I think they are still kind of young. It wasnt until my mid 30s before I accepted that it was ok to feel things. It was during my reading of The Wheel of Time, I started feeling things alot and talked to a friend about it, and he told me "yeah, youre feeling emotions... like a human." As a 6'2 grown ass man in his 30s. Its ok to cry, its ok to feel things. Its not a sign of weakness. Opening myself to my emotions and not just blocking them out has made me enjoy life much much more.
Seeing this in IMAX was an unforgettable experience. I dont know what the comments have said, but for the spinning part, earlier in the movie, they're on the outer edge, think hamster wheel. It spins to imitate earth's gravity. Kacee's face when Anthony realizes he's the one who pushes the bookcase lol, such satisfaction haha. Seems like watching a reaction of a reaction is just as satisfying as watching the initial reaction hahaha. Kacee you need to do more reactions where you saw something and Anthony didnt! That expression you have when Anthony realizes or figures something out! lol
I didn’t get to see it in IMAX but I’ve found out a couple of weeks ago that they’ve actually been doing a once a year screening every year since it’s release at the BFI IMAX in London and if they’re still showing it next year, i am seriously thinking about booking a 2h and 50m train journey from Manchester to London to watch this!
Thanks, I saw it in IMAX too. I had left across the country to get another job and left all my friends, family, coworkers behind. Coop leaving earth hit me very hard.
"It's not possible, Coop!" "No, it's necessary." This has got to be one of the best lines I've ever heard delivered when considering the moment it was delivered in. Just, wow. Goosebumps.
Basically, the "gravity problem" is how do you get mass humanity off earth. In order to understand and therefore solve gravity, they needed to see inside a black hole because this is where gravity is crazy next level so they can get the required level of information needed to solve the problem. Love the reaction and love you guys!
Just to add to what @Ricky said, Matt Damon explained that they needed to see inside a black hole to get the data needed to unify the theory of gravity with the theory of relativity. Once they did that, they could figure out how to control gravity to lift those space stations they were building (in the nasa headquarters!) into space to eventually get humanity to the new planet.
@@craigharris41 You mean an O-Neill Cylinder and there are already ideas about quantum gravity that connect general relativity and quantum physics, one is Superstring Theory/M-Theory, the other being Quantum Loop Gravity
Interstellar is one of the greatest sci-fi movies ever made. This movie genuinely contributed to the scientific community, they actually got 2 research papers published about this. When Christopher Nolan was working on this movie rather than have an “artist’s concept” of what a black hole would look like he worked with a physicist named Kip Thorne and asked him how black holes work. So Kip gave him a bunch of maths, they sent the math to the VFX team, they put it in their render engine (which is far more powerful and expensive than anything that exists in the community) and what it produced was completely unexpected. They knew that a black hole would have what’s known as an accretion disc, but what they didn’t expect as this weird halo effect around it. The VFX team thought it was a bug so they sent it to Kip and he both confirmed that that’s what it would look like and was surprised on how well it looked. This is what a black hole would look like because the gravity is so powerful that it’s pulling light from the other side and causing you to see a second halo because you are seeing the other side of the black hole. And the time dilation is 100% accurate. If you are near something with a strong gravitational pull like a planet larger than earth or a black hole your “clock”, meaning your time, will run slower than on earth. I’m still surprised that 8 years later no one else has used that in a sci-fi movie or tv show.
Calm down. Nolan was greatly inspired by the anime "Voices from a Distant Star" from 2002 and copied key concepts (like time running slower/faster on earth) from that anime for Interstellar. Just like he also copied the anime Paprika for Inception.
Can't remember what doco it was, the guy said if you take off from and go around a strong enough gravity source, you can make it back in time to see yourself leaving
I gotta say, I have a lot of empathy for Doctor Mann. His actions are reprehensible and rightfully unforgivable by most viewers, but they're also deeply human and understandable. Very, very few people would choose differently than he did if they found themselves in his situation.
@@joaobelezo I mean, yes. He's reprehensible and his actions are unforgivable...like I said. My point is, you're genuinely fooling yourself if you - or 99.9% of the human race - think you'd act differently in his shoes. It's so, so easy to call him a coward from the comfort of a warm home. Signing up to die, on Earth, with your colleagues, emboldened by the respect from and for those closest to you, is 100% easier to do than ACTUALLY dying, alone, slowly, one breath at a time, on an alien planet that not only serves as a total reminder of the failure of your work in the mission. That kind of misery would easily break almost anyone.
@@quegs If I was in his shoes, I would just kill myself rather than die slowly or DOOM THE ENTIRE SPECIES TO A HOT DEATH ON EARTH. There is no justification for how far he went in his selfishness, and it's really not as common as you think it is to be a slimy turd. Sorry man, the indomitable human spirit is made of tougher stuff than that. I truly hope if it came down to it, you wouldn't make the same mistakes.
@@joaobelezo That's a very easy thing to say. I've lost count on how many times the best of people become the "worst" when faced with a life or death situation.
All of the old people at the beginning except the old version of Murph were not actors. They were clips from the Ken Burns documentary on the great American dust bowl so they actually lived through what they are talking about.
Ive watched thousands of movies. This is the only one that brings tears to my eyes whenever I watch it. Cooper and Murph's relationship is one of the most beautiful relationships in cinema history.
Something that was not obvious to me at first is that, the space stations near Saturn in the end - the reason they’re near Saturn is that they’re preparing to pass through the wormhole and go to Brand’s planet to reunite all that survives of humanity. And that’ll be the society that evolves into the 5-dimensional future humans. I was hung up on whether the future humans came from the space stations or Brand’s population bomb; then I realized it’s both, united.
The population bomb would not be necessary, since the rest of humanity is on the way. Plus, Brand would barely have gotten anywhere with the infrastructure to grow and support a bunch of newborn humans before contact was reestablished with her.
The "information" that he sent through the watch was the quantum data needed to solve the equation of gravity. Once solved, they are able to manipulate gravity to the point where they can transport the entire NASA building they were working in, into space as a type of space station. Therein taking all that is left of humanity off the earth all at once and travel through space. At least that's what I interpreted.
It's not the NASA building. It's any object they wish to sent into space. People, fuel, equipment etc all weigh a lot. So the manipulation was required to send anything up.
@@bedinor yes obviously, I thought it was clear by my breakdown that I didn't mean the equation was just to know how to move that very specific building. I only mentioned the building to tie it in cause it was mentioned in the movie. If they can move something as large as that entire building obviously they can move anything else they wish.
I still love the Irony of Matt Damon explaining why they had to keep the fact that Plan A was a ruse because "humanity needed to work together to save the species instead of themselves" and him almost ruining everything because he wanted to save himself lol
The fact that Dr. Brendt was right in all of this and they should have gone to Edmund's planet is just crazy. Maybe if they'd go straight there, they would't have to lose so many years, but it would also mean the end of a movie straight there :D Great movie, great cast! I also loved the cast for Murph, from a child to an old lady she just felt the same exact person. Mind blowing movie.
If they had gone straight there they wouldn't have gotten the information from the black hole to send back to Earth. Everything worked out as it was supposed to.
But then again, if they went there first and all was hunky dory, would Cooper still go to the black hole instead of just back to earth (and thus never solving the problem).
0:14 Should definitely watch The Prestige and any of Nolan's films you guys haven't watched yet. Memento is one of his earliest films but also one of his best.
For that dust storm in the beginning of the movie, they actually did drop dumploads of sand just outside the filming location, and had industrial fans blow it around in order to create a realistic dust storm and avoid bad fog-like CGI.
Interesting fun fact about this movie. Christopher Nolan planted that cornfield (500 acres) for the movie, turned around, and sold it to a farmer for a profit. All because he didn't want to have a CGI farm.
Mathematical formulas about the nature of gravity. The sheer mass of the space station could not reach escape velocity without manipulating gravity. Amazing film
I love this movie. Scientifically, it is one of the most accurate movies and portrayals of science there are. Director Christopher Nolan, of the Christian Bale Batman movies, consulted one of the foremost theoretical astrophysicists available, Kip Thorne, to make sure the science was as accurate as possible. In fact, Kip had suggested a few changes to the plot as the original script got some of the science wrong. So, Nolan, at Kip's behest, changed nearly all of those parts to keep with the science. The only part he did NOT change was the upside down ice mountains on that second world. Kip said that the gravity of the planet would have made those ice formations so high up nearly impossible. However, they were kept in. Nevertheless, everything else in the movie is as accurate as possible. The gravity equations that were being worked on back on Earth, were real equations used by scientists, namely astrophysicists. The tesseract near the end, inside the singularity, was based on what theoretical physicists believed it would look like. The black hole depiction was based on real mathematical models of what one would look like up close. They plugged in those models and equations, and viola, that's what we got. There is a nearly one-hour documentary, called "The Science of Interstellar", that was available on DVD and BluRay purchases of this movie. There is another documentary narrated by Kip Thorne that expounds in further detail the science. You can also watch both of them here on YT. Here are the links. ruclips.net/video/Sv9WzXekSiw/видео.html and ruclips.net/video/lM-N0tbwBB4/видео.html
Fun fact, this was the first realistic rendered image of a black hole. The scientific advisor Kip Thorne is an astrophysicist and was responsible for a research paper that basically simulated what a black hole would actually look like, particularly how it has that halo that show's its own reflection behind it by bending the light so much. The numbers showed thats what it would look like, but they turned to the movie industry for the most powerful cgi rendering computers in the world to actually show US what it would look like. And then just a few years after, we got the actual first HD photograph of a black hole, and it looks just like its depicted here
What I like about this movie is that it goes into topics such as time dilation which are totally real things and not made up fiction. As Einstein said, time is relative. There are two ways time dilation can occur. Moving at fast speeds (only close to light speed would it become noticeable to humans without instruments) and the path this movie explored, gravity wells. The faster you move or the closer you are to a gravity well the slower your time moves relative to the outside observer. In theory this applies to all types of speeds and gravity wells it just that these differences are so incredibly tiny that no one notices them, but your feet which are closer to earth gravity well are a tiny tiny tiny tiny bit younger than your head and if you fly with a plane you fly a tiny tiny tiny tiny bit into the future. Satellites that whiz around the earth actually need to take this into account and compensate by having their onboard clock slowed down by ~ 45 microseconds per day.
The information they got from the black hole helped them control gravity, that's how the space ship was a cylinder and how the baseball went up instead of down, this showed humanity got advanced enough to get off planet and move across the universe, because of the mastery of gravity
I think that they would eventually bring the people from the stations to the planet they found, set up a new home base for humanity. Love this movie, it is one of my top 3 for sure.
Among all the crazy things in astrophysics, understanding time dilation is quite simple: 1. All objects move forward though time. 2. All massive objects cause you to move less in time but more in space (i.e. pull you in). It's like if these objects drag you and slow you down in the timeline, while all other objects in the universe keep moving through time at their normal speeds. 3. But the ratio is astronomically crazy. People on Earth have time dilation of a minuscule fraction of a millisecond per year. We can actually measure this time dilation by comparing clocks on Earth and clocks on space satellites (GPS, for example). 4. To get something crazy like 7 years per hour you need to be in vicinity of an extremely massive object, like a supermassive black hole (which unlike regular black holes absorbed masses of thousands if not millions of stars). The quality physics in Interstellar is quite impressive actually. Nolan invited Gav Thorpe to do the math, and during his calculations he predicted the actual look of black holes, as a black sphere that has an accretion disk which its image is stretched all around (above and below) it because of gravitational lensing. This was never done before, and all black holes in previous movies looked different from what it actually should look like. And this rendered image based on real math, made for Interstellar, later coincided with the actual images of the black hole at the center of the Milky Way, which we obtained years later.
Coop is travelling back through the wormhole to live, grow old and die with Brand on the very late, lamented Wolf Edmonds' planet, which is fortunately habitable and will eventually be colonised by other humans. The information Tars was able to learn from direct observation from within a black hole allowed Murph to finally complete professor Brands gravity calculations back on earth and therefore launch and operate the ark ships they had already built, saving the remainder of humanity, instead of abandoning them to their fate on a dying earth.
I'm sure I wont be the first one to point this out, but my favorite part about Interstellar is the lengths they went through in an attempt to be as accurate as possible to the underlying physics. As a astrophysics undergrad (working towards my Ph.d.) with a special love for black holes/event horizons, this movie made me happy in ways most sci-fi fails to replicate. Loved your reaction!!!!
Great reaction! This movie means so much to me, I remember watching it every day for a week when it came out, with my mom, with my girlfriend, and with everyone I could find. I was in the middle of my undergrad in physics back then and I was feeling like giving up, this movie gave me the push to the finish. A bit of info about your last comments: what doctor Mann meant with "solve gravity" was to find a way to harness gravity and use it to allow large-scale space travel. The problem with that is that you need data from very strong gravitational objects... black holes, which is what was sent using the clock and allowed Murph to finally figure out how to use gravity (I imagine that created enough scientific breakthroughs to build the big spaceship/colony). Well-known fact: the image of the black hole was modeled using real physics!
what did you think of gravity travelling through space and time from Superstring Theory and M Theory? I have a theory that gravity could be both gravitons which correlates to quantum loop gravity, but also connecting dark energy and dark matter with gravity, as dark energy is an expansive force, and if it can expand in all directions from more than one point, it would also be the compressive force of gravity. The theory also uses string/m-theory, and connects to ideas like Nassim Haramein's fractal universe, Stephen Hawking's zero-energy universe and could include Garrett Lisi's particle geometry.
I honestly don't know how you didn't cry at least once. I have seen it a few times and because it was the 10th anniversary i saw it the other day again in the cinema and i still couldn't stop crying 😂
Notice how Conaughey's character is leaning his head into the direction of the rotation, while Hathaway's character doesn't. This would help him stay conscious, as it's a lot easier to be subjected to positive G-forces rather than negative G-forces. Also the difference from the center of rotation would make a huge difference, and iirc Conaughey's character is sitting in the inner most seat. :)
I watched this movie in the movie theater back when I was like a freshman in high school, and I absolutely loved it I cried in the theater man ❤. One of if not my favorite movie of all time 🐐
Same here. I had to leave my friends, family, coworkers for a new job and saw this in the theater. Covid hit and it was even more likely I would never see anyone I knew again.
The reason Cooper didn’t black out during the docking spin is because he leaned WITH it. Brand blacked out because she leaned against it and tried to fight the spin.
I know why he left because of the “a parent shouldn’t have to watch their kids pass” thing, but I always thought it was funny how he walks in and to all her relatives it’s like wow it’s our matriarchs father who made possible the salvation of humanity…cool nice 30 second reunion ok bye now 👋😂
This is probably my favorite Nolan movie. I think Coop just went to be with Brand. He wasn't planning on bringing her back to the station. The tesseract was pretty cool and the future human knew that he will do it, because it's already happened. I like Anthony's reaction to Matt Damon, because that's what I thought, but him going nuts caught me off guard. The information that was sent through the watch was a variable that Murph and old man Brand needed to solve the problem of gravity to get that station off of Earth.
I saw this during a metaphysics class in college. I swear it gave me such an existential crisis when i had the thought of us being the ghosts for someone else. What if our existence is solely to propel someone else?
I would hate if that were true, because I did some embarassing stuff in my private moment imagine someone ghosts were there watching you did all of that 😅
Often in religion and human metaphysics we say there's a purpose for us. There's a reason we exist. But rarely do people want to hear that maybe your reason to exist was to just throw a piece of paper out one day, and that piece of paper goes to a landfill, where it grows bacteria, which causes a new strain of disease, which is then used for ______. We'd like to think that maybe it'll be something big, but we don't get to see that. But maybe yes. All you were meant to do, is press this one button somewhere, that's it. No grandiose explanation. No big picture.
I mean the usual interpretation of ghosts are people that have passed on, among them our relatives. And yes, each generation of humanity "should" be better than the previous one. Just like you should be better than your parents and your kids better than you. But human pride and greed prevents much of this unfortunately.
The whole point of the "crack gravity"'s equation thingy was to build that technology. Getting things to space is HARD because of gravity. If you somehow can manipulate gravity, then it isn't hard. That's how you get EVERYONE off planet. Also, for inception: The spinning top is his wife's totem. Not his. Therefore if you truly want to know whether or not he is awake, pay attention to his wedding ring. When he is in a dream, he has it on. When he is awake, he doesn't.
He was going to Anne Hathaway, and she's the new "Eve", he's the new "Adam". And their descendants would one day be the humans that evolved far enough to transcend dimensions, and would one day send back the information needed for humans to escape earth, which would help his children go to them to join them and and prosper, hopefully, as part of the future humans ancestors. Time being linear is no longer a thing. Space is no longer a thing. Only gravity, and maybe love was able to travel backwards. And what's a massive amount of gravity/mass in a single spot? A black hole. That was them sending back to their ancestors what they needed to have happened in order for them to be. And they are.
The stories of the old people…are actual survivors from our own Dust Bowl..from Oklahoma and Kansas up to Canada..about Nov.29, 1929..through mid to late 1938..dates that parallel our Great Depression..prolonged drought dried up crops in the Midwest to Canada..years without rain..created land erosion which brought the wind and dust storms..my family lived in Kansas..my mom was 10..the same age probably as the people talking..
I love this movie so much. I went in not knowing what to expect and ended up bawling my eyes out because of Murph and Cooper's struggles to re-unite. It's such a beautiful film, in many more ways than one. I get that it's not for everyone, but that's okay.
If you Google 'dust bowl', you'll see that dust storms wiped out the agriculture of Kansas, Oklahoma, and Northern Texas, during the depression, just like the storms in the movie. Poor agricultural practices led to over grazing and depletion of topsoil and the locals were referred to as dirt farmers. This led to a mass exodus, generally to California where there was a booming agricultural industry. But California could not absorb the influx of people, leading to tent cities and horribly unsanitary conditions. John Steinbeck wrote of this time in his novel, The Grapes of Wrath. My mother was born into this, in California, and her family eventually returned to Oklahoma, poorer than before, and became share croppers, fighting to turn the land back into a sustainable farm. Dust storms on my grandma's farm were still a major problem when I visited as a kid.
Evan as "just" a stepdad, the scene of Cooper witnessing his daughter's death crushes me. Driven home by the thought that this could actually, according to the laws of physics as we currently understand them, could actually happen, makes it so poignant.
48:50 A black hole's singularity is highly theoretical. We have ideas but nothing close to something measurable. TARS was able to take data readings of the singularity and they were able to transmit the data to the watch.
Well even the movie never showed what that Singularity actually looks like. The Tesseract region Cooper was in to transmit information across time was probably situated in some tangent topography within the black hole but not quite at the singularity itself. The Tesseract is like a machine using the black hole as energy to power itself. To my bleak perception the Singularity is a really dense overlapping of every possible dimensions of spacetime tangled into each other like a tight knot of lace....but constantly un-knotting & re-knotting itself. When you tie a knot the surrounding fabric also gets pulled creating tension towards the knot...that's how i see why gravity well of black hole is so strong.
Christopher Nolan's new movie is Oppenheimer. Seeing a trailer of a Christopher Nolan movie about J. Robert Oppenheimer right before Avatar 2. I was not ready for today.
The “halo like” spaceship at the end was supposed to be the revelation that humans solved gravity. Like Michael caines character was trying to solve. And the end was, like you said, supposed to be him going to her planet. roll credits. Great film. 💯
@Joseph D. "by the time youve returned, i will have solved the problem of gravity." i only said it was a ship because the covazos referred to it as a ship. SiMMER DOWN SPORT.
My favorite is still his first big movie, Memento! A serial killer, used as a serial killer, but doesn't know he's a serial killer, so he's completely innocent! But this movie...if u don't cry, u have no soul!!
It was the answer to the gravity equation he got from the black hole singularity that allowed Murph to harness gravity to get a space station of the size needed to evacuate earth
Let's GOOOOO This and "The Thing 1982" were up there for "when are they going to react to these?" lol Highly recommend John Carpentar's "They Live", go in blind, trust me.
He was going back through the wormhole to go to her planet. The space station was on its way to the wormhole to get everyone from earth to that planet that they found.
i have a SSD called "post apocalypse ssd" it's a size of a fluid lighter, easy to pocket. basically it's a data capsule. in which i have stored family and friends pictures some documents and movies, series which i would never get bored watching. interstellar was the first movie to be part of my PA-SSD storage. i might have watched this movie more than 30 times by now.
BTW, in inception, leo's piece was actually his wedding ring, the spinning top was his wifes, so yes he was in the real world. and YES please watch all the chris nolan films
God is every Dallas cowgirls fan this dimwitted? I first watched this movie when I was like 16-17 and understood almost the whole movie the first time I watched it.
29:23 look carefully there is a landscape behind the hole. because what they staying on is not actually a ground level but another leyer of frozen gas. i think there is another shot like this on landing but didn't show in this video. also at the end. it's kinda one way trip. the only reason he survive blackhole is they bring him back to solar system.
![CHILE vs. BRASIL [1-2] | RESUMEN | ELIMINATORIAS SUDAMERICANAS | FECHA 9](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5ObJt_71AYc/mqdefault.jpg)
Watch the full-length watch-a-long reaction to this movie on Patreon: www.patreon.com/posts/interstellar-76086308
I never thought u guys would drop a reaction on this zimmer & Nolan's masterpiece
Watch "Life" staring Ryan Reynolds and "Cloverfield Paradox". Plus "Predators"💡👍
Prestige is a good one
Yes we want Casey to react to the prestige 🎅🎄👍
I can’t trust anyone who doesn’t cry when watching this movie
This movie KILLS me every time I watch it.
That's silly.
maybe they are machines lol
@@theencryptedpartition4633 All the more reason not to trust them then,
I think they are still kind of young. It wasnt until my mid 30s before I accepted that it was ok to feel things. It was during my reading of The Wheel of Time, I started feeling things alot and talked to a friend about it, and he told me "yeah, youre feeling emotions... like a human." As a 6'2 grown ass man in his 30s. Its ok to cry, its ok to feel things. Its not a sign of weakness. Opening myself to my emotions and not just blocking them out has made me enjoy life much much more.
Seeing this in IMAX was an unforgettable experience. I dont know what the comments have said, but for the spinning part, earlier in the movie, they're on the outer edge, think hamster wheel. It spins to imitate earth's gravity. Kacee's face when Anthony realizes he's the one who pushes the bookcase lol, such satisfaction haha. Seems like watching a reaction of a reaction is just as satisfying as watching the initial reaction hahaha. Kacee you need to do more reactions where you saw something and Anthony didnt! That expression you have when Anthony realizes or figures something out! lol
I seen this in IMAX when it came out, and ill agree with you. It truly was an unforgettable experience
Seeing this in imax was glorious, probably the best theater experience ever for me
Im so jealous you got to see this IMAX!
I didn’t get to see it in IMAX but I’ve found out a couple of weeks ago that they’ve actually been doing a once a year screening every year since it’s release at the BFI IMAX in London and if they’re still showing it next year, i am seriously thinking about booking a 2h and 50m train journey from Manchester to London to watch this!
Thanks, I saw it in IMAX too. I had left across the country to get another job and left all my friends, family, coworkers behind. Coop leaving earth hit me very hard.
"It's not possible, Coop!"
"No, it's necessary."
This has got to be one of the best lines I've ever heard delivered when considering the moment it was delivered in. Just, wow. Goosebumps.
Basically, the "gravity problem" is how do you get mass humanity off earth. In order to understand and therefore solve gravity, they needed to see inside a black hole because this is where gravity is crazy next level so they can get the required level of information needed to solve the problem. Love the reaction and love you guys!
Just to add to what @Ricky said, Matt Damon explained that they needed to see inside a black hole to get the data needed to unify the theory of gravity with the theory of relativity. Once they did that, they could figure out how to control gravity to lift those space stations they were building (in the nasa headquarters!) into space to eventually get humanity to the new planet.
"crazy next level" accurate measurement created by Ricky ladies and gentlemen lol
@@zumasa9991 Haha ikr, I was trying not to get too technical!
The new equation allowed them to build a Dyson Sphere.
@@craigharris41 You mean an O-Neill Cylinder and there are already ideas about quantum gravity that connect general relativity and quantum physics, one is Superstring Theory/M-Theory, the other being Quantum Loop Gravity
Interstellar is one of the greatest sci-fi movies ever made. This movie genuinely contributed to the scientific community, they actually got 2 research papers published about this. When Christopher Nolan was working on this movie rather than have an “artist’s concept” of what a black hole would look like he worked with a physicist named Kip Thorne and asked him how black holes work. So Kip gave him a bunch of maths, they sent the math to the VFX team, they put it in their render engine (which is far more powerful and expensive than anything that exists in the community) and what it produced was completely unexpected. They knew that a black hole would have what’s known as an accretion disc, but what they didn’t expect as this weird halo effect around it. The VFX team thought it was a bug so they sent it to Kip and he both confirmed that that’s what it would look like and was surprised on how well it looked. This is what a black hole would look like because the gravity is so powerful that it’s pulling light from the other side and causing you to see a second halo because you are seeing the other side of the black hole.
And the time dilation is 100% accurate. If you are near something with a strong gravitational pull like a planet larger than earth or a black hole your “clock”, meaning your time, will run slower than on earth. I’m still surprised that 8 years later no one else has used that in a sci-fi movie or tv show.
Calm down. Nolan was greatly inspired by the anime "Voices from a Distant Star" from 2002 and copied key concepts (like time running slower/faster on earth) from that anime for Interstellar. Just like he also copied the anime Paprika for Inception.
@@Worldgonemad ....time dilation is a concept of relativity developed by Einstein not some fucking anime from 2002.
Can't remember what doco it was, the guy said if you take off from and go around a strong enough gravity source, you can make it back in time to see yourself leaving
@@Worldgonemad Damn, wait until you find out that anime is based on real life, not the other way around. Weeb.
Watch 2001
I gotta say, I have a lot of empathy for Doctor Mann. His actions are reprehensible and rightfully unforgivable by most viewers, but they're also deeply human and understandable. Very, very few people would choose differently than he did if they found themselves in his situation.
@@joaobelezo I mean, yes. He's reprehensible and his actions are unforgivable...like I said. My point is, you're genuinely fooling yourself if you - or 99.9% of the human race - think you'd act differently in his shoes. It's so, so easy to call him a coward from the comfort of a warm home.
Signing up to die, on Earth, with your colleagues, emboldened by the respect from and for those closest to you, is 100% easier to do than ACTUALLY dying, alone, slowly, one breath at a time, on an alien planet that not only serves as a total reminder of the failure of your work in the mission. That kind of misery would easily break almost anyone.
@@quegs If I was in his shoes, I would just kill myself rather than die slowly or DOOM THE ENTIRE SPECIES TO A HOT DEATH ON EARTH. There is no justification for how far he went in his selfishness, and it's really not as common as you think it is to be a slimy turd. Sorry man, the indomitable human spirit is made of tougher stuff than that. I truly hope if it came down to it, you wouldn't make the same mistakes.
@@joaobelezo would you do it.
@@joaobelezo That's a very easy thing to say. I've lost count on how many times the best of people become the "worst" when faced with a life or death situation.
@@joaobelezo 🧢
You know a movie is filmed well when the sad parts are sad every time and the intense parts are always intense, every time you watch them.
All of the old people at the beginning except the old version of Murph were not actors. They were clips from the Ken Burns documentary on the great American dust bowl so they actually lived through what they are talking about.
Ive watched thousands of movies. This is the only one that brings tears to my eyes whenever I watch it. Cooper and Murph's relationship is one of the most beautiful relationships in cinema history.
Something that was not obvious to me at first is that, the space stations near Saturn in the end - the reason they’re near Saturn is that they’re preparing to pass through the wormhole and go to Brand’s planet to reunite all that survives of humanity. And that’ll be the society that evolves into the 5-dimensional future humans. I was hung up on whether the future humans came from the space stations or Brand’s population bomb; then I realized it’s both, united.
The population bomb would not be necessary, since the rest of humanity is on the way. Plus, Brand would barely have gotten anywhere with the infrastructure to grow and support a bunch of newborn humans before contact was reestablished with her.
The "information" that he sent through the watch was the quantum data needed to solve the equation of gravity. Once solved, they are able to manipulate gravity to the point where they can transport the entire NASA building they were working in, into space as a type of space station. Therein taking all that is left of humanity off the earth all at once and travel through space. At least that's what I interpreted.
It's not the NASA building. It's any object they wish to sent into space. People, fuel, equipment etc all weigh a lot. So the manipulation was required to send anything up.
@@bedinor yes obviously, I thought it was clear by my breakdown that I didn't mean the equation was just to know how to move that very specific building. I only mentioned the building to tie it in cause it was mentioned in the movie. If they can move something as large as that entire building obviously they can move anything else they wish.
@@BasedNate it seems you didnt get the movie at all ...
@@romeorodrigues3680 please, enlighten me.
@@romeorodrigues3680 please, enlighten me.
The cylinder he woke up in was a O'Neill cylinder, which creates artificial gravity via rotation.
I still love the Irony of Matt Damon explaining why they had to keep the fact that Plan A was a ruse because "humanity needed to work together to save the species instead of themselves" and him almost ruining everything because he wanted to save himself lol
Which makes his death adds to the extra irony.
The fact that Dr. Brendt was right in all of this and they should have gone to Edmund's planet is just crazy. Maybe if they'd go straight there, they would't have to lose so many years, but it would also mean the end of a movie straight there :D Great movie, great cast! I also loved the cast for Murph, from a child to an old lady she just felt the same exact person. Mind blowing movie.
If they had gone straight there they wouldn't have gotten the information from the black hole to send back to Earth. Everything worked out as it was supposed to.
But then again, if they went there first and all was hunky dory, would Cooper still go to the black hole instead of just back to earth (and thus never solving the problem).
"Because my father promised me"... the delivery makes me cry everytime.
0:14 Should definitely watch The Prestige and any of Nolan's films you guys haven't watched yet. Memento is one of his earliest films but also one of his best.
Prestige totally caught me off guard! Sooo good!
For that dust storm in the beginning of the movie, they actually did drop dumploads of sand just outside the filming location, and had industrial fans blow it around in order to create a realistic dust storm and avoid bad fog-like CGI.
This is the most NPC reaction i have ever seen on Interstellar and I've seen it all they have no emotion like how do you even .
Interesting fun fact about this movie. Christopher Nolan planted that cornfield (500 acres) for the movie, turned around, and sold it to a farmer for a profit. All because he didn't want to have a CGI farm.
that is a very cool fact! thanks for sharing
Bro what. That’s nuts!!
My second favorite bit of trivia about this movie, lol
Mathematical formulas about the nature of gravity. The sheer mass of the space station could not reach escape velocity without manipulating gravity. Amazing film
"Because my dad promised me.."
Me: Tears starting to roll up everytime...
if you listen to the background music when they land on the first planet with the giant waves, each tick in the music is a day passing on earth
I love this movie. Scientifically, it is one of the most accurate movies and portrayals of science there are. Director Christopher Nolan, of the Christian Bale Batman movies, consulted one of the foremost theoretical astrophysicists available, Kip Thorne, to make sure the science was as accurate as possible. In fact, Kip had suggested a few changes to the plot as the original script got some of the science wrong. So, Nolan, at Kip's behest, changed nearly all of those parts to keep with the science. The only part he did NOT change was the upside down ice mountains on that second world. Kip said that the gravity of the planet would have made those ice formations so high up nearly impossible. However, they were kept in. Nevertheless, everything else in the movie is as accurate as possible. The gravity equations that were being worked on back on Earth, were real equations used by scientists, namely astrophysicists. The tesseract near the end, inside the singularity, was based on what theoretical physicists believed it would look like. The black hole depiction was based on real mathematical models of what one would look like up close. They plugged in those models and equations, and viola, that's what we got. There is a nearly one-hour documentary, called "The Science of Interstellar", that was available on DVD and BluRay purchases of this movie. There is another documentary narrated by Kip Thorne that expounds in further detail the science. You can also watch both of them here on YT. Here are the links. ruclips.net/video/Sv9WzXekSiw/видео.html and ruclips.net/video/lM-N0tbwBB4/видео.html
Interstellar is my all-time favorite film. It's awesome that everyone on the internet loves this film as much as I do
Fun fact, this was the first realistic rendered image of a black hole. The scientific advisor Kip Thorne is an astrophysicist and was responsible for a research paper that basically simulated what a black hole would actually look like, particularly how it has that halo that show's its own reflection behind it by bending the light so much. The numbers showed thats what it would look like, but they turned to the movie industry for the most powerful cgi rendering computers in the world to actually show US what it would look like. And then just a few years after, we got the actual first HD photograph of a black hole, and it looks just like its depicted here
Yes, exactly. Have you read the book on the making of interstellar? It's amazing. If you haven't I can give you some snippets of what's in the book.
The ticking on the water planet is important. Each tick is a day for earth and the other astronaut in orbit.
His daughter said the line at the end...... "In our new home"
The music in this movie is _OUTSTANDING_
Hans Zimmer is the *G.O.A.T.*
Absolutely
Apparently Nolan lied to Zimmer about what the film was about. Told him it was about an estranged father and son and that's how he scored it
Intersteller is one of the movies which is like a crush whom you cant stop thinking about
this is my all time favorite film from cinematography to dialog its so very good glad too see you guys enjoy it as well. cheers
What I like about this movie is that it goes into topics such as time dilation which are totally real things and not made up fiction. As Einstein said, time is relative. There are two ways time dilation can occur. Moving at fast speeds (only close to light speed would it become noticeable to humans without instruments) and the path this movie explored, gravity wells. The faster you move or the closer you are to a gravity well the slower your time moves relative to the outside observer. In theory this applies to all types of speeds and gravity wells it just that these differences are so incredibly tiny that no one notices them, but your feet which are closer to earth gravity well are a tiny tiny tiny tiny bit younger than your head and if you fly with a plane you fly a tiny tiny tiny tiny bit into the future. Satellites that whiz around the earth actually need to take this into account and compensate by having their onboard clock slowed down by ~ 45 microseconds per day.
The information they got from the black hole helped them control gravity, that's how the space ship was a cylinder and how the baseball went up instead of down, this showed humanity got advanced enough to get off planet and move across the universe, because of the mastery of gravity
I think that they would eventually bring the people from the stations to the planet they found, set up a new home base for humanity.
Love this movie, it is one of my top 3 for sure.
Among all the crazy things in astrophysics, understanding time dilation is quite simple:
1. All objects move forward though time.
2. All massive objects cause you to move less in time but more in space (i.e. pull you in). It's like if these objects drag you and slow you down in the timeline, while all other objects in the universe keep moving through time at their normal speeds.
3. But the ratio is astronomically crazy. People on Earth have time dilation of a minuscule fraction of a millisecond per year. We can actually measure this time dilation by comparing clocks on Earth and clocks on space satellites (GPS, for example).
4. To get something crazy like 7 years per hour you need to be in vicinity of an extremely massive object, like a supermassive black hole (which unlike regular black holes absorbed masses of thousands if not millions of stars).
The quality physics in Interstellar is quite impressive actually. Nolan invited Gav Thorpe to do the math, and during his calculations he predicted the actual look of black holes, as a black sphere that has an accretion disk which its image is stretched all around (above and below) it because of gravitational lensing. This was never done before, and all black holes in previous movies looked different from what it actually should look like. And this rendered image based on real math, made for Interstellar, later coincided with the actual images of the black hole at the center of the Milky Way, which we obtained years later.
yeah i saw this and crying at the scene with 300 other strangers in the theatre was like a religious experience, emotion is a wild thing
What I love about this movie is it got many people interested about relativity and time dilation which is a REAL thing
Hey dudes, this isn't a funny movie
You're laughing all the time
Thank you
16:11 The ticking sound in this scene is interesting. Every 'tick' that you hear marks the passing of one day in Earth's timeframe.
Coop is travelling back through the wormhole to live, grow old and die with Brand on the very late, lamented Wolf Edmonds' planet, which is fortunately habitable and will eventually be colonised by other humans.
The information Tars was able to learn from direct observation from within a black hole allowed Murph to finally complete professor Brands gravity calculations back on earth and therefore launch and operate the ark ships they had already built, saving the remainder of humanity, instead of abandoning them to their fate on a dying earth.
Prestige is Nolan's Best. Should totally watch it.
Completely agree!
This is one of my all-time favorite movies. I was in pure awe. This is my FAVORITE Nolan film.
Lol no way, I literally just watched someone else's reaction earlier today and wondered if you guys did one. Spooky!
This guy laughs like a maniac lol
This is one of those films that I wish I would have gotten to experience in IMAX in a Dolby atmos theatre.
That would have been dope! Try the new Avatar movie in IMAX, heard it's quite an experience.
@@kavinsky2 that’s definitely on the list!
Watching a genuine movie that touches your soul….
With you two would be afing nightmare…
The constant laughter ffs
Seriously! I couldn’t agree more. Just two busy idiots unable to feel any emotions or empathy
I'm sure I wont be the first one to point this out, but my favorite part about Interstellar is the lengths they went through in an attempt to be as accurate as possible to the underlying physics. As a astrophysics undergrad (working towards my Ph.d.) with a special love for black holes/event horizons, this movie made me happy in ways most sci-fi fails to replicate. Loved your reaction!!!!
what did you think of the use of Superstring Theory and M Theory regarding the idea of gravity able to travel across space and time?
Great reaction! This movie means so much to me, I remember watching it every day for a week when it came out, with my mom, with my girlfriend, and with everyone I could find. I was in the middle of my undergrad in physics back then and I was feeling like giving up, this movie gave me the push to the finish.
A bit of info about your last comments: what doctor Mann meant with "solve gravity" was to find a way to harness gravity and use it to allow large-scale space travel. The problem with that is that you need data from very strong gravitational objects... black holes, which is what was sent using the clock and allowed Murph to finally figure out how to use gravity (I imagine that created enough scientific breakthroughs to build the big spaceship/colony).
Well-known fact: the image of the black hole was modeled using real physics!
what did you think of gravity travelling through space and time from Superstring Theory and M Theory?
I have a theory that gravity could be both gravitons which correlates to quantum loop gravity, but also connecting dark energy and dark matter with gravity, as dark energy is an expansive force, and if it can expand in all directions from more than one point, it would also be the compressive force of gravity. The theory also uses string/m-theory, and connects to ideas like Nassim Haramein's fractal universe, Stephen Hawking's zero-energy universe and could include Garrett Lisi's particle geometry.
I honestly don't know how you didn't cry at least once. I have seen it a few times and because it was the 10th anniversary i saw it the other day again in the cinema and i still couldn't stop crying 😂
They have no idea of empathy, compassion or feeling stories. Just two cackling busy idiots
On the water planet, every click you hear = 1 day on earth, love this movie, really love the sound track of this movie.
You really watched the greatest movie of all time with 1 airpod
They’re busy idiots
Notice how Conaughey's character is leaning his head into the direction of the rotation, while Hathaway's character doesn't. This would help him stay conscious, as it's a lot easier to be subjected to positive G-forces rather than negative G-forces. Also the difference from the center of rotation would make a huge difference, and iirc Conaughey's character is sitting in the inner most seat. :)
I watched this movie in the movie theater back when I was like a freshman in high school, and I absolutely loved it I cried in the theater man ❤. One of if not my favorite movie of all time 🐐
Same here. I had to leave my friends, family, coworkers for a new job and saw this in the theater. Covid hit and it was even more likely I would never see anyone I knew again.
Easily my favorite movie of all time, I could watch it a million times!
Yes. I feel like we won't ever see a movie of this caliber in our lifetimes
i didn't know interstellar was a comic movie.....they justlaugh all the time for no reason at all
The Prestige and Momento are my favorite Nolan films.
This is better. Memento is good but I have no impulse to see it again.
"How would humanity survive on this planet?" Life uh, uh, finds a way.
No, no I'm sorry, but you've made a mistake. That is "uh, uh um" actually. And it'll be "a way.. a way.. " if you're being formal. 🤓
@@sagnikadhikary2917dammit I wish you were wrong, but you're not.
his daughter was also put into cryo sleep so time had definitely passed they woke her when they found her father
The reason Cooper didn’t black out during the docking spin is because he leaned WITH it. Brand blacked out because she leaned against it and tried to fight the spin.
I know why he left because of the “a parent shouldn’t have to watch their kids pass” thing, but I always thought it was funny how he walks in and to all her relatives it’s like wow it’s our matriarchs father who made possible the salvation of humanity…cool nice 30 second reunion ok bye now 👋😂
she told her "no parent should watch their own child die"
did you even watch the movie?
This is probably my favorite Nolan movie. I think Coop just went to be with Brand. He wasn't planning on bringing her back to the station. The tesseract was pretty cool and the future human knew that he will do it, because it's already happened. I like Anthony's reaction to Matt Damon, because that's what I thought, but him going nuts caught me off guard. The information that was sent through the watch was a variable that Murph and old man Brand needed to solve the problem of gravity to get that station off of Earth.
I saw this during a metaphysics class in college. I swear it gave me such an existential crisis when i had the thought of us being the ghosts for someone else. What if our existence is solely to propel someone else?
I would hate if that were true, because I did some embarassing stuff in my private moment
imagine someone ghosts were there watching you did all of that 😅
Often in religion and human metaphysics we say there's a purpose for us. There's a reason we exist. But rarely do people want to hear that maybe your reason to exist was to just throw a piece of paper out one day, and that piece of paper goes to a landfill, where it grows bacteria, which causes a new strain of disease, which is then used for ______. We'd like to think that maybe it'll be something big, but we don't get to see that. But maybe yes. All you were meant to do, is press this one button somewhere, that's it. No grandiose explanation. No big picture.
I mean the usual interpretation of ghosts are people that have passed on, among them our relatives. And yes, each generation of humanity "should" be better than the previous one. Just like you should be better than your parents and your kids better than you. But human pride and greed prevents much of this unfortunately.
Good point. Read the book this movie is based on. It's very solid physics.
I love that both of your laughs are so aggressive 😂
I hate them both…yuck
One of my favorites. I saw in the theater the day it was released and they gave out a poster 😂🎉❤
The whole point of the "crack gravity"'s equation thingy was to build that technology. Getting things to space is HARD because of gravity. If you somehow can manipulate gravity, then it isn't hard. That's how you get EVERYONE off planet.
Also, for inception: The spinning top is his wife's totem. Not his. Therefore if you truly want to know whether or not he is awake, pay attention to his wedding ring. When he is in a dream, he has it on. When he is awake, he doesn't.
He was going to Anne Hathaway, and she's the new "Eve", he's the new "Adam". And their descendants would one day be the humans that evolved far enough to transcend dimensions, and would one day send back the information needed for humans to escape earth, which would help his children go to them to join them and and prosper, hopefully, as part of the future humans ancestors.
Time being linear is no longer a thing. Space is no longer a thing. Only gravity, and maybe love was able to travel backwards. And what's a massive amount of gravity/mass in a single spot? A black hole. That was them sending back to their ancestors what they needed to have happened in order for them to be. And they are.
Everytime she says "Because my dad promised me" I break
The stories of the old people…are actual survivors from our own Dust Bowl..from Oklahoma and Kansas up to Canada..about Nov.29, 1929..through mid to late 1938..dates that parallel our Great Depression..prolonged drought dried up crops in the Midwest to Canada..years without rain..created land erosion which brought the wind and dust storms..my family lived in Kansas..my mom was 10..the same age probably as the people talking..
At the end Mr Cooper hopping into a craft with his Droid....to set off to a distant galaxy far far away...
He was going to join her..as older Murph said..under the warm sun of our new home..Brand already started one colony..
This is one of the best movies ever made
I’m not going to lie this was weird watching them smile this movie and making jokes lol like wtf was going through their heads when watching this
Nothing is going through their heads. They’d watch Fast and the Furious the same way. Two idiots
Yeah, I get the feeling they didn't understand all the emotions in the movie
I love this movie so much. I went in not knowing what to expect and ended up bawling my eyes out because of Murph and Cooper's struggles to re-unite. It's such a beautiful film, in many more ways than one. I get that it's not for everyone, but that's okay.
Wow, these two laugh at the strangest parts. It's so bizarre lol
They’re complete idiots
They kind of ruined the movie with their inappropriate laughter. I hope they don't review schindlers list the same way.
"...Because my dad promised me....' That scene had me
If you Google 'dust bowl', you'll see that dust storms wiped out the agriculture of Kansas, Oklahoma, and Northern Texas, during the depression, just like the storms in the movie. Poor agricultural practices led to over grazing and depletion of topsoil and the locals were referred to as dirt farmers. This led to a mass exodus, generally to California where there was a booming agricultural industry. But California could not absorb the influx of people, leading to tent cities and horribly unsanitary conditions. John Steinbeck wrote of this time in his novel, The Grapes of Wrath. My mother was born into this, in California, and her family eventually returned to Oklahoma, poorer than before, and became share croppers, fighting to turn the land back into a sustainable farm. Dust storms on my grandma's farm were still a major problem when I visited as a kid.
This movie broke my spine worse than Bane did to Batman!
Edit, the Prestige is my 2nd favorite Nolan film
Evan as "just" a stepdad, the scene of Cooper witnessing his daughter's death crushes me. Driven home by the thought that this could actually, according to the laws of physics as we currently understand them, could actually happen, makes it so poignant.
Thanks for the reaction to this comedy film.
It's not really a comedy
48:50
A black hole's singularity is highly theoretical. We have ideas but nothing close to something measurable. TARS was able to take data readings of the singularity and they were able to transmit the data to the watch.
Well even the movie never showed what that Singularity actually looks like. The Tesseract region Cooper was in to transmit information across time was probably situated in some tangent topography within the black hole but not quite at the singularity itself. The Tesseract is like a machine using the black hole as energy to power itself. To my bleak perception the Singularity is a really dense overlapping of every possible dimensions of spacetime tangled into each other like a tight knot of lace....but constantly un-knotting & re-knotting itself. When you tie a knot the surrounding fabric also gets pulled creating tension towards the knot...that's how i see why gravity well of black hole is so strong.
Christopher Nolan's new movie is Oppenheimer.
Seeing a trailer of a Christopher Nolan movie about J. Robert Oppenheimer right before Avatar 2. I was not ready for today.
Yes please do the Prestige! Fantastic movie and would be fun to watch y’all react to!
It’s been like 86 years
So Murphy is now 100 years old
The “halo like” spaceship at the end was supposed to be the revelation that humans solved gravity. Like Michael caines character was trying to solve. And the end was, like you said, supposed to be him going to her planet. roll credits. Great film. 💯
@Joseph D. "by the time youve returned, i will have solved the problem of gravity." i only said it was a ship because the covazos referred to it as a ship. SiMMER DOWN SPORT.
My favorite is still his first big movie, Memento! A serial killer, used as a serial killer, but doesn't know he's a serial killer, so he's completely innocent! But this movie...if u don't cry, u have no soul!!
It was the answer to the gravity equation he got from the black hole singularity that allowed Murph to harness gravity to get a space station of the size needed to evacuate earth
Indeed. But combining quantum mechanics and relativity wouldn't allow you to do that. You still need the energy
Let's GOOOOO
This and "The Thing 1982" were up there for "when are they going to react to these?" lol
Highly recommend John Carpentar's "They Live", go in blind, trust me.
Her voice is kinda relaxing tbh! Love this reaction of this amazing movie.
He was going back through the wormhole to go to her planet. The space station was on its way to the wormhole to get everyone from earth to that planet that they found.
If someone landed here in the middle of the Pacific, would it be a good guess that Earth isn’t habitable?
If someone landed in the middle of Antarctica, would it be a good guess that Earth is too cold?
i have a SSD called "post apocalypse ssd" it's a size of a fluid lighter, easy to pocket.
basically it's a data capsule. in which i have stored family and friends pictures some documents and movies, series which i would never get bored watching.
interstellar was the first movie to be part of my PA-SSD storage. i might have watched this movie more than 30 times by now.
Yeah, have to say I prefer when Kacee does a solo film reaction, no hate.
I just love this movie's photography; it's awesome
BTW, in inception, leo's piece was actually his wedding ring, the spinning top was his wifes, so yes he was in the real world. and YES please watch all the chris nolan films
One of the greatest epic Sci Fi Adventure films ever made.
#InterstellarFact : The Black Hole scene takes about 100 days to render.
Thank you for watching this movie! Much love, new subscription you guys are great!
Damn, shocked that you haven't seen this classic
God is every Dallas cowgirls fan this dimwitted? I first watched this movie when I was like 16-17 and understood almost the whole movie the first time I watched it.
29:23 look carefully there is a landscape behind the hole. because what they staying on is not actually a ground level but another leyer of frozen gas. i think there is another shot like this on landing but didn't show in this video.
also at the end. it's kinda one way trip. the only reason he survive blackhole is they bring him back to solar system.