Prophet has announced Hazrat Ali as his successor in khadeer during the last Hajj and during the first invitation of Islam during the dawat zul asheera who ever supports me now will be my successor.sunnis also accept that imam Mehdi will be come who is the successor of Moula Ali
Well explained...Shia Laws on divorce seems to be better than others...even in Sunni,,,ahle Hadis, wahabi, & modern scholars like ghamidi, Zakir Nayak, waheeduddin Khan etc are of the same view like Shias. Only Sunni hanafi deobandi have different views. They couldn't reform themselves and faced the intervention of Supreme Court. To be honest SC gave them many opportunities to reform themselves and come up with uniform interpretation through aimplb. But aimplb failed to update themselves and SC had to intervene. They are more concerned about anu hanifa than the actual Quran and Sunnah. Quran is the divine constitution which caters to the needs of every society.
Respected sir, Salamunalaikum and thank you for your efforts. I am a Shia muslim, I may be missed your point on the concept of Taqleed in shia Islam. Taqleed literally means to put a necklace on the neck. In Shia fiqh it is a common sense system where the one who does not know follows an expert. In today's time we have certain scholars like Ayatullah Sistani (Iraq) and Ayatollah Khamenie (Iran) who are knows as Mujtahids = one who does Ijtehaad = Strives and makes effort (Jihad) to go through the Quran and Ahadith, and then brings out the Divine law for us. The chain is like this- The mujtahid derives laws from the teaching of the Masoomeen (prophet Mohammed and his 12 Divine sucxessors),these Masoomeen get the teachings from Allah/God. So in Shia Fiqh even though the laws are derived by fallible humans the source is Divine = God. For more details u can visit www.al-islam.org Thank you and stay Blessed always.
@syedbakeruddinbekar9433 yes but in creatures Allah tala made differences ... there are stages in Divine systems like our prophet Muhammad swas is higher then other prophets ... BAASKUM A'LA BAAS .. one who have knowledge is higher then who doesn't have.. if any body is judge is not equal to a common man right... So Follow Allah follow Messenger and infallibles (ulilAmr)
You said Ali ibn Abi Taleb was the first among children to accept Islam. This brings you in confrontation with the Qur'an where Jesus (Eisa) is not treated as an infant, rather as an oratory delivering prophet of God within the first few days of his birth. Even learned intellectuals like yourself at times are overwhelmed by prefixed ideology to the extent of going against the Mustatir (hidden) but totally valid esoteric knowledge in Scripture.
I believe and have Imaan that Quranic Laws are the best for entire humanity and have to be implemented intentionally or unconsciously in the human society
@@nkn987 Yes, Sharia compatable with Quran Only. As expalned by Faizan Sb, Sharia is also adultrated with thime. It is not uniformly under implementation anywhere in so called Muslims World. Sharia means the path (Road), the way one will reach to destination. But we Muslims have chosen wrong Road.
@@nkn987 Yes, Sharia compatable with Quran Only. As expalned by Faizan Sb, Sharia is also adultrated with thime. It is not uniformly under implementation anywhere in so called Muslims World. Sharia means the path (Road), the way one will reach to destination. But we Muslims have chosen wrong Road.
Sir, on behalf of entire indian muslim community take the lead for settling UCC with govt, because you only have better knowledge on islamic law than our so called moulana and mufties. The semiliterate moulana , mufties and scholars who are found to be debating in TV are issuing confusing statement to give a wrong message to majority community that muslim are against UCC which might help BJP to polarized the society. All the best sir, we are proud of you.
Faizan sb Quran is giving Laws to mankind to live in this world peacefully. Since Quran is a coincise Book for entire humanity for all the time. Therefore Quranic Laws cannot be given in detail but are in Principles to deduce laws by mankind from time to time inder human intellect. But human laws must not be contradict with very basic principles of the Quran.
जब तक सरकार UCC का ड्राफ्ट जारी नहीं करती है, और इसे पढ़ और समझ नहीं लिया जाता है, तब तक UCC पर किया जाने वाला हर डिबेट सांप्रदायिक ध्रुवीकरण की एक साजिश है। इस तरह के ध्रुवीकरण का लाभ किसे मिलता है, इसे हम सभी जानते हैं। यह ट्रैप है। इससे बचें।
@@syedhaider3315 Assalaamu alaikum, Muslims ka ek hi qanoon hai bhai, aap kisi reputed aalim se milkar apne doubts clear kar sakte ho, aap jiss City mein bhi rahte ho. Ulema e deen respected log hote hain inki respect tamaam musalmano ko karni chahiye.
ISLAM KA AIK KANOON IMAM JAFER SADIQ TAK THA ,HAROON RASHEED KHAIFA KE ZAMANE ME ISLAM FIRKON ME BAT GAYA,FIQU BHI ALAG HOGAYEN,ISI LIYE PERSONAL LAW ME BHI DIFFERENCE HAI.
Sir, Witch are those 8 Vedios. I would love to see / Listen all,If those are translated in Hindi . As in North India this Language was not there. Or other such heritage If that is in Hindi.
Sir.. Ek sawal hai ki.. Agar dada ke 2 bete.. dada apne kuch jamin jo (unke, unke nawald bhai aur unke walid ke name se jamin hai ) apne dono bete ko bakhshish karte hai ek hi din same gawah pahchan 50-50. Bara beta apne hisse ka jamin apne name na likh wakar apne 2 nabalik bete ke name se likhwate hai jo us samay 2 hi paida howe the . Fir bare bete ko bad me 2 beta aur paida hua. Sir puchna yah hai ki dada ne jo bap ki jamin apne pita ko likha hai usse jo baad me paida howa uska haq hoga ki nahi.. ghar aur dokan ka wahi jamin hai... Dada apne chhote bete ke hisse ka jamin unhi ke name likhe ussa mai unka koi beta nahi tha. Aaisa Case bahut hai sir.. please reply me.. ya ek video banayee
Sir, just looking at the complexities of Islamic law alone. Is it even possible to formulate a uniform civil code for all the sects of Muslims let alone the whole country ? Is it even a viable exercise ?
@faizanslegalawareness sir,how to take action against a Russian App on google play where a majority of users from rural india upload hate speech articles . there is no content moderation on the App and no action is taken against such posts and blogs there.I want to report it anonymously
Sir please do an video on can certain communities and regions of country like North east or tribals can be exempted under UCC...is it constitutionally valid ,and wudnt be discrimination with other parts of the country ...besides isn't it violating the very essence of article 14 which strives for universal uniformity throughout the country...and PlZ say will it be acceptable under court of law
Islam ek complete way of life life hai. Differences in opinion ka istemal kar ke ap ye nahi bol sakte ki kyuki differences in opinion hai, we will throw baby with the bath water.
Absolutely ,it the negative strategy of BJP and RSS to divert the attention of 140 crore's India's from real issues like inflation, and economic crisis, poverty, suicide of farmers , unemployment, rising poverty, scandals, Adani scandals, etc etc.
Meher is the Pre requisite condition for Nikah, Women gets certain agreed amount for the nikah. Will it be waived off under UCC or non muslims will also pay the Meher amount??If it's waived off then the right given to muslim women will be denied and it will be unjust to the women in the name of empowerment of muslim women. How can you justify it SIR.
Sir, unform civil code me saare khanzar talwaaren Muslim culture per hi kyo chal rahi hen, aap full list ek baar banaaiye ki dharm wise kis kis ke religion se kyaa kyaa kaata htaya jayga barabar culture hatane hi honge, democracy khatm mat hone dijiye, ye chaman me sabhi ki khushboon ko rehna jaroori he. Aap ki fikr jayaj he
سنیوں کے یہاں ان مسائل میں اجتہاد کا دروازہ آج بھی کھلا ہوا ہے جو نئے پیش آمدہ ہیں، البتہ جو پرانے ہیں ان میں بند ہو چکا ہے، بحیثیت لاء ٹیچر آپ کو یہ معلوم ہونا چاہئے
people who want to understand this topic in depth need to watch a whole series of ghamidi about it . Your mother has aqeedat for ahl e bait so does all sunnis have its khatmals who are venemous
Faizan Sir ki biasness shuru hi me khul ke aa gyi.. tribals ko exclude kar dena chahiye.. lekin Muslims ke liye UCC (basically Hindu Civil Code) aana chahiye 😅 Waah Faizan saab waah!!
ASSALAM ALEKUM JAB TRIBE KE LOGON KO UCC SE HATAYA JAYEGA TO ISAI SIKH AUR MUSLIMON KO BHI HATAYA JA SAKTA HAI AAPKI KYA RAYE HAI SAHAB MASLA BAHUT PECHIDA HAI UMMID HAI AAP MERI BAAT SAMAJH GAYE HONGE AAP PER ALLAH KI RAHMAT HO FAIZAN MUSTUFA SAHAB.
I do watch your episodes from time to time. With all due respect, I think you need to study Fiqah Jafariya in more depth. First of all, the tern Shian e Ali is extensively used in Hadiths e.g. hadith e Kisa or the nuzool of ayat tat-heer Surah Ahzab, verse 33. You mentioned the last sermon of the Prophet (صلى الله عيله و آله), but you completely ignored the legal appointment of the guardian after prophet, which was the core objective of that last khutbah. Allah knows best about your intent. But a rational person should have put it the right way. There is a concept of Qiyas in Fiqah Ahle sunnah, i.e. making decisions based on own ideas. But there is no place for Qiyas in Fiqah Jafariya. In Fiqah Jafariya there is ijtihad ie. making decisions based on reasoning with prior knowledge. Before advent of the 4 Fiqah of Ahle Sunnah which Fiqah Muslims used to follow? They named that Fiqah as Fiqag Jafariya. Ahle Sunnah Fiqahs were created by the students of Imam Jafar al-Sadiq (as). Now the question must arise why did they differ with Imam Jafar Al - Sadiq? And Shia do taqleed in Fiqh. They have marjas for that purpose to guide at all times. Study Tuhfatal awaaam or Tawzihul Masa'il. Now you said that reforms are needed. Yes they are very much needed in Ahle sunnah because majority of their laws were made by later caliphs. As far as the matter of muta is concerned, it was very much practiced during the time of the prophet and valid from Quran as well. Quran is the last guideline for mankind that means it is valid till the day of judgement. Muta was not for fun but to avoid fornication and illegit relationships. Today we see live-in in fashion. Muta can counter that and have legit relations and population. Egypt recently allowed Muta to avoid high rate of divorces. So my dear fellow Muslims pay close attention to reasoning. Do not try to reform Quran out of lack of knowledge and western liberal satanic influences. Surah Al-Anfal, Verse 22: إِنَّ شَرَّ الدَّوَابِّ عِندَ اللَّهِ الصُّمُّ الْبُكْمُ الَّذِينَ لَا يَعْقِلُونَ Indeed the worst of beasts in Allah’s sight are the deaf and dumb who do not exercise their reason.
Sir, Agar Hazrat Abu Bakar ko elect Kiya tou phir Abu Bakar Ney Hazrat Umar aur Umar Ney Hazrat Usman ko kyun select Kiya? Phir Ummat Ney Hazrat Ali ki phir 4 th Khalifa kyun chuna. Kaya pur process par par sawal nahi hai? You are deep Thinker. Shia 30% aur outher countries Mai minorities hai. Shia 6th Imam Jafar Sadiq key Shagird (student) Imam Hanif, Malik, Safi, Humba hai.
@@Karanbansal007 Bro, Jab Prophet Ney koi committee khilafat key liye nahi banai aur Ummat nay Hazrat Abu Bakr ki elect Kiya tou Hazart Abu Bakar Ney phir committee kyun banaya? Aur agr Committee Ney Hazart Umar ko Khalifa banay tou phir committee Ney Hazrat Usman ko kyun nahi elect Kiya, aur Hazart Umar Ney Usaman ko select Kiya. Phir uskey baad Ummat (logo) Ney Ali ki Khalifa banaya. Kyun Sunni fiqh (Jurisprudence) Prophet key 200 saal bad Imam Hanif, Malik Safi etc key bad laya gaya.? Bani Abbas Ney bani Umayya ko Fiqah Mai badalaw key khilaf movement Kiya aur apni haqumat kayam ki. Yeh baat sab scholar and thinkers jantey hai lekin kehney sey dartey hai. Jab Mai apney Ghar Mai sawal karta hun to khud mery faimily Waley meri thought ko accept nahi karty. Bhai agar Niyam hai tou sab key liye barabar hona chahiye. Khalifa key selection aur election Mai farq ki wajah sey Jurisprudence Mai park hai. Plz think deeply. Deep Thinking will present all clear picture. TC
@@ehteshamali8319 aapne mera comment dhyan se nahi padha, Hazrat Abu Baqr ko Sahaba ke ijma ne select kiya tha, Umar ko Abu Baqr ne aur 6 members committee hazrat Umar ne bnayi thi.
Faizan saab munafiqat choday aur khul kar kahey uniform civil code kay bajay uniform economic code baney and extinction of poor n rich n emerging of middle class n uniform housing code matlab every family to have 1000 sft apartment n balance to be given to other indians homeless or uniform land costs why at one place to be 1 lakh per sq yard n other per acre or why sharuq khan make 500 crores instead of standard 50 thousand rupees for all indians n uniform marriage spending code matlab late jaya lalita adopted son marriage at cost of 500 crores instead of uniform 10 thousand rupees per marriage n like wise uniform medical code or transport code or education code n uniform wealth distribution for 140 crores population n not held by 5 percent of population etc n this uniformity will be welcomed by all religions citizens of india
Sir eid e ghadir mobarak ho ap shia kitab men padhiye pahle k shia maula ali ko khalifa relationship k bina pr nhi balki allah k khukm se banaya hua khalifa mante hen Ap ne is men ye jo kaha h k shia maula ali ko khalifa relationship k wajah se mante hen ye bilkul ghalat h Ap Allama amini ki kitab alghadeer padh sakte hen agr haq janna chahte hen to waise ap khud kah rhe hen k ap ki waleda ahlebait se zyada aqidat rakhti hen aur ap bhi to haqiqat janna ap k liye zyada zaruri ho jata h
Faizan sahab, Law agar serious business hai aapki nazar me aur koi aira ghaira raaye nahi de sakta, to aap kya samajhte hain ke Islamic law/Fique me koi bhi aira ghaira yahan se wahan Kuchh information le liya to wo apni raaye de sakta hai? Ye to double standard hai, ke aap human law me intervene nahi karsakte lekin aap divine law me karsakte hain! Sochiye aap ek intellectual hain apni zahanat ka sahi istemaal kijiye.
Time waste kar hai Sir aap... Itni details suna kar kya sabit kar rahe samjh nahi aa raha .... Qanoon ki shariyat ki baat karte karte history padhane lag gaye aap to... Sidhe sidhe mudde pe aaye Basic difference bataye kya fark Hindu law me, Muslim law me, chirstan law etc etc... Aur fir bataye k kese inko common civil code me tabdil karnge ....
Mr Faizan Mustafa, you were talking against UCC last year, why this change of heart. Is it because you are aiming at AMU vice chancellorship or something like that by pleasing RSS?
You are not a Islamic scholar. You are terming both as Islamic laws. Sharia is laws given directly by Allah and Rasoolallah. Whereas Fiqh is interpretation and implementation of shariah in various time periods and circumstances. As sharia, you can not touch the laws of Quran like permission for multiple marriages, inheritance laws, etc.
Quran aur Ahadees ki roshni mein hi tamaam qavaneen banaye gaye hain Mr Faizan isliye ye divine laws hi hain ismein usuli maamelaat mein tarmeem ka haq kisi Muslim hukumat ko bhi nahi kaja k ek gair Muslim hukumat ko. Faroee maamelat mein bhi ye aapka kaam nahi ulemaye deen aur Muftiyaan e karaam ka kaam hai, Kisi duniyavi , ya insaano k qanoon ko aafaqi qanoon par tarjeeh dene waale Faizan Mustafa ka ye kaam hargiz nahi hai na uski ye haisiyat hai na usko ye ijaazat di ja sakti hai sharyee taur par. Ek aur baat khud Hindus mein, Tribals mein, sikh, Christians k aapasi ikhtelaaf ko bhi batao, kya inn sobke liye UCC acceptable ya applicable hoga ya nahi. Ek saal pahle app UCC k khilaaf thhe ab kiss laalach ya dhamki ki wajah se uske favour mein ho ????? Please answer.
السلام علیکم ورحمة الله وبركاته As you are an expert in Indian Constitution and Law, better you speak about that only. You are not an expert in Islamic studies, you don't even have the BASIC KNOWLEDGE of Islam, hence you should not speak about that. It will be better for you hereafter. This is my sincere advice.
बोहोत बोहोत शुक्रिया फिक्काः जफरिया डिस्कस करने के लिए
What a coincidence that today is Eid e Ghadeer.. 🎉
Prophet has announced Hazrat Ali as his successor in khadeer during the last Hajj and during the first invitation of Islam during the dawat zul asheera who ever supports me now will be my successor.sunnis also accept that imam Mehdi will be come who is the successor of Moula Ali
Absolutely correct
Today is Ghadeer🎉🎉
Well explained...Shia Laws on divorce seems to be better than others...even in Sunni,,,ahle Hadis, wahabi, & modern scholars like ghamidi, Zakir Nayak, waheeduddin Khan etc are of the same view like Shias. Only Sunni hanafi deobandi have different views. They couldn't reform themselves and faced the intervention of Supreme Court. To be honest SC gave them many opportunities to reform themselves and come up with uniform interpretation through aimplb. But aimplb failed to update themselves and SC had to intervene.
They are more concerned about anu hanifa than the actual Quran and Sunnah. Quran is the divine constitution which caters to the needs of every society.
Sir, please iski ek playlist bana dijiye, asan hoga dekhna. 🙏
Respected sir, Salamunalaikum and thank you for your efforts.
I am a Shia muslim, I may be missed your point on the concept of Taqleed in shia Islam.
Taqleed literally means to put a necklace on the neck. In Shia fiqh it is a common sense system where the one who does not know follows an expert. In today's time we have certain scholars like Ayatullah Sistani (Iraq) and Ayatollah Khamenie (Iran) who are knows as Mujtahids = one who does Ijtehaad = Strives and makes effort (Jihad) to go through the Quran and Ahadith, and then brings out the Divine law for us.
The chain is like this- The mujtahid derives laws from the teaching of the Masoomeen (prophet Mohammed and his 12 Divine sucxessors),these Masoomeen get the teachings from Allah/God.
So in Shia Fiqh even though the laws are derived by fallible humans the source is Divine = God.
For more details u can visit www.al-islam.org
Thank you and stay Blessed always.
@syedbakeruddinbekar9433 yes but in creatures Allah tala made differences ... there are stages in Divine systems like our prophet Muhammad swas is higher then other prophets ... BAASKUM A'LA BAAS .. one who have knowledge is higher then who doesn't have.. if any body is judge is not equal to a common man right... So Follow Allah follow Messenger and infallibles (ulilAmr)
Thank you Mustafa Sahab bahut hi behtarin tarike se aap ne samjhaya hai.🙏
29:51 haaaaan lekin IJTEHAAD Olama aur MUJTAHIDEEN ke liye hi hai na ke humarey Non-Believers & Advocates ke liye 😇🥰
Main to aap ki videos ke liye waqt nikal kar dekhta hun
Thanks for this knowledgeable video.
You said Ali ibn Abi Taleb was the first among children to accept Islam. This brings you in confrontation with the Qur'an where Jesus (Eisa) is not treated as an infant, rather as an oratory delivering prophet of God within the first few days of his birth. Even learned intellectuals like yourself at times are overwhelmed by prefixed ideology to the extent of going against the Mustatir (hidden) but totally valid esoteric knowledge in Scripture.
So how come Eisa and Ali are compared to the point of the first child who accepted Islam?
Sir, क्या धारा 371 (A to J) UCC के लागू होने में बाधक होगी? क्या इसे भी हटाना पड़ेगा? इस पर भी किसी एपीसोड में रौशनी डालिएगा बड़ी मेहरबानी होगी।
371 पर कहीं नहीं जाएगे ये। ये सिर्फ विवाह आयु, तलाक, जनसंख्या पर कुछ करेंगे बस
सर!आप जाणकार तों. अच्छी दे रहे हो.आप लेक्चर देते वक्त इंग्लिश वर्ड कम ईस्तेमाल करेटाके कम पढे लिखे लोग समज स्के.
I believe and have Imaan that Quranic Laws are the best for entire humanity and have to be implemented intentionally or unconsciously in the human society
Quranic Laws are not followed by Moulavis & they brainwash people through their own dictates.
U mean Sharia laws 😂
@@nkn987 Yes, Sharia compatable with Quran Only. As expalned by Faizan Sb, Sharia is also adultrated with thime. It is not uniformly under implementation anywhere in so called Muslims World. Sharia means the path (Road), the way one will reach to destination. But we Muslims have chosen wrong Road.
@@nkn987 Yes, Sharia compatable with Quran Only. As expalned by Faizan Sb, Sharia is also adultrated with thime. It is not uniformly under implementation anywhere in so called Muslims World. Sharia means the path (Road), the way one will reach to destination. But we Muslims have chosen wrong Road.
@@AftabKhan-lg8uc ha ha good joke
Very informative
Sir, on behalf of entire indian muslim community take the lead for settling UCC with govt, because you only have better knowledge on islamic law than our so called moulana and mufties. The semiliterate moulana , mufties and scholars who are found to be debating in TV are issuing confusing statement to give a wrong message to majority community that muslim are against UCC which might help BJP to polarized the society. All the best sir, we are proud of you.
My dear 😂 friend, Who had asked & given the concent .They may be from the 😂 category followed by Worthy P M of India rather than viceversa!
Faizan sb Quran is giving Laws to mankind to live in this world peacefully. Since Quran is a coincise Book for entire humanity for all the time. Therefore Quranic Laws cannot be given in detail but are in Principles to deduce laws by mankind from time to time inder human intellect. But human laws must not be contradict with very basic principles of the Quran.
Agree 👍💯
Nice
Askm.sir aap se guzarish Hai plz Islamic law Padhi aur kiss aalim se is
Topic par bat Karo sir pair ucc ki tayeed kariye
Prophet was not elected by the people but was selected by God and his successor was also decided by God
This aqeeda is totally against Khatme nabuwat 😂
Gud explained sir g
जब तक सरकार UCC का ड्राफ्ट जारी नहीं करती है, और इसे पढ़ और समझ नहीं लिया जाता है, तब तक UCC पर किया जाने वाला हर डिबेट सांप्रदायिक ध्रुवीकरण की एक साजिश है। इस तरह के ध्रुवीकरण का लाभ किसे मिलता है, इसे हम सभी जानते हैं। यह ट्रैप है। इससे बचें।
Faizan sahab Allah se daro jaisa k darne ka haq hai.
ALLAH SE DARNA CHAHIYE ,MAGAR MOLVIYON SE NAHI JINHON NE ISLAM ME 72 FIRQUE BANWA DIYE.ALLAH EK, KURAN EK, NABI EK,PHIR KANOON KYON ALAG ALAG?
@@syedhaider3315 Assalaamu alaikum,
Muslims ka ek hi qanoon hai bhai, aap kisi reputed aalim se milkar apne doubts clear kar sakte ho, aap jiss City mein bhi rahte ho.
Ulema e deen respected log hote hain inki respect tamaam musalmano ko karni chahiye.
ISLAM KA AIK KANOON IMAM JAFER SADIQ TAK THA ,HAROON RASHEED KHAIFA KE ZAMANE ME ISLAM FIRKON ME BAT GAYA,FIQU BHI ALAG HOGAYEN,ISI LIYE PERSONAL LAW ME BHI DIFFERENCE HAI.
सलाम आलेकुम,
आप मीर साहेब लगते हैं आप का तौर तरीका बताता है या आप का उठना बैठना मीर साहेब लोगों में है
Sir, Witch are those 8 Vedios.
I would love to see / Listen all,If those are translated in Hindi .
As in North India this Language was not there.
Or other such heritage If that is in Hindi.
Good details
Sir aap ak mic🎙️lagaye aap ki aawaj me noic hai
Islam is a complete law. Change or ammendment in Islamic law means to give up islam
Why don't u accept Sharia law for criminals
I like the subject
Aaj ki video dekh kar ek baat samaj aaya Islam ko samjna hai to study bahot zaruri jaheel andh bhaqto hota
💌
Dr Afia Siddiqui par video banaye sir
Sir.. Ek sawal hai ki.. Agar dada ke 2 bete.. dada apne kuch jamin jo (unke, unke nawald bhai aur unke walid ke name se jamin hai ) apne dono bete ko bakhshish karte hai ek hi din same gawah pahchan 50-50. Bara beta apne hisse ka jamin apne name na likh wakar apne 2 nabalik bete ke name se likhwate hai jo us samay 2 hi paida howe the . Fir bare bete ko bad me 2 beta aur paida hua. Sir puchna yah hai ki dada ne jo bap ki jamin apne pita ko likha hai usse jo baad me paida howa uska haq hoga ki nahi.. ghar aur dokan ka wahi jamin hai... Dada apne chhote bete ke hisse ka jamin unhi ke name likhe ussa mai unka koi beta nahi tha.
Aaisa Case bahut hai sir.. please reply me.. ya ek video banayee
Sir, just looking at the complexities of Islamic law alone. Is it even possible to formulate a uniform civil code for all the sects of Muslims let alone the whole country ? Is it even a viable exercise ?
There is no school of thoughts in Islam ... Only thoughts of Quran ...
@faizanslegalawareness sir,how to take action against a Russian App on google play where a majority of users from rural india upload hate speech articles . there is no content moderation on the App and no action is taken against such posts and blogs there.I want to report it anonymously
Congratulations Mustafa sab you have assured your berth as vice chancellor of AMU or may be a Governer post .
❤
Sir please do an video on can certain communities and regions of country like North east or tribals can be exempted under UCC...is it constitutionally valid ,and wudnt be discrimination with other parts of the country ...besides isn't it violating the very essence of article 14 which strives for universal uniformity throughout the country...and PlZ say will it be acceptable under court of law
Sir please hear 10 revivalists movements by Javed Ahmed Ghamidi.
Islam ek complete way of life life hai. Differences in opinion ka istemal kar ke ap ye nahi bol sakte ki kyuki differences in opinion hai, we will throw baby with the bath water.
Faizan sb Article 371 pe roshni daliye. What's the difference between 370 n 371
उसका सरकार पर कोई असर नहीं होना, सरकार सिर्फ हिंदू को " गांधारी" बनाने वाली सरकार है
Sir, kindly compare the ahle Hardee school of law with others,,,,
For inheritance, you didn’t discuss about the Wasiyat as per Quran and not as per different schools of Muslims
"Sir, what is the need for UCC when, from your lecture, we see we have such a stable system? Don't you think it's like demonetization, exercise?"
Absolutely ,it the negative strategy of BJP and RSS to divert the attention of 140 crore's India's from real issues like inflation, and economic crisis, poverty, suicide of farmers , unemployment, rising poverty, scandals, Adani scandals, etc etc.
MUKHTAR MUMBAI INDIA
Meher is the Pre requisite condition for Nikah, Women gets certain agreed amount for the nikah. Will it be waived off under UCC or non muslims will also pay the Meher amount??If it's waived off then the right given to muslim women will be denied and it will be unjust to the women in the name of empowerment of muslim women. How can you justify it SIR.
Sir, libaas wahi rakhiye Jo aapne aapke ghr me aapke Walid sahab ka dekha hoga, kuch bachaana he Teachers ko abhi mulk banzar hone se
Sir, unform civil code me saare khanzar talwaaren Muslim culture per hi kyo chal rahi hen, aap full list ek baar banaaiye ki dharm wise kis kis ke religion se kyaa kyaa kaata htaya jayga barabar culture hatane hi honge, democracy khatm mat hone dijiye, ye chaman me sabhi ki khushboon ko rehna jaroori he. Aap ki fikr jayaj he
سنیوں کے یہاں ان مسائل میں اجتہاد کا دروازہ آج بھی کھلا ہوا ہے جو نئے پیش آمدہ ہیں، البتہ جو پرانے ہیں ان میں بند ہو چکا ہے، بحیثیت لاء ٹیچر آپ کو یہ معلوم ہونا چاہئے
Is ghr ko aag lgi ,ghr k chirag se
Aap se gujarish hai ke Urdu me samjhai
people who want to understand this topic in depth need to watch a whole series of ghamidi about it . Your mother has aqeedat for ahl e bait so does all sunnis have its khatmals who are venemous
Faizan Sir ki biasness shuru hi me khul ke aa gyi.. tribals ko exclude kar dena chahiye.. lekin Muslims ke liye UCC (basically Hindu Civil Code) aana chahiye 😅
Waah Faizan saab waah!!
Hindu civil code don't follow Hindu religion.
Sheikh Nisar indore se
ASSALAM ALEKUM JAB TRIBE KE LOGON KO UCC SE HATAYA JAYEGA TO ISAI SIKH AUR MUSLIMON KO BHI HATAYA JA SAKTA HAI AAPKI KYA RAYE HAI SAHAB MASLA BAHUT PECHIDA HAI UMMID HAI AAP MERI BAAT SAMAJH GAYE HONGE AAP PER ALLAH KI RAHMAT HO FAIZAN MUSTUFA SAHAB.
*Tribal ki aur Muslim ki population ratio mein fark hai ya nahi..!?*
हमको लगता है पाकेटमार एलेक्शन के लिए ध्यान भटकाने केलिए हल्ला कर रहा है।
phir kaaheka UCC
I do watch your episodes from time to time. With all due respect, I think you need to study Fiqah Jafariya in more depth. First of all, the tern Shian e Ali is extensively used in Hadiths e.g. hadith e Kisa or the nuzool of ayat tat-heer Surah Ahzab, verse 33. You mentioned the last sermon of the Prophet (صلى الله عيله و آله), but you completely ignored the legal appointment of the guardian after prophet, which was the core objective of that last khutbah. Allah knows best about your intent. But a rational person should have put it the right way. There is a concept of Qiyas in Fiqah Ahle sunnah, i.e. making decisions based on own ideas. But there is no place for Qiyas in Fiqah Jafariya. In Fiqah Jafariya there is ijtihad ie. making decisions based on reasoning with prior knowledge. Before advent of the 4 Fiqah of Ahle Sunnah which Fiqah Muslims used to follow? They named that Fiqah as Fiqag Jafariya. Ahle Sunnah Fiqahs were created by the students of Imam Jafar al-Sadiq (as). Now the question must arise why did they differ with Imam Jafar Al - Sadiq? And Shia do taqleed in Fiqh. They have marjas for that purpose to guide at all times. Study Tuhfatal awaaam or Tawzihul Masa'il.
Now you said that reforms are needed. Yes they are very much needed in Ahle sunnah because majority of their laws were made by later caliphs. As far as the matter of muta is concerned, it was very much practiced during the time of the prophet and valid from Quran as well. Quran is the last guideline for mankind that means it is valid till the day of judgement. Muta was not for fun but to avoid fornication and illegit relationships. Today we see live-in in fashion. Muta can counter that and have legit relations and population. Egypt recently allowed Muta to avoid high rate of divorces. So my dear fellow Muslims pay close attention to reasoning. Do not try to reform Quran out of lack of knowledge and western liberal satanic influences. Surah Al-Anfal, Verse 22:
إِنَّ شَرَّ الدَّوَابِّ عِندَ اللَّهِ الصُّمُّ الْبُكْمُ الَّذِينَ لَا يَعْقِلُونَ
Indeed the worst of beasts in Allah’s sight are the deaf and dumb who do not exercise their reason.
Sir, Agar Hazrat Abu Bakar ko elect Kiya tou phir Abu Bakar Ney Hazrat Umar aur Umar Ney Hazrat Usman ko kyun select Kiya? Phir Ummat Ney Hazrat Ali ki phir 4 th Khalifa kyun chuna. Kaya pur process par par sawal nahi hai? You are deep Thinker. Shia 30% aur outher countries Mai minorities hai. Shia 6th Imam Jafar Sadiq key Shagird (student) Imam Hanif, Malik, Safi, Humba hai.
Hazrat Umar ne Usman ko select nahi kiya tha, Hazrat Umar ne 6 members committee bnayi thi aur kaha tha ki inme se kisi ek ko khalifa chun lena
@@Karanbansal007 Bro, Jab Prophet Ney koi committee khilafat key liye nahi banai aur Ummat nay Hazrat Abu Bakr ki elect Kiya tou Hazart Abu Bakar Ney phir committee kyun banaya? Aur agr Committee Ney Hazart Umar ko Khalifa banay tou phir committee Ney Hazrat Usman ko kyun nahi elect Kiya, aur Hazart Umar Ney Usaman ko select Kiya. Phir uskey baad Ummat (logo) Ney Ali ki Khalifa banaya. Kyun Sunni fiqh (Jurisprudence) Prophet key 200 saal bad Imam Hanif, Malik Safi etc key bad laya gaya.? Bani Abbas Ney bani Umayya ko Fiqah Mai badalaw key khilaf movement Kiya aur apni haqumat kayam ki. Yeh baat sab scholar and thinkers jantey hai lekin kehney sey dartey hai. Jab Mai apney Ghar Mai sawal karta hun to khud mery faimily Waley meri thought ko accept nahi karty. Bhai agar Niyam hai tou sab key liye barabar hona chahiye. Khalifa key selection aur election Mai farq ki wajah sey Jurisprudence Mai park hai. Plz think deeply. Deep Thinking will present all clear picture. TC
@@ehteshamali8319 aapne mera comment dhyan se nahi padha, Hazrat Abu Baqr ko Sahaba ke ijma ne select kiya tha, Umar ko Abu Baqr ne aur 6 members committee hazrat Umar ne bnayi thi.
@@Karanbansal007s ka matlab hazrat Mohammad s.a.w.w na khalafa ko nahee bana (abu bakar ko ) logoo na banaya ?
@@asgarjhon183 yes, Abu Baqr sahaba ke ijma se khalifa bne, Prophet ne kisi ko apna successor declare nahi kiya tha
Faizan saab munafiqat choday aur khul kar kahey uniform civil code kay bajay uniform economic code baney and extinction of poor n rich n emerging of middle class n uniform housing code matlab every family to have 1000 sft apartment n balance to be given to other indians homeless or uniform land costs why at one place to be 1 lakh per sq yard n other per acre or why sharuq khan make 500 crores instead of standard 50 thousand rupees for all indians n uniform marriage spending code matlab late jaya lalita adopted son marriage at cost of 500 crores instead of uniform 10 thousand rupees per marriage n like wise uniform medical code or transport code or education code n uniform wealth distribution for 140 crores population n not held by 5 percent of population etc n this uniformity will be welcomed by all religions citizens of india
Sir eid e ghadir mobarak ho ap shia kitab men padhiye pahle k shia maula ali ko khalifa relationship k bina pr nhi balki allah k khukm se banaya hua khalifa mante hen
Ap ne is men ye jo kaha h k shia maula ali ko khalifa relationship k wajah se mante hen ye bilkul ghalat h
Ap Allama amini ki kitab alghadeer padh sakte hen agr haq janna chahte hen to waise ap khud kah rhe hen k ap ki waleda ahlebait se zyada aqidat rakhti hen aur ap bhi to haqiqat janna ap k liye zyada zaruri ho jata h
Shia ,Sunni keya kehte hai yeh baat apni jagah, Quran Kaya hai oh he absolute hai Quran he final autharty hai.
Quran give permission to Mutta marriage.
@@ehteshamali8319astakfirullah
Qur'an ne kbi nhi kaha hai ye Terey jahil zakiron ne Qur'an ko galat tarjuma kiya hai 😂
Faizan sahab, Law agar serious business hai aapki nazar me aur koi aira ghaira raaye nahi de sakta, to aap kya samajhte hain ke Islamic law/Fique me koi bhi aira ghaira yahan se wahan Kuchh information le liya to wo apni raaye de sakta hai?
Ye to double standard hai, ke aap human law me intervene nahi karsakte lekin aap divine law me karsakte hain!
Sochiye aap ek intellectual hain apni zahanat ka sahi istemaal kijiye.
Time waste kar hai Sir aap...
Itni details suna kar kya sabit kar rahe samjh nahi aa raha ....
Qanoon ki shariyat ki baat karte karte history padhane lag gaye aap to...
Sidhe sidhe mudde pe aaye
Basic difference bataye kya fark Hindu law me, Muslim law me, chirstan law etc etc...
Aur fir bataye k kese inko common civil code me tabdil karnge ....
Achi books aur acche people sab ki samajh me nhi aate
शादीया कैसे होगी हिन्दू मुस्लिम सिख ईसाई यहुदी कोन सा लौ लागु होगा
Mr Faizan Mustafa, you were talking against UCC last year, why this change of heart. Is it because you are aiming at AMU vice chancellorship or something like that by pleasing RSS?
You are not a Islamic scholar. You are terming both as Islamic laws. Sharia is laws given directly by Allah and Rasoolallah. Whereas Fiqh is interpretation and implementation of shariah in various time periods and circumstances. As sharia, you can not touch the laws of Quran like permission for multiple marriages, inheritance laws, etc.
Building structure of India not like hindu.
Quran aur Ahadees ki roshni mein hi tamaam qavaneen banaye gaye hain Mr Faizan isliye ye divine laws hi hain ismein usuli maamelaat mein tarmeem ka haq kisi Muslim hukumat ko bhi nahi kaja k ek gair Muslim hukumat ko. Faroee maamelat mein bhi ye aapka kaam nahi ulemaye deen aur Muftiyaan e karaam ka kaam hai,
Kisi duniyavi , ya insaano k qanoon ko aafaqi qanoon par tarjeeh dene waale Faizan Mustafa ka ye kaam hargiz nahi hai na uski ye haisiyat hai na usko ye ijaazat di ja sakti hai sharyee taur par.
Ek aur baat khud Hindus mein, Tribals mein, sikh, Christians k aapasi ikhtelaaf ko bhi batao, kya inn sobke liye UCC acceptable ya applicable hoga ya nahi.
Ek saal pahle app UCC k khilaaf thhe ab kiss laalach ya dhamki ki wajah se uske favour mein ho ?????
Please answer.
السلام علیکم ورحمة الله وبركاته
As you are an expert in Indian Constitution and Law, better you speak about that only.
You are not an expert in Islamic studies, you don't even have the BASIC KNOWLEDGE of Islam, hence you should not speak about that. It will be better for you hereafter. This is my sincere advice.
Be wakt ki raagni alaap rahe hain ye.
क्या मुसलमान भी सात फेरे लेंगे अगर ये कानून आया तो अगर ऐसा है तो ये स्वीकार्य नहीं है
very informative