Entertaining but British people and anyone who knows anything about WWII might be offended since it was the British that did this America entered the war after the code was already broken
As a British Submariner I find the film tense and exciting. However to have no acknowledgment of the truth is just disgraceful. I thought when it came out at the cinema originally there was a statement of fact.
I love how there was no enemy destroyer on the surface waiting for the disabled U-boat even though there was one depth charging them just minutes ago...
@BROCKATRON That makes no sense. The depth charges literally cripples the sub, kills the engineers and then blows the tanks within a matter of minutes. How on earth did it take hours for that to happen when we just saw it happen?
@BROCKATRON That is not true - in the movie it was pitch dark during their attack on the marchant ship. We can literally see the captain give the order to surface(you can hear it in german and the english subtitles are actually correct for that part, they only miss the sentence in which he orders flank speed ahead) and he never reverses it. Only logical to assume they surfaced immediately.
@@lukeheigle494 In one of the scenes later on we can see the officers during the briefing on the american submarine talking how "a british destroyer reported sinking a submarine". You can see that scene in the clip number 3 from this movie on movieclips channel.
I think the aspect at play here is rising from 120m and how offset that may bring you from a target right above you. This is later described in the movie while they are attempting to evade and eventually sink a German destroyer by surfacing a good distance from the target while just minutes before, being right beneath it.
@@grantshouse9229 so what? It was made by Americans to make the English look bad as always in US media while Celtic people like Scottish and Irish are good people according to Hollywood. Examples are JAG season 2 episode 6 Trinity were the SAS are bad people and the US Navy and the IRA are good people. The Patriot were British are bad and burned a church with people inside.
The Allies already have the enigma machines, but you see, the way enigma is designed is that you cannot decode an engima message with the machine alone, you need a number as well, and the Germans communicating with each other have numbers pre-decided before so they know which numbers to displace the rotors on the enigma machine to decode their messages with each other. That's why the british have departments dedicated to cracking enigma messages, they have to check all those numbers for which one is the valid to decode the messages.
Would you like to know about and infinitely better movie. A movie that is actually based on a true story, has a life like feel to it, more drama, doesn’t glorify war and neither aims to bastardize the enemy or promote their faction, all the while proving that there were good men trying to survive on the other side of the war. This movie is Das Boot
@@networkengineer2734 Only the explosions underneath the boat are really dangerous because the force of the explosion is straight upwards due to water pressure.
Jep in such a severe fire it would be better to let the diesel compartment sealed so it wont get air. And the next thing is how should it even cach fire in the first place ? Its diesel thats hard to ignite you can even dump a match in a bucket full of it and it wont ignite. Most fires on a uboat where electric fires and batery explosions because a batery produces hydrogene while charcing which needs to be vented if salt water gets into a batery it would get shrotcircuit and could ignite the hydrogene in it.
thanks for the reply, i did watch the clip again more carefully and i think the guy is repeating "depth is set" or whatever he says is right after "depth is set" cause i don't hear "vorne" anywhere so we might be talking about a different time, thank you though,i appreciate it.
The destroyer was with a convoy. They had to keep moving with it. Later in the movie they state how the destoryer reported sinking the U-571, so they probally got out of there fast. Takes a while for those submarines to rise and they move with the current, as well.
Kriegsmarine... Luftwaffe Kriegsmarine... Luftwaffe ...Luftwaffe. I'd rather die crashing to the ground in a fireball than being drowned, burned, or crushed to death in an underwater tin can.
It is historically inaccurate. But at least all the Germans in this movie are actual Germans. That alone puts it one tier above most Hollywood war movies
I almost agree, but you are wrong about the worst crews. The soviets had the worst crews. Americans simply didn't have a good standing army when the war broke out, they were unprepared. They had a partially good surface fleet, but no u-boat experience. Americans learned they U-boat experience in the Pacific theater. But you are right, one should stick to watching Das Boot. You can learn much about submarine warfare from that movie alone.
After watching Das Boot, this looks horrible. So much more space on that boat! But, I respect the filmmakers and actors. Even if it’s not a good film from a naval standpoint.
Im American and I hate this movie also. I liked the German actors and did not like the American actors. War is War , either you or them but the story flow was just to high and mighty.
shirl woolf Im American and I love this movie also. I liked the American actors and did not like the German actors. War is War, either you or them but the story flows was just to high and mighty.
thats all right, everyone to their own. I happen to like the story flow to foreign movies. I think the german actor Kretschner? was great. I also love American war movies like The Big Red ONE with Lee Marvin.Great story flow. I also ( DOG ) love many military american movies but I also like other movies like Stalingrad (german) , The Black Book etc..( which happens to be Dutch)? Why worry over who likes or doesn't like a movie, that is what makes us unique. Happy for you that you like this movie as many people do…..shirl
are they trying to rip off "Das Boot"? which was based on the book written by an actual former German reporter who was actually in a submarine during WWII
Great movie, but disturbingly inaccurate considering all credit should go to the British. And it's still not as good as Das Boot. Ah well....enjoy it for what it is.
@@pasnthr6251 For those crew members of HMS Bulldog it was an insult. But hey, the same as "The Patriot", the Americans are great at distorting historical facts.
This is why I look up movies, for the comments. I've learned more about WWII Naval history in three minutes than most movies. I seriously wish all countries would be historically & factually accurate, but this would be delusional to think most movies are accurate. We are talking, in this case Hollywood. This is another reason to check comment sections & if truly interesting fact check certain comments. Sometimes you can find some real pearls. Other times it's like an unexplored mine field.
U-Boots ran on diesel when in surface when underwater it ran on electrical so it should be fire in this scene i hate this movie so many fakes like when americans attack U-Boot VIIC have 30 seconds to dive in alarm mode and next 30 to dive to 60m but Americans attack this U-Boot 2 or even 3 minutes german gave alarm dive on begening of the attack or when German destroyer attack U-Boot with americans german officers was not stupid like in this movie they would sink u-boot at very beggining when they show thats americans and next stupid thing when U-Boot shot torpedo to destroyer they just shot no any information about torpedo deepth, speed or bearings thy just screems fire or we die omg so stupid and the last thing Enigma its totaly fake Enigma was first decoded by three Polish cryptologists, Marian Rejewski, Jerzy Różycki and Henryk Zygalski in 1932 after german upgrade Enigma Polish works with British and French to decoded Enigma again USA never get Enigma or decoded it you should watch Das Boot great movie especialy long 5 hours version Uncut
You're right. Diesel fuel. Good luck getting it to ignite. You'd need a torch to get it to burn. They did that on Terminator 2 as well. No way a spark from a battery cable would ignite the truck's diesel fuel.
Wait a goddamn minute they had a destroyer dropping depth charges on them and less than a minute later the german captain orders all ballast tanks blown and then they surface and the destroyer is suddenly vanished ?? has this director even seen das boot ??
Ironically, if a depth charge exploded that close the sub, the ship would be torn apart, something that the original Das Boot got wrong, which this dumbass director copied.
im familiar with u boat terminology in german but at the beginning of the movie when the captain is making final arrangements to fire torpedos one of the helmsmen replies back something to the effect of "folum drily" (this is how it sounds to me, i know its not correct) and i was wondering what that meant,if you have seen the movie as many times as i have you will know exactly what i'm talking about, its not translated into the subtitles, they missed it,maybe someone out there knows, thanks.
Doğukan Kaya What?? That's not true.....did u not see the under water battle scene with the other u-boat......both were clearly steering left and right to aim torpedoes at eachother.....Did u not hear what the German mechanic said at the beginning of the movie....."we have enough battery power to dive and maybe manoeuvre around a bit"........
Doğukan Kaya That doesn't make any sense at all, the Diesel engine and battery power operates the turbines/propellers...... the use of the rudder or elevator planes is not determined by its power source......All they have to do is turn the helm to steer left and right, which I've seen them do many times in other movies while underwater.....
This movie is another of the many scoundrels of the US and Hollywood. The real action, which took place in May 1941, was carried out by an English, not American, command as it appears in this film, among other reasons, because at that time the United States had not yet entered the war. In the book on which the film of Russell Crowe is based, The Farthest Coast, the pirate ship against which the English fight is not French, is American. American political propaganda has no scruples about misrepresenting history, and adulterating literature, when this suits their political interests. On numerous occasions the US has fabricated "incidents" to justify their invasions or their bombings, false indeed. This has been revealed by their own documents once they were declassified.
It is a personal opinion of David Balme, but Tony Blair was very offend for this historical falsification, and in general the English must feel offended in his pride because the heroism of his soldiers who carried out this operation was silenced. Americans are arrogants as Roman emperors, and they have no scruples about lying when it suits to their political interests. It is not the first time that they falsify the story by adulterating the original books. In the film of Russell Crowe “The farthest coast”, the pirate ship is French, but in the original text it is American. Maybe the truth is "politically inconvenient".
It is so amazing to me that we are blessed with so many submarine warefare experts. Clearly I attended the wrong schools. Never even saw those classes on the list. Give it a rest experts. It’s called a movie. It is no more representative of reality than a CNN “news”cast. 😆
This is an entertaining movie, but I'm not crazy about the way they sensationalized it. That's the problem sometimes with Hollywood--they never let the truth get in the way of a good story.
On the one hand, I love this movie...on the other it's historically inaccurate....it was the Brits that captured a U-boat and it's Enigma device, not the US....but when has Hollywood ever let historical accuracy get in the way of telling a story?
The British captured U-110 in 1941, as mentioned in the closing credits. That was by chance. H.M.S Bulldog forced her to surface and was attempting to sink her. The captain gave the order to abandon the ship and the British ceased fire when they realized the German sailors wanted to surrender. The British sailors found her enigma machine and coding documents intact. They tried to tow the sub to port, but she sank along the way. The US navy captured U-505 (which is on display at a museum in Chicago) on June 4/1944, 2 days before D-Day. The Royal Canadian Navy captured U-744 in March 1944. There were 15 U-boats and their enigma machines captured altogether. All but 2 were captured by the Royal Navy.
@@baddriversofmoosejaw8681 That was HMS Bulldog. HMS Petard was one of five that captured U-559. Three of her sailors boarded and captured the codebooks. The machine and two of the sailors were lost with the boat.
@@pizzaplanettruck9761 I know. I read about that. As much as I love this movie, there are so many things wrong. That's Diesel fuel leaking from the pipes in the engine room. No way could some sparks ignite it and cause an inferno. Diesel does burn, but it's very difficult to ignite. The destroyer would've been waiting for them when they surfaced. Not long gone. And it either would've sunk the boat, or captured it, along with the enigma and codebooks. Almost every sailor on U-boats and ships of other navies are trained to be able to maintain the ship, so the idea of the U-boat's engine crew being dead would leave it stranded with no one that can fix the Diesel engines is false. The S-33 never operated in the Atlantic. Only the Pacific and it only saw action against the Japanese. It was never sunk. It was later scrapped after the war. No way could less than 10 men operate a U-boat. You need at least 44 to operate a Type VII. Tank wouldn't have been able to fix the Diesel. It's a different design than American ones and he wouldn't have training in that. Resupply U-boats didn't have torpedo tubes or even deck guns. Just AA guns, so the resupply U-boat would've radioed for help when they saw what was happening. They needed space for transporting supplies and fuel and also for bakeries. The idea of a German destroyer being that far west all by itself is ridiculous. The Royal Navy was the biggest in the world back then, until late in the war anyway, and even the Bismarck never made it that far west. The Kriegsmarine only built 31 destroyers and after the Bismarck was sunk, German surface ships rarely left port. They just didn't have the time needed to build a surface fleet that could challenge the Royal Navy. They could've started building one before the war, but it wouldn't have been ready until 1948, since it was ordered in 1939 and was shelved shortly after the war began. That and German reconnaissance planes didn't have the range to fly halfway across the North Atlantic and make it back to France or Germany. Even their bombers couldn't fly that far. The Germans didn't have SONAR/Asdic like the British. The closest they had was Hydrophones, which were all that was available in World War I. A single torpedo will damage a destroyer, but won't sink it. Not a chance. The Polish had already captured Enigma machines and coding documents and turned them over to the Allies before the war. That and we know that the Royal Navy had already captured some by 1941. Also, Karl Donitz, who was the micromanaging type, compromised his own security by having the U-boats send daily messages, whether there was anything important to report or not and the Allies were able to trace the signals and easily locate and destroy them, especially by 1943, when Radar advanced enough that even B-24s were equipped with it and could still find them at night and in bad weather. That and the British having the Huff-Duff, so they could trace the signal's position, even if they didn't know what they were saying. The Germans had some suspicion that their codes had been compromised, but never did quite catch on and thus never changed them.
To me this movie was an attempt to introduce American audiences to the German U-boats. However the marketing department said to the director "we have to have Americans in the German Submarine otherwise American audiences won't go and see it because they don't want to watch a film in which the 'bad guys' are the main characters"
I agree with your comment the most. US Audiences are racist & dim-witted. They can't read fast enough for Subtitles. They hate all & any historical accuracy due to their incompetence & shame in war tactics. And their country was founded on the principles of theft, torture, death & lies.
I don't believe I argued to the contrary? But America take pride in War, & that just offends the rest of the world. It's like if Germany was proud of National Socialism. The Americans *stole* the land from the indigenous population, slaughtered everyone & everything in sight, & then put up signs saying "Thou Shall Not Steal" & re-wrote the history books out of shame.
Every person, every nation, every grain of sand is different. We are all affected by our environment. And the mere fact that kids are brought up around Guns obviously has a completely different effect compared with those who shall never fire a weapon. The US also spends more on "Defense" than the next 7 highest spenders *combined* It has the highest crime rates, highest drug overdoses, highest rate of homelessness, corruption, highest prison population, etc. They also overwork people, & as a result have less sleep than any other country in the world. Its no surprise the US is the 1st country where Net Neutrality is lost. "Love your Country"... even though they dumped 65 tons of nerve gas into the ocean off the coast of Miami. Now I'm not saying that other countries aren't guilty of the very same things. But I would say it is vital that we take note of our differences, & in that, the USA is the example of precise what NOT to be like. TL:DR: ruclips.net/video/u6LrqLaDOmU/видео.html
I’m watching this movie right now and I noticed a mistake in it, just before they go to attack the uboat the lieutenant takes off what is supposed to be his US Navy ring but it’s a US Army ring, ooops
I love these German WW2 u-boat scenes - very suspenseful and dramatic
I remember watching this when I was little I enjoyed it back then and I still enjoy it to this day
“Where's Fegelein!?”
“Mien Führer, he is now ze kapitan of U-571”
@Pizza Hahaha!!!
Yeah it’s Thomas Kretchsmann. He’s also the Umbrella Corp official in RE: Apocalypse.
I use this scene at 0 dB to test sound setups. The dynamic range in this scene alone (among the many) is monstrous.
Entertaining but British people and anyone who knows anything about WWII might be offended since it was the British that did this America entered the war after the code was already broken
Yeah...at least the combat scenes were authentic.
As a British Submariner I find the film tense and exciting. However to have no acknowledgment of the truth is just disgraceful. I thought when it came out at the cinema originally there was a statement of fact.
@@ianboorn4861 Apart from the text crawl at the end of the British version.
But this is a good depiction as to how dangerous working on a submarine is.
Man who cares
I love how there was no enemy destroyer on the surface waiting for the disabled U-boat even though there was one depth charging them just minutes ago...
@BROCKATRON That makes no sense. The depth charges literally cripples the sub, kills the engineers and then blows the tanks within a matter of minutes. How on earth did it take hours for that to happen when we just saw it happen?
Perhaps it was a plane?
@BROCKATRON That is not true - in the movie it was pitch dark during their attack on the marchant ship. We can literally see the captain give the order to surface(you can hear it in german and the english subtitles are actually correct for that part, they only miss the sentence in which he orders flank speed ahead) and he never reverses it. Only logical to assume they surfaced immediately.
@@lukeheigle494 In one of the scenes later on we can see the officers during the briefing on the american submarine talking how "a british destroyer reported sinking a submarine". You can see that scene in the clip number 3 from this movie on movieclips channel.
I think the aspect at play here is rising from 120m and how offset that may bring you from a target right above you.
This is later described in the movie while they are attempting to evade and eventually sink a German destroyer by surfacing a good distance from the target while just minutes before, being right beneath it.
LOL when i first watched Das Boot i comfused it with this movie
Don't you just love American historical films? Braveheart, The Patriot etc. "The Following is Based on a True Story. Only the Facts Have Been Changed"
Braveheart takes place in Scotland
Stoooppiidd
@@grantshouse9229 so what? It was made by Americans to make the English look bad as always in US media while Celtic people like Scottish and Irish are good people according to Hollywood. Examples are JAG season 2 episode 6 Trinity were the SAS are bad people and the US Navy and the IRA are good people. The Patriot were British are bad and burned a church with people inside.
@@grantshouse9229 nope was filmed in ireland too :)
@@reakingringpiece Its about Scottish fighting for independence in "Scotland"
Where the hell did the destroyer go?
larrymcjones Very fast destroyer.....it just dropped charges 2 times and then left to nowhere......
larrymcjones i
back to base. @_@
Yankee football ja ja
They are near u boot ,but they went on cofe pause!!!!
If there was a fire on board like that it would use up alot of oxygen- ==death
Fegelein is now uboat commander.
Death in submarine very fearfull
The enigma machine was captured by HMS BULLDOG off U110 before she sank in May 1941.SIX MONTHS before the US entered WW2.
I think before that Brits capture a machine from a German weather ship. But the rotors changed.
The Allies already have the enigma machines, but you see, the way enigma is designed is that you cannot decode an engima message with the machine alone, you need a number as well, and the Germans communicating with each other have numbers pre-decided before so they know which numbers to displace the rotors on the enigma machine to decode their messages with each other.
That's why the british have departments dedicated to cracking enigma messages, they have to check all those numbers for which one is the valid to decode the messages.
@@rune.theocracyTherefore it would be codebooks they would be looking for in a U-boat.
Would you like to know about and infinitely better movie. A movie that is actually based on a true story, has a life like feel to it, more drama, doesn’t glorify war and neither aims to bastardize the enemy or promote their faction, all the while proving that there were good men trying to survive on the other side of the war.
This movie is Das Boot
The best of its kind
Best fantasy film i have seen in a long time.
😂
Normally, one depth charge blowing up at that close range is enough to sunk a U boat.
No it isnt
@@johannsebastianbach9003 Depends on how close it explodes to the boat.
Here comes the submarine experts
@@networkengineer2734 Only the explosions underneath the boat are really dangerous because the force of the explosion is straight upwards due to water pressure.
Oh look ı ve played u boat game
Das ist Tomsen!! Tomsen!!
I just saw FEGELEIN ! FEGELEIN! FEGELEEEEIIIINNNNN!
No wonder old Hitler couldn't find Fegelein. He was commanding U-571 in the Atlantic.
3 best movies I’ve seen for depictions of submarine warfare: U-571, Das Boot, and The Hunt For Red October.
Well those are the only movies 😂
@@Feuergraf U-47 , Haie und kleine Fische, Greyhound...
I like Hunter killer
That fire extinguisher was made up of water, like that would put out a fuel fire that easily.....
Jep in such a severe fire it would be better to let the diesel compartment sealed so it wont get air.
And the next thing is how should it even cach fire in the first place ? Its diesel thats hard to ignite you can even dump a match in a bucket full of it and it wont ignite.
Most fires on a uboat where electric fires and batery explosions because a batery produces hydrogene while charcing which needs to be vented if salt water gets into a batery it would get shrotcircuit and could ignite the hydrogene in it.
thanks for the reply, i did watch the clip again more carefully and i think the guy is repeating "depth is set" or whatever he says is right after "depth is set" cause i don't hear "vorne" anywhere so we might be talking about a different time, thank you though,i appreciate it.
hey. I actually like this movie
They're all looking up like they can see something other than the ceiling. :)
i love german and i respect thier soldiers GREETINGS FROM PHILIPPINES!
@companion sports no they're the best soldier During both ww1 and ww2
Thanks and best greetings for 2022 from Germany.
@@uweschreiber8226 the gemans soldiers during ww2 kild tens of millions of people befoe they had the she kickd out of them in the war
@@Fylnnn Best? Is that why they lost both the wars and ended up being an irrelevan country in the world and wors and american puppetstate
@@uweschreiber8226 Respect for inventing nazsm and kild literlaly tens of millions of people?
gemany has a disgusn histry`
He says "Vorne oben drei" ("forward up three", i.e. forward dive planes three degrees up), repeating the command given to him.
Even K19 is a better in historical respect, at least they didn't say it was Americans who saved the soviet sub.
Gotthard Leng k19 is better in every way. It’s a proper legit retelling of a a real historical event.
Silly movie. The real U-571 has nothing to do with an enigma capture and was sunk in January, 1944.
They don't want to know this.
from what I've read, this was meant to be some sort of sequel to das boot.
@@sekulrtsnfnugg6126 In that case, it's even more of a flop.
The destroyer was with a convoy. They had to keep moving with it. Later in the movie they state how the destoryer reported sinking the U-571, so they probally got out of there fast. Takes a while for those submarines to rise and they move with the current, as well.
how can diesel fuel take fire like this??? diesel fuel takes fire only at more than 260 C...
Until it becomes vapor fumes as depicted here.
Next you are going to say the diesel fuel catching fire in T2 is realistic as well I suppose.
When the motor is damaged and sparks are flying? Easily.
@@Shadowkey392 diesel fuel are not easily burned just like normal gas
@@igederaeyana8513 Still are flames going off and Sparks from the light blowing out
Kriegsmarine... Luftwaffe
Kriegsmarine... Luftwaffe
...Luftwaffe.
I'd rather die crashing to the ground in a fireball than being drowned, burned, or crushed to death in an underwater tin can.
das boot better than this movie...
+Jack the Gestapo Indeed
The new TV series is awesome
Great WW2 movie that looks like realistic portrayal of German u boat life during ww2
1. Diesel is not that easily combustible
2. When dive, they turn off most lights to conserve battery.
3. Real U boats are not that spacious
Woah... Do you mean to tell me this is a movie... *you're supposed to suspend disbelief*
1. Liquid diesel isn't easily combustible, but vapors are.
2. How did they see?
3. Totally true. I've seen the practice dive scene in Das Boot.
Seriously offensive Hollywood BS.
Jack, the Japan Alps Brit
It is historically inaccurate. But at least all the Germans in this movie are actual Germans. That alone puts it one tier above most Hollywood war movies
I almost agree, but you are wrong about the worst crews. The soviets had the worst crews. Americans simply didn't have a good standing army when the war broke out, they were unprepared. They had a partially good surface fleet, but no u-boat experience. Americans learned they U-boat experience in the Pacific theater. But you are right, one should stick to watching Das Boot. You can learn much about submarine warfare from that movie alone.
Is it a remake? Cuz it's the same scene from "das boot"
Diesel isn't that flammable for sparks to ignite a flash explosion
Pk appunto c'è l'olio
After watching Das Boot, this looks horrible. So much more space on that boat! But, I respect the filmmakers and actors. Even if it’s not a good film from a naval standpoint.
Im American and I hate this movie also. I liked the German actors and did not like the American actors. War is War , either you or them but the story flow was just to high and mighty.
shirl woolf Im American and I love this movie also. I liked the American actors and did not like the German actors. War is War, either you or them but the story flows was just to high and mighty.
thats all right, everyone to their own. I happen to like the story flow to foreign movies. I think the german actor Kretschner? was great. I also love American war movies like The Big Red ONE with Lee Marvin.Great story flow. I also ( DOG ) love many military american movies but I also like other movies like Stalingrad (german) , The Black Book etc..( which happens to be Dutch)? Why worry over who likes or doesn't like a movie, that is what makes us unique. Happy for you that you like this movie as many people do…..shirl
i want to know why
why what? (-:
+shirl woolf love germane
Was this some sort of "Das boot" remake?
Yes. It was a very bad done attempt to copy Das Boot somehow. It failed big time.
@@megatwingo i see. i vagely remember U 571...I was very young when it first came out. However, Das Boot is one of my favorites
@@fernyfloresdrummer3568
:-)
Wonderful film.
good submarine movie...
All the people in the comments pretend to know more than they really do.
are they trying to rip off "Das Boot"? which was based on the book written by an actual former German reporter who was actually in a submarine during WWII
agenttheater5 DUDE.. ONLY das BOOT haz the right to make a movie about SUBMARINE!!! Stop ripping them offf!
Dog
I'm nor ripping anyone off. Since writing that I've thought about it and changed my mind. I like this movie, I just like Das Boot better.
Den Gran Sasso 2917meter jetzt danach 2500meter Ca wie Monte Amaro!
U-571
こちらも良いなぁ。
眼下の敵 を思い出しますね。
明夢あむり
ロバート・ミッチャム！
KUSUNOKI KONZERN
家巣！
明夢あむり
出巣根！
Great movie, but disturbingly inaccurate considering all credit should go to the British. And it's still not as good as Das Boot. Ah well....enjoy it for what it is.
Anonymous Guy it’s just a movie lightn up
@@pasnthr6251It's misleading.
@@pasnthr6251 For those crew members of HMS Bulldog it was an insult. But hey, the same as "The Patriot", the Americans are great at distorting historical facts.
@@pasnthr6251 That's no excuse
@@pasnthr6251 A film about how to steal Valour.
This is why I look up movies, for the comments. I've learned more about WWII Naval history in three minutes than most movies. I seriously wish all countries would be historically & factually accurate, but this would be delusional to think most movies are accurate. We are talking, in this case Hollywood. This is another reason to check comment sections & if truly interesting fact check certain comments. Sometimes you can find some real pearls. Other times it's like an unexplored mine field.
U-boats ran on batteries or diesel right? What ignited? Was it something else burning? Electrical fire?
U-Boots ran on diesel when in surface when underwater it ran on electrical so it should be fire in this scene i hate this movie so many fakes like when americans attack U-Boot VIIC have 30 seconds to dive in alarm mode and next 30 to dive to 60m but Americans attack this U-Boot 2 or even 3 minutes german gave alarm dive on begening of the attack or when German destroyer attack U-Boot with americans german officers was not stupid like in this movie they would sink u-boot at very beggining when they show thats americans and next stupid thing when U-Boot shot torpedo to destroyer they just shot no any information about torpedo deepth, speed or bearings thy just screems fire or we die omg so stupid and the last thing Enigma its totaly fake Enigma was first decoded by three Polish cryptologists, Marian Rejewski, Jerzy Różycki and Henryk Zygalski in 1932 after german upgrade Enigma Polish works with British and French to decoded Enigma again USA never get Enigma or decoded it you should watch Das Boot great movie especialy long 5 hours version Uncut
I just thought it weird that that the engines burst like a gasoline fire...let's watch dasboot instead!
You're right. Diesel fuel. Good luck getting it to ignite. You'd need a torch to get it to burn. They did that on Terminator 2 as well. No way a spark from a battery cable would ignite the truck's diesel fuel.
One of the last good war movies to be created.
dengerin pake 🎧 JBL mantep👍
Biggest load of bilge going.
what is the soundtrack on the scene?
Das boot was better
A film about how to steal Valour.
Don't join the navy!🤣
Nothing as aromatic as burned human flesh. Enough to make you vomit on the spot. Even smells like death.
One of my favourite films of all time, I used to watch this with my grandad when I was a kid
Eine Atombomben in Weltraum brauchst immer Sauerstoff un effektiv Zu werden!
Wait a goddamn minute they had a destroyer dropping depth charges on them and less than a minute later the german captain orders all ballast tanks blown and then they surface and the destroyer is suddenly vanished ?? has this director even seen das boot ??
Ironically, if a depth charge exploded that close the sub, the ship would be torn apart, something that the original Das Boot got wrong, which this dumbass director copied.
The depth charge can also sink the destroyer so the destroyer must be away from the location where the depth charge explodes, I suppose.
Destotyer is there..just on cofe break!You can not depth charged someone without coffe!!!🤗
our german heros!
im familiar with u boat terminology in german but at the beginning of the movie when the captain is making final arrangements to fire torpedos one of the helmsmen replies back something to the effect of "folum drily" (this is how it sounds to me, i know its not correct) and i was wondering what that meant,if you have seen the movie as many times as i have you will know exactly what i'm talking about, its not translated into the subtitles, they missed it,maybe someone out there knows, thanks.
I think it means "vorne oben drei liegt" which means "bow depth rudder three degrees up is set".
when i saw submarine attack i thouth the submarine was attacking, fix the error and say its a submarine attacked.
Depth charges
Nice film,very good..Actors,"History" Cadrage et realisation
Nice interpretation
Good for the schools and memory
Bien a vous
Olivier Altruy you have google at your fingertips and still type like a muppet
I always wondered why the U boat didn't just steer left or right to avoid the depth charges.....it cant be that hard.....
killbot86 U boat cant use his rudders when diving.
Doğukan Kaya What?? That's not true.....did u not see the under water battle scene with the other u-boat......both were clearly steering left and right to aim torpedoes at eachother.....Did u not hear what the German mechanic said at the beginning of the movie....."we have enough battery power to dive and maybe manoeuvre around a bit"........
killbot86 When a U Boat dives, Diesel engines changes to Electric, that means they cant make any move, they only can use their elevators.
Doğukan Kaya That doesn't make any sense at all, the Diesel engine and battery power operates the turbines/propellers...... the use of the rudder or elevator planes is not determined by its power source......All they have to do is turn the helm to steer left and right, which I've seen them do many times in other movies while underwater.....
But you know, they shouldnt make any sound when they are below of a cruiser or a battleship.
Watch "Das Boot" - that's amazing movie. I believe they made U571 after watching "Das Boot"
You have to watch the Das Boot series on Hulu. Same quality filming and character development as the original movie.
MK6 .
Hahahahaaaaaaa cooool Gunter was a friend of mine in the 80's in germany ! The good old Punkrock days !
While this movie has its faults, it did do a good job showing what life on World War II submarines was like.
The most and only impression clip , and the most and only best clip of the movie...as my image
This movie is another of the many scoundrels of the US and Hollywood. The real action, which took place in May 1941, was carried out by an English, not American, command as it appears in this film, among other reasons, because at that time the United States had not yet entered the war.
In the book on which the film of Russell Crowe is based, The Farthest Coast, the pirate ship against which the English fight is not French, is American.
American political propaganda has no scruples about misrepresenting history, and adulterating literature, when this suits their political interests. On numerous occasions the US has fabricated "incidents" to justify their invasions or their bombings, false indeed. This has been revealed by their own documents once they were declassified.
It is a personal opinion of David Balme, but Tony Blair was very offend for this historical falsification, and in general the English must feel offended in his pride because the heroism of his soldiers who carried out this operation was silenced. Americans are arrogants as Roman emperors, and they have no scruples about lying when it suits to their political interests. It is not the first time that they falsify the story by adulterating the original books. In the film of Russell Crowe “The farthest coast”, the pirate ship is French, but in the original text it is American.
Maybe the truth is "politically inconvenient".
submarines movie . good.
It is so amazing to me that we are blessed with so many submarine warefare experts. Clearly I attended the wrong schools. Never even saw those classes on the list. Give it a rest experts. It’s called a movie. It is no more representative of reality than a CNN “news”cast. 😆
JEFF, YOU are correct. No one should regard a Hollywood movie script as reality. !!!!!GENE HOLLON
Hitler: FEGELEIN 1:03
😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲😲شوه.هيده.اخ.
هومي.
Your chances were better in the Infantry.
This is an entertaining movie, but I'm not crazy about the way they sensationalized it. That's the problem sometimes with Hollywood--they never let the truth get in the way of a good story.
Wir konnen Nur auf liptonen Arbeiten! Energia im Vacuum!
this is why I don't like U-boat's
Not exactly Das Boot
Muy buena película
Captain Fegelein!
It should be Gruppenführer
@@jerryu8166 I know. I'm referring to how the captain is played by Fegelein's actor
@@pizzaplanettruck9761 yes and I'm referring the rank for the role that Fegelein's actor hold in the movie Der Untergang
Drevag Dresden Oder Eon Enel Eni! !🌋😁💋
Hell yeah they did!
On the one hand, I love this movie...on the other it's historically inaccurate....it was the Brits that captured a U-boat and it's Enigma device, not the US....but when has Hollywood ever let historical accuracy get in the way of telling a story?
Americans should be ashamed of this film.
As usual the Yanks are trying to re-write history, enigma was retrieved by some REALLY brave BRITS!! THIS is a load of COBBLERS
so what´so wrong with this Clip? To me it seems to be quite realistic and authentic. I recognized the actor Oliver Stokowski. I don´t know it.
This scene is fine. Once the American bullshit starts, the movie dies.
The British captured the U-boat not Americans
The British captured U-110 in 1941, as mentioned in the closing credits. That was by chance. H.M.S Bulldog forced her to surface and was attempting to sink her. The captain gave the order to abandon the ship and the British ceased fire when they realized the German sailors wanted to surrender. The British sailors found her enigma machine and coding documents intact. They tried to tow the sub to port, but she sank along the way. The US navy captured U-505 (which is on display at a museum in Chicago) on June 4/1944, 2 days before D-Day. The Royal Canadian Navy captured U-744 in March 1944. There were 15 U-boats and their enigma machines captured altogether. All but 2 were captured by the Royal Navy.
@@baddriversofmoosejaw8681 That was HMS Bulldog. HMS Petard was one of five that captured U-559. Three of her sailors boarded and captured the codebooks. The machine and two of the sailors were lost with the boat.
@@pizzaplanettruck9761 I know. I read about that. As much as I love this movie, there are so many things wrong. That's Diesel fuel leaking from the pipes in the engine room. No way could some sparks ignite it and cause an inferno. Diesel does burn, but it's very difficult to ignite. The destroyer would've been waiting for them when they surfaced. Not long gone. And it either would've sunk the boat, or captured it, along with the enigma and codebooks. Almost every sailor on U-boats and ships of other navies are trained to be able to maintain the ship, so the idea of the U-boat's engine crew being dead would leave it stranded with no one that can fix the Diesel engines is false. The S-33 never operated in the Atlantic. Only the Pacific and it only saw action against the Japanese. It was never sunk. It was later scrapped after the war. No way could less than 10 men operate a U-boat. You need at least 44 to operate a Type VII. Tank wouldn't have been able to fix the Diesel. It's a different design than American ones and he wouldn't have training in that. Resupply U-boats didn't have torpedo tubes or even deck guns. Just AA guns, so the resupply U-boat would've radioed for help when they saw what was happening. They needed space for transporting supplies and fuel and also for bakeries. The idea of a German destroyer being that far west all by itself is ridiculous. The Royal Navy was the biggest in the world back then, until late in the war anyway, and even the Bismarck never made it that far west. The Kriegsmarine only built 31 destroyers and after the Bismarck was sunk, German surface ships rarely left port. They just didn't have the time needed to build a surface fleet that could challenge the Royal Navy. They could've started building one before the war, but it wouldn't have been ready until 1948, since it was ordered in 1939 and was shelved shortly after the war began. That and German reconnaissance planes didn't have the range to fly halfway across the North Atlantic and make it back to France or Germany. Even their bombers couldn't fly that far. The Germans didn't have SONAR/Asdic like the British. The closest they had was Hydrophones, which were all that was available in World War I. A single torpedo will damage a destroyer, but won't sink it. Not a chance. The Polish had already captured Enigma machines and coding documents and turned them over to the Allies before the war. That and we know that the Royal Navy had already captured some by 1941. Also, Karl Donitz, who was the micromanaging type, compromised his own security by having the U-boats send daily messages, whether there was anything important to report or not and the Allies were able to trace the signals and easily locate and destroy them, especially by 1943, when Radar advanced enough that even B-24s were equipped with it and could still find them at night and in bad weather. That and the British having the Huff-Duff, so they could trace the signal's position, even if they didn't know what they were saying. The Germans had some suspicion that their codes had been compromised, but never did quite catch on and thus never changed them.
Lol he’s living with him on a submarine through dangerous mission after mission and he calls him “radioman”…. Bad scripting.
To me this movie was an attempt to introduce American audiences to the German U-boats. However the marketing department said to the director "we have to have Americans in the German Submarine otherwise American audiences won't go and see it because they don't want to watch a film in which the 'bad guys' are the main characters"
I agree with your comment the most. US Audiences are racist & dim-witted. They can't read fast enough for Subtitles. They hate all & any historical accuracy due to their incompetence & shame in war tactics. And their country was founded on the principles of theft, torture, death & lies.
I don't believe I argued to the contrary? But America take pride in War, & that just offends the rest of the world. It's like if Germany was proud of National Socialism. The Americans *stole* the land from the indigenous population, slaughtered everyone & everything in sight, & then put up signs saying "Thou Shall Not Steal" & re-wrote the history books out of shame.
Every person, every nation, every grain of sand is different. We are all affected by our environment. And the mere fact that kids are brought up around Guns obviously has a completely different effect compared with those who shall never fire a weapon.
The US also spends more on "Defense" than the next 7 highest spenders *combined*
It has the highest crime rates, highest drug overdoses, highest rate of homelessness, corruption, highest prison population, etc. They also overwork people, & as a result have less sleep than any other country in the world. Its no surprise the US is the 1st country where Net Neutrality is lost.
"Love your Country"... even though they dumped 65 tons of nerve gas into the ocean off the coast of Miami. Now I'm not saying that other countries aren't guilty of the very same things. But I would say it is vital that we take note of our differences, & in that, the USA is the example of precise what NOT to be like.
TL:DR: ruclips.net/video/u6LrqLaDOmU/видео.html
Just remember that there's a text crawl at the end of the British version explaining the truth.
I’m watching this movie right now and I noticed a mistake in it, just before they go to attack the uboat the lieutenant takes off what is supposed to be his US Navy ring but it’s a US Army ring, ooops
this movie is not good good, nor compelling as Das Boot is
best moment in the film.......rest is pure American cheese
Pls disable the comments, its cancer
No.
lol
0:52
Americans should be ashamed of this film.
從敵人剩一個沒死還沒認出他是艦長之後就開始爛了…
最好鑰匙還能在小兵身上
要鎖犯人鎖在那看起來就是能自行解開
整個爛掉了 唉
難怪放在好萊塢電影台不是沒道理的
Yep