I think Nicole Kidman did great job with the role in the movie and I think she also would've nailed it in the series I think all actors in the movie could've done as well in the series but I wouldn't trade any of the actors that played in the series either I love both and all.
@@mydnyghts2988 yes, Ruth deserves all the praise she gets, but it should be extended to Dafne, who is fantastic for her age, and a great actress overall.
When I saw the Golden Compass the movie it kinda confuses me since I don't read the book, am from Indonesia and not familiar with it. Yet when I saw the 1st season of this series am instantly fell in love with it. Season 2 is even so more phenomenal and I can't wait for season 3. All the actors, the production quality and the story just top notch for me, I loooove the shows so much.
The one of many things they do right: make Ms. Coulter a dimension she deserves, a troubled minded, bipolar and power driven woman who sacrifice everything, for the safe of her daughter. I mean everything, like giving her own daughter sleep inducing potion, and lie to an angel. and make Ms. Coulter's hair the colour she deserves LOL
My compliments to the producers and writers of this show for staying true to the books!!!!! There are too many book-to-screen adaptations that are lost in translation because the writer(s) want to inject "their" own story lines into the adaptation by thinking "they" know better than the author of the original books. I never thought these books would be adapted to the screen, but I am glad to see that they have faithfully done so.
I want to point something out that just shows how much respect they really have for the source material. I don't think they say "The Golden Compass" once. That wasn't the original book title. They changed it for American production. Everyone is so specific and so knowledgeable. It's really refreshing.
“The Golden Compasses” (plural) WAS actually the original title before Pullman changed it to His Dark Materials. The US publisher did get attached to this name although they used the singular “compass”, which is obviously wrong
@@krisallen1583 The Golden Compass is only the name of the first book in the trilogy tho. The second one is called The Subtle Knife and the 3rd one being The Amber Spyglass...
Despite my many problems with the show, just the fact that it was made and it's not terrible is worth celebrating. This was a difficult world to put on screen no matter how you spin it, and the production team did a bang-up job.
A.m.a.z.i.n.g! I need to read the books by Pullman. Seen the movie. Now would like to watch the series. Mind blowing acting, puppeteering, production, screenplay, VFX, sets, costumes etc...thoroughly enjoyed watching behind the scenes. Thank you.
"everyone who reads the book is gona have a different vision" **Me who saw the series after the books and had to check that I definitely hadn't watched the series because I imagined them the exact same**
I really hope Warner bros release another one of these behind the scenes for season 2! Warner Bros, please release a behind the scenes of the subtle knife!
@@MercurialRed9 ... I meant because of how detailed and bizarre the books are. I have no idea how they have the budget or the writers capable of translating it so well onto the screen, but BOY am I glad :D
And it's stunning to think that it all started from that one line that Pullman himself said just appeared in his head: "Lyra and her demon..." Just think, what if he had had an itch or a bird flew past his window or his phone rang, he might never have caught that moment of inspiration.
@@markendres2099 no they were only guaranteed to have season 3 a couple of weeks ago. They havent even started filming yet, so we probably wont get s3 till 2022
Hopefully one day it will (or will be upscaled) but if they wanted to do 4k justice they would have to shoot in 4k... Then if they shot in 4k the image would have to be downscaled to a Full HD/HD screen..In either case you lose image quality or smoothness. I think the market for people wanting a true 4k picture simply isnt there. The money would be better spent on the effects, post-production e.t.c. Remember the series is meant for home viewing and not IMAX/Cinema size screens. Im not part of the production so I wouldnt know but I expect thats why.
@@matwatson7947 The series is shot in 4K or higher: "The first season was photographed on the large format sensor Arri Alexa LF with additional camera work on the Alexa Mini. Material was primarily recorded In UHD in Prores 444 converted to EXR files for VFX and colour managed with an ACES workflow through to the grade by Jean-Clément Soret at Technicolor. Season 2, which has been shot back-to-back with the first series, has shifted to the Sony Venice camera recording native 6K to allow for more re-racking and reframing of the image in post." Source: www.ibc.org/trends/behind-the-scenes-his-dark-materials/5149.article With more people getting a 4K player with their new Xbox or PS5 I'm sure more people want to buy the 4K disks.
@Broeder Pitter So its shot in 2k and upscaled? Or shot in 4k and downscaled? Or shot in 1920vs 1080p and upscaled? It actually gets even sillier than that because unless you have a 4k monitor none of the above is relevant. If however you do but it isnt a Smart TV you will need to get an HDMI cable and that has to be HDMI 2. If your TV does not have an HDMI 2 port and you only have HDMI 1 the format will be compressed as HDMI 1 isnt able to transfer enough Data....
I dont like they didnt make battle/war between lord asriel's legion vs magisterium vs angel like in the books. In books version way much better.. and about the land of the dead. Book's version still the best.
They tried but as soon as they got the 'Armoured Bear' armour on the bears ran away in full garb. There's now a small army of escaped, bullet-proof armoured, bears roaming the arctic. True story.
No, each person has a gender but *each pair of 'people' *, since that means not jusr one person, could be referred to as 'they'. It's the 3rd person plural.
Keep going for the book of Dust trilogy. Sorry fail with the aleitheiometer! The designer was striving for different to the movie version, but tried so hard to deny it! His ego ruled.
Pullman must be a very gracious man to see his books turned into the most boring show ever. Every other scene is Mrs. Overbite trying to look hard walking down a hall.....what a masterpiece, lol
Why say such words about a show most people who’ve seen it loved. If you don’t like the show then stop watching but there’s no need to disrespect the amazing actors in this wonderful adaptation.
@@MercurialRed9 Perhaps because he is a misogynistic troll whose only joy in life comes from tromping on other people accomplishments, as he has none of his own.
@@faeriefayee, Warner Bros fired Johnny Depp from the Fantastic Beasts series due to the accusations by his ex Wife Amber Heard (some court drama that he abused her and she abused him) These People want him back, so they comment on these Warner Bros videos so they can,,,,,, you know.
I cant imagine anyone else but Ruth playing Mrs Coulter, she plays her so well
Poor Nicole Kidman
Bbj66⅞mb
nah - what about Rosamund Pike ? I think she would have nailed it!
I think Nicole Kidman did great job with the role in the movie and I think she also would've nailed it in the series I think all actors in the movie could've done as well in the series but I wouldn't trade any of the actors that played in the series either I love both and all.
I think this Lyra was much better though but possibly because she was a bit older and you could connect to her more
I absolutely agree. Mrs Coulter is Such a complex character and Ruth portrays her in such an impeccable way
She deserved an Emmy for both season 1 & now for season 2 as well
yes definitely, but also Dafne Keen plays absolutely fantastic
@@mydnyghts2988 yes, Ruth deserves all the praise she gets, but it should be extended to Dafne, who is fantastic for her age, and a great actress overall.
The scene with Lee and Mrs. coulter. Not in the books, but just wow, was beautiful.
when she meets Lyra on Boreal's mansion was also pretty great.
they did amazing. this is my favorite adaption ever because you can tell they actually cared about the books they were making the show from.
Pullman is an executive producer, which says everything...
"Puppet Captain" is a real job title. That is magnificent
When I grow up, I want to be a Puppet Captain.
When I saw the Golden Compass the movie it kinda confuses me since I don't read the book, am from Indonesia and not familiar with it. Yet when I saw the 1st season of this series am instantly fell in love with it. Season 2 is even so more phenomenal and I can't wait for season 3. All the actors, the production quality and the story just top notch for me, I loooove the shows so much.
What did you think of series 3?
This show is so well-written with beautiful sceneries, great CGI-s, and fantastic acting! Amazing gem!
This show is phenomenal.
thank you to the entire cast and crew for your devotion to the books and the worlds created by Pullman. it really shines through.
The one of many things they do right: make Ms. Coulter a dimension she deserves, a troubled minded, bipolar and power driven woman who sacrifice everything, for the safe of her daughter. I mean everything, like giving her own daughter sleep inducing potion, and lie to an angel.
and make Ms. Coulter's hair the colour she deserves LOL
I mean 😳 In book 3
SPOILER WARNING
My compliments to the producers and writers of this show for staying true to the books!!!!! There are too many book-to-screen adaptations that are lost in translation because the writer(s) want to inject "their" own story lines into the adaptation by thinking "they" know better than the author of the original books. I never thought these books would be adapted to the screen, but I am glad to see that they have faithfully done so.
I've seen every single episode of His Dark Materials with my wife and we both thoroughly enjoy it.
I want to point something out that just shows how much respect they really have for the source material. I don't think they say "The Golden Compass" once.
That wasn't the original book title. They changed it for American production.
Everyone is so specific and so knowledgeable. It's really refreshing.
“The Golden Compasses” (plural) WAS actually the original title before Pullman changed it to His Dark Materials. The US publisher did get attached to this name although they used the singular “compass”, which is obviously wrong
@@krisallen1583 The Golden Compass is only the name of the first book in the trilogy tho. The second one is called The Subtle Knife and the 3rd one being The Amber Spyglass...
@@alaster1403 no, the title of the first book is _Northern Lights_ , they changed it for American production.
This show is so underappreciated. It deserves so much more recognition and attention.
The work that has gone into HDM is nothing short of phenomenal. I've not been this enthralled in a series for ages!!
Ruth Wilson is gorgeous. I could not take my eyes off all the scenes with her😍
Despite my many problems with the show, just the fact that it was made and it's not terrible is worth celebrating. This was a difficult world to put on screen no matter how you spin it, and the production team did a bang-up job.
With how things are going so far this might end up being my favorite show.
This show somehow got 0 Emmy nominations for its first season. Not even for Best Visual Effects or Costume Design.
Are you kidding me?? Are they _blind??_
Yeah, definitely should be nominated for Seasons 2 and 3! Amazing series.
@@BiancaShaw3 U.S. hasn't seen season 3 yet.
@@Karma-un2ws Thanks Harriet the spy and Sherlock up there I didn't know 😒
@@markendres2099 you all have season 3 already???
One of my favourite book series of all time!
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS INCREDIBLE SHOW, THANK YOU TO EVERYONE INVOLVED!!!! THANK YOU!
A.m.a.z.i.n.g! I need to read the books by Pullman. Seen the movie. Now would like to watch the series. Mind blowing acting, puppeteering, production, screenplay, VFX, sets, costumes etc...thoroughly enjoyed watching behind the scenes. Thank you.
Watched this because a friend suggested it. Absolutely loved it.
"everyone who reads the book is gona have a different vision"
**Me who saw the series after the books and had to check that I definitely hadn't watched the series because I imagined them the exact same**
Amazing job to all involved ✨❤️✨
Dafne Keen 😍
literly the best show ever made in all of history
Just watched the series finale..............I want to jump in that pit.
I really hope Warner bros release another one of these behind the scenes for season 2! Warner Bros, please release a behind the scenes of the subtle knife!
I just luv this series💕
16:32 , 17:47 Ruth and Brian duo!
I love Jack Thorne for this
I just knew now that the actress playing Ma Costa used to be married to James Mcavoy
this show is beyond amazing
Sad to see how many of these scenes didn't actually end up in the show..
We’ll probably get an extended edition when it’s out on Blu-ray/DVD.
I have no idea how this show exists, because by all rights it shouldn't, but I am eternally grateful it does.
Try the books. Wrapping your grey matter around Phillip Pullman’s descriptions takes one heck of an imagination and it’s brilliant.
@@MercurialRed9 ... I meant because of how detailed and bizarre the books are. I have no idea how they have the budget or the writers capable of translating it so well onto the screen, but BOY am I glad :D
@@nobodyimportant7135 Agreed.😊
And it's stunning to think that it all started from that one line that Pullman himself said just appeared in his head:
"Lyra and her demon..."
Just think, what if he had had an itch or a bird flew past his window or his phone rang, he might never have caught that moment of inspiration.
Has James Cosmo ever been in anything bad? Highlander, Trainspotting, GoT, HDM etc etc. He can pick a project.
Una increíble serie
its absolutely fabulous!!!!!!!!!
I miss James
I do a bit too...
Young Charles Xavier meets X-23
Absolutely amazing series, especially those animal characters. Stunning realisation!
Is season 2 based in the second book? And so does that mean the 3rd season will be the last?
Yes it does 👍
@@oliviaberry3428 I cant wait
great show!
What a pity this wasn’t on my DVD set 😔
hmm, I wonder if they were able to reuse some of this set for A Discovery Of Witches, wouldn’t surprise me.
Just watching A discovery of witches now! Heard great things about it
Who’s watched the last his dark Materials episode????
Meee can’t wait for season 3!!!
yyyyyyyyyyyyyyeeeeeeeeeeeeeesssssssssss
Renew it for Season 3 PLEASEEEE
I’m pretty sure it has 😊
You'll be glad to hear that they did 2 years ago
@@oliviaberry3428 Season 3 was ALREADY finished two years ago you say?
@@markendres2099 no they were only guaranteed to have season 3 a couple of weeks ago. They havent even started filming yet, so we probably wont get s3 till 2022
started filming s3 about a month ago!!
I would like this to be on 4K blu-ray, no idea why it isn't.
Hopefully one day it will (or will be upscaled) but if they wanted to do 4k justice they would have to shoot in 4k... Then if they shot in 4k the image would have to be downscaled to a Full HD/HD screen..In either case you lose image quality or smoothness. I think the market for people wanting a true 4k picture simply isnt there. The money would be better spent on the effects, post-production e.t.c.
Remember the series is meant for home viewing and not IMAX/Cinema size screens.
Im not part of the production so I wouldnt know but I expect thats why.
@@matwatson7947 The series is shot in 4K or higher:
"The first season was photographed on the large format sensor Arri Alexa LF with additional camera work on the Alexa Mini. Material was primarily recorded In UHD in Prores 444 converted to EXR files for VFX and colour managed with an ACES workflow through to the grade by Jean-Clément Soret at Technicolor.
Season 2, which has been shot back-to-back with the first series, has shifted to the Sony Venice camera recording native 6K to allow for more re-racking and reframing of the image in post."
Source: www.ibc.org/trends/behind-the-scenes-his-dark-materials/5149.article
With more people getting a 4K player with their new Xbox or PS5 I'm sure more people want to buy the 4K disks.
@@ottot3221 I didn't realise it was shot in 4k.
@Broeder Pitter So its shot in 2k and upscaled? Or shot in 4k and downscaled? Or shot in 1920vs 1080p and upscaled?
It actually gets even sillier than that because unless you have a 4k monitor none of the above is relevant. If however you do but it isnt a Smart TV you will need to get an HDMI cable and that has to be HDMI 2. If your TV does not have an HDMI 2 port and you only have HDMI 1 the format will be compressed as HDMI 1 isnt able to transfer enough Data....
Buenas noches a q en Colombia megustaria. Saber si la materia hoscura continúa con más hepisodios muchas gracias 🇨🇴🇨🇴🇨🇴🇨🇴🇨🇴🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Love 😍
ممكن الاشتراك بقناتي ومردووده ياغالي ❤️👍
Its the Keylontic Science Series, its from the Ashayana Deane material
Well, this show's nice
Should make season 3
❤!!!
well done xept for the classic wayy to American narrator, wich would be more suitable for a " Emmerich end of all and everything movie" trailer😅😅
great series!!
Why the RomCom music and voiceover on this? Lol
I remember the previous version with Nicole Kidman, was also a great version.
Marissa Coulter... I haven't seen such a remarkably dreadful villain since Farscape's Scopius. I love to hate this monster!
You should check her out in Luther. She's splendid :)
James Mcavoy and his ex wife, Anne Marie is in this show, interesting 🧐
is Clarke petters narrating?
Yes he is
La brújula dorada
#JusticeForJhonnyDepp
can you explain what happened and why is johnny deep involved?
I love it minus the snake 🐍 demons
James and Anne-Marie are ex husband and wife. It’s so weird. (Yes I know they never shared scenes)
which means they organized their child-sharing duties on set...
This is for Jonny deep
Dislike u for queen amber
@@MrWarlock124 Well done!
can you explain what happened and why is johnny deep involved?
What do you mean?
36th!
i like the daemons
His Dark Matuurls, about a young gurl called Luura Buurluurquur and her duurmn, Puurn.
I dont like they didnt make battle/war between lord asriel's legion vs magisterium vs angel like in the books. In books version way much better.. and about the land of the dead. Book's version still the best.
They did. 1 season per book mate. Try season 3.
SO they didn't use real polar bears.... I'm disappointed
They tried but as soon as they got the 'Armoured Bear' armour on the bears ran away in full garb.
There's now a small army of escaped, bullet-proof armoured, bears roaming the arctic.
True story.
#justiceforjohnnydepp
The daemon/human dynamic means eveyone in this world goes by they/them pronouns.
No, each person has a gender but *each pair of 'people' *, since that means not jusr one person, could be referred to as 'they'.
It's the 3rd person plural.
#JUSTICEFORJOHNNYDEPP
#JUSTICEFORJOHNNYDEPP
can you explain what happened and why is johnny deep involved?
#JUSTICEFORJOHNNYDEPP
Keep going for the book of Dust trilogy. Sorry fail with the aleitheiometer! The designer was striving for different to the movie version, but tried so hard to deny it! His ego ruled.
#JusticeForJohnnyDepp
#justiceforjohnnydep
can you explain what happened and why is johnny deep involved?
SECOND!!!!
No one cares 🤣
@@coolguy2563 it is
SEASON IS OUT NOW!!!
@@muradkerimov2784 He is not talking about Season he is talking about views 🤦
@@coolguy2563 hey, i just finished his sentence 😅
Fourth 😁
Here we go again 😠🤦
@@coolguy2563 what I just said fourth because I've never been one if the first ones
Look how they massacred the orginal cast
Pullman must be a very gracious man to see his books turned into the most boring show ever. Every other scene is Mrs. Overbite trying to look hard walking down a hall.....what a masterpiece, lol
😂😂😂😂 seriously how my wife and I felt.
And you can do it better? Just stop watching if you don’t like it, Mr Whoknowshowtoact.
Why say such words about a show most people who’ve seen it loved. If you don’t like the show then stop watching but there’s no need to disrespect the amazing actors in this wonderful adaptation.
If you don’t enjoy the show, fair enough. But why the body-shaming comment about Ruth Wilson?
@@MercurialRed9 Perhaps because he is a misogynistic troll whose only joy in life comes from tromping on other people accomplishments, as he has none of his own.
#justiceforjohnnydep
can you explain what happened and why is johnny deep involved?
@@faeriefayee, Warner Bros fired Johnny Depp from the Fantastic Beasts series due to the accusations by his ex Wife Amber Heard (some court drama that he abused her and she abused him) These People want him back, so they comment on these Warner Bros videos so they can,,,,,, you know.
#justiceforjohnnydep