@@sbmuss7118 i know. Thats why i like him. He's very relatable to me. I like how he actually kept a normal job while working on red dead redemption 1 and 2, but he has became a bit more of a common occurance on camera compared to when he was on rdr1
That scene gets me every time. Hes just so raw in this moment, hes a broken man, and for him to be just so vulnerable tells us so much about the character
he's done so much, seen so much, suffered and felt so much ... by that point? He's despairing - he knows death's coming, even welcomes it, but he has one more thing he needs to do. One thing that motivates him to keep going until he sees it done. That's what propels him right up until his dying breath.
My old Highschool English teacher once told me "There is a difference between having a character be afraid and having a character feel fear" and I think about that a lot with this scene
@abramoostronzo2618 my interpretation of it is that while you feel afraid of something, be it an outcome/person/thing, you're not locked in fear meaning you can still function and you still have your wits. If you're fearful you'll act irrationally
Honestly wished they’d have done more with it than just have a couple different lines of dialogue. Was so grateful to have gotten the good ending the first time through. I would have been shattered if I’d have gotten that bad one.
I think a genre that's very masculine showing vulnerability in a way that was unexpected catches you off gaurd in an emotional way is ultimately why I thought this scene was so compelling. You're used to Arthur not really opening up too much about his feelings, so him showing genuine human fear for death really makes him feel so much more real, as opposed to the typical "I don't give a shit about dyin'" cigar-in-mouth havin badass character.
This video game is one of the only video games that made me feel like I was playing as a person that actually existed. I was emotionally invested in their lives and did everything I could to make Arthur the best person possible so that makes this game so good
@buriednameless965 yeah oddly enough it happened to me today. Did you know arthur sings himself a little tune quietly while exploring big valley for the first time?
And the most realistic character to ever be written, it’s so good that he feels like he existed in our time. And he’s the most human that anyone can relate. He has pain, joy, love, hatred. And all of those get thrown into a mix that becomes sludge. And yet he still keeps going due to bad circumstances and is hopeful for change. It’s like what everyone in reality does, and it’s what makes him such a legendary character.
Seeing Arthur slowly die, over the course of the last act breaks my heart, truely tragic what disease can do to a healthy person, sometimes irreparable damage.
Throughout the game we can see Arthur never been scared of anything even going to hell. But knowing that he's about to die without doing anything to help his family actually scared him. And seeing him like actually broke me so emotionally that I started to rethink about my life choices
Arthur was a good guy who used his loyalty and moral center to protect his perceived family. The ppl that took him in as an orphaned child, taught him to read and how to stay alive. It’s evident through the game that it had long been Arthur’s responsibility to keep these ppl well. If he doesn’t give food, it stays red, if he doesn’t protect the ladies at least twice someone would have hurt them. He gives the most to the camp box. He’s always the voice of reason even if he still follows through with what Dutch wants, whom he sees as a father figure. You did well sir, there’s no better protagonist than Arthur Morgan.
Arthur is a brutal man and lived a brutal life because he felt like there was no other choice. He still wants to do good but he’s a cold blooded killer. It’s hard to say that adds up to a good man but Arthur definitely wants to be a good man. I think he redeems himself in the end with a grand sacrifice.
And it’s good that he doesn’t justify for being good, he knows he doesn’t deserve it. But he knows he deserves it when he helps the people he loves. Because that’s when he’s ready to accept that he’s a good man and ready to die for people.
Cuando Arthur dice tengo miedo estuvo fuerte hermano se transfirió totalmente la emoción del personaje. Tremendo trabajo, uno de los diálogos que más recuerdo.
Played rdr2 for the first time recently, got me through a very rough patch in my life. Best scene in the game. Being my name is Morgan and I USED to be what one could call a problem. Arthur Morgan didn’t just allow me to reflect on my own life but appreciate the changes I’ve made and how important the people that accept me are as well as make me look forward to the progress I continue to make. He also taught me that using my strong arm CAN be a used for good and helping those around me that can’t do it themself. Most impactful protagonist I’ve had the honor of experiencing.
This is typically why i keep arthur in the Grey until the later chapters, because of what Clark says about human nature. We're good one day then bad the next
holy fuck, and of course he has the PERFECT explanation for why that scene not only works well in the genre still but also why it works well in general for a person like Arthur. he literally needs to be him in a live action anything.
I got this in my playthrough, and deeply appreciate the utter vulnerability it takes to pull something like that off genuinely. It almost feels like Arthur is tapping into an innocent, almost childlike fear. Beautiful, heartbreaking, and inspiring.
This scene was as much of a tearjerker as his death. He’s as honest and raw about his impending death as he can be, to the only person he’s sure won’t judge him negatively for that honesty. In that rawness, Calderon sees that he’s looking to make up for past sins, and to be the good man she’s know so far, and not the outlaw killer and thief he’s been. Amazing scene.
"People can be complicated. They can be good one day, and bad the next. That's not a contradiction of their character - people react differently in different circumstances." That really resonated with me. I needed to hear that.
That's why I connected with Arthur more than any other character in maybe anything. He's not a good person he's not a bad person. He does good things and bad things. Some people look at him like a monster some people look at him like a hero.
This was an extremely powerful scene which I was not expecting and then I found out later the other players didn't see this scene because they didn't have high enough honour I'm really glad I went through my first playthrough as a good man
This scene hit me hard, since it reminded me of my father he literally had this conversation with his actual sister. I was there listening to it all, hearing my father who i saw as this strong person knowing his achievements and feats. Just terrified of what's to come, i still miss him.
This scene made me tear up slightly. That was when I realized that arthur was going to die at the end. All the actors were great in this game. I never got emotional about a game story before this one, and the ending made me cry.
My grandfather said something similar to me when he was in the hospital due to cancer. When I saw this scene in RDR2, it broke me. I couldn't even think about playing the game for days.
But I think there’s something special about that nun (maybe similar to the strange man) bc she’s also in rdr1 and she even survives the events of undead nightmare lol
It would be cool to have a sit down with Roger 1 on 1 as a fan. You just talk to him about the game and some of the things it took to create it, and then you convince him to do a monologue from the game in Arthur Morgan’s voice. That kind of stuff would make my life complete
I respected Roger Clark for his performance in rdr2 but now respects him even more with his insight with the narrative and his own character, you can tell how passionate he is.
"People can be complicated they can be good one day and be bad the next, and thats not a Contradiction of their character, people react differently in different circumstances"
I’ve gone a long time in life and still to this day not knowing the type of man I am. I’ve done some real awful things and hurt people. I’ve also sacrificed my mind body and soul for people I’ve barely known. I struggle with self a lot and this game really opened my eyes that. People are complex. They learn, they grow, they make mistakes. But they persevere. And right now perseverance is all I need until I take the next step in life. Don’t give up.
Yes, I think it was one of the most unexpected story twists I've ever came across in a video game. It's such a grounded story from that point on, like reality is kicking you in the head, making you aware what kind of life Arthur is actually living, not the outlaw fantasy you want to experience.
Arthur is one of the best written characters in any game, movie, story or anything else. Rockstar knocked it out of the park with RDR2... and Roger's performance is absolutely wonderful. EVERY performance in this game is wonderful. It's the gold standard now.
Seeing Arthur through thr story of the game, a poet, a writer, an artist, a man who felt and thought deeply when left to his own devices. Brought to such a blisteringly transparent place - I'm scared to die. The performance is so painful, it's sold so perfectly and so real. it's hard to see him - scared to die, wavering with fear for the large unknowable chasm that awaits us. And even more painful, in a wonderful way, that Sister Calderón is there to immediately comfort him. Arthur spends so much time alone, looking for connection but guarded from heartbreak, and in this one scene he tells the world he's scared - and the world says there is NOTHING to be afraid if. It's the comfort given with the love of a mother. With gentleness and conviction. she isn't convincing him of a religious belief, she's saying with motherly certainty he is going to be ok. that's exactly what someone needs in a spasm of genuine terror. he let the walls down and she responded with love. she practised exactly as she preached. what a blessing to have this scene
I got this scene in my first playthrough and it really made me not want to continue the story, knowing that if i dident accept that misson, i dident have to face the reality like arthur. Truely an amazing game.
It was a great devolopment. A ruthless killer of men forced to face his mortality in a way he had never anticipated. Completely changing his outlook on his life and what would come next. It's great.
I hope this man realizes how much he has gifted to do the gaming community, blessing us with humanity instesd of plain shootouts and massacres. This game have changed some of my friends view of videogames, people, society, art and everything reality implies.
I wonder when my time comes to leave this world if ill have time like Arthur did to help atleast one person i wonder if ill remember Arthur in that time
I like to pay arthur as if I were in his shoes as often as I can. Granted there are many times where I dont as well. Many times I give the helping hand but I think I do just as much gun draws. I got this cut scene my first time and I honestly felt that fear, but I felt kindness from the sister. I at that moment felt like I was Arthur. Never again have I felt like the charater I was playing as if I were them no matter what other games had done. Thank you for bringing this character to life the way you did, for I may have never experienced such a connection.
![Red Dead Redemption II Cast [SacAnime Summer 2019]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ifohZGPVBMQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![Red Dead Redemption II Cast [SacAnime Summer 2019]](/img/tr.png)
It's just like what Hosea said "I've seen unspeakable evil, and incredible kindness... Often from the same people"
Im just writing this that i agree, cuz i wanna keep the like count to 444
@@vetonrecica5558 imma do unspeakable evil, changing the like count😈 now it's 445 likes
But remaining kind in those unspeakable moments, it’s what makes you an outstanding human being.
That sums up Dutch so well
It’s honestly such a beautiful quote
So good seeing Roger talk about rdr2
Fr
Same. I wish john's VA had this opportunity with rdr1 too. I remember playing that game for hours, just like i did this one.
@@lilmancc35johns va had always been a rly quiet dude, he’s barely done anything besides rdr n kinda just keep to a private life
@@sbmuss7118 i know. Thats why i like him. He's very relatable to me. I like how he actually kept a normal job while working on red dead redemption 1 and 2, but he has became a bit more of a common occurance on camera compared to when he was on rdr1
My favorite scene. “Take a chance that love exists, and do a loving act”
Not chance but gamble
That scene gets me every time. Hes just so raw in this moment, hes a broken man, and for him to be just so vulnerable tells us so much about the character
he's done so much, seen so much, suffered and felt so much ... by that point? He's despairing - he knows death's coming, even welcomes it, but he has one more thing he needs to do. One thing that motivates him to keep going until he sees it done. That's what propels him right up until his dying breath.
My old Highschool English teacher once told me "There is a difference between having a character be afraid and having a character feel fear" and I think about that a lot with this scene
What does it mean?
@abramoostronzo2618 my interpretation of it is that while you feel afraid of something, be it an outcome/person/thing, you're not locked in fear meaning you can still function and you still have your wits. If you're fearful you'll act irrationally
The honor mechanic in this game was brilliant
Honestly wished they’d have done more with it than just have a couple different lines of dialogue. Was so grateful to have gotten the good ending the first time through. I would have been shattered if I’d have gotten that bad one.
Not really just change cutscenes
Nah it wasn't, barely changes anything
@@porkins4108let’s just say….I was visibly regretful about every choice I’ve made after Arthur’s head was obliterated
@@DOWNTOWNMAK I think I audibly gasped when I watched it online afterwards
'' I'm afraid '' is the best delivered line in voice acting
the entire scene is god tier
It's performance capture not just voice act
I think a genre that's very masculine showing vulnerability in a way that was unexpected catches you off gaurd in an emotional way is ultimately why I thought this scene was so compelling. You're used to Arthur not really opening up too much about his feelings, so him showing genuine human fear for death really makes him feel so much more real, as opposed to the typical "I don't give a shit about dyin'" cigar-in-mouth havin badass character.
This video game is one of the only video games that made me feel like I was playing as a person that actually existed. I was emotionally invested in their lives and did everything I could to make Arthur the best person possible so that makes this game so good
“You’re a good man Arthur Morgan”
and you sir...are a fish
To the bar, señor!
When does he say this about the fish? I've played through sooo many times and can't remember it
@@justinakers3196 it's a random like that sometimes plays when you catch a fish, I think it's relatively uncommon
@buriednameless965 yeah oddly enough it happened to me today. Did you know arthur sings himself a little tune quietly while exploring big valley for the first time?
That scene broke my soul
Same 😢
I can’t lie he might just be one of the most well written characters in all of fiction
And the most realistic character to ever be written, it’s so good that he feels like he existed in our time. And he’s the most human that anyone can relate.
He has pain, joy, love, hatred. And all of those get thrown into a mix that becomes sludge. And yet he still keeps going due to bad circumstances and is hopeful for change. It’s like what everyone in reality does, and it’s what makes him such a legendary character.
@@thenom6648 hes perfectly imperfect, perfectly human
@@kaiser234 I agree
That was the most heartbreaking moment for me in RDR2. It really got me. The tears in his eyes and the shaking voice. Oh, Arthur
Seeing Arthur slowly die, over the course of the last act breaks my heart, truely tragic what disease can do to a healthy person, sometimes irreparable damage.
Throughout the game we can see Arthur never been scared of anything even going to hell. But knowing that he's about to die without doing anything to help his family actually scared him. And seeing him like actually broke me so emotionally that I started to rethink about my life choices
That scene was amazing and heart warming. I liked playing the regretful Arthur.
The way he explains this entire thing, and especially the ending of this just goes to show that they really chose the right man to play Arthur.
Man, that scene makes me tear up. How vulnerable Arthur was and how understanding Sister Calderon on this exchange is brilliant.
Arthur was a good guy who used his loyalty and moral center to protect his perceived family. The ppl that took him in as an orphaned child, taught him to read and how to stay alive. It’s evident through the game that it had long been Arthur’s responsibility to keep these ppl well. If he doesn’t give food, it stays red, if he doesn’t protect the ladies at least twice someone would have hurt them. He gives the most to the camp box. He’s always the voice of reason even if he still follows through with what Dutch wants, whom he sees as a father figure. You did well sir, there’s no better protagonist than Arthur Morgan.
It was human. And it really hit home if played correctly. Best game of all time no debate
I feel bad for anyone who's only ever played through the game once at low honor. High honor Arthur is definitely canon.
Arthur is a brutal man and lived a brutal life because he felt like there was no other choice. He still wants to do good but he’s a cold blooded killer. It’s hard to say that adds up to a good man but Arthur definitely wants to be a good man. I think he redeems himself in the end with a grand sacrifice.
And it’s good that he doesn’t justify for being good, he knows he doesn’t deserve it. But he knows he deserves it when he helps the people he loves. Because that’s when he’s ready to accept that he’s a good man and ready to die for people.
Cuando Arthur dice tengo miedo estuvo fuerte hermano se transfirió totalmente la emoción del personaje. Tremendo trabajo, uno de los diálogos que más recuerdo.
We need a movie with him in it and we need it now!!!
There's a movie called The Bunker that he's in
@@JACKRIDERPLAYZIm pretty sure they meant a red dead movie but ok💀
Imagine a live action RDR with Jeffrey Dean Morgan as Arthur and Jensen Ackles as John
@@firephoenix019 that would be amazing
@@EpsilxnMUSICThat "💀" was unnecessary
Played rdr2 for the first time recently, got me through a very rough patch in my life. Best scene in the game. Being my name is Morgan and I USED to be what one could call a problem. Arthur Morgan didn’t just allow me to reflect on my own life but appreciate the changes I’ve made and how important the people that accept me are as well as make me look forward to the progress I continue to make. He also taught me that using my strong arm CAN be a used for good and helping those around me that can’t do it themself. Most impactful protagonist I’ve had the honor of experiencing.
“Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act.”
The only bad part of the game was having to see Arthur die. I don’t care if he faced the way he wanted in the sun. It’s still so sad
The fact that this is such a masterpiece and I can’t ever explain its importance to my parents because it’s just a video game is unjustified
Yeah this scene touched my heart. It showed the emotions in which Arthur felt, making us more connected to the game.
This is typically why i keep arthur in the Grey until the later chapters, because of what Clark says about human nature. We're good one day then bad the next
This scene gets me every time…the fear on his face and the way she comforts him.
holy fuck, and of course he has the PERFECT explanation for why that scene not only works well in the genre still but also why it works well in general for a person like Arthur. he literally needs to be him in a live action anything.
I got this in my playthrough, and deeply appreciate the utter vulnerability it takes to pull something like that off genuinely. It almost feels like Arthur is tapping into an innocent, almost childlike fear. Beautiful, heartbreaking, and inspiring.
No one is ever just one thing
So many people missed this beautiful scene. I missed it on my first playthrough, it's crazy such an emotional scene can be so easily missed.
This scene was as much of a tearjerker as his death. He’s as honest and raw about his impending death as he can be, to the only person he’s sure won’t judge him negatively for that honesty. In that rawness, Calderon sees that he’s looking to make up for past sins, and to be the good man she’s know so far, and not the outlaw killer and thief he’s been. Amazing scene.
That was legitimately one of my favorite scenes in the game. Very emotional moment.
"People can be complicated. They can be good one day, and bad the next. That's not a contradiction of their character - people react differently in different circumstances."
That really resonated with me. I needed to hear that.
That's why I connected with Arthur more than any other character in maybe anything. He's not a good person he's not a bad person. He does good things and bad things. Some people look at him like a monster some people look at him like a hero.
This was an extremely powerful scene which I was not expecting and then I found out later the other players didn't see this scene because they didn't have high enough honour I'm really glad I went through my first playthrough as a good man
People who have an Arthur without a big beard are just odd.
Tuberculosis is very curable. Arthur should have just moved to a dry and warm area. If only there was such a place nearby, well darn it!
He looks so sad it makes me tear up everytime
This scene hit me hard, since it reminded me of my father he literally had this conversation with his actual sister. I was there listening to it all, hearing my father who i saw as this strong person knowing his achievements and feats. Just terrified of what's to come, i still miss him.
For me it's the most emotional scene
"I'm afraid" No matter how many times I heard that line a tear always escapes
This scene made me tear up slightly. That was when I realized that arthur was going to die at the end. All the actors were great in this game. I never got emotional about a game story before this one, and the ending made me cry.
Roger Clark understood Arthur and his journey on such a deep level. Man pulled off one of the greatest performances in the history of visual media fr
My grandfather said something similar to me when he was in the hospital due to cancer. When I saw this scene in RDR2, it broke me. I couldn't even think about playing the game for days.
This is hands down one of my favorite scenes in the game
everybody who has seen this moment probably had high honor in their games for the fact they see this guy as a hero
Redemption is not a good thing that happens to someone bad, it is someone who understands that there where always goodness inside and embrace it.
Probably one of my favorites, hell might actually be one of my favorite scenes
That scene was very heavy on the heart
By far my favorite game of all time. I still play this masterpiece till this day. RDR2 was just perfection
I got that scene, and it broke me. Arthur saying “I’m afraid” made realize the end was near.
I cried on that scene so first time I did played the game but I did not know that how did I trigger that scene ty
I think you have to be high honor too.
I prefer seeing the reverend instead tbh, otherwise ya never hear about him again.
But I think there’s something special about that nun (maybe similar to the strange man) bc she’s also in rdr1 and she even survives the events of undead nightmare lol
No joke, this is probably my favourite scene from any game or movie. Its so brilliantly written and performed
This is my favourite moment in the game. I always cry a lil bit ngl
in my opinion arthur morgan is one of if not the best written video game character i've ever had the pleasure of playing
One of my favorite parts of this game is this moment I cry every time
I’m afraid
This moment pulled on the heart strings man 😭
It would be cool to have a sit down with Roger 1 on 1 as a fan. You just talk to him about the game and some of the things it took to create it, and then you convince him to do a monologue from the game in Arthur Morgan’s voice. That kind of stuff would make my life complete
I got this scene on my first playthrough and thought it was so impactful, i didn't even realize it was a missable scene till my second playthrough
I'm disappointed he's not speaking in Arthur's voice
I respected Roger Clark for his performance in rdr2 but now respects him even more with his insight with the narrative and his own character, you can tell how passionate he is.
Its sometimes easier to open up to a stranger who seems to have a mother-like essence to them
The damn acting in this game is superb.
I played through this game 3 times. Did so many things and still missed this amazing scene.
His face expression is so powerful in this scene
"People can be complicated they can be good one day and be bad the next, and thats not a Contradiction of their character, people react differently in different circumstances"
I’ve gone a long time in life and still to this day not knowing the type of man I am. I’ve done some real awful things and hurt people. I’ve also sacrificed my mind body and soul for people I’ve barely known. I struggle with self a lot and this game really opened my eyes that. People are complex. They learn, they grow, they make mistakes. But they persevere. And right now perseverance is all I need until I take the next step in life. Don’t give up.
On Arhurs final ride. I heard Hosea say "i just dont want people to die Dutch" and it broke me. I never heard that on another one of my playthroughs
Yes, I think it was one of the most unexpected story twists I've ever came across in a video game. It's such a grounded story from that point on, like reality is kicking you in the head, making you aware what kind of life Arthur is actually living, not the outlaw fantasy you want to experience.
Man, i didnt know people might not get that scene. Had it in my play through and i was reduced to tears when he said "I'm afraid"
all these years later its still the best video game protagonist in any game.
Arthur is one of the best written characters in any game, movie, story or anything else. Rockstar knocked it out of the park with RDR2... and Roger's performance is absolutely wonderful. EVERY performance in this game is wonderful.
It's the gold standard now.
It was a really powerful scene. The whole story is amazing tbh.
Seeing Arthur through thr story of the game, a poet, a writer, an artist, a man who felt and thought deeply when left to his own devices. Brought to such a blisteringly transparent place - I'm scared to die. The performance is so painful, it's sold so perfectly and so real. it's hard to see him - scared to die, wavering with fear for the large unknowable chasm that awaits us. And even more painful, in a wonderful way, that Sister Calderón is there to immediately comfort him.
Arthur spends so much time alone, looking for connection but guarded from heartbreak, and in this one scene he tells the world he's scared - and the world says there is NOTHING to be afraid if. It's the comfort given with the love of a mother. With gentleness and conviction. she isn't convincing him of a religious belief, she's saying with motherly certainty he is going to be ok. that's exactly what someone needs in a spasm of genuine terror. he let the walls down and she responded with love. she practised exactly as she preached. what a blessing to have this scene
This scene made me weeep like fucking baby. It was sooo emotional good
I got this scene in my first playthrough and it really made me not want to continue the story, knowing that if i dident accept that misson, i dident have to face the reality like arthur. Truely an amazing game.
I got this on my first playthrough and it hit the feels
This is one of my favorite scene!
It was a great devolopment. A ruthless killer of men forced to face his mortality in a way he had never anticipated. Completely changing his outlook on his life and what would come next. It's great.
I hope this man realizes how much he has gifted to do the gaming community, blessing us with humanity instesd of plain shootouts and massacres. This game have changed some of my friends view of videogames, people, society, art and everything reality implies.
I really loved this scene so much. On my first playthrough, I cried with Arthur, its hard not too :3
I hear him saying I’m afraid I’m my head the most definitely the line that stuck with me the most
I pity those who miss this cutscene. It is one of the best in the game. Very powerful, and revealing.
I wonder when my time comes to leave this world if ill have time like Arthur did to help atleast one person i wonder if ill remember Arthur in that time
It’s honestly one of the best scenes in the whole game
RDR2 is a Magnum Opus
That was a powerful and deep Cut scene
“Good one day, bad the next”
I like to pay arthur as if I were in his shoes as often as I can. Granted there are many times where I dont as well. Many times I give the helping hand but I think I do just as much gun draws. I got this cut scene my first time and I honestly felt that fear, but I felt kindness from the sister. I at that moment felt like I was Arthur. Never again have I felt like the charater I was playing as if I were them no matter what other games had done. Thank you for bringing this character to life the way you did, for I may have never experienced such a connection.
I just love roger and his passion for not only acting but playing this game. He loves it an appreciates it just as much as we do 🥹
One of the best scenes in the game
This was my favorite scene in the game, I had a couple glasses of wine in me and this scene really hit me in the feels lol
This scene was surreal.