Modi’s a Dictator & His Return Would be a Disaster: Finance Minister’s Husband, Parakala Prabhakar
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024
- "Of course, Modi's a dictator; he's dragging India back to the dark ages; his return to power would be a disaster for India": Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman's husband, the author and economist Parakala Prabhakar
...........................................
In a devastating critique of the 10 years of Narendra Modi’s prime ministership, the Finance Minister’s husband, the author and economist Parakala Prabhakar, has said: “Of course, Modi is a dictator” adding “our democracy is in crisis, our social fabric is torn, our economy is in peril and we are being dragged back to the dark ages”. Dr. Parakala says “a return to power of the present government would spell disaster for India”.
However, Dr. Parakala believes this is unlikely to happen and also adds that Narendra Modi and the BJP will struggle to get more than 220-230 seats in the forthcoming elections. Explaining his electoral analysis more fully, Dr. Parakala says Modi and the BJP could lose 50-60 seats in north India and perhaps 10-12 in the south (that is after taking into account any seats they win in Andhra). Dr. Parakala also says that if Modi is restricted to 230 seats he neither has the talent nor the people to help win allies to cobble together a majority and, therefore, he is destined to sit in the Opposition.
In a 45-minute interview to Karan Thapar for The Wire, Dr. Parakala says that if, however, Modi wins a third term “what is happening in Manipur is likely to happen in every state in the country”. He says “if it doesn’t fall in line the entire opposition leadership could be sent to jail”.
Speaking in some detail about the situation facing India’s 200 million Muslims if Narendra Modi wins a third term, Dr. Parakala says they would face “tiraskar”, which he translates as “rejection”. Dr. Parakala foresees a two-stage process. First, Muslims would be reduced to a subordinate status as second class citizens but then they could actually be pushed out of the country or forced to leave.
In fact, Dr. Parakala says what happens to Muslims could also, in some shape or form, happen to all minorities. When he was asked if he meant not just Christians but also Buddhists, Sikhs and Jains, his answer was “why not?”.
Asked what is likely to be history’s verdict on the 10 years of Narendra Modi’s prime ministership, Dr. Parakala said: “He has set India back in terms of economy 20-25 years, in terms of polity to pre-independence days and in terms of social fabric back to 1818”.
Dr. Parakala said the big difference between Indira Gandhi’s Emergency of 75-77 and the situation that could follow a third Modi victory is that the Emergency was a result of one woman’s concern with her future whereas post-2024 it will be a project to make India a Hindu Rashtra and reverse its federalism. Therefore, whilst Indira Gandhi’s Emergency ended after 21 months the “disaster” that possibly looms ahead for India will be a lot more difficult to reverse.
I am only giving you the big broad points made by Dr. Parakala. There’s an awful lot more in this interview, both in terms of analysis and news, which I am leaving you to find out for yourself by watching the interview. I do not want to inaccurately paraphrase or precis Dr. Parakala. You should hear him in his own words by watching the full interview.
Join The Wire's RUclips Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
Being the husband of India's finance minister, this man has a gut to speak the truth. Salute you sir.
That's an indicator of a healthy democracy .
Yes. Estranged husband. They hated each other. That's his claim to fame.
@@penntemp That seems to be the BJP IT cell answer but he is an economist and highly educated person.
Seems divorce suit has been filled 😂😂😂😂
@@kunalsarkar1984Healthy democarcy for bakht only
This is called country first, he is exposing Modi and BJP risking his family relationship, really he is a genius
My big respect to you and your sayings.🙏🙏🙏
May people awoke
He is protecting his wife and not exposing modi
Surprised that BJP has not taken any action against Madam FM.
If it was Mr. Rahul Gandhi who were to say this - from top to bottom the BJP would have used all the possible adjectives to humiliate him.
@@periirani5509It is election time, they cannot afford to say anything.
Where was he in last 5 years ?
Once i supported bjp. But now i am done with their false promises.
Binod, tum yahan ho hum tumhe 2 saal se dhood rahe the😅
Ur the cause of our sufferings
Even my entire family of 14-20 people were huge supporters of BJP.. This time , we have all changed our mind, no more BJP. We are done with them
Once I supported so-called secular political parties. But now I am done with their pseudo-secularism as Haz Subsidy, Madrasa Education, Wakf Bord, Separate law only for a special community .
The most corrupt regime.
Hats off to you sir for expressing your views so boldly …. Praying to God that our country should be freed from the clutches of Mr. Modi
Not
Never gonna happen!
PM Modi jee versus PM Nawaz
PM Modi jee versus PM Shahbaz 9:47
PM Modi jee versus
President Sardar Asif Ali Zardari 10:56
He says 'this is the most corrupt Govt in the history of India"
Tht's a very strong statement😢
Why was he silent for so long?
Maybe his wife throws a tantrum everytime he tried to , like she does while replying to unfavorable questions.
It's so funny that he never spoke a word about all the scams, corruptions, inflation, unemployment, about Indira gandhi emergency, about banning BBC, about imprisonment of journalists for talking against them etc etc during the Congress rule !!!
Why??
Bcoz he wad one of them!😂
TRUTH! ANY DOUBTS? EBS
@@garygeorge-wi7co no, he was not silent he kept criticizing the govt from so long , in his book also he criticized the govt.
Saving the country is more important than saving his marriage & family . A real patriot. More power to this man.
Can't judge so quickly. Yes he had spoken about the govt several times earlier, but opportunity is the thing which most of politicians look for the most
Are you talking of Parakala? Your statement could be misinterpreted as a bhakt ranting about Modi !
He is not having any stats to support .. biased opinion than balanced one
Parakala Prabhakar is he jilted ex. He is jealous of his wife's success. May be they are dibrorced and trying to take revnge on his capable wife when he him self is zero.
He looks jealous after his wife became minister
This video needs to be dubbed into all the major languages of India and be made viral nationwide!
Yes
Or with sub titles option
Aww
Then under bjp you are death
i have watched all his recent interviews... views on those videos are very good.
Happy to see that true journalism is still alive and hats off to these remarkable personalities who struggle and fearless to fight the sold out media
This man should be honoured for speaking the TRUTH
❤️
absolutely agree
He want be raided or arrested because of his credentials with our FM
@@Spidhey buddhe ke khane pine ke lalle ab🤣
The reason no one believes Thapar or Parakala is because of their extreme positions.
Any educated man will agree 101% that he is right
It means if any one who is agrees with him and supports Congress, that means he is educated and anyone who does not agree with him and supports BJP. That means he is uneducated ??😂😂😂 GREAT LOGIC 😂
It could be nota 😐😏
@@dep4025
@@dep4025 if you don't understand the political agenda of BJP you are illiterate even if you have education masters or PHD.
@@dep4025 cow 🐄 💩… run 🤣
Exactly. Narendra Modi is 101% right.👍
Respect to this man. We want more people like him who speak boldly.
And nobody listens or cares. Election results will prove
Boldness lies in advising FM and PM, not in talking behind the screen like this
Your name tells who you are
@@valagamraghunathan 😄😄 yeah, maybe that works at times.
@@valagamraghunathan And your'e the person who judges on basis of name and not his/her statements or logic. Do not judge on so surface level and speak with logic and valid argument.
I salute Mr. Prabhakar on helping us save our CONSTITUTION. Proud to have such intellectuals in India who were deprived from speaking right ..
Only the people of India can save India from imminent disaster through their ballot.
We will ensure our vote goes only to BJP...💪💪
@@Dan1-m6u Abki baar gtr paar... Popet pdffile rmdbaaz ke yaar...🤣😂
There is no disaster. You too be a part of India’s growth
Indira Gandhi rigged polls by ballot 😅
Ok IT cell employee @@Me_Nishant
I appreciate and admire what was spoken by Mr. Prabhakar boldly and the truth. May the almighty save our beautiful country from dictatorship.
Yes please...
John, since you have bias, it appear music for your ears.
Yes right 🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳
Dont worry brother...we will vote for Modiji and make him victorious.
@@chandrasekhar-qv3mgtoh tumhare vote ki next time unko jarurat nahi hogi phir khelte rehna hindu hindu apne ghar pe aur apne haq ke liye tum awaz tak nahi utha paoge Sikh toh ladh lega apne haq ke liye ya Muslim aur minority ke liye toh duniya awaz uthayegi lekin tumhare liye koi nahi uthayega kyuki tumhi jimebar hoge iske aur apni history padho tum kabhi apne haq ke liye nahi ladh paye jab samne Wale ke pass power ho toh tum vichare ban jate ho dusre ke pass jate ho madad ke liye apna dharam tak nahi bacha paye the uske liye bhi dusre se madad liya tha toh apne haq ke liye kya ladh loge tanashahi se jo kisano ke saath huya use bura tumhare sath hoga jo dusro ke liye gadah khod te woh khud girte usme tumhe taraki rass nahi aya rahi hai duniya mein thodi se respect bani woh rass nahi aya rahi hai tumhe dobara gareeb bana hai dobara wohi haal karna hai socity ka jo Mughalon ke waqt tha tabh jaat paat ne barbad kiya tha ab dharam ke name pe karoge
this man has guts.....being husband of FM and these kind statements are just shockers. I still cant fathom the courage this man.
Why do you think nirmala tai isn't contesting the election?😂😂😂 She knows she'll end up in jail if she stays on with the BJP
True, he has guts to Speak against his wife and Modi BJP Government
@@SabeerAbdulla unemployment which is the biggest problem in our country is being hammered in our head and rightly emphasised by Dr PP . But our opposition head by Raga is just glossing over it. I wish this 'I know all' panauti to go from congress and give the baton to somebody else.
No guts. If he has guts he would have advised the PM
@@thyagarajuponangi8576 why should PM listen to him?
He is probably the only husband in India who has the gut to go against his wife. And that too publicly 😂😂 salute to your courage sir🙏🙏
She should immediately divorce him.He is a unfit person to remain in marriage
Hahahahahahhahahahahaha
Guys he is a member of the Indian National Congress and his parents were also from INC 😂😂😂 check his Wikipedia page
@@G-vlogs. hahahhhhahaha
She agrees with him in private.waiting for June 4 results to publicly confirm what her husband has been saying all these years( only if bjp looses otherwise she still support bjp 😂😂).
The real Indians are the one who safe the India from destruction through their speech and action.
Only speech and no action.
Pen is mighter than sword
@@SuptiSupti-y2dBY the way it is mightier and not mighter. I guess you studied at WhatsApp university. I have lived overseas for 15 years. When I was leaving, the disastrous UPA hotchpotch government under Sonia and with Dr Singh's face ruled. NRIs could invest in tax free FDs with a compounded annual returns of 11%, and I benefitted. You Indians paid that hefty interest. Modi came FDI flowed in and he reduced the returns to 6% and later to 4.5%, still reserves went up and quarterly growth rate went up. Dr. Sitharaman's husband is left liberal in ideology and obviously will rubbish state capitalism. Even China, the Leftist mecca, adopted state capitalism to get out of its stagnation under Deng Xiaoping. Care to read books and reports and develop a studied view and not blindly follow crooks like Dhruv Rathi. Even Rihana tweeted her support for Farmers protest but made 1 million for one tweet and shed crocodile tears. Please gain media literacy. With no malice intended.I have also witnessed the massacre of innocent Sikhs, seen Bhagalpur blindings, forced sterilization of poor people, National Emergency and suspension of the constitution under Congress rule at least 35 times. I have seen some Gurgaon roads blocked so that 32 year old Rahul baba could race cars with hos friends. So, please read books and go deeper into information.
Democracy should prevail in India. 🇮🇳 Very bravely and well said by Dr Prabhakar.
Absolutely, we‘re a country built on secularism & Democracy. It‘s time the BJP goes away. Spread the word.
What do you think you are frightened to live in this country? Don’t you have right to vote and right to speak… even people are freely abusing PM … watch what happened with Ridhi Patel in USA then you can believe what is democracy
@Desiinamericaa andhbhakt chup rHiye
@@jen4ra-vs5og I can’t bcz I have freedom of speech and like you I am not afraid in my own country
@@jen4ra-vs5og ghar mein chamcho ki awaz Jayda aa rahi 😂
Protect this man at all cost. Thank you sir for speaking our the truth.
Dhruv rathee is still fine for now.
He barks all the same since his failed political entry. He has mental problems. Leave him alone.
Chiche
@@mkrao100 yeah yeah anybody who talks against Modi or BJP are mental or anti Indian or terrorist. Great democracy, people should not even talk about anything, this is what is called dictatorship, similar to what Hitler did.
@@Phjghh nathu
Dr.parakala is a real desh bhakt who is bold enough to speak even when his wife is F M in the goi.very rare in indian politics to see this.🙏🙏👌
Sounds like a jealous husband and pseudo Khangressi
So that's democracy right ???
And you guys calling Modi a dictator 😂
@@sridharkutube A dictator doesn't become one overnight, it's a slow, sly process, through suppression of fundamental rights, like protests, freedom of expression etc. It also is achieved through bringing in draconian laws like the UAPA, amendments to PMLA making it so hard to get bail, a sitting CM is arrested, think what will happen to the common man.
look at the BJP's control over mainstream media, they are completely one-sided and hardly ever question the central govt. look at the thousands of fake news peddled through WhatsApp, the blatant polarisation of the majority against the minority.
Hitler didn't become a dictator overnight, he did just that, controlled the media, made major amendments to the constitution, led the Germans to believe that they were victims of the minority, showed the dream of a greater Germany, made propaganda films, He didn't just wake up one day and proclaim himself the supreme leader of Germany.
read my friend, look into it with an open mind
Yeah, see his wife heading a major ministry in bjp cabinet still he is free to speak bullsh!t against bjp (had it been congress, his wife would lost post long back and he got kicked out) with no repercussions, fear, worry or whatsoever And yet hypocrisy or irony is u guys still say modi a dictator
This is the FM's husband, who is saying this is the most corrupt govt. in the history of India???
Biwi se dukhi hoga
उनको ये बातें अपनी पत्नी की बातों से या हाव-भाव से पता चला होगा, कि तानाशाह तथा उसके गुंडों के मन में क्या चल रहा है | उनकी पत्नी इन सब झंझटों में नहीं पड़ना चाहती, शायद इसीलिए पैसे की कमी का बहाना बनाकर अगला चुनाव लड़ने से मना कर चुकी हैं | यह बहुत ही गंभीर बात है |
whole world knows beeing an insider he will know more than anyone. GST incomce tax all gives Modi more income compare to any previous govt including Vajpayee still he has not achieved anythng simply cinematic speeches to make pappus...........most of the BJP voters are victim of his speech
Just do basic research before saying whatever you feel like. He is one of the well known economist and author of India.
❤
Thank you Dr. Prabhakar for speaking the truth. Being a Manipuri, we feel so humiliated and disgusted by the response we got from Modi in the past eleven months, and we still don’t see any light of bringing peace in the near future.
3 days ago, Modi said that Manipur is back to normalcy because of timely intervention by the central and state govt. Irony is, there was a shootout in a village called Heirok between the two warring communities, in which 3 person from my community was injured and hospitalised.
If this is peace, God only knows what war is like.
We want peaceful existence, not killings and hatred.
You people are adults and you cannot live in peace. you cannot communicate between yourselves and blame the governmnet.
@@atulmaratheoo7 How idiotic this argument is. We chose the government to take responsibility and maintain law & order and allow us to do what we do as a citizen in our normal life. If you are asking a citizen to do something extraordinary then your argument is farse. What's the point of electing a government then.
@@atulmaratheoo7 Why can't the govt use the armed forces/ army to drive out the illegal militias that are creating havoc everywhere?
Why do we have to rely on ourselves for our own protection?
Are we "less Indian" than any of you? 11 fucking months of our lives wasted down the drain just like that?
You guys only come to celebrate when we bring Olympic medals, but when the we need the country's help, everyone is silent!!! You betrayed us when we needed u most.
From the various articles and videos on Manipur I understand that there has been ethnic conflicts in Manipur for decades which the Congress couldn't resolve in its decades of rule there. Now they expect BJP to wave a magic wand n do magic.
I understand the home minister Amit Shah was camping in Manipur at the time n doing his best to settle it.
We've different departments in govt to handle appropriate issues n it's not necessary for the PM to be present.
I also understand that the locals in Manipur are happy with the BJP's development schemes for Manipur which was never there during the Congress rule.
@@atulmaratheoo7 We are not beggars . We are Indians. Manipur is a part of India. What a narrow and uncivilised mindset you have. If something is happening in a nation, then the leader of the nation must intervene to find out a solution. Modi has never spoken about the Manipur m. When UN and other western countries talk about Manipur, Indian government warned them saying that it is totally internal matters of India. Then why can’t they solve this internal matters. Don’t be a blind supporter of any government, do support good governance not the government.
Rare to find a true intellectual like him in today's time in India. I rarely miss his interviews. Thanks
Thanks for keeping it forthright, independent and truthful. India needs freedom of the press / media more than ever in the current times.
We don't want dictatorship whichever party may rule India.
At the same time, we don't want any dynastic governance also. 😊
@@jayaramprabhu5595 in cricket too 😂
Not BJP under any circumstances
@@pompababbar5112 Indian Muslim League you prefer ?
@@ramachandraks1 cbi for kejriwal where cbi for brij bhushan,cbi for sandeshkahkai yes ,but not for brij bhushan 😂😂
Respect to this man for his boldness to speak the fact.
He is more a negative thinker. If he is really bold, he should advise FM and PM
Anyone has the guts to advise these times
The ruling party has become complacent and arrogant .
I think they already were
that is the first sign of dictatorial regime
@@Spidhey Bullies are the one who fails and they are the most arrogant in the class.
This shows the culture RSS.
Taking bond money from Beef Exporting companies and act like nobody know about it..
What hindu are they who doesn't have moral ethics in any ideology
they are for no one
they are virus
This tendency of taking people for granted happens when a party rules continously. No party should be given a chance to rule continously. It's high time to throw BJP out.
@@Spidhey Their work in ruining the social fabric??? Top Sportsmen like Tendulkar, Federer, Messi, Schumacher are all humble its only the insecure ones like Sehwag, Gambhir, Djokovic, Ronaldo etc who are arrogant.
Dr. Parakala is full of wisdom & insight. What a refreshing interview!
Prabhakar Sir . This is the meaning of Courage . Respect to you . This is called INDIA FIRST .
If PM Modi n Shah does not resign themselves, the people of India should drag them down from their present position. This is very necessary for the safety and solidarity of India and its democracy plus the Constitution.
For sure
absolutely correct and factual comments! The real dictatorship commenced in India since the year 2014 and they are looting our nation and peoples.
Also should put behind the bars for his atrocities
Today people can't speak freely even on social media and you're talking about dragging them. I hope you didn't get knocked by ED and CBI after posting this comment.
Bilkul bilkul aisa hi karenge, chaand tak road bhi bana dein kya lage haath?
Dr.Parakala Prabhakar is a wonderful personality and excellent subject very good family
kal se pehle kisi ne naam nahi suna tha. aaj bhai ko puri personailty ka pata lag gya
@@lazyguy4825😂😂
2014 से पहले गुजरात से बाहर मोदी को भी इतने ही लोग जानते थे। वो तो गुजरात लॉबी का प्रोडक्ट था कि जल्द ही झूठी popularity पा लिया
I request your team to please post the first 1 minute 30 seconds of this video to all your social media accounts. It must reach the masses.
PM Imran versus PM Modi jee ❤️ Gallup poll 12:13
After yogendra Yadav, he has predicted the result most accurately
I thank you Mr Karan to bring Mr Prabhakar and present this to the Indian public just before election
Perfect and accurate assessment by Dr.Prabhakar.He is authentic and fearless Economist.
Yes, Dictator modi is to be thrown out of power as soon as possible.
And Lalu prasad yadav should be made PM along with Rahul Gandhi as Finance Minister.
@@phantommrinalmusk3685 no way, I believe the next PM should be from South India.
Lalu prasad is not only good politician but he is good human being also.He has served in all the department and gave justice to everyone @@phantommrinalmusk3685
@@phantommrinalmusk3685 Andh Bhakt Spotted
How
Dr. Parakala's assessment is very correct.
I am impressed and salute Honourable Doctor Parakala for his courage of conviction. It's an inspiration for all of us to speak up for what is right.
He is from my village in Warangal.
Biwi se dukhi hai … uska career khatam karne ka planning kiya 😂😂😂
He should have been Finance minister of India rather than his wife..
@@khanlatifahmed owaisi ko bana dain Finance Minister 😂
@@vineetdeorari8017 Banado...
Same was been warned long back by our honourable ex PM Mr. Singh
Ex PM, was a puppet 😂
But an educated economist....brought india whatever good Indian economy achieved in last 3 decades.
@@SKS-a2324dthere are puppets in all parties ..Shenshah is the puppeteer of our PM.
@@SKS-a2324dAnd who is the puppet of Corporates?
@@SKS-a2324dकुतर्क दो रुपए मात्र
Salute courageous Dr Parakala, for narrating truthful state in India. Very nice interaction. Thank you both.
He almost predicted everything which happened today. #election2024
Bjp needs such assessments to introspect honestly.
What an explosive interview this is. Right questions by Mr. Tapar & brutally honest answers by Mr. Prabhakar. Kudos to both 🎉. Vote for India.
I welcome the optimism of Dr Prabhakar, and do hope that his forecast comes true.
But.......evm
Thank you The Wire .. this video needs to be watched not only in India but rather the whole world.
A very honest, Matured and Respectful discussion… Very good job by the Wire Team… Keep up the good work 👏👏👏🌷🌷🌷
He should get the bravest husband award
The fact that he is allowed to criticise the sitting PM, is itself the sign that Indian democracy is alive and kicking.
@@garygeorge-wi7co So as per your standard, only when no one can even raise a voice against Modi will the Indian democracy not be "alive and kicking". So something worse than even China where we do hear occasional voices of dissent. It does seem like we will be on fast track towards that too if Modi comes back to power. Of course, compared to China the difference will always be that he can still be thrown out of power if a large proportion of India's population decides on doing so.
😂😂😂😂
Are pakka divorce hoga inka
@@garygeorge-wi7comatlab tabh manoge jab actual mein ye ho jayega phir tu kuch kar payega kya tun keh raha hai ki wait Karo jab tak tanashah ban naa jaye tabh tak bethe raho jab ban jayega toh kya kar lenge log kya dimag hai bhai yaha toh logo ka mindset hi kharab hai ye kya sahi faisla kar lenge
Well said sir, loud and clear message to all fellow Indians!
I urge all my Hindu brothers and sisters don't ever think that you will be safe n sound n will live freely under BJP rule. So vote wisely
I urge my Muslim brothers and sisters to agree for UCC CAA NRC and population control bill . shun and oppose polygamy halala and conversion and send children to schools by closing down the madrasas
Muslim league would be best option for India.
@@aadilansari5997 correct Muslim league can convince Its followers that there is a hidayat of hijrat in the holy book 😀
We should support I.N.D.I alliance for rulers as Shaikh Shahjahan, Sandeshkhali, Weast Bengal !!!!!
But we can't give vote to Congress and all
So last option is modi only
More power to such independent media as well as bold and daring personality like Dr. Parakala Prabhakar!!!
Truth be told! You are a real man. A great and wise husband and father, India should be proud of you Sir.
Respected Prabhakar, We indians salute you Sir. Your statements are True and Fact. The government should use him as an economic advisor. Worth for bravery award. God bless you Sir.
Don’t salute so easily.
Outstanding Prabhakar sir, salute for your transparent comments 🙏👌👍
Please people of India. Vote smartly. Do not vote for goons. We need a change to put a stop to dictatorship.
Mr. Singh had already warned that it would be disastrous. Mr. Singh, who served two terms, was largely peaceful and stable. Mr. Singh sailed India through when the world suffered with recession in 2008. Hats off to him.
Mr Singh who made Indian a fragile 5 candidate ! #abkibaar400paar
In 2014 Gujrat lobby came in to power because of Kejriwal & Anna Hazare team. In 2019 he came in to power because of pulwama. In 2024 fakir jola lekhe bagjayenge.
There are many who still haven't realized that he was the best.and what we are going through is because we failed to make right choice then.we lost the gem.😢and traded for fakes
Yes, he said at the beginning
Mr Singh was a puppet of Soniya Gandhi. What he had done, knows by everyone.
Absolutely right Statement by Hon'ble Prabhakar ji. I salute Hon'ble Respected Shri Prabhakar ji.
Dr P.PRABHAKAR IS A HIGHLY EDUCATED PERSON. HATS OFF TO HIS REPLIES, GREAT MAN.
He nailed the point perfectly at 18:27 - the mentality of the govt truly seems to be "give 5kg rations to the poor, but at the same time, give 5 airports to our friends"... Well said
This guy is a hero to stand up for the people of India
I truly believe that truth will prevail and the Modi Government will be thrown out.
I don't think this is possible now bcz people are soo dumb they only think and vote for religion or caste 😢
Soo much hate in young generation nowadays 😢
@@singh88920very true
@@singh88920If that was the case they would all continually vote for Congress who played that game for years, and still does.
Very unlikely, unfortunately!
Please record this interview in all our regional languages.
Its very important to aware the poor rural areas voters.
TRUE. Every individual should know this.
YES CORRECT
They probably scare them or buy them off. India's poor people are so poor I doubt a lot of them really care.
No one will listen nor care! Cult following is hard to break...
This just reconfirms my belief that our current FM is a scapegoat, she didn't know what she was getting into...
Let's make India a beautiful country for Indians 🎉
Under congress I used to feel abused.So don't generalise
We fully support that. India belongs to all Indians regardless of their religion.
We need to define Indian's as those who thinknof their fellow countrymen as equals and worthy of community.
And Islam free society 🙏🏽
@@Kps123-j6t what do you mean free? When did Islam come with a price tag?
Dr.Parakala Prabhakar is forthright and outspoken. Hope he remains safe. Thank you Karan for this insightful interview. I sincerely wish that the people of India rise to the occasion and vote responsibly.
These arm chair psephologists always are safe! They have nothing to lose. Will not do anything on the ground, it's only the children of the poor who suffer. Looking up to politicians in this country on both sides is a waste of time
Ok whom will you vote?do you have choice
Mr. Prabhakar is as much intelligent as
Mr.Marana Thappad is unbiased.
I always wonder what kind of shit does Marana thappad carries in his mouth for speaking in the way he does.
Thanks Mr Prabhakar! You are a true Indian!
Govt saying inflation is only 7%. 2 years ago the bus price was 100 now it's 200. But my salary is not doubled .
Dr Prabhakar is "forthright, outspoken,and independent" as Karan Thapar introduces his program.
Mr Prabhakar is not able to convince his wife.
I wish him good luck when returning home .. god knows what this poor man has to endure at the hands of his wife today
Karan Thapar is a bold Question to Dr Prabhakar n Thank's to clear concept of correct New's GOD Bless You Both 🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿💞
@@blackpanther0990lol, she has no idea what she is doing anyway as can be seen by the state of the economy.
@@sandeepnerurkar4918she's chosen hers. Not very decent of karan thaper to slip that in the intro. What's the relevance?
Thanks to Dr. Pravakar for raising his voice to save the democracy
Yes
How an interview to 3rd class RUclips journalist save democracy?
@@PULKITKAUL-greatbecause first class journalist nothing front of RUclips JOURNALISTS
@@manavgill1763 crying against one man is not journalism. Rahul Gandhi is lazy we can see from his campaign schedule.
This interview should be translated in Hindi so that Majority of Indians could understand
It's a must watch for all Indians
100% agree with you.
So can spread lies as was done by Kasim thappar on behest of Soros and CIA on Indian History and demean Indian image in the world.
100% agree
Yes
Pls
True Brave Indian!
Indeed indeed
May we all be this brave..and never bend before atrocities
He is real Bharat Ratna, 130 crores Indians should.salute him
Not all Bharat Ratan should be respected. See for example, Sachin is promoting gambling apps
BJP will manipulate elections using EVM. Modi is a hard core dictator.
How u know 130 crores sir😂😂 this govt never took indices, we can say around 130
A Bharat Ratna never wants a country to be undergo in slavery. Like your modi.
Are you going to do on behalf of others?
This man Mr Karan Thapar is the reason why our prime minister has no guts to hold a free press conference since his term in the PMO. His one interview has scared the shit out of Mr Mudi
Karan interviewed mr modi long time ago while he was the CM of Gujarat , there...the interview was cut-short as modi left ....
Yes that was in 2007 and now here we are in 2024
Wrong person
He us from the beginning a Modi hater, like Barkha dutt or Rajdeep who were all on congress mercy
This man is not afraid of rogues like Modi/Shah/RSS/BJP. Commendable people of India should stand with him to kick out Modi.
Means in India still rule of law works and not like emergency time. I don't understand nhow modi team is still rogues.
The most important is that he is not afraid of nirmala ji😅😅
We no longer have a government of the people, by the people, for the people. But we have a government of the people, by the people, but as dictated by a facist dictator. Don't let it happen again. Throw BJP out. Don't vote for hell.
*We, the people of India* doing the good or bad as per our obtained Skills & Experience from our respected families as well as our society values & culture, whatever in the form right or wrong.
*Is it not our duty* check & balance? where we stand in the light of Man-made policies and divine teaching & its law.
*Why not?* We the People of India in Search of True Divine Teaching & its law, why should we simply believe in Man-made Religions & Caste-system in India.
What is the purpose of divine teaching & its law from our creator, address to we, the people of the world for our benefits in all sections of our personal and public life.
*Personally,* I can give the name to Daylight as darknight, but I can't change the reality of daylight into Darknight.
*At the end of the day,* what benefits to me and my fan following to my mindset and my strong believed in Caste-system and Man-made religions against divine teaching and its law.
Rightly said that India's democracy become "mockery".
How wise. Now it makes sense on June 4. Listen from 15:00
💯♥️
Agreed with Parakala Prabhakar...❤️❤️❤️
Great analysis 👍👍👍👍
Some people are born with intellect while other have courage. Parakala Prabhakar embodies both. Posterity will remember you, sir. You are speaking at a time when people are in fear and tongue tied. Hats off to you, Parakala Prabhakar!
Salute to you Sir,, for your courageous interview being a husband of a Finance minister..God save this country, Thanks for opening our eyes in many ways//
What courage do you need to criticise a govt. Have you ever seen the govt reacting to his views.Not worth it . Govt has a bus load of better economic advisers .
watching this video on result day June 04 2024..
Bravo PP u have not minced words! U are a man of integrity and morals! Bravo!
Salute to Mr. Pravakar for his true, fearless and bold as well as courageous analysis.
don't trust this guy he is like Double-edged knife
If Modi was a Dictator then Karan Thapar and This Prabhakar Would Be in Jail
@@MysticSage-hg3jh they're all coming together now after 9byears coz they don't want it to go to that full extent. Plus many MANY journalist have been unalived. Read and educate yourslef plz.
@MysticSage-hg3jh elect him 2 more times. That's exactly will happen! That's how it all started in places in history.
@@kamalchoudhury2910 That Will Be Very Good
We'll have to salute and appreciate Mr. Parakala Prabhakar sir for his statements and observations. Great sir 💯💯🙏🙏🙏
Hats off to this man. Wow!!
Modi shouldn't have come to power in 2019. That was itself a disaster. One more term..the consequences would be unimaginable.
I feel so good at looking people like you after Modi & Yogi wins lol 😂 it's so satisfying
But the fact of the matter is come what may, our Modi will be back with a larger Mandate, it's 100%, you can't stop him. He's unstoppable, what Parkala Prabhakar is doing is he's portraying PM in such bad shape, it's a Shame on him
2019 modi won because of pulwama n balakot strikes and opposition parties laziness and lack of strategy how to counter back
@@krisgopi_8 people don't vote on army Operations... BJP is giving freebies to lower class and they are voting him blindly... 80 cr people of india don't know where balakot and Pulwama are located... Modi is directly sending money into people's account and middle men are getting skipped and that's why he is coming power again and again... people don't care who is PM, all they want is money coming into bank accounts every month...
Arun shourie in 2019 asked opposition to av United fight, otherwise it is disastrous. But opposition thugs like mamatha, chandrasekhar jagan mohan AAP didn't
Absolutely healthy and worthwhile discussion
Thank u parakala n thappar sir
Heartbreaking to hear the truth. Why aren’t the news media and even the independent press in India doing their job by reporting on this reality and making the citizens of India aware of the truth 😭😭😭😭 Thank you for this interview 🙏🏽🙏🏽
" independent press .....?' --- are you in slumber ? All democratic institutions are under threat for the past 10 years of Modi / RSS rule !
The Masses doesn't even bother to know the truth. They have such idealistic view of one man that they see past all his fault and risk the future of their country.
Then the media won't be able to generate money. The government gives money to the media channels for their advertisement, and if the media is going to speak the truth, then they won't get money, and Indian people don't want to pay for news channels.
For Example : You are a Russian news reporter Make a report about Putin's criticism in Russia.....
What comes next...????
You would be sued....
Do the same in China....???
@@WildernessFauna-iu7ih countries like Russia and China are not democratic countries while India is. So don't compare India with China or Russia in this parameter. Do instead compare India with U.S.A,France , Britian and the like in democratic parameter.
By comparing it with China, you are indirectly admiting the autocratic character of India nowadays under BJP.
Thank you Dr. Parakala for exposing the truth.
What guts
True patriot
We salute you
India needs you - Hats off and hates off
❤
It's pleasure listening to these two great learned gentleman.
Just amazing. He is undoubtedly a man of courage and integrity.
Great to see there still are educated honest credible people in India. Great interview Dr Parakala & Mr Thapar 👏🏽✌🏽
Huge fan of Karan Sir…. Salute to Parakala Prabhakar Sir for his honesty and showing us the dreadful future ahead in store for us all Indians….. The only way the Democracy can be saved is by speedy intervention of Hon Supreme Court and the decision…. making VVPAT slips counted or removing the machine for maual voting……God bless all my Indians Hindu, Sikh, Parsi, Muslim, Jain, Christian etc…. brothers and sisters …. save India from becoming a Dictatorship. Jai Hind 🙏🏻
I totally agree with the proposition painted by the guest in the interview. Let us see. Next 2 months are very crucial for the future of India. Thanks.
He deserves for Padma Bhushan award for educating and exposing the biggest corruption in the world.
Thoda jyada hochuka sir
Frustrated person
Thank you for speaking the truth... Boycott BJP.
God save India.
God bless you Dr Parakala.
Thank you Karan.
Nirmala sitaraman ko aysi lok sabh seat mili Jo sabko pata hai harne vali hai aur Indian finance minister badalne wala hai so uska gussa hai😂😂😂
It is God alone Who has always been with India, don't you worry! Precisely therefore He sent Modi to this land. To put an end to the utmost corrupt and nepotistic congress.
True Deshbhagt...The whole country salutes you...Sir.
Country won't need your certification
I salute Mr Prabhakar for his true courage and wisdom. Great!. God bless you.
For you guys you will go to any extent to support who are against modi😂, hats off it seems you jokers go do better job
He is an economist and his views are more or less bookish. These economists find fault in everything and they donot give solutions, only highlight the problems. Economists are not practical in their views.
The FM's husband itself saying all this. What more do we need to awaken.
Absolutely true
But he has been saying this all around...so why is the surprise....
But he is no angel as ppl of Andhra know...he is a self Hating hindu who passes as an intellectual and a product of JNU....
So no surprise on ideology.....
The fact ofcourse is he has worked in two parties ....under Chiranjeevi (Praja Rajyam) and CBN (in Telugu Desam)....both are in fact more family run and more dictatorial....
@@anant14 he is now voicing on digital media. Unconcerned abiut his personal religious beliefs, but he is spot on about ruling dispensation. Calling critics anti-hindu is either a phobia or more likely manipulative narrative.
@@Hrynve85 ,
Dear,
He has given similar interviews in print and social media before 2019 election as well.
He is known to be a Hinduphobe and was one of the ppl who claimed Modi as dictator /was anti Modi since many years. (exactly like Karan Thapar).
If somebody has an inveterate hatred towards Hindus and their basic socio-cultural demands (like freeing Temples in AP from govt control...a secular state has no buisiness running Temples in first place), there is no Justification for not calling them as a Hinduphobe.
Such people are proof that there is absolute freedom on public expression in India at present. (since he has been very critical of Modi govt., in public since long....all Telugu audience knows this...since is well known in Telugu media ).
@@anant14 Truth hurts & how. Critics are not Anti-nationals or Hindu phobes.
True patriot. Respect to Dr prabhakar for showing his love to his country 🎉
Well said ...I believed most of the educated Indian have the same opinion specially those who know the clear difference between parliamentary government of India and Dictatorships.
People knew the difference in 1977. Also in 2014,2019 and now in 2024 too.
Change of the central GOVT will be in the best of our national interests.
No! We educated are with Modi.
@@legoooo09
Only a few upper caste educatedg😢😢😢
@@ahmedmalek4758 such a shallow
Anyone after Results
I came back to troll PP