This song has been out for over a decade. All this time later and I'm still listening, and of course it hits just as hard every time. Used to sit on top of my car in highschool playing this song all while wishing life was different. Now I'm married with a kid, and absolutely life is different. But this song will always be there to take me right back.
2022 and this song still hits just as hard as the first time. I've seen ADTR live a few times but I would just collapse if they ever played this song OR released it
found this song when i broke up with my first love in 2012, and now the feels are still here everytime i listen to this song. 2012 is 7 years ago. one of my high school memories, a good one. 2012 a year that i called a beautiful sadness.
I really wish they would remaster their EP! beautiful music on that album! "Halos for Heroes, Dirt For The Dead". It just has bad quality because it was recorded in Jeremy McKinnon's Bedroom.
agreed they have been my favorite band ever since i found them back when homesick first came out and i don't know if they ever wont be my fav there all so great but especially Jeremy so talented would be epic if they remastered that ep but i couldn't actually see them doing it.
This is my favorite acoustic song. Idc if jeremy didnt want this released its helped me through a few hard times. So i thank him for writing such a beautiful masterpiece
Except move on yourself. That is actually the only thing you can do at that point. Seeing as I've recently been through that kind of situation, the only thing I've learned i can do is just move on. It's hard, but not impossible.
I simply don't undertsand how anyone can dislike this, especially a song like this. Really! What kind of problems do you have to make you dislike this song.
When I posted that it was the first time i had heard it as well. But im not sure hoe long I just know its one of the earliest. I think off "And their name was treason"
Damn...brought tears to my eyes. It's been awhile since I came across a song on RUclips and continued to just sit there and replay it countless times... Kinda reminds me of my girlfriend in all honesty, but in a good way. I've been a huge fan of ADTR, but this....this takes it to a whole new level. Thanks guys (':
3 years ago I met a girl. 2 years ago I liked her. In previous autumn I loved her. And I have been listening to ADTR including this song for all those 2 years. It fit me perfectly. And now we are together, she loved me... Im so happy, this is the best thing that have ever happened with me in my life. Best 5 months I have ever lived. This love makes me so high! Thanks Jeremy, this song helped me a lot, it led me to this moment. It made me who I am now.
@@jacobconfined4836 We are still together and she is my wife now. And I am still loving her to death. And loving ADTR to death aswell xD Especially their old stuff
Lembro que conheci essa música quando tive minha primeira decepção amorosa kk nem sabia a tradução mas a melodia ja me fazia sofrer, quando descobrir a tradução parecia que estava descrevendo minha vida. Amo essa banda e amo o fato da música consiguir tocar nossas almas e nos transmitir sensações incríveis.
This song for some reason always seems to get to me. I have never been in a relationship before and I get this awkward feeling that I some how broken so many hearts. I have pushed away so many girls that anyone can say it's laughable that I would say "nobody likes me". Honestly I feel scared that when I get into a relationship, i might do something to screw it all up and feel the pain that everyone is feeling in the comments section. Everything seems to be out of place.
No matter what you give someone they can take you for granted and never realize. Then you’ll see them get hurt by the person they chose over you and still get no chance. Usually means you were led on and used. Ive been seeing this happen to everyone lately. I think of this song whenever this happens to people. Even me.
I knew a girl, the first verse to this was relevant. Then she went and made the whole song relevant, it was uncanny how the lyrics suddenly all came true and made perfect sense.
Dude this song reminds me of my ex so this makes me smile, esp. the "You'll think of me when you're next to him" part. Seriously, thanks for posting this
"Leaked online in late February 2010 was a song named "When 3's A Crowd". The song was written and recorded by Jeremy himself, and should not be associated directly with the band" got this from Wikipedia
I hear this and I think about him. I really dont know if this is for the best. I miss him some times but remember what he's put me through. I wonder if he thinks about me.. :/
this beautiful, mournful ode du sorrow helped me through. Glad, in retrospect, that I'm not where I would've been if I'd had my way then. She was a terrible person and I'm so glad we broke it off I'd have never been happy, she'd not have been satisfied until I had worked myself to death to support her. sometimes the pain of loss is a good thing.
I showed this to a girl and told her I can't listen to this song without thinking about her, along with a few others. She didn't seem like she cared all that much... but I'll always keep trying. I love you Lexie, and I want you more than anything.
You touch I tremble you never were one to play fair. I wish I hadn't been a game and you could have stop the tremble instead I feel that tremble in my heart everyday I just live with it...
Right? Story of my life! But life goes on dude, totally not worth your time anymore, life goes on and gets better and there is always someone else out there nicer, smarter, and more beautiful, all in the same bundle. You just have to find them! Cheers dude and freedom the fuck on!
Приколы
This song has been out for over a decade. All this time later and I'm still listening, and of course it hits just as hard every time. Used to sit on top of my car in highschool playing this song all while wishing life was different. Now I'm married with a kid, and absolutely life is different. But this song will always be there to take me right back.
Been out for over a decade and one of the few songs I wish was on Spotify
your comment made me nostalgic and sad :(
I remember listening to this in 8th grade. This video specifically. It’s so nice to see it still up
Who's still listening in 2019?
2020 lol
2021
Time is a social construct
2021
Does anyone know if this song is on spotify?
It's 2023 and I STILL cry when I hear this song.
Same man, same
Me too
And it’s 2022
Same and it's almost 2023 lol
2022 and this song still hits just as hard as the first time. I've seen ADTR live a few times but I would just collapse if they ever played this song OR released it
found this song when i broke up with my first love in 2012, and now the feels are still here everytime i listen to this song. 2012 is 7 years ago. one of my high school memories, a good one. 2012 a year that i called a beautiful sadness.
I really wish they would remaster their EP! beautiful music on that album! "Halos for Heroes, Dirt For The Dead". It just has bad quality because it was recorded in Jeremy McKinnon's Bedroom.
that would be awesome i agree i love this song
I love everything they have ever released. It's all so proper. Some of it just needs dusting off.
Nick55ADTR ^
agreed they have been my favorite band ever since i found them back when homesick first came out and i don't know if they ever wont be my fav there all so great but especially Jeremy so talented would be epic if they remastered that ep but i couldn't actually see them doing it.
This is my favorite acoustic song. Idc if jeremy didnt want this released its helped me through a few hard times. So i thank him for writing such a beautiful masterpiece
2023 and I still love hearing this
it's just so much harder to breathe when you're near.
Cienna Miller i just did a shower :/
The "We could have been beautiful!" in the background at the end was the perfect way to end this perfect song!
They need to put out an album with all of their unreleased songs on it
If jeremy can get through it then so can I. Thank you for this song Jer.
"You'll think of me when your next to him" ^^ best lyric ever
Who's still listening in 2018?
2019
🙌
2019 :c
2019 boiiiiiiiii
2020
That feeling knowing that she has completely moved on and you cant do anything about it....
Except move on yourself. That is actually the only thing you can do at that point. Seeing as I've recently been through that kind of situation, the only thing I've learned i can do is just move on. It's hard, but not impossible.
@@DJ-gu1kf Amen to that, time to focus on you and bettering yourself.
5 years later hope all is well
I know it is quite off topic but do anyone know of a good place to watch newly released movies online ?
@Kash Nicholas flixportal :)
You picked them over me...I loved you so much...I gave you my heart my soul..you still put me second to someone who doesn't care about you...
''Heartless'' is an amazing song, I think you might like it.
1:43 Favorite part of the song!
my favorite as well :3
Jeremy’s vocals are orgasmic same
I simply don't undertsand how anyone can dislike this, especially a song like this. Really! What kind of problems do you have to make you dislike this song.
Wow.....
I somehow have never heard this before today...just wow...
All ADTR is good....even better in concert sooo....its like a mountain, it rocks
When I posted that it was the first time i had heard it as well. But im not sure hoe long I just know its one of the earliest. I think off "And their name was treason"
no it's from halos for hero's, dirt for the dead
RaisinBrand no its not from adtr at all its just Jeremy
We could have been *beautiful*
Jeremy’s married with a kid now :’)
Bout to be 2 kids now
@@YungAegir still waiting on that album it’s hard when everyone has families
We're getting old
Damn...brought tears to my eyes. It's been awhile since I came across a song on RUclips and continued to just sit there and replay it countless times...
Kinda reminds me of my girlfriend in all honesty, but in a good way. I've been a huge fan of ADTR, but this....this takes it to a whole new level. Thanks guys (':
3 years ago I met a girl. 2 years ago I liked her. In previous autumn I loved her. And I have been listening to ADTR including this song for all those 2 years. It fit me perfectly. And now we are together, she loved me... Im so happy, this is the best thing that have ever happened with me in my life. Best 5 months I have ever lived. This love makes me so high! Thanks Jeremy, this song helped me a lot, it led me to this moment. It made me who I am now.
I need an update bro
@@jacobconfined4836 We are still together and she is my wife now. And I am still loving her to death. And loving ADTR to death aswell xD Especially their old stuff
Whose still listening 2021?
"I went to sleep thinking about you and I woke up just the same." I felt that
"We could've been beautiful" at 4:23 is amazing!!!
Play this every Valentine's Day
I think that with their upcoming album that Jeremy should go back and re-master this song. it'll make me a happy happy hippo
Lembro que conheci essa música quando tive minha primeira decepção amorosa kk nem sabia a tradução mas a melodia ja me fazia sofrer, quando descobrir a tradução parecia que estava descrevendo minha vida. Amo essa banda e amo o fato da música consiguir tocar nossas almas e nos transmitir sensações incríveis.
About 2004 or 2003, it was on their demo that sadly was never released.
This song for some reason always seems to get to me. I have never been in a relationship before and I get this awkward feeling that I some how broken so many hearts. I have pushed away so many girls that anyone can say it's laughable that I would say "nobody likes me". Honestly I feel scared that when I get into a relationship, i might do something to screw it all up and feel the pain that everyone is feeling in the comments section. Everything seems to be out of place.
Makes me want to cry so bad
No matter what you give someone they can take you for granted and never realize. Then you’ll see them get hurt by the person they chose over you and still get no chance. Usually means you were led on and used. Ive been seeing this happen to everyone lately. I think of this song whenever this happens to people. Even me.
I knew a girl, the first verse to this was relevant. Then she went and made the whole song relevant, it was uncanny how the lyrics suddenly all came true and made perfect sense.
this song makes me cry xc
All I can say is music speaks..love this song so much!!
First time I have heard this and it’s 2020. Nice song.
This band, it's so amazing. Jermey, I LOVE YOU.
This song hits home everytime ❤
I seriously love this song so much.
Chills, man. That's a beautiful song.
Dude this song reminds me of my ex so this makes me smile, esp. the "You'll think of me when you're next to him" part. Seriously, thanks for posting this
This is so perfect. I hope they'll re-release it :D
Westfall is another good chill song, it's a demo that was never officially released on an album.
best song ever
"Leaked online in late February 2010 was a song named "When 3's A Crowd". The song was written and recorded by Jeremy himself, and should not be associated directly with the band"
got this from Wikipedia
I broke the replay button...
very touching=/
"We could have been beautiful!"
I hear this and I think about him. I really dont know if this is for the best. I miss him some times but remember what he's put me through. I wonder if he thinks about me.. :/
Why do I feel like this takes me back? My phase with this wasn’t even 7 months ago
"Don't mind my asking, but could I trouble you, miss, for a smile?"
"why can't you just mean what you said, when you said 'no one can love me like you" FRIENDZONED :c
**you make it so hard for me to avert my eyes.
completely changes that line's meaning...
I didnt even know this song existed. wtf
RaisinBrand it was never supposed to be released Jeremy wrote it when he was 17
Omg perfection I love ADTR
I absolutely adore this song... reminds me of my man who just went away for months...
this beautiful, mournful ode du sorrow helped me through. Glad, in retrospect, that I'm not where I would've been if I'd had my way then.
She was a terrible person and I'm so glad we broke it off I'd have never been happy, she'd not have been satisfied until I had worked myself to death to support her.
sometimes the pain of loss is a good thing.
i'm so glad you could move on.
that's so great to hear. and i hope you are doing better.
:)
Forever obsessed 🖤🖤🖤🖤
I showed this to a girl and told her I can't listen to this song without thinking about her, along with a few others. She didn't seem like she cared all that much... but I'll always keep trying. I love you Lexie, and I want you more than anything.
Don't mind my asking, but could I trouble you, miss, for a smile?
Such an amazing song :)
That's because it was on their demo. It wasn't released. They've never played it live as far as I know.
I miss this.
This is a great song
awsome, just awsome
You touch I tremble you never were one to play fair.
I wish I hadn't been a game and you could have stop the tremble instead I feel that tremble in my heart everyday I just live with it...
This song is so amazing :3
We could've been beautiful, but you never gave me a chance.
I this song has saved me so many times. I was with her for over 2 years and she left me for someone I thought was my best friend xc
Right? Story of my life! But life goes on dude, totally not worth your time anymore, life goes on and gets better and there is always someone else out there nicer, smarter, and more beautiful, all in the same bundle. You just have to find them! Cheers dude and freedom the fuck on!
Damn bro you're stronger than me respect
bicho corno
2019
More like you'll think of him when you're next to me T-T
i love this song!
holy shiz i love this song. i thought i heard all adtr songs, damn this is good!
One of my favorite songs by adtr
I love this song
Are there any other chill ADTR songs like this?
I'm in love with it. You don't even know. ♥
This was a 2004 EP released along with Westfall, and The Sun Has Set.
Holy shit, all of their songs are amazing. I love ADTR!
This song and its feels are intense x:
we could've been beautiful...
I’m still listening in 2021. Who else!?
I love this song, it reminds me of her.
Yup... I love this song too, but kinda reminds me of him.
It's actually pretty easy to read, if you pay attention when you learn cursive back in GRADE SCHOOL
sooo good
Such a shame.. It is soo beautiful^^
2020 BABY!
awesome song!
o.m.f.g I MISSED THIS SONG SO MUCH
Listening in mid 2020
1:42 Oh my gawd.. So amazing,
When was this masterpiece recorded?
This song gives me hope.
Awesome songggggg! :D xx
So cute C':
HOLY **** It s unbelieveable how much I can relate to this song....
"You'll think if me when your next to him" /3
you made it so hard for me to close my eyes....