Huawei Watch Fit Review: Heart Rate Accuracy (test)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 297

  • @stefan5414
    @stefan5414 3 года назад +102

    This is what we need. A reviewer that actually compares fitness trackers to established health measurement devices. This channel deserves more attention! Keep up the good work, LG aus Wien

  • @mousaqa4998
    @mousaqa4998 4 года назад +76

    The best comparison on the RUclips .. Thank you so much .

  • @TheQuantifiedScientist
    @TheQuantifiedScientist  4 года назад +1

    *Subscribe to my weekly Newsletter(!)* on www.robterhorst.com
    Instagram: instagram.com/quantified_scientist/
    Twitter: @QuantifiedRob
    👇Amazon Affiliate links, support the channel!👇
    Huawei Watch Fit: geni.us/wAaY
    Of course, only buy it if it makes sense for you!👍

  • @nadamohammad8230
    @nadamohammad8230 3 года назад +1

    I don't trust other channels anymore. Thank you for the effort you put in these videos.

  • @MICHA3363
    @MICHA3363 4 года назад +16

    As always very good test. Would love to see sleeptracking, step counting and More ☺️

    • @donantoni0
      @donantoni0 3 года назад

      So would I because my steps are way off. Very disappointed

  • @Snowmans.Cradle
    @Snowmans.Cradle 4 года назад +38

    So, TruSleep accuracy test is near as well?

  • @tahmidt
    @tahmidt 3 года назад +3

    Just discovered your channel. You won a new sub! Thanks for the thorough tests, it is quite a rarity to find quality stuff like this!

  • @Bughy195
    @Bughy195 4 года назад +7

    Can you make a video about Huawei GT2 Pro? I think it will be very interesting to see how the high end of Huawei watches perform.
    Thanks for the hard work!

  • @aliwerner615
    @aliwerner615 3 года назад +6

    Great Test, I have this watch since 3 months and I really love it. They have new Software Update since a week and now they even have integrated a permanent SpO2 measurement feature. Maybe you want to do another Test with the new Software Version 1. 0.3.20? Also I am really looking forward to your sleep monitoring test.

  • @jamespritchard3838
    @jamespritchard3838 4 года назад +6

    Just got this watch the other day, it's awesome and loving it. Great review

    • @huzzich
      @huzzich 3 года назад

      Is the frame metal or plastic?

    • @jamespritchard3838
      @jamespritchard3838 3 года назад

      @@huzzich plastic.

    • @jamespritchard3838
      @jamespritchard3838 3 года назад

      Giving another update stopped wearing it after I started noticing small burn marks on my skin, after having it off for 3 weeks the burn marks are still slightly visible

  • @schwarzberry2550
    @schwarzberry2550 4 года назад +34

    Very good test, thank you! Would love to see how the Huawei GT2 Pro perform in heart rate and Sp02 accuracy

    • @boibluex12
      @boibluex12 4 года назад

      Polar says their heart is good and sleep tracking is good.. Please make a video if he you have time!

  • @salvaph
    @salvaph 4 года назад +5

    Thank you for this review! This makes me very happy since I have one and I'm very happy with its functionality

  • @lucapenzo3876
    @lucapenzo3876 Год назад +1

    Thank you very much Rob for your scientific analysis. This is what I needed to understand and compare. Stoked to find your video! Thanks again!

  • @WeissmannX
    @WeissmannX 3 года назад +2

    Just got this yesterday and I'm so happy with it!

    • @namnta
      @namnta 3 года назад

      Hi 👋
      After three months.. Still happy with it? No issue?
      Im planning to get it soon

  • @rasilsabah
    @rasilsabah 2 года назад

    This channel deserves more subscribers for the hard work!

  • @c0nfuser
    @c0nfuser 4 года назад +6

    Amazing work! Please consider testing also the sleep tracking for this watch! Thanks for the high quality content!

  • @EnzoPietro
    @EnzoPietro 2 года назад

    I know that I'm completely unimportant but I only follow people that I think that are doing an amazing job for the community, and you sir, your job it's fantastic keep the good work, we are all very grateful to you!

  • @diego_perez
    @diego_perez 3 года назад +1

    I loved the style of the comparison, which is with comparisons with something accurate and not between different smartwatches. Thank you so much for this content!

  • @fedepetit
    @fedepetit 3 года назад

    Thank you very much for your testing!. I've been using it for a month so far and I'm very pleased with it.

  • @henduck1816
    @henduck1816 4 года назад +7

    Amazing test!
    Do you plan testing honor band 6 like that?

  • @hellooowxxme
    @hellooowxxme 2 года назад

    Echt super fijn hoe je deze smartwatches test! Hartelijk dank voor de duidelijke video's

  • @fitgearhunter
    @fitgearhunter 4 года назад +2

    Great job. Super useful information- I might have to test it for CrossFit/HIIT. Thanks!

  • @rodas4yt137
    @rodas4yt137 4 года назад +6

    Great video as always!

  • @loonayeon2222
    @loonayeon2222 4 года назад +4

    This was super interesting, i'll be awesome if you could test the step accuracy and all the other features

  • @gracierunwiththewind
    @gracierunwiththewind 2 года назад

    Glad I came on here I purchased the Amazfit Bip U Pro 2 weeks ago and the workout heartrate was dreadful to say the least ,never went past 80-90 on my training rides and 31km an hour average speed and the heartrate just never moved, after 12km into the ride. So sent it back to Amazon. Came and saw this and purchased the Huawie watch fit instead what a difference in the readings almost as good my Garmin Strap belt. I advice you all to stay well clear of all the Amazfit products for your training purposes. Fantastic stuff.

  • @nathanmountford7768
    @nathanmountford7768 2 года назад

    The comparison between different heart monitors was VERY helpful.

  • @TungTing1
    @TungTing1 4 года назад +1

    Very good test and comparison. You earned yourself a sub.👍

  • @DW-sw8of
    @DW-sw8of 3 года назад

    I am very grateful for your effort and your great videos. Don‘t stop! Großartig!

  • @3cani
    @3cani 4 года назад +5

    Great video, I finally found what I was searching, please continue with these tests because they are a gem.
    I have an Honor band 5 now, and even if it works fine, it seems that during my bodyweight workouts (sometimes with HIIT or jump rope) it can't keep with the heart rate and sometimes lost the measurement.
    Do you think that the changes that Huawei/Honor have made with this new generation of smart band/watch is worth the upgrade?
    This Watch Fit records all the calories burned through the day (including basal metabolism) or only with the workouts? Thanks

  • @brian7193
    @brian7193 2 года назад

    Again another brilliant in depth review,you really do know how to put products thru their paces, helps me decide which devices to consider and which ones to ignore keep up the good work

  • @zoltanjanosi4031
    @zoltanjanosi4031 3 года назад +1

    Hi!
    I bought the watch fit because it did well based on your review. Now we have at least two measurements. After a week of use, I can conclude, that it was a complete garbage for me. I have a fitbit tracker and an omron blood pressure monitor with heart rate measurement and under moderate excercise, or after excercise, the watch fit was inaccurate by a huge amount. It specifically had problems with the 80-110 range, where for the watch it was like this range does not exist. If my heart rate was anything in between, the watch fit always showed 88-92. Even if I did a couple of pushups, and my heart rate was definitely more than that, it would not detect.
    After restart, it does read correct values for around 30 seconds, and then it locks itself again to 88-92. For some weird reason, below or above this range, the measurement seems to be ok.
    Fortunately I can get a full refund so does not bother me that much.

  • @notunhungry4025
    @notunhungry4025 3 года назад +4

    Love and appreciate your in depth reviews on all these wearables!! Thank you so much for the scientific analysis and your methods of testing (along with the potential biases that may be present!). Have you compared or tested the step counter on this watch to others? I was trying one out, and found the step counter undercounted for the majority of the time for day to day steps and was especially obvious (gross undercounting) with longer outdoor hikes (ie. an outdoor hike recorded on the watch's GPS of 9.87km - which should have actually been more around 12km, & step counter was only about 5500 total for the day & even less on the actual "details" of the hike while my phone on various apps gave me over 20,000 steps which was more consistent with my fellow hikers using an Apple Watch, Fitbit Charge 3, as well as an iphone). I was wondering if it was just me (& maybe a faulty device?) or if others found this too? I recorded 3 other hikes using the watch GPS and this gross undercounting of total steps was consistent with all of them.

  • @horiabass
    @horiabass 4 года назад +2

    Great in-dept video. A lot of effort you went through which brought detailed results. Keep up the good work!
    Are you willing to test out the Mi Band 5? It would be interesting to see the results considering it's such a popular device.

  • @tortzrumem
    @tortzrumem Год назад

    You made the Great job with these comparison 👍 thanks for this video and best regards 😊

  • @DuduTheDoraAmon
    @DuduTheDoraAmon 4 года назад

    Omg, looking for a fitness tracker atm, your channel is a godsend ! Really loving the looks of the witching watch but super impressed with the huawei one as well. I’d love to see a working update.

  • @derekb117
    @derekb117 4 года назад +1

    I'm sold! after watching the video on the charge 4 I've decided the watch fit is better and cheaper! now just to decide between the gt2 and watch fit!

  • @Maciejfw
    @Maciejfw 4 года назад

    Thank you for your videos, those time series are the most useful sources of information about wearables on the internet.

  • @lufasumafalu5069
    @lufasumafalu5069 3 года назад +1

    Thanks for the incredible effot in making these videos .. im indebted to your effort and now going to buy Huawei watch Fit based on your result. Was thinking of buying Amazefit GTR/GRS and saw their horrible result here. Then going to get Huawei GT2e but theres no automatic continuous SPO2 masurement in that watch.

  • @Kallago
    @Kallago 4 года назад +3

    Huawei Watch GT2 Pro now have ecg (news 4 days ago) please review it

  • @Thomasmcse
    @Thomasmcse 4 года назад +4

    Thanks mate! That was what I was waiting for. This will be my watch in case of a fitness watch. Hope sleep tracking is also as good as the heart rate.

    • @TheQuantifiedScientist
      @TheQuantifiedScientist  4 года назад +3

      Glad it was helpful!

    • @travis5173
      @travis5173 4 года назад +1

      @@TheQuantifiedScientist would you be able to test the spO2 and sleep tracking functions for the Huawei Watch Fit? Thanks in advance

    • @Thomasmcse
      @Thomasmcse 4 года назад

      He Quantified Scientist. I bought the Huawei Watch Fit and I'm excited! Heart rate monitoring, battery life as well as the watch itself is brilliant! Just can recommend this watch.

  • @reel1186
    @reel1186 3 года назад

    Thanks for your videos, now I understand about my next fitness watch

  • @jasonwoolley7891
    @jasonwoolley7891 4 года назад +1

    Great testing. I would love to see the Ticwatch Pro 3 tested as well.

  • @grafisteion
    @grafisteion 3 года назад

    Thanks a lot! I was on the lookout for a heart rate watch and you just pointed me to the right direction. (Saved me a lot of money too, as I was gonna get the Charge 5) Much obliged!

  • @SamEfDee
    @SamEfDee 4 года назад +1

    Great video as always. I recently asked if you could please do a heart rate and sleep accuracy test using a the Xiaomi mi band 5. I found a study that was meant to be testing the sleep tracking on the device but for whatever reason, the results weren't included in the paper. Its just be great to see how budget devices perform against the higher priced devices.

  • @Hrethgir
    @Hrethgir 4 года назад

    Oh, good, another watch i didn't know about to add to the list! Another great review, thanks! And dive you don't waste our time and make the video just over 10 minutes to get more ads, I don't skip any of the ads you do have, doing what I can to help. By the way, any chance you plan of trying out the Amazfit GTS 2? That one also just popped up on my radar, and has me very interested.

  • @rolandrohde
    @rolandrohde 4 года назад +1

    Thanks! Since the Fitbit Sense didn't really do as well as I had hoped, I am still on the lookout for a successor to my Garmin Vivoactive 4s. The Huawei GT2 Pro and this Watch Fit didn't really show up on my radar so far...but this looks promising. Sadly there is no ECG on this one, but the rest looks interesting. Can you perhaps do some Outdoor tests? Jogging or similar where the watch gets shaken around a bit more? Also, a test of the GT2 Pro would be fantastic...

  • @juliamarshall6469
    @juliamarshall6469 4 года назад

    Great test. Really looking forward to what your sleep test shows for this device.

  • @thomasl.7645
    @thomasl.7645 3 года назад

    Sehr gutes und informatives Video. Das war für meine Kaufentscheidung sehr wichtig. Vielen Dank 😊

  • @roberto28briggs
    @roberto28briggs 3 года назад

    Another fantastic review. I was surprised by Huawei watch. I will defo consider it.

  • @tomhanxs
    @tomhanxs 3 года назад +1

    Thank you for made it clear! I’m on the budget off course but at the same time didnt want ‘just another copy of apple watch’ so this is great. Knowing it works well with ios also a plus! I’ll be making a purchase now. ☺️ thank you

  • @Rhjnkiitewsxbmlp
    @Rhjnkiitewsxbmlp 3 года назад +1

    Oh just bought this, thank you for reviewing the HR, looking forward your review on the sleeping track mode 🥰 new sub! Gracias

  • @andrewmcintyre391
    @andrewmcintyre391 3 года назад

    I have just ordered a Huawei Watch Fit based on your excellent survey since I only need it for its accurate heart-rate readings. Thank you!
    At the same time I am surprised you spend so much time measuring the performance of optical wrist-band devices as a means to determine different sleep levels. Surely the only possible way to do this is to record the faint electrical brain signals using the sensitive head-mounted instrument you wear? In which case it wouldn't it be better if manufacturers restricted their devices to show only the beginning and end of a sleep cycle, rather than padding the sections in between with a lot of visually impressive but completely misleading tom-foolery!

  • @FiveTM
    @FiveTM 3 года назад

    Thanks so much for all this time working to get us this informations

  • @Sofian350z
    @Sofian350z 4 года назад +4

    Thanks for this test ! Can you try the galaxy active 2 44mm with the new update tizen 5 ? Thanks.

  • @farzanaazmy
    @farzanaazmy Год назад

    As someone who used to be a science student, your video intro reminds me of the scientific paper's summary section. Ngl it is helpful as it is brief and concise 😂

  • @den15423
    @den15423 4 года назад +12

    ohh, unexpected result.
    Especially comparing to Garmin and Fitbit

  • @asd710
    @asd710 4 года назад +1

    Thank you very much for your efforts, it would be great if you could make a review on Galaxy watchs

  • @rockinfreakapotamuxs
    @rockinfreakapotamuxs 4 года назад +2

    Wow, that heart rate its pretty pretty good

  • @takehikoinoue2471
    @takehikoinoue2471 4 года назад +1

    You do the best review I've ever seen! Thanks. Can you review the amazfit gtr2 and huawei watch gt 2 pro?

  • @tonnieatkins1277
    @tonnieatkins1277 10 месяцев назад +2

    Does the same accuracy happen with the special editions?

    • @AdminUnofficial
      @AdminUnofficial 9 месяцев назад +1

      Same question

    • @georgietorrance
      @georgietorrance 8 месяцев назад

      finding an answer to this as well. hard to find reviews for the special edition

  • @kaizoku8899
    @kaizoku8899 3 года назад +4

    I would appreciate if you could test the accuracy of the SpO2 sensor and also the sleeptracking accuracy.
    Btw, your test are very good, I appreciate them. Good work 😁

  • @ivoryandgoldweddings8204
    @ivoryandgoldweddings8204 4 года назад +2

    can you please do a comparison or review of the galaxy watches? after watching all your vides ( which i thouroughly enjoyed) I feel apple has everything you need in terms of a more accurate reporting... but I don't have an apple phone. Is an apple phone required in order to have the full benefits of apple watch? I have a google phone - which the galaxy is a more functional watch

  • @sabotage3d
    @sabotage3d 3 года назад +1

    It would be great to see a comparison with other Huawei watches like GT 2. Do you know if the sensors are the same?

  • @vineshbhasin4139
    @vineshbhasin4139 3 года назад

    Very informative video....thanks for your objective analysis

  • @andrekramer5019
    @andrekramer5019 4 года назад +1

    Hello! Please test the accuracy of the Huawei device during CrossFit or Cross Training movements. I wear a Huawei GT2, and it is always disappointing during workouts which have many variations of movements, specially movements with the arms. The HR readings of the Huawei are always 40bpm below my Fitbit Ionic readings.

  • @effjay3751
    @effjay3751 2 года назад

    Thank you very much for this video. This is what im looking for. The accurancy of the sensor. This is great! I love you lahhh

  • @DavisMedoriPhotography
    @DavisMedoriPhotography 4 года назад +1

    Congrats! Amazing work! I would like to ask you, do you know the difference between TruSeen 3.5 and TruSeen 4.0?

  • @wellmyouguan942
    @wellmyouguan942 4 года назад +1

    Wonderful content! How did you get the data from Huawei Watch Fit? I couldn't find a way to export the data from the APP. Thanks!

  • @bro93285
    @bro93285 3 года назад

    Been looking for this one. Thanks 🙏

  • @dungnguyenmanh6420
    @dungnguyenmanh6420 2 года назад +1

    Love your work, love the data, thank you

    • @TheQuantifiedScientist
      @TheQuantifiedScientist  2 года назад

      My pleasure! What watch are you most interested in?

    • @ridhwannasution5085
      @ridhwannasution5085 2 года назад

      @@TheQuantifiedScientist band 6 for sure, i dont know if every single piece of huawei band 6 is in the same quality as you, but overall my hb6 just work the same as yours. A bit lagging to catch up in the first section of training and be able to catch up just a few second after. Maybe because this is have a lower end chip / processor so make the calculation a bit slower than other

  • @AAAAAA-fj3dh
    @AAAAAA-fj3dh 4 года назад +1

    Hi, thank you for the review. It would be great if you could compare it as a sleep monitor. It looks like huawei gave this one some serious effort. Thank you again.

  • @The07Traveller
    @The07Traveller 2 года назад

    Excellent comparison. Thank you. Maybe if they could introduce a calibration feature it could solve the late registration of increase in heart beat.

  • @williamstevenson2649
    @williamstevenson2649 3 года назад

    Just checking back on Huawei reviews while waiting in case you do one of your excellent reviews on the Huawei GT3 when it becomes available!

  • @chas3997
    @chas3997 5 месяцев назад

    Class mate! I love your detail!😁 I purchased an HUAWEI watch 3 and found that it’s better than some more expensive watches 🤣

    • @chas3997
      @chas3997 5 месяцев назад

      HUAWEI watch fit I mean 🤡

  • @leonidpiliptsevich5329
    @leonidpiliptsevich5329 3 года назад +1

    Can you please explain how do you get data? Is it possible to get stress(HRV) levels, or timestamps of every heartbeat? Thank you!

  • @giarakhma8994
    @giarakhma8994 3 года назад +1

    Please review the steps counter and sleep accuracy in this watch. Thanks!

  • @jrsams5373
    @jrsams5373 3 года назад

    Great vid. Very detailed and informative. Thanks for posting.

  • @Tjensen999
    @Tjensen999 2 года назад +1

    So... here is my question. I understand that the Polar H10 is used as a benchmark for testing heart rate monitoring, correct? Wouldn't there be some kind of latency for the watch since it isn't strapped directly to your chest (closer to the heart beat) like the Polar H10? Would that be the reason for some of the delay in reading the heart rate accurately? Just a thought I was considering.

  • @Cloud_Storage14
    @Cloud_Storage14 3 года назад +1

    Kindly review honor band 6 as well and compare it to other fitness tracker. Thankyou

  • @vicster9401
    @vicster9401 3 года назад

    Excellent video presentation supported by science - good job !

  • @supportWCHS
    @supportWCHS 4 года назад +1

    Query whether The Quantified Scientist is encouraging the media to consider scientific measurements and studies?

  • @vicster9401
    @vicster9401 4 года назад

    Excellent and informative video - good job ! and thanks

  • @mishkattasdid
    @mishkattasdid 3 года назад

    Wao that was something cool comparison. Comparison should be like this.

  • @saracassio5846
    @saracassio5846 4 года назад

    Thank you for your reviews (you're so accurate, I love it!). Can you tell us something about arm hearth rate monitors? I find chest straps too uncomfortable...

  • @minh1391993
    @minh1391993 4 года назад

    for the last two weeks (since the release of your testing with apple watch series 6) I have been thinking about switching to iPhone and Apple watch. Thanks for your comparison, now I can at least rely on a smartwatch at a reasonable price.

  • @szakacsattila2505
    @szakacsattila2505 4 года назад +1

    Nice video comparison!

  • @johnmanley4528
    @johnmanley4528 4 года назад

    Excellent video. Do you plan on reviewing one of the Garmin Forerunner watches, like the 245?

  •  3 года назад

    Great review! I would be interested in comparison with Garmin Vivoactive 4 I have or also with Garmin top models such as Fenix.

  • @acarrillopineda
    @acarrillopineda 3 года назад

    Great channel and reviews! Are you planning to do an assessment of step count? I have a Huawei smart watch and I find it utterly inaccurate

  • @logikman439
    @logikman439 4 года назад

    Rob Hello. Your review for Huawei Watch fit, it is outstanding! I want to ask you something please. The Huawei Watch Fit has a mode for recovery how much time is needed for rest, until the next workout as the Huawei Watch GT 2e has?

  • @GK-qc5ry
    @GK-qc5ry 3 года назад

    Great analytical review.

  • @federicogandolfi8104
    @federicogandolfi8104 3 года назад

    Absolutely cool. Interesting. Precise. Grounded. And all of that proposed with a constant smile. Thanks a lot! I just have one question. Has it got rope skipping (rope jump) amongst the workouts? I can only find it in xiaomi band 5, am I correct? Thabks again. I'll follow you for sure

  • @kevinpeters9283
    @kevinpeters9283 4 года назад

    Nice review. I think it could also be helpful to discuss what kind of data you get. I think those chest straps output every heartbeat and if I understood it right watches already send out some processed data (averaging a few heartbeats and filtering measuring errors). I think this also shows a bit in the weight lifting results.
    It was a bit hard to interpreted the data on the spinning sessions without pausing the video. Maybe you can include a standardized routine like 20s sprint 1 minute rest, 1min sprint 2min rest.
    Don't understand me wrong. I really liked this test/ review. It really stands out from the others which are more generic. An other review pointed out that there is no Strava support, that is very unfortunate.

  • @tommiel6740
    @tommiel6740 4 года назад

    Much looking forward to the video on 3rd party sleep tracking apps for Apple Watch 6 !!

  • @andyd.3701
    @andyd.3701 3 года назад +5

    Hi Rob, thanks for your in-depth investigations. :-) Would you recommend the watch fit or GT2e for heart rate accuracy? I don't care much about all the other features but want a reliable watch just for fitness tracking. Have you calculated a measure like R-Squared? From the correlation figures, it looks like the watch fit was more accurate, would you agree? I could also afford a more expensive model, but the iWatch 6 is too expensive. ;)
    Thanks! :) Andy

    • @anmolchhabra097
      @anmolchhabra097 3 года назад

      Exactly..!
      iWatch 6 is out of my budget.
      I am also looking for the heart rate accuracy in lesser price range. I want to buy for my dad

    • @andyd.3701
      @andyd.3701 3 года назад +3

      @@anmolchhabra097 Am very happy with the accuracy of the watch fit. Measurement has to be started before starting the training and band has to be tight around the wrist.
      Best wishes for you and your father.

    • @anmolchhabra097
      @anmolchhabra097 3 года назад +2

      @@andyd.3701 Thank you so much brother. I want to keep Record of heart rate upto date that's why i was thinking to buy one for my Dad. 🙂

    • @andyd.3701
      @andyd.3701 3 года назад +2

      @@anmolchhabra097 You are very welcome! May peace be with you, brother!

  • @thomasgkoasis6766
    @thomasgkoasis6766 3 года назад

    Great analysis as always. Just one question: Between Huawei watch fit and Honor band 6 which one is your favorite? and why?

  • @faithlives8667
    @faithlives8667 4 года назад +1

    What about Sleep tracking and Step count ? pls make a review on Amazefit New Series Watches

  • @Mgh101590
    @Mgh101590 4 года назад +1

    What's your opinion on the Amazon Halo band I hope you can get one Early Access and do a breakdown of their data including the Body Fat accuracy and sleep analysis.

    • @TheQuantifiedScientist
      @TheQuantifiedScientist  4 года назад +1

      I wish I could get one!! I think it is only US for the moment though, maybe Europe will get it soon😄

  • @mikkelsn2574
    @mikkelsn2574 3 года назад +1

    Can you do a sleep test of the Huawei Watch Fit?

  • @md.tariqalamchowdhury8798
    @md.tariqalamchowdhury8798 Год назад

    thanks. you helped me to choose the right one.