Montblanc Meisterstück: Is It Really Worth The Hype?!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 янв 2025

Комментарии • 138

  • @SamuelNaldi
    @SamuelNaldi  Год назад +20

    What do you think about the Montblanc Meisterstück?

    • @praveennanagaratnam
      @praveennanagaratnam Год назад +1

      Love it! The 149 is gorgeous but unfortunately too big for my hands. Love the Classiques and the 146!

    • @BuffaloNickel9
      @BuffaloNickel9 Год назад

      Meisterstuck 149 & Mod. 146 Piston fill must have classics! My everyday users

    • @nicolasmikah4168
      @nicolasmikah4168 Год назад

      Love it too! I have three 149s, each with different nibs of course.

    • @thirtycrows
      @thirtycrows 11 месяцев назад +2

      The only thing I dislike is the marketing bs about the precious resin. It's PMMA. There's nothing special about it. I'm using a curved calligraphy and this nib blows my mind each time I pick it up but I wouldn't mind if it was in a different barrel. For me MB is all about the gorgeous nibs.

    • @maximilianschwab9668
      @maximilianschwab9668 10 месяцев назад

      Thank you for the informative video!
      I possess a couple of 146s, one 149, a couple of rollerballs, and ballpoints. The larger nibs in the 149 make them definitely something special. I tuned all the nibs myself. I did not pay in any case the official price for those pens.
      MB was for a long time a company that produced excellent writing instruments, at some point they could not completely keep up with their renomé. They still produce excellent pens, I think for the resin lineup we should pay around € 200,00 to € 300,00 less, that would be a fair and competitive price range.
      The only real complaint that I would post here is the lack of the possibility of easily disassembling and cleaning the fountain pens. I like to clean and change the silicon grease of my piston fillers once in a couple of months, and of course, I like to deeply clean the barrel of the pens. That is not possible without taking some risks. That is not "up to date".

  • @uspedregulho
    @uspedregulho Год назад +100

    My left ear loved this video 😳😳

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  9 месяцев назад +10

      Ahhaha sorry for that man! 🙏🏼

  • @pac1fic055
    @pac1fic055 9 месяцев назад +7

    I own a 149 limited edition - only white gold and black. It’s stunning and writes beautifully.

  • @locophotographyofficial
    @locophotographyofficial Год назад +9

    i recently bought the 146 fountain pen in yellow gold. perfect size and feels great in hand. i love the writing experience with it and use it mostly for journaling. greets from thun!

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  Год назад +2

      Super cool! Enjoy it and glad to know you’re a swiss fella!

    • @locophotographyofficial
      @locophotographyofficial Год назад +2

      @@SamuelNaldi thanks! i also just ordered TOYOOKA CRAFT Wooden Fountain Pen Box With 8 Slots from your shop, seeing it live on your video helped me to finally order it 😊 i was looking for a while for a nice way to store my pens, i have like 5-6 nice pens which will now have nice place!

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  Год назад +2

      @@locophotographyofficial amazing 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

  • @lead-dog
    @lead-dog Год назад +12

    Great video. I have both the 149 and the 146. I love them both. Actually the 146 is my favorite of the two because I like the nib on the 146 better. My 149 has a B nib and I bought it primarily for signing legal papers. I bought both of mine in the 1990's. Lov'em. Thanks.

  • @varadharajannadarajah
    @varadharajannadarajah Год назад +10

    Meisterstuck 149, Black with Gold trim - It’s the definition of a classic fountain pen. I’ll buy one without hesitation anytime. The only glitch I’ll say is - Getting a well tuned ExtraFine nib is a matter of luck !

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  Год назад +3

      Thanks for sharing this! 🙏🏼

    • @nicolasmikah4168
      @nicolasmikah4168 Год назад +1

      100% agree, the meisterstuck looks best with yellow gold trim

  • @focusers1
    @focusers1 Год назад +15

    Samuel: You are part of the industry, and the MB 149 sets a high price for an ordinary tool. When I began to use a fountain pen as a lawyer in the early 1970s, the MB 149 (then often called the "Diplomat") was huge compared to the pens one saw more regularly, and the No. 8 size nib was an object of fascination. A client bought me my first 149 as a reward for a larger-than-expected award for him from a jury, and I rarely used it because I thought cartridges were more convenient. And I really was not an aficionado or collector in those days, just a user. However, in the next 50 + years, I purchased many pens as large as or larger than the 149, with gold nibs that were as good or better (e.g.,. King of Pen, Pilot Custom Urushi, Pilot Emperor, Pelikan M-1000, and newer steel nibs of huge size like the Magna Carta Magna 1000. I also have put gold No. 8 nibs from Jowo and Bock on pens that were designed for No. 6 size nibs. After that experience, I concluded that the MB 149 is a ripoff. But when Jinhao and other Chinese companies started making No. 8 size nibs (e.g., the Dadao and X159, along with the Jun Lai 630 with a gold nib). I became convinced. In terms of writing experience, the MB 149 is in the middle of the bunch. As you noted, it scratches and breaks. Moreover, as time passes, the piston filler does not work as efficiently. Over the years, when I saw a new old stock version of the 149 offered at $400 or less, I bought it, and I have 5 of them. I do not consider them grail quality, and actually, they are the pens I carry when on a trip where I might lose my pen since the 149 is so easily replaceable.

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  Год назад +14

      Hi Gary,
      i wouldn’t start comparing products like Jinhao to Montblanc and for sure not to a 149.
      As you said, I’m part of the industry and as such i’ve visited a lot of pen factories. What Montblanc brings on the Table is something else compared to everyone else in the industry and i look forward to all other factories going into the same direction (with their own USP). The 149 is an extremely well made writing instruments, with a lot of features and a vedy precise instrument. It also is a very complete writing instrument. In addition to that it provides recognition, after sale service (which the chinese brands surely don’t), and a sense of belonging. Judging the pens merely on nib sizes, or performance would be like judging a timepiece merely for its precision, while there are many more aspects that make a fine writing instrument something to aim for. Also let’s not forget that Montblanc produces a high quantity of such writing instruments without compromising on quality and making hundred thousands of customers happy every year.
      Thanks for sharing your opinion.

    • @BuffaloNickel9
      @BuffaloNickel9 Год назад +2

      @@SamuelNaldi Indeed! There is no other pen I'd reach for at my desk than my W Germany Meisterstuck 149 or Mod. 146 with the piston fill. It's feel is natural, like coming home to sleep in your own bed after time spent away.

  • @markcotter2931
    @markcotter2931 Год назад +6

    If I could only keep one of my pens, the 149 would be the one I’d keep. I can’t remember mine not being inked in the 11 years I’ve had it - the only pen that has never gone out of my rotation. It’s currently sat on my desk and will be my pen of choice for tomorrow’s meetings!

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  Год назад

      Thank you much for sharing! 🙏🏼

    • @vinaynagdev03
      @vinaynagdev03 3 месяца назад

      In 11 yrs how many times pen go for servicing?

    • @markcotter2931
      @markcotter2931 3 месяца назад

      @@vinaynagdev03 never had any serviced. All still working exactly as they should.

  • @CarGi_
    @CarGi_ Год назад +4

    Great video Samuel! Montblanc Meisterstück is a true icon among writing instruments

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  Год назад

      Thanks Carmine! Absolutely 👏🏼

  • @mikewinston8709
    @mikewinston8709 8 месяцев назад +1

    I bought mine in 1980. It’s still perfect.

  • @DrJRaven
    @DrJRaven 4 месяца назад +2

    I have a 149, and a 146, I bought them in the late 1970’s, and the early 1980’s. Are they worth it? Absolutely.

  • @toddmurphy523
    @toddmurphy523 Год назад +3

    I have a burgundy, smaller Montblanc fountain pen that uses either the added plunger or refill cartridges. I also have the larger, thicker black fountain pen that has the built in plunger. Both write beautifully. My two favorite fountain pens. The nibs are beautiful.

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  Год назад +2

      Glad to hear Todd and thanks for sharing!

  • @nirmaljena1830
    @nirmaljena1830 11 месяцев назад +2

    very nice presentation sir.....

  • @spnwang3505
    @spnwang3505 Год назад +4

    Samuel you really should post more contents, I’m enjoying your videos

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  Год назад +1

      More coming for sure ❤️🙏🏼

  • @evanrandolph5928
    @evanrandolph5928 15 дней назад

    Where can I get that pen box with the drawers?

  • @wybuchowyukomendant
    @wybuchowyukomendant 11 месяцев назад +2

    rose gold is beautiful on those

  • @MukeshGupta-mk4bh
    @MukeshGupta-mk4bh Год назад +2

    Good job, please keep making...

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  9 месяцев назад

      Thank you, i surely will!

  • @michaelbradley6488
    @michaelbradley6488 Год назад +3

    I have had only two, I preferred the nib on my 146 to the medium nib on my 149. I would love to purchase another 146 from the late 1980's.

  • @thomasmorrison675
    @thomasmorrison675 23 дня назад

    I understand the historical relevance of "precious resin" but can certainly attest to how easy it can break if dropped. Years ago the top of my ballpoint literally shattered. Montblanc replaced it at no charge, but good luck getting them to do that now. I have 4 Meisterstucks and am VERY CAREFUL when handling/using them and never leave them laying on a desk. Valuable lesson learned.

  • @SereneLongPier-op5en
    @SereneLongPier-op5en 9 месяцев назад +3

    Thank you brother

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  9 месяцев назад

      🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

  • @schweepy_g
    @schweepy_g Год назад +2

    Amazing vid. Coming from the watch hobby I've gotten the pen bug and finally pulled the trigger on a Montblanc Meisterstück Solitaire Doué Blue Hour Classique Fountain Pen I found at half off on the used market. Unlike my watch collection, I'm intending this to be my singular great pen... because I still have more watches to buy haha.

  • @darylsalazar8244
    @darylsalazar8244 Год назад +3

    I want to own one, especially the 146!

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  Год назад +2

      You won’t regret having the 146!

    • @bovnycccoperalover3579
      @bovnycccoperalover3579 6 месяцев назад

      Love my 146. I think the 149 would be too large for my hand.

  • @DrJRaven
    @DrJRaven 10 месяцев назад +2

    I own a number of MontBlanc pens . My pride and joy is the 149 fountain pen which I bought in 1976 in Sydney. My only complaint is I can’t put in my suit jacket pocket because it leaks. So it resides on my study desk.

  • @pedrol.5417
    @pedrol.5417 8 месяцев назад +3

    I use my Montblanc 146 every day. M nib, its a pleasure to write with the 146.

    • @Maddog494
      @Maddog494 Месяц назад +1

      Just bought a 145 diamond edition. Haven’t written with it yet

  • @vict2805
    @vict2805 Год назад +3

    Worth it 👌

  • @josecarlos11
    @josecarlos11 Год назад +1

    What pen holder box is that? it's beautiful

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  Год назад

      That’s Toyooka Craft available at Style of Zug.

    • @josecarlos11
      @josecarlos11 Год назад

      @@SamuelNaldi Thank you!

  • @cherrybrandy269
    @cherrybrandy269 6 месяцев назад

    I use the ‘163’ rollerball version on a daily basis and I must say that it is a pleasure to write with.

  • @banisaad007
    @banisaad007 9 месяцев назад +1

    Thanx for the review…it was trully worth…i have montblanc meisterstuck unicef edition

  • @michaelrowley1970
    @michaelrowley1970 9 месяцев назад +1

    Love the box. Do you sell them?

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  9 месяцев назад

      Yes of course: styleofzug.ch/shop-all/?s=Toyooka

  • @saadgandapore
    @saadgandapore Год назад +1

    Any pen that Naldi touches is a must-have and class 🔥

  • @mauriciolacruz
    @mauriciolacruz 3 месяца назад +2

    I'm going to pose and answer two questions to make it clearer:
    Q1. Are Montblanc pens worth the price?
    A1. Definitely NOT.
    Q2. Are Montblanc pens worth it?
    A2. Definitely YES (although collectibles ONLY at second-hand prices but in perfect condition).
    Or in other words: Montblanc pens are overpriced even considering their top quality. But they are worth it, more especially if you collect them at second-hand prices.
    However, that being said, I will also say that the quality of a Montblanc 149 is superior to that of a Pelikan M1000 (so it's not as overpriced as the majority might think). For example:
    The resin of the MB is almost glassy (like a ruby ​​when the light passes through it) and you can tell, not only visually but also to the touch (it's like 50% resin and 50% glass), that it feels much nicer. The Pelikan feels much more plasticky and cheaper, especially the cap (which sucks).
    Also, the plating on the MB is of much higher quality and long-lasting than on the Pelikan.
    I also find the flow in the MB to be perfectly balanced and in the Pelikan to be excessive, because in the latter, instead of the nib being attached (together/joined) to the feeder, there is a gap between the two which causes an excessive "hose-type" flow that causes constant ink leaks.
    Montblanc's after-sales service is simply second to none (they will completely refurbish a 149 with only the cap cabochon broken into a practically brand new one for less than €100)... They are always looking after you!
    Etc.
    Prestige is not only an image and an iconic emblem on a cap...

  • @Messi94.777
    @Messi94.777 Год назад +2

    Nice bro. is it better than sailor king of pen or namiki

    • @niceone2282
      @niceone2282 Год назад

      No. Kop has better nib

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  Год назад +3

      It’s different. If we take the Resin King of Pen i would say that the Montblanc overall is better Writing Instrument, however the writing experience with the King of Pen is one of a kind and pretty much uncomparable.
      Regarding the Namiki, we’re talking about a pen that is double the price almost. All in all i would say one need to have all three in collection. 😂

    • @varadharajannadarajah
      @varadharajannadarajah Год назад +3

      KOP - Only drawback is the filling mechanism and very low ink capacity. Leaving that it has the best nib in the market (better than Namiki even).
      Namiki Emperor- A pen collector’s life will be incomplete if they don’t get one in their lifetime.
      MB 149 - An all round star 🌟, will get the top spot !

    • @niceone2282
      @niceone2282 Год назад +1

      @@varadharajannadarajah Agreed but it's easy to change inks whereas we have to put much effort to clean a 149.
      I prefer vintage Ebonite feeded 149s rather than current ones

    • @varadharajannadarajah
      @varadharajannadarajah Год назад

      @@niceone2282 Those who use MB149, use it for daily works and mostly don’t change inks often. If you tend to change inks often then a cartridge/converter is the better choice.

  • @genegoranov5865
    @genegoranov5865 4 месяца назад

    I've sold a 149 and missed it very much. The experience of using it can't be properly described. It somehow epitomizes the positive in fountain pen. I used many trendy pens, but this one is so lovable..

  • @junalmarines9342
    @junalmarines9342 6 месяцев назад

    i like the pen drawer... pls make a review about this drawer

  • @klt479
    @klt479 Год назад +2

    There are multiple fountain pens at all price points that are higher quality, with greater build quality, with higher quality materials (brass instead of plastic), better balance, better weight, significantly better build quality, greater reliability, and a noticeablely better writing experience than any Montblanc. The vintage Montblancs are a slightly better choice than current models.

  • @ramontg5488
    @ramontg5488 6 месяцев назад

    What do you think of ballpoints? I’m between roller and ballpoint, but roller sometimes drys…but don’t know if ballpoint on Montblanc is like a Bic pen 😅

  • @d.martins4471
    @d.martins4471 8 месяцев назад

    i lost it when he said "precious resin" lol

  • @jamesgorman351
    @jamesgorman351 Год назад +2

    Badass

  • @frdfro
    @frdfro 6 месяцев назад +2

    It's always a matter of taste. I've tried the "holy Pilot Custom 823" M & F nib and it didn't fit me at all. No matter what everyone elsewhere is praising this foutain pen, I didn't like it at all for writing.
    The 149, to me, looks way better (overall quality, finish, nib, etc).
    It always a matter of taste (and needs).

    • @bovnycccoperalover3579
      @bovnycccoperalover3579 6 месяцев назад +1

      I have been watching reviews of Pilot 823. The fact that it doesn't have the Namiki name means it's not that higher end. But, IMO, the negatives outweigh the positive. It seems to be a very fragile pen that can break easily.

    • @frdfro
      @frdfro 6 месяцев назад

      @@bovnycccoperalover3579 the 823 didn't look "fragile" to me.
      But it's so highly praise everywhere...
      It's just hard to understand why sometimes. Like I said, it's just a matter of taste. I think the pen's great but the nib doesn't fit my hand.

    • @muallaemine
      @muallaemine 4 месяца назад +1

      This comparison is not a fair one. I have both the Custom 823 and the MB 149 and they are good writers within their range. But a fair comparison in many ways would be the 149 vs the Pilot Custom Urushi pen. And quite frankly, although I love my 149s, the Pilot Custom would come on top in my opinion

  • @thomasmorrison675
    @thomasmorrison675 Год назад +3

    Translation: Montblanc prescious resin = plastic.

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  Год назад +2

      Precious resin = Precious Resin - or i would have said plastic

  • @PrasanthPuthiyillam
    @PrasanthPuthiyillam 5 месяцев назад

    I have one but I don’t write anything as I type mostly

  • @burningmanmike
    @burningmanmike 9 месяцев назад

    couldn't get passed the layered shirts.

  • @XJarhead360
    @XJarhead360 6 месяцев назад +1

    I have a 2 MB fountain pens, a ball point pen, and a rollerball. Do they write better than my less expensive pens like Pelikan, Cross. No, writing is good with all my pens. Nevertheless, they are cool and conversation pieces.

  • @kerry1383
    @kerry1383 Год назад +1

    Voice audio only in left channel.

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  Год назад

      We fixed that in future videos, thanks and sorry. 🙏🏼

  • @MrFwlger
    @MrFwlger Год назад +3

    My right ear feels lonely

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  Год назад +2

      Yes i think something went wrong there, we’ll check and do better in the next video. 😢😄

  • @dab7963
    @dab7963 9 месяцев назад +1

    I bought a 146 calligraphy and a 149 both at full retail price and I've absolutely no regrets. Yes expensive but the quality and writing of these writing instruments is amazing. They also hold their value long after you purchase them.

  • @dr.stevenpennym.d.3241
    @dr.stevenpennym.d.3241 5 месяцев назад

    What is precious resin? To me? It's just a engineered plastic like ABS or polycarbonate.

  • @garciliofalcao7221
    @garciliofalcao7221 7 месяцев назад +1

    Meisterstuck is s classic

  • @multipotentialite666
    @multipotentialite666 3 месяца назад

    I paid 620 dollars for the classique silver inlay, did I get scammed.
    edit: it's a rollerball

  • @tonytony1349
    @tonytony1349 Год назад +1

    🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

  • @Paul-fx4hb
    @Paul-fx4hb Месяц назад

    People are stupid to criticise the precious reason. It’s a beautiful material that always feels warm and has a magic to it.
    Aside from solid gold or sterling silver nothing actually has a nicer feel.
    Lacquered brass is awful. It’s cold, heavy, clunky and chips. A big pen in lacquered brass feels like a parody of a pen.

  • @AndreasJankeEU
    @AndreasJankeEU 11 месяцев назад

    The best engineered part in a Montblanc is invisible: the market. Making Millions of muggles into corporate drones who think they'd need a boring black cigar of brittle plastic with just mediocre writing experience is ingenious! The pen itself just doesn't cut it and is far overhyped. Would be a better experience to grab just a Lamy Safari and if you want so put one of Lamys gold nibs on it.

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  11 месяцев назад +1

      Which is exactly the opposite of what i said in the video. ☺️
      Thanks for sharing your opinion.

  • @lordabhikingfisher8087
    @lordabhikingfisher8087 7 месяцев назад

    Yes, after using it for 20 years, you will know.

  • @ccooper8785
    @ccooper8785 5 месяцев назад

    "Precious Resin" Really ? 🤣
    You must be the sort of person who keeps rolex in business....

  • @salehelsileni3665
    @salehelsileni3665 Год назад +1

    🥲🥲

  • @mylogify
    @mylogify 2 месяца назад

    Is this even a question

  • @Cocos-u7s
    @Cocos-u7s Год назад +2

    Montblanc has serious QC issues nowadays...

  • @AG-en5y
    @AG-en5y 4 месяца назад

    lol common bro "precious resin" ?!?! plastic aint precious

  • @Penul15
    @Penul15 10 месяцев назад

    I have had a 144 for a long time and it is quite simply a piece of overpriced JUNK. Not only does it not keep the cap on - it falls off - and it's no wonder it was discontinued! I will never buy 'German Craftsmanship' pens again. Having said that BOTH my Lamy pens have performed flawlessly & written better for much longer and at 10% of the price.

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  10 месяцев назад

      I’m sorry to hear about your experience. It also makes sense that there are other brands on the market because of experience such as yours. 🙏🏼

  • @86stelist
    @86stelist 22 дня назад

    No it is not worth it! Buy a Pelikan instead, you’ll be more pleased and take your girlfriend/wife/daughter to dinner.

  • @Володимир-п6й
    @Володимир-п6й 11 месяцев назад

    sound is terrible in headphones, check micro next time plz

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  11 месяцев назад

      Plz next time come film for me

  • @mrobin1987
    @mrobin1987 Год назад +1

    All hype

  • @deshik
    @deshik 11 месяцев назад

    Is he trying to look like a turtle ?

  • @rajonrahmanrumi988
    @rajonrahmanrumi988 10 месяцев назад

    Your video sound quality is very bad

  • @wifeoflurch3572
    @wifeoflurch3572 6 месяцев назад

    At least pronounce it correctly?

  • @douglasrandall6737
    @douglasrandall6737 6 месяцев назад

    I bought 4, 149 Montblancs from internet dealers. And each one was a fake! Buy from a store carrying Montblanc.

  • @ismaelbonal6537
    @ismaelbonal6537 Месяц назад

    My only comment is: why do you pronounce the name as if it were French? It is a German brand and has always been. The "T" in Mont is pronounced and so is the "C" in Blanc (as K). The "a" in Blanc is also pronounced as an "O".
    In short, it is pronounced Mont Blongk, not Mon Blan.

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  Месяц назад +1

      Are you joking or serious? 😂

    • @ismaelbonal6537
      @ismaelbonal6537 Месяц назад

      @SamuelNaldi I am dead serious. Such brands should be respected and pronounced as in their original language. The same applies to car brands and watch brands. Exactly the same way the French get bothered for not pronouncing Cartier or Louis Vuitton the right way.
      Anyway, it is a comment. If you don't like it, no need to bother about it.
      Apart from that a good video.
      BTW, you pronounced "meisterstuck" as good as possible in German. Why didn't you do it in French like Mont Blanc? 😅

  • @billmorapedi4069
    @billmorapedi4069 10 месяцев назад +1

    no its not worth it japanese makes better but cheaper pens

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  10 месяцев назад

      Wow ok, so i did this video for nothing now that we have this comment 😄

    • @bovnycccoperalover3579
      @bovnycccoperalover3579 6 месяцев назад

      The Sailor is my favorite Japanese pen. I wish they would make a piston filler pen soon.

  • @JustAnotherDayToday
    @JustAnotherDayToday 21 день назад +1

    Your blouse is very offensive.

  • @renkeschulenberg1596
    @renkeschulenberg1596 Год назад +1

    No, its plastic-Bullshit.....no quality.....

    • @SamuelNaldi
      @SamuelNaldi  Год назад

      Ok thanks for your input

    • @renkeschulenberg1596
      @renkeschulenberg1596 Год назад +2

      @@SamuelNaldi i have had one, and its Not edel-Harz, its cheap Plastik, the pen falls ohne o the Ground and ia broken......no quality...they want make profit !!!!