What happens if a crucial ocean current collapses? | About That

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 148

  • @FarmerRiddick
    @FarmerRiddick Год назад +10

    The children and grandchildren born today have a likely chance of experiencing the negative effects in their old age tomorrow.
    Thanks mom and dad, grandma and grandpa for the gifts of struggle and hard survival.

    • @chinookvalley
      @chinookvalley Год назад +4

      If things happen like the profits say, WE will see the negative effects happen. I'm guessing we have until 2025 to call it, "the good ol' days". Our children don't stand a chance. Forget the grandchildren. Too little too late.

    • @FarmerRiddick
      @FarmerRiddick Год назад

      @@chinookvalley Still, we must endure and keep doing what we can.
      these children are an example of a form of right action.

    • @tealkerberus748
      @tealkerberus748 6 месяцев назад

      Humans have lived through struggling to survive before now. Future generations are going to have an extra burden of rage that the struggle bequeathed to them was so unnecessary - the leaders and voters from the 20th century knew exactly what they were doing and chose to continue doing it - but they will still do their absolute best to survive and thrive. That's what all life forms do.

    • @peterp5099
      @peterp5099 4 месяца назад

      So how could we switch our current global economic system against one that would allow saving the climate to work? I mean, today the richest 10% are responsible for half of the climate relevant emissions, and in our current system there is literally nothing that we could do to make them reduce that.

  • @stevenrichardscott1622
    @stevenrichardscott1622 Год назад +20

    The AMOC and the Gulf Stream are two different, though connected, things. The first is powered by water temperature and salinity, the second by the spinning of the earth and wind. Thus the stopping of the AMOC does not mean the end of the Gulf Stream.

    • @ElectroCouture
      @ElectroCouture Год назад

      YESSIR! They are talking nonsense in order to impliment new draconian measures to control our lives... Worst part is, it will all be for naught! If you follow legit, open minded, highly qualified climatologists, they will tell you there is much much more at play and that we have zero control over... Yet here we are playing day after tomorrow clips to frighten people into submission when the measures are rolled out. I would hate to be Canadian these days. Its gonna suck for Europe AND Canada. Dont get me wrong, they will try it here in the states, but our constitution is keeping them in check.

    • @renatoantonelli3894
      @renatoantonelli3894 Год назад +4

      Therefore what happens to the gulf stream if the Amoc is interrupted ?

    • @mayatara1980
      @mayatara1980 7 месяцев назад

      Came here to say that.

    • @TheVinor14
      @TheVinor14 7 месяцев назад

      So.....were in the video, did they get that confused?
      Do you know how amoc can affect farming

    • @showme360
      @showme360 4 месяца назад +1

      Please do a video demonstarting your argument! Because I don't know where your golf stream starts and ends.

  • @grindupBaker
    @grindupBaker 2 месяца назад +1

    AMOC is down from 20Sv to 17Sv now. Scientists estimate it's unstoppable at 10Sv. "Collapse" or "tipping point" means it passes a point at which it becomes self-sustaining so continued slowing to a total stop is inevitable, unstoppable. It then takes about 100 years to finish slowing from 10Sv to a total stop with whatever climate effects that has steadily progressing. The point is that its slowing becomes UNSTOPPABLE at the "Collapse" or "tipping point" (estimated 10Sv) and not at all that it STOPS at the "Collapse" or "tipping point". This from Stefan Rahmstorf leading expert with many AMOC papers published.

  • @chinookvalley
    @chinookvalley Год назад +7

    Sad how people aren't willing to look at the facts. If you think that God created the Garden of Eden, you don't want to contemplate the fact that YOU are killing it? Let's see how your God judges you for your morals and actions.

    • @mayatara1980
      @mayatara1980 7 месяцев назад

      I am not religious, and I do not challenge that we are totally disrupting the ecosystems and climate systems, I just want to point out we're not killing the planet per se, we're destroying its current biosphere. The planet will be fine and readjust itself and find new balances, as it always does, and life will thrive again with news species replacing the old ones, the problem is we're killing ourselves and most other life we depend on to survive. So in that sense, you can say we're killing "the planet", but it will bounce off once it gets rid of us.
      Your argument is still a good one. According to the bible, we're supposed to be the caretakers of god's creation. But when someone wrongfully translated "care for" for "dominate", to justify destroying it and killing all the animals, that's when they completely took us away from being caretakers of "god's creation" and now they really don't seem to care anymore.

  • @justbecauseOK
    @justbecauseOK Год назад +5

    If you dont like climate science then please do not comment here. We who do believe the scientists will be picking up the pieces for you. That will probably be a little bit humbling for you.

    • @cricketmusic62
      @cricketmusic62 Год назад

      Climate change is for real, but it is unstoppable because it is a cycle the Earth will complete. Always has and the evidence confirms it.
      The proposterous claim of human carbon emissions is the root cause of the ever changing climate cycle, now thats where the ethical scientists leave the room. Biggest scam that has ever been played on some parts of the world, but millions of Americans have been and will continue to be duped for the ill gotten gains of a few billionaires.

    • @mikepotter5718
      @mikepotter5718 19 часов назад

      I hate the science on this. :) Something is happening but its not clear when or what. (Googles AI has come to the conclusion that a collapse could happen between don't look out your door to 6000 years in the future,) How do you make policy on that kind of information?

  • @social3ngin33rin
    @social3ngin33rin Год назад +5

    2100 is really close
    But 2yr is much closer

  • @da80
    @da80 Год назад +5

    13k years in Earth age is a blink of an eye

  • @showme360
    @showme360 4 месяца назад +2

    At 35 gigatonnes of CO2 being released each year, I don't see any relaxing of the emissions. After all the meteorite than finished the dinosaurs was estimated to be around 600 - 1000 gigatonnes, we matched that in the last 20 years, and are on target to reach the 1000 gigatonnes by 2040 all be it slower. Its the migrations of billions of people from the equator to the North hemisphere that will be be the biggest problem for humanity!

  • @misterfunnybones
    @misterfunnybones 8 месяцев назад +2

    How much fresh & sea water Arctic & Antarctic ice melting from sea water ice & land-based glaciers will it take to convince people that things are changing?

  • @matthewporter1376
    @matthewporter1376 Год назад +1

    If we are the problem then let's limit how many people there are? What's the holding capacity of earth? 1B? Maybe less; the people that call earth home should love her like a mother.

  • @ryuuguu01
    @ryuuguu01 Год назад +16

    Some missing points in the video. The latest paper that has everyone talking about this now says it will stop between 2025 and 2095. The end of the video leaves the impression that 2100 is the expected year it will stop not 2065 which is what the paper says the expected date is. Also, it only mentions in passing that it evens out the temperature between temperate Northern latitudes and tropical equatorial latitudes. So we get climate change deniers talking about ice ages. In reality, it means a slower warming in the north and faster warming in the south part of the northern hemisphere.

    • @TherealRTZ973
      @TherealRTZ973 Год назад +4

      The water movement now is what evens out the temperature. If you get rid of it you will see further extremes. Warm places like England will see an incredible amount of cooling. I'm sure as the planet on average continues to heat It will go far above that after.

    • @javiersantos4385
      @javiersantos4385 Год назад

      I agree, good point. I also thought she failed to include the effects on salinity, that makes salty warm water sink under cooler but less saline arctic meltwater.

  • @loveobviously
    @loveobviously Год назад +14

    Could you imagine “IF” this movie actually happened 🤯

    • @CHIEF_420
      @CHIEF_420 Год назад

      🌏⌚️

    • @Magickmoon
      @Magickmoon Год назад +1

      The truth is stranger than fiction, think about that!

    • @drew_x_insights
      @drew_x_insights 26 дней назад

      It happened in history before & it will happen again in the future.
      Just a matter of asking “when”

  • @angelsplace
    @angelsplace 5 месяцев назад +1

    Professor Kevin Anderson explains AMOC collapse better on utube.

  • @haydndoucet4172
    @haydndoucet4172 Год назад +1

    When the Beaufort gyre releases it could stop the AMOC. Recently 2023 it changed and looks like it wi release, but they’ve been saying that since 2017. So it could any day or year. It holds 40% more freshwater than it had since the 70’s. It holds as much freshwater as the Great Lakes.

  • @grindupBaker
    @grindupBaker 2 месяца назад

    If the AMOC stops then the Gulf Stream will slow down a tad less than 50% because the gyre wind will keep blowing. However (HOWEVER) most by far of the heat it carries north will stop because the gyre wind blows water around without a big change in its temperature but AMOC overturning brings water north thats many degrees warmer than the water south. Well it's 17Sv carrying 900 terawatts (800 billion electric kettles) so the temperature change it brings must be 900,000,000,000,000 / (17,000,000,000 * 4120) = 12.8 degrees (the water departing south must be 12.8 degrees colder than the warm surface water flowing north). The Gulf Stream is 35Sv but that wind driven 18Sv bit isn't dumping much heat into the north, nowhere near the 12.8 degrees of the AMOC overturning.

  • @DarkSideOfThePepper
    @DarkSideOfThePepper Год назад +10

    IF this and IF that

    • @jsEMCsquared
      @jsEMCsquared Год назад +1

      ​@FaithShortridge " i think ,therefore I am."
      You ,whomever you are, must not exist.

    • @sandorski56
      @sandorski56 Год назад +1

      Don't miss the forest for the trees.

  • @gokulkrishna4011
    @gokulkrishna4011 Год назад +2

    Is it possible it can happen faster

  • @degagnemarc
    @degagnemarc 8 месяцев назад

    Little correction on, "We are not at this point yet !". I don't know how one measure the start of something, but on my side, if there are sings, it has started! Yes we are at this point now, It's starting and every sings are there. In 2021, Canada had It's worst crop yield and so as other food countries. Droughts and floods, fires, tornados where there was none, hurricane stronger than ever, climate going from drought to floods over and over again. Yes there is other factors contributing to the rise cost of food but the main one is availability. Food cost is just going to rise rapidly and as other goods as rebound.
    No food does mean the crash of this type of economy we live in and the good comfort of modern living we enjoy so mush and take for granted.
    In 2023 we had our FIRST full year 1.4 °C above pre industrial levels. Ok it does take at least a decade of repeated temperatures to say we reached it, but it as started nevertheless.
    And the gentlemen comment before me is right about the AMOC and the gulf stream. These are two distinctive currents, one influences the other but are considered different.
    I don't now what it will take for people to open there eyes!

    • @grindupBaker
      @grindupBaker 2 месяца назад

      AMOC is down from 20Sv to 17Sv now. Scientists estimate it's unstoppable at 10Sv. "Collapse" or "tipping point" means it passes a point at which it becomes self-sustaining so continued slowing to a total stop is inevitable, unstoppable. It then takes about 100 years to finish slowing from 10Sv to a total stop with whatever climate effects that has steadily progressing. The point is that its slowing becomes UNSTOPPABLE at the "Collapse" or "tipping point" (estimated 10Sv) and not at all that it STOPS at the "Collapse" or "tipping point". This from Stefan Rahmstorf leading expert with many AMOC papers published.

  • @08wolfeyes
    @08wolfeyes Год назад +1

    Well, the Amoc has already begun slowing down.

  • @leohorishny9561
    @leohorishny9561 8 месяцев назад

    It needs to happen, otherwise concrete steps to affect anything will not happen for decades.

  • @kimlibera663
    @kimlibera663 2 месяца назад

    Bunk. Gulf current will not collapse. This is because it moves via the rotation of the earth.

  • @cjever6625
    @cjever6625 6 месяцев назад

    A great video to make will be about the 2015 Paris Climate Agreement which will be a decade old next year. How much have we done?

  • @Dman8s
    @Dman8s 8 месяцев назад

    The current would depend on gravity ? Tides. So unless the land is changing to funnel water off somewhere else like man made lakes, massive canals ? The rotation of the planet might change if the weight of the water starts moving in another direction, so then tides could maybe wash over countries or your country could end up suddenly bigger as the water goes somewhere else. Hot water rising towards the surface has zero to do with current movements. Like if Ireland was positioned on the Pacific equator it would be underwater, if you view the earth without water its not round at all

  • @JB-np5xi
    @JB-np5xi 8 месяцев назад

    Our friend the atom 30+yrs ago and we would not be where we are today.

  • @MaryJane-hi7tu
    @MaryJane-hi7tu Год назад +7

    10 years later we'll be saying remember that time they thought the currant was going to stop.

    • @ninemoonplanet
      @ninemoonplanet Год назад +2

      I hope your here when another decade is done, then add this to your memory, write it down and see if you are right.

    • @MaryJane-hi7tu
      @MaryJane-hi7tu Год назад

      @@ninemoonplanet no need to wright it down. I'll find out in ten years. I could care less. An asteroid could wipe us out tomorrow. Do I seem worried?

    • @MaryJane-hi7tu
      @MaryJane-hi7tu Год назад +2

      I am worried Trudeau is going to screw over the middle class though. 🙃

    • @da80
      @da80 Год назад +1

      let's tag it in our calendars 10 years from today to see how much more we all destroyed our only home while still living in it.

    • @MaryJane-hi7tu
      @MaryJane-hi7tu Год назад

      @@da80 nothing to do with us. It's pretty ignorant of you to think humans can destroy the planet. You don't give this rock the credit it deserves.

  • @7Trident3
    @7Trident3 Год назад +1

    Canada has the worlds largest salt mine???!!!

    • @EmeraldView
      @EmeraldView Год назад

      Well they did until Trump lost the election in 2020 and then all his criminal indictments Now the largest salt mine is his horde of MAGAts.

  • @cynthiadonegan2097
    @cynthiadonegan2097 Год назад +4

    How is it possible for you or anyone to be absolute about "what if"?
    Thanks for the minimal data but - no thanks to a plastic container & glass tank to give credit to a living planet - what a joke

    • @EmeraldView
      @EmeraldView Год назад

      It was a simple basic demonstration to illustrate a concept.
      Do you think climate scientists do THAT (tank thing) and then draw their conclusions?

  • @davidgeyer3988
    @davidgeyer3988 2 месяца назад

    Please check your fact the rotation of the earth causes this current.

  • @LuvLight44
    @LuvLight44 3 месяца назад

    The Great Mother they shouldn’t have made dams. The water will go back where The Great Mother put HER water

  • @tophat2115
    @tophat2115 8 месяцев назад

    could be, might be...don't hedge, the human brain says, nothing to worry about then... this needs attention especially if you live on this planet

  • @kennethsnyder9236
    @kennethsnyder9236 Год назад

    Oh, I don’t know? What do you do when your moon is gone? Boy oh boy what do we do?
    “We’re all doomed, what are we going to do “? I am going on a limb and say we better get out on the water and start splashing around. The fish need aeration.

    • @showme360
      @showme360 4 месяца назад

      Stop Burning stuff, thats what you do!

  • @dinvsl
    @dinvsl Год назад +3

    What happens if CBC is defunded and stops stealing taxpayers money ?

    • @apextroll
      @apextroll Год назад +2

      Nothing. You will continue to cry about your horrible life.

  • @sotonpo
    @sotonpo Год назад +1

    Sad News

  • @amyntazoe9831
    @amyntazoe9831 Год назад

    And there's a war going on,. Where are all the environmentalists at.

  • @canadaclub8920
    @canadaclub8920 Год назад

    Canfield Ocean risk

  • @thezenfarmer
    @thezenfarmer Год назад +1

    Anyone following the science behind the magnetic reversal and recurrent micronova?

    • @NordeggSonya
      @NordeggSonya Год назад

      Eyes open no fear be safe everyone, yes Suspicious 0bservers know about this.

  • @BobbyBiff
    @BobbyBiff Год назад +3

    Cbc has gone to heck in a hand basket, I'm losing all hope for them

    • @cindyhaduik7171
      @cindyhaduik7171 Год назад

      Yea , we'll show you a grade 7 experiment ...
      Everyone panic !!!! 🙄

  • @sotonpo
    @sotonpo Год назад +1

    😢

  • @Jen-e-sis
    @Jen-e-sis Год назад

    It’s already been prophesied to happen and the four winds will be held back.

  • @mwagicalpwush
    @mwagicalpwush Год назад +4

    boo

  • @sotonpo
    @sotonpo Год назад +1

    😢😢😢

  • @giftedfooljjhg1981thepasmb
    @giftedfooljjhg1981thepasmb Год назад +3

    Doom

  • @joelmcneney5366
    @joelmcneney5366 Год назад +1

    We want you : Scared, broke and compliant.

  • @nativespiritindian8278
    @nativespiritindian8278 7 месяцев назад

    day after tomorrow. we warned you all now red kachina comes again.

  • @willy4571
    @willy4571 Год назад +1

    The ocean currants have something to do with the earths rotation, ozone layers and gravity.
    Just my opinion. 3:30

    • @ninemoonplanet
      @ninemoonplanet Год назад +3

      Partially right, but those forces are much weaker, smaller than the AMOC. Unfortunately the amount of CO2 absorbed around the world in the oceans is heating up the polar ice, Arctic and Subarctic.

    • @justbecauseOK
      @justbecauseOK Год назад +1

      Offering an opinion is like pissing in the wind as a wildfire consumes your community and reduces it to ash.

    • @showme360
      @showme360 4 месяца назад

      Wow you have such an over welling wealth of knowledge!

  • @robin1655
    @robin1655 Год назад

    The cartoon ball 😂

  • @Dragonfly_vbz
    @Dragonfly_vbz Год назад +1

    Please tell her she is lovely, but the pauses in her speech to make points are too much. Ugh. 😮 otherwise, it is very informative, but that speech pattern is unnecessary.

  • @Steelblood27
    @Steelblood27 Год назад +4

    Pollution is bad, and warming is bad yes. But the earth has existed for much much longer than we have, and I feel we risk over estimating our own impact, and knowledge. Since we existed humanity has had to deal with natural disasters out of our control. We still do when it comes to tsunami's and earthquakes. This whole debate is essentially our argument that WE are now the ones causing the random chaos of earth's nature.
    Ultimately the earth has always been a dynamic system. Our cities and infrastructure is largely designed and based on the assumption of fixed conditions. When those "fixed" conditions change, that's where technology and old designs need to be adapted. Whether we are impacting the rate of that change or not, we still need to innovate. There will always be a limit to how much we influence the planet. We are quick to forget that we are the passengers on earth, but not the ones in the driver seat.

    • @john15008
      @john15008 Год назад

      Humankind has hijacked this natural process. Humanity has never had to cope with changes, at this rate, with a population of close to 7.9 billion.

    • @showme360
      @showme360 4 месяца назад

      Quite right, but for the fact that our technologies have allowed us to remain fix in one place, creating cultures, and beliefs in one social segment on all the continents, so leading to countries. The great US of A will have to move to Canada to escape the heat, are you ready for the great migration? Is anyone planning this migration like in the movie 2011. I fear NOT!!

    • @Steelblood27
      @Steelblood27 3 месяца назад

      @@showme360 🤨huh

  • @talpark8796
    @talpark8796 Год назад +1

    😂

  • @jsEMCsquared
    @jsEMCsquared Год назад +1

    It is going to collapse. Period. .
    Edit, its going to happen within 5 years! David bowie "that's all we've got"

  • @rodneypantony3551
    @rodneypantony3551 Год назад

    Citing ChatGPT re Bronze Age

  • @sotonpo
    @sotonpo Год назад +1

    😢😢😢😢

  • @heleenotto329
    @heleenotto329 Год назад

    Yes of de circulation stop....than you get cool EARTH..

    • @ninemoonplanet
      @ninemoonplanet Год назад

      Unfortunately that's exactly the opposite of what's going on.
      Permafrost is melting, forest fires are far worse, more frequent, because of the heating of both the atmosphere and oceans.

  • @bobleclair5665
    @bobleclair5665 3 месяца назад

    The planet pretty much regulates itself

  • @troyzieman7177
    @troyzieman7177 Год назад +1

    So when you start your " news" clip with an overly dramatic movie clip from a non relevant to the topic movie .I know we have moved from news to entertainment .
    This report of the AMOC collapsing is not considered the finished science on this topic . It is one viewpoint with many detractors.
    I live in Ontario , my view of the weather we have received this summer as damn near perfect. Lots of hot weather, with plenty of rain am I too now conclude that Climate change is good ? No , of course not . I will consider that not all the effects from it will be neccesarily negative. Where you live will matter .
    Science does not take a single report , study , ect and declare definitive conclusions , but CBC found a report that fit its narrative and presented it as fact .
    The climate that needs to change is public funding to the CBC....

  • @jonfklein
    @jonfklein Год назад +4

    Scare-monger.

  • @raedaltaee7358
    @raedaltaee7358 Год назад

    طاب يومكم اعزائي الملائكة والسلام عليكم
    السماح للملائكة بزراعة الحنطة والشعير والرز والبقوليات وجميع الفواكه والخضراوات بما يكفي عدد المستهلكين له في الجنة .
    تمت الموافقة عليها من قبل ( اللّه والرب والخالق)
    رسول ومستشار الخالق رائد الطائي

  • @theguess7
    @theguess7 Год назад +2

    Amazing how advocacy journalism is indistinguishable from propaganda.

    • @vrisket771
      @vrisket771 Год назад +6

      you could argue any kind of persuasive material meant to change mindsets and raise awareness is propaganda in the truest sense of the word. propaganda isn't always bad, it sure is effective at raising awareness both good-natured and nefarious

    • @theguess7
      @theguess7 Год назад +1

      @@vrisket771 Wow. Never thought I would see the day when someone would advocate for propaganda! This sure is a brave new world we live in.

    • @vrisket771
      @vrisket771 Год назад +5

      @@theguess7 Clearly you're not able to separate the connotation of the word from the actual meaning.

    • @adelelavoie515
      @adelelavoie515 9 месяцев назад

      I’m curious what motivation scientists would have to use “propaganda “ to convince us that there’s a problem with the earth’s balance? Because I can clearly see the motivation for pushing *denial*of climate change ($$$ greed, laziness to act, “I want what I want and I want it now” no matter the consequence)

    • @adelelavoie515
      @adelelavoie515 9 месяцев назад

      I’m curious what motivation scientists would have to use “propaganda “ to convince us that there’s a problem with the earth’s balance? Because I can clearly see the motivation for pushing *denial*of climate change ($$$ greed, laziness to act, “I want what I want and I want it now” no matter the consequence)

  • @felixthecat2786
    @felixthecat2786 Год назад

    Why don't they just allow scientists to explain how this works instead of the pretty blond report who says "like" and
    "Um" 70 times.

  • @davidhudson5452
    @davidhudson5452 Год назад

    When it happens will to deal with it 2 ice ages we did not cause it this is normal

    • @ninemoonplanet
      @ninemoonplanet Год назад

      Wishful thinking. The amount of methane, CO2 is going to make Canada a drought zone, forest fires hotter, more frequent and tornadoes much more frequent and powerful.
      Nobody is safe from these effects, even the rainforest zones.

  • @johndoe-ko8nu
    @johndoe-ko8nu Год назад +1

    nice orange prison uniform

  • @johndoe-ko8nu
    @johndoe-ko8nu Год назад +3

    More propaganda!!!! SCARE TACTICS!!!!

    • @sireorcry
      @sireorcry Год назад +1

      Propaganda for what?! Prove that fossil fuels DON'T harm the climate.

    • @johndoe-ko8nu
      @johndoe-ko8nu Год назад

      @@sireorcry C02 promotes plant life all plants consume C02 and give oxygen at night !! Do you breath Oxygen??

    • @justbecauseOK
      @justbecauseOK Год назад

      @@sireorcry he cannot and will not. These people are lost causes.

  • @johndoe-ko8nu
    @johndoe-ko8nu Год назад +1

    This is a JOKE!!!

  • @michaelsmomenton
    @michaelsmomenton Год назад

    Prppaganda

  • @mikesrdtrukr
    @mikesrdtrukr Год назад +2

    Blah blah blah.....
    There sure is a lot of "possibly" , "might" and "if" words going around in the vid.
    We need more taxes! Lots and lots of taxes! And more boards, and committees and science.....
    Yeah. That outta fix it. 🥱

    • @showme360
      @showme360 4 месяца назад

      What your referring to is tweaking! The basic understanding of the changing climate is fix. Its going to happen!! Get ready for the mass migration of Americans heading north!

  • @sotonpo
    @sotonpo Год назад +1

    😢😢

  • @randicook15
    @randicook15 Год назад

    😢