hasten to the rememberable of Allah" or "guard the salawaat and especially the middle Salah..." I appreciate the dimensions of meaning you infer because after all interpretations have always been numerous, but when you have managed to cancel all the normative religious practices of Muslims what do you suggest replacing it with? So Christians and Jews have places of worship "houses in which God is remembered" but Muslims should make use of factories and libraries to establish the law of God, and have no formal known means of prayer despite that they in fact do? What a fantastic innovation and effort it must've been to align all sects who hated and fought wars against each other on the simple matter of Salah (prayers)? I think your ideas are interesting but seems inconsistent. You'd have to take every instance of every reference and interpret the entire Quran with those inferred meanings. Like if Rijal meant only "Peoole in authority" you'd have to do a deep dive on the vast discussions related to marriage in the Quran. For example "then wed women of your choice two, three or four..." If Nisaa here were just people without authority then a person in authority even a woman can wed (Nikah/ sleep with) two three or four or any number of men. You seem to have a very gender neutral approach. How can we even talk about the law of God if everything is seemingly metaphorical? What would be the law of God? Wash your face and your hands to your elbows and wipe your head and feet to your ankles is metaphorical and does not actually refer to a ritual purification according to you. So we'll have very little tangible anything if we follow along that trajectory.
Brother, pls don't address people other than muslims as "Kafir" countries or "Kafir people," but let's address all people as brothers and sisters in humanity. I learnt from Kerala Quran-only following muslims and the term "Kafir" consists of two words "Kafi" plus "Ra" which means any person who says whatever he is believing now and following is enough (Kafi) for him and he does not want to enrich his knowledge with truth and he is content with his views which is "Ra" or "Ru'ya."
I always tell people about the fact that Jews and Nazareancs (Christians) etc, we all were given the same Shariah and Sunnah, as in verse 42:13. And this goes against your point. Rather we see the same establishment of salah in Judaism and the Bible, with Orthodox Jews standing, bowing and prostrating and the same of Jesus and in the New Testament.
We are 'not' to follow any so-called books of God written by men. Nothing but the Quran. Same goes for the 'culture' or 'rites' of any culture. Either way, we're all free to do / believe what we want brother
@@AlMosesPhD When I said Sunnah, I did not refer to/say "hadith", I said Sunnah. The one Sunnah of Allah ta'ala and of our predecessors. See Qur’an 40:85, Qur’an 33:38, Quran 41:43, Quran 33:62, and Quran 17:77. It's the same way Musa and Isa lived, prayed, etc. Standing, bowing, prostrating as is seen in the Bible and with Orthodox Jews
@@dr.perrybrimahstheesoteric741 brother I don't comment debate. Watch the series from the beginning, and the 'sunnah' argument in particular is covered in the last video of the series. Once more, as my last word, we do NOT follow the Jews or Maoris or Aboriginals or Native Americans.
@@AlMosesPhD I never said we follow them. You asked: why don't we see the same prayer ritual among them before the Quran. I provided that we actually do. They pray the same way-the serious of them and have the same salat ritual in their books. You can decide what to do with that reality.
Brother, may ' know why there are diverse interpretations of Quranic terms such as Salah, wudhu, zakat, hajj, Ramadan, fasting and so on.. among the Quranists or those who uphold Qur'an only... According to you, Salah means two way connection, but there are others who say, i). it is 'duty', ii) it is twice a day iii)thrice a day and so on. Zakath is i). Sexual purity ii) Spiritual purity iii) charity.. Why there is no consensus among Quranists.. Wouldn't it be better you debate it among yourself and arrive at a consensus first, before teaching the lay majority, confusing them, misleading them to (your) preferred narrative?
क्या उन्होंने उन चीज़ों पर विचार नहीं किया जो अल्लाह ने पैदा की हैं? उनकी परछाइयाँ दायीं और बायीं ओर झुकती हैं, अल्लाह को सजदा करती हैं, जबकि वे [अर्थात् वे रचनाएँ] विनम्र हैं। 16/48 And to Allāh prostrates whoever is within the heavens and the earth, willingly or by compulsion, and their shadows [as well] in the mornings and the afternoons. और अल्लाह ही को सज्दा करता है, चाह या न चाह, वह जो आकाशों तथा धरती में है और उनकी प्रछाईयाँ[ भी प्रातः और संध्या1। 13/15 मैंने उसे तथा उसकी जाति को पाया कि सज्दा करते हैं सूर्य को अल्लाह के सिवा और शोभनीय बना दिया है, उनके लिए शैतान ने उनके कर्मों को और उन्हें रोक दिया है सुपथ से, अतः, वे सुपथ पर नहीं आते 27/24 [और] इसलिए वे उस अल्लाह को सजदा नहीं करते, जो आकाशों और धरती के भीतर छिपी बातों को निकालता है और जानता है जो कुछ तुम छिपाते हो और जो कुछ घोषित करते हो - 27/25 JANAAB / NABI AS , NE PRACTICALLY SAJDA ,SALAH , NAMAZ KA TARIQA BATAYA HAI UMAAT KO...{AAP SUNAAH KE MUNKIR HO } हे ईमान वालो! अल्लाह की आज्ञा का अनुपालन करो और रसूल की आज्ञा का अनुपालन करो तथा अपने शासकों की आज्ञापालन करो। फिर यदि किसी बात में तुम आपस में विवाद (विभेद) कर लो, तो उसे अल्लाह और रसूल की ओर फेर दो, यदि तुम अल्लाह तथा अन्तिम दिन (प्रलय) पर ईमान रखते हो। ये तुम्हारे लिए अच्छा[ और इसका परिणाम अच्छा है 4/59 ..
Brother, did you know that you + the scholars of your sect are munkire hadith too? See the vid 'Kya mein Quranist hoon? Munkare hadith?' if you wish to learn
Aqeemu Salat...... ESTABLISH THE DIVINE SYSTEM OF LIFE, AS PRESCRIBED IN THE QURAN SO AS TO IMPROVE YOURSELVES AND SOCIETY. Salat had nothing to do with praying, as you correctly state, brother Moses. Salat means to follow as closely as possible, all that is given to us in the Quran, 24/7
Brother, this is from Bangladesh, please continue the awesome work.. And in English please.. I can't make out some Urdu words but I watch anyway... gather whatever I can. Please share your email on yr channel so we can connect. Salamun aleikum.
Allah brought me here. I always thought that the mainstream islam was different from the quran. Everything was so complicated. It have been asking Allah to help me understand quran better and I ended up here.
Salam Moses, I am am American revert. I read the Quran in English and fell in love with the word of God. I then read Bukari/Muslim and took classes that said my following was wrong. My certainty in Allah existed, but the more I “followed” the more distant I became. Your work is helping me a great deal. Thank you
Salam, I've great sympathy for converts who end up joining yet another religion far from the Quran.
Keep reading, keep pondering the Quran. So long you're honest, Allah will give you guidance
Dear brother in Islam, please keep away from any books other than the Qur'an. Do not read the translation of the Qur'an but rather learn Arabic and understand the Qur'an by yourself because on the day of judgement you'll be asked about yourself.
Believe in Allah and day of judgement and do good deeds as well as give charity. The rest is just added points if any. Bless you
Salamun to you sis.
I write to bring ur attn to yt channel marvelous quran by dr hani atchan.
U could learn from him and bro musa.
Sukran.
@@tiaratiarasam1886
Dr hany is kafir. He misleads with the way he translates the Quran words.
Are you promoting his kufr?
youtube.com/@MarvelousQuran?si=CG2v8bttKWtrgHzG
Brother Mosa, You are doing a lot. You are one and only person in this world who is explaining this way. I have never seen such a person like you. You are really a gem and should be protected by Muslims. May Allah protect you and keep you fit and healthy for us. You cover your topic from all sides and do not leave any question to ask. Thanks brother.
Thanks for the well wishes. There are others way more knowledgable than me, doing a much better job.
Let's all keep pondering over the Quran.
@@AlMosesPhD ... RESPONSE..क्या उन्होंने उन चीज़ों पर विचार नहीं किया जो अल्लाह ने पैदा की हैं? उनकी परछाइयाँ दायीं और बायीं ओर झुकती हैं, अल्लाह को सजदा करती हैं, जबकि वे [अर्थात् वे रचनाएँ] विनम्र हैं। 16/48
And to Allāh prostrates whoever is within the heavens and the earth, willingly or by compulsion, and their shadows [as well] in the mornings and the afternoons.
और अल्लाह ही को सज्दा करता है, चाह या न चाह, वह जो आकाशों तथा धरती में है और उनकी प्रछाईयाँ[ भी प्रातः और संध्या1। 13/15
मैंने उसे तथा उसकी जाति को पाया कि सज्दा करते हैं सूर्य को अल्लाह के सिवा और शोभनीय बना दिया है, उनके लिए शैतान ने उनके कर्मों को और उन्हें रोक दिया है सुपथ से, अतः, वे सुपथ पर नहीं आते 27/24
[और] इसलिए वे उस अल्लाह को सजदा नहीं करते, जो आकाशों और धरती के भीतर छिपी बातों को निकालता है और जानता है जो कुछ तुम छिपाते हो और जो कुछ घोषित करते हो - 27/25
JANAAB / NABI AS , NE PRACTICALLY SAJDA ,SALAH , NAMAZ KA TARIQA BATAYA HAI UMAAT KO...{AAP SUNAAH KE MUNKIR HO }
हे ईमान वालो! अल्लाह की आज्ञा का अनुपालन करो और रसूल की आज्ञा का अनुपालन करो तथा अपने शासकों की आज्ञापालन करो। फिर यदि किसी बात में तुम आपस में विवाद (विभेद) कर लो, तो उसे अल्लाह और रसूल की ओर फेर दो, यदि तुम अल्लाह तथा अन्तिम दिन (प्रलय) पर ईमान रखते हो। ये तुम्हारे लिए अच्छा[ और इसका परिणाम अच्छा है 4/59 ..
Salamun. Check marvelous quran. Learn from the likes of moses. Get 2nd opinion, 3rd opinion and make up ur final decision. We all be judged by our intellect.
No he's not, he's just one
@@tiaratiarasam1886 marvelous quran sounds like a sufi tafseer
Subhaan Allah.
Brother Moses, Brilliant to see true scholars who are giving us TRUE QURANIC ISLAM.
Throughout history, even in the 19th and 20th century there have been scholars who have tried to bring us back to the Quran.
Even the great Poet Allama Iqbal knew that the prayer of the Muslims was not bringing about change!
We can pray all day long, but, as the Quran states:
Allah does not change the condition of a people, until, they, themselves change.
Another veese:
Man gets nothing, but what he strives gard for.
In other words, no amount of praying will get you what you want!.But the true adoption of Aqeemu salat can change the whole planet!!
Iqbal, if he could speak today, would have some very interesting insights to share
@@AlMosesPhD
Indeed
Another great Allama, who was consulted by Qaid e Azam Jinnah was Allama Pervez. He was asked by Jinnah to formulate the basis for the Government for the newly formed Pakistan. Allama G. Pervez came in for a lot of backlash from the mullahs! Their backwards mentality clashed with the " Quranic" Allama Pervez. He was called a kafir by the mullahs. In my humble opinion he was one of the great scholars of the 20th century.
Please can you do it video for us, i mean like how you do your salat, thank you.
Thnk you brother
Allahu akbar.
Slamun alaikum dear brother mashaallah
Alhamdulillah. Beautiful, wonderful. Holding these in heart been years.
Alhamdulillah
You are courageous but of course backed up with the relevant quranic logical reasoning. May Allah continue to guide us. PS. It shall be awesome if yours is synergised with Dr Hany Achtan of the Marvellous Quran which I have been enamoured two years since. Salamualaikum
Luv your english vids more pls :)
inshallah
Thank you. There is problem with the sound (cracks). I am waiting for all the coming videos in English.
Salamun Alaikum, your brother in learning Quran from Indonesia.
I love the way you presented Quranic material.
I did the same way when learn The Quran.
Your method of providing: propositions, etc really enriches me.
Thank you
SA, the Quran unites us across cultures and countries :)
Salamun ruan.
Ada 1 yt channel paling keren (maaf ya en musa) marvelous quran oleh dr hani atchan.
Demi Allah, dia benar2 jujur dgn alquran. Tuan nilaikan sendiri. Sukran.
@@tiaratiarasam1886 Ya, saya juga ikuti kurang lebih sekitar 2 tahunan
@@yudiarianto498 alhamdulillah. Cohort dr hani, kamu.
Thank you for your efforts! I am benefiting from it a great deal. Please continue the English lessons.
Thank you!
Inshallah, the English videos will keep on coming
Masha Allah
Pls maintain this way, its easy to understand & follow. Keep the good work. Its v enlightening.
Inshallah
Musa abd wall.. Faqamu meaning not literally repair.. But he made it standing without falling.. So standing.. Whatever he did restore but standing position..
Salamun Alykum, can you please do a video regarding the verses of Kaaba
Great initiative Brother! If you can announce the day for us to join please. Short and informative video with discussion at the end will be better opportunity to ask further questions to clear up our understanding.
May Allah reward you for your hard work Brother.
We have dedicated sessions for joining. There will be one coming up soon inshallah.
Thanks for the feedback
Good work
Salaam brother Moses
Again very well done, I do like this format.
As a suggestion maybe a video on difference between Deen Islam vs mazhab (religion's) to add to the salat series?
Thanks
Salam, we've covered this elsewhere in the urdu videos if you understand it.
Sa, Mosa bhai itne dino baad aye wo bhi inglish me hamare bare me bhi socho bhai bahut lamba intzar ho gya
SA, Urdu mein bhi aayay gi inshallah
More och more students of the Qur'an discover God given "self-declaritive" quality of the Kitab. This has been the forgotten tool. Thanks to you. May God increase your knowledge. I hope that you can add more effort to translate more of your videos in english.
Inshallah, I'll be doing more videos in English as time goes
Salaam dear brother im new to youre videos but in 20 years of reversion i alweyes had a big problem with ahadith and never accepted them. i apreciate youre efforts and many things you said are my interpretation also, other topics and details i will need to check.
As a portuguese (old andalus) citizen i would sugest you keep doing youre videos in english , even knowing that english is a "limited vocabulary language" , but in that case you will reach more brothers and sisters.. or simply make it in urdu and add subtitles. If you need help to translate to portuguese or spanish i can help you. May allah reward you with the best of this and the best in next life.
Salam. Yes, if you could do the Salat series subtitles in Spanish / Portuguese, I will add them into the videos.
Alhamdulillah MaasyaAllah thank you
Alhamdulillah
Excellent. Thanks for bringing clarity of Allah's words to us
Alhamdulillah
Salamun alaik almousesji ,
I got your reply that you don't know about "Ahmedisa rasoolallah"
So I suggest you to go to youtube channel "NABA 7" to have all information revealed by creator through Ahmedisa rasoolallah, before it's too late and you would be blamed to be ignorant,
With best wishes from a well wisher brother.
Wow ! I ve watched all your videos! Do you have your translation ? I support yours and wish to buy copy of your translation
No translations
Have you made any video on riba or intetest? Kindly send me a link if it is available.
Sorry, I had to listen at a later time. A side note. In the beginning you said not to add anything to the Quran, I agree with you, the majority add Amin at the end of Fatiha,
Good observation. There is no ameen in the first surah
Which translation is better?? I do not understand Arabic..thank you
Salamun Alaikum can you please explain 24/61
Please watch Marvelous Quran, by Dr. Hany
You are doing great work too. Jazak Allah
Yes I know him
@@AlMosesPhDWhat about Kashif khan of Pakistan? is he reliable?
Salam, here you are saying that in 62/9, Allah is saying on the day of gathering and not ‘day of Juma’ but the way it is written this word is actually seems ‘ day of Juma’ because if it is gathering or collecting then see 75/9 which is actually saying on combining or gathering or making together sun and the moon, AS Ansari says it is Day of Juma, please explain further.
Need more English video pls. Sub English your urdu video
Inshallah.
Too much effort sadly to sub Urdu videos. As and when time allows inshallah
Peace8
Sa, Mosa bhai COVID se abhi aap theek huwe ya nahi mere bhai bahut be Sabri se intzar he aapka bahut din ho gye mere dost kuch kahiye
SA Kamil bhai, soon baat karoon ga inshallah
@@AlMosesPhD ji Mosa bhai abhi sab kuchh theek hu bhai
Wonderful job ✔️ this is continuing the series , hope we see you continuing the subject. One thing is your presentation was different, not as interactive as previous work. Some sort of lacking coherence. These are just friendly comments!
Salamun Alykum
Thanks for your feedback.
Was it that I couldn't move the cursor to highlight items on the screen, or the actual verbal delivery?
@@AlMosesPhD salamun alykum brother. Sorry for replying you late. Actually voice was breaking. Please check your mic and jacks. May be need some dusting.
Otherthan that no issue at all. Waiting to hear this weeks topic !!!
Salaam. I don't understand the two way connections you are talking about. I always understood establish salat and zakat as meaning to establish salat ( the divine order and Zakat the economic order of welfar) when it's established vices and corruption will be eradicated. Am I wrong? Every prophet came to establish Allah's system of Islam..
Salamunalaikum Brother Moses,
I appreciate you sharing your in depth findings in English. May Allah reward you for your efforts.
Perhaps I have missed your explanation in the 'zikr' as Allah's System (refer to time 28:40). In the books of translation, 'zikr' = the remembrance of Allah. Another translation by Dr Hany Atchan, 'zikr' = the stories in the Quran.
Can you guide me on the meaning of 'zikr' based on your research. Thank you.
SA,
I'll cover zikr properly one day.
Yes, it can be the stories of the Quran as well but their overall purpose is still rememberance / prominence of Allah and His system.
Deen means System of Allah per your lecture. if you insert ' System of Allah in the second part of the Aya 10:105, translation becomes 'never be of those who add/remove to Allah's System'. My question is ' are we capable of adding/removing/changing Allah's System'? If not then, why Allah say this?
Listen to marvellous Quran by dr Hany….. very well researched work
Salamun alaikum
sura 61: 6 refers to ahmed in past tense
Can you pls explain how can we refer this to our prophet
In any of ur videos
SA,
Watch vid 'Kya mein Quranist hoon? Munkir e hadith?'
Brother what video is covering 4-102 war verse and 4-101 shortning verse 'please let me know.
It’ll be the next video in the series. As I said, there is no ‘ritual’ prayers being done there.
Brother, during your interview with Edip yeskiel, why you didn't interrupt and correct him when he stated,salah consists of standing, rukuh, sujood and so on according to Qur'an?
He is a force of nature and pretty hard to get a word in :)
Salam, I am muqtada from Ghana, you are always an eye opener.May Allah bless you. Please can I get your contact
Salam brother, al.moses.phd@gmail.com
@@AlMosesPhD salamun brother. May Allah guides us all. We have strived to be guided.
sometimes people conflate `salaah` and `ibadaah` how would you deconstruct this?
in 27:20 you've explained it in urdu in the past but i don't speak it.
Ibadah is to walk a path = path of Allah is Ibadat of Allah
@@AlMosesPhD so what is `tariqā` then?
I'm not quite sure what you mean by 'two-way communication'. Do you mean dialogue? Relationships? Fellowship? I'm not clear on what communication we need to uphold or maintain.
All of what you said. The form and specifics change based on contexts
Salam, great lecture, just one question, in my understanding deen is Allah's system and zikr is the remembrance of Him, please explain how and why did you translate zikr as system. May Allah reward you for your work.
Salam, Zikr is the rememb rance/making prominent Alllah's deen.
Aoa, can you share a link to your video in which you explained these words/concepts Jannat, Jahanum, Akhirat, Saza, jaza etc. Thanks
SA, I've not yet in English
@@AlMosesPhD please share urdu video link, i watch urdu videos.
@@saimch.9388 I've talked off and on in the Urdu videos but haven't dedicated specific videos yet
@@AlMosesPhD ok waiting videos on these important topics
Answer to your question on verse 20:14 as I earlier mentioned, the Jews pray the SAME ritual way. Check the Jewish foremost book on prayer by Haslim Doyen. Or google it to see many such videos of Jews praying just as Muslims do.
We are 'not' to follow any so-called books of God written by men. Nothing but the Quran. Same goes for the 'culture' or 'rites' of any culture.
Either way, we're all free to do / believe what we want brother
@@AlMosesPhD I ONLY follow the Quran as guide. I sift through Shakespeare, hadith, Bible and any other book on a find-some-good, reject falsehood basis. That said, we have one sunnah. The sunnah of Allah, which is the same sunnah our predecessors were all given as Quran clearly says (See Qur’an 40:85, Qur’an 33:38, Quran 41:43, Quran 33:62, and Quran 17:77) SO as expected you can find all the rituals Mohammed (p) was given in the practice of serious orthodox Jews and written about in the Bible, Torah and lost gospels. You only have to look to see it. Or google "Do orhtodox jews bow and prostrate like Muslims". Thanks.
There is nothing like salaat jumuah in the Quran . But Quran mentioned salaat fajr, salaat Wustah and salaat ishai...Does it mean we should reconnect with Allah system three times in a day ?
Continue with the series
The voice has quite a bit of popping in this video. Not as clear as before.
Ah, that might be hard to control as it's introduced by the streaming software.
Did it detract from listening?
@@AlMosesPhD It is a little distracting and takes away from the clear professional quality from before.
@@knowledgeistreasure yes, that's what I feared would happen.
Extra work on a professional video which slows down the production vs a few audio issues in live
Brother Moses, which Quran translation in English are u using.
My own
@Al Moses PhD - Quran Student can we get it on PDF
No sorry because I only do those ayaat that I am talking about
@Al Moses PhD - Quran Student no worries tks.
May I know, how do u perform Yr connection prayer n how many times. Pls
Do you know who Sam gerrans is on RUclips?
yes
@@AlMosesPhD what do you think of he’s understanding ?
I have a question. If Namaaz doesn’t exist so where did this very very very strong concept came from ???? . If someone never prays but no one can deny this fact .. in khana Kaba 5 times namaaz is prayed, if we see whole world Namaaz is Always the biggest and powerful priority.. so why didn’t Arabic people understood this?? Or we may be not understanding this properly??
Or there maybe some hidden signal available regarding namaz? If you can record this answer with very detail first in In Urdu and English both please.. thanks
Last video of the series brother
How then we establish salat according to Quran?
We have to 'refix/renew/strengthen' our salat with others all the time
@@AlMosesPhD in all our actions, right? And do it according to the deen. It is a personal quest.
Yes
Can you please clarify verse 17:78
It's in the series. Keep watching
Very informative. MashaAllah..you doing very good job moosa bhai.
Now All islam is wrong
There are 'two' versions of Islam: one in the Quran and one of tarikh. One of the two is set on wrong foundations
I have a thousand questions for you. It's unfortunate that I can't see you face to face and that typing questions is the only way. I do understand where you are coming from but as always either you're complicating the simple or you don't understand these concepts enough to give simple and concise answers to simple questions. What is salat and zakat...
Assalamualaikum. Brother Your Voice is similar with CP. Haha
SA, hopefully minus his akhlaq
Who is CP brother?
@@ZonaldoCR7 Christian Prince
Firstly, good job with the presentation.
Secondly, I find myself concurring with almost everything you presented here.
Thirdly, I have come to the realization that the true meaning of "Aqeemo" is in the word itself. I am sure you and almost everybody with a thinking mind are aware that the same 3 root letters "Qaf-Waw-Miim" is also for the English equivalent "People" or the Arabic "qawm!"
Now, it does not matter if you want to use "stand/establish/restore/repair" but the main thing is that is all about "standing/establishing/restoring/repairing" to the people/system.
For example, "repairing the wall that is about to collapse" is using your knowledge to make the wall that you are repairing to unobtrusively fit the existing wall.
So, "aqeemo al-salat" is simply reciting the Quran, and keeping it pure and untainted, to the people!
Thus, ensuring peace, prosperity and security to the people who believe in the Word/Command of God, i.e. the Quran.
Easy peasy lemon squeezy!
Verily, this Quran is made easy for you.
salam.
Good way of looking at it
whats the meaning of 4:103
Next video
Dear Brother Moses , what is the history of undertaking the Salah in the way fiqh have been doing it , are those who are imam and from Arab completely misleading the ummah, what do we do to connect with Allah, did resul not pray this way, what is then god asking us when he says they remember their lord in the hour leaving the comfort of their bed
I will cover this in the last vid of the series
Apni marzi ki translation kr k logon ko gumrah na jrain.jb Quran ma open ahkanat hain .phir ghuma phira kr q logon ko ghalat side pr le kr ja rahe hain.
Salamun brother.
I hear that musa u stresses as nabi whereas isa u stresses as rasul. May u share ur advanced understanding ofnabi and rasul.
I prefer the understanding that rasul is a delivery person of divine messege/messeges whereas nabi is an interpreter of that messege/messeges.
See surah maryam whereby zakaria said to her 'i am a rasul to u'. See surah yusuf whereby yusuf ex prison inmate say he will be a rasul to bring yusuf messege to the king.
Sukran brother. May Allah guides us as we have strived to be guided.
SA,
Isa is not called a nabi so I cannot do that :)
@@AlMosesPhD i understand ur stand.
I will be pleased to hear ur understanding of nabi vs rasul. Sukran.
@@tiaratiarasam1886 One day inshallah
@@AlMosesPhD insyaAllah. I am a non arab. I understand the quran thru govt endorsed translation. I hv doubted hadith a very long time ago.
I found dr hani, brother joseph, said mirza and the likes. Somehow their understanding differ. For the time being i prefer dr hani understanding. I am looking forward to hearing from u.
Sukran. We are all seeking knowledge from our sustainer. We will be judged according to our intellect. I will not hold u responsible for ur words. May Allah guides us for we hv strived to be guided.
@@tiaratiarasam1886 that's the right approach. We're all humans and thus will always have differrence of understanding.
Best we can do is be honest to ourselves
What is your proof/evidence to show that the Prophet, his companions and his later followers did not follow the so called "ritual prayer" 5 times a day?
This is not a history channel.
All I talked was about and from the Quran
Brother Moses, I didn't mean to cause any offense. But just to say that since we all regard our Rasul (PBUH) to be the principal source of our guidance, alongside the holy Book, your interpretation of Salat/namaz must hold against the practice he and his companions and followers adopted. My question/comment had nothing to do with history as such, but to be educated about any evidence in his and his companions'/followers' practice of Salat, whether 'ritualistic' or otherwise. I maintain an open mind on the issue, following your commentary/interpretation.
@@Maazi12345 I understand your position, thanks for clarifying.
Rasul Muhammad wasn't/isn't the source of guidance--it was/is/will be Allah and His risala through the rasul.
Re the historic / cultural practice of namaz we see, I'd like to cover it off in the last video of the series
The question is: how do we know whether our prayers are accepted?
There is no "prayer" in the Quran.
@@WaqasAfzali-e8p In total there are around 67 verses in the Quran about Salat.
The Quran also says, “Establish regular prayer: for prayer restrains from shameful and unjust deeds, and remembrance of Allah is the greatest (thing in life).”
@@baqirhemraj7639 nope. "Salat" doesn't mean prayer. "Establish prayer" doesn't actually mean anything. You don't establish prayer. You perform it. Salat is adherence and connection between entities. According to the Quran, birds do salat as well.
@@baqirhemraj7639 nope. "Salat" doesn't mean prayer. "Establish prayer" doesn't actually mean anything. You don't establish prayer. You perform it. Salat is adherence and connection between entities. According to the Quran, birds do salat as well.
Brother i respect your efforts 'but if you read 4-102 ALLAH is telling the prophet during times of war to be cautious of the enemy and this ayah clearly states the prophet and believers are instructed to perform a ritual SALAT. Also ALLAH says in 4-103 'that SALAT is prescribed on the believers on specified times 'and also ALLAH says in 4=101 that if your traveling through the land 'then shorten your SALAT. Now 'i ask you brother 'how can you shorten 'following closely or connecting 'brother i used to also believe there was no ritual SALAT 'but after further study 'i have come to know that there is a ritual aspect in QURAN. The word SALLU can mean contact, connect. follow closely 'but when ALLAH says AQEEMOO SALAT 'ALLAH is referring to a ritual SALAT. The SALAT has two aspects in QURAN the physical SALAT and phycological SALAT 'standing position for the phycological side is 'one monotheism and the physical position is when you stand to perform a ritual SALAT . The bowing position phycological is being humble to the verses of ALLAH and not disputing with verses of ALLAH and the physical side when you bow to perform SALAT. The phycological prostration is accepting and implementing and believing the QURAN 'and physical is when your in your Sujjoood.
Brother there are two sides to follow the QURAN physically and phytologically 'you are only following the phycological SALAT 'and leaving out the physical part. When the word SALLU is used in QURAN 'you have to understand the context and then use the root meaning of the word to fit in with the context. The word following closely and connect or contact 'must be applied in most verses 'but when ALLAH says establish SALAT 'you have to perform the ritual SALAT 'and the format we have to get for the SALAT is from the standing place of ABRAHIM in surah 2-125 'which is located in MECCAH.
But when performing SALAT 'i can grantee you all imams around the world when leading the SALAT 'will only recite the verses of ALLAH 'never HADITH. But when sitting down bowing 'you the believer will only recite the QURAN silently and complete your SALAT. The difference between the believers and the MUSHRICKS 'is simply 'we the believers will recite the QURAN when bowing sitting in SALAT and the MUSHRICKS will start to praise ABRAHIM and MUHAMAD peace be to both.
Brother 'do further study and research the QURAN and i promise you god willing 'you will understand. Peace be with you.
Brother, from the beginning of the series, I have mentioned that I will cover the so called 'war' situation verse and the so-called 'shortening' of it.
There is no war or a strange ritual salat being carried out a prescribed times there.
In the upcoming videos, both of these ayat will be covered inshallah.
All the examples you gave, the wall, the deen, the word can also be Establish, as with Establish your self to the upright system. Which is what we say of salat, "establish salat". DO you have any other evidence?
I don't see how aqeem as salat translated as establish the salat (ritual prayers) doesn't serve the purpose of connection between God and people as well as between people and other people. It in fact does that, and I believe you are undermining the importance of ritual prayer in almost any religion as well as the importance of congregating in the place (Masjid) for that purpose. It is quite possible that Salah in the way you translate it to connect entities does refer to the prayers also. How would you reconcile this, "establish the salah at the declining of the sun, and into the night and the reading of the Fajr...." or "do not let them enter your place of undress in set times..... After salat Al eshaa..." or "when the call to Salah is made on the day of jumuah, then hasten to the rememberable of Allah" or "guard the salawaat and especially the middle Salah..." I appreciate the dimensions of meaning you infer because after all interpretations have always been numerous, but when you have managed to cancel all the normative religious practices of Muslims what do you suggest replacing it with? So Christians and Jews have places of worship "houses in which God is remembered" but Muslims should make use of factories and libraries to establish the law of God, and have no formal known means of prayer despite that they in fact do? What a fantastic innovation and effort it must've been to align all sects who hated and fought wars against each other on the simple matter of Salah (prayers)? I think your ideas are interesting but seems inconsistent. You'd have to take every instance of every reference and interpret the entire Quran with those inferred meanings. Like if Rijal meant only "Peoole in authority" you'd have to do a deep dive on the vast discussions related to marriage in the Quran. For example "then wed women of your choice two, three or four..." If Nisaa here were just people without authority then a person in authority even a woman can wed (Nikah/ sleep with) two three or four or any number of men. You seem to have a very gender neutral approach. How can we even talk about the law of God if everything is seemingly metaphorical? What would be the law of God? Wash your face and your hands to your elbows and wipe your head and feet to your ankles is metaphorical and does not actually refer to a ritual purification according to you. So we'll have very little tangible anything if we follow along that trajectory.
There's a reason it's a 'series'.
Best to reserve judgement unless you've heard the reasoning for all these ayaat.
Salat ka matalab hai bhalai
Is series ki pehli vid dekhyay
Islam Mein music haram hai
Kahan likha hay?
Brother, pls don't address people other than muslims as "Kafir" countries or "Kafir people," but let's address all people as brothers and sisters in humanity. I learnt from Kerala Quran-only following muslims and the term "Kafir" consists of two words "Kafi" plus "Ra" which means any person who says whatever he is believing now and following is enough (Kafi) for him and he does not want to enrich his knowledge with truth and he is content with his views which is "Ra" or "Ru'ya."
I always tell people about the fact that Jews and Nazareancs (Christians) etc, we all were given the same Shariah and Sunnah, as in verse 42:13. And this goes against your point. Rather we see the same establishment of salah in Judaism and the Bible, with Orthodox Jews standing, bowing and prostrating and the same of Jesus and in the New Testament.
We are 'not' to follow any so-called books of God written by men. Nothing but the Quran. Same goes for the 'culture' or 'rites' of any culture.
Either way, we're all free to do / believe what we want brother
@@AlMosesPhD When I said Sunnah, I did not refer to/say "hadith", I said Sunnah. The one Sunnah of Allah ta'ala and of our predecessors. See Qur’an 40:85, Qur’an 33:38, Quran 41:43, Quran 33:62, and Quran 17:77. It's the same way Musa and Isa lived, prayed, etc. Standing, bowing, prostrating as is seen in the Bible and with Orthodox Jews
@@dr.perrybrimahstheesoteric741 brother I don't comment debate.
Watch the series from the beginning, and the 'sunnah' argument in particular is covered in the last video of the series.
Once more, as my last word, we do NOT follow the Jews or Maoris or Aboriginals or Native Americans.
@@AlMosesPhD I never said we follow them. You asked: why don't we see the same prayer ritual among them before the Quran. I provided that we actually do. They pray the same way-the serious of them and have the same salat ritual in their books. You can decide what to do with that reality.
Brother, may ' know why there are diverse interpretations of Quranic terms such as Salah, wudhu, zakat, hajj, Ramadan, fasting and so on.. among the Quranists or those who uphold Qur'an only... According to you, Salah means two way connection, but there are others who say, i). it is 'duty', ii) it is twice a day iii)thrice a day and so on. Zakath is i). Sexual purity ii) Spiritual purity iii) charity.. Why there is no consensus among Quranists.. Wouldn't it be better you debate it among yourself and arrive at a consensus first, before teaching the lay majority, confusing them, misleading them to (your) preferred narrative?
Sister / brother, watch the last video of the series.
Secondly, I am no Quranist. Just a muslim.
क्या उन्होंने उन चीज़ों पर विचार नहीं किया जो अल्लाह ने पैदा की हैं? उनकी परछाइयाँ दायीं और बायीं ओर झुकती हैं, अल्लाह को सजदा करती हैं, जबकि वे [अर्थात् वे रचनाएँ] विनम्र हैं। 16/48
And to Allāh prostrates whoever is within the heavens and the earth, willingly or by compulsion, and their shadows [as well] in the mornings and the afternoons.
और अल्लाह ही को सज्दा करता है, चाह या न चाह, वह जो आकाशों तथा धरती में है और उनकी प्रछाईयाँ[ भी प्रातः और संध्या1। 13/15
मैंने उसे तथा उसकी जाति को पाया कि सज्दा करते हैं सूर्य को अल्लाह के सिवा और शोभनीय बना दिया है, उनके लिए शैतान ने उनके कर्मों को और उन्हें रोक दिया है सुपथ से, अतः, वे सुपथ पर नहीं आते 27/24
[और] इसलिए वे उस अल्लाह को सजदा नहीं करते, जो आकाशों और धरती के भीतर छिपी बातों को निकालता है और जानता है जो कुछ तुम छिपाते हो और जो कुछ घोषित करते हो - 27/25
JANAAB / NABI AS , NE PRACTICALLY SAJDA ,SALAH , NAMAZ KA TARIQA BATAYA HAI UMAAT KO...{AAP SUNAAH KE MUNKIR HO }
हे ईमान वालो! अल्लाह की आज्ञा का अनुपालन करो और रसूल की आज्ञा का अनुपालन करो तथा अपने शासकों की आज्ञापालन करो। फिर यदि किसी बात में तुम आपस में विवाद (विभेद) कर लो, तो उसे अल्लाह और रसूल की ओर फेर दो, यदि तुम अल्लाह तथा अन्तिम दिन (प्रलय) पर ईमान रखते हो। ये तुम्हारे लिए अच्छा[ और इसका परिणाम अच्छा है 4/59 ..
Brother, did you know that you + the scholars of your sect are munkire hadith too?
See the vid 'Kya mein Quranist hoon? Munkare hadith?' if you wish to learn
Mischievous
Aqeemu Salat......
ESTABLISH THE DIVINE SYSTEM OF LIFE, AS PRESCRIBED IN THE QURAN SO AS TO IMPROVE YOURSELVES AND SOCIETY.
Salat had nothing to do with praying, as you correctly state, brother Moses.
Salat means to follow as closely as possible, all that is given to us in the Quran, 24/7
Fake
And where is the Quranic ayah to counter what's been said?
Brother, this is from Bangladesh, please continue the awesome work..
And in English please.. I can't make out some Urdu words but I watch anyway... gather whatever I can. Please share your email on yr channel so we can connect.
Salamun aleikum.
Thanks brother.
al.moses.phd@gmail.com