correction: umar bin khattab didnt dispatched khalid because of polticis but because he feared that people will belive khalid brings victory rather victory comes from allah.
Sir Roy Casagranda, your details are in depth, please also study the authentic narrations of Hadith ( sayings and situations recorded off the Prophet pbuh and his companions) which are validated to its source through an established chain of narration.
@@davissae it's not the soldiers but the general people who believed that... For this reason Umar decided to drop khalid from his position not for his political ambitions... He didn't have any...
Umar didn't demote khalid out of fear of losing his position. He replaced khalid for 2 main reasons. 1. Victory comes from Allah and Umar feared Muslims believe victory comes from Khalid and 2. Umar also sincerely likes Abu ubaidah who was a very humble (zuhd) leader
Its not because Omar thought that Khaled will try to be the new khalifa Its because to not let the muslims thinks that victory comes only with Khaled Actually the khalifa omar didn’t had interest in the the rule
For those who like to know more detail and accuracy about the battle of Yarmouk, you should read "The Sword of Allah". It was written by a late Leftenan General of the Pakistan Army. So, the book does not have any hocus-pocus or magic tricks in battles but rather the General tries to show how the Muslims win with clever military tactics, strategy, and logistics.
People started believing there is something with Khalid because of his victories. He was indeed skilled in the battles. Umar dismissed him to show an example to the people that victory belongs only to our Creator, not us humans, we are just his servants, Islam ended idolatry in Arabia, so idolizing someone goes against the belief. Also, battle of Uhud (muslims vs meccans) ended with victory of meccans because of Khalid. Him becoming muslim, the way he defeated Persians and Byzantines (2 superpowers of the time) in a matter of months by being present in both.
it's the difference between "macro management vs micro management" , Abu Baker was macromanagment ,Omar wants it micromanagement ,interventions in the details ,and Khalid says you gave me role let me do my responsibilities without interventions otherwise take the leadership to other leader than me. the leadership was taken from him to Abu Obadiah and Khalid then under him, were brothers without objections at all.
The ROMAN MACEDONIAN 5th LEGION the GREEK LEGIONS and SLAVIC as well as the Armenian Army made the bulk of the FIGHTING FORCE (over 125,000) ... ...there were also tribal Christian Syrian arabs as well .....
Actually Umar did not want to be Caliph no one wants it. It is not a kingdom. Abu baker forced Omar to be Caliph. He isolated Khalid so people don’t think victory because of him.
God Chose Arabs for a reason and they are trying to erase us from history but they can't erase our greatness and caliphates Once Arabs were united no one could've taken them@@MM-tw7pu
the Persians who are the shias they haye khalid ibn alwalid and omar and abubakar because they destroyed the Persian empire forever just as the prophet predicted khalid ibn alwalid was the greatest general of all time he never got defeated in100 battled ever he died undefeated SEYYIDNA omar demoted him because hrhe told the muslims yur succesful not because of khalid but because of alllah
correction: the reason which omar ibn lkhatteb has fired khaled is not because he thinks that khalid ibn lwalid has political ambitions, he fired him because he was afraid that the soldiers starts praising ibn lwalid that they win wars because of him in place of Allah blessings , because that is major koffer, that is why he fired him.
correction: umar bin khattab didnt dispatched khalid because of polticis but because he feared that people will belive khalid brings victory rather victory comes from allah.
That’s true,
Khalid was not a threat politically,
People start thinking he is the main reason why they are winning battles.
Sir Roy Casagranda, your details are in depth, please also study the authentic narrations of Hadith ( sayings and situations recorded off the Prophet pbuh and his companions) which are validated to its source through an established chain of narration.
👍👍👍
If the soldiers are faithful Muslims, they believe all victory comes from God. Why the insecurity Mr. Khalifa?
@@davissae it's not the soldiers but the general people who believed that... For this reason Umar decided to drop khalid from his position not for his political ambitions... He didn't have any...
Umar didn't demote khalid out of fear of losing his position. He replaced khalid for 2 main reasons. 1. Victory comes from Allah and Umar feared Muslims believe victory comes from Khalid and 2. Umar also sincerely likes Abu ubaidah who was a very humble (zuhd) leader
Yes, that’s right.
Its not because Omar thought that Khaled will try to be the new khalifa
Its because to not let the muslims thinks that victory comes only with Khaled
Actually the khalifa omar didn’t had interest in the the rule
Interesting
For those who like to know more detail and accuracy about the battle of Yarmouk, you should read "The Sword of Allah". It was written by a late Leftenan General of the Pakistan Army. So, the book does not have any hocus-pocus or magic tricks in battles but rather the General tries to show how the Muslims win with clever military tactics, strategy, and logistics.
muslim women also took part in fighting and pushing back the roman flank.
People started believing there is something with Khalid because of his victories. He was indeed skilled in the battles. Umar dismissed him to show an example to the people that victory belongs only to our Creator, not us humans, we are just his servants, Islam ended idolatry in Arabia, so idolizing someone goes against the belief. Also, battle of Uhud (muslims vs meccans) ended with victory of meccans because of Khalid. Him becoming muslim, the way he defeated Persians and Byzantines (2 superpowers of the time) in a matter of months by being present in both.
it's the difference between "macro management vs micro management" , Abu Baker was macromanagment ,Omar wants it micromanagement ,interventions in the details ,and Khalid says you gave me role let me do my responsibilities without interventions otherwise take the leadership to other leader than me.
the leadership was taken from him to Abu Obadiah and Khalid then under him, were brothers without objections at all.
Khalid doe not want to be caliphate,Khalid is a military man.
The ROMAN MACEDONIAN 5th LEGION the GREEK LEGIONS and SLAVIC as well as the Armenian Army made the bulk of the FIGHTING FORCE (over 125,000) ... ...there were also tribal Christian Syrian arabs as well .....
13:39 sent chills down my spine, what a way to end a war….two leaders fighting to the death….💀
That just shows how brave and honourable Khalid Bin Walid was
لم يتكلم عن كتيبة الموت المكونة من اربعمئة مقاتل بقيادة عكرمة بن ابي جهل التي كانت سببا في هزيمة الروم
Actually Umar did not want to be Caliph no one wants it. It is not a kingdom. Abu baker forced Omar to be Caliph. He isolated Khalid so people don’t think victory because of him.
Hey world meet the Arabs
You meant meet Islam? Arabs were nothing before that and even less now had it not been for Islam and those who obeyed Allah and his messenger
God Chose Arabs for a reason and they are trying to erase us from history but they can't erase our greatness and caliphates Once Arabs were united no one could've taken them@@MM-tw7pu
the Persians who are the shias they haye khalid ibn alwalid and omar and abubakar because they destroyed the Persian empire forever just as the prophet predicted khalid ibn alwalid was the greatest general of all time he never got defeated in100 battled ever he died undefeated SEYYIDNA omar demoted him because hrhe told the muslims yur succesful not because of khalid but because of alllah
2:54
source: trust me bro!
You must be a fatherless child who don't know his own history let alone Islamic history.
correction: the reason which omar ibn lkhatteb has fired khaled is not because he thinks that khalid ibn lwalid has political ambitions, he fired him because he was afraid that the soldiers starts praising ibn lwalid that they win wars because of him in place of Allah blessings , because that is major koffer, that is why he fired him.