Is South Africa's Operation Dudula xenophobic against migrants?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
- An anti-immigration movement continues to pick up steam in South Africa. Operation Dudula has its sights on several targets: from dirty cops to drug dealers. But most of all, the organisation wants undocumented migrants to get out of the country. But are protesters battling crime and unemployment? Or using the country's woes to promote a xenophobic agenda?
Guests:
Ike Khumalo
Operation Dudula Supporter
Andrew Whitfield
South African Shadow Minister of Police
Gareth Newham
Head of the Justice and Violence Prevention Programme at the Institute for Security Studies Africa
Subscribe: trt.world/TheNe...
Livestream: trt.world/ytlive
Facebook: / thenewsmakersontrtworld
Twitter: / the_newsmakers
Instagram: trt.world/insta...
Visit our website: trt.world
U need to be in south Africa to get the real truth about what is going on
Exactly and thank you
Oh getting stabbed everytime you get your paycheck
@@mcbarca Where you are from not SA
EXACTLY!
lol European are now doing their own xenophobic nonsense but no ine says a thing
Ike never disappoints 👏👏👏
The black guy has a point. It's simpluly impossible to document the number of undocumented foreigners. I think having ID checks through finger print is the best way to go. Only legal foreigners should be allowed.
👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
All countries, even western countries know exactly how many illegal immigrants are living in their countries. All countries have illegal immigrants.
@shanghaichica how Do you know if they're illegal ?
TRT needs to keep their western wokeness to themselves. South Africa is for South Africans. We don't need more immigrants. There are other countries that can take them. Has nothing to do with xenophobia. Also, if you want to emigrate to another country, you have to do so legally. Period.
So how can you tell who is legal and who isn't? Do you work for customs and immigration?
@@OfoeNelson Have you heard of things called "passport" and "work permit"?
@@tell-it-like-it-is8305 so you'll go around checking people's work permit and passport? Who gave you that authority? Who walks around and goes to work with their passport and work permit?
@@OfoeNelson I am simply explaining how immigration works in most countries. I don't have time to check everyone's passports, that's the job of South Africa immigration. You mean to tell me you don't even undestand how immigration works? Is something wrong with you? Get a life.
@@tell-it-like-it-is8305 He’s asking how do you know who is legal by just walking on the street that’s what he meant
The Europeans are playing a double game here
Thank you Khumalo
IKE KHUMALO🙏🙏🙏
I wonder why Nigeria go to South Africa 😂😂😂 let South Africa eat their land
Someone has to stand up for the interest of the poor South Africans.
Thank Ike salute 🙏👏
The white guy must stop talking on South African affairs period
Like it or not, he is right!
Why are these privileged Caucasians talking about matters that affect Africans? Yeses naga e ke masepa hela.
its just obvious that they have medical aid and do not have a problem with service delivery. so they just dont care about ordinary south africans
@@dalegoldsmith4342so the reason why millions of people in SA don’t have access to pipped water, stable electricity or decent housing is caused by a couple of hundred thousand immigrants.
@@shanghaichica there are more than 10 million of African migrants in SA
Bullshxt!@@thabangtladi8057
"Nobody frees anybody. People free themselves or they are not free "--Eusi Kwayana.
The black person is not given enough time to finish what he is saying.
The black Guy is A Real Patriot
It's a pity South African media like ENCA, Mail & Guardian, and News24 are failing to cover this issue as objectively.
Ike seemed a bit emotional at times however he raises valid points. The statistics the other guests mention are not reliable as the topic is mainly concerning undocumented/illegal immigrants, the fact that the minister of home affairs admitted that South Africa has an illegal immigration problem should be proof enough that Operation Dudula is raising a valid concern.
International viewers won't realise this but the vast majority of white people in South Africa are less affected by the influx of illegal immigrants because white South Africans do not live in the inner Cities or the Townships that these foreign nationals are occupying.
Andrew and Gareth are out of touch with the reality most black South Africans are facing, I would wager that both haven't set foot in Johannesburg CBD, Pretoria CBD, or Durban CBD lately hence they are relying on fabricated statistics.
Also bare in mind that Andrew is a politician from the opposition party, he didn't offer any tangible solutions other than pointing the finger at the current ruling party which we all know is incompetent.
As a South African, I can confirm that we do have an immigration crisis and a failing government. South Africans are not xenophobic, we just want immigrants to respect the laws of our country (although even our politicians don't care for our laws).
From my understanding, countries such as Australia, Canada, USA, Italy, Morocco etc have much stricter immigration laws but there's no outrage from Human Rights groups when those stricter laws are implementated.
On the contrary, I think the key issue is that white people will be the *most* disadvantaged.
They won’t have access to 100r/day hard labourers at the robots who they can use to build their high rises and the cheapest cost possibly cost; employing immigrant domestic workers at below minimum wage to be their all in one household chef , au pair, midwife and personal assistant wrapped into one; gardeners; Airbnb hosts/butlers; WAITERS… etc etc.
Cheap labour.
Always follow the money.
100% behind you. these privileged people will never understand or feel the cries of black people. they are the minority and we dont care about their opinions, forward dudula.
SABC is worse
This DA guy is talking rubbish!
To sell vegetables in the streets of Johannesburg and working to domestic jobs and working to retail shops and restaurants. South african government is a disgrace.
I disagree with the lawyer. The accusations are unfounded. Poverty gives birth to crimes. I think they should focus on their government and not the immigrants to make laws and enforce them. Immigrants is not SA problem but their government.
" lawyer...?" did you write ? A contradiction of fella.
Somebody with basic education does not stoke such hysteria on foreigners unless of course Hitler, Mao, Leopold's.
Hatred consumes all ur thinking capacity
then like an animal -- ( your only able to target the low hanging fruit).
poverty does give birth to crime...but not in this case. this is a huge problem that the government was surposed to take care of. so obviously if the government does not have intrest in puting south africa first. the people will govern
The immigrants should also go back to their own countries and focus on their own government so that SAcn can also do the same without carrying Africa's burden. South Africans are not immigrant's problems but their leaders who makes them uncomfortable back home are their main problem
True❤
This country is literally 60% run by mini bus gangs😂😂😂😂
thanks ike khumalo you hittin the facts!! these other guys always hide behind the truth with thier fancy words. they have nice jobs,medical aid,nice houses. they wouldnt understand the daily reality south africans face
The struggle you are facing is because of poor government. Not immigrants.
There was never a prostitute in SA before 1994.
😂😂😂
I'm from neighbouring Namibia but I've never been called a foreigner cause I'm white 💀
This man has to much anger
He gets emotional because people dnt want to face simple facts his raising instead dey bizi making useless excuses I get where Ike comes from his right 💯 percent
salute Ike
Thanks ike khumalo
Yes Mr IKE
Dudula means push... Not force out
There's an immigration crisis in South Africa and it's needs to be sorted ASAP
There are 15 million immigrants in SA
ou guys need to leave, I know it's not right but South Africa does not feel like our South Africa anymore. That's why my people are behaving like this, it's the disrespect you guys have for us, I had Nigerian, Somalia and Zimbabwean guys who had disrespected me ( just because I choose to have romantic relationships with South Africans only. I love my country but you need to go
Dudula means to push away
They must stop use xenophobia when we speak about the crisis caused by foreigners in this country
The crisis is caused by your country. You don’t have a 40% unemployment rate because of immigrants. You are not the rape capital of the world because of immigrants. You don’t have such high rates of murder due to immigrants. The majority of people are not living in poverty and in informal housing because of immigrants. You need to hold your government accountable not blame the issues of millions of SA’s on a few thousand immigrants.
Those foreigners are not registered
you don't know what yu are talkin about wena
Thank you Ike may God bless you
ENCOURAGE THE SA TO ADOPT CHINA AND UK CCTV STYLE. FOR EXAMPLE : CCTV THAT IS MONITORED 24/7 and police and security guards . Communicating with the CCTV CONTROL ROOM. HAS REDUCED CRIME IN UK. Austealia and Ghana.
The focus of the reviews are the prevention of personal and property crime.
This summary draws primarily on one meta-analytic review (Review one). Review one included 76 studies which used police and/or hospital records (for example, data on accident and emergency department admissions) to examine the effectiveness of CCTV in reducing crime.
The majority of studies in Review one were carried out in the UK (34 studies) and the USA (24 studies). The remaining studies were conducted in a range of other countries, including Canada, South Korea, Sweden, Norway, Spain, Poland and Australia.
Operation Dudula is right, but misguided. They should hold their government accountable. Because the government is mandated to secure all boarders and ensure that all or most people coming in the country are legally recognized. The main job of police is to keep law and order. Take the anger and frustration to your government
Whilst we wait for the government to. Do something we must what sit back and enjoy being terrorized by foreigners? We will fight back until govt gets their house in order.. We are not livestock we are humans with kids and families.
Malema said they must come to South Africa illegally and so be criminals
South Africans should hold their government accountable and the rest of the African continent should just runaway from their own oppressive selfish dictatorial goverments and tell SAcn what and how to run their own country when their own hopeless zoo called countries are falling apart
No Dudula marginalising foreign nationals, inflicting violence and intimidating them
The black guy did law in a public toilet
he is more intelligent than you
@@africantraveller8303 that's a burn🤣😂
He’s just spouting off all the crap that he’s been indoctrinated with. It’s sad that the people are so uneducated that they would not stop and think about what’s being said and if it actually makes any sense.
@@africantraveller8303 nah the black guy is not intelligent at all, he's just angry.
Thankyou Ike you are our Hero more especial talking about Chinese
No they are not
Long live Ike long live you are a Brave man tell this people the truth
Shadow minister of police, your police are not doing their job.go to any Taxi rank or bus terminus and you will find foreigners brazenly dealing with drugs and have a strong relationship with police
I am an African American retiree researching where to invest my retirement funds to start a large Farmstead, South Africa was top on my list closely followed by Kenya, after watching these xenophobic videos, I am really scared. This is scary for investors who want to create Jobs. My farmstead would have been quite a good investment for South Africa.
Come to Zambia...get in touch we make it happen, Zambia has lots of opportunities for investors especially in the agric sector...I'm in the agric sector and can help you get started or do a partnership if you are interested in setting up in Zambia
yeah Nigeria is alright you create jobs there
Black Africans non Americans don't quality for migration to begin with? We attracting skills not charity cases, that's why Africa should not bother applying. When we change this governments the "African non Americans" will be first to be deported, Africa is not in South Africa genius so take your pan African Communism to CAR it's simple
Gooooood go to Nigeria we re organising
It is impossible to debate someone unable to engage with empirical evidence. Don't waste your time. Allow Ike to stay ignorant and hateful!
IKE, FACTS DON'T CARE ABOUT YOUR FEELINGS
This DA GUY IS ONLY CONCERNED ABOUT ANC'S FAILUES. HE CARES A HOOD ABOUT POOR BLACK PEOPLE'S PLIGHT. Thus is the good reason Black people in SA shouldn't vote for DA
White people feel that in order to become rich, they must exploit others. The apartheid government achieved success economically because it utilized cheap black labor. Because we all have equal rights, white South african choose to hire undocumented immigrants in order to perpetuate exploitation.
The Anchor!!! 💪🏿
I'm 100% behind Operation Dudula
South Africa are very weak by calling Nigeria and Somalia.and this is distraction South Africa need to take their land back
Land issue is very interesting. I always wonder why people who own land end emmigrating , seeking better life in other countries ?
I wish and pray southt africa will be smart regarding this issue. People need to acquire skills eg farming skills.
Africa is the headquarters of poverty yet we own land . Why ????
Statistics are a scam 😢
They don't want truth
Dr Mg Buthelezi spoke a lot about all these things happening in this crime.
No it is not xenophobic
Pakistani mafia lol
We didn't a single problem in Africa with crime before the invasions, colonization, all our problems came with them
Ike is just ignorant. He acts like he is uneducated.
Ike is is probably far more educated than you by the way i am judging from your comment. theres a difference between being ignorant and speaking the reality truth. Ike chose to speak the language of the people, these whiet people that are being interviewed with Ike are just Hiding behind the truth with big fancy comments of words. those white people may be educated but they are being unfair because they choose not to walk a mile in a ordinary south africans shoes.
Anger in him
31.5.23
One person is incoherent here. This can't be normal.
Those whites were really professional and reasonable.
no they are not reasonable but they benefit a lot from illegall foreigners by exploiting them.
True
Rubbish platform
ya hei foreigners will hate you for not wanting them in their dream land SA😅🤣
The people know who is affecting and disturbing the community, the talking heads defend not holding the lawbreakers accountable. It has always been this way. Diversity is our strength they tell us as the world empties its prisons and mental hospitals into our country through Mexico.
"Firstly, the issue of crime should be addressed and dealt with effectively. Crime is a problem that exists in various societies around the world, and it is not unique to any particular country or region. South Africa has the highest number of gender-based violence cases in the world, and these crimes are committed by South Africans and not foreigners. The ongoing case of the accused murderer named Bafana Mahungela is an example, And it is concerning that a significant number of South Africans are supporting this individual.
95% of the prisoners in South African prisons are South Africans.
It is crucial to focus on implementing strong law enforcement, promoting community safety, and ensuring justice for all individuals, regardless of their nationality or background.
Africa will unite with or without South Africa, and South Africa can go unite with Europe or whoever it pleases and see how that goes."
And please remember that a whole province, the Western Cape, is about to be taking away from you. and it is not due to the black foreigners.
We need a Pan African Curriculum to elevate the consciousness of Africans in Africa and in the diaspora. Doing that will ensure that the new generation of African leaders don't loose focus and the concept of Pan Africanism. Further, such a mass re-education program will create more critical , conscientious voices and will ensure sustainable critical mass of intellectual mind base.
Africa is 51 countries so take your pan African Communism to the Central Africa Republic... South Africa has a right to sovereignty and Africa is not a continent it's a country part of the continent!
Why are these whytez are clueless.
LAX obunete retlo bantsa ka kgang mosuthafrica omongwe leomongwe gagabo
99 % of them live in abuslte poverty most black south african live in disgusting condition in shak house
Tsek TRT
So this lawyer is just spewing lies and saying blanket generalizations about foreigners but didn't see that as xenophobic? Lol ...
You must ask Andrew why are the Farm murders is and who is the farm murders? Why are the no evidence of fingerprints after famers are killed? Keep on protecting illegal immigrants, you farmers going to keep on dying..
What is xenophobia in Zulu don't elaborate in English.
Care batle matswa ntle bicus babolaya Nana barons keko pagore way cavarmente yarona egana kamatswantle gabuwe nnete Gore waye batlola ntwa setshsba he bare gaba banyake otswanetse gutlwela setshsba
Graham lies 🤣🤣 we invite everyone to a fact finding mission, nobody will comment or influence you.
Modern day Slavery is the topic nobody wants to touch in South Africa.
We have adequate resources and the guests must never mislead.
Check the number of schools, hospitals, clinics , police stations and the millions of social housing units built by Gov since 1994. We have the momentum but gov will fail 10/10 times when uncontrolled movement happens.
Infrastructure is built from tax base and sensus.
All the BS hurts the legal foreigner the most.
South Africa need to cut ties with African countries they don't want in their country and watch South Africa economy destroyed
MTN of South Africa make tens of billions of dollars every year in Nigeria and so do 100s of South African companies in Nigeria these funds they send back to SA
only 24k of Nigerians live in SA and most high professionals smallscale entrepreneurs and quite few number engaged in illegal activities yet this ike came on TV with his hatred and anger problem castigated Nigerians
force your government to end relations with Nigeria
You talking rubbish, there are more than 2 million of Nigerians living in SA and we want them all deported back to their hopeless zoo called Nigeria
Much love to Lux, but down with dudula xenophobic organization
@ kudzu munetsi There's nothing xenophobic about refusing to host unskilled, illegal immigrants. Unskilled South Africans are not entering neighboring African countries illegally in large numbers.
The black guy did law in a public toilet 😂
whilst your mother was busy giving birth in the bushes like an animal coz of lack of health care facilities back home
Who finance operation dudula i think is FBI or CIA
It is funded by the citizens of South Africans
Lmao
ike khumalo unamanga
Whites are playing a game here Ike correct
Uwena onamanga u Ike uqinisile thula uma ungazi
@@bonizandwalane1538 look if you don't know the broader game then just keep quiet the colonialist are employing that foreign garbage in our country so, what exactly I'm I wrong about ?
What about Kurds of turkey? They have been continuously and brutally oppressed by the Turkish state since 1923
Ask your fellow white south African ELON MUSK to help you with ideas to make money .💡💰🪙💳💸💲💎♟♦️♣️♥️😆