🚩 Help support HistoryMarche on Patreon and get ad-free early access to our videos for as little as $1: www.patreon.com/historymarche 🚩 Thank you so much for watching!
Thank you really for your efforts A critic in the video Ali is escaping from the battle field with the cowards while we know that he was fighting and he killed anyone who tried to rise the banners of Quraish back then when the banner is up the army is stable. Umar ibn Khattab said according to bukhari that he escaped to the mountain just like abu bakr and uthman.only ali and his shias confronted the rapist khaled ibn walid
By the way, I never heard a word about the century old Armenian Genocide -- not discussed in schools, colleges or universities. These last few years, a 21st Century Armenian Genocide is unfolding as Azerbaijan starves 120,000 Armenians, who now appear to be nearly out of water too.
@Laurence Kueffer There was no genocide Laurence. Genocide is when a force tries to exterminate an entire population because of their ethnicity. The events that unfilded in 1915 prove otherwise. Archives in Turkey have been opened to all historians for inspection but Armenia doesn't open its archives for the same. If Ottomans wanted to exterminate Armenians why didn't they do that at the peak of their power, when nobody could have said anything to them but decided to do it when fighting a loosing war on many fronts, just to be more stigmatized and give the enemy a noble cause to attack more?? If Ottomans were rhat cruel to Christians why didn't they exterminate millions of them living in their lands and after 600 years of their rule you see the Chrisitans in Egypt, Bulgaria, Romania and elsewhere were untouched? Even in modern day Turkey they are still living. Armenians were once a most trusted and respected minority in the Ottoman lands and this was an official title by the way. Unfortunately they were used by western powers and Russia for their own agenda of weakening the Ottomans during 1st ww. Mostly France and Russia promised them their own nation country and supported them with weapons. While Ottoman men from Eastern provinces of modern day Turkey were on duty at war elsewhere, Armenians living in those areas, rose up and attacked Muslim villages. They killed many women and kids and elderly because men were at war. Ottoman soldiers from those areas (mostly kurds) came back and started taking revenge, killing Armenians. In order to prevent the killings Ottomans ordered an evacuation of Armenians and while that was happening unfortunately more deaths occurred, because of the continued attacks but if it wasn't for the Ottoman army now protecting the evacuated Armenians, deaths would have been much more. I hope you are a fair person and would ask you to read up on Khojaly massacre done by Armenian forces in modern day Azerbaijan where pregnant women had their wombs slit and kids were killed as admitted by Armenian. generals themselves. That was genocide! Armenians are hailing those butchers as national heroes!
The 50 archers were strictly forbidden to leave their posts under any circumstances, this was done precisely to check Khalids cavalry, but a large group of them left thinking they had won and the battle was over
Its literally took place in one of the first known battles - battle of Cadesh, then hittite chariotiers fall into looting egyptian camp, that allowed Ramzes to strike back
Masub (Who raised the flag and sacrificed himself) was one of the wealthiest man in Makkah. He used to wear expensive dresses and perfume , when he accepted Islam his uncle threw him out of his house without even a piece of cloth. Her mother gave him a piece of cloth he traveled to Medina stayed in company of Muhammad ﷺ for a couple of years until the day of Uhud. When he was buried he had a small clothe which was not even enough to cover his whole body his feet were covered with grass. Radiallahu anhu
@@bouhsoumare2571 didn’t Muhammad get 1/5 of whatever they stole or captured? And I’m sure someone who had all money in the world and left it all to follow Muhammad Muhammad would give A shirt to atleast I would expect. Especially since Muhammad said he was going to spend some Of his 1/5th of the money on charity
A thing to note here: Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) had FORBIDDEN those archers to come down from the hill, unless he himself gave the order. But the archers disobeyed our Prophet, and came down thinking that the fight is over. And General Khalid (R) was actually waiting for the perfect time to strike. Once the archers came down, Khalid sprung his attack, defeating the Muslims. We would not have lost if the archers didn’t move from their position.
I'm Muslim and read a lot about this battle. This video had details I never knew like the standard bearer being mistaken as the prophet and the previous raids
for your information, Abdullah Ibn Ubay is considered a hypocrite in Islam because he intentionally withdrew his men from the battle to break the Muslims morale (not mentioning him making multiple deals with the enemies of Islam) , there are multiple verses in the Quran which talk about those hypocrites and also there are verses which talk about this battle. as always fantastic work from this channel ,I also love the use of AI for those images
He seems like a very logical and sensible general to me. Someone who recognized an idiotic decision for what it was and decided not to waste the lives of his men.
@@faisald8821 How was the decision idiotic if the battle was won with 300 less men no less, had it not been for the undisciplined archers abandoning their post and exposing their flank, leaving it wide open for a cavalry charge? Now granted taking the defensive approach, which is what Mohammad and many of the wise senior figures suggested, would have been the better decision here; but that doesn't automatically make giving battle an idiotic decision as the muslim army had a good position, with a rocky hill protection their left flank and a mountain protecting their right, and a narrow entrance between the two means that the Quraysh army can neither use their cavalry nor can they use their superior numbers to their full potential as the narrow battle field offers very little maneuverability.
ibn ubayy was still bitter he was deprived being the leader of medina, when the prophet came to medina he was just about to become their leader when many of the notables died in a previous in another battle he didnt bother to join, in that time people of medina saw in the prophet just the leader to unite their warring tribes.
@@faisald8821 Yeah I worded that wrong I should've said "would have been won, had it not been for...", point is the battle plan was good, Khalid's cavalry unit was rendered useless due to the battlefield terrain and the archers placed on the rocky hill. Sure the decision wasn't the best available, but I wouldn't necessarily call it idiotic.
the words of Prophet Muhammad SAW to those archers were "even if you see ravens picking off meat of our bones, still don't leave your position unless I advise you other wise". Yet the archers disobeyed him in greed and turned victory into defeat.
So many historical figures had been so wrapped up in myth, religion, and legend that it's easy to forget that many were real people. Muhammad's life was consequential, and it's great to see this aspect from a historical perspective.
The lessons to be learned from consequences are an essential part of the religion if you're insinuating that muslims think the prophet never made mistakes or had hardships
12:12 The prophet actually warned his army that such attack would happen but they did not listen to him thinking that the battle was won and you know what happened next
@@thetrollslayer3716 Bro this is historical thing Btw it wasnt the sahaba dont think all the muslims were sahaba 😂 Edit :even if they were they were humans they arent perfect they make mistakes
@@thetrollslayer3716 yeah guess he had a full army of sahaba Small brain Your kind is why we are going downhill and our religion is being disrespected by a bunch of nobodies
@@thetrollslayer3716 first of all no one says that you drama queen The prophet says stay on mountain until the battle is over. but archer on the mountain (not all of em) though the battle was over, so they just get down and start looting and khalid saw this opportunity by move his troop around the mountain and attack on their backline which is openly exposed
There was also a female warrior Nusaiba bint Kaab RA , she was among the 12 remaining bodyguards , she kept on firing arrows untill the mecans retreat. She had fought 33 battles until she was finally martyred during time of Abu Bakr RA I think Edit: typo in name of Abu Bakr RA
Maybe at that time the verse about dividing loot is not revealed yet, so everyone get whatever they took Everybody is going to party but the archers are prohibited by the prophet to leave their position, no matter what and they can not stand it
Its crazy .... here Khalid is fighting basically a small skirmish against Muslim. And in a few years, he be a Muslim himself fighting massive battles against the sassanians
There were many more in the contest of being the greatest ever.... Dhiraar ibn al Azwar who killed 36 Romana at duel in ajnadyn and 160 in the siege of oxxyrynchs bahnasa... Al ba'ara ibn al malik;who killed hundred enemies in the siege of shustar
yet imam ali killed way more over 500 in one battlend he fought the greatest aran warriors nd was never defeated in battle but was martyred while praying
@@SyedRizvi786110why? Ali wasn’t commander in many battles like khalid was. Ali was the best 1v1 fighter, a duel expert. Khalid was the best commander ever
Allah prepared them for the cause of Allah. Who could have guessed that these people would conquer the most powerful lands inhibited by human in the world at the time.
It's an insanely rapid rise. In 625 AD it was still a tiny conflict between two remote city states no one had heard of. By 633 AD they'd have wiped one great power off the map, brought another to its knees and become the greatest world themselves at the time. That's 8 years later from the time depicted in this video. Another unusual thing, it was a southern conquest and expansion into the north. Usually it's the other way around, a remote northern people bursting onto the scene by raids, expansion and conquest into the south, Huns, Mongols, Scandinavians. Sometimes it's also a central peoples, Romans, Greeks, Chinese. But it almost never comes from a southern peoples.
Wow, finally you made a video on Islamic history again in the time of the Prophet Muhammad (Battle of Uhud). Thank you for your video. Btw there is an added bonus and maybe it would be better to explain history about the Battle of Khandaq ☺️
That's a myth. He was indeed defeated when he was a believer in the battle of mu'ta. He was called the Sword of God after the battle by the prophet himself. This was after everyone blamed him even though he made a skilled retreat. The myth of "undefeated" commander doesn't really exist, as it's not just about the individual himself.
@@soldierof-allah11 it was definitely a defeat, they were forced to retreat but Khalid was able to rally the army to retreat. It was no stalemate, they were severely overwhelmed.
first, I am very thankful, I knew this episode was coming, and was waiting for this one, and thanks once again. I am a scholar in Islamic History"Assiyar & Al-Maghazy", and Arab geneology"Al-Ansab" among other things, and your depection of the battle is very good, almost perfect, and I wanna share with you the details that you left out. 1- the reason why the Prophet peace be upon him changed his mind, and moved to pitch battle, is pressure, those who did not join the fight at the battle of Badr, even when the Prophet and the Qur'an said that the battle of Badr was optinally, they felt bad, so the pressed Hard on the prophet to show him what can they do in battle. 2- Abu Sufyan was elected as the Leader of Quraysh tribes because he is the only one who fulfilled all the criterias: * Age: he was in his 60's (unlike Ikrimah, or Khalid, or Safwan, not because of their lack of experience, but the elders were always prioritized ) * Family: he was From Banu Abdu-Chams tribe one of the prominent tribes in Quraysh , his father Harb led the Kinana Army in the wars of Al-Fijar.(unlike Abu Yazid who was from Banu Amer, a lesser tribe even with his old age) * The hatered of the Prophet Muhammed, because anyone who a sympathizer with the Islamic cause was kind of excluded from the tribe, like Al Abbas 3- Hamza radya Allahu Anh died later in the battle, when the chaos ensued and everyone was screaming his name to the one on one battle in the field, Wahshi threw his Javelin after Hamza just killed a man. Wahshi Radiya Allahu Anh recites how he killed Hamza Radiya Allahu Anh:" I was following Hamza, and he was like a speading Camel between the two lines, carrying two swords, I swear by Allah nothing stands before him, destroys people such a destruction, and I was looking for a tree or a rock to hide behind waiting for the right moment, until Sabba ibn Abdul'Uzza marched to him, stating his name, Hamza cursed him before hitting him one hit, that didn't miss the head, then I saw an opening, and I threw my Javelin, it landed just under his belly button, he tried to charge me but he collapsed before" 4- Abu dujanah did not charge the enemy camp alone, more like the whole army pushed the Meccans back, after their banner carriers fell, and Abu sufyan nearly killed, the Meccan army started fleeing, Zubayr ibn Al Awwam and Abu Dujanah spoke how they pushed the Meccans back to the point that they saw the women in the camp, running and fleeing. 5-after the Prophet was hit, and Mus'ab killed, the Muslims lost Morale, but then Anass ibn Annadir Radiya Allahu Anh rallied the flleing Muslims saying :"if the prophet died, return to die on what he died fighting for" those who come back pushed through the Meccans many dying in the process but the prophet at that time called them to retreat to the mountain behind them. once the Muslims gained high Ground it became impossible for the Meccans to attack effectively, they regrouped and a stand off started, where men and women recited poetry against each other. 5- battle end. when Meccans lost hope of cutting the remaining Muslims, Abu sufyan walked near the mountain and shouted: "is Muhammad alvie?" no one replied "is Abu Bakr alive?" no one replied "is Omar alive?"no one replied "at least we go rid of them" Omar shouted:"oh no enemy of God, all those you mentioned are alive and hearing you" Abu Sufyan called Omar:"Oh Omar, is Muhammed really alive?" Omar confirmed. Abu Sufyan said:"you are more trustworthy than Ibn Qam'a"(the one who claimed to kill the prophet when he actually killed Mus'ab) Abu Sufyan then said:"let's meet next year in Badr" as if telling them that another Battle is coming. the prophet sent Ali to see what the Meccans are riding, Ali came back stating that they are riding Camels. the prophet replied:"they are going to Mecca, I swear if they are marching to Medinah to fight them to our last man" the encounter ended before sunset, and two days later the prophet gathered only the men that fought in the battle of Uhud, and persued the Meccan army, to further discourage them from turning back and attacking Medina and Thank you once more. Thanks to @pakistanzindabad9753 : for adding the detail that Ali radiya Allah anhu did nothing t run from the battle, he stayed with the prophet all fight long, to the point that at agiving moment he was the only man standing with the prophet before the rally came and broke the tide surrounding the prophet
From a Muslim perspective, the Battle of Uhud holds several important lessons: 1.Obedience to the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him): The defeat at Uhud was partly due to a group of Muslim archers disobeying the Prophet's orders to hold their position. 2. Patience and trust in Allah: The defeat at Uhud was a test of faith, reminding Muslims to remain steadfast and rely on Allah's plan, knowing that ultimate success comes from Him. 3. Perseverance and resilience: Despite the defeat, the Battle of Uhud did not demoralize the Muslims. They regrouped, learned from their experiences, and continued their struggle for the sake of Islam.
Really well done to HistoryMarche. The video was really well done. There are some vital points I’d like to mention as well - Abdullah Ibn Ubai was the leader of the hypocrites in Madinah and came to the battle only to make the Muslims lose motivation. - Muhammad ﷺ had ordered the archers not leave the mount at all cost, even if they see the birds of prey eating their flesh. They disobeyed, causing Muslims to defeat. - Abu Dujanah fought ferociously against the Meccans. Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) gave Abu Dujana a sword and instructed him to fight with it until he was satisfied, the sword broke, or bent. As the battle commenced, Abu Dujana charged into the enemy lines and killed a soldier from the Banu Asad clan named Abdullah ibn Humayd al-Harith. He continued his assault and confronted Hind bint Utbah, but he refrained from attacking her with the sword given by Muhammad, saying that he did not want to stain it with a woman's blood. - You can’t mention Uhud without mentioning Talha Ibn Ubaydillah. When Meccans came to kill Muhammad(ﷺ), Talha used his own body as a shield for the Prophet ﷺ . Someone shot an arrow which he caught with his hand, causing his hand to become permanently paralysed.
One gets goosebumps while reading this magnificent history of Islam. No doubt, Sahabah Kiram (Companions of Holy Prophet Muhammad PBUH) are the biggest Mohsin of Muslim Ummah after Prophet Muhammad PBUH himself. ❤️
From this battle we learn never to run behind worldly pleasure while ignoring the direct orders of the prophet If you do this was is a great example of what will happen Your victory will be turned into defeat
There is also one important information missing here. Prophet Muhammad ﷺ gave strict order to archers about not moving from their position no matter what. He said “Keep the horsemen away from us, and be aware that we might be attacked from your direction. If victory was for or against us, remain in your positions. And even if you see us being picked up by birds, do not abandon your positions.” But they failed to fulfill this order. If they were patient, they would be victorious. Because Allah said in Quran 3:125 "Yes, if you remain patient and conscious of Allah and the enemy come upon you [attacking] in rage, your Lord will reinforce you with five thousand angels having marks [of distinction]" May Allah forgive them. They got their lesson and sign of Allah. In Quran 3:126 Allah said "And Allah made it not except as [a sign of] good tidings for you and to reassure your hearts thereby. And victory is not except from Allah, the Exalted in Might, the Wise" (Please do not disrespect them. They were human like us. We make mistake. Prophet ﷺ said "Every son of Adam is sinner. Best of them is one who repent")
Exactly ...... but it was not Muhammad but rather his uncle hamza , he told the archers : " dont move from this position even if you see us being massacred...." , but those idiots did, just to get their part of the loot . And then khalid ibn al walid entered the chat .....
@@SousouCell don't call the prophet's companions idiot. That's extremely disrespectful towards the companion whose intentions were good even though they do it in the wrong time.
@@SousouCell you're saying Abdullah ibn Jubair (RA) was regular soldier? This is ridiculous. Show me the shahih hadiths that says the archers weren't prophet's companions!
@@komododragon410 I remember learning about this battle when i was a child. When my father said we will be visiting Medina and climbing the Archers' Hill, I was terrified. I thought Quraysh was still there awaiting more Muslims to kill
it probably wouldnt work because not much actual fighting happened from what I read the main fighting happened between the inhabitants of medina in the form of infighting and there was a bit of political intrigue in the form of the muslims and the banu quraydah
It was actually the Prophet Muhammad`s idea to engage in an Urban combat but many of his men pushed him to fight the meccans in an open area due to their pride thinking they would look like cowards if they didn`t meet the meccans on the battlefield. Later on close to the confrontation they changed their minds and told the Prophet Muhammad that his idea of urban combat was actually the better decision but the Prophet reprimanded them for their indecisiveness and ordered them to move out.
I'm sure that's how he told the story afterwards, also prob left out the cowering under dead bodies too. History is written by the victors no matter how deserving they really are
@@caracal9458 if that was the case then we would have many different accounts from people telling a different version like it mostly happens when some people rewrite history but we only have one version that is agreed upon by everyone so you're wrong
@@socitsgoodlol, well the bibble says over 500 people saw zombie jesus rise from the dead. And there's only one version and it's agreed upon by everyone. Therefore, it's true. BOOM! Irrefutable argument, at least according to your own criteria. 😂
@Caracal a mere personal opinion of yours. There has been no hiding the fact that the prophet was fiercly defended by his guards. To cower under bodies is just a conclusion made by the channel. How can someone cower from that much larger number of opponents? He would have been killed by the stampede, especially after being hit already. Not mentioning that hiding to protect oneself was already exercised by the prophet so no shame would be in that. Furthermore, the meccans didn't retreat because they knew they killed him. There was a whole post-battle speech between the 2 armies, where the meccans were boasting avout their victory; which was the point. They wanted a win for prestige.
Towards the end, you may have missed a few points. The prophet(s.a.w.s) was engrossed in a heavy defensive combat and they were badly pressed and Ali(r.a.) came with a huge rescue almost single handedly. The Meccans were surprised out of their wits and backed off seeing that the field was won and no further damage could be done.
@@MM34173 Heraclius: (to translator): Tell him I asked him about his lineage and he said he is noble. It is the same with the lineage of the messengers within their people. I asked him if anyone before him had had the same pretension and he told me no. Because, if someone before him had had the same pretension, I could have believed that he only wanted to renew what someone else had already accomplished. I asked him if there were kings among his ancestors and he told me no. I said to myself: If there was a king among his ancestors, I might think that he was seeking to reclaim his father's throne. I asked him if they called him a liar before he had to introduce himself as a prophet and he told me no. Now I understood from this that if he was not the man to lie towards his fellow men, he could not, even more so, lie towards God. I asked him if it is the nobles who follow him or the common people and he answered the common people, but these are the very people who always follow the messengers. I asked him if those who follow him increase in number or regress, and he answered me that they progress, but that is the nature of faith which is to grow until it reaches completeness. I asked him if there were any among his disciples who apostatized out of aversion and he told me no, but that is indeed what faith is like, when its sweet flavor meets hearts. I asked him if he was betraying, he told me no, but this is the behavior of messengers, they never betray. I asked him if they fought each other, and he told me yes and that the fights between you had alternatives, sometimes to his advantage and sometimes to theirs. It is like this with the prophets, they undergo trials, but success and final success come to them. I asked him what he commands them and he replied that he commands them to worship God without associating anything with him, to abstain from worshiping idols, to pray, to cultivate sincerity and chastity. . Tell him if everything he told me is true, he will be master of the place where my feet are trodden. I knew that a prophet was going to appear, but I did not imagine that it would come from you. reported by Bukhari, Ibn 'Abbâs said to have been informed by Abû Sufyan ibn Harb of the dialogue which took place between him and the emperor Heraclius
I personally have visited the place where the battle took place. The Uhud mountain is large and majestic providing a perfect cover for one of the flanks. The small hill where the archers were placed is a very small easily climbable hill and shows the genius of Prophet Muhammad PBUH to protect the flank. There is a huge mosque now on its place showing that the ultimate and timeless victory was reserved for the Holy Prophet.
man really waited for the whole army to crumble before absolutely smiting with that cavalry charge, you might have even thought he was indecisive, but man knew exactly what he was going.
Well, he soon converted to Islam, & became one of the most successful generals of all times (conquering the entire Persian empire; and the Levant & Palestine from Romans).
Khalid bin Al waleed's (ra) attack on the flank at the right time was a masterpiece but after his attack he waited again on the flank for the meccans to come to launch the second attack that was an absolute genius
There's so much to learn from History! The battles, politics, archaeology etc. Thank you HM for covering such a crucial topic in the best quality possible ❤
Prophet was incredible in every aspect...He was genius in strategy as well...We Muslims are more focused of religious aspects of Prophet..I never knew he was also a incredible strategist in battles.
Unfortunately, some people neglected that he was a very brilliant leader and a fierce fighter, and he founded a divine state, but some (cute Muslims) focused only on his mercy.
@@MM34173that's such an incredible way to put it, some never have a thought that the prophet PBUH was a strong man 😂😂, "cute muslims" i laughed soo hard but its true!
Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) was a genius, he is not only a prophet. His life exemplifies the integration of various responsibilities, demonstrating how one individual can excel in multiple domains. As a merchant, prophet, preacher, social reformer, teacher, lawgiver, head of state and government, commander-in-chief, and diplomat, Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) left an indelible mark on history, shaping the course of human civilization.
@@MM34173no he wasnt he got completely rolled in most battles he fought and the only records of him are from a religous book he made? Thats like saying jesus was actually able to heal people because his religous book said so,
I have been on the place mountain Uhud. 70 martyrs are burried there including Hamza i have seen where they are burried. This battle is a valuable lesson that muslims have learned till this day. When Prophet Muhammed says or order something you gotta follow no matter what. If you follow him you will be victorious in this life and in the next. He orderd his archers on the small hill never ever leave your positions you guys must stay on your positions to protect our flank. The archers went on helping looting the camp and left there positions and then Meccans cavalary whit commander Ibn Walid attacked from the flanks. Prophet Muhammed mournd a lot about his losses on this battle especialy about his uncle Hamza.
In a recent trip to Medina, I have visited Mt. Uhud and climbed the mountain of arrows, where the archers stood. It was a great feeling. Unfortunately, I didn't have time to visit the Martyrs of this battle as our bus was about to leave.
You must use video to record it 😀😀😀, I watched the journey to cave Hira and cave tsur, thanks to certain youtuber, as if I am the one who did the journey
I learned this differently as a Muslim kid here’s my narrative: Before the battle started Muhammad’s Scouts saw Khalid Ibn walids contingent and Muhammad assembled a archer force on the mountain and told them if they broke rank they could be flanked, And the reason why they broke rank wasn’t to loot but, They thought the battle had ended and they won and so they began dispersing of the mountain to celebrate with the main infantry army
I am a Muslim as well and this video matches the history we've been taught. The archers indeed went after looting despite having orders not to leave the mountain which turned the battle from a win to loss. It was a good lesson for Muslims to remind them that they fight for Allah not for loot and richess.
I cover this every semester when I reach my History of the Middle East class. I never have time to do a deep dive into the battle. Have you done one on the Battle of Badr? I have a quick overview on my channel on all this but nice to give my students a place to go with more details if they want to watch on their own.
@HistoryMarche excellent. I like to add supplemental materials. I teach survey classes and sometimes don't have time to go into all the battle details.
@@Fallout3131 if you live in California! You can take my online classes at Cypress College. That is where I teach. Also, all my lectures are on my RUclips channel 😊
I heard that Because Ubay left with 300 men, Meccan scouts thought Muhammad sent them as a reserve to protect Medina, so when They heard Muhammad was dead, they were reluctant to push any longer fearing a fresh reserve army would arrive.
Watched all your history videos as I consider it as a masterpiece storytelling . Greatly appreciate you respecting our belief not putting any face on our beloved Prophet Muhammad PBUH. Love from Malaysia!
From Uhud to Yarmouk, what a legendary journey had it been for one the greatest ever to bless the field of battle with his presence, "Sword of Allah" Khalid ibn Walid 🤍
@@williamrobert9898 Lol, of course they should be in that list, but I was thinking maybe Alexander and Genghis Khan are almost in a league of their own, haha.
I would recommend the full story to anyone, small example: at 13:57 it was mentioned he was "cut down" here are some of the details. but he was fighting one only one hand one of the strongest fighters (so he doesnt drop the banner) until his arm was cut off, he tried to defend but his second arm was cut off, so he picked up the banner with what remains of his arms. then finally he was killed.
I always keep waiting for your videos . These videos are one of my favourites. Being so intrested in history, i really love your work. Thank you for such a great content 😌
Alhumduliah, its here ! Also, this is why you don't disobey orders to hold a vital position during battle. You're just opening the door for the enemy to hit you where you're weakest.
interesting video, thank you, just a thing I think you missed was that during the last stand of Muslims protecting prophet Muhammad in battle of uhud one of the main persons who remained protecting him was "Ali ibn abitalib" taking several wounds doing that but in the video you showed him among the retreating group
There's also another is that hamza(RA) death wasn't from the beginning of the battle but when the Quraish running away and the Muslims chased them And another is that abu Sufyan(RA) knew that prophet Muhammad is still alive when they hide on the hill.
@@adamryamizard5560 exactly our Prophet saww ordered his men to chase the meccans so that it would look that the muslims have lost it morally and psychologically it would look muslims r still very much alive in their struggle n wouldnt give in just like that
I swear I watched the battle of Badr video only yesterday and was like ahh, there's no quality vid on the battle of Uhud in this format and I was like maybe one dayyyy. And today HistoryMarche delivered lol
After that, he became one of the Muslims leader and was martyred in the Battle of Yarmouk. The story of his martyrdom is a great one (may Allah be pleased with him).
the man who harmed the prophet with the sword was killed in pieces by a forest animal with its horn. the woman and the slave who killed hamza all converted to islam. abu sofyan is converted after. the man who had the plan to win the battle also converted to Islam and became like a semper soldier, then after years became the sword of Allah which allowed him to conquer Persia and Byzantine Roman.
Heraclius: (to translator): Tell him I asked him about his lineage and he said he is noble. It is the same with the lineage of the messengers within their people. I asked him if anyone before him had had the same pretension and he told me no. Because, if someone before him had had the same pretension, I could have believed that he only wanted to renew what someone else had already accomplished. I asked him if there were kings among his ancestors and he told me no. I said to myself: If there was a king among his ancestors, I might think that he was seeking to reclaim his father's throne. I asked him if they called him a liar before he had to introduce himself as a prophet and he told me no. Now I understood from this that if he was not the man to lie towards his fellow men, he could not, even more so, lie towards God. I asked him if it is the nobles who follow him or the common people and he answered the common people, but these are the very people who always follow the messengers. I asked him if those who follow him increase in number or regress, and he answered me that they progress, but that is the nature of faith which is to grow until it reaches completeness. I asked him if there were any among his disciples who apostatized out of aversion and he told me no, but that is indeed what faith is like, when its sweet flavor meets hearts. I asked him if he was betraying, he told me no, but this is the behavior of messengers, they never betray. I asked him if they fought each other, and he told me yes and that the fights between you had alternatives, sometimes to his advantage and sometimes to theirs. It is like this with the prophets, they undergo trials, but success and final success come to them. I asked him what he commands them and he replied that he commands them to worship God without associating anything with him, to abstain from worshiping idols, to pray, to cultivate sincerity and chastity. . Tell him if everything he told me is true, he will be master of the place where my feet are trodden. I knew that a prophet was going to appear, but I did not imagine that it would come from you. reported by Bukhari, Ibn 'Abbâs said to have been informed by Abû Sufyan ibn Harb of the dialogue which took place between him and the emperor Heraclius
I feel so grateful for your content about this battle. I learn so much more from your videos rather than the literature provided in my school. And it's a shame, really. I'm a muslim yet almost every book provided at my school that telling this battle are so little in details, and only emphasizes on the blunder of the greed to plundering the enemy. I never knew the rough map of this battle, I never knew how the the both armies are positioned, and I never knew when exactly that battle happen. I'm very glad for your video. Truly, you've done a great thing.
Good quality stuff. The details are a bit different from what I read since childhood but still in line with the facts. I always tried to imagine the details of this event but thanks to HistoryMarche I can see a very good version with open eyes. Thanks.
@@jawaidiqbalkhalil Hahahahahhahahah, what a joke. Khalid wouldnt even get close to Imam Ali (AS) in the battle of UHUD because he knew he would get himself killed. You Sunnis lie to yourself so you can sleep at night 🤣
Thanks a lot for such dedication and information you showed. A clear concept of the war is what I have learned. Make sure you make more of these videos in future.
Khalid Ibn walid who fought against Muslims here, next will be known as Sword of Allah and one of the best if not the best commander in entire Islamic history
@@mantheman11 the man who harmed the prophet with the sword was killed in pieces by a forest animal with its horn. the woman and the slave who killed hamza all converted to islam. abu sofyan is converted after. the man who had the plan to win the battle also converted to Islam and became like a semper soldier, then after years became the sword of Allah which allowed him to conquer Persia and Byzantine Roman.
You didn’t mention that the prophet PBUH, gave specific order for the archers not to leave the hill, but they disobeyed him because of greediness to loot and Khalid immediately capitalized.
I am a hindu, and don't know anything about muslim history. It is not taught anywhere. I think it is important to tell things like stories in schools.Not as a religious text but just what you know that has happened in past.
@@alexanderchronos8694 even in case of mughals and all, battles aren't taught. Instead they yap about art and culture and palace designs. No politics or war.
An amazing depiction of historical battles, but little to none had been covered about how bravely Maulana Ali fought, he stood till the last, and killed down lines of enemies while being surrounded by Meccans.
Love you videos ! Started watching you a month ago and I must say, this is the one of the most entertaining and informative content on youtube, the voice over and storytelling are BBC documentaries level, please keep going ❤
Great work as usual. You forgot to mention that when deploying the archers Mohammed ordered them to keep their position even if they see the Muslim army getting slaughtered.(He said that literally) and the reason why they left their position is that they thought the battle was over and feared that they wont get any loots. For correction , the hill of arrows is actually the hill of archers.
I don't understand why they fear they wouldn't get any loot. Its not like the loot can walk on its own 😂. If only they wait it out until evening time 😂😂 And it was clear all loot would be given out fairly so its not a first come first serve buffet 😂
14:30 Littel detail here, Meccan did think they Killed Prophet(PBUH) but they were ensured at the last time by Umar Ibn Al Khattab that Prophet is Alive.
Tears in my eyes 😢😢😢 may peace and blessings of Allah the exalted be upon Muhammad and his family and his companions. Aameen. May Allah the exalted bless you with Al Islam brother orator. Aameen
@@danialhalal :- ) sure. That's why you cannot mention any testable claim about the "truth". Ice is real. It exists. If an old dude in a HOT area rejects the legend of "Rock Water", I can show him a freezer. He can reject ice till his brain explodes, but the glass of water still freezes in his hands. Every. Single. Time he stays in there long enough. that's how the truth works. How far away are you from it? you cannot even define the g0d, let alone test any claims ever made about the g0d. That's why you can never convince UNindoctrinated 5th graders or older. Once critical thinking is up and running, they always ask you: "How do you KNOW about magic?" they never ask you why you BELIEVE. and you have no answers to their valid question. You cannot even hope to have one. And in 8th grade, they already know that you can't. without lies, religi0n DIES.
Might as well for you to give citation and proof as for why he is not a prophet He did everything similar like prophets before him Lead war like David, Solomon and Moses!? Checked Ruler of the nation like Moses, David and Solomon? Checked Religious leader? Checked Secular leader? Checked He is a successful version of Napolean in warfare and legacy of the nation His legacy in spiritual is also successful just as his legacy in secular: syaria law, governance and culture
@@asmrnaturecat984 "Might as well for you to give citation and proof as for why he is not a prophet" :- ) no citation needed. You just have to be a thinking, sane ADULT. pr0phet = a dude talking to a deity. we have no reason to THINK that a deity exists. you cannot even define what the g0d is. No testable claim about the g0d. A pr0phet to sane adults is like a unicorn whisperer. But that can change. Here's how: - define the g0d - present 1 testable claim about the g0d - IF the g0d hypothesis does not get falsified, it becomes the god theory. Then mankind can use it to make this world a better place. Just like we all benefit from the Germ Theory of Disease, for example. - When we have this God Theory, we can investigate whether a dude can communicate with the scientifically well accepted deity. then you can call the dude a prophet. And you are at step 0.000000 in this process. ALL religi0ns are. That's why without lies, religi0n DIES. and I run the 100 m in 9.99 seconds. Exactly 657 people saw me sprint like that yesterday. no magic, not even a world record. If you have doubts about a PROVEN possible sprint, maybe you see now why sane, UNindoctrinated adults don't accept any claim about MAGIC.
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
🚩 Help support HistoryMarche on Patreon and get ad-free early access to our videos for as little as $1: www.patreon.com/historymarche
🚩 Thank you so much for watching!
Jazak Allahu khair been waiting for this vid!
Thank you really for your efforts
A critic in the video Ali is escaping from the battle field with the cowards while we know that he was fighting and he killed anyone who tried to rise the banners of Quraish back then when the banner is up the army is stable.
Umar ibn Khattab said according to bukhari that he escaped to the mountain just like abu bakr and uthman.only ali and his shias confronted the rapist khaled ibn walid
Were the Quraysh always known as that?
Or does it refer to their status as Muhammad's arch-enemies, and/or non-Muslims...?
@@NobleKorhedron that was their name as a tribe. It was one that they had been known by since pre-Islamic times.
Bring battle of trench next week
I've always been fascinated with Muslim history. It's simply not a topic typically discussed in schools. Thanks for another great video
By the way, I never heard a word about the century old Armenian Genocide -- not discussed in schools, colleges or universities. These last few years, a 21st Century Armenian Genocide is unfolding as Azerbaijan starves 120,000 Armenians, who now appear to be nearly out of water too.
@@ArmenianBishop You don't hear about a lot of things sadly. It "flies under the radar". Or isn't deemed academically important.
@@darthmada9574 Well Said: Thanks!
@Laurence Kueffer There was no genocide Laurence. Genocide is when a force tries to exterminate an entire population because of their ethnicity. The events that unfilded in 1915 prove otherwise. Archives in Turkey have been opened to all historians for inspection but Armenia doesn't open its archives for the same. If Ottomans wanted to exterminate Armenians why didn't they do that at the peak of their power, when nobody could have said anything to them but decided to do it when fighting a loosing war on many fronts, just to be more stigmatized and give the enemy a noble cause to attack more?? If Ottomans were rhat cruel to Christians why didn't they exterminate millions of them living in their lands and after 600 years of their rule you see the Chrisitans in Egypt, Bulgaria, Romania and elsewhere were untouched? Even in modern day Turkey they are still living. Armenians were once a most trusted and respected minority in the Ottoman lands and this was an official title by the way. Unfortunately they were used by western powers and Russia for their own agenda of weakening the Ottomans during 1st ww. Mostly France and Russia promised them their own nation country and supported them with weapons. While Ottoman men from Eastern provinces of modern day Turkey were on duty at war elsewhere, Armenians living in those areas, rose up and attacked Muslim villages. They killed many women and kids and elderly because men were at war. Ottoman soldiers from those areas (mostly kurds) came back and started taking revenge, killing Armenians. In order to prevent the killings Ottomans ordered an evacuation of Armenians and while that was happening unfortunately more deaths occurred, because of the continued attacks but if it wasn't for the Ottoman army now protecting the evacuated Armenians, deaths would have been much more. I hope you are a fair person and would ask you to read up on Khojaly massacre done by Armenian forces in modern day Azerbaijan where pregnant women had their wombs slit and kids were killed as admitted by Armenian. generals themselves. That was genocide! Armenians are hailing those butchers as national heroes!
Not in France, Muslim history is in the school program.
Christian history is not even in the program, while France has been christian for 1600 years.
The 50 archers were strictly forbidden to leave their posts under any circumstances, this was done precisely to check Khalids cavalry, but a large group of them left thinking they had won and the battle was over
This is was a lesson from Allah so muslims never disobey thier leaders orders espically in wars.
40/50 archers left their posts... Remaining 10 were all martyred...
@@Judge_Magister yes greedy for your land and like we took it before we will retake it soon just wait
@@Judge_Magister typical racist comment lmao.
@@Judge_Magister Apparently you have no idea about muslims
This was common in many ancient battles. Armies got too caught up in looting and lost cohesion.
You get what you pay for, and often troops were only paid in the form of whatever they could loot.
Discipline was lacking for many armies.
It was common up through the 1800s, but especially through, roughly, the 1500s.
Its literally took place in one of the first known battles - battle of Cadesh, then hittite chariotiers fall into looting egyptian camp, that allowed Ramzes to strike back
greed is terrible weakness
Masub (Who raised the flag and sacrificed himself) was one of the wealthiest man in Makkah. He used to wear expensive dresses and perfume , when he accepted Islam his uncle threw him out of his house without even a piece of cloth.
Her mother gave him a piece of cloth he traveled to Medina stayed in company of Muhammad ﷺ for a couple of years until the day of Uhud.
When he was buried he had a small clothe which was not even enough to cover his whole body his feet were covered with grass.
Radiallahu anhu
Muhammad didn’t even get him clothes?
@@Ss3gokusprophet muhammed lived as a humble man so did his followers
@@Ss3gokus Muhammad was not someone who endowed with money like you thought. even the soldiers were free.
@@Ss3gokus you judged the prophet at this first time when the Muslims were expelled from Mecca
@@bouhsoumare2571 didn’t Muhammad get 1/5 of whatever they stole or captured?
And I’m sure someone who had all money in the world and left it all to follow Muhammad
Muhammad would give
A shirt to atleast I would expect.
Especially since Muhammad said he was going to spend some
Of his 1/5th of the money on charity
A thing to note here: Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) had FORBIDDEN those archers to come down from the hill, unless he himself gave the order. But the archers disobeyed our Prophet, and came down thinking that the fight is over. And General Khalid (R) was actually waiting for the perfect time to strike. Once the archers came down, Khalid sprung his attack, defeating the Muslims. We would not have lost if the archers didn’t move from their position.
Peace be upon our Prophet 💚
like a smell of bad faith from our dear Zacharie
I was looking for this comment, thank you sister :)
If the Muslims didn’t lose maybe khalid would of died who knows
Meanwhile the Archers : ghanima? Ghanima!! That, is, GHANIMA!!! Let's Go.
That's the most detailed map of Western Arabia in the time of the Prophet that I've ever seen.
It wasn't just blank desert like I often see on maps.
I'm Muslim and read a lot about this battle. This video had details I never knew like the standard bearer being mistaken as the prophet and the previous raids
Need civilisation to get detailed maps.
HistoryMarche maps are usually very detailed. That's one of the things I like the most about this channel.
@@skyhappy So why do you follow a religion of a child rapist, slaver and murderer?
It is forbidden to draw the sahaba, please edit the video
for your information, Abdullah Ibn Ubay is considered a hypocrite in Islam because he intentionally withdrew his men from the battle to break the Muslims morale (not mentioning him making multiple deals with the enemies of Islam) , there are multiple verses in the Quran which talk about those hypocrites and also there are verses which talk about this battle. as always fantastic work from this channel ,I also love the use of AI for those images
He seems like a very logical and sensible general to me. Someone who recognized an idiotic decision for what it was and decided not to waste the lives of his men.
@@faisald8821 How was the decision idiotic if the battle was won with 300 less men no less, had it not been for the undisciplined archers abandoning their post and exposing their flank, leaving it wide open for a cavalry charge?
Now granted taking the defensive approach, which is what Mohammad and many of the wise senior figures suggested, would have been the better decision here; but that doesn't automatically make giving battle an idiotic decision as the muslim army had a good position, with a rocky hill protection their left flank and a mountain protecting their right, and a narrow entrance between the two means that the Quraysh army can neither use their cavalry nor can they use their superior numbers to their full potential as the narrow battle field offers very little maneuverability.
ibn ubayy was still bitter he was deprived being the leader of medina, when the prophet came to medina he was just about to become their leader when many of the notables died in a previous in another battle he didnt bother to join, in that time people of medina saw in the prophet just the leader to unite their warring tribes.
@@abod2333 Because the battle was never "won with 300 less men". Khalid ibn al-Walid was still in the battle field.
@@faisald8821 Yeah I worded that wrong I should've said "would have been won, had it not been for...", point is the battle plan was good, Khalid's cavalry unit was rendered useless due to the battlefield terrain and the archers placed on the rocky hill. Sure the decision wasn't the best available, but I wouldn't necessarily call it idiotic.
They were so close to another brilliant victory, but the greed of a few archers costed them the battle. What a life lesson
There were many lessons learned in this battle that paved the way for future battles...
the words of Prophet Muhammad SAW to those archers were "even if you see ravens picking off meat of our bones, still don't leave your position unless I advise you other wise". Yet the archers disobeyed him in greed and turned victory into defeat.
So many historical figures had been so wrapped up in myth, religion, and legend that it's easy to forget that many were real people. Muhammad's life was consequential, and it's great to see this aspect from a historical perspective.
It is mind blowing how close he was to being killed but was lucky enough to survive
@@williamrobert9898 Allah willed it
This is mainly myth. Islamic tradition isn't really seen as history. It's propaganda and undocumented claims.
@@artemo.shapovaloff5577 They tried to kill prophet pbuh many times, but failed. Alhamdulliah
The lessons to be learned from consequences are an essential part of the religion if you're insinuating that muslims think the prophet never made mistakes or had hardships
God have mercy on our heroes who have fallen in this battle.
Thank you for the support. Very kind of you.
@@HistoryMarche gladly. Thank you for this incredible work
I think you're heros (Banu Umaya) won this battle
12:12 The prophet actually warned his army that such attack would happen but they did not listen to him thinking that the battle was won and you know what happened next
Didn't listen to him? What are you trying to say ? That sahabas were inobidient? Or was the prophet a bad leader? Astagfirullah.
@@thetrollslayer3716
Bro this is historical thing
Btw it wasnt the sahaba dont think all the muslims were sahaba 😂
Edit :even if they were they were humans they arent perfect they make mistakes
@@thetrollslayer3716 yeah guess he had a full army of sahaba
Small brain
Your kind is why we are going downhill and our religion is being disrespected by a bunch of nobodies
@@thetrollslayer3716 Those were probably not Sahabas on the mountain. And Remember a few of they stayed but many of the archers on mountain left.
@@thetrollslayer3716 first of all no one says that you drama queen
The prophet says stay on mountain until the battle is over. but archer on the mountain (not all of em) though the battle was over, so they just get down and start looting and khalid saw this opportunity by move his troop around the mountain and attack on their backline which is openly exposed
How long I have been waiting for Battle Of Uhud. Thank you very much for delivering it Mr Historymarche 💯🔥
I know a few years
Worth the wait to be honest 👍👍
me to lol been waiting along time
So... when will the Battle of the Trench come out? I would love to see it in details!
I hope he includes the cold blooded murder of Medina’s Jews
After this
@@yasararafatha3139 probably next year LOL... what a crime
There was also a female warrior Nusaiba bint Kaab RA , she was among the 12 remaining bodyguards , she kept on firing arrows untill the mecans retreat. She had fought 33 battles until she was finally martyred during time of Abu Bakr RA I think
Edit: typo in name of Abu Bakr RA
Give it time. Netflix will make a movie about her.
@@marchellochiovelli7259 don't think so, netflix has the agenda to downgrade islam & morality and promote gays & nudity.
@@marchellochiovelli7259 i hope they dont netflix now ruins history and ideas
Correct Hazrat Abubakar's R.A
Name please
@@ImaLegend1131 JazakAllah for informing brother ❤️
Historical Lesson: Stop getting into a tussle for booty in the enemies camp when the battle is still going on.
درس اصلی: وقتی پیامبر بهت دستور میده گوش کن
Maybe at that time the verse about dividing loot is not revealed yet, so everyone get whatever they took
Everybody is going to party but the archers are prohibited by the prophet to leave their position, no matter what and they can not stand it
0:03 Look at that massive and powerful Sasanid empire on the map. Surely, it would last for centuries, right?
Its crazy .... here Khalid is fighting basically a small skirmish against Muslim. And in a few years, he be a Muslim himself fighting massive battles against the sassanians
@@danielj7958 and against the roman empire too at the same time. and the Muslims smashed both of these empires simultaneously
Khalid: only if we had let 'em last
.....mmmmmmaybe
Lol
Ali and hamza truly greatest warriors in history of Arabia wow
There were many more in the contest of being the greatest ever....
Dhiraar ibn al Azwar who killed 36 Romana at duel in ajnadyn and 160 in the siege of oxxyrynchs bahnasa...
Al ba'ara ibn al malik;who killed hundred enemies in the siege of shustar
yet imam ali killed way more over 500 in one battlend he fought the greatest aran warriors nd was never defeated in battle but was martyred while praying
It’s crazy that such a small community produced so many great commanders like Khalid Ibn Al Valid.
He deserves an entire series of his own.
Ibn Al Waleed*
A better documentary would be on Hazrat Ali
@@SyedRizvi786110why? Ali wasn’t commander in many battles like khalid was. Ali was the best 1v1 fighter, a duel expert. Khalid was the best commander ever
Allah prepared them for the cause of Allah. Who could have guessed that these people would conquer the most powerful lands inhibited by human in the world at the time.
because their life before Islam revolved around raids & fighting each other
It's an insanely rapid rise. In 625 AD it was still a tiny conflict between two remote city states no one had heard of. By 633 AD they'd have wiped one great power off the map, brought another to its knees and become the greatest world themselves at the time. That's 8 years later from the time depicted in this video.
Another unusual thing, it was a southern conquest and expansion into the north. Usually it's the other way around, a remote northern people bursting onto the scene by raids, expansion and conquest into the south, Huns, Mongols, Scandinavians. Sometimes it's also a central peoples, Romans, Greeks, Chinese. But it almost never comes from a southern peoples.
Certainly bro
Wow, finally you made a video on Islamic history again in the time of the Prophet Muhammad (Battle of Uhud). Thank you for your video. Btw there is an added bonus and maybe it would be better to explain history about the Battle of Khandaq ☺️
Thank you so much for the support! Very kind of you
Yeahh khandaq, trench war, would be great
Yes! More incredible episodes! You're truly one of the Best history channels!😊😊
Undefeated when he was a disbeliever, undefeated when he became a believer.
The Sword of God, Khalid Ibn Alwalid.
Khalid (immortal, everlasting)!!!
Lol true
That's a myth. He was indeed defeated when he was a believer in the battle of mu'ta. He was called the Sword of God after the battle by the prophet himself. This was after everyone blamed him even though he made a skilled retreat. The myth of "undefeated" commander doesn't really exist, as it's not just about the individual himself.
@@mohammadfakhoury1187Not fully defeated. Most sources call the battle a stalemate
@@soldierof-allah11 it was definitely a defeat, they were forced to retreat but Khalid was able to rally the army to retreat. It was no stalemate, they were severely overwhelmed.
first, I am very thankful, I knew this episode was coming, and was waiting for this one, and thanks once again.
I am a scholar in Islamic History"Assiyar & Al-Maghazy", and Arab geneology"Al-Ansab" among other things, and your depection of the battle is very good, almost perfect, and I wanna share with you the details that you left out.
1- the reason why the Prophet peace be upon him changed his mind, and moved to pitch battle, is pressure, those who did not join the fight at the battle of Badr, even when the Prophet and the Qur'an said that the battle of Badr was optinally, they felt bad, so the pressed Hard on the prophet to show him what can they do in battle.
2- Abu Sufyan was elected as the Leader of Quraysh tribes because he is the only one who fulfilled all the criterias:
* Age: he was in his 60's (unlike Ikrimah, or Khalid, or Safwan, not because of their lack of experience, but the elders were always prioritized )
* Family: he was From Banu Abdu-Chams tribe one of the prominent tribes in Quraysh , his father Harb led the Kinana Army in the wars of Al-Fijar.(unlike Abu Yazid who was from Banu Amer, a lesser tribe even with his old age)
* The hatered of the Prophet Muhammed, because anyone who a sympathizer with the Islamic cause was kind of excluded from the tribe, like Al Abbas
3- Hamza radya Allahu Anh died later in the battle, when the chaos ensued and everyone was screaming his name to the one on one battle in the field, Wahshi threw his Javelin after Hamza just killed a man.
Wahshi Radiya Allahu Anh recites how he killed Hamza Radiya Allahu Anh:" I was following Hamza, and he was like a speading Camel between the two lines, carrying two swords, I swear by Allah nothing stands before him, destroys people such a destruction, and I was looking for a tree or a rock to hide behind waiting for the right moment, until Sabba ibn Abdul'Uzza marched to him, stating his name, Hamza cursed him before hitting him one hit, that didn't miss the head, then I saw an opening, and I threw my Javelin, it landed just under his belly button, he tried to charge me but he collapsed before"
4- Abu dujanah did not charge the enemy camp alone, more like the whole army pushed the Meccans back, after their banner carriers fell, and Abu sufyan nearly killed, the Meccan army started fleeing, Zubayr ibn Al Awwam and Abu Dujanah spoke how they pushed the Meccans back to the point that they saw the women in the camp, running and fleeing.
5-after the Prophet was hit, and Mus'ab killed, the Muslims lost Morale, but then Anass ibn Annadir Radiya Allahu Anh rallied the flleing Muslims saying :"if the prophet died, return to die on what he died fighting for" those who come back pushed through the Meccans many dying in the process but the prophet at that time called them to retreat to the mountain behind them.
once the Muslims gained high Ground it became impossible for the Meccans to attack effectively, they regrouped and a stand off started, where men and women recited poetry against each other.
5- battle end. when Meccans lost hope of cutting the remaining Muslims,
Abu sufyan walked near the mountain and shouted: "is Muhammad alvie?" no one replied
"is Abu Bakr alive?" no one replied
"is Omar alive?"no one replied
"at least we go rid of them"
Omar shouted:"oh no enemy of God, all those you mentioned are alive and hearing you"
Abu Sufyan called Omar:"Oh Omar, is Muhammed really alive?"
Omar confirmed. Abu Sufyan said:"you are more trustworthy than Ibn Qam'a"(the one who claimed to kill the prophet when he actually killed Mus'ab)
Abu Sufyan then said:"let's meet next year in Badr" as if telling them that another Battle is coming.
the prophet sent Ali to see what the Meccans are riding, Ali came back stating that they are riding Camels. the prophet replied:"they are going to Mecca, I swear if they are marching to Medinah to fight them to our last man"
the encounter ended before sunset, and two days later the prophet gathered only the men that fought in the battle of Uhud, and persued the Meccan army, to further discourage them from turning back and attacking Medina
and Thank you once more.
Thanks to @pakistanzindabad9753 : for adding the detail that Ali radiya Allah anhu did nothing t run from the battle, he stayed with the prophet all fight long, to the point that at agiving moment he was the only man standing with the prophet before the rally came and broke the tide surrounding the prophet
Thanks sharing these impormtang information
Thanks for the info mate, much appreciated
@@javohirotamurodiv4108
I felt it was necessary, you are welcome
@@williamrobert9898 you are welcome
Wow! I didnt know those details in Battle of Uhud before. Thanks for sharing the knowledge.
From a Muslim perspective, the Battle of Uhud holds several important lessons:
1.Obedience to the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him): The defeat at Uhud was partly due to a group of Muslim archers disobeying the Prophet's orders to hold their position.
2. Patience and trust in Allah: The defeat at Uhud was a test of faith, reminding Muslims to remain steadfast and rely on Allah's plan, knowing that ultimate success comes from Him.
3. Perseverance and resilience: Despite the defeat, the Battle of Uhud did not demoralize the Muslims. They regrouped, learned from their experiences, and continued their struggle for the sake of Islam.
Really well done to HistoryMarche. The video was really well done. There are some vital points I’d like to mention as well
- Abdullah Ibn Ubai was the leader of the hypocrites in Madinah and came to the battle only to make the Muslims lose motivation.
- Muhammad ﷺ had ordered the archers not leave the mount at all cost, even if they see the birds of prey eating their flesh. They disobeyed, causing Muslims to defeat.
- Abu Dujanah fought ferociously against the Meccans. Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) gave Abu Dujana a sword and instructed him to fight with it until he was satisfied, the sword broke, or bent. As the battle commenced, Abu Dujana charged into the enemy lines and killed a soldier from the Banu Asad clan named Abdullah ibn Humayd al-Harith. He continued his assault and confronted Hind bint Utbah, but he refrained from attacking her with the sword given by Muhammad, saying that he did not want to stain it with a woman's blood.
- You can’t mention Uhud without mentioning Talha Ibn Ubaydillah. When Meccans came to kill Muhammad(ﷺ), Talha used his own body as a shield for the Prophet ﷺ . Someone shot an arrow which he caught with his hand, causing his hand to become permanently paralysed.
One gets goosebumps while reading this magnificent history of Islam. No doubt, Sahabah Kiram (Companions of Holy Prophet Muhammad PBUH) are the biggest Mohsin of Muslim Ummah after Prophet Muhammad PBUH himself. ❤️
May Allah reward you for informing us and reminding us of these great Muslims heroes. Thank you.
From this battle we learn never to run behind worldly pleasure while ignoring the direct orders of the prophet
If you do this was is a great example of what will happen
Your victory will be turned into defeat
There is also one important information missing here. Prophet Muhammad ﷺ gave strict order to archers about not moving from their position no matter what. He said “Keep the horsemen away from us, and be aware that we might be attacked from your direction. If victory was for or against us, remain in your positions. And even if you see us being picked up by birds, do not abandon your positions.” But they failed to fulfill this order.
If they were patient, they would be victorious. Because Allah said in Quran 3:125 "Yes, if you remain patient and conscious of Allah and the enemy come upon you [attacking] in rage, your Lord will reinforce you with five thousand angels having marks [of distinction]"
May Allah forgive them. They got their lesson and sign of Allah. In Quran 3:126 Allah said "And Allah made it not except as [a sign of] good tidings for you and to reassure your hearts thereby. And victory is not except from Allah, the Exalted in Might, the Wise"
(Please do not disrespect them. They were human like us. We make mistake. Prophet ﷺ said "Every son of Adam is sinner. Best of them is one who repent")
There's also another about hamza (Radiyallahu anhu) death was when the Quraish running away and not from the start of the battle.
Exactly ...... but it was not Muhammad but rather his uncle hamza , he told the archers : " dont move from this position even if you see us being massacred...." , but those idiots did, just to get their part of the loot .
And then khalid ibn al walid entered the chat .....
@@SousouCell don't call the prophet's companions idiot. That's extremely disrespectful towards the companion whose intentions were good even though they do it in the wrong time.
@@adamryamizard5560 there was no companion among those who descended from the hill to loot the meccan camp, just regular soldiers from médina .....
@@SousouCell you're saying Abdullah ibn Jubair (RA) was regular soldier? This is ridiculous.
Show me the shahih hadiths that says the archers weren't prophet's companions!
How long I have been waiting for this. Thank a lot historyMarch
Thanks for watching!
Thanks!
Thank you so much for the support. Very kind of you!
I visited the battlefield of Uhud and it was quite the experience. I even climbed the hill of arrows.
You still there? Khalid's contingent could attack us at any moment!
@@komododragon410
I remember learning about this battle when i was a child. When my father said we will be visiting Medina and climbing the Archers' Hill, I was terrified. I thought Quraysh was still there awaiting more Muslims to kill
We lose a battle, lesson learned, and grow bigger and stronger. Now that is a win.
On wikipedia it says it was a stalemate
@@QuintusFabiusMaximusVerr-vf9sb It is Wikipedia, anyone can change something in it to his liking
@@williamrobert9898 if its false tho someone else could change it back to reality
@@QuintusFabiusMaximusVerr-vf9sb Yeah and I hope someone does it soon
@@williamrobert9898 it was a stalemate, the Mexicans couldn't finish the Muslims or the prophet, or attack medina.
Super excited for this one... Can't wait till historymarche makes a video on the battle of trench( 3rd Islamic battle)
That would be amazing!! I can't wait!
it probably wouldnt work because not much actual fighting happened from what I read
the main fighting happened between the inhabitants of medina in the form of infighting and there was a bit of political intrigue in the form of the muslims and the banu quraydah
@@appleenjoyer8551 Are you Muslim?
@@appleenjoyer8551 yes too much of war strategy which is good for making documentary
@@appleenjoyer8551 Even though not much fighting happened but still, it's considered to be a major islamic battle.
It was actually the Prophet Muhammad`s idea to engage in an Urban combat but many of his men pushed him to fight the meccans in an open area due to their pride
thinking they would look like cowards if they didn`t meet the meccans on the battlefield.
Later on close to the confrontation they changed their minds and told the Prophet Muhammad that his idea of urban combat was actually the better decision but the Prophet reprimanded them for their indecisiveness and ordered them to move out.
I'm sure that's how he told the story afterwards, also prob left out the cowering under dead bodies too. History is written by the victors no matter how deserving they really are
@@caracal9458 where is your source for this statement? Never heard of this.
@@caracal9458 if that was the case then we would have many different accounts from people telling a different version like it mostly happens when some people rewrite history but we only have one version that is agreed upon by everyone so you're wrong
@@socitsgoodlol, well the bibble says over 500 people saw zombie jesus rise from the dead. And there's only one version and it's agreed upon by everyone. Therefore, it's true. BOOM! Irrefutable argument, at least according to your own criteria. 😂
@Caracal a mere personal opinion of yours.
There has been no hiding the fact that the prophet was fiercly defended by his guards. To cower under bodies is just a conclusion made by the channel. How can someone cower from that much larger number of opponents? He would have been killed by the stampede, especially after being hit already. Not mentioning that hiding to protect oneself was already exercised by the prophet so no shame would be in that.
Furthermore, the meccans didn't retreat because they knew they killed him. There was a whole post-battle speech between the 2 armies, where the meccans were boasting avout their victory; which was the point. They wanted a win for prestige.
Towards the end, you may have missed a few points. The prophet(s.a.w.s) was engrossed in a heavy defensive combat and they were badly pressed and Ali(r.a.) came with a huge rescue almost single handedly. The Meccans were surprised out of their wits and backed off seeing that the field was won and no further damage could be done.
True. This is the most important aspects of the battle missing from this video.
Muhammad is a great warrior and a fierce fighter
Yeah it kinda doesn’t made sense they just backing off after supposedly killing the prophet
@@MM34173 Heraclius: (to translator): Tell him I asked him about his lineage and he said he is noble. It is the same with the lineage of the messengers within their people. I asked him if anyone before him had had the same pretension and he told me no. Because, if someone before him had had the same pretension, I could have believed that he only wanted to renew what someone else had already accomplished. I asked him if there were kings among his ancestors and he told me no. I said to myself: If there was a king among his ancestors, I might think that he was seeking to reclaim his father's throne. I asked him if they called him a liar before he had to introduce himself as a prophet and he told me no. Now I understood from this that if he was not the man to lie towards his fellow men, he could not, even more so, lie towards God. I asked him if it is the nobles who follow him or the common people and he answered the common people, but these are the very people who always follow the messengers. I asked him if those who follow him increase in number or regress, and he answered me that they progress, but that is the nature of faith which is to grow until it reaches completeness. I asked him if there were any among his disciples who apostatized out of aversion and he told me no, but that is indeed what faith is like, when its sweet flavor meets hearts. I asked him if he was betraying, he told me no, but this is the behavior of messengers, they never betray. I asked him if they fought each other, and he told me yes and that the fights between you had alternatives, sometimes to his advantage and sometimes to theirs. It is like this with the prophets, they undergo trials, but success and final success come to them. I asked him what he commands them and he replied that he commands them to worship God without associating anything with him, to abstain from worshiping idols, to pray, to cultivate sincerity and chastity. . Tell him if everything he told me is true, he will be master of the place where my feet are trodden. I knew that a prophet was going to appear, but I did not imagine that it would come from you.
reported by Bukhari, Ibn 'Abbâs said to have been informed by Abû Sufyan ibn Harb of the dialogue which took place between him and the emperor Heraclius
Ali feared Khalid so much that he was hiding under bodies of the dead Muslims who fought bravely
I personally have visited the place where the battle took place. The Uhud mountain is large and majestic providing a perfect cover for one of the flanks. The small hill where the archers were placed is a very small easily climbable hill and shows the genius of Prophet Muhammad PBUH to protect the flank. There is a huge mosque now on its place showing that the ultimate and timeless victory was reserved for the Holy Prophet.
man really waited for the whole army to crumble before absolutely smiting with that cavalry charge, you might have even thought he was indecisive, but man knew exactly what he was going.
And its ironic he converted to Islam and won many battles for them...truly Allah is the turner of hearts
This story seems fabricated. There is a theory that the story of Muhammad was created during the Abbasid era to please its citizens.
Well, he soon converted to Islam, & became one of the most successful generals of all times (conquering the entire Persian empire; and the Levant & Palestine from Romans).
CMIIW the Prophet was very impressed with Khalid. He prayed for Khalid to become a believer too.
I know about this battle since I was 4 but the way you illustrate it adds so much into how the battle went in details
convert to Christianity
@@mantheman11 why?
@@mantheman11
I'd rather have a stroke
@@meceffeukada3767 accept Christ oul Lord and Saviour who loves us infinitely
@@mantheman11 you think jesus still alive ?
Khalid bin Al waleed's (ra) attack on the flank at the right time was a masterpiece but after his attack he waited again on the flank for the meccans to come to launch the second attack that was an absolute genius
Our beloved prophet Mohammed was injured😭
@@firewater901yeah 😢 and why did ali ra run away the lion of allah
@@animeszene Have shame and repent, you are nobody to talk ill of the Sahaba
@@admirald.rifter1819 wtf dude I didnt mean it evil
@@animeszene We cannot blame him. This battle was already lost in that point.
Amazing work !!!! Great battle details. I studied this battle many years ago, and you just told so greatly. Well done!
There's so much to learn from History! The battles, politics, archaeology etc. Thank you HM for covering such a crucial topic in the best quality possible ❤
Prophet was incredible in every aspect...He was genius in strategy as well...We Muslims are more focused of religious aspects of Prophet..I never knew he was also a incredible strategist in battles.
Unfortunately, some people neglected that he was a very brilliant leader and a fierce fighter, and he founded a divine state, but some (cute Muslims) focused only on his mercy.
@@MM34173❤❤❤❤
@@MM34173that's such an incredible way to put it, some never have a thought that the prophet PBUH was a strong man 😂😂, "cute muslims" i laughed soo hard but its true!
Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) was a genius, he is not only a prophet. His life exemplifies the integration of various responsibilities, demonstrating how one individual can excel in multiple domains. As a merchant, prophet, preacher, social reformer, teacher, lawgiver, head of state and government, commander-in-chief, and diplomat, Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) left an indelible mark on history, shaping the course of human civilization.
@@MM34173no he wasnt he got completely rolled in most battles he fought and the only records of him are from a religous book he made? Thats like saying jesus was actually able to heal people because his religous book said so,
I have been on the place mountain Uhud. 70 martyrs are burried there including Hamza i have seen where they are burried. This battle is a valuable lesson that muslims have learned till this day. When Prophet Muhammed says or order something you gotta follow no matter what. If you follow him you will be victorious in this life and in the next. He orderd his archers on the small hill never ever leave your positions you guys must stay on your positions to protect our flank. The archers went on helping looting the camp and left there positions and then Meccans cavalary whit commander Ibn Walid attacked from the flanks. Prophet Muhammed mournd a lot about his losses on this battle especialy about his uncle Hamza.
Was waiting for this one since Badr! thanks HM!
Cheers KHK! Thanks for stopping by
@@HistoryMarche Can we have Battle of Khandaq (with extra detail in regard to the Bani Qurayzah)
In a recent trip to Medina, I have visited Mt. Uhud and climbed the mountain of arrows, where the archers stood. It was a great feeling.
Unfortunately, I didn't have time to visit the Martyrs of this battle as our bus was about to leave.
You must use video to record it 😀😀😀, I watched the journey to cave Hira and cave tsur, thanks to certain youtuber, as if I am the one who did the journey
The breeze and climate of Medina is astonishing. So warm yet so cool.
I learned this differently as a Muslim kid here’s my narrative: Before the battle started Muhammad’s Scouts saw Khalid Ibn walids contingent and Muhammad assembled a archer force on the mountain and told them if they broke rank they could be flanked, And the reason why they broke rank wasn’t to loot but, They thought the battle had ended and they won and so they began dispersing of the mountain to celebrate with the main infantry army
Yea they did break rank, but it was to partake in the looting the enemy camp, they also probably thought the battle was over as well
Even as a muslim kid, I was still taught in my madrasa that the archers messed up by joining in the looting...
@@goodhore They did, had they stood their ground they'd have given time for reinforcement to arrive from the main army to quell the cavalry contingent
@@ThePatriarchXCI91 Uh yeah okay, I believe that? I'm literallt saying that its what my school taught me?
I am a Muslim as well and this video matches the history we've been taught. The archers indeed went after looting despite having orders not to leave the mountain which turned the battle from a win to loss. It was a good lesson for Muslims to remind them that they fight for Allah not for loot and richess.
I cover this every semester when I reach my History of the Middle East class. I never have time to do a deep dive into the battle. Have you done one on the Battle of Badr? I have a quick overview on my channel on all this but nice to give my students a place to go with more details if they want to watch on their own.
Yes he has. Check it out it's amazing!
Yes sir, I covered Badr a couple of years ago. ruclips.net/video/zioVlE8Vt_s/видео.html
@HistoryMarche excellent. I like to add supplemental materials. I teach survey classes and sometimes don't have time to go into all the battle details.
@@HistoryfortheAges Can I join one of your classes?
@@Fallout3131 if you live in California! You can take my online classes at Cypress College. That is where I teach. Also, all my lectures are on my RUclips channel 😊
I heard that Because Ubay left with 300 men, Meccan scouts thought Muhammad sent them as a reserve to protect Medina, so when They heard Muhammad was dead, they were reluctant to push any longer fearing a fresh reserve army would arrive.
That actually makes perfect sense
Watched all your history videos as I consider it as a masterpiece storytelling . Greatly appreciate you respecting our belief not putting any face on our beloved Prophet Muhammad PBUH. Love from Malaysia!
Thanks
Thank you for supporting my work. Much appreciated!
"...Led by Khalid Ibn Al-Walid" Uh oh...i think i knew how this is gonna end.
Not good this time, mate.
By far TOP 10 youtube channels to date.
From Uhud to Yarmouk, what a legendary journey had it been for one the greatest ever to bless the field of battle with his presence, "Sword of Allah" Khalid ibn Walid 🤍
I wouldnt count uhud but ewverything else still does
Without a doubt, one of the best generals to have ever lived. Right up there with the like of Hannibal, Napolean, Scipio.
@@Uncle_Fred Come on dude you should add Alexander there too
@@williamrobert9898 Lol, of course they should be in that list, but I was thinking maybe Alexander and Genghis Khan are almost in a league of their own, haha.
@@Uncle_Fred 😄🙌🏻
What a fantastic narration of the battle.🎉
I would recommend the full story to anyone, small example: at 13:57 it was mentioned he was "cut down"
here are some of the details.
but he was fighting one only one hand one of the strongest fighters (so he doesnt drop the banner)
until his arm was cut off, he tried to defend but his second arm was cut off, so he picked up the banner with what remains of his arms. then finally he was killed.
Yes True
I never thought I would see this channel making a video about the Battle of Uhud, thank you so much for this!
Facts: Arab was wearing Turban during that time not shimakh
Ali didn’t flee from the battle he defended the prophet Fiercely
Ali ran from the battle as he was no match to the fearsome Khalid
@@jawaidiqbalkhalilali did not flee
@@jawaidiqbalkhalil shut up
@@abolfazlabasnatj2319 it looked like he fled tho
I always keep waiting for your videos . These videos are one of my favourites. Being so intrested in history, i really love your work. Thank you for such a great content 😌
Alhumduliah, its here !
Also, this is why you don't disobey orders to hold a vital position during battle. You're just opening the door for the enemy to hit you where you're weakest.
HistoryMarche never fail to amaze me with detailed battle maps and illustrations
Absolute greatest war documentary provided by this channel.❤
interesting video, thank you, just a thing I think you missed was that during the last stand of Muslims protecting prophet Muhammad in battle of uhud one of the main persons who remained protecting him was "Ali ibn abitalib" taking several wounds doing that but in the video you showed him among the retreating group
There's also another is that hamza(RA) death wasn't from the beginning of the battle but when the Quraish running away and the Muslims chased them And another is that abu Sufyan(RA) knew that prophet Muhammad is still alive when they hide on the hill.
@@adamryamizard5560 exactly our Prophet saww ordered his men to chase the meccans so that it would look that the muslims have lost it morally and psychologically it would look muslims r still very much alive in their struggle n wouldnt give in just like that
@@MohsinRaza-uq2ow there's actually lots of details that missing in this video. But, I only able to named view of them.
Ali protecting the Prophet pbuh in Uhud is a fake story added by his followers.
The content of this channel is on the fire 🔥
I swear I watched the battle of Badr video only yesterday and was like ahh, there's no quality vid on the battle of Uhud in this format and I was like maybe one dayyyy. And today HistoryMarche delivered lol
Fun fact: Ikrimah ibn Abu Jahl was the son of Amr ibn hisham,the meccan chief killed at Badr.
After that, he became one of the Muslims leader and was martyred in the Battle of Yarmouk. The story of his martyrdom is a great one (may Allah be pleased with him).
Great narration yet again. You never fail to impress me. Hats off.
lesson learned dont do a victory lap untill your sure your enemy is dead
They killed the man who didn't just looked like him but also wore similar armor
the man who harmed the prophet with the sword was killed in pieces by a forest animal with its horn. the woman and the slave who killed hamza all converted to islam. abu sofyan is converted after. the man who had the plan to win the battle also converted to Islam and became like a semper soldier, then after years became the sword of Allah which allowed him to conquer Persia and Byzantine Roman.
Heraclius: (to translator): Tell him I asked him about his lineage and he said he is noble. It is the same with the lineage of the messengers within their people. I asked him if anyone before him had had the same pretension and he told me no. Because, if someone before him had had the same pretension, I could have believed that he only wanted to renew what someone else had already accomplished. I asked him if there were kings among his ancestors and he told me no. I said to myself: If there was a king among his ancestors, I might think that he was seeking to reclaim his father's throne. I asked him if they called him a liar before he had to introduce himself as a prophet and he told me no. Now I understood from this that if he was not the man to lie towards his fellow men, he could not, even more so, lie towards God. I asked him if it is the nobles who follow him or the common people and he answered the common people, but these are the very people who always follow the messengers. I asked him if those who follow him increase in number or regress, and he answered me that they progress, but that is the nature of faith which is to grow until it reaches completeness. I asked him if there were any among his disciples who apostatized out of aversion and he told me no, but that is indeed what faith is like, when its sweet flavor meets hearts. I asked him if he was betraying, he told me no, but this is the behavior of messengers, they never betray. I asked him if they fought each other, and he told me yes and that the fights between you had alternatives, sometimes to his advantage and sometimes to theirs. It is like this with the prophets, they undergo trials, but success and final success come to them. I asked him what he commands them and he replied that he commands them to worship God without associating anything with him, to abstain from worshiping idols, to pray, to cultivate sincerity and chastity. . Tell him if everything he told me is true, he will be master of the place where my feet are trodden. I knew that a prophet was going to appear, but I did not imagine that it would come from you.
reported by Bukhari, Ibn 'Abbâs said to have been informed by Abû Sufyan ibn Harb of the dialogue which took place between him and the emperor Heraclius
I LOVE YOUR EARLY ISLAM CONQUEST VIDEOS
Epic voice narration to go along with the epic illustrations as always
كالعادة حلقة رائعة من المعارك والحروب التي صنعت تاريخ البشرية مشكورة القناة على هذا العمل الجبار وتحياتي الخالصة لكل التقنيين وطاقم القناة
Jaw-dropping stuff!
Would you please make the videos on Battle of Khyber and Battle of Karbala
I feel so grateful for your content about this battle. I learn so much more from your videos rather than the literature provided in my school.
And it's a shame, really. I'm a muslim yet almost every book provided at my school that telling this battle are so little in details, and only emphasizes on the blunder of the greed to plundering the enemy.
I never knew the rough map of this battle, I never knew how the the both armies are positioned, and I never knew when exactly that battle happen.
I'm very glad for your video. Truly, you've done a great thing.
Good quality stuff. The details are a bit different from what I read since childhood but still in line with the facts.
I always tried to imagine the details of this event but thanks to HistoryMarche I can see a very good version with open eyes. Thanks.
Its a yt vid cant take it 100% serious
This battle is all about "don't celebrate too early" 😁
Another detailed and historically accurate video. Great channel!
Ali was there among those who protect the prophet to the end, he did not run away
Ali feared Khalid and was hiding under dead bodies
@@jawaidiqbalkhalil Hahahahahhahahah, what a joke. Khalid wouldnt even get close to Imam Ali (AS) in the battle of UHUD because he knew he would get himself killed. You Sunnis lie to yourself so you can sleep at night 🤣
Great content HistoryMarche, thank you.
Absolutely magnificent video 😎👍
I really like that there is much more tactical movement in this video, usually I skip towards the end where the battle begins tbh
Thanks a lot for such dedication and information you showed. A clear concept of the war is what I have learned. Make sure you make more of these videos in future.
Khalid Ibn walid who fought against Muslims here, next will be known as Sword of Allah and one of the best if not the best commander in entire Islamic history
Very well done. Never disappointed.
Fascinating! Khalid is the beast..
Anyway, I like the fast movement especially the troops.
convert to Christianity
@@mantheman11 why would anyone want to join that pagan inspired human worship when their is a more logical well sound religion out there?
@@mantheman11 the man who harmed the prophet with the sword was killed in pieces by a forest animal with its horn. the woman and the slave who killed hamza all converted to islam. abu sofyan is converted after. the man who had the plan to win the battle also converted to Islam and became like a semper soldier, then after years became the sword of Allah which allowed him to conquer Persia and Byzantine Roman.
Salute and Salaam from a Turkish guy born and living in Belgium !
Please keep up the good work ,,
These are phenomenal !
Probably the best history channel ❤️
Great video! I love this series. I hope the next video comes out soon!
You didn’t mention that the prophet PBUH, gave specific order for the archers not to leave the hill, but they disobeyed him because of greediness to loot and Khalid immediately capitalized.
و همینطور به دروغ گفتن که علی از جنگ فرار کرد
Thank you I where going to write this
I am a hindu, and don't know anything about muslim history. It is not taught anywhere. I think it is important to tell things like stories in schools.Not as a religious text but just what you know that has happened in past.
Yes
Bruh what? Mughal history is taught extensively. What were the Mughals again?
@@alexanderchronos8694 even in case of mughals and all, battles aren't taught. Instead they yap about art and culture and palace designs. No politics or war.
To be honest, once i saw Khalid's name with cavalry unit squares, the result was obvious
decreed by Allah that he will never lose. Never break.
Me too
@@alvirarahman2690 Well if not for the Archers to leave their positions, otherwise it was gone case.
An amazing depiction of historical battles, but little to none had been covered about how bravely Maulana Ali fought, he stood till the last, and killed down lines of enemies while being surrounded by Meccans.
Wait for it it's going to come out soon, Insha'Allah
We don t need non muslims to tell us about how brave the sahaba were.
@alz2865 ahh 1 month ago commented... why not? Look many non Muslims can find their way towards Islam through these videos too
Love you videos ! Started watching you a month ago and I must say, this is the one of the most entertaining and informative content on youtube, the voice over and storytelling are BBC documentaries level, please keep going ❤
Great work as usual.
You forgot to mention that when deploying the archers Mohammed ordered them to keep their position even if they see the Muslim army getting slaughtered.(He said that literally)
and the reason why they left their position is that they thought the battle was over and feared that they wont get any loots.
For correction , the hill of arrows is actually the hill of archers.
Subordinate disobeying orders- a bunch of idiots
I don't understand why they fear they wouldn't get any loot. Its not like the loot can walk on its own 😂. If only they wait it out until evening time 😂😂
And it was clear all loot would be given out fairly so its not a first come first serve buffet 😂
@@Epiderm91 Nah bro at the time you take what you can get, if you do not then tough luck you ain’t getting anything
@@williamrobert9898 Well usually they had to share the loot and it was divided. With the Amir/Prophet dividing and distributing it.
May be the verse about dividing loots in sura Al Anfaal (if I am not mistaken) is not revealed yet, so you get what you took
14:30 Littel detail here, Meccan did think they Killed Prophet(PBUH) but they were ensured at the last time by Umar Ibn Al Khattab that Prophet is Alive.
A masterful job thanks a lot! Can’t wait to watch The battle of the trench.
i learned about the Islamic history by reading, but seeing your detailed videos explaining it all is such a wonderful way. Thank you !
Even as an enemy, God didnt let His "Sword" lose the battle that day. Indeed He is the best of planners.
Indeed just a perfect miracle everything was in perfect order
Missed many points and events but still was a good viseo
Tears in my eyes 😢😢😢 may peace and blessings of Allah the exalted be upon Muhammad and his family and his companions. Aameen.
May Allah the exalted bless you with Al Islam brother orator. Aameen
Plus, the prophet was in the thick of the fighting, not aside
citation needed. oh, and the so called "pr0phet"
@@istvansipos9940 by all definitions he was a prophet who brought the truth
@@danialhalal :- ) sure. That's why you cannot mention any testable claim about the "truth".
Ice is real. It exists. If an old dude in a HOT area rejects the legend of "Rock Water", I can show him a freezer. He can reject ice till his brain explodes, but the glass of water still freezes in his hands. Every. Single. Time he stays in there long enough.
that's how the truth works. How far away are you from it? you cannot even define the g0d, let alone test any claims ever made about the g0d.
That's why you can never convince UNindoctrinated 5th graders or older. Once critical thinking is up and running, they always ask you:
"How do you KNOW about magic?"
they never ask you why you BELIEVE.
and you have no answers to their valid question. You cannot even hope to have one. And in 8th grade, they already know that you can't.
without lies, religi0n DIES.
Might as well for you to give citation and proof as for why he is not a prophet
He did everything similar like prophets before him
Lead war like David, Solomon and Moses!? Checked
Ruler of the nation like Moses, David and Solomon? Checked
Religious leader? Checked
Secular leader? Checked
He is a successful version of Napolean in warfare and legacy of the nation
His legacy in spiritual is also successful just as his legacy in secular: syaria law, governance and culture
@@asmrnaturecat984 "Might as well for you to give citation and proof as for why he is not a prophet"
:- ) no citation needed. You just have to be a thinking, sane ADULT.
pr0phet = a dude talking to a deity.
we have no reason to THINK that a deity exists. you cannot even define what the g0d is. No testable claim about the g0d. A pr0phet to sane adults is like a unicorn whisperer. But that can change. Here's how:
- define the g0d
- present 1 testable claim about the g0d
- IF the g0d hypothesis does not get falsified, it becomes the god theory. Then mankind can use it to make this world a better place. Just like we all benefit from the Germ Theory of Disease, for example.
- When we have this God Theory, we can investigate whether a dude can communicate with the scientifically well accepted deity.
then you can call the dude a prophet. And you are at step 0.000000 in this process. ALL religi0ns are. That's why
without lies, religi0n DIES.
and I run the 100 m in 9.99 seconds. Exactly 657 people saw me sprint like that yesterday. no magic, not even a world record. If you have doubts about a PROVEN possible sprint, maybe you see now why sane, UNindoctrinated adults don't accept any claim about MAGIC.
Thanks for the hard work; this narration makes me shiver.