Would a Quebec constitution unite or divide us? | The Corner Booth

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
  • Antoine Dionne Charest and Robert Libman join Bill Brownstein and Aaron Rand on the Corner Booth at the Snowdon Deli

Комментарии • 70

  • @jandron94
    @jandron94 13 дней назад +9

    The French-speaking guests invited here always have a better English than all the hosts around the table do have it in French...
    The French majority in Quebec accomodates so much more the English minority...

  • @bobby5678-ck2tc
    @bobby5678-ck2tc 14 дней назад +5

    We French Canadians are also considered a minority so i have no clue why he is crying about this anyways.

  • @nomadesanslieux1703
    @nomadesanslieux1703 15 дней назад +7

    There's no such thing as the PLQ, the reality is the PLWM, The parti libéral du Western Montreal.

  • @fs400ion
    @fs400ion 15 дней назад +6

    How are collective rights a problem? Québec has less social tensions than the rest of Canada specifically because it focuses more on collective rights.

    • @trevorchabot864
      @trevorchabot864 14 дней назад

      That's exactly what Hitler was trying to say. Crush the minority, and social tensions just disappear.

    • @fs400ion
      @fs400ion 14 дней назад +1

      @@trevorchabot864 Crush the minority? I did not say that. On the contrat like any Québec nationalist I want the anglos to keep their historical rights such as English education. I dont want them to get ignored like Canada did and does to it's franco minorities all across the ciuntry

    • @trevorchabot864
      @trevorchabot864 14 дней назад

      @@fs400ion collective rights are the excuse Quebec uses to discriminate. Some people are more equal than others, in Quebec.

    • @Tjd1982
      @Tjd1982 13 дней назад

      ​@@fs400ionMaybe Quebec should be officially bilingual, like NB.

    • @fs400ion
      @fs400ion 13 дней назад +1

      @@Tjd1982 I dont see why only the French speaking provinces should be bilingual. This Will only lead to French being optional in a French speaking nation, which is a non-sens

  • @jean-philippeemond7638
    @jean-philippeemond7638 15 дней назад +4

    I love to hear what english quebecer think about our society!
    Keep up with that window in our ecosystem!
    Thank you!

    • @hexhex7220
      @hexhex7220 15 дней назад

      sarcasm...the prattling of an inferior mind

  • @VLQL-s2g
    @VLQL-s2g 15 дней назад +15

    VIVE LE QUÉBEC LIBRE 💙

    • @MattFrame
      @MattFrame 13 дней назад

      Long live a free Quebec; free to choose (as it has done twice already) to remain part of a strong, vibrant, bilingual Canada! Canada is a godsend to Quebec, and for this great country, we are grateful and blessed!

  • @rboisvert2175
    @rboisvert2175 15 дней назад +7

    Start printing your own money, stamps, build a coast guard and army, post office and leave the First Nation people alone

    • @davemcd9077
      @davemcd9077 10 дней назад

      lol...'build a coast guard and army'?...ya mena ya don't realize the 'Canadian' military is primarily Kebekers ALREADY? (

    • @Willsmith547
      @Willsmith547 Час назад

      The army is already ours even the name canada originally refers to the french of Quebec 😂😂😂 we even make the canadian anthem and produce all the maple syrup and made the canadian national dish😂😂😂😂 English are just low grade American you have absolutely nothing for you😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @yveslorange2689
    @yveslorange2689 15 дней назад +3

    with 5% of francos voting for the liberal the party is now a loobist west island group no longer a nationale party in québec

  • @Bobkanada
    @Bobkanada 15 дней назад +2

    Great podcast again! Well done Corner Booth. And a great debate. Antoine Dionne Charest is a very smart individual. He is going somewhere. The future of the Liberal Party or a new Quebec Provincial party? I would support this guy.

  • @Habebandebardown
    @Habebandebardown 12 дней назад

    I dont get how hard they are on him, this guy is the most federalist and on the same side as them in any french media

  • @yveslorange2689
    @yveslorange2689 15 дней назад +2

    well all party in quebec refuse to sign the canadian constitution because its suck

  • @tonyblundeto4000
    @tonyblundeto4000 5 дней назад

    Really great to have an interview in a noisy room where you hear chatter and over the guest. Professional at works here.

  • @gabycesari7799
    @gabycesari7799 15 дней назад +3

    Ouch...the federal and provincial liberals are to blame for the English demise in quebec😢

    • @yveslorange2689
      @yveslorange2689 15 дней назад

      blame no way José bravo for once the do something right

    • @trevorchabot864
      @trevorchabot864 14 дней назад

      @@yveslorange2689 poor old Yves The Orange.

  • @ianhowes8141
    @ianhowes8141 12 дней назад +2

    Would not make any difference - we are already divided! The rest of the country should just stop paying for Quebec's folly!

    • @Willsmith547
      @Willsmith547 Час назад

      Why English don’t leave Quebec before 😂😂😂😂

  • @user-ku3wp3bj1e
    @user-ku3wp3bj1e 15 дней назад +1

    My opinion of the liberal party declined and the interim leader, like most of the party are separatists in sheep's clothing

  • @gailg2327
    @gailg2327 14 дней назад +1

    It’s insulting!

  • @trainglen22
    @trainglen22 7 дней назад

    Curious that the Liberal party of Quebec is really the island of Montreal Liberal party.

  • @martinemjt
    @martinemjt 15 дней назад +1

    go duhaime go! that s going to unify quebeckers. dealing with real issues!

  • @robinanddaviddavies8317
    @robinanddaviddavies8317 15 дней назад +1

    I admit I live south of the border (Georgia, state mot country) Silly me, I thought you were Canadian.

  • @Tjd1982
    @Tjd1982 13 дней назад +1

    Good bye equalization payments.

    • @Habebandebardown
      @Habebandebardown 12 дней назад

      Keep them its ok

    • @ianleslie6971
      @ianleslie6971 8 дней назад

      ​@Habebandebardown tell that to your own politicians who are always demanding more money 😂 Both hands out.

  • @d.wmjoseph2506
    @d.wmjoseph2506 12 дней назад

    Real Talk: Quebecois Sovereignty will never happen unless and until the overriding Indigenous Sovereignty issues can be resolved. s.25 & 35 of the Charter is clear that Aboriginal rights pre-empt almost all other Rights in Canada and in Quebec

  • @Digorysmallz
    @Digorysmallz 15 дней назад +2

    This Antoine guy is so far off the real issues. The rights of minorities in Canada are firmly held up across Canada, more so than most countries in the world. No need for another constitution unless you're gonna separate.

    • @bobby5678-ck2tc
      @bobby5678-ck2tc 14 дней назад

      We French Canadians are also considered a minority so i have no clue why he is crying about this anyways.

    • @Habebandebardown
      @Habebandebardown 12 дней назад

      Maybe because separation is the inevitavle logical step?

  • @trevorchabot864
    @trevorchabot864 14 дней назад

    When Quebec comes up with healthy ideas, I'll consider healthy debate.

    • @trevorchabot864
      @trevorchabot864 14 дней назад

      After looking at Quebec's current charters, a Quebec Constitution would look something like this:
      1.1 [redacted]
      1.2[redacted]
      2.1[redacted]
      2.2[redacted]
      2.3[redacted]

  • @kopias
    @kopias 15 дней назад

    Audio is predictably awful. Why is this not recorded somewhere else?

  • @bobby5678-ck2tc
    @bobby5678-ck2tc 14 дней назад +3

    Always talking about minorities this is Quebec the majority rule over the minorities welcome to democracy where the majority rule. VIVRE LE QUEBEC LIBRE. Learn our language and assimilate to our culture or these conflicts will continue to happen most of us know how to speak English yet you guys will not learn our language we are a different culture than you anglo saxons.

  • @hexhex7220
    @hexhex7220 15 дней назад +2

    quebec constition? liberal party needs to quit wasting time with B...S...and get in the real game

    • @johnmavros7431
      @johnmavros7431 15 дней назад +1

      Don't trust them, time to let go!

  • @RockinJohnnyG
    @RockinJohnnyG 15 дней назад

    What happened to that place? It looks like a weird art gallery now.

  • @Marc_Gagne
    @Marc_Gagne 15 дней назад

    Does Robert Libman use Greshian Formula? He's not that young anymore.

  • @giovanydallaire3044
    @giovanydallaire3044 13 дней назад

    Les anglos qui vivent au Qc ne sont pas une minorité, l’ONU ne reconnaît pas la communauté anglophone comme étant une minorité.

  • @garyvalentine5923
    @garyvalentine5923 15 дней назад +7

    Stop acting like a country you are not, and start acting like a province in the country of Canada for god sakes.

    • @johnmavros7431
      @johnmavros7431 15 дней назад

      They like to play pretend.

    • @bobby5678-ck2tc
      @bobby5678-ck2tc 14 дней назад

      No thank you we will do that once you people learn how to speak French and abandon your language and become part of our culture or we will continue to have these conflicts either adopt to our culture or go to other provinces.

    • @Habebandebardown
      @Habebandebardown 12 дней назад

      We’ll know soon enough

  • @randtheman8636
    @randtheman8636 9 дней назад

    Backdoor separatism.

  • @cbalducc
    @cbalducc 15 дней назад

    Isn’t Charest a Francophone? He has no accent.

    • @lindabrouillette6765
      @lindabrouillette6765 15 дней назад

      So what is your point?

    • @davidpatry4195
      @davidpatry4195 15 дней назад +5

      he's been completly assimilated a long time ago.

    • @peg60606
      @peg60606 10 дней назад

      What about Charlotte Cardin? She's French but has no accent when she speaks English.