Jungyeon - an actress in SM's Subsidary, KeyEast Ent. Yiyang - a soloist under Tao's Ent in China. Koeun, Hina and Lami and Herin - living their lives happily. Ningning - *DEBUTING TOMORROW* let's all support our girls 🥺
@@Cookie33300 not really sure if they had plans on being in the industry again but as of now Koeun takes some sponsorship, Lami is pretty inactive but was rumored to audition for being a model instead(an agency commented on his IG but there's no assurance if Lami talked to that company), Hina is just enjoying his freedom rn
ning ning covering taeyeon’s part for the bridge and now debuting in aespa. we already know who the main vocal gonna be. 2nd gen : taeyeon/jessica 3rd gen : wendy 4th gen : ningning
@@celined2031 i mentioned them because that's my opinion, you mentioned your opinion like a forcing me to agree with you, and now you mentioned it, i can go on with yeonjung wjsn, sejeong gugudan, yuri izone, goeun purple kiss, they are good but not as good as wendy and yuju... And for luna, she was good singing Korean song, have u seen her singing English against Charice, she was not near taeyeon ability.... Luna was top 10 but never was the top 2..the only one can give taeyeon a run for her money is eunji... Bora is a great vocalist but her voice doesn't really versatile while haeyoon techniques was bad, she always seem to sing higher than her voice....and anyway that's my opinion, you can share your opinions but don't correct mine
Thank you Ningning, for surviving so far and successfully debuting in AESPA, your hard work, perseverance, patience has paid off. I will always support you .
More like SM won't dare let go of her. Her vocals are insane, a visual, main dancer material and has great stage presence. SM will be too stupid to let go of her.
I’m glad SM is not throwing its reputation for having the best vocalists in Kpop. Like every group from SM, the main vocalist always has a great technique and strong vocals. Here we have Ning Ning.
Yess...I really want to see Lami and koeun performing in stage. I'm sure if Lami will debut she would have been one of the top visual in the k pop industry
@@user-nd5lg2rj2j i hope they're debut this year. It's too long for them, specially koeun. It's been 10years for her. I'm afraid if another will left SM after herin and yiyang:'(
I really love the combination of Hina and Ningning's voices. Hina has unique tone, I really thought she would be another Haechan (NCT), who has special tone in the whole industry. Meanwhile Ningning is the main vocal like Taeil (NCT). We won't get that kind of combination anymore.
Only Ningning survived the SM trainee system here. SM clearly knew who their next main vocalist was going to be, Ningning did every single adlib and had 2 solo verses while the others got 1 or 0. She's always had the best vocal technique.
@@wonwoosburger9066 i think there's really no confirmation of her as an sm trainee (someone correct me if i'm wrong) but now she debuted as an actress under keyeast entertainment, which is i think a subsidiary of sm! today's the first episode of the drama she's in, the title is 'wind, clouds and rain'~
SM has already eyed for their main vocal, Ningning the sole smrookie survivor is indeed a TALENT. No wonder SM did not let go of her. The first ever non Korean main vical of all SM girl groups, says a lot about how good she is and now she is aespa's MAIN SLAYER, a total and born performer🔥
so I actually miss them so much, i swear why won't SM debut them?????? We've been waiting long enough for these beautiful, talented girls. I can assure you that when they debut almost no other girl group will be able to take over them in my heart. They're honestly amazing, I think they'd do well if they debuted,
kirin chan how long will that take though? I mean, NCT is my favourite group, but I honestly think SM is a little biased to them somehow?? It's been 3 years since NCT debuted and we barely heard of how the girls are doing. Like, SM should at least let them post on the SMRookies account. There are so many people waiting for them!
This hits differently now especially because Yiyang, Lami, Koeun (and Herin) all left sm 😭 I had high hopes for this group but I guess it’s because sm keeps pushing their debut. I wish good luck to all these girls 🥺
Nisarga Shetty No SM basically indirectly confirmed it. A few days ago it was revealed Lami and Koeun’s names were removed off of the SM Rookie’s rosters, meaning they left the label. Additionally, fans found former sm rookie Herin following a new insta account, and it turned out to be Lami (Sungkyung). Her username is @bible_030303 so you can check it out (but Herin unfollowed her after it blew up lol) After all, they’re just trainees so I don’t expect SM to make some official announcement like how they do for their artists. It’s really unfortunate, considering how much time and effort they spent under the label for it to go to waste. However I don’t think it was an easy decision for them to make so hopefully they’ll do well.
JUNGYEON LEFT YIYANG LEFT KOEUN LEFT LAMI LEFT AND HINA LEFT THE COMPANY AT OCTOBER 16,2020 NINGNING YOUR OUR ONLY HOPE NOW PLS 😭 SM DEBUT THE GIRLS ALREADY!?!
And I am here again after hearing Ningning's vocal in Aespa teaser and I am glad SM didn't change her vocal tone, and we know y'all SM never change their idol vocal's color but manage it to be better and let them shine with what they actually have and that we have to appreciate, thanks SM!
Don't forget Herin😭 I'll still support the new gg but I'm kind of disappointed the MMC cast won't debut together, they were my childhood along with the original NCT Dream
i think the reason why they all left the company is that SM changed the concept. The first concept was pure with powerful choreography as SNSD’ a first years & Koeun, Lami, Hina were perfect for this concept. But now if you see Aespa’s teaser photos u can see that concept is mysterious, more adult & chic(?). And this concept doesn't suit them so they changed the line-up? Just think for yourself, they were already popular & had their own fan base. We are all waited them. I don't think they did it for no good reason. Of course, it’s so sad because we all waited our Ko-leader and center- maknae Lami, dance machine Hina, visual Yiyang, our happy virus Herin with cute dimples. But let’s support Aespa!~ I think they deserve it & hope all good wishes for our SR15G, SR16G🤍🤧
It still amaze me how Ningning was offered to signed the contract to be an SM trainee after just one week of being in Korea and inmediatelly was put into SM rookies, I read a twt of an ex SM trainee who was asked that within the trainees who had the Star factor like Seulgi, Taeyeon, Taemin, Kai, etc and she said that Koeun, Ningning and Lami were the ones that came to her mind
let me appreciate all 7 sm rookies girls. you guys brought public interest into sm new girl group, aespa. thank you for your hardworks. even though only 1 left, all 7 of you did your best. thank you for your sacrifices. Jungyeon Koeun Lami Hina Herin Yiyang Ningning thank you girls
hold on ning and hina 😭 please debut together, make herin, yiyang, koeun and lami proud 😭 닝와 히나언니... 데뷔.. ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 언제??? ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 너무 슬퍼,, 진짜 :( 닝 그리고 히나언니, 수고했어요!!! 데뷔 함께 가자!! ㅠㅠ
Actually before even revealing Ningning in Aespa,I knew she was going to debut,she had the hardest parts and did all the adlips so i was so sure that she’s SMe favorite vocalist 🤍
Not really, before Ningning join SM, they have Herin. She's a really good vocalist even at her age. Everyone thought she's gonna stay be the main vocalist.
@@notmyname3556 i was actually heren stan😭 don’t remind of this pain 😭 aahh even tho she was a great dancer more than a main vocalist material so everyone was like she’s gonna be the main dancer and lead vocalist or smth but boom she didn’t make it I literally was so heartbroken but at least my baby Ningning made it❤️
SM really has the vocal powerhouses of KPOP. They choose their trainees well, since SM is known for perfect visuals and powerful vocals. They still kept their brand that way.
everytime sm announce a new gg and now that they already confirmed the members, i still kept on thinking that koeun, hina, herin, lami, jungyeon, yiyang and ningning were the ones that's gonna debut. although i am very happy much happy the a new smgg will debut, i can't help but to have a bitter feeling that only ningning was left. i have been watching and rooting for them especially for koeun because i wanna see more of her leadership. still, best of luck, aespa! i will just think that ningning holds the dreams of her friends who couldn't make it to the stage. in that way, i can feel or ease the bitterness that constantly crept in my heart
the line-up we'll never have :( thank you smrg15-19, thank you herin, thank you lami, thank you koeun, thank you jungyeon, thank you yiyang. we look forward to your debut, hina ❤
@@girlsredpinkbytaengsicseul3091 i heard the rumors that koeun and lami left… lami already made an instagram acc. Her name on Naver(?) already gone. I dont comfim about koeun tho :'(
@@helloangel7803 Hi. Yes, SMR20G just Updated that Lami & Koeun not on the list which only left Hina & Ningning in the Column at Naver. There's two speculation: 1. They left SM for good 2. Both set to debut, and they erase their name. Idk, but I wish them all the best tho 😔😊
What do you mean dirty？ Being a trainee doesn't mean you are 100% guarantee to debut. What happens if there is some hidden trainees who are better？ I feel sad when I heard Lami left but sometimes it can also be a personal decision to give up.
Xu Yiyang being keeping up with her now through Chuang 2020 I hope she finally debuts, she is well rounded im glad that at least she signed with Tao company now that SM was just keeping it there 🙌🏻
Some are questioning the aespa lineup. 1) Ningning voice is the most outstanding than the other 5 smrookies 2) Winter vocal and technique is above the other 5 smrookies 3) Giselle is the best rapper than the smrookies (english speaker is a bonus, so she became the english speaker) 4) Karina not only serving visual and dancing but also her powerful vocal Also lami is my fav visual but seeing her grow up, her face changed a lot (still beautiful but no longer as how she used to (eg: picture in the video), thus Lami often posted photo of her covering her face. She also used filters in her ig live saying she doesn’t feel confident in her face). I think Karina and Winter did surpass her current visual. Anyways goodluck to all these former rookies. I have been supporting them for many years. All the best.
I'm sorry but yiyang and koeun visual are beautiful.. if they debut in the same group.. it will be amazing.. ps I stalked yiyang pictures her face so luxury..
Sorry but i find your comment hella rude. eventhough the rest of them not debut but one thing for sure, smngg bcm a hit and be "the waiting for" bcs of lami koeun hina and herin. The original one that sm show to public.
Smh this comment assumes the girls did not debut because aespa members are more talented/ deserving. I think most of these girls left before they decided aespa lineup and the reason they did not debut is not because of their talents and potential but because sm kept delaying it. Once announced smrookies you're supposed to be sure to debut because why would the company promote you to public? For fun? SM plans kept changing and they kinda got tired of waiting.. These girls and aespa members are all wonderful and no need to relate their reason of debuting/not debuting to each other.
You seem kinda biased in your comment... This video and many other videos of smrookies girls performing are 2++ years old and I'm sure they've improved so much more all these years but we just didn't get to witness their improvements bc SM barely released new content about them.
@@pringlespocari1522 LOL y'all are so delusional it's so clear they left because they DID NOT MAKE THE CUT no one in their right mind would leave SMs new GG if they were confirmed for thw lineup they left cause they got replaced period
And only ningning debut in SM
Ok I'm crying
🥺🥺🥺😭
Wait what about hina???
@@Hehehehehehehehehheheheheehhe she's out, even now she already has an Instagram account
crying😭😭
this makes me so sad fuck sm
Jungyeon - an actress in SM's Subsidary, KeyEast Ent.
Yiyang - a soloist under Tao's Ent in China.
Koeun, Hina and Lami and Herin - living their lives happily.
Ningning - *DEBUTING TOMORROW*
let's all support our girls 🥺
@@Cookie33300 No, they are living a normal life away from the spotlight rn
@@Cookie33300 not really sure if they had plans on being in the industry again but as of now Koeun takes some sponsorship, Lami is pretty inactive but was rumored to audition for being a model instead(an agency commented on his IG but there's no assurance if Lami talked to that company), Hina is just enjoying his freedom rn
wait, hina left sm????
@@alixexpres trainees can't have a social media account & hina made an instagram last october! so we can assume that she also left sm
Isn’t yiyang in the Chinese show chuang 2020?
ning ning covering taeyeon’s part for the bridge and now debuting in aespa. we already know who the main vocal gonna be.
2nd gen : taeyeon/jessica
3rd gen : wendy
4th gen : ningning
f(x) exists
@@celined2031 also 3rd gen was shorter than 1st and 2nd gen also.
@@celined2031 Winter too.
@@celined2031 it has I was deadass confused when they said 3rd gen ended around 2018 when and gen was 2003-2011
@@celined2031 i mentioned them because that's my opinion, you mentioned your opinion like a forcing me to agree with you, and now you mentioned it, i can go on with yeonjung wjsn, sejeong gugudan, yuri izone, goeun purple kiss, they are good but not as good as wendy and yuju... And for luna, she was good singing Korean song, have u seen her singing English against Charice, she was not near taeyeon ability.... Luna was top 10 but never was the top 2..the only one can give taeyeon a run for her money is eunji... Bora is a great vocalist but her voice doesn't really versatile while haeyoon techniques was bad, she always seem to sing higher than her voice....and anyway that's my opinion, you can share your opinions but don't correct mine
Ningning doing all adlibs done by Jessica & Taeyeon. Daebak.
main vocal material lol
And the fact that she is so young this time
@@naevis5832 her vocals now is insane
No one can cover sm song better than sm trainees
periodt
Exactly😭👍
I agree
i agree but yuju also did a good job, yeonjung is sm trainee so i agree with you, she us da best when covering taeyeon part
@@winterchillin yeonjung is under starship lmao
I swear. Yiyang is so beautiful. SM lost another talented visual.
Right! She’s so beautiful
they prefer visual without so much talent so they can focus being a visual lol
Why Am I Not Korean ? FYI SM has the most talentend idols not to mention their Visual. Sm idols are Visuals with talent
Alexa Arielle does sm still have Jungyeon?
She left
Ningning's journey is like this song.
Who’s here after Ningning being revealed as a member of Aespa? 🖤🙋🏼♀️
me
Meeee. My bias!!! The last woman standing in SRG16! 😭😍
A future vocal legend 💜
Hina's vocal is unique, aaah:((( but Ningning still the best for me:* so sad most of them can't debut with Aespa
@@belovayue6570 well but they left
Ningning did all the important ablibs and 2notes. Proud of aespa’s main vocal
Imagine her vocals now.
Thank you Ningning, for surviving so far and successfully debuting in AESPA, your hard work, perseverance, patience has paid off. I will always support you .
More like SM won't dare let go of her. Her vocals are insane, a visual, main dancer material and has great stage presence. SM will be too stupid to let go of her.
I’m glad SM is not throwing its reputation for having the best vocalists in Kpop. Like every group from SM, the main vocalist always has a great technique and strong vocals. Here we have Ning Ning.
Also Koeun but I believe she will only be a Lead vocal
Hahahaha. I also appreciate Hina’s voice despite being the main dancer. Kinda like Seulgi
And we only ended up with ningning
@@veIvette yeah, so sad. Everyone here has a great potential. Let’s just support Ningning
@@shersurewin yes of course I'm really happy she made it into the final line up.
Woah!!! Ningning is like jessica and taeyeon has a daughter..
And she seems to Baekhyun jajaja
Exactly!
Only Ningning made it 😭 hoping to see them debut soon and reunite on stage😭😭😭
Yess...I really want to see Lami and koeun performing in stage. I'm sure if Lami will debut she would have been one of the top visual in the k pop industry
i can hear ningning’s voice even with all their voices in harmony like it’s sos distinct
Her voice is so sweet
yup, a main vocal quality.
Ningning deserves so much love🤍 let’s support her guys🤍 she patiently wait and fought so hard to debut🥺🤍. Aespa Ningning🤍
Koeun reminds me of Yuju.
•੭ुRosé omg same
I was just about to comment that, they really look alike
Yes me too
yeah same a mix of Yuju and Nako
she reminds me of momo, for some reason
Ningning's vocals are seriously amazing. Like to think she was what 16 years old at the time of them releasing this song and she slayed it.
She was 15 here
i falling love with ningning's voice ㅠㅠ ♡♡♡
me too
superioryena she’s still there, preparing to debut with the other girls ;)
same
Me too. Her voice is so beuatifull♡
Now she's in Æspa
first bias herin left.
second bias yiyang left.
third bias lami left.
anuna
Also koeun left
omeghad sameee, herin first bias ko then si yiyang :((( parehas sila nagleave :(((
Ningning na bes. Haha
Yiyang redebuted lol then disbanded. She’s a trainee under Long Tao entertainment now
kapit lang
ace Ningning!
She can sing,dance,she have charisma,and her visual is just-
Why she is so perfect
Ningning looks like a female version of Baekhyun
I can t unsee it now
Yesss
SM cloning on another level
Ikr :O
Also jaemin
Yiyang looks like a mix of krystal and joy
I think she kinda looks like Heechul lmao
she left SM~
I think yiyang looks Tao ex EXO girl version
-xia小優 bruh you did not😂😂 i’m dead
@@el.c.8858 heechul is gorgeous so..
But yeah we lost yiyang now
oh we lost her months ago. she’s doing great on the next top bang though, you should check out her performances (especially shape of my heart!)
@angel yeah, has been for months
Did she leave sm ?
@@ranaker1967 yes, she confirmed it in september. she signed to LTAO entertainment (tao's company) and has been on the chinese show 下一站传奇.
@@user-nd5lg2rj2j i hope they're debut this year. It's too long for them, specially koeun. It's been 10years for her. I'm afraid if another will left SM after herin and yiyang:'(
I really love the combination of Hina and Ningning's voices. Hina has unique tone, I really thought she would be another Haechan (NCT), who has special tone in the whole industry. Meanwhile Ningning is the main vocal like Taeil (NCT).
We won't get that kind of combination anymore.
pls
ningning last woman standing :((
only Ningning made it to AESPA :(((
Ningning!! THE LAST GIRL STANDING! We will support you Ningning. Congrats on your debut
Ningning's struggles and waiting have paid off, now he's debuting in aespa, congratulations Ningning my dear❤️👍😭
Only Ningning survived the SM trainee system here. SM clearly knew who their next main vocalist was going to be, Ningning did every single adlib and had 2 solo verses while the others got 1 or 0. She's always had the best vocal technique.
Ningning your dream to debut has come true now. you will be successful and I always support you and your group until whenever ❤️
For me SM is still the best when it come to vocal group
Ningning and Hina is the craziest vocalist for me. their voice is so mind blowing😭😭😭♥♥
It’s so sad when you found out only Ningning made it at the end...
Ningning is a VOCALIST, I'm so happy she's debuting in Aespa !!!
When you realize that Hina and Ningning are the only ones who haven't left yet 😭😭😭
my heart 😔😭
Omg really? How about Jungyeon? I was rooting for her so much
@@wonwoosburger9066 i think there's really no confirmation of her as an sm trainee (someone correct me if i'm wrong)
but now she debuted as an actress under keyeast entertainment, which is i think a subsidiary of sm! today's the first episode of the drama she's in, the title is 'wind, clouds and rain'~
It hurts 🥺
I wish they left too sm doesn't deserve them
Lami smiles kinda reminds me of Mark
Oh yazzz
She reminds me of sandara😂
wAit, it's actually similar tho..i feel like i just failed as a mark stan
It's a mix between Hendery and Mark right?
kim so hyun??
omg yiyang is so freaking beautiful??? she looks like she belongs in one of those ancient chinese kung fu films (liu yifei style) CHINA REPRESENT !!
she leaves sm
She left
She's in Tao's agency in China now
@@dc9067 omg in TAO'S?? woahhh
if u could put urself in my shoes she is currently participating in Chuang 2020. You should check it out if you like her.
@@laocongge oooh. I guess they've all grown up now. Thanks for telling
SM has already eyed for their main vocal, Ningning the sole smrookie survivor is indeed a TALENT. No wonder SM did not let go of her. The first ever non Korean main vical of all SM girl groups, says a lot about how good she is and now she is aespa's MAIN SLAYER, a total and born performer🔥
ning ning have a amazing vocal omg
ning ning is really gonna be the queen of vocal
out of these 6 trainees, only one debuted ;( i miss them sm
SAMEEE
😭😭😭
SAMEEEE
Exactly 😭 I really wanted Koeun and Lami to debut
Ningninggg you grow up so fast now your an Aespa member for 1yr now time flew so fast😭
who’s here after the release of Ningning teaser? coz yeah, she’s finally debuting!!
aespa is coming! We can’t have Jungyeon, Koeun, Yiyang, Hina and Lami but we still have Ningning! ❤️ Let’s support them!!
yeeess! ning ning so adorable in teasers
Cant believe Ningning sang Into the new world She has a beautiful voice
so I actually miss them so much, i swear why won't SM debut them?????? We've been waiting long enough for these beautiful, talented girls. I can assure you that when they debut almost no other girl group will be able to take over them in my heart. They're honestly amazing, I think they'd do well if they debuted,
because SM want to focus to NCT first afterthat debut this 5 girls
kirin chan how long will that take though? I mean, NCT is my favourite group, but I honestly think SM is a little biased to them somehow?? It's been 3 years since NCT debuted and we barely heard of how the girls are doing. Like, SM should at least let them post on the SMRookies account. There are so many people waiting for them!
@@amber-qo4ju maybe next year i think?
im waiting them too
@@amber-qo4ju they were born in like 199x-2003 so they're like all over 17 years old now. I think they will debut late this year or just next year.
@@casiekelsie5581 I hope next year,I think SM said they wont be debuting any new groups this year
ningning’s voice is beautiful 😭
Ningning look like jaemin 😁
omg she does
When I first saw her she looked like Jaemin in a wig
LMAOOO
Amaliah Nadhif ; now I can’t unsee that
Yeah
This hits differently now especially because Yiyang, Lami, Koeun (and Herin) all left sm 😭
I had high hopes for this group but I guess it’s because sm keeps pushing their debut. I wish good luck to all these girls 🥺
Lami left????
@@thetinybabbles there are rumours not confirmed
Nisarga Shetty No SM basically indirectly confirmed it. A few days ago it was revealed Lami and Koeun’s names were removed off of the SM Rookie’s rosters, meaning they left the label. Additionally, fans found former sm rookie Herin following a new insta account, and it turned out to be Lami (Sungkyung). Her username is @bible_030303 so you can check it out (but Herin unfollowed her after it blew up lol) After all, they’re just trainees so I don’t expect SM to make some official announcement like how they do for their artists.
It’s really unfortunate, considering how much time and effort they spent under the label for it to go to waste. However I don’t think it was an easy decision for them to make so hopefully they’ll do well.
@@nishu3978 confirmed alrd
@@jyr6453 only Ningning didnt left
SM should make Aespa sing this song, we could see Ning Ning's high note even better.
They will just give the high notes to Winter the “favorite.”
@@chiken8801 exactly. SM history with theirs Chinese idols is legendary
@@chiken8801 😔
@@chiken8801 i dont even like winter but her voice is more pleasing to ears(+she is the most stable) nings voice is annoying sometimes
@@stardust332 winter hight note is uncomfortable that hurt me lol popular opinion
NING NING'S VOCAL GHRR SHE'S SO GOOD😭❤
came back here after seeing lami's graduation photo 😭💘
Me after i heard boys came to nct 127 concert. When will they debut?:"(
@@neodontgotmyback4095 boy group will comeout once every 4 year but not gg. So idk if sm will debut them next year
Zar Law you forgot fx
@@noreennatasha9435 so the 2nd NCT gen should debut next year...
I want Yeri to be the youngest and now this stupid Lami girl will steal all of her attention
Ningning is last standing smrookie that never left and she finally debut in Aespa
JUNGYEON LEFT
YIYANG LEFT
KOEUN LEFT
LAMI LEFT
AND HINA LEFT THE COMPANY AT OCTOBER 16,2020
NINGNING YOUR OUR ONLY HOPE NOW PLS 😭 SM DEBUT THE GIRLS ALREADY!?!
Thank you
Ningning debut Aespa
@@putriwijayanti1937 yes she debuted and some rumors said that koeun might be in the line up for Bighit's new girl group...
@@clairenuestro aahh OMG..really???
@@putriwijayanti1937 yes in 2021
everyone talked about visual, here i am talk about HOW POWERFUL VOCALIST NINGNING IS!! YO GO GIRL! let's debut with hina
닝닝이는 목소리도 귀엽고 얼굴도 진짜 귀엽고… ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 닝닝이가 최고다 닝깅아 사랑해
Last woman standing congrats for enduring everything ningning
I'm Happy that Ning Ning made it to debut, but its sad that not with smrookies too
Same I’m pretty sure she misses them though 🥺
Exactly 😭
ningning is finally debuting she waited for so long im so happy😭😭😭
SMRB - all of them debut except Hansol, SMRG - only Ningning debut, I don't know why but it hurts me sometimes
And I am here again after hearing Ningning's vocal in Aespa teaser and I am glad SM didn't change her vocal tone, and we know y'all SM never change their idol vocal's color but manage it to be better and let them shine with what they actually have and that we have to appreciate, thanks SM!
Yiyang left
Lami left
Koeun left
Herin left
NINGNING & HINA PLEASE STAYY💖💖😭😭
Don't forget Herin😭 I'll still support the new gg but I'm kind of disappointed the MMC cast won't debut together, they were my childhood along with the original NCT Dream
why they left??
@김2000해야 she left?
김2000해야 she left too?
@김2000해야 hina left??
I really miss you all, and congratulations to NINGNING 🥺💞
and here i am, i found myself watching this vid again. i'm so proud of what you've become, Queen NingNing!
SERIOUSLY THE HARMONY ON THE CHORUS IS EVERYTHING
i think the reason why they all left the company is that SM changed the concept. The first concept was pure with powerful choreography as SNSD’ a first years & Koeun, Lami, Hina were perfect for this concept. But now if you see Aespa’s teaser photos u can see that concept is mysterious, more adult & chic(?). And this concept doesn't suit them so they changed the line-up? Just think for yourself, they were already popular & had their own fan base. We are all waited them. I don't think they did it for no good reason. Of course, it’s so sad because we all waited our Ko-leader and center- maknae Lami, dance machine Hina, visual Yiyang, our happy virus Herin with cute dimples. But let’s support Aespa!~ I think they deserve it & hope all good wishes for our SR15G, SR16G🤍🤧
i admire ningning's patience lol
Ningning, the last girl standing huhuhu i'm so proud of you!!! ❤❤❤
It still amaze me how Ningning was offered to signed the contract to be an SM trainee after just one week of being in Korea and inmediatelly was put into SM rookies, I read a twt of an ex SM trainee who was asked that within the trainees who had the Star factor like Seulgi, Taeyeon, Taemin, Kai, etc and she said that Koeun, Ningning and Lami were the ones that came to her mind
among those three. Ning really is the ACE.Her vocals alone is insane. No wonder SM did not let her go
let me appreciate all 7 sm rookies girls. you guys brought public interest into sm new girl group, aespa. thank you for your hardworks. even though only 1 left, all 7 of you did your best. thank you for your sacrifices.
Jungyeon
Koeun
Lami
Hina
Herin
Yiyang
Ningning
thank you girls
hold on ning and hina 😭 please debut together, make herin, yiyang, koeun and lami proud 😭 닝와 히나언니... 데뷔.. ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 언제??? ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 너무 슬퍼,, 진짜 :( 닝 그리고 히나언니, 수고했어요!!! 데뷔 함께 가자!! ㅠㅠ
Ningning's improvement are really impressive, her voice is so powerful now check her latest teaser.
Is there anyone who came after SM announces that Ning Ning will debut on Aespa?
yeaaaa
Ningning's voice 😍
진심 너무 슬프다.. 이렇게 완벽한 애들인데..
Actually before even revealing Ningning in Aespa,I knew she was going to debut,she had the hardest parts and did all the adlips so i was so sure that she’s SMe favorite vocalist 🤍
Not really, before Ningning join SM, they have Herin. She's a really good vocalist even at her age. Everyone thought she's gonna stay be the main vocalist.
@@notmyname3556 i was actually heren stan😭 don’t remind of this pain 😭 aahh even tho she was a great dancer more than a main vocalist material so everyone was like she’s gonna be the main dancer and lead vocalist or smth but boom she didn’t make it I literally was so heartbroken but at least my baby Ningning made it❤️
@@casamera4063 really? i thought her dancing is just decent but it's her vocals that popped off. I think you're talking about Hina.
Ning was obviously better. SM knows who their best vocalists
ningning is carrying a whole song
SM really has the vocal powerhouses of KPOP. They choose their trainees well, since SM is known for perfect visuals and powerful vocals. They still kept their brand that way.
SM town always has one of the strongest vocals. Can't wait for these girls to debut next year
Ningning congrats for your debut
SM is an agency that demands its artists to be perfect faces, vocals , dance and they have it for that sm is the best agency.
Agree but... Take that back! Cuz now only Hina and ning-ning stay in SM, while the others already left:((
@@matchaabi3824 You need to remember that there are other trainees who are introduced like Joy who is not a SMRookie yet became part of RV.
NINGNING YOU MADE IT BABY IM SO HAPPY FOR YOUUU
My First Impression
Right To Left
Shuhua,Tzuyu,Yuju,Jimin,Minju,APINK Member
Same
I CANT UNSEE MINJU-
TWICEZ*ONE Entertainment same
agree but Yiyang too beautiful, why you compare with Tzuyu...
bbang bbangpao excuse you? Why are you bashing Tzuyu
I'm so proud of Ningning 🥺
congrats ningning on debuting!
everytime sm announce a new gg and now that they already confirmed the members, i still kept on thinking that koeun, hina, herin, lami, jungyeon, yiyang and ningning were the ones that's gonna debut. although i am very happy much happy the a new smgg will debut, i can't help but to have a bitter feeling that only ningning was left. i have been watching and rooting for them especially for koeun because i wanna see more of her leadership. still, best of luck, aespa! i will just think that ningning holds the dreams of her friends who couldn't make it to the stage. in that way, i can feel or ease the bitterness that constantly crept in my heart
Ningning!!! She already had so much potential as a vocalist and now she's debuting in Aespa. So proud.
the line-up we'll never have :( thank you smrg15-19, thank you herin, thank you lami, thank you koeun, thank you jungyeon, thank you yiyang. we look forward to your debut, hina ❤
ningning too :))
I'm so proud of Ningning making in Aespa. She ain't positioned main vocalist for nothing 😭😭😭😭
Ningning is the only one who made it and stay till the end😭 i feel sad for my girls
Our NingNing is Super Talented Always💚💚
Sm never fails in their line distribution. They sound just like the original.
Lami will go down as the most hyped trainee who didn’t get to debut in the history of KPop
😭😭
I wanted her to debut so badly
Sm really produced a masterpiece with this song. I feel like crying everytime I hear this song 😭💖
Ningning's voice doesnt change at all
Did we lost everyone except ningning and hina? I cant believe SM did dirty to them.
Lami and Koeun still there tho
@@girlsredpinkbytaengsicseul3091 i heard the rumors that koeun and lami left… lami already made an instagram acc. Her name on Naver(?) already gone. I dont comfim about koeun tho :'(
@@helloangel7803 Hi. Yes, SMR20G just Updated that Lami & Koeun not on the list which only left Hina & Ningning in the Column at Naver.
There's two speculation:
1. They left SM for good
2. Both set to debut, and they erase their name.
Idk, but I wish them all the best tho 😔😊
koeun and lami didt get the final line up after.. 10 and 8 years spent training days at sm.. also koeun didnt finish her school.. it so sad..
What do you mean dirty？ Being a trainee doesn't mean you are 100% guarantee to debut. What happens if there is some hidden trainees who are better？ I feel sad when I heard Lami left but sometimes it can also be a personal decision to give up.
I'm proud of all of them especially NingNing🥺❤
Xu Yiyang being keeping up with her now through Chuang 2020 I hope she finally debuts, she is well rounded im glad that at least she signed with Tao company now that SM was just keeping it there 🙌🏻
Some are questioning the aespa lineup.
1) Ningning voice is the most outstanding than the other 5 smrookies
2) Winter vocal and technique is above the other 5 smrookies
3) Giselle is the best rapper than the smrookies (english speaker is a bonus, so she became the english speaker)
4) Karina not only serving visual and dancing but also her powerful vocal
Also lami is my fav visual but seeing her grow up, her face changed a lot (still beautiful but no longer as how she used to (eg: picture in the video), thus Lami often posted photo of her covering her face. She also used filters in her ig live saying she doesn’t feel confident in her face). I think Karina and Winter did surpass her current visual.
Anyways goodluck to all these former rookies. I have been supporting them for many years. All the best.
I'm sorry but yiyang and koeun visual are beautiful.. if they debut in the same group.. it will be amazing.. ps I stalked yiyang pictures her face so luxury..
Sorry but i find your comment hella rude. eventhough the rest of them not debut but one thing for sure, smngg bcm a hit and be "the waiting for" bcs of lami koeun hina and herin. The original one that sm show to public.
Smh this comment assumes the girls did not debut because aespa members are more talented/ deserving. I think most of these girls left before they decided aespa lineup and the reason they did not debut is not because of their talents and potential but because sm kept delaying it. Once announced smrookies you're supposed to be sure to debut because why would the company promote you to public? For fun? SM plans kept changing and they kinda got tired of waiting.. These girls and aespa members are all wonderful and no need to relate their reason of debuting/not debuting to each other.
You seem kinda biased in your comment... This video and many other videos of smrookies girls performing are 2++ years old and I'm sure they've improved so much more all these years but we just didn't get to witness their improvements bc SM barely released new content about them.
@@pringlespocari1522 LOL y'all are so delusional it's so clear they left because they DID NOT MAKE THE CUT no one in their right mind would leave SMs new GG if they were confirmed for thw lineup they left cause they got replaced period
닝닝이 지분봐...고음이랑 애드립 다 닝이가하는거 어쩔??태생부터 빼어난 닝이줘 보컬실력😍