【驀然回首 019】傳統左派元老後人吳力波:香港學生文革上山下鄉的故事(上)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 45

  • @yvonnewong6486
    @yvonnewong6486 2 года назад +1

    在「左派」家庭出身的人,重溫舊事,甚有同感。
    聽吳先生講親自經歷,加上理性的分析,更加深了解當前的形勢。
    向他致敬!

  • @CS-du3po
    @CS-du3po 2 года назад +2

    我爸爸都係讀廣雅中學,都係68年11月下鄉去海南島紅華農場,一去7年。

  • @kamshingchoi7843
    @kamshingchoi7843 2 года назад +18

    從前爱国左派,係真心愛国,就算做错事都認惟爱国,後來有反思先有悔意,现在爱乜国,爱錢,爱利益,共產黨只可有啲敢人才,怎可以有人為国。

    • @kamshingchoi7843
      @kamshingchoi7843 2 года назад

      曾鈺成,曾德成咪係囉,可惜得個爱,無回報,得细老叫做做局長都畀人踢出局,你夠好爱啦。

  • @simonglobal
    @simonglobal  2 года назад +1

    傳統左派元老後人吳力波:上山下鄉學習心得:深入最基層的共產黨,與國民黨有何不同?(中)
    ruclips.net/video/vxMKlxLt4jc/видео.html
    傳統左派元老後人吳力波:「新香港」不是「二次文革」,而是「二次殖民」(下)
    ruclips.net/video/B9WDntLVMAk/видео.html

  • @albert6439
    @albert6439 2 года назад +18

    現在「鼓勵」年輕人返大灣區工作,都可能有上山下鄉的味道🤔

  • @longguoyao5563
    @longguoyao5563 2 года назад +6

    沈博士的嘉宾都喺有高度的人,唔该晒谢谢

  • @stephenho1752
    @stephenho1752 2 года назад +2

    多謝你。

  • @chanmr8061
    @chanmr8061 2 года назад +30

    大哲學家蕭伯納講過,當你年青時不相信共產主義是庸才,當你年長後仍相信共產主義是蠢材。

  • @annlity
    @annlity 2 года назад +6

    「不求進步不求改變的不配稱為左派」!
    我為呢句說話反複睇呢條片好多次,的確梳理出愛國和維護自身既得利益的差別,明確道出輕易綁埋盲目民族主義者和真正愛國者的差別!

  • @thisisnottheend4392
    @thisisnottheend4392 2 года назад

    🙏🏻🙏🏻

  • @jimmytai1915
    @jimmytai1915 2 года назад

    Thank ❤

  • @suzyuen
    @suzyuen 2 года назад +4

    聽得出吳老先生 顧左右而言他。
    是心虛 還是 心假😔

    • @suzyuen
      @suzyuen 2 года назад

      這樣的話 可信性就打折扣了😒

    • @amylamcf52
      @amylamcf52 2 года назад

      係心裏面有鬼

    • @clothesadoption1111
      @clothesadoption1111 2 года назад

      吳老先生係會站在街頭用口琴吹「願榮光歸香港」嘅人,活得磊落。老人家長氣好難避免,建議沈博士多啲互動,冇咁單調。

    • @clothesadoption1111
      @clothesadoption1111 2 года назад +3

      雨傘運動期間有幸跟老人家去廣州睇革命古跡,參觀完黃花崗七十二烈士紀念碑,突然縛條黃絲帶🎗️上圍欄然後轉身離開。嚇得我目定口呆⋯⋯

    • @suzyuen
      @suzyuen 2 года назад

      @@clothesadoption1111 你說的,那和他鏡頭前 的左閃右避 沒有衝突喎!
      今集 是想説當年文革,不想說可以不出鏡的,是吧?

  • @cheungkk7700
    @cheungkk7700 2 года назад

    Thanks

  • @livefreefromfear
    @livefreefromfear 2 года назад +3

    感謝分享🙏🏻

  • @clothesadoption1111
    @clothesadoption1111 2 года назад +4

    波叔叔!清減咗…保重身體!

  • @hochikwan401
    @hochikwan401 2 года назад +1

    👍👍👏👏👏

  • @wlaw8803
    @wlaw8803 2 года назад

    Thanks . Great sharing

  • @chantingting9017
    @chantingting9017 2 года назад +2

    現在上山下鄉都沒田耕,田地大多數都蓋起高樓大廈⋯⋯

  • @simonglobal
    @simonglobal  Год назад

    【國際香港本傳 068 🇨🇳🇹🇼🇬🇧🇺🇸】吳力波:「兩航投共」謎團解密(上)港英政府如何在國共兩黨之間周旋?
    ruclips.net/video/bEf_vwCFhIs/видео.html

  • @christomanchan4986
    @christomanchan4986 2 года назад

    💪

  • @kanlexkanlex9965
    @kanlexkanlex9965 2 года назад

    Greatsss

  • @albert6439
    @albert6439 2 года назад +3

    唉,阿爺的戰狼文化,搞到各國都對華人,不會再互信😫

  • @HK-bc9hh
    @HK-bc9hh 2 года назад +2

    收音唔多掂

  • @amychan999
    @amychan999 2 года назад +6

    六四事件的確令一些原來紅色背景的人對共產黨改觀 但亦有人在此背景長大選擇繼續留在體制內 繼續自欺 否則就是否定了自己的人生
    所以先生的醒覺非常難得

  • @archiekleung
    @archiekleung 2 года назад +2

    Man management system.
    Vietnam war, for the first time, reporters, photographers were embedded into combat units. For that people around the world, particularly people in USA, could see the battle unfold and watch the progress of war.
    >>>At the same time in China through the eyes of young people they could see how poor and backward the country was.
    >>>Reading between the lines I see an interesting man management system.
    >>>Germany in the 30s had a system giving power to, say, street representative or district representative acting as ears and eyes for the Party. Any one not toeing the Party line would go to the concentration camp. After the war people were still afraid to speak up because those people were still around even though they do not have the same power. Gun shy, I guess.
    >>>Obviously Beijing learned this via Russia. As a whole this is a brilliant man management move. Over night the government created millions of jobs. Talking about buying love?
    >>>Economically this is a disaster. These people are professional Peeping Tom. They are not productive. They eat like field mice. They instilled fear in village life. However they scared the shit out of Pentagon. They did not expect a command in Beijing, during the Big Leap, could penetrate so deep into the country. Thank you Germany and no thanks to Beijing.
    >>>At the same time don't expect such system would be efficient.

  • @candyho1358
    @candyho1358 2 года назад

    Like

  • @amylamcf52
    @amylamcf52 2 года назад

    講到好複雜聽唔明

  • @harwu1752
    @harwu1752 2 года назад

    培正,广州七中

    • @mathieu8083
      @mathieu8083 2 года назад

      五十年代才保留校名如培正、培僑等等。後來改曬叫乜中物中。九十年代後又改番舊名

  • @SKWater
    @SKWater 2 года назад

    佢同沈生有乜嘢關係?

    • @dcar6530
      @dcar6530 Год назад

      佢同沈生父母有朋友關係.

  • @德胜门
    @德胜门 2 года назад +7

    作为沈教授的忠诚跟随者,这一期我强迫自己看了十分钟。

    • @amylamcf52
      @amylamcf52 2 года назад

      Me too, 越看越嬲越覺得這個波仔面容扭曲……唔講啦!

    • @candyyim3913
      @candyyim3913 2 года назад

      好難頂

  • @ganbatte1920
    @ganbatte1920 2 года назад +2

    so boring 😴

  • @Robin-Free
    @Robin-Free 2 года назад

    歐洲 入門級移民

  • @wongchikeung5775
    @wongchikeung5775 2 года назад

    👻👻👻👻👻👻👻