i may not agree with a lot of your takes here but A.) big props for you for not caring what others thinking and saying what you dont really mean for easy views, I love the confident honesty and B.) Its Undeniable that malzeno has the best theme and even with your hot takes you acknowledge it
I appreciate how your editing is still hugely high-effort, even for a relatively simple tier list like this; it really gives every song a chance to shine in its context! I prefer the Elgado theme a lot more than they're placed on the list, but I'm probably biased by the jazz version, which I've completely replaced it with. Scarlet Feast, though? ABSOLUTELY where it belongs. Instant masterpiece.
Espinas's theme isn't the from Low Rank Jungle. It's from High Rank Great Forest. Edit: and Low Rank Jungle would just be the regular Jungle theme, the one that already plays on the map in Sunbreak normally
On the Shagaru Themes, my favourite version is the 10th anniversary orchestra version. Altough thats an unfair comparison, with the remix not beeing intended to be played ingame on a hunt, it's just inexplicably beautiful and really feels like it tells an important story
Malzeno Vs Gaismagorm: ruclips.net/video/LYjQEyla8WQ/видео.htmlsi=6YcTDm6rhiJw1sJ- Primordial Malzeno Vs Gaismagorm: ruclips.net/video/si-Gb13jwmI/видео.htmlsi=8d32ACTgphKap0GQ
I REALLY like Sunbreak's Proof of a Hero personally, it might just be my new favorite version of it. It's the first version of Proof of a Hero that feels like it was explicitly made for the monster that it actually plays on, it has some arrangement changes like you mentioned and features taken from Archdemon of the Abyss, which makes it feel appropriate for the fight. It's not just Sunbreak's Proof of a Hero, it's Gaismagorm's Proof of a Hero, and it's the only one I can really say that about.
since its not on the list, what is your opinion on the theme when you fight the afflicted lunagaron in the story? you know, the one with the horror. Was really looking forward to this video, you delivered!
I definitely agree about Shagaru'd theme being better in sunbreak. They did change up one part of the song that instantly madr it better for me than the original, and thats the section right after the first section when the pitch changes, as the original theme just repeated the same melody with no change and then suddenly changes pitch when the buildup needs it, whereas the buildup starts earlier in sunbreak, and carries into the rest of the theme
Ok hear me out all village themes tierlist no need to thank me for a great video idea. (Btw if you end up making a video like that please include the themes from stories they are great and gildegarn and hakum village themes are both s tier if not higher) (oh and I do know this video is 10 months old)
I was really disappointed by the new versions of old themes in sunbreak. it was a great opportunity to change the feeling of these themes in interesting ways but to me they just sound like almost 1:1 remakes, the only exception is astalos. The best remake still remains to be misutsunes theme tho. Also while i think the citadel really doesnt sound nearly climactic enough i still would put it as my 4th or 5th favorite
i may not agree with a lot of your takes here but A.) big props for you for not caring what others thinking and saying what you dont really mean for easy views, I love the confident honesty and B.) Its Undeniable that malzeno has the best theme and even with your hot takes you acknowledge it
I appreciate how your editing is still hugely high-effort, even for a relatively simple tier list like this; it really gives every song a chance to shine in its context!
I prefer the Elgado theme a lot more than they're placed on the list, but I'm probably biased by the jazz version, which I've completely replaced it with.
Scarlet Feast, though? ABSOLUTELY where it belongs. Instant masterpiece.
Espinas's theme isn't the from Low Rank Jungle. It's from High Rank Great Forest.
Edit: and Low Rank Jungle would just be the regular Jungle theme, the one that already plays on the map in Sunbreak normally
Ill be completely Honest. Sunbreak Proof of a Hero is my absolute favorite version of it. Its just so smooooooooooth
On the Shagaru Themes, my favourite version is the 10th anniversary orchestra version. Altough thats an unfair comparison, with the remix not beeing intended to be played ingame on a hunt, it's just inexplicably beautiful and really feels like it tells an important story
I can't say I've heard of the orchestra versions, I'll have to look for those
Even in a theme tierlist, Gaismagorm gets clowned on by Malzeno
Malzeno Vs Gaismagorm: ruclips.net/video/LYjQEyla8WQ/видео.htmlsi=6YcTDm6rhiJw1sJ-
Primordial Malzeno Vs Gaismagorm: ruclips.net/video/si-Gb13jwmI/видео.htmlsi=8d32ACTgphKap0GQ
@@BoneReaperLagiallosaurus why
@@Roigraton cause I feel like it :)
Personally I perfer giasmagorm but that's because M O L E
I REALLY like Sunbreak's Proof of a Hero personally, it might just be my new favorite version of it. It's the first version of Proof of a Hero that feels like it was explicitly made for the monster that it actually plays on, it has some arrangement changes like you mentioned and features taken from Archdemon of the Abyss, which makes it feel appropriate for the fight.
It's not just Sunbreak's Proof of a Hero, it's Gaismagorm's Proof of a Hero, and it's the only one I can really say that about.
immediately puts the best village theme in all of monster hunter in the Worst slot 🤷♀
For real
L take elgado theme is mid at best
Elgado is C- at best, somehow I find asteras theme more pleasing to the ears
Pokke would like a word with you
Rise baby detected
The “tubas” in gore magala’s theme sound way more like trombones especially since they have the melody there
espinas theme perfectly describes your mentality after being paralyzed, poisoned and burnt from 1 fireball
Sunbreaks ending credits theme is one of the most beautiful ones for sure
since its not on the list, what is your opinion on the theme when you fight the afflicted lunagaron in the story? you know, the one with the horror.
Was really looking forward to this video, you delivered!
Gathering of the Qurio is one of the creepiest themes in MH if not the most creepy.
The trumpet in gore’s theme reminds me of a college football band
Casually puts the best theme ever in the third last place
common Malzeno W
Walzeno
Malzenos theme just feels royal
18:50 astalos was so difficult for me when I first hunted it
I definitely agree about Shagaru'd theme being better in sunbreak. They did change up one part of the song that instantly madr it better for me than the original, and thats the section right after the first section when the pitch changes, as the original theme just repeated the same melody with no change and then suddenly changes pitch when the buildup needs it, whereas the buildup starts earlier in sunbreak, and carries into the rest of the theme
Definitely a controversial tier list to say the least lol
Don’t even have to watch to know Malzeno is most likely number 1. It really does sound like you’re fighting Dracula as a dragon.
Yo even the Metal remix Malzeno slaps even harder!
Im still searching the name of band that made it!
Astalos is my 3rd favourite theme
I know from playing sunbreak that the sunbreak shaguru theme is easily better than the original
Ok hear me out all village themes tierlist no need to thank me for a great video idea. (Btw if you end up making a video like that please include the themes from stories they are great and gildegarn and hakum village themes are both s tier if not higher) (oh and I do know this video is 10 months old)
you need to do the world and iceborn version i love so much that video
5:20 wait, you can change the music for Elgado? How?
Talk to the cat in your room and it should let you
The Cat in your room gives you the option to pick music you already heard during Hunts like Malzeno theme or Map Themes
Malzeno theme is better than velkhana cough cough
I agree with your piano
Opinion*
agree all day
Agreed
True
I feel espinas’s theme would’ve been better if it was more like yian garuga in world
Do a world them tier list
The Citadel has one of the best area themes ever in MH
You could've ratée tye intros to the Citadel you know the starting theme before you go look for a. Monster
You should try the mhw theme , there are banger
I was really disappointed by the new versions of old themes in sunbreak. it was a great opportunity to change the feeling of these themes in interesting ways but to me they just sound like almost 1:1 remakes, the only exception is astalos. The best remake still remains to be misutsunes theme tho. Also while i think the citadel really doesnt sound nearly climactic enough i still would put it as my 4th or 5th favorite
Bazelgeuses theme is better than malzenos
For almost all remakes from 4u even shagaru's , the originals are defenetly better
pls don't kill me its my opignion
The menu and elgado theme remind me of Sonic 06, so I hate it
I,m not a fan of gaismagorms theme
I really hate the credits scene of Sunbreak, it sounds so much like Disney and I hate it.
I can definitely see that now that you mention it.
Your partner was right.
The original Shagaru theme was better.
The original shagurus theme is trash
god the elgado theme's so overrated. by far the most boring and forgettable village theme.
It's beautifully done. Just not as catchy. Whoever did that has extremely good taste in musical arrangements.
Malzenos theme is so bad