DARK Season 3 Ending Explained!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 июн 2020
- In this video I take a deep dive into season 3 the finale of Netflix Germany's time bending drama "DARK" as I explain the ending, some of its unanswered questions and theories!
Follow me on twitter: / thinkstoryyt
Help me translate this video: ruclips.net/user/timedtext_vid...
#Dark #Netflix 
Кино
WOW! This show has rocked my world. I've been trying to get my friends to watch it but they just won't (LOSERS). I tried to cram a lot in this video, but I know there is a lot I wasn't able to get to. My apologies, or as they say in German "
Es tut mir leid!"
How is it possible to have two Jonas and two Martas? I don't understand. Smth bla bla Schrödinger bla bla. Help me to get it, pls!
For some weird reason i read that in richtohen voice from COD
I wish someone elaborated how exactly Claudia figured out everything about the origin world. She doesn't go into details in that scene, it's not explained on dark netflix io website. Was it completely theoretical, like Einstein predicting black holes? Or did she try and go to the 3rd world? Did she do some experiments?
Lol. None of my friends or even my wife will watch it either!
Same. People just don't know what they are missing out on. Only takes an episode or 2 to get hooked...
Remember when we thought the plot was just about Mikkel going missing? 😂
good old days
remember whe we thought that Noah is Older Bartosz because they look like each other, turns out they're related lol
@@romeblanchard3419 not just related but Noah is interacting with his father's younger self
I lost my mind trying to analyse this show😫
Or when we thought that only jonas and mikkel were in the wrong place
The entire show is tanhaus succeding in saving his son
Same thought
But he doesn't know that since in the end he had no reason to make the time machine. Pretty crazy and I am glad everything wrapped itself up.
That's right. It's amazing to see everything our love for someone can do.
Indeed that too he didn't Martha and Jonas did that for him 😅.. What we know is a drop and what we don't know is an ocean
@@RAMIC-tv1ye By inventing time travel he created Jonas and Martha who eventually prevent his son from dying.
Bartosz be like: Friend got the girl so I nailed his sister
THIS IS SO UNDERRATED LMAO
🤣🤣🤣
And also his grandchild. And that got killed by his own son because of Jonah's order. His wife's brother lol
Took me a minute to understand
Step sister😂
Dark: some german teenagers travel back in time, and instead of killing Hitler, they sleep with their relatives...
that killing Hitler theory was always interesting to me, because imagine if you traveled back in time to kill Hitler (or maybe baby Hitler) it could have huge effect on the world today. not only you might not even be born due to people traveling, escaping, dying, behaving because of war etc., but the war boosted the technology, science and medicine in huge way (unfortunately also thanks to nazi scientists and experiments, also most probably given the political and sociological situation at that time the war would probably happen anyway but probably in different maybe more destructive way, maybe leading to the destruction of everyone eventually.
Ending point, dont kill Hitler if you happen to travel back in time, because you could fuck up the whole world.
x340x You can't kill Hitler even you travel in time, time does not allow it.
@@x340x Basically the plot to command & conquer red alert
Felix Andrade would rather go back in time and kill Engels, so that the communist pest is never created
@@x340x It's a paradox, the whole reason you go back in time to kill Hitler in the past is because of the events he causes in his future/your past therefore if you kill Hitler he wouldn't create the events that caused you to go back in time to kill him for.
Moral of the story: Tell your kids you love them.
Before you beat them to death, stuff rocks in their bag and sink them in the lake?
or drug them so they won’t leave you ?
Or dont love them enough so you dont give them a bloody damn name,
but love them enough to keep an endless loop of pain and tragedy so they can have a life???
Before telling its raining outside?
Don't have kids x)
When they appeared on the road in the origin world for second I thought that they cause the accident that kills Marek and his wife, that would be really depressing
god same and i was like there goes season 4
me too
Nah I knew it won't happen remember tht scene where Adam and Eva meet and Eva dint die she knew something was wrong and it was diffrent this time
😂😂me too. I thought Claudia was the real devil
Lol same here! When i saw them suddenly popped out in the middle of the street when Tanhaus's sons car was approaching and losing control, i was like, ah fuck so theyre the cause again!... Car suddenly stopped and they lived.. false alarm
Dark storyline: A drop
Wöller's eye: The ocean
hahaha this is hilarious....
What we know is a drop, what we dont know is the ocean
@Demon Panda It was just a joke. Woller actor had an injury before starting the series that's why he has the bandage but as viewers thought that was some kind of special detail the producers keep it
@@qqq386 other world he had an missing harm too weird
@@qqq386
Ah, so he traveled from this world into theirs to set the events correct. Now i see
We're fooled to believe that Adam and Eva are the bosses and do the whole things for time travel.
In the end, we're realized that the real boss is Claudia who lead them just to save Regina.
Yeah
So badass, im going to miss watching this masterpiece
Claudia was def a boss. Great character.
so Claudia is Good & Jonas aka Adam is evil lol but season 1 show these two characters opposite personality and I never thought that Claudia is actually doing for goodness
Tanhaus actually did succeeded in bringing his family back. Just the fact happened without knowing by himself.
The same philosophy is in the movie The Fountain. Love is stronger than any bond. And it has the power to affect the past as much as the future.
I also love how they all tied this down into realm of quantum physics somehow, with stuff like quantum entanglement, the God particle and the whole thing basically being one giant quantum eraser experiment xD (ruclips.net/video/8ORLN_KwAgs/видео.html)
@Gandalf in Heels Interstellar
mindblown
Love is the only thing we are capable of perceiving that transcends dimensions of time and space - Interstellar
Great analysis. But just so you know; Tanhaus' real granddaughter who disappeared in the accident is not the same Charlotte we all know who is both Elisabeth's mother and daughter
That is totally fair and true. I should have explained better. Who knows what this Charlotte will grow up to be.
Can you explain this to me? Im very confused about this whole Charlotte situation! How is this not the same Charlotte?
@@Cat-oj5oj its not the same Charlotte, because the Charlotte we know is the daughter of Noah and Elizabeth. And they both are the result of the family tree that is the result of the two worlds that are created WHEN THE SON, THE DAUGHTER IN LAW AND THE GRANDDAUGHTER OF TANHAUS DIE (so he creates the worlds when trying to go back in time to prevent their deaths). This Charlotte is Tanhaus's granddaughter and when they die, he gets the Charlotte we know and probably names her after her "original" granddaughter :)
@@mariapaulamacedo4858 Okay first of all Charlotte was named Charlotte by Noah(Hanno)and Elisabeth beforehand..Also if you haven't missed the beginning of the third episode you will know that there is a man in a chariot whose wife's name is Charlotte and he is discussing death with his blind son who happens to the owner of Tanhhaus factory in 1888..The blind,old Tanhhaus..
@@shreysingh9327 Yes. Charlotte Tanhauss (the product of Marek and Sonja) is named after her grand grand grandmother Charlotte Tanhauss, the wife of Gustav Tanhauss. While, Charlotte Doppler is the product of Elizabeth and Hanno, which is totally different individual. The name itself, however, can be correlated and influenced by each other. Since, at same time H.G. Tanhauss loses his family, baby Charlotte Doppler arrives in his door.
Jon Snow: My family tree is complicated...
Jonas Kahnwald: Hold my jacket...
Lmao YES
copied
stolen
Hold my raincoat 🤣
Gold for you sir
I know I'm late, but the fact that Tannhaus' plan to invent a time machine and save his family actually succeeded (in the most twisted and mind-bending way) at the end of the story, is just beautiful.
great point of view, I hadn't thought about that yet
Not later than me! Loved this show.
So which means the chracters did exist since the couple both saw them
Charlotte's theory worked. Get them from before they are dead
Brilliant observation! I hadn't thought of that.
Fun fact : Old lady ghost rumor (when they swim in lake) in season 1 is catharina
Yeah
What episode?
@@kostas4590 Season 2, Episode 6, between mins 10.41 and 11.18
That scene made me cry a lot😖
Also Jonas found the Katherine's locket in s2e6 near the lake when he was sitting with Martha...it was dropped when Katherine dies and her mother was disposing Katherine's body
I think Bartosz doesn't exist (either Regina didn't meet Alexander or she did not get married) so he can't travel back in time.
Therefore,
It means he will never meet Silja and no Noah or Agnes will exist.
No Agnes means no Tronte.
No Tronte means no Ulrick
No Ulrick means no martha, magnus or Mikkel.
No Mikkel means Hannah never met him and found that one eye inspector and got married to him.
Katherina is single. Hannah got married. Regina seems to be single.
Since Charlotte doesn't exist so no Charlotte or Francizka or Elizabeth in Peter's life.
I mean silja would never even exist in the first place because she's the product of time traveling hannah & egon, and maybe the reason why is regina alone is because she would have never met boris/alexander if ulrich wasn't there to bully her.
Bartosz could still exist, but he wouldn't travel back in time. Thus no Nielsen family and no Charlotte/Elisabeth/Franziska Doppler.
Yeah so all the teenagers never exist
@@luciencastle2487 except for Bartosz eventually
@@uchikattana We can't be sure of it. Because of Bartosz to born its important that Alexander becomes a part of Regina's life. I think its left on us to interpret.
the whole show is a father trying to save his son and a mother trying to save her daughter
Wich is idiotic as it was introduced only on the last season as all bad endings for mistery series.
And there is Hannah
father also trying to save his daughter (Noah) - parents’ wars for their children🙃
Whole show is about a father(Adam) trying to kill son(unknown) of his past self and a mother(eve) trying to save son(unknown) of her past self
But in the end the creation of time machine by tanhaus actually saved his son's family...
You got a number of things wrong due to the fact that you didn’t catch that a number of characters disappear from existence along with Jonas and Martha:
- Charlotte cannot exist nor can Elisabeth as they are the result of a time paradox. As season three’s dialogue (H.G. Tannhaus with Charlotte) mentions, Charlotte was named after the grand child _he_ _lost_ - this is a different Charlotte
- It’s not that Katarina didn’t hook up with Ullrich in the origin world, it’s that Ullrich doesn’t exist! He’s the son of Tronte who is the son of Agnes Nielsen who was the daughter of Silja and Bartosz, which was only possible through time travel. So Agnes ceases to exist as well.
Others that cease to exist: Martha, Magnus and Mikkel/Michael (children of Ullrich), Tronte (son of Agnes) and Mads (son of Tronte), Hanno/Noah (son of a time traveling Bartosz and Silja), Silja who is the product of a time traveling Hannah, Franziska whomis also a daughter of no longer existing Charlotte
The dinner party group is a large part of the key cast that remains in the origin world...
This comment deserves more attention.
Fact, the narrator did not understand it all
@@Robinhudloom The show could have helped us out a little bit better.
There are elements of mysticism in the show. I think we are supposed to be left wondering if characters like Jonas and Charlotte are going to somehow be reborn (even if it's from different parents).
Exactly right Milton77. Thank you
Its really sad to see that an amazing Series is coming to a beginning 😣
😂
It's happening again.
Hahaha u got me in ur last word
Under rated
@@pritvanjara7017 its not under rated... Here in india not everyone watched english dubbed series but everyone is talking about this one
If dark season 3 had ended on ep.7 then the whole show would have been considered as an infinite loop.
In my opinion the car accident should have happened in ep8 because now it is a pardox and a logically contradicts itself.
@@immanuelkant7552 explain?
@@karmantuli.7454 He probably means what i am also thinking,that a perfect ending would be Jonas & Martha actually causing the accident,thus we would have the perfect triqueta,perfect looping between 3 worlds,beginning is the end and the end is the beginning. This way it doesn't make sense and destroys the established foundations of the show before the end. So my opinion is,we got another "LOST" ending,maybe even worse,haven't decided yet
@@BlackSheepScreaming Thank you, that shits been eating me since 4 days,
the perfect ending would be them causing the accident thus completing (& starting) the loop,
and if the writers really wanted to break the loop they should have properly introduced that certain out of the loop thread which is gonna break the cycle,
instead we got claudia popping out of nowhere in the last minute saying she have cracked the knot of infinity and this is all happening for the first time.
Especially considering how claudia been lying through the entire series and how characters trying to change there past instead end up stucking in the loop.
P.S. For me the end is when J&M caused the accident.
Immanuel Kant I actually expected that that would be what happened.
Was anyone else worried that Jonas and Martha were going to accidentally cause the car to go off the bridge in the original reality? This would have solidified the knot instead of breaking it, which sounds super depressing.
I was actually hoping for it, felt more philosophical - gods being the cause of themselves.
@@pabroj i mean it would have made sense, and it turned out those events had all happened before and there was no ending the loop, but honestly
i liked the idea that the families end up happier in the origin word and jonas could potentially have a normal life
YES
Yeah but they needed to end the show in some manner 😂
I started clapping when they showed up in the middle of the road thinking that would be the case. Should have ended like that.
Most importantly, in origin world.
Everyone finally had a bath.
yeah i had the same idea while watching, i simply thought that having a bath is not a common thing in Germany
@@blackmullet6237 /j
Man Tanhaus really caused all this shit storm just to save his son
He did succeed.
KEVIN VARGHESE MATHEW Yeah and he gave us a pretty good show. So Tanhaus pretty much won twice.
@@vansharora5859 no lie this show is the best show I have watched ever honestly. Plus I grew up in Germany so it was a extra cherry on top for me
AKHAA & TJ ya I agree this was possibly the deepest & best show ever made
he caused it without causing it
There is no ulric in the origin world because his grandmother is daughter of bartosh who travelled back in 1888 .
And his grandfather is Jonas and Martha's son...
@@ScionStorm1 Please explain how??
@@Venturegram
Jonas + Martha -> Unknown
Unknown + Agnes -> Tronte
Tronte + Yana -> Ulrich
Which means, Ulrich's Grandfather is the son of Jonas and Martha.
Hope this helps!
Yes this was pretty much the only one I could wrap my head around. I knew his grandfather, tronte, was the son of Agnes.. who was the daughter of bartosh so yes she never existed in the origin world. So no Ulrich.. ugh so mind bending!
@@rafikbenn1776 wait, Unknown is married to Agnes Nielsen? when did that happened? which Season/eps?
This show has played with my mind more than my ex ever could
😂😂😂
you mean your aunt?
Anyone else having an existential crisis after finishing this show
Yep
Yep
I was having an existential crisis after seeing bojack horseman. Rick & Morty and Dark worsened it. 😕
I’m just wondering if I already died in the parallel universe
The story about the women that magnus tells to jonas and martha while swimming is actually about his own mother... Damn.. 😅😅😅
Yeah that‘s so fucking sad and I wonder if anybody has known about this besides the mother herself
When was that
What part ?
Pretty sure it was Bartosz in Season 2 Ep 6 that told it to Martha whilst they were in the water with Magnus.
“When the water is clear, you can still see her dress down there.”
Edit: Then Jonas finds the St Christopher pendant in the sand, that Katharina pulled off her mum when she was killed.
Yes i noticed after watching the szn
This show is an inverse bootstrap paradox: the characters use time travel to stop (Tanhauss') creation of time travel
@@a.1.8.8 It won't be the Jonas we know. A different person but with the name Jonas.
I think that's a valid point if martha and eve stopped tannhaus from making the 2 other world so how do they travelled, how are they created??
@@a.1.8.8 Hannah wasn't the result of time travel,she exist in origin world like peter and bern doppler
those who are the born through time travel or by manipulating time do not exist in real(origin) world
Also its the creators who keep their audience in the dark even at the end
Even Tannahaus granddaughter name was Charlotte which is not the same Charlotte who exist in Adam and Eva's world
its just a coincidence which will keep us in Dark forever
Hey, I have no one to discuss this with. Can you answer my question, please? Isn't this world created at the end of the series a 4th world and the other 3 worlds continue experiencing loops? Isn't that how "time" travel actually works? From what I've understood -not only from this series but from time travel discussions in general- you can't really TIME travel, you just move through parallel universes, NOT through time. So isn't the universe at the end a 4th one, and the rest STILL exist going through the same loop all over again? Am I right? What do you think? Thank you.
oh, sorry, that line was supposed to be between parentheses.
My brain is damaged after watching this series
This is as close to 'perfect' as any show will ever get. Never believe anything else.
I see what you did there. Nice
The real mystery in the series is. What happen to Wöhler’s eye 😂😂😂
They tease us so hard at the very end 😂 so mean of them
It must have been a pretty bad accident. In Jonas timeline he had the eye patch. In Martha's timeline he was missing his left arm. I sometimes wonder if he was the cause of the bridge accident that killed Tannhauser's family.
Well... Last summer................
@@ScionStorm1 thannhanus dies in 71. He live j. 2019
I read a comment somewhere that the actor was injured before shooting the show
TS I think you missed the fact that Ulrich isn't in the last scene because he doesn't exist. He is the son of Tronta and the grandson of Agnes and the unknown which makes Martha and Jonas his great grandparents. Thus, once they ceased to exist so did he.
Right
Was just about to post this
@Expecto Patronum Yes and Agnes and The Unknown are the parents to Tronte so i think he means that ultimately, Martha and Jonas are his ancestors therefore, because they no longer exist, he doesn't exist either.
@Expecto Patronum Ulrich is Jonas's grandfather. Jonas is Ulrich's great grandfather. _Infinite Incest Loop._
@Expecto Patronum wtf !! Bartosh dated his grand daughter lol
I don't know why but the fact that the entire crux of this complex story lies in a father who wants to bring back his family is just so beautiful to me. Normally I would hate endings that rely on a narrative thread that was just introduced however there is just something so beautiful and simple about this in a story that is complex and "Dark"
It's not very beautiful when you think about the fact that he's hoping for a big event to somehow change their dynamic when he neglected his son all his life
Especially when he succeeded! Because he did that they were able to time travel back and save his family, without him even knowing.
So the theory goes like this: Tanhaus, in the original world, is God and his son and daughter in law are the original Adam and Eve. They leave away from him and die, commiting the original sin, which as we know from the bible leads to death and to exile from the garden of Eden (Eden is the original world)
This situation creates two "sinful" worlds in which Adam and Eve exist as sinners, as other people from the original ones.
Adam (jonas) and Eve (Martha) have a son (unknown). This son bears a birthmark (or a scar) on his lips. This birthmark/scar is the "mark of Cain". The unknown is Cain.
Also Jonas has Jesus like attributes, because he chooses to sacrifice himself, and everyone of the incest loop, so that the "original sin" can be cancelled just like jesus did in the books.
Great show. Filled with occult "winks" and the analysis on the occult aspect and meaning of the show can go on forever.
Eve's time machine is the Apple of Eden. (strongly reminded me of Assassin's Creed)
My explanation on how Claudia figured out the origin-
Claudia is a pure genius!In each loop she killed her alternative world(Eve's world) young self and chose to play both sides to find out a way for Regina to live in both the worlds.She knew to find a way she needs NOT to interfere with the loop and need to everytime meet her destiny which is to get killed by Noah in Adam's world. So that she will keep living through the loops, each time observing more and more details from the both worlds , taking down notes all the while maintaining the order of events in many loops until in one loop she wondered that the reason why Adam fails everytime to destroy the knot is because he has got the origin wrong.
After so many loops she was bound to think out of the box. She realised both the worlds are born out of each other and there isn't a single point/event in either of the world that could be recognised as the origin/initial event. Then what gave these both worlds existance must be an event which is a part of neither of these 2 worlds. May be another world!? She rejected dichotomous perspective.Triquetra emphasizes 3 entanglements. She took a chance by going to Scarface Adam and revealing this theory.
Few common questions arise after this:
1)Why did Tannhaus not build a machine to bring his son back from dead in Adam and Eve's world?
-Tannhaus in both the worlds has moved on from the death of his son BECAUSE he was given Charlotte from the post apolcalyptic world to cope up with his loss.
2)How did Claudia trace the exact origin event and person of interest?
-if you remove all the byproducts(people born out of loop) of the loop in both the worlds, Tannhaus is the only one who suffered an actual loss of a child( in both worlds), who wasn't connected to the loop or accidents involving the loop.More importantly
Tannhaus has got the resource-
He is the only one capable of building an apparatus/machine on his own without external help. (Schrodinger's cat metaphor)
Tannhaus has got the Motive-
In a way Claudia was the only one who could've understood the loss of Tannhaus and resonated on what he is willing to do to prevent it. Because they both are doing everything they can to bring their children back from dead.
All she had to do was to find out when(which year)and how Tannhaus lost his son and follow up the upcoming 33 years cycle event thus tracing the origin.
And this is the loop in which she meets scarface Adam for the first time to reveal all this hoping it would be the last loop she had to die into. And as we all now know it indeed turned out to be the last loop.
Agreed to every point you said especially why Tannahaus doesn't try to make time machine in the other two world, just because of introduction of baby in his life so that he can move away from grief.
underrated comment!
I have one more question, every time she decides to die, how does she pass on the information to her younger self? Through the book?
@@phsyco202
Quantam entanglement
Exist more than one reality
In one she died by Noah
In other she exist
@@phsyco202 presumably. Alternatively another way to look at it might be that in each loop the circumstances changed ever so slightly during the single moment when time stands still in the apocalypse. Over an infinite number of loops these changes are built up to a point that allows Claudia to realise all the stuff about the original world. I think a good example of this is the feedback loop for the matter in the cave passage. From what I gathered, each loop the amount of radioactive matter in the passage built and built due to half life, therefore this is a circumstance that changes each loop
Well done. Katharina couldn't be with Ulrich in the Origin World because Ulrich is a descendant of time travelers and part of the knot. Therefore he doesn't exist in the Origin World.
You right , but very nice review
Why can't Ulrich exist again? I thought that his parents weren't time travellers?
@@Cat-oj5oj Ulrich's grandmother is Agnes. Agnes is the daughter of Bartosz and Silja. Agnes and Silja exist because of the loop and so does Ulrich. Since there is no loop in the origin world, none of them can exist
Catherine Taylor lol did you even watch the show? It’s clearly explained
Catherine Taylor Ulrich's grandfather i.e tronte's dad is the unknown, son of Martha and Jonas
I literally have a headache after reading all these comments and now I'm more confused 😳
I almost understood the whole series but the question still remains unanswered... What happened to Wholler's eye?
question -
Why Erik oberdorf and mads Neilson were kidnapped and put in that machine, there was no link for that in finale.
Also fun fact - the UNKNOWN (son of Martha and Jonas) has cleft palate ( cut above there lips) because it's a neural tube defect and may occur when a child is born with incest relation.
Thank me later ;)
I think Erik oberdorf and Mad Neilson were the Lab rats for the Time machine prototype built-in the bunker and either they traveled through the cave or Helge kidnapped them using briefcase time machine. So both them are easy at disposable.
Erik & Yasin were simply collateral of causality they died because that's the way time remembers it going but Mads was because he's death started Ulrich descent down the rabbit whole for truth.
My theory is that, Eric is chosen so that the other teens (Jonas and friends) and kid (Mikkel) would come near cave to pick Eric's stash. It will be easy for Jonas to grab Mikkel into the cave and avoiding creating scene in the public.
Yasin is chosen by Noah because Yasin was close to Elizabeth (Noah's wife). So, it was just Noah jealous/to avoid Elizabeth's future relationship with Yasin.
There are reasons behind those two kids' kidnapping.
Mads Neilson is kidnapped and killed because it will trigger the events of Ulrich becoming police, investigating the body found in forest, suspecting helge and following into caves... therefore all the further events. So it was just to keep the cycle intact.
I don't think so Martha and Jonas are from different worlds so no its not an incest relation mikkel from Eves world never travels and I think Eve made that scar as the one she made to martha remember ?
it would be cool if Hannan said "Jonas if it is a boy, Martha if it is a girl."
she already knows the gender of the baby because i told her during one of her ultrasound checks
Why martha? She has nothing to do with Martha. She probably just like the name Jonah
I think Martha will be born later after Jonas. It could happened. Because Jonas is coming and if Jonas comes Martha will come. This will be their second life
Zikri m12 🤦🏻♂️
Orvin Tenn not happening.
When Martha said she remembers seeing Jonas as a kid in her closet, my initial thought was "oh shit, this has already happened then"
Meaning, they already did the same thing, thought they succeeded, but the time loop goes on
Yeah, the destruction of the twin worlds is probably another quantum event.
@Gil Barkan There is a doubt, if they (Jonas + Martha) already did the same thing (the closet one) then why Claudia says to Adam that meeting there was their first time?
And upon which Adam sends his younger self (Jonas) and young Martha to change the course and save Tannhause's Son and his family.
I thought the same thing. I wanted a dark ending so bad. I was DEAD sure that burned Jonas was secretly old Bartoz trying to find a way to have martha for himself and eliminate every version of Jonas.
@@dylandog1289 wtf😂
I think it didn't already happen. They might be walking in the tesseract
Putting the last paradox aside (the one that if Tannhaus' son didn't actually crash and die, the time machine wouldn't of been created, yet what saved Tannhaus' son is the creation of his time machine), Jonas and Martha did actually exist in the "original" word. Only for a brief minute or two, they existed. Even in the minds of Tannhaus' son and his wife, they existed.
It's not quite a paradox since their own worlds briefly don't have causality and they diverge away from the knot. In their two worlds, Tannhaus's family still dies and in the Origin version of themselves (jonas and martha), they exist briefly as you said as different entities from the ones from their own two worlds. They are now part of Tannhaus's Origin without a paradox. In their own worlds, every time someone makes a choice during the diversion, it splits them into more worlds, like how Jonas didn't die when Martha killed him because he did actually die in one world but not the other where he diverged.
Of course, feel free to point out if my explanation makes no sense
His granddaughter is the not the Charlotte who grows up to be the police inspector.
There’s so much missing in this explained video, I don’t expect them to get this right.
The one showed earlier is the police officer handed over by Claudio to prevent him missing his family.
Exactly what I came here to say! So many mistakes in this vid xD Iol
He better start re-watching the show asap, it helps^^
Yeah, I was half expecting him to say the Jonas that Hannah is pregnant with is our gullible jacket wearer.
Yeah she was only born because of time travel. Charlotte and Elizabeth are a paradox.
There should not be any Ulrich in the origin world. Tronte to Ulrich are all descendants of Jonas-Martha progeny.
The entire Nielsen Family shouldn't exist there as they all come from Bartosz
U are wrong, agnes=ulrich, noah=bartosz+silia(product of hannas time travelling)
So martha and jonas pregnancy does not have to do anything with it
@@zaidshaikh9619 Agnes gets with Jonas and Martha's unnamed son. Agnes is Bartosx daughter who he had with Jonas's sister.
@@zaidshaikh9619 umm they do Tronte is the son of Agnes and Unknown( son of Prime Jonas and Mirror Martha) in both worlds.
Still now we don't know how that police guy lost his eye and arm in the two worlds
It started by a man trying to save his son and ended by a woman trying to save her daughter ❤
For me, what stood out is the fact the HG Tannhaus' invention actually worked; no matter how much suffering it brought, in the end it fulfilled it's purpose of leaving his son and his son's family alive. The entire world we saw was just a tragic side-effect of a successful process created by one "small" man to solve one "small" issue. A tiny point, a singularity in time, created the entire Universe we saw between two worlds, four main families, dozens of philosophical questions and a shit-ton of confusing connections I that turned into lines in a big paper hanging on my room's wall as I tried to follow the plot. Between all of that, it also created a passion for us. Great show!
I think it perfectly portrays the butterfly effect too.
I think it's like the machine saved him from himself. He couldn't live with the fact that he neglected his son and now losing him is even more devastating. He didn't have to create the machine for his own selfish reasons, but he did without thinking about the consequences. His family could've remained dead without the worlds splitting. In the end, he doesn't change for the better. His own hubris prevented him from making the mistake but he would've made it anyway if his family were to die in another way because he learned nothing.
Technically Tannhaus' machine didn't malfunction. It just took eternal cycles of repetition to be broken which results in Tannhaus' family actually getting revived from the dead. As this origin Tannhaus will never know what happened in the two split parallel worlds he seemingly just succeeded in his goal
Yeahh
Can i know how it is found out that Tannhus's action only created these worlds. There is no sign of claudia travelling to orgin world also
kavitha Cog she said she spent 33 years to find the loophole. Also mentioned, to Jonas that she seen a world without him. Or is that the last pages of the information about Triqueta ?
It's kind of crazy how you can succeed in your purpose in life and yet have no idea you did
Wish we could see some scenes from the main world what went down
Plot twist:
Thanos killed jonas and martha
Batman and superman team up to save martha
@@contextualbandit 😁🤣🤣🤣
The Tanhauss' Snap
@@contextualbandit but deadpool killed martha
Also batman-why did u say that name....
"Love transcends space and time" - I guess that Dark and Interstellar have a lot in common. Spread love everybody!
3:11 no she won't. Charlotte was never Charlotte.
11:46 Ulrich never existed in the original world, because his grandmother Agnes (sister of Hanno/Noah) was never born.
Dark is the Mercedez S class of Sci-fi. It is the best time travel show ever. It is German precision at its finest. Even H G Wells will bow down to Odar and Friese.
@Paul I know 12 Monkeys, Travellers, BSG (Not exactly time travel but it had the larger theme of things repeating), Legends of Tomorrow, The Crossing, Dr Who (I've not watched this), Terra Nova, Some episodes of Star Trek, perhaps more
Although iam a complete failure in this world, i think that the other me in the alternate world is doing well there.
He is a drug Lord if I go by the name 😁
Or he doesn’t exist
@@AnkyD u nailed it 😂
@@AnkyD haa haaa😂
@@AnkyD 😂😂😂the chemistry guy
So, in the end the decision to make the time machine actually saved tanhauss's son's family...
For a second, I thought Jonas and Martha suddenly showing up in front of Tannhaus' son driving would cause them to crash.
I was watching dark season 3 then suddenly my parents came in my room I quickly switched it to porn bcoz it was easy to explain
Top kek!
Dark has to be watched in order to understand. No one can explain until u watch
@@seya_2 Mate, I think not watching Dark makes you understand it more than watching it at all *cries*
Imagine after all this tanahaus still makes a time machine 🤣🤣🤣
Mehnat barbad Jonas aur Martha ki schrondiger cat theory ki maane toh possible cheez hai, uska motivation kahi na kahi se aa hi jayega ya alternate reality main banayega.
Lol.. Tannhaus be like: You know what, let me make a time machine to entertain my son.
Claudia: WTF dude.
yes - the true moral of the story is: dont let a German clock maker get lonely
That's exactly what I was thinking 😂
his son can die later by any method and he still can decide to creat it 😂😂😂
10:26 Did Anyone else felt that jonas and martha will themselves cause the accident😂
I’ve been thinking about this “creation of two worlds” part (how they split) and I realised something.
The only difference in alt-world(Martha’s world) is that Mikkel never travelled through the tunnel so Jonas doesn’t exist.
Then I thought about the fact-what started everything in Jonas’ world. And it was this - Mikkel travelling theough the tunnel and consequently people trying to find him, travelling as well … and Jonas sending himself a letter that his father left and the map and telling himself about time travel.
And then I remembered what Mikkel said. Jonas BROUGHT him through the tunnel. Which means Jonas is the one who started everything in his world by his free will to do this. (He caused the existence of himself so basically he created himself knowingly).
And then followed by Martha also telling herself about time travel (her older self sent Jonas to get her from her world). And she already had that apple travelling machine. She provoked Jonas with the apple to follow her and tricked him into having a baby (see the parallel with the Biblical story) and then tried to keep the baby alive. Causing all this events to happen and the world to be created and keep existing.
So older versions of Jonas and Martha were actually responsible for creation of the worlds (I mean as a consequence of Tannhouse opening the portal - he made it possible - so we can look at him as this sort of like God figure) and older versions of Jonas and Martha = Adam and Eve. So Adam and Eve were responsible for the creation of the worlds (by influencing their younger selves and ensuring their own existance) but God made it possible. There’s also the apple and baby and all that.
I think Eve’s storyline is particularly interesting because we don’t get to know, how all the time travelling developed in her world and how everyone was created (like Ulrich, Agnes …).
And in the end everything is stopped by the younger selves of Adam and Eve.
And Claudia plays the role of “knowledge” or “consciousness” impersonalised. We could also say that she gives then the knowledge about their free will in the situation. She gave Adam and Eve knowledge about where their actions would lead them so their young selves would stop it. I just thought about how we can compare her to Jesus (if we are doing a comparison to the Bible). The young versions would stop it and clear the world of “sin”.
And she also sacrifices herself in the process but survives.
That’s my comparison to the Biblical version.
I’m not Christian but I thought that might be interesting.
Oh and another little part. As I said before if we compare Tanhaus to God (because he created the tunnel and subsequently enabled the worlds to create themselves) - on the tunnel it says “Let there be light” which is how in the Bible God creates the world.
Even though you're correct, I personally felt that if it were purely a biblical parallel it would be underwhelming. Instead I think we get a much richer philosophical deep dive
3:08 No. Grown up Charlotte was not that child. Little "real" Charlotte died in an accident. The adopted child named as Charlotte after that.
She was already named charlotte as she came with the clock
because it was passed down by HG to adopted Charlotte as it was originally for biological Charlotte. Adopted Charlotte passed it to Elizabeth, who passed it to adopted Charlotte and so on. I think at least. I thought the clock came up in 1888 or 1910 as well@@danielpereyra2290
When Matha and Jonas' world falls apart.
The infinite (Son of Martha and Jonas) ceases to be born, so Tronte (Son of the infinite and Agnes) does not exist, and his entire lineage like Ulrich, Magnos and Bartorz and so on.
Only those who are not part of the node remain in the world of origin.
The family tree was never supposed to existed and was brilliantly written...Not sure if it was ever planned since day 1 but man...This was a hell 9f a ride
The Nielsens, Charlotte and her kids, and the Kahnwalds after Ines ceases to exist, and if you think about it, the Tiedemanns are the only family who can exist entirely out of the loop
@@sbastianbrilyanto4722 why does Charlotte cease to exist? Shes not part of the nielsons or have I missed something?
@@sajivdoley6949 Noah is Charlottes father and Bartosz is Noahs father and since Ulrich and Katharina never tied her up in the woods then Boris/Alexander never met Regina so Bartosz can't exist.
Sajiv Doley Charlotte is Hanno and Elizabeth’s daughter. Hanno is a Nielsen, so yes. Charlotte won’t exist
This was one of the most amazing shows I've ever watched
What i really like about this series, even though it totally mind bending story they gave us a proper ending. This one is close to perfect story telling 🖤
I thought when Jonas and Martha travelled to the original world that they were again being played by Adam and Eve. That is to say, Jonas and Martha would be responsible for the accident of HG Tanenhaus's son and ensuring the parallel worlds were created.
There's an alternate reality where that's exactly what happened, hahaha
@i am the MVP Yea exactly there was a scene where Jonas couldn't kill himself because his older self exists . Same logic should apply here as well as the parallel world already exists
@i am the MVP Why tranhaus didn't tried to bring his son back in Adam's world? Just bcoz he met young Charlotte ?
This is the ending I expected. The Canon ending is so meh. The clock guy appeared out of no where. Cliché deus ex machina type of thing. Such a meh ending
Imagine if Jonus and Martha caused the accident of tanhous son.
I think the last scene with Hannah isn't implying their in another loop just simply saying in its own way nothing truly stops existing in some way if it once was brought to reality. A simple wink to the audience which why she smiled into the camera.
Right because its not going to be the same Jonas Mikkel isnt the father so no it's not going to start over again.
Hannah probably just liked the "Jonas" name, she named her child as Jonas in the loop without any time travel impact on the choice of name (so no one said to her younger self the Jonas name which lead her to choose it later or similar) so we can assume that Hannah like that name and it was her first name idea either way.
I mean, Claudia saved her daughter and that love for her daughter made her to find the answers and Tanhaus did the same. This show is about love lmao its fucking mindblowing
I'm in love with the end scene: The fact that Peter ended up getting together with the person he could not stop wanting and Hannah who was torn apart between different men who now nether existed ends up with a totally different guy.
Ulrich doesn't exist. And that's why you don't see him at the dinner table.
Bartosz is the one !
No bartosz no noah no noah no Charlotte therefore no her aunt agnes no agnes no tronte no tronte no ulrich no ulrich no mikkel and martha no mikkel no jonas no jonas and martha no unknown my mind hurts now 😭😂
@@dhegadheer2600 ulrichs grand father is jonas's and martha's son.
No jonas, no cleft lip nielsen, no tronte, no ullrich.
@@dhegadheer2600 Bartosz can still exist. He is basically the origin of most looped family trees. He's the ancestor of Martha and Mikkel, this also the ancestor of Jonas. Jonas and Martha then loop themselfes back into their own tree through the unknown being the Father of Tronte.
But Bartosz is the Son of Regina and Alexander, both being completely independant entities from the loop.
@@TheSorrel but Alexander came to save Regina from Ulrich and Katarina so if Ulrich doesn't exist then they probably wouldn't meet and Bartosz probably wouldn't be existed
@@tronalddump6768 True. I was just saying that its still possible for him to exist.
*HIGHLY UNDERRATED SHOW*
How the fuck is it "underrated"? It's one of the most successful pieces of television to come out of Germany in recent years.
Looks like this guy didn’t get a word in the show 🤣
@@joelgerhardt7097 its successful but not much people know about it
3:10 no this is not that Charlotte (she is H.G. Tanhaus's actual granddaughter and the other is police chief of Winden is Noah and Elizabeth's daughter- Two different people) they only have the same names.
Think Story, I've watched DARK Season 3 twice and I've watched a number of RUclips videos in which people have tried to explain/summarize/recap this magnificent show. Your explanation is one of the clearest I've seen. So A+ to you for clarity.
The great thing about this show is that it is such a mindfuckery that u can't even argue about the outcomes
Dark 1-0 GOT
True, the ending couldve been different but still fucking crazy because of the nature of this show.
I didn't really like season 3. The ending didn't really make sense to me.
Immanuel Kant I think it makes perfect sense
@@vansharora5859 It really didn't.
1. How was Claudia able to change anything in the first place.
2. Why does Adam even know that Martha is pregnant?
3. How can Martha and Jonas prevent the accident if they had never existed in the first place?
Immanuel Kant 1. Claudia found the origin of the knot, 2. Adam has been alive for 60+ years trying to understand what is causing the knot, 3. They didnt “never exist” they just dissapeared to avoid a paradox. The other worlds also dissapeared but its kind of like a new reality was created. The new reality in the origin world where time travel was never invented and so it doesnt exist in a knot anymore.
There are two charlottes. The real charlotte(missing in crash) and the adopted Charlotte(police chief) daughter of Noah.
there are 3 jonas and 4 martha
@@ulrichk3677 and which Ulrich are you? 😂
screw driver the k 😂
Remember at the end of S2 where Martha,magnus and bartosz talking about the dead women that got murdered and dragged into lake when they were swimming?IT WAS ACTUALLY TRUE AND IT WAS THEIR OWN MOTHER and also remember how Jonas picked saint christopher necklace and gave it to Martha .It was Martha’s mother (Kathrina) necklace when she was killed by her own mom.DARK 🤯
Best summary I’ve seen so far. Thanks!
So, Jonas is the great grandfather of Ulrich, and Ulrich is the grandfather of Jonas... God who wrote this ?? whooooo
Noah doesn't trust Claudia. Noah killed Claudia. Noah is Claudia's great grandson. Noah is Silja's son. Silja is Jonas's sister. Noah is Jonas's nephew.
How Jonas is great grandfather of Ulrich? Can u explain
@@akashgiri41 Jonas + Martha = The Unknown
The Unknown + Agnes = Tronte Nielsen
Tronte Nielsen + Jana = Ulrich Nielsen
@@iswandidarwis6430 which episode The Unknown + Agnes = Tronte Nielsen
@@ulrichk3677 episode 4, when Egon's wife was searching for Agnes and she met the Unknown at the church
I think you need to watch the show again. The reason Katarina isn't with Ulrich is because he doesn't exist in the origin world. Since Ulrich was only born during to time travel.
Its because as martha not existing in first place no relationship between ulrich and katarina so no ulrich in final feast one should assume may be
@@GVishnuPrabhaAA Ulrich doesn't exist. He's a product of the _infinite incest loop._
yes bro
@@GVishnuPrabhaAA Ulrich, is son of Tronte, who is son of Agnes and the kid(Son of Jonas and Martha). Since Jonas and Martha no longer exist, that is the reason the Nielson lineage doesnot exist
Sushant Sharma but jonas is going to be born.
Bartosz is Magnus, Mikkel, Martha, and Charlotte's great-grandpa😂😂😂
It was a very satisfying ending, I was crying and smiling with them as they were ceasing to exist
It is probably the best serie I have ever watched.
To be honest, I had a totally different ending in mind, when I was watching the finale. When Jonas and Alt. Martha travelled to the origin world to prevent Marek’s accident, they should’ve been the ones to cause it in the first place. That would establish the whole ‘paradox’ theory dark has been explaining for the previous 2 seasons, for example: Jonas convincing Michael not to suicide is the actual cause for his suicide, and Claudia killing her father in S02.
That would keep the knot never-ending, and a truly messed up ending for the whole series😄
Even for a brief moment I thought about the same. But knot can be broken with external influence is introduced and same is intended in the series.
That would be depressing. I loved the bittersweet ending more😊
My olderself told me to watch the first 2 seasons of dark again before S3 gets released to have a better understanding😂
I cried my eyes out at the last episode.
It was so beautiful and so painful at the same time..
God I love dark.. It is amazing and mind-boggling
Best series ever imo
Katherina isn't dating Ulrich cause he doesn't exist in this timeline, since Agnes didn't have Tronte.
There is no Agnes at all i guess, same with all other characters connected to Jonas and Martha, basically only the one in the final scene.
Why agnes doesn't have tronte please tell
Silja doesn't exist therefore couldn't have made agnes and therefore tronte doesn't exist
@@alessandraa1323 - Not only the ones at the table in the final scene,Helge (Peter's father exists),Claudia as well (Regina's mom),Bernd probably died of age same as Egon. Katharina's and Hannah's parents also,either old or died of age,etc..
agnes didn't even exist in the origin
it's still a bummer that we never get to learn what really happened to Woller's eye or arm (in alt world). We never learned also who Boris Neiwald really is. Who Benni and Torben's mother is? What happened to the real Aleksander? How Helge fathered Peter?
Well we can implied that Aleksander never meet Regina because she never got bullied by Katherina who in this reality doesn't know Ulrich do to him never been born.
So Aleksander never gets save Regina.
Well we can implied that Aleksander never meet Regina because she never got bullied by Katherina who in this reality doesn't know Ulrich do to him never been born.
So Aleksander never gets save Regina.
Boris Neiwald was a bank robber who kill the cop brother and assume his identity.
And Helgen, Peter, Torben and Benny are part of the original world, so their parents are not part of the not and their become better because of it.
These are very very minor tho.
Those circles DO NOT represent different worlds.
Now to make things clear:
Season 1: Time travel
Season 2: Time travel and introduction to different worlds.
Season 3: Different worlds and different realities.
If you listen to the conversation between alt Martha and Eva, you'll find that Eva mentions the outer edge and the inner edge. Two overlapping realities but yet it is the same line. Hence, the two realities, the one in which Jonas dies and the other in which he doesn't, are represented by the inner and outer edge of that thick black line. And, these realities keep going on and on in the loop. She also mentions quantum entanglement (you can google and learn more about it). Due to quantum entanglement, the happening of one reality(Jonas dying) ensures that the other reality works exactly in the opposite way(Jonas being safe and later becoming Adam). So it is the two realities in Jonas' world, one in which he is saved by alt Martha and the other in which he goes down in the basement, which exist in his world only.
The basic explanation is: when you go back in time and try to tweak something through the loophole, a different reality is created. So both the two realities keep going on in the loop.
If you still find it confusing, read it again, then revisit episode 7's beginning where Tannhaus explains everything and then read it again.
This show was brilliant! I agree, it's the best representation of time travel on film. I'll wait a few weeks, but I will definitely watch it again. Love your analysis/explanation of tv shows. When I find a show I like, I always check your channel to see if you are talking about it. Thank you!
They all just say "I dont feel so good" and disintegrate.
Nah, in this series they say "This feels great!" and then disintegrate.
I'm still so SHOOK that my song "Inside" is in Season 3 Episode 3 of DARK. This show looks SO GOOD.
@A Man yes
@A Man Pretty sure she will be dude.
Amazing you are a part of tv history,
holy shit congrats! this show is the best time travel adaptation so far!
when the friends went to the river...there jonas found the saint Christopher which got disowned during katharina's mother killing her daughter😭😭..also the dead body Magnus mentioned while pranking Martha in the river was actually there...it was there mother's body 😭😭
The ending song "Irgendwie, irgendwo,irgendwann released in the year 1984".
1st season of Dark got released in the year 2017
33 years gap a "coincidence" ?
Challenge: take a shot everytime Alt Martha (almost) cries
or take a shot every time jonas says “i don’t know”
Wann stay sober? Take a drink every time anyone seems even SLIGHTLY happy. Good luck with your ONE shot.
Take a shot when Jonas does everything as he is told without even questioning it, and then makes a sad face when everything goes wrong.
Add to that every single scene in which Jonas is awkwardly silent when being asked a question (if you wanna get alcohol poisoning).
with my BF we took a shot everytime someone in the show says "
unmöglich"
Fantastic breakdown and one of my top 5 fav of all time series! I’m glad that they didn’t over do it and make the seasons run through to 10 seasons and end on a low like GOT 😉 the creators, director, casting & actors made this series a top class show that so far I have not watched such a great detailed series. Consistent, engaging & all round success! I only hope to watch something similar that I will be in ore of. Think Story thank you for all your great ending explained. I must admit you are always my first search to see if you have covered it. Still have no idea why you are not on a main stream channel on tv giving reviews! Much love and appreciation. Fan from 🇬🇧! 😊
a very simple and concise explanation to the whole series and the finale! thanks.
Dark has replaced Lost as my all time favorite television series
I think I was most upset he never said what happened to his eye at the end!! Lol
So true !
That remains unknown
Last Summer.....
This is a fantastic explanation. I felt like I thoroughly understood it, but came here anyway to see if I had missed anything, and you cleared some stuff up for me about my favorite show I've ever watched and probably will EVER watch!
Just wanted to put this out there, with Katharina not wearing a wedding ring in the origin world at the end, the wedding ring is worn on the right hand in Germany, so I'll have to go back and check myself to see if we could see one on her other hand. Thanks again for this video, I'm off to watch your other video about Dark in chronological order.
So this is a story about 2 really selfish people. 1 refuses to end his life bacause he hates living in an unending loop but wants to take everyone with him to eternal darkness. The other wants to keep her Murderous son alive, a son who has never done anything in his entire life but kill to preserve his mother's wish to make sure she keeps living and therefore killing!???
So Charlotte and Elisabeth are each other’s mother and daughter.... that’s what I call a plot twist
So is bartosch's family...
Actually that’s known since Season 2 Episode 8 ^^
@@davidro8028 Yeah, what we didn't know until season 3 was that adult Charlotte delivered herself as a baby to Tannhauser all those years ago.
It's called bootstrap paradox
Jonas is the great grandfather of Ulrich, and Ulrich is the grandfather of Jonas
The Machine, did it really malfunction? From our point of view, it worked almost perfectly.
exactly
Though in the end it never existed. :D
Its so sad that Dark is coming to a beginning
Very good video, thanks !
Loved the series, but it's always good to get someone else's opinion, especially as good as this !