What Yoda Did After Seeing Anakin and Padme Embrace on Geonosis in Episode 2! (Legends)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 фев 2020
- Star Wars Gaming Channel: / @starwarsgamingclub2526
Twitch: / swrcgaming
Twitter: @SWReadingClub
Looking for Star Wars books? Check out our Amazon Influencers page and help support SWRC: www.amazon.com/shop/influence...
Thank you very much to our amazing Patrons for their support of the channel, including our Darth Bane and Grand Admiral Thrawn Tier level Patrons:
Ben Lewitt
Daniel Kim
Rvmuller
Jasmine (Thatzer)
Andrew Seiner
The Non-Canon Expert looks at what Yoda thought and recognized after seeing Padme run to Anakin Skywalker and initiate an embrace between the Jedi Padawan and the Senator from Naboo on Geonosis, explaining how Yoda responded to this action in the immediate aftermath of Episode 2: Attack of the Clones.
This is a Legends story for Yoda and the events of Episode 2: Attack of the Clones with information found within the Legends novel "Star Wars: The Clone Wars: Wild Space." I hope that you enjoy it!
Decisions by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommons.org/licenses/...)
Source: incompetech.com/music/royalty-...
Artist: incompetech.com/
A Dream Within a Dream by Twin Musicom is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommons.org/licenses/...)
Source: www.twinmusicom.org/song/301/a...
Artist: www.twinmusicom.org 
Развлечения
![The Battle That Caused Palpatine to Replace The Clones With Stormtroopers [FULL STORY]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eznwSJjw9_I/mqdefault.jpg)
What he should of done was get a rolled up newspaper.
"No. Bad Chosen one. Forbidden that is"
Alex BaBomb this is genuinely one of the funniest things I've ever read on a Star Wars topic
Alex BaBomb most underrated comment bro😭😭😂😂
wow that is comedy gold my friend
I literally just imagined that
Alex BaBomb should have took out a light saber whip and whoop that ass.
“Virgin you must remain, losing the v pass is the path to the dark side”
You do realize, many Jedi go undercover and possibly lose their V-card accidentally or intentionally, during their missions😏.
@@kingnamor7777 r/woooosh
Jedi can lose their V. But they can't create permanent attachments. Good joke tho
They can only go do it with thots, they can't be simping
@@jayantkumarmandloi5745 so in other words the Jedi are a bunch of dogs.
Padme: "Can I go to Naboo?"
Obi-wan: "To break up with Anakin?"
Padme: "Yees"
Padme: *actually gets married like a boss
_Clone Wars time_
Nice meme
It should be reversed. Padme doesn't need Obi's permission to go to her homeplanet, but Anakin does.
LMAO 😂😂😂
@Jesse Rhodes Inovashon
Damn straight😃. The princess doesn't takes orders from anyone. Not even the Jedi.
Notice that Yoda knows everything going on but in the end chose to save himself and chill out on Dagobah eating lizards.
Ye man he be chilling
SNGaming he do be kinda vibin doe 😳
900 year old smoking dagobah green
Well Hel O’Deer ayyyyyy i guarantee it has the best in the known universe. Dagobah Delight 😂😂😂
Azuma Reiji bro if you haven’t heard it already go RUclips Star Wars Gangsta Rap
Anikin and Padme's relationship is like an open secret.
Everyone knows it but nobody ever talks about it.
Well he is the "chosen one", basically the strongest force user alive besides Yoda, and becomes the most important General in the clone wars.
Nobodys gonna say shit about what he's doing lol.
That is true. In the most recent clone wars episode I think it's shown that Rex knows about it.
@@darthgamer9468 i didn't watch the episode yet did you enjoy it
bdhc 210 it was interesting tbh. (I actually watched it on car audio on the way to school this morning)
@@darthgamer9468 He either knows, or he just knows Anakin has feelings for her. Either way, that nose art.
Yoda: Paying for child support like me he will, if stop them i dont
Omfg you made my day
And thus the biggest mystery of the Mandalorian is explained
Lmao
then why did he push him away in episode 3 to sign divorce papers?
That must suck considering fact that Yoda's species dont grow up till they're a hundred years old lol
"Attachment is forbidden. Possession is forbidden. Compassion, ...is central to a Jedi's life..." -Anakin, AOTC novel.
Compassion is KINDNESS, not love. Understanding, not companionship. Anakin, as usual, is twisting things to suit his desires.
@Tahkaullus01 Playing devil's advocate here, compassion is a form of "agape", which is one of the 7 forms of love in Ancient Greek philosophy. I don't particularly agree with the theory of the 7 forms of love (particularly "eros"), but it's worth mentioning.
@@SirYodaJedi Wow...okay, I'm giving you a like purely because you got Ancient Greeks involved.
His words won’t matter now because Luke made a new Jedi order, but this dogma is the reason the Jedi must be destroyed
Jedi also preach against passion which is apart of compassion
They even kissed behind Obi-Wan’s back after Yoda’s duel with Dooku
Darrel's Wonderland he knows what it’s like and doesn’t wanna ruin it for him
plus i think he was too busy looking at the giant monster tryna eat him
He didn't saw it they were not in the arena fighting stage yet but in a "corridor" or room inside the arena building
I think he means when she jumped into the animal Anakin was on and she kisses him on the cheek
@@sonofabrick2945 ah yeah you mean when a fucking giant mantis thing was trying to have a snacc on Obi's Booty?
Look at it from a psychological view. They were together and had gone through an emotional journey together before they had reached geonosis. Geonosis had been an incredibly stressful and emotional conflict where both of them had nearly been killed by monsters, droids, and bugs, and are now thrown immediately into a full scale war without warning. With or without their romantic chemistry this moment of embrace can easily be explained as a coping mechanism for padme. After so much stress, being reconnected with the person she has spent the most time with, was her sworn protector at the time, and the person she had the strongest relationship with this embrace would be the greatest most immediate sense of security and decompression at the moment, also acting as embrace of relief knowing that anakin is not dead after being sent to fight someone far more powerful than him.
Too many emotions for me
Plus she saw he was missing half his arm so I'd assume she was making sure he was okay
A. Love the comment
B. As I have been told many times before women are drawn to those who make them feel safe/ enable them to go on adventures. All though Anakin had the emotional intelligence of emotionally repressed shut in he still got the girl.
And he fucked up someone far more powerful than him. Gave her the waterfall.
This is the way i always took that scene. An embrace after an intense battle really isn't really out of the ordinary. I never took this as a reflection on any kind of plot hole and it never needed an explanation. As the viewer i already knew their relationship, but for the other characters, i always thought they were way more focused on other matters than a hug.
"There are no secrets among the Jedi." - Yoda
Freaking lol, the Order was nothing but secrets which was a contributing factor to Anakin choosing to join the Sith in the first place. Here is Yoda's hypocrisy in full view.
What's worse is he didn't even recognise his own hypocrisy until it was too late.
The most dangerous of hypocrites are those who do not see it within themselves.
To be fair he said the Jedi get no privacy, not that they have no secrets. He's basically just saying a Jedi's personal life is the concern of the entire order and by entering into a relationship with a Jedi Padme forfeited the privacy of that relationship.
I'm not saying I agree with that stance, but it's not the same thing as keeping dangerous information from reckless and impulsive young Jedi. Especially in a universe that's more fleshed out like in the EU there are certain things that are dangerous just to know about.
Vladislak some of the knowledge in the Legends Universe, if even slightly glanced upon, could drive some beings to madness. This goes for some ancient horrors as well...
Aloha732 yoda had some fucked up policies... he had become too cocky.. i am glad palpatine beat his fallen order
telanis9 yes. And legends it must remain. This is not like yoda’s actual character
“Hmm. Good relations with the Senator, he has. Go to Naboo, he will.”
lol "relations"
Jerry Strand “Inspect the senator he must” 😏
@@seriousnesstv7902 Little known fact: Yoda never got proper training as a gynecologist, let alone an OBGYN, but he considers it a hobby anyway
NICHOLAS JOHNSON That begs the question... was Yoda on top or chewie?
*sexual relations
Obi wan Kenobi? More like Swolebi Wan Keratini. That has to be the most ripped drawing of Obi wan I've seen.
I do like the drawing style. Padme is looking pretty fine.
Imagine Anakin Swolewalker from RotS in this art style
Time stamp?
It's actually obi wan more rep
The original Ben Swolo
This is one of those scenes I've actually never noticed before. My brain is still dizzy from the duel that I completely miss Padme embracing Anakin every time I've seen AOTC.
Me too! I was like wait, was that in the movie? ^^
Me too
Yoda: "simp"
bukaketsunami89 :P
was thinking this the entire fuckin video
anakin is the biggest simp of all time
"You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means."
A Simp Lord?
Obi-wan: So you're going to end it with anakin?
Padme: Yep
Obi-wan: When will you do it?
Padme: When we go away together alone to this private island on naboo
Obi-wan: Sounds good
Yoda: ...
Husaam Maawia Yoda: meditate on this I will
facepalm
Also after Padme dresses into the same ripped Geonosis outfit.
This is why Luke’s New Jedi Order(Legends),where he embraces attachment and allows jedi to marry, including himself, is a better philosophy. To deny love and keep it secret is part of what drove Anakin to the dark side. If Yoda would have allowed Padme and Anakin to marry publicly, I believe that things would have turned out differently.
Yes, then he would have gotten awesome wedding gifts from every Jedi before he lost control of his emotions, betrayed everyone, and murdered children. The guy was a ticking time bomb because of his emotional instability and selfishness. That was proven in Attack of the Clones. Sooner or later, Sidious would have found a way to exploit those deep character flaws, regardless of whatever support Anakin received from the Jedi.
I mean that one Jedi master on the council had multiple wives and kids openly
@@WaitingtoHit maybe, maybe not. We dont know what is down the path not travelled.
@@Allmightyimortal No, we do because the movies very clearly established him as someone who is open to acting purely on emotion and with little regard for others. His instability and impulsiveness were there since the very beginning; that's why the Jedi sensed it was risky to train him. Some movies require in-depth analysis to discern a character's nature but not these. In the very first prequel, we literally see that Anakin's shadow is not his own but Vader's.
@@WaitingtoHit that is called foreshadowing because that path was already taken, we knew it was coming, which is why I dislike prequels. However, you are making the same mistake the council made and they are what made him fall into vader and take that path. As he said himself constantly calling him the chosen one. They made him into that state as much if not more as he himself fell into it. Also he cared very much for others that was part of the problem in a way.
Obi-Wan was in love with Satine Kryze for nearly his entire stint as a Jedi and even said he’d have left the order if she asked, makes sense he’d keep quiet about Anakin and Padme
but obi-Wan had the emotional intelligent to keep his emotion in check where anakin didn't
He went to beat his little green bean as he saw them hugging passionately
Lol
Soooo...you sent a young man, raging hormones and all, to be the bodyguard of a hot, classy woman and you expect him to not catch feelings?🤦🏾♂️
Especially since he had the hots for her since he was young in tpm
@@PHEONYX79 lol, the talk they had during the start of the movie while she was sleeping makes it clear for anyone with a brain that he likes padme
The Jedi council is full of idiots😑. They have no common sense whatsoever
@@kingnamor7777 Very much like the US white House and Senate. Not brains in sight!!
hackman669 nigga this is Star Wars go back to your cnn and news shit to talk about politics
That thumbnail with Yoda looks like Tomas the train meme but just with Yoda: "Master Yoda had never seen such bullshit before."
Hmmmmm, suspicious this is.
Way of the Jedi, this is not
Gundom run over children with my Honda Civic, I must
Amazingworldgumball in a hurry to meet your ketamine dealer, you are?
Chris H yes, allah is angry with me
@@heathburdiss8447 Commit genocide to please allah, I must
The explanation toward the end really makes the "Anakin is the father, isn't he" line a far more impactful line than what it came out as originally
@ 0:47 😅 Yoda's face
He on death sticks
Maryam مريم ketamine withdrawal will do that!!
6:22
🗿🗿🗿
"forbidden, the booty is"
Omg 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣💀💀💀💀💀💀bruhhh u made me spill my coffee on my lap.😀
More like emotional attachment.
Bootylover Order now recruiting
Padme: **Exists**
Anakin: "Swiggitty, swoogitty, I'm coming for that booty."
Yoda: "No, Anakin! Bad, the booty is!"
Obi-wan: **chuckles mischievously in the background while looking at a picture of Satine**
"Obi-Wan believed the painful task was completed."
*Ignores their obvious continued feelings all during the Clone War.
Obi-Wan’s just a bro
It’s cause obi wan knows how it feels and he really cared about anakin and padme was even some what a friend to him , during tcw cartoon anakin even tried to ask him obi wan for advise on his relationship troubles trying to be direct about it but obi wan being wise and intelligent as he is saw right through it and just kinda said something along the lines of I don’t wanna know. Any other Jedi would have immediately gotten him jail time or ex communicated from the order
Obi-wan knew the whole time he just ignored it
@@husaammaawia3057 100% fact
Love doesn’t lead to the dark side. Passion can lead to rage and fear, and can be controlled... But passion is not the same thing as love. Controlling your passions while being in love, that's what they should teach you to beware. But love itself will save you... not condemn you. - Jolee Bindo.
We especially know that this is true in Anakin's case. He was saved by the love of his son in ROTJ.
Wise words from a RUclipsr and a Grey Jedi.
@K A Repressing emotions causes them to build in power until they spill out.
@@awakenow7147 Palpatine just exploited the Attachment between Anakin and Padme. Even with the most Rational of People can be exploited because of their emotions and attachments.
Wise words...except what everyone forgets is that Anakin lost himself to his passions and became Darth Vader. I'm not saying that his love for his son isn't valid, just that people should remember to study all its aspects and not get dogmatically narrow-minded.
"Padme's feelings were of no importance as there's no such thing as privacy with the Jedi," - Am I the only one who finds that deeply disturbing and really fucked up?
No you aren’t, I got that feeling too
Yoda: "Use the force for only good the Jedi do, abusing the force forbidden it is, leads to the darkside it will, safety
young padme needs, too dangerous for her to be left unguarded it is, constant force seeing surveillance she requires,
even if in shower room she goes into, HMMMMM... Mace windu, see you must, big rack young skywalker's wife has!!!!"
Mace Windu: "Skywalker has a WHAT!!!!"
But you are twisting his words he said her feelings are of no importance when a Jedi is involved. Her privacy was accepted by the Jedi but when one was involved then she couldn’t have it.
@@anttwo let's just say that almost everyone in the galaxy is creepy
Yoda is a space frog.
Yoda went, in some alternative universe: "See this I did not. Forget all, I will. After a battle, Deathsticks I need to go smoke. My floaty chair, I will need"
Why does Yoda always look like a tired black man in every comic?
Cryo Judgement wow
Oh thank god, I thought I was the only one.
HOLY SHIT YOURE RIGHT LMAO 😂 I almost choked on my rice.
BITCH Wtf is a tired black man there PLENTY of WHITE men that look like him
@@Astavyastataa BITCH Wtf is a tired black man there PLENTY of WHITE men that look like him
I feel like if Anakin ever found out about this it would just have given him more of a reason to see the Jedi as betraying him
Yoda be like. “Thots lead a path to the dark side.”
He’s not wrong tho
*Facts.*
Yoda: thot be gone you must say.
Yes and no. Controlling your passions while being in love that's what the Jedi should've have taught😒.
King Namor 777 yoda: Mmmm, Much love for Thots I see in you. Great care you must take...
0:26
Padmé: Anakin!
Anakin: Phew, It's a releif Padmé's alri- OH MY GAAAD! WHAT'S WRONG WITH YOUR FACE??
Haha
So Koh is in star wars now?
Nice pfp
Screw the Jedi. Anakin should've just left. Or straight up told them what was up and they could either deal with it or nah
And then he still would have joined the dark side because he was already an unstable, selfish guy who committed mass murder.
Aaaaand look where his attachments led him. To committing genocide.
Guess the Jedi were right all along.
@@damobeck1 if he didnt have to deny his attachments and be alone in his troubles, i doubt be would have caused felt like he needed to follow the dark path
@Dr.'sorders "oh and dont forget that while you're spying on the highest elected official in our government, it is actually considered high treason. And when one of our strange old cult masters tries to murder him, definitely let that happen. Remember the Jedi Code. But only when its convenient. If someone is too dangerous to be left alive, just go ahead and kill them for good measure."
Anakin, in a way, did the right thing. The legal thing, at least. Imagine if a bunch of catholic priests came in to try and kill the President. You would side with the President lol
@@damobeck1 They weren't right. They took a boy who knew the warmth of love and told him to surpress all feelings, to dedicate himself only to a council who had damned themselves by attempting to play politics. If they'd guided Anakin through his feelings instead of ignoring them he'd have been better off
It's weird that Yoda would institute a ban on a natural thing that so often results in the creation of new life and therefore the expansion of the force. It doesn't make sense that life creates the force and for it to simultaneously be wrong for Jedi to engage in relationships like any other being in the galaxy and have children; thereby creating new life and expanding the force. The polar opposite of that rule makes more sense. The rule only makes sense in an extreme utilitarian type way that suggests attachment it wrong because it could be used against the people involved by an enemy or through an assumption that attachment only results in people doing terrible things. The Jedi Order under Grand Master Yoda must have been an Order that really dove into an ideology that didn't engage in a lot of questioning and reflecting, let alone tolerant of different view points.
Except it wasn’t Yoda who instituted that ban. Attachment has been forbidden for a Jedi for thousands of years before Yoda was even born. It’s their biggest rule. It was attachment that drove Anakin to the dark side, and made him a genocidal monster. Attachments were banned for this very reason, because the negative emotions that so easily come from attachment, drove so many Jedi to the darkness.
@@Delete240 What is the dark side even? Is it simply any strong human emotion? Is it a psychological tendency or disorder? Or moral failure? Or is it one's actions? Or one's affiliation to an organization? Star Wars seems to conflate all five of it. The Prequels is just well-constructed Jedi propaganda.
"Did you at least tell Padme I said Hi" people caught up on clone wars know.
Anakin: *Hugs a female of any age*
Everyone: Oh they just survived a near death experience and just happy to see each other alive.
Yoda: YOU'RE NOT AN INTELLECTUAL YOUR A FAKE AND A FRAUD!!!!!!!!
Yoda gets so mad he actually speaks proper english
anybody see a rebellious daughter vs dad vibe with this?
1st Failure: Obi-Wan failed his Master, felt responsible for his death
2nd Failure: Obi-Wan, sensing Anakin's feelings for Padme, should have requested an emergency meeting with Yoda, maybe the entire Council, and ask for an Outer Rim reassignment.
3rd Failure: Allowing Anakin to be Senator Amidala's personal body guard, even after Obi-Wan sensed Anakin's longing for her.
4th Failure: Dismissing Anakin's connection to his mother, as every other Jedi alive never knew their parents.
5th Failure: Once Obi-Wan got in touch with R2 on Tatooine, and found out they were on Anakin's homeworld, he should have ordered R2 to disable the ship, completely, in every way, to keep Anakin from putting himself and Padme in further danger.
6th Failure: no one instructing Jar Jar an army is not what Naboo wants.
Final failure: an organization like the Jedi, not quite religious, not quite social, not quite political, but allowing it to serve the Supreme Chancellor's instructions. The Jedi should not have had political affiliations at all. They should have remained loyal to democracy (more of a democratic republic) than to either the Senate or Chancellor. The Jedi were sent as negotiators during the Trade Federation blockade over Naboo. At that moment, with the Trade Federation's response, it was obvious the Jedi were already viewed as the bullies of the Republic. A republic that failed.
Great points!
"Awkward this is, unseen it can not be...although, likeable Padme is, a cutie."
Robert Vantine LOL!!!!
Honestly Yoda really apreciated Padmé. He had a clear soft spot for her, Obi-Wan and Ahsoka
Probably meditate on it. Just like when they found out Dooku made the clone army. Meh, it's probably ok. We'll just win the war faster before Dooku can't do his evil plot. Even though they can't see the future anymore. Is it too late to join the Dark Side?
And the moral lesson is: Meditation won't solve all your problems and, you have to be more proactive sometimes.
Never too late my friend
Dooku didn’t create the army, Syfo Dias did
@@Saiaxs I'm not sure if your joking or being real
@@kostyatamburrino1821 but he is right, Dooku took over later, but Sifo Dyas ordered the creation of the army
Yoda: Dealt with the issue have you, master Obi Wan?
Obi Wan: Yes master Yoda, Anakin will no longer see Senator Amidalla
Yoda: Told you this much, did she? Sincere did she seem?
Obi Wan: Indeed master, so sincere she's taking him away to her private Island Paradise to break up with him in secret.
Yoda: ...
Obi Wan:....
Yoda: *sigh* A bottom , you are, aren't you, master Kenobi.
Obi Wan: What!?
*Yoda Leaves*
Obi Wan: WHAT!?
LMAO !!!
I didn't know what bottom meant, I thought it was another kind of insult for asshole, but I googled it and WTF. lol
Huh
Plz explain
TheHulkbuster13 you know Duchess Satine was the top in that relationship
I like the fact that it’s canon that Anakin didn’t pull out.
But to be fair, who would pull out of Natalie Portman?
One thing’s for sure. Padmé has a great body. Yes it’s a random statement.
Init
At least I wasn't the only one who thought she was good looking and decent body
GamerTimeFunTime the comics make it even more sexy for sure. Then they cut to a clip in actual movie... hmm actually drawn pretty accurately. Nice job on that guys. How about Obi Wan looking like a body builder... In a fight he could have just taken off his shirt say, “I am the high ground.” His goes around him... Oh shit yup that’s the trump card and plot armor has entered the room.
I like how the number of likes for this specific comment is *34*
Thank you. I can’t remember if I asked you guys for this or somewhere else but finally. An answer! You guys are great!
Had Anakin not heeded Obi Wan's council, he may have kept that arm.
he could've lost Obi wan if he didn't help him though
@@bluelightstudios6191 Perhaps, but that was a possibility regardless of what Anakin chose to do. It was only through Yoda's interference that Obi Wan was saved. Whereas we know what happens when Anakin decides to heed Obi Wan.
*had he heeded
@@garyjones2561 I don't believe Obi Wan or Anakin were the seasoned warriors they needed to be during Episode 2 to defeat the count under any circumstances.
@@StannisHarlock No, you said "Had Anakin not heeded Obi-wan's council, he may have kept that arm." You implied that because Anakin *did* heed Obi-wan's council, he was dismembered. How's that?
I love your channel man! We need more legends vids tho I love legends idc if it isnt cannon 😭
Thank you for watching, and I hope that you enjoy the upcoming Legends videos! :)
Legends is cannon. The Disney stuff is horrible fan fiction
@@vexing4734 a star wars book I read is SW Death troopers and it was a good book
@@vexing4734 yeah, and Yoda being a jerk is better then the "fan fiction" right? Come on, legends is full of fan fiction, don't be hypocrite
You don’t need the force to tell Anakin be given Palme “I want you eyes” 😂😂😂
The council was just as much to blame for giving Anakin the assignment to protect Padme. And for not putting Shmi under Jedi protection. Yoda is damn good at deflecting blame.
It's kind of like how Palps fostered and developed his relationship with Anakin with he full knowledge and even (at times) the blessing of the Jedi.
They should have been a lot more worried about a middle aged politician taking an interest in a 12 year old Padawan, not just because its creepy. Instead, they let him take Anakin on a special assignment and become like a father figure to him.
He's also the biggest coward in all of starwars too, imo...
He hid away on Dagobah for the rest of his life... not once did he try to fight the empire through espionage and assassinations, like taking out Vader. He owed the people of the fallen Republic his life. It was his DUTY AS A JEDI to protect the galaxy, to fight the empire, even if it assured his death. Under Yoda, the Jedi were soldiers, warriors. Guess that applied to everyone but him in the end lol.
He was content just sitting around, not passing on his knowlege... or anything. He was going to take his knowledge to the grave...
Hell, when Luke showed up for training, he even rejected him initially lol....
Yoda was a pathetic coward, who deflected blame, lacked ANY self accountability, and was a horrible leader/horrible Grand Master... his blatantly flawed philosophies and strict rules directly led to the fall of the Republic and the Jedi. Lol
@@Kevin-zz9du I don't disagree, but he also knew he would be the only one likely to survive long enough to train Luke
Yoda does not understand family at all. He is a space frog.
@@Kevin-zz9du I’m convinced you’ve never watched the films. Espionage and assassination aren’t the way of the Jedi. Plus, he literally tried to kill the emperor, and he failed. He is far too old to be able to take on Vader and the Emperor. He needed a cane to walk, and had to augment his body with the force in order to fight. All Yoda could do is live long enough to train a Jedi who could take them on. The thing about Star Wars, is that no one is perfect. Everyone has their flaws. Luke was just as ineffective as Grandmaster as Yoda was, in both canon and legends.
And what accountability is Yoda meant to take? Only Sidious is responsible for the fall of the Jedi. He carefully orchestrated every tiny detail, and withheld his station as dark Lord through the force. By the time the Jedi knew about it, it was too late. Sidious was simply far too powerful for them.
I often think about past Jedi orders all the way back to the time of Reven and how all of them were so terrified of even the slightest trace of the dark side they would rather sit and do nothing. Joli Bindo put it best when he said love itself cannot condemn you. "Controlling your passions while being in love; that's what they should teach you."
"You at least told Padme I said 'Hello.' "
I can imagine many Jedi had secret lovers I don’t know why they just didn’t allow relationships.
The good thing about Star Wars is you can interpret it a lot of different ways. I also think that many jedi would have secret relationships that the council would just gloss over.
Great video! Thanks =D
If the jedi would have got off there high horse , and allow jedi to have families, none of this dark side empire crap would have happened. They should have supported them and protected the two. Would have saved alot of planets being blown up, and alot of people all across the galaxy from being killed from the empire.
Are you going to make a video about your thoughts on Project Luminous/The High Republic? I'd love to hear your thoughts about it!
If not for meee... For probably needing the follow up on this one. Brilliant, simply brilliant
Thanks for this.
What Yoda really said to Obi Wan “end the relationship you must. Ship with another I do.”
Oh no...are you talking about...
I left a like for *probably needing to follow up on this one*
You had me at Legends
Sick thumbnail!!! Amazing
I don't know why Anakin's severed right forearm wasn't surgically reattached as it was cleanly severed and there were medical facilities not far away?
Perhaps a teaching point.
Yoda: business mind my own i should
Electrical kid99 Yeah no matter how they wanted Anakin to avoid it the will of the plot I mean the force was that Padme gets pregnant
i tell ya... ive never wanted to watch the end of a video more than to see what comes after, "if not for meeEEeee" lol this one is in the top ten for sure.
I didn’t even notice or realize this part! Wow!! I was so oblivious! 😬
"for probably needing to follow up on this one"
As I’m watching The Clone Wars again for the first time in a while, the more I see just how right Luke was for wanting to end the Jedi. The Jedi belief system was very flawed at the end of the Republic. Sidious and the clone war completely blinded them to their flaws and arrogance. There are so many examples of it taking place that I could write a whole book of them.
You can tell through this story that Yoda genuinely cared for every jedi under him. He’s upset that he allowed such a thing to develop and he is upset that both he and Obi Wan where blinded by it. He clearly didnt want either of them to end up as it did
Wild Space is one of a very few instances of the Jedi actually acknowledging the growing relationship between Anakin and Padme, and I frankly adore it. They are not good at hiding their feelings, and a scene like this not occurring would be far stranger
For probably needing to follow up on this one then. Great video. I love this book. I always wondered why in the hell the jedi let Anakin go back to Naboo with Padme'. Seemed like the dumbest idea ever. They should have sent a padawan to throw rice. The rest of the book is really interesting too. I hope to see you do a video on the rest of it. It is a very comprehensive volume.
To be fair, Anakin was a padawan.
So Yoda can since this but not the darkness is Palpatine
I have read and own the book Wild Space. I don't remember this part of the story. It's time to reread this book. Thank you for the video.
For probably needing a follow-up on this one!
I liked for ANAKIN Skywalker
Are the Jedi corrupt? Hmmm, saying it's not okay to LOVE? That sounds like a Sith rule. Yes. Yes they are very corrupt cause that's F'd up.
I mean tge argument is that it would be extremely easy to fall to the darkside if one fell in love and was used against them.
They’d be easy to control if they had relationships and children
i was blown away by Yoda's sheer lack of compassion.
Darth Revan no the sith actually think love is a very important thing to have
Do you type like an obnoxious moron? Hmmm, it does SEEM to be that way. You speak very matter of factly. Yes, yes you are an obnoxious moron cause that’s obnoxious, moron
"Dangerous, this attachment is." - Yoda (out loud)
"In my bunk, I will be." - Yoda (in is mind)
I read the book and that was a great scene
All the Jedi knew. There was too much interaction between them in the clone wars for nobody to know nothing. Obi Wan immediately knew Anakin was the father of her children. They looked the other way most of the time because of his success in the Clone wars.
Wow. Obi Wan is buff!
"Padmes feelings were not important"
Oh were they in for something special
Yoda looking at them the way Stephen was looking at Django.
Hmmmmm Ketamine I smoke, make me savage it does
*"Jealous I am. Hot Natalie Portman is"*
I agree, She cheated on Anakin with me aswell lol.
I love the thumbnail. It looks like yoda is jealous of anakin😂
In the Episode II novelization Obi-wan shared his concern about Anakin and Padme to the Council before they were separated. The Council told Obi-wan they this was part of a test for Anakin. Then in Episode III novelization Obi-wan specificly tells Padme that he doesn't want to know the details or depth of their relationship.
What Obi-wan doesn't know can't be reported back to the Jedi.
love makes jedi and sith stronger (:
Yoda’s Jedi Order should’ve allowed marriage, but Yoda made some stupid decisions regarding emotions
Yoda is a fictional character that has no control in the matter
allowing marriage and love and families would put Jedi in a sticky situation due to many unethical people would blackmail Jedi by targeting their children. Lets face it, the sheer virtue of younglings at the Jedi Temple makes it easy pickings for Crime Families and holding them for ransom.
saying the Jedi order should let people marry sound like saying jar jar binks is a droid
that doesn't compute
Luke’s Jedi Order did
Ummm... no? Marriage is literally what caused Anakin to fall.
*Hit it and quit it!*
- Relationships and the Jedi Order, Padawon Handbook, Chapter 3.
Yoda the ancient Jedi would be ashamed of you love is important to the force!
It's literally a chief principle of the light. You see many jedi who embrace actually become stronger,
This is the first time i find yoda to be kind of the jerk in a situation , and the jedi in general for the no privacy and no feelings policy , i always found it stupid , they are not droids they have them and repress them so much they dont know how to deal with them
Mister Kirikou agreed
Exactly. Like catholic priests in reality. Lots of religions talk about celibacy and/or staying single but all that just makes people weak. Having a partner in a monogamous relationship is more important to human development than reading dumb books and following dumb rules
@@cosmictsunami it does not make people weak staying celibate. It's shown your testesterone levels drop with about 20% when in a monogamous relationship. It also make you less ambitious as you pour your time energy and creative energy into it.
@@ottomanpapyrus9365 When im in a relationship i bulk up more bc my morale is high. More muscle. Idk my testosterone levels true, but makes me feel and look better. Results may vary. And not to argue with yoy friend, but if you get LESS ambitious when in a relationship, that means you dodnt find the right one. Ambition isnt everything tho so both our statements are up for high debate but when im single, im weaker overall. Not weak, but not my full self. I even feel more free but thats just my rose tinted love goggles bc im def more free when single, but canr feel or smell the freedom bc im sad. Again, results may vary. And i certainly wont argue with science 😏
WHY ARE THESE LEGENDS?! PLEASE New Disney CEO let these stories be canon again! Just erase the Disney EU for good! Thanos Snap it now!
These Legends eventually become Myths should Disney sell Star Wars/Lucasfilm to yet another bug entity. And Disney canon becomes Legends.
Disney will probably re-canonize it with a minor rewrite that doesn't credit the original author.
“Feel the force, I must. Euphemism, that was.”
I just love the thought of Thrawn leading a reading club.
The lack of support when Anakin first came to the Jedi Order was a stupid rejection.
That level of Force sensitivity and Force ability at so young an age would strengthen with age.
The boy cam from Tatooine which as a slave planet it was known to be abusive to slaves and Qui Gon and Obi Wan KNEW they were pursued by a Sith.
Want to reject a powerful Force sensitive and maybe by rejecting him make him more likely to seek another teacher to protect himself.
They should have sent someone to see what life on Tatooine was like if they didn't know.
Anakin's mother and Padme were his anchors to the Light Side of the Force, just ad Qui Gon had become to be.
The lack of the Jedi's interest in people unless their was a payment or expected payment in either wealth or political favor made their problem.
If the love was an issue, they should have sent him to work and live with the Jedi Master who actually had a wife, so Anakin could see how the two were balanced.
And maybe they shouldn't have discounted Anakin's every expression of the abuse Shmee was going through that he Saw and Fore-Saw while the Tuscans tortured her to death.
They might as well have had a treatise "how to make a person vulnerable to the Dark Side by abusive negligence."
The dead Paduwans died an easier death than of they had survived to become the slaves of the people that Sidious had convinced of the Jedi's corruption before things came to a head during Order 66
They made Darth Vader with their neglect in dealing with a battered Force Sensitive and growing user brought before them.
The way Yoda deals with absolute is why the Jedi needed to die.
Seeing the Jedi Council react to Anakin’s relationship should have been what episode 2 was about
"Mmmmmmmhmmhmhm, watch I must, like it I do."
It took me a long as time to read that title properly
Quick question: how can you label something as legends, when the source shows Rex (a known canon character) on the cover?
It was written prior to Disney cannon. SWTCW was a project that began to really retcon a lot of pre-existing legends lore regarding the Clone Wars, outright ignoring most of, if not all of, the albeit disjointed and unrelated Clone Wars novels. It really doesn't belong in Legends because it creates a lot of problems, just like Force Unleashed 1 and 2 create problems with the legends lore. It sort of gets both titles because of it's coincidental relationship with legends and that TCW books appear in older legends timelines (despite the contradictions they cause with other books and material).
There's something so funny about the Yoda art in that graphic novel.
I think what Yoda does in his personal time with Little Yoda is his own business, TYVM