Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.

Arlecchino is an ACTUAL ERROR in Teyvat’s Code? | Genshin Impact

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 апр 2024
  • #genshinimpact #genshin #shorts #genshinlore #hoyocreators #arlecchino
    A leify lore streamer's initial thoughts on the Song Burning in the Embers Full Animated Short!
    ⟡ I'm your leify lore streamer Minsleif
    ⟡ "I read the Genshin Impact lore so that you don't have to"
    ⟡ / minsleif
    ⟡ / minsleif

Комментарии • 912

  • @yi-hira
    @yi-hira 4 месяца назад +9661

    Scara: *erases his existence from the Tree*
    Arlecchino: lmao

    • @elaeka3685
      @elaeka3685 4 месяца назад +260

      Its definitely not from Arlecchino's point of view tho, otherwise how do we see the storybook reading scene indoors while she's outside burying her spider?

    • @lyght18
      @lyght18 4 месяца назад +128

      @@elaeka3685 It is a common practice in story telling. Her closest friend is there, she prolly told aler what's happening inside or aler just know it. We even encounter a lot of this kind of POVs in sumeru archon quests.

    • @FirstLast._.
      @FirstLast._. 4 месяца назад +46

      ​@@lyght18 but there's many theories that what we, the players, know are different from what the Traveler knows. We don't know everything about the Traveler (when the Traveler 1st woke up, how the world looked when they woke up, why they were in a rush to leave, etc). And i believe Traveler didn't know about Kayea being from Khaenri'ah (unlike us, we knew). They only figured it out when Dainsleif and Kaeya talked about it. Traveler also doesn't know all the Harbinger's names, only we know (because of the Trailer, of course). Players and the Traveler have different knowledge.

    • @UrMom-qf6db
      @UrMom-qf6db 4 месяца назад

      What if fatui are capable creating puppet

    • @zanaquack8179
      @zanaquack8179 3 месяца назад +3

      I h a v e g o o d m e m o r y . >:) 😭

  • @yuvi1492
    @yuvi1492 4 месяца назад +13444

    What if Arlecchino also remembers Scaramouche other than the Traveler... if she is somehow a "bug" in Irminsul, then there's a possibility that sudden changes in the database may not affect her directly

    • @nightpunch8533
      @nightpunch8533 4 месяца назад +767

      Decenders are not effected by irmensul and its change. As Paimon and Nahida didnt remember Scara, but the Traveler - as an Decendent did.
      So as mentioned in the short, Arlechino could actually be an Decendent

    • @Witchyelfpeach11512
      @Witchyelfpeach11512 4 месяца назад +239

      Im just glad she isn't a hilichurl in disguised. 😂

    • @CurvnVibes
      @CurvnVibes 4 месяца назад +45

      We will have to see in her about character screen if he is truly there or not, it could open up after her quest

    • @darvinlenard4363
      @darvinlenard4363 4 месяца назад +121

      Could explain why the fatui wanted her even though she killed the previous knave she could tell them if anything was changed through irminsul like a potential threat like scara. Wanderer might not be as invisible to the fatui as he thinks

    • @Ullr94
      @Ullr94 4 месяца назад

      Would make sense considering the hearth is making decenders​@@nightpunch8533

  • @sparkj0y
    @sparkj0y 4 месяца назад +3860

    How small Scara was compared to his coat distracted me so much I didn't even get to think of that in a lore perspective

    • @-Raiden_shotgun-
      @-Raiden_shotgun- 4 месяца назад +218

      I also noticed how he didn't bother to cover himself up completely with the coat. Considering he's a puppet he doesn't feel the cold in Snezhnaya from a little to no extent, unlike other harbingers like Signora.

    • @_makao4267
      @_makao4267 4 месяца назад +56

      ​@@-Raiden_shotgun- maybe he wants to look charismatic i guess?

    • @RandomQiqiMain-qe1mr
      @RandomQiqiMain-qe1mr 4 месяца назад +49

      @@_makao4267IF THATS THE CASE HE SUCCEEDED

    • @bulbaa2241
      @bulbaa2241 3 месяца назад +14

      ​@-Raiden_shotgun- signora wasn't fully wearing hers either but she has cryo magic (I'm pretty sure they just all had to wear their coats so that's how those two just wear theirs)

    • @mr.awesome7361
      @mr.awesome7361 3 месяца назад +11

      ​@@bulbaa2241Also Signora has high level pyro powers that wouldve killed her if it wasnt being suppressed by her cryo powers

  • @aceee..
    @aceee.. 4 месяца назад +3947

    i knew it was odd scaramouche was there. thinking it was just a pre irminsul thing. honestly she has to be the most interesting character ever to me. she’s in my opinion still the definition of an enigma itself. can’t wait to find out more about arle

    • @lukespetschanel
      @lukespetschanel 4 месяца назад +37

      Same here like wait why he is there while he said he is no longer at the harbringer story

    • @dystopia4755
      @dystopia4755 4 месяца назад +65

      ​@@lukespetschanel I mean, it could just be a flashback of the old timeline

    • @thnch
      @thnch 4 месяца назад +44

      ​​@@dystopia4755but she's not supposed to remember that since scaramouche was wiped from the irminsul (if she's actually from this world)

    • @dystopia4755
      @dystopia4755 4 месяца назад +102

      @@thnch in the video, it's not shown that she is actively remembering this. At least, it wasn't explicitly shown, unless they really want to go for this plot. But right now, it honestly just looks like a reenactment of her story before she became a harbinger.

    • @thnch
      @thnch 4 месяца назад +5

      @@dystopia4755 yeah, i guess you're right, let's see how it goes

  • @hikari9262
    @hikari9262 4 месяца назад +2521

    1. The animated short is not a memory in Arlecchino's POV, so it was just telling the past like how it originally happened.
    2. Otherwise, it's possible Arlecchino is not affected by the changes in Irminsul.

    • @xingqiu1809
      @xingqiu1809 4 месяца назад +50

      Still, they could've added any harbingers and it would make sense but scara? after the sumeru quest year ago?

    • @hikari9262
      @hikari9262 4 месяца назад +206

      @@xingqiu1809 That scene happened before Scara tampered with Irminsul. It's not Arlecchino reminiscing about her past.

    • @labradorite7051
      @labradorite7051 4 месяца назад +42

      this! i think this could be the most possible case. otherwise we could just wait till the official arle story quest

    • @Not_A_Friend0777
      @Not_A_Friend0777 4 месяца назад +19

      we can confirm it when Arle voice lines released

    • @xingqiu1809
      @xingqiu1809 4 месяца назад +20

      @@hikari9262 and? Scara already tampered it so he still shouldn't existed at all just like how people in genshin couldn't remember or even knew the existence of Rukkadevatta. This could only mean that Arlecchino is not from teyvat

  • @littlemouche
    @littlemouche 4 месяца назад +5650

    How did i not realize the scara detail 🤯🤯🤯

    • @VentiStan
      @VentiStan 4 месяца назад +96

      We finally got Snezhnaya outfit Scara! Now we just need Signora

    • @PancakeFlowers
      @PancakeFlowers 4 месяца назад +142

      @@VentiStan we do, she’s in the background in the same scene as scara

    • @sadplatinum7552
      @sadplatinum7552 4 месяца назад +58

      @@VentiStanwhat are they gonna do? throw a fur coat on her urn?

    • @VentiStan
      @VentiStan 4 месяца назад +13

      @@PancakeFlowers Oh she is? Sorry, I’m the least observant person ever

    • @VentiStan
      @VentiStan 4 месяца назад +5

      @@sadplatinum7552 Yes. Please yes.

  • @alischannel3285
    @alischannel3285 4 месяца назад +1762

    That scara part took my brain, now im confused

    • @S24246
      @S24246 4 месяца назад +30

      It was from before the sumeru quest

    • @greenvega
      @greenvega 4 месяца назад +136

      ​@@S24246doesn't matter when it was, before or after, there is no scara should even exist in world or memories, they probably just forgot about that detail

    • @sprinkleydonut8087
      @sprinkleydonut8087 4 месяца назад +96

      @@greenvegait could just be that the animated short wasn’t exactly arle going through her memories but rather from the pov of the audience- we alr know scara existed idk

    • @greenvega
      @greenvega 4 месяца назад +5

      @@sprinkleydonut8087 we can just overthink, forgetting details or not knowing them by ppl who was doing job requested by someone who didn't think about that detail pretty common thing, if we just follow lore in game, there is no scara in past, that past remember only scara alone, cuz traveler didn't know about that past aether

    • @rose4lyfe
      @rose4lyfe 4 месяца назад +2

      @@greenvega
      Wait, didnt scara take his memories back though? So it makes sense to me for him being there…

  • @gulshanamin918
    @gulshanamin918 4 месяца назад +455

    No wonder how she glitches after ult, she's definitely an error.

    • @Liam-bn4jy
      @Liam-bn4jy 4 месяца назад +52

      Ikr, and keeps doing the "🤫" expression.

    • @gulshanamin918
      @gulshanamin918 4 месяца назад +39

      @@Liam-bn4jy Yesss, constantly telling us to stay quiet,lol

    • @blulaguna18
      @blulaguna18 3 месяца назад +11

      And "X" pupils

  • @strxrry_ace
    @strxrry_ace 4 месяца назад +958

    I JUST SAW SCARA AND WAS LIKE "omgg hes finally in his fatui coat" i forgot he erased himself

    • @yunamoonlight1015
      @yunamoonlight1015 4 месяца назад +9

      Same 😂

    • @Kaeyassnowflake
      @Kaeyassnowflake 4 месяца назад +8

      Erased himself? HOW?

    • @yunamoonlight1015
      @yunamoonlight1015 4 месяца назад +20

      @@Kaeyassnowflake Play the Sumeru Archon Quests xD

    • @Kaeyassnowflake
      @Kaeyassnowflake 4 месяца назад +6

      @@yunamoonlight1015 please spoil🥹
      I'm still stuck in liuye😭

    • @ritaisiuma
      @ritaisiuma 4 месяца назад +29

      @@Kaeyassnowflake basically, scara got access to irminsul (tree that records events in teyvat) and found out he was indirectly the cause of someone's death (forgot name) so he erased his existence from irminsul

  • @RequiemMasses
    @RequiemMasses 4 месяца назад +304

    If she has a voice line about the balladeer its gonna be crazy

    • @snubby49
      @snubby49 4 месяца назад +12

      I was just thinking thattt- i can't wait to find out more about her😮

    • @darylewalker6862
      @darylewalker6862 4 месяца назад +34

      Newbies should see a Arlecchino/Scaramouche voice line. We need to compare what happens to players that did the Scaramouche epilogue and those that haven’t yet.

    • @Trainboy1EJR
      @Trainboy1EJR 3 месяца назад +2

      @@darylewalker6862 guess I need to prioritize her friendship level! XD Things have been such a nightmare for me that Inazuma is still under that Sodoku decree. XD

  • @Minsleif
    @Minsleif  4 месяца назад +3597

    dragonmiryo found the Scaramouche detail under a Twitter post I'd made and I've been thinking about it since...

    • @lyss5302
      @lyss5302 4 месяца назад +22

      hehe >:D

    • @ExtraAin
      @ExtraAin 4 месяца назад +21

      _i am the 69th like_
      it can be like because it was a past where scaramouche isnt deleted or something?

    • @imjustgdcg96
      @imjustgdcg96 4 месяца назад +47

      ​@@ExtraAin No. Wanderer deleted everything about the Balladeer; its past, present, and future I think.

    • @haroonafridi231
      @haroonafridi231 4 месяца назад +9

      There are too many characters for hoyo to get every detail right now?
      I saw someone comment somewhere that in the new event venti is ok around cat girl of monstad but wasn't he elergic to cats?
      But then people were making other theories that she is not a full car and this and that...

    • @AnimationStation3000
      @AnimationStation3000 4 месяца назад +10

      ​@@haroonafridi231 she's a nekomata not an actual cat

  • @VentiStan
    @VentiStan 4 месяца назад +87

    I’d just like to note that Arle’s official name being Peruere and Freminet’s penguin being called Pers (forgot how it’s spelt) is cute to me, even if not intentional

  • @tokkiuyu
    @tokkiuyu 4 месяца назад +67

    I figured it was just like watching a new anime with no context, and we're just watching her life from the beginning not a POV. That's why it didn't strike me as odd to see Scaramouche with Signora and the others. It's not a flashback or a memory, it's literally just Hoyo saying "hey this is how it happened btw, now you're caught up!"

  • @geboaebo
    @geboaebo 4 месяца назад +166

    I am convinced she is an outworlder, but not a descender. Since the traveller, who is a descender, has angel imagery, that would explain why she has that fallen one-winged angel motif. Like she is also from another world, but she failed to become capable of rivaling an entire world

    • @sumsumplays
      @sumsumplays 4 месяца назад +19

      Probs from another world but has no idea. Hense the “curse” to. While we’re obvs not cursed, the descender before died and we can’t find our sibling, are ALWAYS caught up in crap we never wanted to be dragged into and ig even irminsal not changing our minds could be considered “cursed” by others view

    • @ntsm66
      @ntsm66 4 месяца назад +4

      I think the traveler is indeed cursed, i don't remember when this is said in the main story but i think we are told that the travelers lose their "true light powers" or something and also the ability to travel through other worlds

    • @Sandstimes
      @Sandstimes 3 месяца назад +2

      ​@@ntsm66 I often think abt the really ominous comment that one melusine in merusea village makes abt us and paimon

  • @greatsageamane1984
    @greatsageamane1984 4 месяца назад +117

    This animation left me with no words lol- DRIP QUEEN LORE LET'S GOOOO

  • @freudjulien8763
    @freudjulien8763 4 месяца назад +47

    Yea “if it’s a memory of her life as it flashes before her eyes” but that’s not confirmed. This could just be a telling or her past to the audience as to know her origins hence the Scaramouche appearance

    • @Minsleif
      @Minsleif  4 месяца назад +8

      That’s true this is just a theory based off the recent animation!

    • @yukidandelion8537
      @yukidandelion8537 4 месяца назад +5

      @@MinsleifIf it’s from her POV, how do we see the storybook scene when she’s outside burying her spider?

  • @iforgetiamacat8348
    @iforgetiamacat8348 4 месяца назад +209

    Imagine devs just fucked up with Scara and laughing now, seeing how community building insane theories 😂

    • @kamisnotanerd
      @kamisnotanerd 4 месяца назад +34

      That's what I'm thinking, unless we're not seeing her memories but just showing us what happened and her ascension to harbinger 🤷

    • @lelepodproductions_
      @lelepodproductions_ 4 месяца назад +20

      ​@@kamisnotanerd I feel like they had to have done that on purpose tbh. They could've shown ANY harbinger but they chose to show him??? Idkkkk imo that's not a coincidence, especially with her glitching and stuff.

    • @ChaseWood-_def_gay_
      @ChaseWood-_def_gay_ 4 месяца назад +4

      Hoyo never does anything without no reason there is ALWAYS a reason and foreshadowing or reference

    • @elaeka3685
      @elaeka3685 4 месяца назад +8

      Its definitely not Arlecchino's memory tho, otherwise how do we see the storybook reading scene indoors when she's outside burying her spider?

    • @calvinci
      @calvinci 4 месяца назад +3

      Plot twist: The Arlecchino animation was made way back before Sumeru's storyline was written, and they forgot to remove him

  • @ryomahoshi643
    @ryomahoshi643 4 месяца назад +21

    For clarification, Irminsul doesn’t actually change history, simply people’s memories of what happened. It’s explained by Nicole at the end of the 3.3 interlude quest that it doesn’t actually tamper with history, and that only few have the capability to do so (an example being Istaroth in Ei’s second story quest.) So Scara being there does make sense. As for why he was chosen over any other harbinger, I’m guessing it’s because they wanted to show his winter coat, since we had never seen it.
    Alternatively though…Dottore has at least some level of an ability to circumvent Irminsul, as he proclaims that the knowledge he shares with Nahida is hidden by it. I’ve also always found it weird how the No. 6 seat is just…empty after Scara’s erasure, because you’d kind of assume that if no one remembered him, people would just call them “The Ten Fatui Harbingers” and Sandrone would be treated as if she was always No. 6, Signora as if she was always No. 7, so on and so forth. So…I do have to wonder if maybe the harbingers (at least the higher ranking ones since Childe doesn’t seem to remember him) do actually remember Scara through some method of Irminsul circumvention, but only time will tell.

  • @Raininpain
    @Raininpain 4 месяца назад +72

    what if ot just happened in the past and not Arlecchino's memory that would explain Scara being there

    • @starlight14673
      @starlight14673 4 месяца назад +1

      hmm..they could have tried to show but hoyo is cooking so somehow this detail feels they added it purposefully

    • @didiwever834
      @didiwever834 4 месяца назад +1

      This past doesn't exist anymore.

    • @The_original_one
      @The_original_one 4 месяца назад +13

      ​@@didiwever834it exist but nobody remembers irmansul doesn't chang reality it's just replace perspective of how it happened.
      Scara still killed kaidahara clan but nobody remembers it as scara.
      There is still a 6th harbinger just not named scara.
      And for a fact it's not a memory anyway

    • @mangoman4671
      @mangoman4671 4 месяца назад +23

      ​​​@@didiwever834 It still exists, just not in people's memories. Scara still existed and his actions still happened. His existence wasn't removed from reality, just from people's memories and books and stuff. All the stuff he did, still happened, it's just no one knows anymore who did that cause people can't remember his existence although he still exists. And I feel like the video is also more from an audience pov and not necessarily arlecchino's pov

    • @elaeka3685
      @elaeka3685 4 месяца назад

      Yeah its definitely not Arlecchino's memory, otherwise how do we see the storybook reading scene indoors when she's outside burying her spider?

  • @Lyney-0
    @Lyney-0 4 месяца назад +41

    And with all this amazing details... she's just number 4
    I wonder how will Columbina be 💀

    • @Minsleif
      @Minsleif  4 месяца назад +32

      If she’s not some seelie goddess reborn or smth I will be VERY SURPRISED

    • @motemo8413
      @motemo8413 4 месяца назад +7

      @@Minsleif Hoyo be like: Nabu Malikata survived btw ;)

  • @GenshinPlayerBR
    @GenshinPlayerBR 4 месяца назад +186

    What if "Perinheri" also means something different like "Per in her I"? Maybe a different soul into another body? I don't know.

    • @didiwever834
      @didiwever834 4 месяца назад +6

      You need to explain this to me.

    • @exentine7693
      @exentine7693 4 месяца назад +14

      @@didiwever834 “Pear in her eye”??!!?! 😳😳😱😱🤪🤯😱🤪🥵😳💀💀

    • @GenshinPlayerBR
      @GenshinPlayerBR 4 месяца назад

      @@didiwever834, I know this sentence doesn't make much sense in English, but in my language if you translate "per in her I" literally, it would mean something like "put me inside her".

    • @akarifuyuki9763
      @akarifuyuki9763 4 месяца назад +2

      Where do you find this book?

    • @didiwever834
      @didiwever834 4 месяца назад +4

      @@akarifuyuki9763 Fontaine book store.

  • @Vigrass
    @Vigrass 4 месяца назад +193

    I love how they all need to keep warm and wear big coats and then scara is there in shorts with just the hood on 😭
    Edit: IK HES A PUPPET!!!! That’s why I find it funny cause he doesn’t need to stay warm

    • @yunamoonlight1015
      @yunamoonlight1015 4 месяца назад +7

      Right?!

    • @sinnerproductions2510
      @sinnerproductions2510 4 месяца назад +11

      Well... He is technically not Human in physical sense. Emotional? Yes. But he was a "doll" made by Inazuma's Archon.

    • @cloudstrife4324
      @cloudstrife4324 4 месяца назад +5

      Isn't he a puppet

    • @merusotajio2222
      @merusotajio2222 4 месяца назад +13

      He is a puppet so I guess he is wearing it for fashion, or just to fit in

    • @Vigrass
      @Vigrass 4 месяца назад +4

      @@merusotajio2222 yeah thats why I love it

  • @miyu.rizz_
    @miyu.rizz_ 4 месяца назад +8

    Scara "I dont care how cold it is ima wear shorts" mouche

    • @cloudstrife4324
      @cloudstrife4324 4 месяца назад

      He's a puppet lol

    • @miyu.rizz_
      @miyu.rizz_ 4 месяца назад

      @@cloudstrife4324 I know, its just a joke lol

    • @darylewalker6862
      @darylewalker6862 4 месяца назад

      The cold doesn’t bother him, anyway.

    • @miyu.rizz_
      @miyu.rizz_ 4 месяца назад

      @@darylewalker6862 became Elsa 💀

  • @lyght18
    @lyght18 4 месяца назад +33

    There's a high possibility that Aler remembers Scara. There are still lots to uncover. But one thing is for sure, the harbingers are no joke and not to mess with. They collect the most valuable information about Teyvat, so there's no doubt that one of their members is immune to Irminsul.

    • @ayamarukitty
      @ayamarukitty 4 дня назад

      she probably does, since we know irminsul tampering doesn't affect descenders (people that don't originate from teyvat) because traveler is living proof of that

  • @Dazaiburger
    @Dazaiburger 4 месяца назад +10

    They didn't say it's arlechinno's memories tho, is just a animated short from third person view or player's perspective

    • @elaeka3685
      @elaeka3685 4 месяца назад +1

      Yeah its definitely not Arlecchino's memory, otherwise how do we see the storybook reading scene indoors when she's outside burying her spider?

    • @Dazaiburger
      @Dazaiburger 4 месяца назад

      @@elaeka3685 yes that's what I thought, it's just for players view not her memories

  • @Someone_ExistsVtuber
    @Someone_ExistsVtuber 4 месяца назад +7

    Why is kid Arlechino so adorable 🥰🥰

  • @itskabso
    @itskabso 4 месяца назад +7

    Thats story is literally a past before scara delete himself from the irminsul.

    • @ayamarukitty
      @ayamarukitty 4 дня назад +1

      but the thing is that, when he deleted himself from irminsul, he altered every single person from teyvat's memories, meaning that if someone were to reflect on their past after said deletion (as the animation is theorized to be arlecchinos life flashing before her eyes) and their past included scaramouche somehow, he wouldn't be there in their perspective, same with rukkhadevata, people from sumeru now think nahida was always their archon so their memories were altered to make them believe history went down in a different way (ex. instead of knowing that nahida was locked up by the akademiya due to being deemed useless as rukkhadevata's reincarnation?? i think??, they now think she was locked up because she used all her power in the cataclysm i think i dont remember exactly and was now weak)

  • @redemption2734
    @redemption2734 2 месяца назад +8

    Yall i realised that venti revealed he is frim ten future. In act one of the prologue in Monstand it says venti knows all songs from the past , present and future

  • @Xender_XD
    @Xender_XD 4 месяца назад +23

    She also has a curse

    • @Minsleif
      @Minsleif  4 месяца назад +25

      very true! and the only other person who SEEMS to have something similar is Cater, although off the top of my head I don't recall Cater mentioning a curse, so the Narzissenkreuz deserves another lookover!

    • @DiamondDiancie10
      @DiamondDiancie10 4 месяца назад +3

      @@MinsleifIf I recall correctly, I think he mentioned something about a curse in the Pursuit questline? Either that or it was mentioned in the notes left in the Book of Revelation by the sunflowers after the quest. That could be a good place to look, especially considering that it's a really easy quest to miss!

    • @XXNDRRFG
      @XXNDRRFG 4 месяца назад

      @@Minsleif CATER DOES HAVE A CURSE!!! I swear he mentioned it, and also, it looks veeeery similar to Arle's. Another thing: He's a hilichurl. From Khaenri'ah. I'm pretty sure that's the cause of his curse, so maybe Arle is from Khaenri'ah????? But it's just a theory! A GAME THEORY-

    • @Talinthis
      @Talinthis 4 месяца назад

      @@Minsleif Not sure if he said it, but the hilichurl curse is a curse from the gods

  • @just.kazuhaa
    @just.kazuhaa 4 месяца назад +17

    I was so distracted by Scara that I didn't even question why he was there, thanks for giving me something to think about for the rest of the week

  • @LilithLuvsPlaying
    @LilithLuvsPlaying 3 месяца назад +1

    Imagine wanderer visiting Fontaine and passing by Alreccino and smirking that she probably doesn't remember him only for her to stop and put a hand on his shoulder and go " long time Sacarmouche "

  • @luv4ruqi
    @luv4ruqi 3 месяца назад +1

    your voice gives the vibes of a genshin character so much!! ❤❤❤

  • @Blossommoshi77
    @Blossommoshi77 4 месяца назад +5

    Also the way arlechinno fought the previous harbinger is similar to how lyney , Lynette and freme gonna fight arlechinno

  • @libradan2854
    @libradan2854 4 месяца назад +20

    I was also suspicious of Scara in her memory.

  • @lunix3259
    @lunix3259 2 месяца назад +2

    You finally got another Dainsleif quest!! congrats

  • @mikaxerror
    @mikaxerror Месяц назад +1

    "Hes just standing there... Menacingly!"

  • @sirthomasevangelion1258
    @sirthomasevangelion1258 2 месяца назад +4

    Wei’s theory strikes again!!! Different parallel timelines made arlechino

  • @Bxll_y
    @Bxll_y 4 месяца назад +3

    Scara is there because he was a harbinger when arlechino was appointed, the events of his deletion happen after arlechino becomes a harbinger

  • @BashTagg
    @BashTagg 4 месяца назад +1

    THANK YOU! I feel soooo validated, I mentioned this detail on Reddit and got torn to shreds!

  • @roslee7047
    @roslee7047 4 месяца назад +1

    Damn she’s such an interesting character with all this lore and stuff. I wonder how the other Fatui will be.

  • @WaterTaster
    @WaterTaster 4 месяца назад +46

    God, this is so insane, i just eatched your short about how arlecchink might die and im wondering if she actually dies would there be consequences? And now scaramouche is there? Could she still remember what has been erased from Irminsul? Or maybe they might be showing what had happened before scaramousey erased himself? And why claim to be from fontaine?

    • @namaerro6738
      @namaerro6738 4 месяца назад +3

      She wont because she will be playable

    • @WaterTaster
      @WaterTaster 4 месяца назад

      @@namaerro6738 I just watched a bunch of theories nothing is for certain though

    • @namaerro6738
      @namaerro6738 4 месяца назад

      @@WaterTaster i'd put lots of spices on genshin theories. The lore is dropping so slow the community has too much free time to theorise everything, holding themselves even on a string of grass

    • @Tyva_1
      @Tyva_1 4 месяца назад +2

      It wasn't her memory.
      However, if it was the case then it still would be factual. How irminsul works is when erasing a presence from the world, it would be the name. That's it. The figure and what they look like would be remembered (to an extent depending on how long ago). For further proof of this, after Scara erased himself from Irminsul, we were to go back to Inazuma for a short side quest. It was here where they remembered a figure. But not a name.

    • @rb.v
      @rb.v 4 месяца назад

      ⁠@@namaerro6738 the fact that you had time to put a bait down and excitedly wait for anyone to fall for it is telling me you have too much free time on your hands aswell

  • @Mo0n_LighT965
    @Mo0n_LighT965 4 месяца назад +3

    I just assumed this happened before the whole scara messing with irminsul thing, which is y he’s there.

  • @sallyfaceenjoyer
    @sallyfaceenjoyer 4 месяца назад +1

    I thought it was just showing us her experience, not her current memories. I can’t believe that she actually remembers everything

  • @Luck613
    @Luck613 3 месяца назад

    I need a movie with the whole genshin lore in it, all of it. I never read the notes/books/etc bc theres always so much to do but it sounds interesting

  • @radwanahammedtanver6666
    @radwanahammedtanver6666 4 месяца назад +11

    The scara part blew my mind

  • @distritochristianangeloa.157
    @distritochristianangeloa.157 4 месяца назад +2

    Finally someone acknowledge on how does Wanderer is in this trailer when he change things about him in Irminsul

    • @Ghosta_
      @Ghosta_ 4 месяца назад +6

      Because it ain’t a memory

  • @walbertoXIII
    @walbertoXIII 3 месяца назад

    Since it was an error in the code, his memories of the skirmish were neither erased nor altered.

  • @divinestorm3562
    @divinestorm3562 Месяц назад

    My mind has just been blown because I watch that cinematic several times and I didn't even think about the fact that scara erased himself from existence that slipped my mind entirely🤯

  • @Smilingcat4ever
    @Smilingcat4ever 4 месяца назад +4

    Wait how in the world did I miss the scara detail?! 😭💀🙏

  • @Deadnight-ei6lp
    @Deadnight-ei6lp 4 месяца назад +13

    I noticed that Arlecchinos true name also phoneticlly sounds similar to Perinheri

  • @kitsune5746
    @kitsune5746 3 месяца назад

    Hoyoverse really knows how to cook a story

  • @enju7
    @enju7 4 месяца назад +2

    I also noticed Scaramouche and immediately made me wonder if Hoyo just wanted to show the original memory before he was deleted from Irminsul. However, we have already seen the consequences of Scara deleting himself from Irminsul, so why would they go out of their way to show a memory before that event?

    • @rainaghosh5198
      @rainaghosh5198 4 месяца назад +1

      Cause maybe that's not a memory just a way the storyteller telling us what transpired at that time

  • @gtoyadhatagyab8013
    @gtoyadhatagyab8013 4 месяца назад +4

    Who's Scaramouche?

  • @taakaashi
    @taakaashi 4 месяца назад +2

    If you look at the new post about her, you can see a wheel that has multiple symbols, each symbol represents a harbinger, and, there was one for wanderer.

  • @connorb1775
    @connorb1775 3 месяца назад +2

    I have two issue with this theory is that there are only 4 know descenders, and the second is that she has a vision
    The descender is the primordial one, and the fourth is the traveller, and the third descender being dead and turned in Gnosis doesn't leave much room for Father
    Maybe she could be a descendant of a descender and iruminsul is having issues computing her seemingly missing a family member from her family tree

  • @buttercup947
    @buttercup947 4 месяца назад +2

    Scaramouche actually is probably just there because not everyone has reached the part of the story where he’s wiped. Probably there to avoid spoilers for people I’m assuming

  • @nasmatique
    @nasmatique 3 месяца назад +1

    I think the only way to settle the debate regarding whether or not this short was based on Peruere's memories or not, is if she mentions Scara in her voice lines.
    If she does, she's highly likely to be a descender.

  • @hydrofalls8154
    @hydrofalls8154 11 дней назад

    Do you imagine The Wanderer seeing Arlecchino and she just. "Long time no see." To just leave with no explanations.

  • @angelalaurie1007
    @angelalaurie1007 4 месяца назад

    In a previous video, Minsleif talked about the Perinheri books and the crimson moon but i think she is linked to that crimson moon, just look at her ultimate animation and her splash art... There is the crimson moon behind her

  • @TheDramacist
    @TheDramacist 4 месяца назад

    Descender's memories are not affected by re-written history of the Irminsul tree. We're seeing A'cino's memories.

  • @Ohwoww
    @Ohwoww 3 месяца назад +1

    I think arlecchino is like the reincarnation of the crimson moon which is why her hands are black

  • @Klier2003
    @Klier2003 4 месяца назад +1

    I actually ignored that Scaramouche detail because I thought it was her past before he erased himself from Irminsul, but now that I thought about it clearly, it's actually strange to why he's there.

  • @MateoMatmat
    @MateoMatmat 4 месяца назад

    Scara: "Removes hiimself from irminsul"
    Arlecchino: "Did you get smaller?"

  • @bnpray2279
    @bnpray2279 4 месяца назад

    the fact that she remembered Scara is kinda a giveaway about her identity (at least for now) haha

  • @Goldy_the_Knight
    @Goldy_the_Knight 4 месяца назад +1

    This was a flashback to the original timeline before scaramouche erased himself.

  • @user-pq8vg5yz1h
    @user-pq8vg5yz1h 4 месяца назад +2

    Arlecchino and Clervie together r so cute!

  • @4rch0711
    @4rch0711 4 месяца назад

    Great Singularities always impact both the storyline and the players. We had Elysia sacrificing herself to give a chance for upcoming Herscherrs hold on to the bits of humanity they have left and fight back. Very excited to see how descenders impact the story and what her and the fatui's role in it

  • @daevastafford
    @daevastafford 4 месяца назад

    Damn... I was resisting the urge to pull, but now... MINSLEIF!!! 😤😭

  • @locksley12
    @locksley12 4 месяца назад

    I think it's just a flashback to her story before scara's existence got removed

  • @meikyochimatsuri448
    @meikyochimatsuri448 4 месяца назад

    One more hints about Teyvats being a huge Matrix, love it

  • @sahil00001
    @sahil00001 4 месяца назад

    Another reason why i can calm down

  • @mini3681
    @mini3681 4 месяца назад

    I think she remembers scara because she isn't from there and the tree only affects those who are born from there

  • @ClockiePizza
    @ClockiePizza 4 месяца назад +1

    UGH WHY AREN'T THESE THINGS IN THE NAIN QUESTS😭 Some people haven't or don't want to go looking for hidden lore. The main story would make so much more sense if they brought up stuff like this and actually explained it for those who didn't know about it :

  • @Why-nv2js
    @Why-nv2js 3 месяца назад

    Imagine Arlecchino meeting wanderer and say wassup

  • @KillerPassifist
    @KillerPassifist 3 месяца назад

    I still love that her title in the fight is "Peruere, Cinder of Two Worlds' Flames.

  • @ladyyobs8565
    @ladyyobs8565 3 месяца назад

    Because the animation it's not based on arleccino memories, it's an accurate vision of the events, for us, the viewers

  • @averagecupofcoffee
    @averagecupofcoffee 4 месяца назад +1

    Peruere does mean something, although it’s a loose transition- it’s “to succeed” in Latin, but I’ve also heard “to perish.”

  • @_Rabbit.Lori_
    @_Rabbit.Lori_ 4 месяца назад +1

    I mean Arlecchino became a harbinger BEFORE scaramouche wiped himself from the tree, since this is her past. So it didn’t really happen until AFTER Arlecchino is like an adult.

  • @no.one.has.survived
    @no.one.has.survived 4 месяца назад +2

    If scara will come back I'll literally die from happiness

  • @rakuzikanzakii7115
    @rakuzikanzakii7115 4 месяца назад

    The scara Detail just Clicked OMG

  • @TheBarcelonianRepublic
    @TheBarcelonianRepublic 4 месяца назад

    New Character: *Released*
    Everyone 2 seconds later:

  • @saraabdelaziz5306
    @saraabdelaziz5306 4 месяца назад +1

    Guys this clip was abt her when she first became a harbinger.. ofc scara was there it was not arlecchinos flashback i promise 💀

  • @stormcloudproductions2109
    @stormcloudproductions2109 3 месяца назад +1

    I don’t think we’re diving into her memories. I think this is just them, showing us how she became a harbinger.

  • @miko_oliver
    @miko_oliver 3 месяца назад

    the end made me think of arlecchino just staring at scaramouche and going "i know who you are" then acts like nothing happened

  • @kadambarisingh2101
    @kadambarisingh2101 2 месяца назад

    The in-game character archives actually show an error like appearance for arlecchino😮

  • @Advent10II7
    @Advent10II7 3 месяца назад

    I’ve been wondering for a while if Arlecchino would have voice lines about Scaramouche, and her being an error who remembers him would be such a cool way to implement them.

  • @Rewwrs
    @Rewwrs 3 месяца назад

    Holy shit it makes sense why in game one of her idle animations is her constantly glitching in and out

  • @rutkarsh08
    @rutkarsh08 4 месяца назад +1

    I mean we know from the interlude removing someone's existence from irminsul is not possible for someone ordinary. So, instead of removing existence, irminsul wiped scara's memories from everyone. So, the events happened, the crimes he did, happened, the people didn't just remember who did it, thus the vase in the sumeru room at the end of quest.
    TLDR: Nope, scara's existence was not wiped from irminsul but instead his memories were wiped

  • @DismemberTheAlamo
    @DismemberTheAlamo 3 месяца назад

    It mean its pretty obvious something is up because her idle animations include one of her glitching. Not, becoming spectral like a ghost or demon unable to control their form, but very much made to have he appearance of a digital "glitch"

  • @JTQA_Tester
    @JTQA_Tester 4 месяца назад

    Which makes sense by Piero mentioning that Rosaline aka LA Signora will be awoken in the new world

  • @ValiantStranger12
    @ValiantStranger12 4 месяца назад

    I've just come to accept that all Harbingers either can effect reality or are immune to reality shifts

  • @orbitgaming2400
    @orbitgaming2400 3 месяца назад

    scara: 'ye no ima just delete this detail'
    farther: 'skill issue my friend ik who u are'

    • @Mmmmmrrrrr103
      @Mmmmmrrrrr103 3 месяца назад

      Yeah about that.... No she didn't remember him

  • @NearNo1fan
    @NearNo1fan 3 месяца назад +1

    Scara still appears most likely because it's the truth??? Like I can't explain it but he didn't really disappear yk, the thing only changed people's memories and perception, not what really happened

  • @agatsumaVtuber
    @agatsumaVtuber 3 месяца назад +1

    I think the reason that scaramouche is there was this story happened before he delete himself from the Irminsul Tree and the pov is not from Arlecchino, its from us we are like a spectator

  • @iwanwoodley829
    @iwanwoodley829 3 месяца назад

    Also with the satellite, a moon is a satellite so it ties in with the theory of her being a reincarnation of the crimson moon god

  • @alicewnderlnd
    @alicewnderlnd 3 месяца назад

    Low and behold one of Arlecchino’s idles is her glitching

  • @GGameBois_o7
    @GGameBois_o7 3 месяца назад

    The glitching just makes her better tbh

  • @averagecupofcoffee
    @averagecupofcoffee 4 месяца назад

    I have a feeling that this was less of a recollection of memories and more so just a look into her past, so Scara is there because we remember him.

  • @spymadmax584
    @spymadmax584 4 месяца назад +2

    Scara part caught me off guard ngl

  • @mar-nyan
    @mar-nyan 4 месяца назад +1

    But the animation is clearly not done in 1st person POV, so there’s nothing weird about Scara being there. Irminsul changes the memories, not the actual past, so Scara was still present when the events in the animation took place.