Strap in. I have theories. There was also a clone in a box at the beginning. That was a different clone. She didn't want current clone to end up like that, so she helped him escape. (Note Military Jeff has shorter hair as box clone is taken away.) Now, Military Jeff is trying to get back to normal life with his wife, but she's depressed about the escaped clone. Then Clone Jeff writes to her, and she writes back, and Military Husband Jeff sees them. He goes off by himself. She shows up, and he confronts her and then cries on her (bonfire scene). Later, we see Clone Jeff come back passing Military Jeff's grave (confirming that this takes place in the future. The dates are 2054 - 2143.) New pictures on the wall. She's old now too. He stats with her until she dies and then buries her too. He doesn't age cause he's a clone. A yellow leaf is a dead leaf. And now all he has is a mind full of memories... ghosts, as he goes on by himself. Those are my thoughts, anyway. Also, JEFF WHAT THE HELL???!!!
Generally, I don't get emotional watching mvs, but this one made me cry when I saw it for the first time. I was waiting for Roscoe's reaction cuz I knew it's worth every second
I can tell a clone by his earring. There's no earring in the fight by the fire scene, so I think it's her husband being jealous of the clone. He returned home, hung the uniform in the closet (= I won't leave you anywhere again), the clone project was closed (clone body parts in boxes, people taking something out of their house). I feel like when her hair is in a ponytail, it's a sign that she can't fully express her feelings. But then she still accepts her feelings. I think she loved both. She corresponds with the clone and keeps a wooden ring, but even after her husband’s death there is a metal ring on her hand. And I like to imagine that this song about endless love could be sung by any of the three of them. Of course, in the video a clone sings her, but her husband loves her and she loves them. Maybe someday Jeff will record another version from her husband's point of view or we'll hear a female version. The versions of Dum Dum and Why do you stay were so good. And yes, Jeff's acting is mesmerizing 😍 (God, I want a big picture with all the frames on the stairs. One - with an astronaut suit. But nothing else can be seen. Knowing Jeff's love for detail, I think there's still a lot to unearth there.)
I also noticed the earring this time through. I went back and watched ghost and yellow leaf with that in mind and I feel like I was able to follow the story more clearly.
The way I am here for Roscoe reacting to Jeff and him screaming "Oh Shut Up" got me so good. The feet kicking over the parallels are so valid. He is SO good. The hand to chest is also too relatable, Roscoe. In Ghost she was married to the astronaut (silver metal ring), husband went off to space, she saved the clone and took him to the house, they eventually fell in love he braided the vine ring and gave it to her in their "wedding". Then when the original husband came back he was trying to put the experiment back in the box, so to speak, and she turned the clone loose. I was reading her "fireball fridaying" with her astronaut back. Like she's mad, she blames him for the clone being gone. This mostly felt like her life with her astronaut husband (her first husband, since she married the clone with the vine ring and blindfold 'ceremony') while the clone is out in the world. Agreed she was writing letters to the clone, and the husband was mad (glaring through doors etc). When the clone comes back the husband is already dead, and the wife is now passing, so he holds her hand eventually buries her before riding off again.
In my opinion when they're by the fire on the couch that is her husband, not the clone. She is exchanging letters with the clone and her husband sees it (when he's peeking through the door) and so when they're by the fire and he looks at her he feels that their relationship is changed, maybe she still loves him but not in the same way and I think he sort of blames himself because that's his fault in the end since he """gave""" her the clone. This music video is so so SO BEAUTIFUL it makes me cry every single time, Jeff is so talented 🤧
Roscoe, friend, you’re just like me while watching Jeff’s vids and creating bad theories 😂 Love it! Thank you soooo much for all your vids. The fact that you truly appreciate Jeff’s capabilities not only as a singer, but as an actor warms my heart. Thanks man! You’re amazing 😃👍 Keep reacting to Jeff! Sats appreciate your service! 😉🫶🏼
clone : 4 connectors on back, seen with horse, wearing white shirt, black gilet, black coat and top hat, live in barn. human jeff : military uniform(remember he put the military coat and the tie into the closet in one of the scenes then change to white puffy shirt), white puffy shirt, tie, no horse, live in house. (seen spying on wife, drinking heavily and arguing with her in the campfire.) pretty easy to differentiate.
Loved this story line. At the end of Ghost they came to collect the clone. But she was attached already and freed him. She loved the clone which is why she kept the vine ring. His voice is just ethereal. I knew you were gonna lose it. DAMMIT JEFF
It's the clone that combes back, the ring is the selfmade one because she took of the metal one she got from her husband. The one looking at her at the fire is her husband, not knowing what to do because she is unhappy and drinking. The picture is the one of the wedding of the clone and the selfmade ring. The husband doesn't have the things in the back...
It's the husband in front of the bon fire. He is in the front yard burning the flower arch from their wedding. the picture was hitting at the arch. He burned it in anger.
Dude - that’s not the clone you’re talking about. The one with her throughout the video is the real husband. (Yes, the husband is dead by the end of the video, as she dies by the video.) Look at the dates. The husband died at 89 years old. They lived their life together. She loves her husband AND the clone. That was the husband by the bonfire. Easy way to differentiate - Barn or Horse in the image is the clone. Everything else is husband. (BTW that’s HER in the astronaut picture on the wall.)
Haven't spotted her picture on the wall. That adds even more depths to the whole story. So it means there could be a lot of subtle details yet to see in both, I mean Ghost and Yellow Leaf
I personally I think it's more like a literal continuation of ghost, where she goes back to live with Og Jeff, but she doesn't feel the same way towards him, but she fell in love with the clone, because even with the same face they are not the same, (because I believe that we fall in love with the person not how they look) and that Og Jeff realizes that the relationship that he and she had can not be the same as when he left and left the clone to replace him, no matter how hard he tries to make everything look like it was before he left, and that she seeing Og Jeff desperate decides to stay with him but always thinking and waiting for the clone Jeff. thanks always for reacting to Jeff with such enthusiasm
I have also been waiting for your reaction, thank you! So many theories…Is it a clone or a robot? 😮 There were comments on “Ghost” about the horse in the house. My theory is that the horse is just like 2nd Jeff not quite human and that’s why it was in the house. And still with him to the end. Someone should ask him at his concert clone or robot that are taking place now in Asia after he sings “Ghost” and “Yellow Leaf” Go Sats! I would love to see your reaction to Jeff’s MV announcement of his Asia Tour named “Space Shuttle No. 8” It is a masterpiece as well. And his first album was released on Feb 8 same as the MV “Yellow Leaf”. Although no MV check out “Almost Over You” it is in English. It is addictive.
My theory is that the husband die and become a ghost that came alive and visit her not a clone. She in ghost liberate him but they continue to have contact until she die.
This experimental is a transfer the memory to the clone to another clone and another clone and she is a staff of this project that know after the experiment the clone will be kill and she help some of them back home and give him love .
I watched all the videos where you reacted to jeff satur's music. Your videos were very good. If possible, I hope you will try reacting to the music group 4mix.
My theory: the stool between them with a photo was a representation of a baby she lost which is why by the fire his head is on her belly. And I also think since letters were so delayed, he was dead by the time she got it.
The military one went out to space. He created the clone one to leave with the wife, to leave his life, get married (metal ring) and everything that military one should do while on earth. Time pass, the clone started to have the feeling for her (the hand made ring) and she also had tge feeling for the clone. The military came back. The clone gone leaving in the barn but kept contact to the wife via letters. The military upset cuz he thought that the created clone would only be only his representative but not the feeling. When the military passed away. The wife told the clone via the last letter. The clone came to say goddbye and sent her to heaven for the last time. End
The story behind this mv is that the husband realises in the first mv that he's starting to lose her, so he stops working in the military and comes home. He starts to become a husband to her, but she's in love with the clone and keeps her distance from the husband. She writes letters to the clone. The husband can't figure out why she's so distant and think she's having an affair with someone. He confronts her, they have a fight and then she tries to forget the clone and fulfills her role as a wife until the husband dies Meanwhile the clone never ages, he returns when she's old and stays with her until she passes away and moves on
Idk if you’ll read this but anyway I think The husband travels by that space shuttle (maybe somewhere bla bla) and leaves a clone for her. Now the clone is doing his job to serve her. She loves her husband but because her husband is not there she gets swept away in the emotions and her venerability and slowly falls in love with “THE GHOST OR CLONE “whatever you may call it... Under the influence of alcohol, she does these with his ghost but when she gets a little sober the light falls on the clone giving her again a reality check that hey he is just a clone and not him. The husband must have installed a secret chip in his processor to monitor what happened in his absence. ( then he might have seen it and got angry but didn't want her to know that he knew about the secret recording. So he just patted his face in that shot. Because his anger was still there he captured the clone by saying something like his job is done now so no need for him to hear this she might have felt scared and pitiful seeing the clone's condition so she freed him and sent him away. But he keeps coming back on horse secretly. Then there are two sets First: she became old with age but because his husband had space traveled his age had stopped just that that Hollywood movie where the actor goes to space and every second on earth is yrs but in space it was only a few minutes. So he is still the same age as he left Earth. Second is maybe the original military Jeff died as there were written JS initials on cross JS- Jeff Satur and year. So the clone has fully taken over his husband's place and because he’s close he didn't age but she did. That's why the clone put the wedding photo of the real one and that together I'm the sand
Jeff with earing and hold on his back is AI OG Jeff is more short hair and silver ring I feel real sad with Og Jeff. He do not thing wrong. But when he arrrive and take his suit in closet (that mean he will never go anywhere again). He found his belove wife love that AI not him anymore(she keep the pic and wood ring till her die) I need 1 more MV from Jeff to represent Og Jeff Ghost is represent the wife Yellow leaf is represent Al Jeff
Strap in. I have theories. There was also a clone in a box at the beginning. That was a different clone. She didn't want current clone to end up like that, so she helped him escape. (Note Military Jeff has shorter hair as box clone is taken away.) Now, Military Jeff is trying to get back to normal life with his wife, but she's depressed about the escaped clone. Then Clone Jeff writes to her, and she writes back, and Military Husband Jeff sees them. He goes off by himself. She shows up, and he confronts her and then cries on her (bonfire scene). Later, we see Clone Jeff come back passing Military Jeff's grave (confirming that this takes place in the future. The dates are 2054 - 2143.) New pictures on the wall. She's old now too. He stats with her until she dies and then buries her too. He doesn't age cause he's a clone. A yellow leaf is a dead leaf. And now all he has is a mind full of memories... ghosts, as he goes on by himself. Those are my thoughts, anyway. Also, JEFF WHAT THE HELL???!!!
I also had this EXACT thought!
0:27 คือโครน อีกตัวที่นางเอกใช้เพื่อหลอกวางตาย แต่ความจริงคือปล่อยไป
นางเอกและโครน ตกหลุดรักันแลกัน และแต่งงานกัน
2:28 สามีของนางต้องการคำอธิภาพจากรูปภาพนี้ (ภาพแต่งงาน)
2:38 พวกเขาทะเลาะกัน เพราะความผิดพลาด ของพวกเขา
2:50 พวกเขาปรับความเข้าใจกัน อภัยให้กันและจะอยู่ด้วยกันจนตาย (แต่หัวใจนางเอกให้โครนไปแล้ว)
ทุกสิ่งคืออดีต ตั้งแต่จากเพลงที่จนถึง วินาทีที่เข้ากลับมาบ้าน นั้นคือเวลาปัจจุบัน รอมานาน กว่าสามี จะตายสุดท้าย เธอก็ลาจาก โครนจึงกลายเป็น ผี อีกครั้ง
พิมพ์ไทยยังผิด ทรานเสรด มันจะแปลรู้เรื่องไหม สภาพ
I don't know why... I watch his mv 10 time and i cry all 10 time. It must be his acting, his very sad smile in the end, make my heart broken.
Generally, I don't get emotional watching mvs, but this one made me cry when I saw it for the first time. I was waiting for Roscoe's reaction cuz I knew it's worth every second
I can tell a clone by his earring. There's no earring in the fight by the fire scene, so I think it's her husband being jealous of the clone.
He returned home, hung the uniform in the closet (= I won't leave you anywhere again), the clone project was closed (clone body parts in boxes, people taking something out of their house).
I feel like when her hair is in a ponytail, it's a sign that she can't fully express her feelings. But then she still accepts her feelings.
I think she loved both. She corresponds with the clone and keeps a wooden ring, but even after her husband’s death there is a metal ring on her hand.
And I like to imagine that this song about endless love could be sung by any of the three of them. Of course, in the video a clone sings her, but her husband loves her and she loves them. Maybe someday Jeff will record another version from her husband's point of view or we'll hear a female version. The versions of Dum Dum and Why do you stay were so good.
And yes, Jeff's acting is mesmerizing 😍
(God, I want a big picture with all the frames on the stairs. One - with an astronaut suit. But nothing else can be seen. Knowing Jeff's love for detail, I think there's still a lot to unearth there.)
I also noticed the earring this time through. I went back and watched ghost and yellow leaf with that in mind and I feel like I was able to follow the story more clearly.
Jeff's voice (melts) Love the story he told with both MVs, ah my heart!
mmm love me some Jeff
เพลงนี้เพราะและซึ้งมาก ฉันฟังทีไรน้ำตาก็ไหลทุกครั้งเลย ดีใจมากที่คุณก็ชอบเจฟเหมือนกัน ฉันภูมิใจในความสามารถเจฟมาก
I love your Jeff reactions they’re my favourite. Seeing you get so excited about his music & mv’s is the best. 💛🖤
The way I am here for Roscoe reacting to Jeff and him screaming "Oh Shut Up" got me so good. The feet kicking over the parallels are so valid. He is SO good. The hand to chest is also too relatable, Roscoe. In Ghost she was married to the astronaut (silver metal ring), husband went off to space, she saved the clone and took him to the house, they eventually fell in love he braided the vine ring and gave it to her in their "wedding". Then when the original husband came back he was trying to put the experiment back in the box, so to speak, and she turned the clone loose. I was reading her "fireball fridaying" with her astronaut back. Like she's mad, she blames him for the clone being gone. This mostly felt like her life with her astronaut husband (her first husband, since she married the clone with the vine ring and blindfold 'ceremony') while the clone is out in the world. Agreed she was writing letters to the clone, and the husband was mad (glaring through doors etc). When the clone comes back the husband is already dead, and the wife is now passing, so he holds her hand eventually buries her before riding off again.
In my opinion when they're by the fire on the couch that is her husband, not the clone. She is exchanging letters with the clone and her husband sees it (when he's peeking through the door) and so when they're by the fire and he looks at her he feels that their relationship is changed, maybe she still loves him but not in the same way and I think he sort of blames himself because that's his fault in the end since he """gave""" her the clone.
This music video is so so SO BEAUTIFUL it makes me cry every single time, Jeff is so talented 🤧
jeff is just brilliant
I love when everyone want to explaining it. 😅
Your reaction for "Yellow Leaf" is what I'm waiting for. 😄
The voice of an Angel 😇 ❤❤❤
Roscoe, friend, you’re just like me while watching Jeff’s vids and creating bad theories 😂 Love it!
Thank you soooo much for all your vids.
The fact that you truly appreciate Jeff’s capabilities not only as a singer, but as an actor warms my heart.
Thanks man! You’re amazing 😃👍
Keep reacting to Jeff! Sats appreciate your service! 😉🫶🏼
clone : 4 connectors on back, seen with horse, wearing white shirt, black gilet, black coat and top hat, live in barn.
human jeff : military uniform(remember he put the military coat and the tie into the closet in one of the scenes then change to white puffy shirt), white puffy shirt, tie, no horse, live in house. (seen spying on wife, drinking heavily and arguing with her in the campfire.)
pretty easy to differentiate.
He is sooooooo good Jeff
Loved this story line. At the end of Ghost they came to collect the clone. But she was attached already and freed him.
She loved the clone which is why she kept the vine ring. His voice is just ethereal. I knew you were gonna lose it. DAMMIT JEFF
It's the clone that combes back, the ring is the selfmade one because she took of the metal one she got from her husband. The one looking at her at the fire is her husband, not knowing what to do because she is unhappy and drinking. The picture is the one of the wedding of the clone and the selfmade ring. The husband doesn't have the things in the back...
It's the husband in front of the bon fire. He is in the front yard burning the flower arch from their wedding. the picture was hitting at the arch. He burned it in anger.
Dude - that’s not the clone you’re talking about. The one with her throughout the video is the real husband. (Yes, the husband is dead by the end of the video, as she dies by the video.) Look at the dates. The husband died at 89 years old. They lived their life together. She loves her husband AND the clone. That was the husband by the bonfire. Easy way to differentiate - Barn or Horse in the image is the clone. Everything else is husband. (BTW that’s HER in the astronaut picture on the wall.)
Haven't spotted her picture on the wall. That adds even more depths to the whole story. So it means there could be a lot of subtle details yet to see in both, I mean Ghost and Yellow Leaf
All the songs in his album is connected like a novel series ❤
I personally I think it's more like a literal continuation of ghost, where she goes back to live with Og Jeff, but she doesn't feel the same way towards him, but she fell in love with the clone, because even with the same face they are not the same, (because I believe that we fall in love with the person not how they look) and that Og Jeff realizes that the relationship that he and she had can not be the same as when he left and left the clone to replace him, no matter how hard he tries to make everything look like it was before he left, and that she seeing Og Jeff desperate decides to stay with him but always thinking and waiting for the clone Jeff.
thanks always for reacting to Jeff with such enthusiasm
Me encantan sus análisis de este hombre, la verdad hasta nosotros sus fans quedamos bien fascinados , Jeff es un artista que tiene mucha potencia ❤
Jeff❤️🔥
I like you try to think theory for this story. Thank you 🙏
I have also been waiting for your reaction, thank you! So many theories…Is it a clone or a robot? 😮 There were comments on “Ghost” about the horse in the house. My theory is that the horse is just like 2nd Jeff not quite human and that’s why it was in the house. And still with him to the end. Someone should ask him at his concert clone or robot that are taking place now in Asia after he sings “Ghost” and “Yellow Leaf” Go Sats! I would love to see your reaction to Jeff’s MV announcement of his Asia Tour named “Space Shuttle No. 8” It is a masterpiece as well. And his first album was released on Feb 8 same as the MV “Yellow Leaf”. Although no MV check out “Almost Over You” it is in English. It is addictive.
My theory is that the husband die and become a ghost that came alive and visit her not a clone. She in ghost liberate him but they continue to have contact until she die.
Love your reaction brother❤
Jeff said "that" not clone but AI (robot) with high tech
Oh, that makes sense. The clone would, in theory, also age.
Thank you!🙏
I love your inner reaction•
thanks you for this good reaction,i did wait for this❤
This experimental is a transfer the memory to the clone to another clone and another clone and she is a staff of this project that know after the experiment the clone will be kill and she help some of them back home and give him love .
The clone is not aging, but she is 😢
He's not a clone, he's an AI.
I watched all the videos where you reacted to jeff satur's music. Your videos were very good. If possible, I hope you will try reacting to the music group 4mix.
My theory: the stool between them with a photo was a representation of a baby she lost which is why by the fire his head is on her belly. And I also think since letters were so delayed, he was dead by the time she got it.
Clone =ghost
Flashing back and forth between past and ghost waiting for her to join him in death
He is a ghost not a clone. This is an after life love.
I only used the word "clone" to communicate which version of him I was referring to, same as Roscoe had@@auroracalderon5308
The military one went out to space. He created the clone one to leave with the wife, to leave his life, get married (metal ring) and everything that military one should do while on earth. Time pass, the clone started to have the feeling for her (the hand made ring) and she also had tge feeling for the clone.
The military came back. The clone gone leaving in the barn but kept contact to the wife via letters. The military upset cuz he thought that the created clone would only be only his representative but not the feeling.
When the military passed away. The wife told the clone via the last letter. The clone came to say goddbye and sent her to heaven for the last time.
End
The story behind this mv is that the husband realises in the first mv that he's starting to lose her, so he stops working in the military and comes home. He starts to become a husband to her, but she's in love with the clone and keeps her distance from the husband. She writes letters to the clone.
The husband can't figure out why she's so distant and think she's having an affair with someone.
He confronts her, they have a fight and then she tries to forget the clone and fulfills her role as a wife until the husband dies
Meanwhile the clone never ages, he returns when she's old and stays with her until she passes away and moves on
Yellow leaf/ Gosth / Lucid.... I do think the 3 songs are a story.
I think that is why the Female is present on the 3 songs.
💜💜
❤❤❤❤❤❤
Idk if you’ll read this but anyway I think
The husband travels by that space shuttle (maybe somewhere bla bla) and leaves a clone for her. Now the clone is doing his job to serve her. She loves her husband but because her husband is not there she gets swept away in the emotions and her venerability and slowly falls in love with “THE GHOST OR CLONE “whatever you may call it... Under the influence of alcohol, she does these with his ghost but when she gets a little sober the light falls on the clone giving her again a reality check that hey he is just a clone and not him. The husband must have installed a secret chip in his processor to monitor what happened in his absence. ( then he might have seen it and got angry but didn't want her to know that he knew about the secret recording. So he just patted his face in that shot. Because his anger was still there he captured the clone by saying something like his job is done now so no need for him to hear this she might have felt scared and pitiful seeing the clone's condition so she freed him and sent him away. But he keeps coming back on horse secretly.
Then there are two sets
First: she became old with age but because his husband had space traveled his age had stopped just that that Hollywood movie where the actor goes to space and every second on earth is yrs but in space it was only a few minutes. So he is still the same age as he left Earth.
Second is maybe the original military Jeff died as there were written JS initials on cross JS- Jeff Satur and year. So the clone has fully taken over his husband's place and because he’s close he didn't age but she did. That's why the clone put the wedding photo of the real one and that together I'm the sand
how come the clone didn't age at all? is he an andriod?
Jeff with earing and hold on his back is AI
OG Jeff is more short hair and silver ring
I feel real sad with Og Jeff. He do not thing wrong. But when he arrrive and take his suit in closet (that mean he will never go anywhere again). He found his belove wife love that AI not him anymore(she keep the pic and wood ring till her die)
I need 1 more MV from Jeff to represent Og Jeff
Ghost is represent the wife
Yellow leaf is represent Al Jeff
It is related to the previous video A Story Jeff Satur - ซ่อน (ไม่) หา l Ghost【Official Music Video】 ruclips.net/video/qguo-j5PxBE/видео.html
Husband doesn't wear earrings. The AI (cloning)wears earrings.