Modi Vs Modi 2014-2021 || Midweek Matters 25 || Parakala Prabhakar
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 сен 2024
- #Modi #PartitionHorrorsRemembranceDay #IndiaAt75
Description:
In this Episode of Midweek Matters, Dr Parakala looks back at all the seven speeches of Prime Minister Narendra Modi from 2014 until last year, and puts this year's speech against the back drop of his utterances in those. And tries to understand from them the shift that has taken place between 2014 and 2021 in the Modi persona and his political and governance discourse.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Link to PM's Independence Day speech 2021:
www.pmindia.go...
Link to PM's Independence Day speech 2020 :
pib.gov.in/Pre...
Link to PM's Independence Day speech 2019 :
pib.gov.in/Pre...
Link to PM's Independence Day speech 2018 :
pib.gov.in/Pre...
Link to PM's Independence Day speech 2017 :
pib.gov.in/Pre...
Link to PM's Independence Day speech 2016 :
economictimes....
Link to PM's Independence Day speech 2015:
www.narendramo...
Link to PM's Independence Day speech 2014 :
www.pmindia.go...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#MidweekMatters #IndpendenceDay #India #AmritMahotsav #IndiaAt75 #75thIndependenceDay #75YearsOfIndependence #Modi #Modispeech #ModiIndependenceDay #PmModi #Redfort #Delhi #JaiHind #NationBuilding #ModiGovt #FuelPrices #BJP #GOI #Nehru #JawaharlalNehru #FuelPriceHike #NarendraModi #Modi #Petrol #PetrolPriceHike #DieselPriceHike #IndianEconomy #NaMo #Midweek #Parakala #ParakalaPrabhakar
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
For Other Episodes :
Amrutmahotsav, IMF & Reimagining Indian State:
• Amrutmahotsav, IMF & R...
BJP & State Elections 2021: Saffron Surge?:
• BJP & State Elections ...
Poverty Data & Data Poverty:
• Poverty Data & Data Po...
Bonsai Universities & Ripped Jeans:
• Bonsai Universities & ...
PSU Mega Sale & Vizag Steal:
• PSU Mega Sale & Vizag ...
Narendra Modi Vs Sardar Patel:
• Narendra Modi Vs Sarda...
A Spectre Is Haunting This Government - The Spectre Of Digital News: • A Spectre Is Haunting ...
Covid Surge, National Numbing & Accountability -
• Covid Surge, National ...
India is crying for #Maitri: Maitri from its Government -
• India is crying for #M...
2021 State Elections: Make No Mistake, It’s A Saffron Surge! -
• 2021 State Elections: ...
Covid-19, Governance & Mother's Day -
• Covid-19, Governance &...
Covid Agony: The Unseen Psychological
• Covid Agony: The Unsee...
Vaccine Mess, Moral Paralysis & Egocratic Government
• Vaccine Mess, Moral Pa...
An Independent Public Inquiry - We Must Have
• An Independent Public ...
Mired in Past, Messing with Present, Muddled about Future
• Mired in Past, Messing...
Cabinet Reshuffle Or Farm Laws Reset: What’s The Priority?
• Cabinet Reshuffle Or F...
India's Covid Children
• India's Covid Children...
Religious India, Political India & PEW Report
• Religious India, Polit...
Who Killed Father Stan Swamy?
BJP’s Population Politics&India's Population Policy
• BJP’s Population Polit...
Pegasus & Turning India Into Surveillance State
• Pegasus & Turning Indi...
India's Unemployed, Unemployable & Unskilled
• India's Unemployed, Un...
BJP - RSS & The Rabbit-Duck Illusion
• BJP - RSS & The Rabbi...
What a superb researched speech, & kudos to you for exposing this hypocritical government. May God bless you Sir, with good health & courage to go on.
Totally agree...
He is Mr Finance Minister. Smt N S . Democracy within the Family
@@michellemoraes9570 sometimes heart break of seeing country falling to pieces breaks the family boundaries 😓😓😓
With all the jumlas and deceits he gets stronger. That is the tragedy. Dont see light at the end of the tunnel. When will we wake up..!!!
Is it a sin to learn from history. We can keep away from historical blunders... uk
Thank you. I must confess that now I end all my classes with " do take good care of yourself and all your loved ones"
The children love it!
🙏🏽
Parakala, I wait for Midweek Matters. I watch it two or three times to let the analyses sink in. It’s simply superb. Lots of food for thought. I wish more people could watch and absorb this intellectually stimulating programme.
🙏🏽
Sir ...your perfect analysis of all the speeches .....hits the nail on the head with such correctness. .....that any one with a bit an analytical mind can see through IT All.!!
We have at the helm of affairs..... master of spin and narrative....!
Again hats off to him
@@ajitshah7013 p
What an incisive presentation Sir! Thank you for this terrific analysis of the speeches. What can be said about such hypocrisy! Hope the Nation wakes up from deep slumber and vote sensibly. God save our Country!
To whom you voting lalu jasya maya idiots we need reforn in judiciuary and electroiral.
Mr Parakala, I'm so proud that we have people like you who dare to expose the lies of the governments in power. God bless you all.
Terrific analysis and logic week after week
" Midweek" is becoming an addiction ! A holistic look on a PERFORMER and an enlightening one .
Nobody can expose modi so intellectually as this intellectual.
Gentleman is husband of our current FM Mrs. Nirmala Sitharaman.
Separated by views I am told !
@@jayoopatwardhan4040 cwcwçwcwwcwcff koi;;fveveeoo
PP is an intellectual, unlike NaMo. Unfortunately the Bhakts, and the paid thousands of them, will label him an urban naxal(??), an anti national, etc. etc. Let’s face it. The Congress is a joke, the so called opposition does not exist and almost all politicos and Babus who matter can be bought or coerced into submission. So it’s NaMo in 2024. Unless the RSS declares otherwise. The RSS is the smartest outfit in India today. Their only Achilles heel is the obsession with Hindi as a unifying language. But why this dogma. ?? If they stick to Bharat and Hinduvta as an ethos, they can go beyond 2024 with or without regional satraps. But NaMo will be the obstacle. Watch it unravel.
@@aramanarao Tathasthu. All is well with New India. Namo Namaha
He was always unclear. He never clarify the truth what people are suffering just bosting themselves .No words just heartbreaking insidences happening in this great country. Every one must inspire Ur heart breaking feelings sir .we salute you sir plz 👍
Astute and perceptive analysis of Modispeak! Respect 🙏
The more I listen to you, the more I feel sorry for the state we are in & how blind we’ve turned ourselves into. How do we come back from here?
A nation made to master the art of living in past ... by its unceremonious leader
Like every week .. you have very skillfully hit the bull's eye Sir 🙏🙏🙏
Superb comparison, Sir! Thanks. I wait for your razor sharp analysis. 2014 and 15 speeches were for his core voters and those hopefuls who saw him as messiah. Now he speaks to his RSS masters and his core voters. But the hopefuls have left him. Let the exodus begin. Mood of the nation survey by India Today indicates a downward trend in popularity graph.
Leader should be the one who applies medicine on the wounds and not the one who wants to keep them bleeding. If one wants to achieve something positive in the future, one should get rid of negativity from own mind...
More bleeding ,more Bhakta n more vote.
He has always been expert in emotional manipulations. He is student of Hitler and Mussolini.
Thank you to Dr Prabhakar
Amazing video
Sir, another brilliant analysis this week too. I endorse what your friend said to you - for all that you say either the government should take cognizance or arrest you!! I look forward to your weekly analysis and opinions of what's happening in our country.
Lies damned lies wicked lies, modis lies.
Sir you are among the rare breed of intellectuals who has courage to call a spade a spade. Midweek matters is always awaited.
Thanks for this video n your analysis n efforts. 2014 independence Day speach of faqueeeer was the last I saw. I think we will see his real, ugly n dangerous face as we near 2024. He will not disappoint the country for sure. We are doooomed.
But I only wish you are proved wrong. And we will get a change for the better
@@marianfurtado7495 I too wish I am proven wrong. But have doubts if we will have elections in 2024 at all.
Thank you Sir for this clear and straighforward episode. Appreciate your inner strength to say what you are saying so cooly. You too Sir please stay safe and blessed .
Appreciate your concerns
🙏🏽
Thank you for your rational clarity and courage
PM Modi's message of 2014 as coming of "achhe din" was promising and reminder of Atal Bihari Vajpayee's soothing messages. Within seven years aura of assurance has recceded. The address on 2021 has brought out what is locked in his inner recesses. Mind has come out as of hindutva figurehead lording over others. Partition Horrors Remembrance Day on 14 August is divisive and going back to 1947. It implies that country is going back to de-recoganise Pakistan as a separate nation. Hopefully, Pakistan would not lebel 15 August as Horrors Remembrance Day. Hate erodes a nation. Nations move forward not backward.
Perhaps neat and intelligent exposure
@@suryanarayanamurthy3794
Thanks.
Absolutely stunning!! I hope the bhakts are listening and using their intelligence a little bit to unmask this self serving individual who can never be one to lead a great nation like India.
Unfortunately there is no intelligence among the bhakts...just illiterate craftiness
@@zenith808 Agree with you
Bhakths have been administerd with Anastasia, they are unable to make out what is right and what is wrong.
Sir, thank you very much for your wonderful observation, analysis and above all calling a spade what it is. The one thing which made me so happy today is to know people like you fearlessly expressing the thoughts and ordinary citizens like us gaining from it. The power and beauty of democracy. My humble bow to our founding fathers for the clarity, vision and our constitution. God bless you.
Very excellent analysis sir
Superb analysis and so insightful. Well done sir!
Great analysis.God bless you Sir
That 2014 speech was probably done with the intention of masking the Godhra tag attached him.
Agree...
Wow correct
Midweek matters is the most informative and well delivered program and it's a pleasure to listen in. I do hope you add on to midweek matters by inviting the youth to form a forum to discuss and counter the wrong that's currently happening in our society.
🙏🏽
Very impressive sir ..we recently
started watching your talks ....
and are already hooked to it....
Do we need a partition Horror Day? What is gained by sowing hatred. The violence was from both sides. In this depressing times country needs some happiness. We are getting empty promises year after year from the ramparts of Red Fort whilst not fulfilling any, only to fool us.
Mr Finance Minister Sir Dr.P P believes in Democracy within the Family.
Violence was from both sides. Who threatened direct action which means I will unleash violence if my demands are not met and did it successfully. The new generation should learn history to avoid historical blunders in future........ uk
100% rightly said
This is another wonderful analysis! Always look forward to your mid week matters. I hope people wake up
Excellent Mr prabhakar. Your analysis r very calm but strong.
Beautiful down to earth analysis of Modi govt’s failiures and lies. Thanks a lot you have truely exposed the fake Modi threadbare
Thanks sir for the analysis. The pm of India is not a statesman but an actor even above amitabh bachaan. He is endowed with gift of the gab and as actors do on screen , he sways the audience with the theatrics through his modulation and carefully chosen sentences!! I really don't understand when will the masses see through this marvellous acting ! Till then we suffer!
Basically Feku has a ego of the size of Mount Everest. He thinks that he is God himself descended on earth.
Yes that's why the bhakts have made a mandir for him!!!
India is a unique country. The world has marvelled at its secularism. India has been invaded and looted in the past, but it did not perish into oblivion. India will continue to live. And the most beautiful part of India is its secularism. Every Indian must be patient, kind, and willing to suffer a bit to see India shine again.
This was a perfect analysis of Modi’s decline . Anyway he was in no way comparable to Nehruji or Atal Behariji. As an octogenarian now,who was in the primary school, I still remember Nehruji’s Redfort address on 15 th August ,1947( heard on the PyeRadio set newly bought at home),and much later in the end of the century speech of Atalji, watched on TV in 1999, I find Modi as a very poor comparison. I greatly look forward to your Wednesday musings.Hope it awakens the India in comatose condition.
I would be glad if he's able to wake up his wife, who's the nation's FM
@@bhushanwagle5098 If that was possible he would have done it long ago dear🙏🏼😍😂
Prabhakar my friend, all the rhetoric and speeches of Modi and his lawmakers, reminds me of "before Elvis there was nothing".
Excellent Analysis sir. Namaste
Who else can do such analysis better? I admire Dr. Prabhakar’s clarity of thought and his power of expression.
yet another brilliant analysis Sir, I fervently wish more people to this instead of drowning themselves in this jingoistic cacophony!
His wife is finance minister....Nirmala....let him give advice to her. Earlier he was in BJP....contested on BJP ticket as M.P., He was adviser to Chandrababu between 2014 to 2019...defeated miserably.
@@tanushree2536 Mistakes n changes is part of life n his wife is highly intellectual person having a mind of her own she will do as she pleases, she's not gonna listen,....n so also he will do what he feels is right.... different individuals n different opinions n mindset 🇮🇳
Brilliant Prabhakar.
Thank you, Rajen.
Sir, which generation in India wishes to remember the Partition by marking it with a Partition Horrors Remembrance Day? The last century celebrated the unification of Germany with the wall coming down. Will we really want to mark this century with a Partition Horrors Day ?
Good analysis. Thanks.
Great analysis
Huge Respect for your work sir 🙏🏼
I am simply short of words to explain your " intellect, utmost balancing of words, and above all, with carefully guarded words the way you explained the most deep rooted intricacies of the speech. Really its a pleasure to listen to people like you and persons like Karan Thaper. PROF AMS RAO TPT.
🙏🏽
Another Brilliant piece and complete justice to the title. Maybe this is the reason we never see him addressing a press conference - he will confuse himself and he will confuse us more.
I liked his calm and composed demeanor! Very well researched also..
As usual, your indepth analysis of crucial matters is much appreciated .👍
Brilliant!
GREAT TALK.
Sir, Midweek Matters is becoming the wellspring of intellectual vitality. Examining our PM's Independence Day speeches and attempting to analyze and interpret them is like stepping into a hall of mirrors ; a confusing, disorienting situation, where it is difficult to distinguish between truth and illusion. Mr. Modi's lament of the violence that rended our nation in 1947 was ostensibly a dog whistle---- a subtly aimed political message intended for a particular demographic group.
Our PM's oratory is a supreme elixir that instantly makes us heady but with the passage of time makes us feel abandoned.
Sir, thank you for bringing to the fore certain aspects of our polity that would otherwise have remained submerged.
Amazing and razor sharp analysis. Dr. Parkala, I admire your intellect and salute your spirit. With you in your mission.
Excellent
Heard you for the first time. Amazing. Very decent analysis of the deterioration of values. I hope the blind followers also understand this.
A strong and meaningful presentation by mr seetharaman. What a contrast between mr seetharaman and Mrs seetharaman.
Sir, I heard you yesterday and if I write now, it is only to avoid overpraise for your incisive, well researched and thought provoking issue that you spoke on Midweek matters'. I wish there are more and more educated lots who listen to you and bring awareness of issues afflicting the nation! All I can say is that we are proud of you for these talks on 'Midweek matters' and hope that you continue your selfless task uninterrupted. Hats off to you, Sir!
Cdr P Surendra Nath
🙏🏽
Very informative speech. Thank you for making us think.
U nailed it sir ,my doubt is he the original PM or is he s double agent 🤗🤔
✅✅✅
Very thought provoking speech that brought to focus many sidelined critical happenings and inconsistencies in ID speeches in the past 8yrs! It is for people to recognize that and derive their own conclusions. Thanks for bringing it to light very nicely, Sir! 🙏
Excellent.
Sir, every week I am anxious to know the topic which you are going to speak. Really it is wonder how the Pradhan Sevak has changed to Pradhan Manthri from 2014 to 2021. Superb presentation this than any other in the recent past. Please keep us enlightened with these type of intellectual matters. Stay safe and do take good care of you please.
Brilliant!
Thank you Sir for reminding us of what was and what is!
Tragic!!
While you talk about the change in his speeches, marking his intent since 2014 to 2021, the real PM is quite obvious to the discerner. He is no Sevak. He is as weak as any other and much more boastful than any other. His failures are colossal. His achievements meagre. Only the very faithful ones need to study the speeches to analyse him. He lacks compassion and empathy hugely. He is no match intellectually for JLN, ABV, PVNR or MMS. The sooner he accepts it will be better for our country as he will operate within his capability and strength.
+@gyan deep banga
Unfortunately, the hordes of active and passive devotees of Modi do not care about these points. In their deluded imagination, this Modi is an infallible super-hero who deserves to be worshipped.
A line from Julius Ceasar: "O judgement, thou art fled to brutish beasts and men have lost their reason!" ...
The similitude of the quote and our present predicament is spectacular. Impressive discernment. Shakespeare is timeless; he is for all times and all peoples. 👍
Again a very well prepared discourse. It is possible to play act in the short period but in the long run reality emerges. This is who the PM really is as portrayed by the paradigm shift in his speeches. I wish the opposition takes note of these points and use them effectively in the run up to the next election.
Some of the people all of the time and all of the people some of the time, but not all of the people all of the time....
@@arindamdutta9371 Yes Bharat proved it. Hence end of decades of family rule and downfall of Commuinsm world wide..... uk
I never follow any ranting by Modi for he's positioned himself as BJP PM n not India's PM. good analysis. Thank you
BEST ANALYSIS
Education matters. Deluding credulous people requires a different kind of qualification which incidentally is independent of education.
Our man has proved it unfailingly on countless occasions.
Well articulated video, as usual.
He has always been expert in emotional manipulations. He is ardent student of Hitler and Mussolini.
I salute you
Watching your video for the first time.... a huge fan already. The chronological analysis was just brilliant and I can feel your passion. B.R.I..L.L.I.A.N.T
🙏🏽
Heard a show on this podcast for the first time and so well articulated! From swatch Bharat in 2014 why are the countrymen being asked to look back and dig graves of the past! Is the future bleak that it’s better to look the other way round!
Excellent speech sir, slow, clear,detailed analysis
Thanks to you, Sir.
And also for google to recommend this great analysis.
Superb commentary 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼..very incisive 👍🏽
Very good analysis Sir! 👍
Your analysis is very clear and clever. It opens our eyes to the truth. Thank you for your courage and trouble
Greatest thing I have found is this channel, always looked up to him during my childhood in prathidwani (ETV). Glad that he took this decision to start up a channel on youtube. Home many minds would get ignited.
🙏🏽
I couldn't find apt words to pay compliment to this presentation.
🙏🏽
Mr. Prabhakar,Your are good as an analyst.A good personal attack which is the joint order of todays.Pls do such an analysis on the opposition of today.
I truly admire your knowledge, courage and the strength you are giving to us. Thank you so much . 🙏 Yesterday, on one of the groups we had a fight for me saying ,"Modi is just a public servant elected by the citizens of India." Forwarding your video there.
Parakalagaru, I read your essays on the website. Your description of Diwali brought back my childhood vividly. Though we lived in Mumbai, Diwali at grandma in Machilipatnam with chinnannalu attalu and cousins was something else again. And I recently connected my father's reverence to your parents after reading about your family. For me, you were Nirmala sitharaman's spouse but my sisters who live in Hyderabad , you are known differently. Wisdom at any age welcome. Thank you and your family for being in public life in spite of the odds and adversaries
🙏🏽
Excellent Sir
What an analysis! 👌🏻
Great analysis as usual sir. What a lovely way to style the data
What I see is this has become a perfect platform for Modi haters. However I will leave it at that.
🙏🏽
Superb , would be a lesser word. Brilliantly analysed.
🙏🏽
Well analysed and articulated..
It reinforces my views on the subject.look forward to listening to you on other related issues. Thanks
Sir, Very brilliantly analysed.
It is We The People who have brought this unenviable change in him.When we change he will have to change,and it is a matter of time when this happens.
Sir you are absolutely brilliant.
I am now reminded of the maxim " Be careful what you wish for "
Pradhan Pracharak not Sevak nor minister.
Right Observation !
Very well dissected the Modi mind and how he is taking his Andhbhakths for ride
Brilliant analysis delivered with great clarity and without any over riding emphasis. Keep up the good word sir. Respect.
Salute to you sir for exposing the criminal
Mind set of our prime minister and agenda of communal forces.
No words are sufficient to congratulate you.... 💖💐🙏👌
This is a great video.. Mr Prabhkar is great
Absolutely brilliant.. and to the point. Very very interesting analysis indeed.
Good night sir,