this is certainly one of the most plausible ways that it was done. there were 2 funeral homes that were a 5 minute drive away from the house. only way he goes there peacefully is with frank. if this was how it was done, it was well thought out and he was literally gone in a matter of hours.
Lol I named my wife's lizard Hoffa because we could never find him, and he kept burying himself under the model of the NY Giants stadium in his terrarium
This movie is very real, not that every detail is perfect but it's pretty real. Let's say my grandfather had some connections in that scene in that time period in the midwest, the union, "Teamsters", it's all pretty spot on
The way you pronounce Provenzano makes me curious about how much of this is legitimately researched. Here’s the evidence in support of the claim... (1) Hoffa’s son, when showed the Hoffex memo, said that Sheeran was the only one on that list who could have got Hoffa in the car at that point in his life (he knew folks were gunning for him). (2) The original detective in the Gallo case and a New York Times reporter who witnessed the murder (who was there when it happened) believe it was Sheeran after seeing his photo and hearing his account. The claim that multiple mobsters burst into the restaurant was a concoction by the NYPD to weed through bad leads. It was one gunman. (3) Sheeran identified which car seat Hoffa sat in when O’Brian allegedly drove to pick him up. His DNA was later found there, in that exact seat. This claim was made to Brandt BEFORE the DNA evidence came out. (4) Hoffa’s daughter wrote Sheeran a letter stating that she believes he is the only one who really knows the truth. Sheeran was a drunk, and could certainly have inflated his role (admittedly). But his account is the most credible of any one of them to come out for the above reasons. I’m surprised you missed these in your research.
Nobody ever mentions how the FBI listed Sheeran as a commission member... While it’s laughable. It PROVES how badly the FBI wanted this guy and were going to ridiculous lengths to get to him. Everyone also mentions how Sheeran was caught in lies... Duh... as if murderous gangsters are beacons of truth. And of course murder has no statute of limitations... So obviously only a moron would confess while they have any quality of life left. The fact that the feds gave Sheeran 18 years for buying a car too cheaply should prove that he wasn’t just a nobody... Instead this mentions some nobody Irish gangster that no one ever heard of to tell us Sheeran never killed anyone and the color of his teeth.🙄
In all honesty, there is much more compelling evidence for Sheeran committing the Gallo murder, but his closeness with Bufalino (who everyone agrees was the one to okay the hit) makes this story compelling. Sheeran pointed out “when your time comes, they don’t send your enemies, they send your closest friends.” That was talked about in Goodfellas as well. Even Chuckie O’Brian was on bad terms with Hoffa when the hit happened, and NOBODY else on the suspect list could have gotten hoffa into a car by himself (not according to his family). I’ve noticed that the majority of Brandt’s critics (like Dan Moldea) made names for themselves by putting forth “alternate” theories. They still sell books with these alternative theories of what went down. Sheeran’s story basically says all their books were wrong about the hit. So I wonder why they’re pushing back on his account.
@lemon mule Sorry, but there is a near "zero" chance Frank had anything to do with Hoffa's murder. His account of his involvement has been discredited by those closest to the investigation, and it's to the point now where he's been conclusively ruled out as a suspect. The Kennedy conspiracy theory in this film is similar nonsense, albeit far more preposterous. I thought this film was phenomenal, but I am judging it as art and historical fiction.
Miguel Torres and hands down the worst Hoffa ever portrayed. Pecci as Rus was the best part of entire movie. Even the camios made it extremely campy towards the end. Good film for a once over; that’s it.
If you are here because of The Irishman then please check out the movie Hoffa.. it has Jack Nicholson and Danny devito in it.. movie is just as good but more in detail about Hoffa..
Thank u Netflix for stepping up and giving us the three Legends( four considering Martin Scorsese) in an EPIC gangster movie that no Big production house would take the risk. The final nail would be if this movie wins Oscar for Best Movie and/or Director !!!
Sheeran's multiple conflicting stories impeach his credibility, but on the other hand, his estranged daughter claims that after Hoffa's disappearance, the way her father looked and behaved convinced her that her father either did it, or was involved in it. Simple question : Would a dying Catholic risk their eternal soul by lying to a Catholic priest during confession about such mortal/serious sins? Really well done video! Thanx for that!
Interesting insider info, thanks. One of our film school graduates actually worked on this movie as a P.A. while it was being shot out in the Kaufman Astoria studios in Queens. She was a direct assistant to the Director of Photography, Rodrigo Prieto, and was on set while they were working with De Niro, Pesci etc. So it's interesting to watch your backstory on the movie. Greetings from Digital Film Academy in New York!
@@ChineduOpara - I thought the film was epic. Great cast and settings. Well pleased this film has been made. Also leave De Niro be, the man is an absolute legend and I admire him. This message is to whom it applies to.
There were two rifles found in that book depository. The German-made Mauser originally reported in the media, and the Italian-made Manlichter Carcano that was reported a few days later. The only one that police officers at the scene testified to seeing there however was the German Mauser sniper rifle. The Carcano was only reported by the media and only after being given the "correction" by investigators (not to mention the FBI report indicating two separate rifles being found, and the news footage which accidentally caught the second, ignored rifle on the ground). But if Scorsese isn't too concerned with the historical accuracy of his movie, I suppose you don't have to be too concerned about historical accuracy in your video.
I'm 38, back when they very first announced that they were gonna make this film I had absolutely no clue who Jimmy Hoffa was. My dad told me what he remembered then I immediately read I Heard You Paint Houses.
@ I'm 37 and watched the movie "hoffa" when I was 9 or 10 years old back on the day. His name has been referenced in movies from the beginning of my lifetime
This movie could have been a comedy. In one scene Joe Pesci's character is helping Robert Dinero's fix a truck and he calls Dinero a "kid" , the guy is in his 70's. In another scene Dinero is kicking a store owner. It's supposed to be a serious beating but old Bobbie is so stiff he can hardly raise his leg.
Its legit. Read the book and do your own research. Many people in the know including cops, CIA and FBI who worked the case over the years acknowledge it as CASE CLOSED. Trolls just hatin for no reason.
Hoffa was worth alot of money and getting up there in age. Why didnt he just take his 12M (36M in today's world) and enjoy his life without work and politics> Oh yeah, greed
Tha Gallo claim by the author is not correct. At first, I thought the same and didn’t think Sheran had done the hit, however, I looked into it a bit further and found out that none other than Joe Coffey, the lead officer for the NYPD Organized Crime Unit, backed the idea that Sheran was, in fact, the lone shooter.
Great movie. I believe it was a simple hit. The mob is efficient. They kill with no remorse and with efficiency. It would be simple, no burying his body beneath a football stadium.
It's weard that people doubt if he killed anyone when in mafia.. dude was in war so he must've kill a lot of people there and be very close to death all the time and after that joined mafia. Yeah he totally just hanged around and was afraid to take care of the business after being in combat and got used to death.
Ain't no way in hell Sheeran was close to Bufalino and not killed anyone. Foh. He was definitely a killer. He was trained to keep his mouth shut and not brag about the killing. Mobsters like to kill for clout. Sheeran already had clout by being close to Bufalino. Why would Bufalino recommend a punk to be a bodyguard for Hoffa? Come on people smarten up
funny, i read the f.b.i. had sheeran as one of the prime hoffa suspects. also, a reporter was in umbertos n described the shooter as a tall irish guy. where did u get ur info?
The killing of Gallo was done by Sheeran according to the lead detective on the case. A newspaper article from that time even stated what the suspect looked like thru eye witnesses
@@johndillinger8482 well with the ratings of IMDb 8.6/10 a rotten tomatoes and metacritic both score it over 95% and the critic reviews are high. Guess you're the dumbass
He starved himself to death after his last interview. I don't think he cared what you believed. Of course people didn't know he killed people. He, like the mob didn't advertise and talk about it.
Facts, i read the book years ago, and alot of what he said in the book did prove to be true, he was seen at umbertos clam house etc... plus Brandt had to pull teeth to get Sheeran to talk about his mob ties, and the work he did for them.....
The narrator made many mistakes, for 1 the money order Oswald supposedly paid for the Italian rifle with was never even cashed, has zero bank stamps on it (it's a near certainty that it was planted evidence), as far as Gallo's murder there is a witness who has identified Sheeran as the shooter, Dan Moldea has zero credibility as he once defended Sirhan as NOT being RFK's shooter but now totally says he's guilty even though the autopsy report clearly shows a shooter firing from point blank range BEHIND RFK and all of the witnesses at the Ambassador hotel say Sirhan never got behind Kennedy. I don't know if Sheeran killed Hoffa but it's the most plausible of all the possibilities.
Not sure about The Irishman but at the time I lived just north of the Red Fox and everyone had a theory. Sorry to see De Niro in the title role. No actual Irish actors available?
Historical accuracy aside, The Irishman is a good movie. The must be few well known movies where the truth was exaggerated or events were totally invented by the main characters. The accounts as told in movies like The Untouchables, American Gangster, Pappillon for example were mostly fiction.
First of all the wife of Gallo would say it was someone Completely opposite of who killed her husband so there would be no retribution on her and the family Also you probably will never find hoffa body I’m sure it was thrown unfortunately in a wood chipper And as far as Frank is concerned there’s no such thing as hanging with them And not having any association with You’re in you’re in for life
It was "Badge Man" a.k.a. J.D. Tippet, the police officer Oswald killed. Tippet took the Grassy Knoll shot that killed Kennedy. See Mary Moorman's photo. Once the assassination went down, Oswald knew he was the "patsy". The plan was to kill Oswald moments after the murder
I like how the scene where they pick up Hoffa with his son you can clearly tell it’s summer time and hot outside, just like it should look like in July
Wow I actually liked the movie and my Irish friend absolutely loved it and is so proud of his Irish heritage because of this guy . Wait til I show him this video 😂😂 lmao
What that one person said this and then some nobody said another ? yeah.. parade ruined. Simple matter of fact.. no other etnicity outside of Been italian ever got so in with the mob as did Sheeran.
*Seen the movie what was needed was a completely different protagonist other than that has been Robert De Niro, Frank Sheeran's part was completely destroyed by De Niro, Joe Pesci was born for this part and many played before, enjoyed the 3 + hours watching till my bedtime!* 😁
So this guy Oswalt, earning laborer's wages, flew or drove to Chicago from Dallas, purchased a 40" long rifle and had it shipped to a PO box even though the ATF and Postal Investigators existed in 1962. Sounds perfectly logical to me.
Captain. Obvious. Prior to the gun control act of 1968, anyone could buy a gun through the mail. Klines was a major mail order gun dealer of that time period.
He was killed and then put into the trunk of a car. The car was then crushed and shipped to Japan. This came from a mob boss after he had done his time and then did a interview. 🍺😎👍
This clip is informed by an article written by Bill Tonelli for Slate. That piece has been refuted extensively by others, notably by the publisher of the book I Heard You Paint Houses in a rebuttal (also published in Slate) that provides a considerable amount of evidence to support the assertion that Frank Sheeran was on an FBI shortlist of prime suspects in Hoffa's disappearance, and involved in other mafia murders. You can read that article here: slate.com/culture/2019/08/the-irishman-book-publisher-reply-bill-tonelli.html
Just watched "The Irishman" on Netflix. Don't bother unless you're trying to fall asleep. A plodding, boring, quasi mob movie until it morphs into The Jimmy Hoffa Story. Then it REALLY gets slow. Goodfellas it ain't ! Great actors in an over hyped snore fest. Far from a "masterpiece".
I liked the movie. Yeah it took 2 days to watch. But the characters were interesting and the storyline made me more curious. Liked seeing them together in the same film- DeNiro, Pesci & Pacino
There's a clise up picture of him with that ring on. I don't think a nobody who 'didn't kill a fly' would have gotten that ring. And in the book, he says many people were killed in that house. If the only found bloid from one person after 40 years, that doesn't really prove anything. And he also says in the book that about 4 other people were with him to kill Gallo. Martin made a cinematic choice there.
Those same guys who said that aren't gonna tell anyone if he did anyway. I think he did that stuff, I don't doubt he probably told a little bravado, and Scorsese adds dramatic flair when he feels it necessary, but he totally did it, I guess I've been one of the few who's believed it.
I saw it last night. If you like DeNiro/Pesci/Pacino and crime/mobster movies it isn’t bad. Note I said it isn’t bad, but it’s not up there with Casino and especially Goodfellas. For one thing, the movie is loooooong. Like 3 hours and 20 minutes long. It is paced slowly and deliberately. It is sort of those movies that is like seeing a novel being played out on screen.
I lived in Ireland for almost 5 years Dublin and also in the south. The world thinks of leprechauns and shamrocks when they think of them. Just let me say they are extremely tough motherfuckers and naturally though. They love to laugh but love to scrap as they call it. Greetings from Brazil 👍
Klyde Johnson “u”. Why can you just write you? It’s only two extra letters. I mean, you took the time to type “one” instead of 1 (twice). All those emojis, but can’t write Y-O-U?
Robert De Niro ruined this movie playing a horrible role as a young man. He just looked way too old and some of his scenes were cringe. Especially when he beats that man for his daughter.
That "digital de-aging" was too distracting to actually enjoy the movie ...DeNero looks like a guy in his mid 50s and when Pesci referred to him as "kid" was just weird…also when DeNero stomps the store owners hand it He moved like a real old man. wish they had just used a younger cast to Portrait them
That wasn't the point of the de-aging. The purpose was to present the younger Sheeran and Hoffa as memories of an old and dying Frank, recalling his life in a last ditch effort to find some meaning in his past. It was art, not an effort to convince you that those guys were "really" 30-40 years younger than they were.
Well acted script by senior well honed actors. but have seen before in their other movies- ones that actually had an edge! I'm a fan of Scorsese and DeNiro, but something not right when a seventy year old plays a thirty year old for half the movie (looking like he was wearing a girdle)... even the violence seemed geriatric!
regardless of who killed Jimmy he already made his mark,created the strongest union of our time,he would be 106 years old today he was 62 when he disappeared i am sure he would of enjoyed a great retirement to live out the rest of his life,but he was the toughest son of a bitch ever,,,
The public has been brain washed by all the pre release hype. I think a lot of people are afraid to criticize the film. I'm not - it was a BORING Jimmy Hoffa movie, albeit with a great cast. "Masterpiece" my ass !
What do you think happened to Jimmy Hoffa?
he was killed . it is 100% accurate .
@@bulllea just as depicted in the movie
I think you rattle off "official" narratives to much. Especially when the officials have been proven to have lied to us for decades...
this is certainly one of the most plausible ways that it was done. there were 2 funeral homes that were a 5 minute drive away from the house. only way he goes there peacefully is with frank. if this was how it was done, it was well thought out and he was literally gone in a matter of hours.
I think he moved to Virginia and died of old age.
If people don’t believe he killed anyone that means he did his job well.
Exactly
Lol I named my wife's lizard Hoffa because we could never find him, and he kept burying himself under the model of the NY Giants stadium in his terrarium
I thought the movie was ok. I was just happy to see Pesci acting again.
Really liked the Movie, Loved Pesci near the end with the grape juice n bread he almost made me cry
This movie is very real, not that every detail is perfect but it's pretty real. Let's say my grandfather had some connections in that scene in that time period in the midwest, the union, "Teamsters", it's all pretty spot on
The way you pronounce Provenzano makes me curious about how much of this is legitimately researched. Here’s the evidence in support of the claim...
(1) Hoffa’s son, when showed the Hoffex memo, said that Sheeran was the only one on that list who could have got Hoffa in the car at that point in his life (he knew folks were gunning for him).
(2) The original detective in the Gallo case and a New York Times reporter who witnessed the murder (who was there when it happened) believe it was Sheeran after seeing his photo and hearing his account. The claim that multiple mobsters burst into the restaurant was a concoction by the NYPD to weed through bad leads. It was one gunman.
(3) Sheeran identified which car seat Hoffa sat in when O’Brian allegedly drove to pick him up. His DNA was later found there, in that exact seat. This claim was made to Brandt BEFORE the DNA evidence came out.
(4) Hoffa’s daughter wrote Sheeran a letter stating that she believes he is the only one who really knows the truth.
Sheeran was a drunk, and could certainly have inflated his role (admittedly). But his account is the most credible of any one of them to come out for the above reasons. I’m surprised you missed these in your research.
Yeah this video is a joke
Nobody ever mentions how the FBI listed Sheeran as a commission member...
While it’s laughable.
It PROVES how badly the FBI wanted this guy and were going to ridiculous lengths to get to him.
Everyone also mentions how Sheeran was caught in lies...
Duh... as if murderous gangsters are beacons of truth.
And of course murder has no statute of limitations...
So obviously only a moron would confess while they have any quality of life left.
The fact that the feds gave Sheeran 18 years for buying a car too cheaply should prove that he wasn’t just a nobody...
Instead this mentions some nobody Irish gangster that no one ever heard of to tell us Sheeran never killed anyone and the color of his teeth.🙄
Not to mention the pronuncation of Moe Daltiz
In all honesty, there is much more compelling evidence for Sheeran committing the Gallo murder, but his closeness with Bufalino (who everyone agrees was the one to okay the hit) makes this story compelling. Sheeran pointed out “when your time comes, they don’t send your enemies, they send your closest friends.” That was talked about in Goodfellas as well. Even Chuckie O’Brian was on bad terms with Hoffa when the hit happened, and NOBODY else on the suspect list could have gotten hoffa into a car by himself (not according to his family).
I’ve noticed that the majority of Brandt’s critics (like Dan Moldea) made names for themselves by putting forth “alternate” theories. They still sell books with these alternative theories of what went down. Sheeran’s story basically says all their books were wrong about the hit. So I wonder why they’re pushing back on his account.
@lemon mule Sorry, but there is a near "zero" chance Frank had anything to do with Hoffa's murder. His account of his involvement has been discredited by those closest to the investigation, and it's to the point now where he's been conclusively ruled out as a suspect. The Kennedy conspiracy theory in this film is similar nonsense, albeit far more preposterous.
I thought this film was phenomenal, but I am judging it as art and historical fiction.
True or not, it was a good movie.
No, it was a boring suck fest.
Miguel Torres and hands down the worst Hoffa ever portrayed. Pecci as Rus was the best part of entire movie. Even the camios made it extremely campy towards the end. Good film for a once over; that’s it.
The buzz going around is that it should be retitled "So, I Hear You Watch Paint Dry".
You misspelled "great"
If you are here because of The Irishman then please check out the movie Hoffa.. it has Jack Nicholson and Danny devito in it.. movie is just as good but more in detail about Hoffa..
Joshua Lang I was deff thinking the same when I watched this
Thank u Netflix for stepping up and giving us the three Legends( four considering Martin Scorsese) in an EPIC gangster movie that no Big production house would take the risk. The final nail would be if this movie wins Oscar for Best Movie and/or Director !!!
This movie stinks - couldn't get through half of it.
@@rg20322 let me guess, Hobbs and Shaw was your movie of the year?
@@rg20322 no doubt you may be Marvel fan... Congratulations
The movie SUCKED. The Sopranos was a thousand times more entertaining! A long, bloated snore fest about Jimmy Hoffa.
Sheeran's multiple conflicting stories impeach his credibility, but on the other hand, his estranged daughter claims that after Hoffa's disappearance, the way her father looked and behaved convinced her that her father either did it, or was involved in it. Simple question : Would a dying Catholic risk their eternal soul by lying to a Catholic priest during confession about such mortal/serious sins? Really well done video! Thanx for that!
Why is there so many people getting mad over De Niro, just cause of his opinions? Just ridiculous
Thewitbew exactly. He’s a voter just line the rest of us
Thewitbew : he’s a leftist traitor to humanity... reason enough!
curragh 42 two bit actor?? 😂😂😂
He’s a jerk
@@michaeldufault4272 What an incoherent utterly idiotic statement!
Really good piece of work. Really first class. Enjoyed it. Have a good day.
Interesting insider info, thanks. One of our film school graduates actually worked on this movie as a P.A. while it was being shot out in the Kaufman Astoria studios in Queens. She was a direct assistant to the Director of Photography, Rodrigo Prieto, and was on set while they were working with De Niro, Pesci etc. So it's interesting to watch your backstory on the movie. Greetings from Digital Film Academy in New York!
So basically we still don't know what happened to Jimmy Hoffa
We all love jack Nicholson movie Hoffa idea about what happened to Jimmy hoffa.
But the mortuary cremation idea makes a lot of sense.
Jimmy Hoffa is living with Elvis at Never Never Land.
The movie would have benefited from a more active role on the cutting room floor.
Sort of have to agree, the movie is looooong. I saw it last night from a website on my phone and it went forever.
@@ChineduOpara - I thought the film was epic. Great cast and settings. Well pleased this film has been made. Also leave De Niro be, the man is an absolute legend and I admire him. This message is to whom it applies to.
There were two rifles found in that book depository. The German-made Mauser originally reported in the media, and the Italian-made Manlichter Carcano that was reported a few days later. The only one that police officers at the scene testified to seeing there however was the German Mauser sniper rifle. The Carcano was only reported by the media and only after being given the "correction" by investigators (not to mention the FBI report indicating two separate rifles being found, and the news footage which accidentally caught the second, ignored rifle on the ground). But if Scorsese isn't too concerned with the historical accuracy of his movie, I suppose you don't have to be too concerned about historical accuracy in your video.
It’s almost like it’s a movie and it never claimed to be the real story.
Boom exactly
Tyler Jacobson thank you lmao
No longer a fan of bob da zero
Is it just me or there's just so more stuff on The Irishman now after the Netflix release? 🤔
There are people under 45 who have never heard of Jimmy Hoffa.
Joe H Moore And your point is ?
They also never heard of Andre the giant
I'm 38, back when they very first announced that they were gonna make this film I had absolutely no clue who Jimmy Hoffa was. My dad told me what he remembered then I immediately read I Heard You Paint Houses.
@ I'm 37 and watched the movie "hoffa" when I was 9 or 10 years old back on the day. His name has been referenced in movies from the beginning of my lifetime
Joe H Moore, hell they don’t know what communism is...thinks it’s a good thing! Don’t expect them to know shite! Smh
This movie could have been a comedy. In one scene Joe Pesci's character is helping Robert Dinero's fix a truck and he calls Dinero a "kid" , the guy is in his 70's. In another scene Dinero is kicking a store owner. It's supposed to be a serious beating but old Bobbie is so stiff he can hardly raise his leg.
Just like in Stone’s movies, license for doing their movies with entertainment value.
Its legit. Read the book and do your own research. Many people in the know including cops, CIA and FBI who worked the case over the years acknowledge it as CASE CLOSED. Trolls just hatin for no reason.
and I don't think they should of went with Pacino for Hoffa.
i said that while i was watching the movie.. like "isnt chuckie his kid?"
Chuckie was his step son, one big reason he decided to go ahead and get in the car.
I’m a big Scorsese fan, and part of me really wants to watch this movie, but I won’t support Robert Dinero’s work anymore.
I’ll just read the book.
I’m not a robot.
It’s a really good book.
The movie stays faithful... but obviously lots more information is found in the book.👍
Thank I appreciate the info it's always great to well informed.
Hoffa was worth alot of money and getting up there in age. Why didnt he just take his 12M (36M in today's world) and enjoy his life without work and politics> Oh yeah, greed
In my humble opinion, just pick a story you like about Jimmy Hoffa and roll with it at this point. We’ll never know which story is authentic...
Tha Gallo claim by the author is not correct. At first, I thought the same and didn’t think Sheran had done the hit, however, I looked into it a bit further and found out that none other than Joe Coffey, the lead officer for the NYPD Organized Crime Unit, backed the idea that Sheran was, in fact, the lone shooter.
He is a traitor to humanity.
You're talking about Robert De Niro right? LOL
Boycott this assholes new movie
Who?
Good movie,good three hours during Thanksgiving, do you blame the turkey on taking a short nap in middle of it tho?
If they had cellphones back then someone would've recorded for likes
Great movie. I believe it was a simple hit. The mob is efficient. They kill with no remorse and with efficiency. It would be simple, no burying his body beneath a football stadium.
there were 2 funeral homes within 5 minutes of the house. he could be dust within minutes of the killing. very clean and simple.
It's weard that people doubt if he killed anyone when in mafia.. dude was in war so he must've kill a lot of people there and be very close to death all the time and after that joined mafia. Yeah he totally just hanged around and was afraid to take care of the business after being in combat and got used to death.
Exactly, I believe he did it.
Ain't no way in hell Sheeran was close to Bufalino and not killed anyone. Foh. He was definitely a killer. He was trained to keep his mouth shut and not brag about the killing. Mobsters like to kill for clout. Sheeran already had clout by being close to Bufalino. Why would Bufalino recommend a punk to be a bodyguard for Hoffa? Come on people smarten up
I can’t believe this movie got 99% on rotten tomatoes. So it was better than Goodfellas and Casino?? Spare me it was boring AF
damn that's more complicated than i thought
funny, i read the f.b.i. had sheeran as one of the prime hoffa suspects. also, a reporter was in umbertos n described the shooter as a tall irish guy. where did u get ur info?
Rishi Puntes right those are facts...
The killing of Gallo was done by Sheeran according to the lead detective on the case. A newspaper article from that time even stated what the suspect looked like thru eye witnesses
What's the name of that newspaper? What's the name of the lead detective?
Coffey New York Times 1972
Who cares whats what. Makes for a good movie
the movie sucked
@@johndillinger8482 well with the ratings of IMDb 8.6/10 a rotten tomatoes and metacritic both score it over 95% and the critic reviews are high. Guess you're the dumbass
john dillinger You’re just a snowflake that gets all turned over just cause of an actor’s political opinion, grow up you sissy
@@johndillinger8482 your trolling on all these videos is weak kid
@ no it isn't
He starved himself to death after his last interview. I don't think he cared what you believed. Of course people didn't know he killed people. He, like the mob didn't advertise and talk about it.
Facts, i read the book years ago, and alot of what he said in the book did prove to be true, he was seen at umbertos clam house etc... plus Brandt had to pull teeth to get Sheeran to talk about his mob ties, and the work he did for them.....
The narrator made many mistakes, for 1 the money order Oswald supposedly paid for the Italian rifle with was never even cashed, has zero bank stamps on it (it's a near certainty that it was planted evidence), as far as Gallo's murder there is a witness who has identified Sheeran as the shooter, Dan Moldea has zero credibility as he once defended Sirhan as NOT being RFK's shooter but now totally says he's guilty even though the autopsy report clearly shows a shooter firing from point blank range BEHIND RFK and all of the witnesses at the Ambassador hotel say Sirhan never got behind Kennedy. I don't know if Sheeran killed Hoffa but it's the most plausible of all the possibilities.
apart from Hoffa and the Kennedys, I thought it was pure fiction and very bad at that and not in a good way!
I'm more excited to see 'Todd', from Breaking Bad than anybody else.
Not sure about The Irishman but at the time I lived just north of the Red Fox and everyone had a theory. Sorry to see De Niro in the title role. No actual Irish actors available?
Supposedly some mobsters say this guy was a drunk and that he lied about his involvement. Who knows? I think his story does seem plausible.
In the 60's it was very difficult to tell mafia and CIA apart....
Historical accuracy aside, The Irishman is a good movie. The must be few well known movies where the truth was exaggerated or events were totally invented by the main characters. The accounts as told in movies like The Untouchables, American Gangster, Pappillon for example were mostly fiction.
Purchased a car from the bufalino family in the 90s... Northeast PA
Can't watch him anymore. He's a real creep.
Who??
First of all the wife of Gallo would say it was someone Completely opposite of who killed her husband so there would be no retribution on her and the family
Also you probably will never find hoffa body I’m sure it was thrown unfortunately in a wood chipper
And as far as Frank is concerned there’s no such thing as hanging with them And not having any association with
You’re in you’re in for life
Oh, you think Lee Harvey Oswald and his flimsy mailorder rifle had anything to do with getting a killshot on JFK. How cute.
Yeah, I'm sure you know exactly what went down with a handle like that 🙄
@@crazyjoedavola5430
Explain. No no, you said it - so go ahead. What do you got?
@@Geronimo_Jehoshaphat - Aliens...or Newman and Kramer
It was "Badge Man" a.k.a. J.D. Tippet, the police officer Oswald killed. Tippet took the Grassy Knoll shot that killed Kennedy. See Mary Moorman's photo. Once the assassination went down, Oswald knew he was the "patsy". The plan was to kill Oswald moments after the murder
The stuff about him arranging the rifles for JFK is interesting... In the movie he is as shocked as everybody else at the news of the death
I like how the scene where they pick up Hoffa with his son you can clearly tell it’s summer time and hot outside, just like it should look like in July
a v I don’t know man, I’m pretty sure people were freezing to death in New York.
Josh Montes it’s summer
Wow I actually liked the movie and my Irish friend absolutely loved it and is so proud of his Irish heritage because of this guy . Wait til I show him this video 😂😂 lmao
What that one person said this and then some nobody said another ? yeah.. parade ruined. Simple matter of fact.. no other etnicity outside of Been italian ever got so in with the mob as did Sheeran.
Your friend is American, not Irish.
xamurai00 no offense you might’ve said something nice and you might be a cool person but can you repeat that please in English
Oh man a guy who believes everything the government tells him...
I don't know if it was a true story or not, what I do know is that it was an excellent movie.
The Irishman was a great movie with great actors
He absolutely didn’t kill Joey gallo but might’ve Hoffa
I wanna know if he had any mental problems or any meds causing confusion or something related to memory loss
*Seen the movie what was needed was a completely different protagonist other than that has been Robert De Niro, Frank Sheeran's part was completely destroyed by De Niro, Joe Pesci was born for this part and many played before, enjoyed the 3 + hours watching till my bedtime!* 😁
I was so disappointed with this movie that I had to watch goodfellas the next night to remember why I respected the cast and director
It was bad...like an ego trip for has beens..
So this guy Oswalt, earning laborer's wages, flew or drove to Chicago from Dallas, purchased a 40" long rifle and had it shipped to a PO box even though the ATF and Postal Investigators existed in 1962. Sounds perfectly logical to me.
Captain. Obvious. Prior to the gun control act of 1968, anyone could buy a gun through the mail. Klines was a major mail order gun dealer of that time period.
redshovelhead77 appreciate that knowledge. TY
So you're pretty much saying this movie is trash and completely untrue?
He was killed and then put into the trunk of a car. The car was then crushed and shipped to Japan.
This came from a mob boss after he had done his time and then did a interview. 🍺😎👍
THE MOB AND THE GOVERNMENT WORKED TOGETHER FOR JFK, COME ON BRO..... LMFAO RUBY WAS CONNECTED
This is exactly what happened this is the story iv heard all my life
You totally dismiss that overwhelming evidence that there was a conspiracy to kill Kennedy.Everything else you say is dismissed
This clip is informed by an article written by Bill Tonelli for Slate. That piece has been refuted extensively by others, notably by the publisher of the book I Heard You Paint Houses in a rebuttal (also published in Slate) that provides a considerable amount of evidence to support the assertion that Frank Sheeran was on an FBI shortlist of prime suspects in Hoffa's disappearance, and involved in other mafia murders. You can read that article here:
slate.com/culture/2019/08/the-irishman-book-publisher-reply-bill-tonelli.html
Just watched "The Irishman" on Netflix. Don't bother unless you're trying to fall asleep. A plodding, boring, quasi mob movie until it morphs into The Jimmy Hoffa Story. Then it REALLY gets slow. Goodfellas it ain't ! Great actors in an over hyped snore fest. Far from a "masterpiece".
I liked the movie. Yeah it took 2 days to watch. But the characters were interesting and the storyline made me more curious. Liked seeing them together in the same film- DeNiro, Pesci & Pacino
I actually do paint houses but not in the winter.
How much?
There's a clise up picture of him with that ring on. I don't think a nobody who 'didn't kill a fly' would have gotten that ring. And in the book, he says many people were killed in that house. If the only found bloid from one person after 40 years, that doesn't really prove anything. And he also says in the book that about 4 other people were with him to kill Gallo. Martin made a cinematic choice there.
Those same guys who said that aren't gonna tell anyone if he did anyway. I think he did that stuff, I don't doubt he probably told a little bravado, and Scorsese adds dramatic flair when he feels it necessary, but he totally did it, I guess I've been one of the few who's believed it.
I hear you go to discount plastic surgeons, yes, yes I do.
What I want to know, if true, is what happened with those 3 rings, would love to have one of them(or all 3)
I saw it last night. If you like DeNiro/Pesci/Pacino and crime/mobster movies it isn’t bad. Note I said it isn’t bad, but it’s not up there with Casino and especially Goodfellas.
For one thing, the movie is loooooong. Like 3 hours and 20 minutes long. It is paced slowly and deliberately. It is sort of those movies that is like seeing a novel being played out on screen.
I lived in Ireland for almost 5 years Dublin and also in the south.
The world thinks of leprechauns and shamrocks when they think of them.
Just let me say they are extremely tough motherfuckers and naturally though.
They love to laugh but love to scrap as they call it.
Greetings from Brazil 👍
🤫
Deniro is a degenerate, won't watch anything he's in, he's got a lot of skeletons in his deep dark closet.
That effects no one but u 😂😂😂💀👌and no one cares but u😂😂💀
My dude, most of Hollywood has that. 💁🏻♀️
Klyde Johnson “u”. Why can you just write you? It’s only two extra letters. I mean, you took the time to type “one” instead of 1 (twice). All those emojis, but can’t write Y-O-U?
I..sure you have some too
Idc if it’s true or not.... it was a good movie
The book is a string of lies. The movie is entirely fiction. Because Robert DeNiro is in The Irishman, I'll pass. He's overrated and a putz.
Karma bite Deniro and took down some great actors with him .Deniro owes them all an Apology especially Sorcese .Deniro your days of glory are gone .
Robert De Niro ruined this movie playing a horrible role as a young man. He just looked way too old and some of his scenes were cringe. Especially when he beats that man for his daughter.
That "digital de-aging" was too distracting to actually enjoy the movie ...DeNero looks like a guy in his mid 50s and when Pesci referred to him as "kid" was just weird…also when DeNero stomps the store owners hand it He moved like a real old man. wish they had just used a younger cast to Portrait them
That wasn't the point of the de-aging. The purpose was to present the younger Sheeran and Hoffa as memories of an old and dying Frank, recalling his life in a last ditch effort to find some meaning in his past. It was art, not an effort to convince you that those guys were "really" 30-40 years younger than they were.
Lol its obviously not gonna be the same its a movie
Klyde Johnson movie is based on book
Well acted script by senior well honed actors. but have seen before in their other movies- ones that actually had an edge!
I'm a fan of Scorsese and DeNiro, but something not right when a seventy year old plays a thirty year old for half the movie (looking like he was wearing a girdle)...
even the violence seemed geriatric!
DeNiro is too old to play this role
It wasn't a dispute with the Columbo family...GALLO was behind the hit on Joe Columbo....that's what got him killed...
But it's still a great movie
The world is full of people raining on the parade.
This was one long movie. Too bad these actors are getting to old to do the next mob movie about the Trump administration.
@Democrats are paedophiles 👈 Triggered
@RUhere4the TRIGGERING 👈 Triggered
Iccus Diccus 😂😂😂
the man gone die why he has to lie??some people just there to say everything is lie,i belive all martys story,great pictuer.
Legacy and nothing more.
FBI documents back up much of his story .
A really ugly story. These guys were ruthless. Mostly towards friends, associates,and family.
For the Most Part,.. the information provided in this video is inaccurate and continues to promote 44 year old propaganda.
Two thumbs down,..
regardless of who killed Jimmy he already made his mark,created the strongest union of our time,he would be 106 years old today he was 62 when he disappeared i am sure he would of enjoyed a great retirement to live out the rest of his life,but he was the toughest son of a bitch ever,,,
The public has been brain washed by all the pre release hype. I think a lot of people are afraid to criticize the film. I'm not - it was a BORING Jimmy Hoffa movie, albeit with a great cast. "Masterpiece" my ass !
That is deniro he will never change
ALMOST 1M
Da-zero always plays a scum bag. Because he's a natural.
thanks !!