Vanilla Fudge "Keep Me Hangin' On" on The Ed Sullivan Show
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 фев 2025
- Vanilla Fudge "Keep Me Hangin' On" on The Ed Sullivan Show, January 14, 1968. Subscribe now to never miss an update: ume.lnk.to/EdS...
Watch Motown performances from The Ed Sullivan Show • The Temptations "Psych...
Watch classic Rock and Roll performances from The Ed Sullivan Show: • The Animals "House Of ...
Sign up to receive the Ed Sullivan Show newsletter! EdSullivan.lnk...
Follow The Ed Sullivan Show:
Website edsullivan.com/
Facebook / edsullivanshow
Twitter / edsullivanshow
Instagram / theedsullivanshow
TikTok: / theedsullivanshow
The Ed Sullivan Show was a television variety program that aired on CBS from 1948-1971. For 23 years it aired every Sunday night and played host to the world's greatest talents. The Ed Sullivan Show is well known for bringing rock n' roll music to the forefront of American culture through acts like Elvis Presley, The Beatles, and The Rolling Stones. The entertainers each week ranged from comedians like Joan Rivers and Rodney Dangerfield, to Broadway stars Julie Andrews and Richard Burton, to pop singers such as Bobby Darin and Petula Clark. It also frequently featured stars of Motown such as The Supremes, The Temptations, Stevie Wonder and The Jackson 5. The Ed Sullivan Show was one of the only places on American television where such a wide variety of popular culture was showcased and its legacy lives on to this day.
© SOFA Entertainment. All Rights Reserved.
#VanillaFudge #KeepMeHanginOn #EdSullivan #EdSullivanShow
![Felix "Unfair" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Oswujxm2Ag0/mqdefault.jpg)
Who’s still as amazed as I am by this in 2024?
Yep, and I saw it in 1968!❤❤❤
Some good early hard rock going on here ! Love it !! ❤🔥
I didn't get to see them in 1968 but I was definitely listening! I was almost 17, a junior in high school. I'm so glad I grew up in the era of really good music by amazing talented musicians. Just imagine - making a song like this with just 2 guitars, an organ, and drums. So-called musicians today ain't got squat compared to the 60s and 70s. Taylor whooo????
Well me for a start. It was so great that they reworked songs uniquely to their own idea, I can't think of any other examples by other artists, in so radical a form.
This is as funky as three cans of wet shaving cream(magic shave).
It's Feb. 2023, and I'll be 69 years young soon-still rockin' to this timeless classic-whose with me?
I’m with you man .. 67.
I’m with you man .. 67.
With you totally!
It' s 2023 too, but December, 8th 😅
72.. I lived through that music scene. Nothing has matched it since.
No one is ever the same after hearing and seeing this.
Rok rok rok
WORD !!!
❤
yep
The drummer! Bad ass
Carmine Appice beating those drums like they owe him money. Love it, and the whole thing.
LOL - Good one.
🤣
Much better than Brandon beating D.Trump out behind the woodshed...or did he? I heard he chickened out.
@@MrSkinnnIt’s hardly an original saying…
@@mutteringmale Not everything in life is politics. Move on. Nobody is buying what youre selling.
To all the young people commenting on the over the top visuals you need to understand how huge it was to be on Ed Sullivan in 1968. 3 channels of TV (4 or 5 in big cities) , UHF TV and FM radio just starting up. AM radio was the king for radio and many channels were farm reports/news/religion. Ed Sullivan show was THE place to actually SEE rock bands.
Mitch Evans Yes, as in so many things, context is absolutely necessary to get a proper perspective on what ever it is that is being talked about.
Also to mention not even everyone had a color TV back then
Also it was a real change for a rock band to be that animated back then. This is only January of 1968. Rock fans had just been turned onto Jimi Hendrix months earlier.
You are so right my friend! I was a Senior in High School when this song came out. I turned 70 2 weeks ago! Never fear! I’m still rock’n!!😆😊👍
I can’t find any of those comments you’re referring to
THAT, is a band giving 100%!!!
Beating the drums like they are a evil stepmom
Dude this has to be considered the best Ed Sullivan performance. I'm blown away.
Imagine what all the old suits in the audience were thinking!
I remember seeing this live the night it aired on TV ... Absolutely Blown Away‼I've seen the Fudge live twice in the past 15 years. Once with the entire band while Tim was still playing bass., and later when they had to get a replacement for him due to his health issues when he couldn't do it anymore. Amazing concerts at the Sellersville Theatre in PA.
You are Right, This is the All time Best, They Absolutely Killed it!!
It's like a religous experiance watching and listening to it. I keep coming back to it.
Check out VFs Shotgun performance
With all due respect to the Supremes this is my favorite version/cover.
Dude that drummer was KILLING IT! WOW, that whole band, what a performance!!!
That's Carmine Appice, his brother Vinnie also played with Black Sabbath and Dio later on.
@@dinorocker8647 Crmine Appice recomend John Boham to change his drum set , and then Jimmy Page said, Bonzo"s drums is much bigger Now ! i have to change my telecaster !
@@guillermogonitorello7328 I didn't know that.
Carmine appice was the one that recomended bonzo to ludwig that's why bonzo started playing ludwig drums.
I believe Carmine also made an album with Jeff Beck. He’s a legend.
That’s how you play…like it’s your last. Fantastic.
Yep. You get it.
@@stratcat4450 Drummer Carmine Appice was going up the escalator opposite me at a NAMM music show years ago as I was going down and I yelled "I love you" at him haha...Couldn't help it, just came out...Such an inspiration. He smiled. Was nice.
@@tcellen2136 wow what a great story. Thank you for sharing it.
Left it all on the floor!
200%
And to think this was done LIVE! No pro tools, no tick track, no studio tricks, no digital manipulation, no quantized drums… just sheer raw talent…
I wonder if the Ed Sullivan show was one of the few shows back then where performances were live. Nothing is more irritating than finding older live video clips where they really aren't playing "live". ☹
They had talent.
@@DrummerDanVa From what I've read, the performers had to stay a week in New York and practice on that stage each day before the show. It was worth it to the performers. Remember, only 3 networks back then, so the audience was enormous. So, no lip-sync. All live.
No one screaming and cheering while they play.
Well all of us younger bands at the time immediately started playing their version of the song, especially because it was such an easy number to do. Seemed so dramatic back then and for young white boys to be covering a SUPREMES hit! Wow! It was revolutionary! Then Beck, Bogert and Appice. Then Cactus... Ted Nugent/Mitch Rider Buddies... all...
It's 01/01/2025, and I still love the greatest Ed Sullivan Show's performance!! Fantastic, especialy for today standards!!!
Happy new year!
I just saw this and it blew me outta my goddamn chair
Carmine Appice's Drumming on this is freaking INCREDIBLE 🎵🥁🎶
Carmine Appice is true rock star!
No, it's not.
@@leftystevenson2436 wut? 😂
This was probably one of the most intense performances on the Sullivan show.
See the Doors do Light my Fire
All the biggest bands you can possibly imagine, all of them, toured with these guys and knew they were getting their arses kicked every night. Deep Purple was just another Vanilla Fudge clone. They were the most fun after gigs too.
and when Hendrix opened for the Monkees@@whatilearnttoday5295
@@michaelgadilhe1509 Morrison sucks. Doors were great FM music phenomenon, but Jim sucked
Sullivan wouldn't let the byrds perform 8 miles high because of the drug reference .lol.what crap.😂
This, folks ... THIS is how you do a "cover." Totally recognizable, yet totally transformed from Motown Sound to the vision of this band. And performed completely live. No lip synching or production tricks. Pure energy and genius at work here.
Correct. Blinded by the Light by Mannfred Mann is another good example.
Um, I had a Vanilla Fudge T-shirt. The album was given to me by the older brother of a friend that went to Viet Nam. He didn't plan on coming back. He did though. One day he came walking up the sidewalk wearing his uniform. He was Maroon beret - Airborne. He wasn't the 18 kid that we all knew when he came back. He was forever changed and not in a good way.
@@zoso73a
@@zoso73and 22á2
@@cullingthegenepool684222
This, kids. This. THIS is how good we had it when it came to popular music.
sigh..oh my gosh, you're so right, we were so lucky 😌 I bout wore this album out 😁
This is lasting head banging rock ! Dig it baby. !!
@@PuffKitty the kids today really don’t care dude.
@@jimmy5634 exactly, just like the kids back in the 60’s didn’t care about the music from the 30’s and 40’s.
@@jimmy5634 Cause they're the most useless crop of stiffs to ever suck up our oxygen ....... music ceased to exist in the mid 90s ......
Carmine Appice Told me this performance was 100% live. I don’t doubt him
Always live on Sullivan, Dick Clark had the lip synch.
@@ronnieguitar99 almost always live. He made exceptions though. e.g. The Dave Clark Five
@@bassball67 I've seen that clip, and what a disaster! They must've waited a good minute and a half for the back track recording to begin. 😂
Ed Sullivan insisted on rehearsals and live performances! That is why these are so good! Only backfired on him with the doors...one lousy word... ;-)
@@JamesAllmond I've seen two clips here on youtube, where the bands didn't play live, but they did sing live. One was the Dave Clark 5, and the other was Paul Revere & The Raiders.
In terms of musicianship Vanilla Fudge is one of the most underrated bands in history.
My first touch listening to Heavy Rock was their Break Song. Timeless. Killer!
Carmine Appice is one of the best drummers of rock. His drumstick twirls in between hits, and cymbal muting with his arms are amazing. John Bonham said he studied Appice and that's where he got his triple bass drum hits from.
The Fudge and Rare Earth both.
Brilliant Master Musicians, great piece of music, a favorite for 55 years
I've read it 10000000000 times under every video of 60-2010's bands.
Dude, relax. they were just another average band. nothing more. this song is a cover version BTW.
now THAT is how you play music
The bass player’s dorkalicious moves and singing faces are legendary
Tim Bogart.
Telecaster bass is cool
Ever heard of Beck, Bogart and Appice?? Good Idea to check 'em out!
@@dabbydude Cactus!!!
@@masterofmuppets357 HA! YES! Wasn't Jim McCarty on guitar? And Rusty Day vocals. Wow! ALmost forgot!
That shit's live. Yeah, that's right. LIVE! No lipsynch, no dubbed in music. LIVE. Very nice!!! This deserves a lot more views for sure.
no autotune?
@@errorsofmodernism9715 JUST " MASTERS OF MUSICAL DISASTER" GIVING THEIR ALL AS USUAL< WITH THE VOLUME TURNED DOWN DUE TO " MR. SULLIVAN's VISE LIKE GRIP OVER THE ENTIRE SHOW> HEY< " THE DOORS DID APPEAR< THEN WHERE " BANNED"( SINGING " TAKE ME HIGHER" IN " LIGHT MY FIRE") KUDOS( U GUYS SAY " PROPS) TO LATE " JIM MORRISON" REFUSING TO CHANGE LYRICS< LIKE " MICK JAGAER
@@SteveEcksteinDouglasDrive THE DOORS legend is just that. the supremes sang I GET NO KICK FROM COCAINE that guy from the jackie gleason show did a joke about lsd and many others did drug jokes. so dont believe the hype
95 percent of the sullivan show was prerecorded, several rehearsals were filmed without an audience and the tv audience saw the taped lip synched version
@@thomasdelvin3683 That's brutal.
This NEVER gets old - Vanilla Fudge - every band member just brings it - so timeless!!!
Agree, I keep coming back every few months and watching this.
This is a masterclass in live performance. And yes, it’s timeless. Carmine is the most underrated drummer of the era. This is just sick good. Damn
100%
I saw this live. they were 2 hours late arriving at Logan Airport in Boston and it was an hour drive from there. The town shut it down as it went beyond legal time limit. I think they did 5 songs.
@@jv-ep2tc you were so lucky to see them perform those 5 songs..I would have loved to see them.
That drummer is killng it. Holy hell, he was slamming those drums as if they offended him. lol
The great Carmine Appice
Carmine Appice is top notch!!!
Carmine Apiece,el Papá de John Bonham,y de Keith Moon
One of the most intense performances ever on the Sullivan show...
I think you are exactly Right!
Shotgun was I think a wee bit more intense. Superb all around !!!!
Looks live to me
Think you mean overlbown and hammy ?
I love it, powerful as hell ! do you think any drugs were harmed during this performance?
i don’t think there was a performance harder than this on sullivan, just amazing stuff right here
Steppenwolf ??..
@@chicanobear13 Vanilla Fudge. This is a cover of the Supremes version.
@@oldiesgeek454 i know that..lol.. I was talking about a harder rock performance.. steppenwolf rocked it on sullivan, the animals.. as well as vanilla fudge.. I'm giving examples of Other hard rock bands on ed sullivan
@@chicanobear13 I see now. Since your comment didn't start with "@Buffalo Beatle", I didn't realize you were replying to him. I thought maybe you didn't notice the Title under the video... 🤣
Outstanding performance. The Fudge really had it!
I feel truly blessed to have grown up in the 60's & 70"s
Class of 1978 Yuma High School Criminals ! :) still rocking at old age :) rock n roll aint noise pollution !
Same 😑
Yes, a great time to be alive to experience the beginning and growth of rock, rock and roll, etc.
Me too I am a 60's Kid born January 20th of 1960 upright
Yeah, driving around drinking beer, smoking weed, listening to Allman Bros, Deep Purple, Led Zeppelin, etc. On the 8 trac.
How earth shattering this must have been to see it on live tv in 68’ Heavy by today’s standards
Totally underrated band. I love how they took an R&B/Soul song and made it theirs. Carmine was a beast on the drums.
Vanilla Fudge and Rare Earth were ahead of their time and legendary.
@@danm5273 and Quicksilver Messenger Service
who exactly underrated them?
Everything is "underrated" now. You fuckers love that word
Carmine is a legend
The way the drummer holds everything together and drives everyone’s energy forward. This performance is so tight but feels like it’s on the verge of exploding at any minute. Pure rock!!!
Fantastic drummer
He is beating those drums like they owe him money 💰
That would be the Great Carmine Appice. Check out Beck , Bogert and Appice released in 1974. Great album.
@@jamesmoore1371 …….and of course his great Rod Stewart years Hot Legs etc, the fantastic work with Pink Floyd Momentary Lapse Of Reason album!!
@@jamesmoore1371 And, of course, the aforementioned Bogert is Tim Bogert, bassist in this video. Highly talented band!
A 60's song that was a calling card to the 70's
A wipe out rhythm section.
how was it a calling card to the 70s?
Very Deep Purple
@@gregdahlen4375vanilla fudge is known to be a major influence on later acts like led zeppelin that expanded rock and metal and psychedelic
Quite a bit of a stretch to say it's a calling card to the 70s. Let's not distort history and appreciate it for what it was.
03/15/2024 I still love this song and always will.
This is a LIVE performance boys and girls. Almost unheard of for television at that time except for the Ed Sullivan Show.
Right on arlo.. make no mistake about it. This is how a live rock band is supposed to play... not faking it with pre-recorded audio.
@@RickZepp Totally agree. Any band that can't nail their own song doesn't belong on TV pretending to play it.
Seemed live, but guitars did not have any chords plugged in.... wireless back then? Hmmmm
@@donkloos9078 Dependable wireless was not around at that time and as such guitars are hard-wired with cords. Go full screen and they are easier to see. You might also listen with headphones. It's very obvious this is not the studio recording. Lastly, watch Carmine (the drummer) and listen. The audio is spot on with his playing. The man is an animal. This is where most lip synched performances give it away.
@@Arlo360-Official *Definitely* they have *leads* to/from the guitars.
Plus it is slightly but *definitely different from the vynil version* ( I have which is decades old).
Until now I have only ever heard them, never seen them. I think the kindest thing to say is 'Well, it was a long time ago and TV wanted a visual show too'. Curiously enough Mark Stein looks astonishingly like Philip Hammond the Top Gear presenter.
(Yep, the one who crashed a rocket powered dragster north of 300 mph - and recovered).
Back in the day when music compositions were so incredibly strong that artists would create alternate interpretations and it becomes a hit all over again.
Right, that was a win-win for everybody involved! The songwriters, bands, DJ’s, etc. all saw the benefits of this
That was huge in jazz as well decades earlier. It's almost like a tribute to the original when you do a cover of it, especially in some new interesting way.
well....technically the only reason the original song DIDN'T sound like this is becuz black musicians were forced to sound like white pop groups to make any money or get radio play back then. THEN when white people started co opting black music, they realized that THEY could play like black people, but LOOK like white people and make money off of sounding how black music should be played...........basically the creation of rock n roll music. so while its cool to hear this done in a different fashion, honestly its just sad becuz the Supremes should have been able to play the song like this. but if they did, they wouldnt have made money or gotten air play....starting to make sense?
it took a white man to say and play it for it to become rock n roll.
@@chrislopez1391 you have a point to a certain extent. Music has all colours. Rock and roll, Jazz etc are THE interracial genres. Don't put white musicians down with disrespect. They contributed a lot, as any other race did. Little Richards, Chuck Berry, Bo Diddley went just as radical. Suppression during the fifties was the same for non black rock and rollers too. Yes, I know the whole story. How conservative, racist and hypocritical (us american) society is and can ever get. Just don't use reverse racism. No need for that. Peace and love from Greece brother.
Carmine Appice is a national treasure. Drummer from the Gods.
still listening to this in 2024
Me too.
Yup! April 2024. Memories of Middle School!!😊
Estou escutando do Brasil.. saudações ✌🏽
❤
😂
I am 65 and remember watching this when this aired originally in 1968 ! Ed Sullivan was the show to watch if you wanted to see the Rock and Roll upcoming stars! It seems like yesterday! Time goes by so fast!
It will get faster the older you get, Socrates warned us but we were too young to understand
Ed Sullivan gave so many bands exposure in the 60's. I'm 71 and I remember so much of this. He was "square" but so cool to showcase these bands.
Ed was a really smart show biz guy. he knew what he was doing and rarely screwed up the programming of his show.
Sullivan had a knack to put acts on his show that would draw viewers.
Yes, Beatles, Doors, Stones… and Topo Gigo. Can’t forget the fellow spinning the plates.
It was the 60’s. Things were eclectic.
Even some guy named Elvis something
Him and Dick cavett had the two rockin shows a lot of great live acts played both places
THIS WAS THE GREATEST SONG VANILLA FUDGE EVER DID. OUTSTANDING PERFORMANCE.
The only one according yo my 70yo dad
What about you keep me hanging on. And take me for a little while. And season of the witch
@@michealmecca3939Michael, THIS song IS "You Keep Me Hanging On".
I'm sure you meant to write the title of another song.
"Epic" doesn't begin to describe this incendiary live performance.
I truly feel bad for the act that had to follow these guys
It's not live
@@TANTRUMGASM it's not. It is pre recorded.
@@zeebatser6930
Says you…..
@@zeebatser6930 Oh no. It is most definitely live. That's NOT a backing track you're hearing.
This has to be one of the best and most enthusiastic, futuristic visuals and overall performances ever on Sullivan. They gave it all.
The futuristic visuals and 1968 being filmed is unreal
You can hear both metal and punk in the performance which is just so insanely cool. They were way, way ahead of their time.
Much kudos to Ed Sullivan for changing with the times and letting these groups get their spotlight.
I think Ed was trying to stay relevant in those fast changing times.
You're right. He could have easily turned into Lawrence Welk if he wasn't open to change.
I agree.Wasn't that the year 1967, Ed told Jim Morrison not to sing “girl, we couldn't get much higher” to “girl, we couldn't get much better”. Also in 1967, The Rolling Stones performed on The Ed Sullivan Show under one condition - they change the lyric of their hit “Let's Spend The Night Together” to the more family-friendly “let's spend some time together.” It was reported that Sullivan's exact words were, “Either the song goes, or you go.” Mick Jagger was diplomatic about his song,
Jim Morrison wasn't as diplomatic about "Light My Fire"😆
Haven't noticed for Ed sullivan but I totally agree on this Fudge
RATINGS !!! Sponsored pay big money to buy commercial r
Time slots big exposure
It was a big thing in America when.there was just one TV lucky ones had color maybe more than one 📺
Families all watched
Something for everyone Big name singers comedians ballerinas.dancing bears Elvis then.The Beatles and everyone else
Big American family show watching together
Long time over those times
Everyone is in there dam world on the internet
Like here on RUclips searching for what was .
Carmine Appice is on another planet with his drums. So damn awesome! This performance was great!
Considering that is was 1968 on Ed Sullivan makes it all the more sensational!
I still have this album on vinyl!
Many thanks to the poster!
Such a classic!!
Carmine is still a great drummer.
¿Carmen?
Best drummer ever!!
@@johnl636
You’re right, John !
Carmine is STILL a great drummer? My apologies!
@@5117sebastian
Sebastian
My apologies for the spelling of Carmine’s name! I had input it correctly but it was auto corrected to the misspelling of Carmen.
Thanks for catching that!
Vanilla Fudge At Their Fucking Best!!
The Ed Sullivan Show was never the same after this...
Vanilla Fudge rockin' out! They still sound as good TODAY!
Better !!!@
ye i like them they created musik in heart not in computer that why are for ever
PARLIAMENT FUNKADELIC Live and don't you forget who are the real rock n roll Heros Muddy Waters B.B King and others who started rock n roll blues Little Richard Chuck Berry 🎸🎸🎸🎸🎸🎹🎹🎹🎹🎹🎤🎤🎤🎤🎤🤘🛸🔦🥁🥁🎺🎷 PARLIAMENT FUNKADELIC.
@@makenomist8aboutit43 they might have had some of the origins, but it was the British groups that captured the soul of Rock!!
@@nicolast.davinci1561 What is Rock the British group are copycats they learned from the legendary Artists I mentioned. Imitation Rock.
I'm at a loss for words. I was in Vietnam when I first heard this and couldn't appreciate the mastery of music and vocals on my tiny little am radio. This performance is epic! Wish I'd been home to witness it live. Drummer is justifiably one of the best of that era.
welcome home, bother. Tom CPL USMC RVN
Thank you for your service. 🇺🇸
I'm former Marine 75-81 & I'd like to thank you for you're service sir..
@@richardmorris6365 Semper Fi and thank you. Marines over there really shined.
Thank you for your service sir
The very best live version I have found of this song. Carmine Appice took great risks twirling his sticks while playing so hard that one didn't go flying on him. This is why he is one of the best drummers in rock history. How does he hit his cymbals while still twirling his sticks? I have never seen this done before. Fantastic.
He got it all from 'Dino ' of The Rascals .Only Dino was better, faster and took more chances. I used to see them together .He, even told Me "Dino was the greatest " .
@@dynasticlight1073 I agree Dino was fantastic!
@@dynasticlight1073 yeah, that's what I was thinking when I watched this. But (a) you can do worse than imitating Dino Danelli, and (b) he doesn't miss a beat, and (c) it's a great show. Carry on!
Choked up on his sticks to put the motion in his arms and gimmicks for days. This is a beast master of rock drumming. As flashy as he's being there's not one superfluous, undisciplined strike, precisely what the song demands. Really cool!
Dino learned his tricks from Sonny Payne. Watch Sonny Payne with the Harry James Orchestra. He does stick tricks behind his back... shit nobody else was doing. Dino is such a humble guy and is always left off of the “greatest drummers of all time” list, but he certainly belongs there. And he has always gives credit to Sonny Payne for schooling him in showmanship.
You have to realize how advanced this was for 1968… even for today!
Beautifully Stated; I mean, just 4 instruments…Unbelievable sound. There is not a remake of this version. I’m sure there are modern day bands that can do it and do it well. Foo Fighters come to mind.
As a veteran of classic rockology,why in the name of ALL THATS HOLY, why am I JUST NOW seeing this EPIC ETERNAL MASTERPIECE??
I used to sing this in performances with just a friend who was an amazing 12 gtr player and harmony vocals... people always loved it..... such a great version of the this song... getting ready to add it back to performances with my husband -organ player of 33 yrs. I know it'll bring back memories for many
I looked up on Apple Music and I could not find this song on any of their studio albums
I feel the same way !
There was sooo much music back then. And in those days, there was no social media people screaming at you that if you like Led Zeppelin, you couldn't like the Classics IV or Canned Heat. I find that a lot of the reaction channels I watch are hung up on what genre the band falls in. Honestly, we didn't care and a lot of the labels currently used were applied after the fact.
You're kidding right?
Vanilla Fudge was waay before their time! Hard to believe this performance was done in the 60’s! Carmine Appice was KILLIN it!!
Uriah Heep owes a lot to Vanilla Fudge
""Vanilla Fudge was waay before their time!"
> I have never heard that being claimed.
How were they ""before their time"?
They are trying -way- too hard to appear as if they are "rockin", very phony.
@@richardpaulhall there’s always a critic in every crazy house
Dude, this song sounds straight out of its era. If someone were to ask me to give them an example of how bands in the 60s sounded, I'd send this as an example. Vanilla Fudge were not ahead of their time, they are a quintessential product of it.
@@richardpaulhall you had to be there, meaning that time period.
Carmine Appice kills it on this performance! Amazing all around but I couldn't stop watching him!
Carmine is a beast on the drums! True rock/metal royalty!
You could have said the same about all of them. Mesmerizing!
@@dennishough3709 Vinnie's no slouch, though.
One can really hear/see the direct influence Appice had on Bonham during this performance.
True legend.
The definitive cover of a Motown classic,who woulda thought that the Fudge would nail it and make it their own!?
One of the greatest cover songs of all time, but the best Ed Sullivan show performance. Unbelievable drumming, guitar, organ, and bass. The energy is outstanding, actual talent.
I can't believe the drumming!! I kinda dig this version!!
@@RainbowFlowerCrow I like all the ones I've heard. This one is the best...in my opinion.
This is a REAL LIVE PERFORMANCE, AWESOME 😎
You want a real drummer, check out Buddy Rich
I could not agree more. Not only one of the greatest covers of all time, but one of the most iconic rock songs ever.
Carmine Appice was incredible back then (still is). I saw him at a drum seminar and everyone's chins were on the floor. He was an inspiration to me to take up drums. Years later, I switched over to bass and toured the world for 20 years, Tim Bogert being a main influence. Unbelievable live performance for Sullivan. RIP Tim.
Bogert
Tim was my Live Performance Teacher at G.I.T .....I had him for a year....he was so cool and laid back....but very strict.....I enjoyed hanging with him and always looked forward to attending his class....R.I.P. Tim!!
He is still a great drummer. His style is amazing...watch his solos.mind blowing
Rockin Rob his brother Vinnie had a good turn with Black Sabbath/ Dio
@@davidcarney1827 Even Buddy Rich liked him!
A lot of the old "Acid Rock" wears thin with time. This is one of the brilliant exceptions. These gentlemen took the Supreme's famous hit from a year earlier to a completely new level. It was a masterpiece for the time, and a masterpiece for the ages. Never get tired of it.
Wish I had a nickel for everytime I played Vanilla Fudge from back then until today. Still listening but albums are worn out and 8 tracks long gone. Still enjoying that great band.
Wears thin? You sound like you possibly like metal lol
Which tunes wear thin?
@@tilesetter1953 rap and hip hop 🤡
You wrote: a lot of the old " Acid Rock" wears thin with time. Rap and hip hop are NOT acid rock, Mr. precision!!!!!
Born 1950,lived the hippie live,and all that came with it,and I’m still alive.
me too brother we were born at the right time...what a trip
hello !! ....me too....1951 in Austria....what a - ride -....we had it all....I'm still a proud hippie....
72y-old-Hippie-and-Yogi from Austria.... Love, Peace-&-Happiness ☮~el~🕉~mar~✝
How was Vietnam?
If u have to ask you don’t need to know
Yeah and so did a whole lot of us .
Boy I felt sorry for those drums...they got a floggin'. One of the greatest live performances, they played like this was their one and only shot at fame. I love how all 4 members were so animated. Still love it after all these years.
tha drummer was Carmine Appice...yea..he kicked ass, and still does..
"FLOG" is an excellent verb to describe how Carmine played.
That’s what a drummer does.
Play like they’re cannons
They definitely left it all on that stage.
@@randal_gibbons that’s what we always did. Drums mics and just about everything stays on the stage for the techs to tear down and pack for the next gig.
So epically over the top it’s brilliant. Kudos to Ed Sullivan and the stuffed shirts at CBS for letting this go out live.
I don't consider the people at CBS at the time to be stuffed shirts. Look at all the talent, including black talent, that made it to Ed Sullivan
@@margaretdasilva5493 How many good acts got the heave ho because of those anal retentive stuffed shirts at CBS? So, they let a few acts through. Whoop dee do. They were still stuffed shirts.
Sullivan *looked* like a stuffed shirt but was the antithesis.
99% of all music on Ed S. was totally live. A few groups used recorded backing tracks but their vocals were live. That is how some groups got banned by Ed because of live lyrics he had told them not to use. Our first taste of Midnight Special type programs.
They felt the pressures that the changes in mid 1960's America that a the counter culture was real.
The band's sound folks worked with CBS/Sullivan's audio engineers to make sure Vanilla Fudge's sound came across for television with few flaws. It worked.
Big time!
dude, hilarious.
And how!
Good live TV
I am 71 and they were the first rock band that I payed any attention to. I thought they were fantastic and still do today! No other band sounded like them .
agreed , Thomas !
Who would have thought that a remake of a Supremes Motown single could ever sound like that. Amazing, especially live on TV.
What a great mix is right!!!!!!!!!! And shows how really great Vinnie, Mark, Timmy and Carmine really were.....What a sound nobody could replicate.... Carmine is a beast and his tenor harmony is epic,, Vinny plays some of the best guitar licks ever heard, Timmys Bass licks were just sick and Mark was just a genius freak. Nobody could play like them. Thats why the were legends.....No rehearsal could prepare for that performance. What all all four had was some thing that just cannot be taught, just that little extra that God gives to some and they shine a little brighter no matter how hard another may practice or rehearse. And when they got this big spot on Sullivan they made the most of it. Just listen to these guys play and sing. Wow!
I have always thought THIS was the best version of the song, bar none! Vanilla Fudge does an outstanding job on this!
It's not a Supremes song. It was written and composed by Holland-Dozier-Holland. The Supremes were the first to record it. Many people have covered it. Fudge is the best!!
Try Sound of Silence by Disturbed, same kind of cover vibe.
Rock music does have its roots in the delta blues. So, I’m not surprised. Incidentally, the blues originated in the old south as black slaves would hum tunes to themselves to overcome the monotony of their field work
This ain't a song, it's a work of art!
Imagine being a kid in 1968 watching the telly with your family surrounding and this happens?!
Life-changing performance. Carmine is a beast.
Sullivan often had "hot" rock groups. Watch the Sullivan show and you saw who was going up or already there.
I was one of those kids. 1 TV in the house. My parents watched the Ed Sullivan show, so we kids did as well. I probably saw this show.
I can imagine that - my dad would have turned the channel!
We too, music was SO happening, My parents welcomed all the music in. GREAT! Born in 56
I don't have to imagine, I was that kid and I loved it!
I was 13. The Ed Sullivan Show was our Sunday night dinner routine.
My precious dad, SFC Potter volunteered for combat arms, Vietnam at age of 40 with two wars under his belt already. He was there fighting tyranny when this aired. Miss ya dad. I so so miss you an mom. Y’all were the best.
❤❤❤❤❤❤
The Vietnamese fought against foreign countries like France and the US from exerting tyranny over them. ✌🏽
What tyranny was that?
@@eemoogee160 I hope you get to face it. You won’t have to ask.
Mark Stein managed to hail 300 NYC taxi cabs during this performance🚕🚕🚕🚕🚕
Bwaahahaha!
🤩👍
Lol
My God...brillant.
IDK ! It's between you and Wild bill for the funniest post. I think he tore his rotator cuff flailing his arm around like he did.
Carmine Appice is truly one of the founding fathers of rock drumming. One of the best there ever was. As a drummer (and a lifelong fan) I can’t help thinking that it took guts to do those stick twirls on such a high-profile show. No room for error there - but as always Carmine was ON it. Fantastic. And he did it on a 4 piece kit 👊🏻
Carmine Appice so young without his horseshoe moustache
Dude played drums like Keith Moon.
@@steveludwig4200 Keith Moon played drums like this Dude !
I fortunately got to see them play it live around 2000.
Too bad the kick drum is so tiny
Mark Stein of Vanilla Fudge was a big inspiration for Jon Lord of Deep Purple, for those who might not have known. You can definitely hear it.
And to Keith Emerson and Paul Schaffer.
Performing live on the biggest stage on national TV at the time. No added sounds, no gimmicks, pure rock & roll...taking a Motown tune and making it a rock classic!
Ritchie Blackmore of Deep Purple: “We loved Vanilla Fudge-they were our heroes.... Initially we wanted to be a Vanilla Fudge clone.”
LOL "No gimmicks". Sure, Jan. They totally didn't have the cliche "project a lava lamp in the background" up.
@BeforeAndAfterScience Oh shush it.
@@MissMiddleEarthling Cry more.
That is crazy to think my dad was in Vietnam when this was going on TV. I just visited him at the cemetery for veterans a week ago first birthday and I broke down in tears like no other.
I too am now a veteran myself. The Vietnam War and everything with the music was just such a powerful era.
I love my life and my family but when I do finally die at least I can see my dad again
The thought of seeing my mother again has comforted me for 45 years.
Cowboy, my Dad died 19 years ago. I think of him every day. Wisdom he taught me still guides me and always will. They're with us always just not in a physical body. When you think of him, think of a special moment with him and it will bring a smile and fill you with joy.
@@bobkeenan2907 Thank you for that comment. I always think of the great times we had together with him and my brothers.
It was a powerful era and it shows in may songs. You will be with your dad.💞
Thank you and bless your
Dad for your service 🫡
After performing this classic song for over 50 years, drummer Carmine Appice plays his part exactly like he did from day one. All of these guys have maintained their form. Simply incredibly done. RIP Tim Bogart.
I'm going to check out Vanilla Fudge. Although I know this version of the Supremes song, I couldn't tell you the name of any of their other hit songs, I'm ashamed to say.
@@janetbaker3616 The Supremes were a groundbreaking act. The number of No 1 hits this trio put out will astound you. Great harmonies and fabulous production made them unique for the times. Take a trip back into the history of Motown and their journey into music fame. You'll be pleasantly surprised .
@@janetbaker3616 oh JB you are in for a treat. check out their early albums. superb recordings: Eleanor Rigby, People Get Ready, Bang Bang, Season of The Witch, Some Velvet Morning, Windmills of Your Mind and many more as well as some great originals as well.....why not get out and see them on the road now!
I am 63 years old and I was 8 years old when I saw this on Ed Sullivan. I remember because I did something wrong and was sent to my room. I watched it through the cracked door. Great memories. I also remember that Diana Ross and the supremes sang this song and was confused as to why this group,was singing this too. Funny how a kids mind thinks, confused as to how two different groups could sing the same song 🫤 🤔
I got to see them live with my high school girlfriend. Can't remember but they may have opened for Jimi Hendrix. It had to be 1968 or 1969. Man, if you had a girl who liked VF you had something. If she liked Hendrix and the Who, oh man.
What I love most about this performance is that all four of them are singing while playing instruments.
The scarves ruined the music though.
… and being WAY over dramatic with their gestures and grimaces. It’s like a parody -
That takes a tremendous amount of talent! To sing & play an instrument at the same time 💯💯💯💯💯
@@naudianeels1328 it actually takes a lot of practice but anyone who plays an instrument can do it. If they want it that much
@@jogmas12 Cool 😎
one of the most iconic Live Television Rock performances of all times.
Absolutely
In the age of lip synch this performance was thrilling and a mega preview of hard rock
and applause goes to the engineers also. Tech sound was in its infancy. Also what we hear on this with our computers may not be how we heard it in 68 on our crappy Over The Air tube TV's. None the less , what we hear now is authentic. I bought their album in 68 and most record players did not have this incredible sound. That performance was mind blowing.
My first concert ever, age 16, the cool kids at church camp took me to San Antonio, Vanilla Fudge and Canned Heat. 1968. Thanks cool kids, for ever.
Of course. Gonna leave the city, got to get away.
"cool kids".. hahaha
I'll never forget the cool beats on the am radio in Austin in 68. I turned 12 that year.
haha..if the Youth Paster ever found out
The cool kids were the best
That's live, children. No lip-syncing, no autotune..nada. Just kick-u-in-the-ass rock n roll! 😎
That Vanilla Fudge performance was fully in overdrive! Nobody probably fell asleep on this one. 🤣
Overdrive but literally half time of the original. Both songs are amazing, but this one without even being an original. wow....
If asleep you were dead !
@@FratAsh It was still a minute longer than the single edit. So brownie points for that.
@@FratAsh They were limited to 4 minutes so they made this arrangement for the show. They made even a different arrangement for the Jimmy Fallon Show, also time limited.
This definitely wins the award for the most dramatic performance.
Carmine Appice is the most unreal drummer ever. The drums for this are epic.
Brilliant drummer
Keith Moon was a little better...
@@steveludwig4200 not anymore.
@@nathanritzo2228 Did you miss "WAS"?
@@steveludwig4200 Appice was easily as good as Moon, maybe better. If he'd stayed in one signed band his whole career, like Keith, he'd be regarded as such. Instead, he spread himself very thin, even going disco with Rod Stewart at one point. But, of course, they're both better than me, and probably you as well.
Ed Sullivan was a visionary. I don’t think people realize how contra-versional these acts were back in the day. Ed was putting drugged out hippies on prime time TV and the younger crowds ate it up. I was only 6 but I can still remember the Ed Sullivan show vividly.
These guys weren't drugged out hippies. They were fine musicians.
@@Sacto_Dave Half of them died of drug overdose man. What the hell are you talking about. I never said they weren’t fine musicians but your are just wrong about them being all high on lord knows what. I know that cuz I grew up in that lifestyle.
@@Sacto_DaveAlso take a close look at the keyboard/lead singer. He’s got to be on many much LSD.
They lit. THREW themselves into every performance.. The energy, so underrated as a band.
What do you mean underrated, they were f...ing on The Ed Sullivan Show!
Not only Ed Sullivan but worldwide fame
Seem OVERrated IMO.
@@oldtimer7635 I'll tell ya what he means. They were underrated as a live/studio band. This live performance more than proves that. This one studio song (the only big hit they ever had which climbed to number 6 is the US) got them the gig with Ed Sullivan. There were plenty of bands/groups from their era bigger than them. Including the Supremes who did the original which went to number 1. And no, they ain't in the rock and roll hall of fame. Criminal when you consider who and what they influenced. Which was hard rock and progressive rock. They're underrated as f.....
@@ki4hw Well, as far as I know, they were almost the only widely celebrated COVER BAND, how in hell they could had been underrated! Give me any other widely known band who made their career basically playing other people´s hits? Especially, from that era. I am not saying they were overrated, but I say that they got the appreciation they deserved, that´s enough for me. I love the band! : )
This is absolutely the most energetic live performance during that era I have ever seen. ❤️ plus it's spot-on.
"Energetic" is a kind way to put this ridiculous performance.
@@pretorious700 will go ahead buddy get it off your chest. Go for it. Trash 'em
I like Santana at Woodstock
@@pretorious700 Go back to your BORING Eric Clapton Music.
The amps aren’t plugged in (guitars are, look behind keyboard at the Marshall stack. Not uncommon for their era, you are listening to the studio recording. Still, great song, high energy either way.
These guys should have been superstars.
There were big egos involved
They are
Found this today! How have I missed Vanilla Fudge all my life? These guys are incredible
They were so hot in the late 60s that Led Zepplin opened for them before they (LZ) made it big!
When I saw this on the Ed Sullivan show I hopped on my bike and bought the 45 record the next day/Carmines Brutal on those Drums Man!! 🎸
hhhahahahaha, well done !!!!! Such a fucking great song such a great show, even today 100 from 100 points.
Yep to me he was one of the first beat the hell outta the drums rock n roll loud drummer's.
One of the greatest Hard Rock bands of all time, hugely Heavy before their time, Carmine is a drumming God!
The camera man couldn't take his eyes off Carmine ! He was the lead guy. So much energy !
Let's not forget Deep Purple with "Hush" and "Smoke on the Water" and Uriah Heep"s "Easy Livin" in that mix. ;-)
Best pre Van Halen band
The drumming is out of this world. What an excellently composed song. Just...layers.
You can thank Motown's team of Holland, Dozier & Holland for composing that song, not all these white guys from Long Island.
Carmine Appice I guess
@@mungous1000 Those " white guys"' voices and energies put the pathos into the song.
He was good
.....EASY to suspect that Carmine was BIGLY influenced by Keith Moon.....
This has to be one of the best live performances I've ever seen on TV. The energy was crazy and these guys were on 🔥. The Ed Sullivan show was a big deal in the 1960s!!
Simply one of the best live acts caught the whole decade, they flat out killed it, and it still gives me chills.
Too bad they show this on the 'Decades' channel.There's only a limited showing of all those great performances.
Freaking awesome. Any musician on this planet would be thrilled to experience that kind of connection with his mates. RIP Tim Bogert, you were a legend on bass.
Ha mark is that drummer is he American Italian
@@jojoe469 yep, Carmine Appice
About 3-4 years back, Vanilla Fudge showed up on Jimmy Fallon's show and performed this song to support their album "Box of Fudge". Carmine hit virtually every single note and beat identical to this performance almost 50 yrs earlier. STILL killer. I could listen to this song every day and not tire of it. These guys rocked it
I saw that performance that night. Incredible.
Few people know 2 of the members were Carmine Appice and Tim Bogart, later known as Beck, Bogert & Appice. Yes, that beck. Bogert & Appice were also in Cactus. Later Appice joined Rod Stewart, writing song like "Da Ya Think I'm Sexy?" and "Young Turks"
For a minute I thought you meant Beck Hansen as "that Beck" thinking, he's way younger than them?😂 duh, Jeff Beck
Wow each band member had insane energy and they showed it on this performance! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
I completely agree! All four of them showed out on this performance!!!
OVERACTING
I agree
" Overacting " or trying too hard to be lead
Great performance, albeit over dramatic and grandiose. Appice and Bogert especially trying to out-Cream Cream. lol
I saw this performance when it happened on TV. Vanilla fudge was the very first heavy metal band.. this was a shock Hear what Vanilla Fudge did with the Supremes Lala version of this song. You have to keep in mind that at the time, bands like the Beatles, Herman’s Hermits,Peter Paul and Mary, The Beach Boys, Booker T. and the MG‘s, the Venture’s, those were the bands putting out heavy music, and then Vanilla Fudge happened. They didn’t knock on the door, they kicked it in..
VERY well spoken!
Do not overlook "Helter Skelter"! 😂
This is amazing but definitely not heavy metal. Black Sabbath was the first heavy metal band. Helter Skelter was the first heavy metal song.
Helter Skelter is loud and fast but I would not say it's metal.
@@vegahunter8 Deep Purple invented the mainstream heavy metal sound as we know it on _In Rock_. Deep Purple started out by emulating their heroes, Vanilla Fudge.
One of the few covers that was better than the original.
That's exactly what I thought when I was listening to it. Definitely better than the Supremes and Diana Ross.
No way
@@ericsydney4240 Yes way
@@Slinkygal The Supremes version was #1 on the charts. Love how the beginning of the supremes version sounds like a news bulletin and you hear more than one Diana. It’s like she’s singing a duet with herself. Very innovative at that time. Then u hear the supremes in the background and on the chorus. I can especially hear Florence. Easy to see why the supremes ORIGINAL version was more successful than all the cover versions. Diana’s voice is the best
I like this Vanilla Fudge cover but um, that's a hard "no"......
Better than many of today's acts. These guys were WAAAY ahead of their time in respect to stage presence/performance and musical talent. Most of the performance in this era that were live were lip synced and backing audio. These guys crushed it even by todays standards.
As a musician, I can say incredible, fantastic and amazing performance! Anyone under the age of 40 would not understand this because they did not have the expert ways of balancing sound and instruments and so forth. This is literally the best performance I have ever seen from that era on The Ed Sullivan Show. I was absolutely and totally Blown Away! I still almost can't believe that this would live!
Yup, you do not see folks with this overall skill these days. Unless they are this age! I saw them doing some other songs on a different show the other night and they ripped it up. It was Shotgun. If you haven't see it, check it out.
@@Vampirebear13 You're deranged. This performance was totally live. Their guitars are plugged in, Carmine is beating the hell out of the drums, and they're all singing. I've heard the original studio version probably 100 times, and this is different.
I have a real problem with that bass not being plugged in.
@@jeffmurphy7683 You and @Vampirebear13 are mistaken. I'm old and a musician too - the instruments are plugged in, the singing is live and the band is rockin!
And even those who think they understand it better than most people don't understand it as well as I do!!
I'm joking to highlight how silly it is to assess oneself in such matters.
Top 3 performances of all time on the Sullivan show, in my opinion!! I watched that show in the 60's as a kid!
which are the other two?
@@nilse7793 The Animals playing the House of the Rising Sun and The Beatles
Vanilla Fudge put their heart and soul on this one. That Ed Sulivan was a heck of a man. I wish their was more men like of him around. R.I.P
Oh my days they really woke this song up didn't they🔊💥
Wow! Talk about leaving the set smoking! These guys should be more well known! Magnificent performance!!
they were very well known .. in the 70's