Sask. premier doubles down on breaking carbon-pricing law | Power Play with Vassy Kapelos
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 июн 2024
- Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe reacts to criticism of his government's decision to not submit money it owes under the carbon-pricing law.
Subscribe to CTV News to watch more videos: / ctvnews
Connect with CTV News:
For live updates and latest headlines visit: www.ctvnews.ca/
For breaking news, fast, download the CTV News App: www.ctvnews.ca/app
Must-watch stories and full programs at www.ctvnews.ca/video
CTV News on TikTok: www.tiktok.com/discover/CTV-News
CTV News on X (formerly Twitter): / ctvnews
CTV News on Reddit: / ctvnews
CTV News on LinkedIn: / ctv-news
---
CTV News is Canada's most-watched news organization both locally and nationally, and has a network of national, international, and local news operations.
Vassy, if the carbon tax didn’t exist, then we wouldn’t be talking about rebates!
If Conservatives weren't denying that climate change is increasing costs and causing hardship for Canadians - we wouldn't be talking about about Conservative opposition to a proven market solution.
@@garyhaggquist740.,the market solution requires an equal tax cut to the carbon tax according to the economists that promote it.
@@antiprogpragmatist859 As Alberta economist Trevor Tombe has shown - Canadians who earn less than $250,000 per year get more back in carbon rebates than they pay in carbon tax. Axing the tax would benefit the wealthy. The tax's contribution to inflation is .15% or virtually nothing.
@@garyhaggquist740 ..Trevor Tombe also didn’t factor in the compounding effects of the carbon tax through the supply chain of everything thing that we buy
@@garyhaggquist740 ..btw..that 0.15 percent is a bogus number already debunked by the PBO because that calculation also doesn’t include the compounding effect of the carbon tax through the supply chain
Scott Moe is on the right side oif this argument.
Really? So the programs that benefit Saskatchewan more than other provinces should be eliminated because they're not exactly equal to everyone?
@@lizliz4186 I think he means that the carbon tax is stupid.... Which it is
💯
Come on Vassy the premier is right. The Feds essentially broke their own law by exempting the tax. Sask is also exempting the tax a different way. Neither level of govt is more or less moral than the other. Every province wishes they had the opportunity Sask has.
vassy is acting like a liberal airhead
@@HECK349that’s because she is one of the
Time for the rest of the provinces to stand up!
When do we stand up against amplifying climate chaos?
@@Method9… there is no climate chaos. You’ve been gaslighted into believing it…
Btw…we’ve had a carbon tax for some time now. Obviously it’s done nothing to abate your “climate chaos”..lol
By paying taxes?@@Method9
Guilbeault even said it is OK to dispute climate change but it is not OK to not pay taxes...
@@TBonertonDispute it academically or accept reality. It's been decades and no one has refuted radiative forcing or revolutionized our understanding of the physics of light. There isn't a single university in Canada that disputes climate change.
Vassy...you asked Moe if he had any evidence that the carbon tax achieves nothing. Can you please educate me and provide evidence on what the carbon tax has or does achieve? Thank you. And thank you Scott Moe and Danielle Smith.
Look NO further than BC. There has been a carbon tax for over 10 years. Guess what? C02 still increasing. The trees love it though. So do crops
@@islandaerial3414 100%....we need it. That's how the earth replenishes itself. It's been happening over the last 25,000 yrs since the last ice age lol. Of course the earth is warming up. It's a cycle and a tax won't stop it.
You forgot to mention that the government loves excessive taxation.@@islandaerial3414
😂😂😂it makes u pay more to live your life😢 thats all it does. When we are all poor we cant travel😢 its the only upside to the taxe... i could choose mass transportation but theres no bus where i work😂
She asks the questions that he deflects. It's his job to provide evidence, not hers.
Why doesn't Vassi bring up the fact that Quebec doesn't pay equal amounts of carbon tax, but enjoys the rebates?
Right on !!!!!!!!
Ya, Vassi, why is that?
Quebec has a cap-in-trade system that meets the Federal Gov't Climate Change Policy, there are a few formulas that a Province can choose to use, but if they did not the Federal Backstop kicks in.
Because Vassy is smart enough to know that Quebec doesn't participate in the federal carbon tax program. They DON'T get the rebate, neither does BC nor Nunavut nor Yukon nor northwest territories.
Provinces were given the choice of opting in or creating their own program.
Please, try using Google if you have questions. A simple google search of "quebec federal carbon tax rebate" would answer your questions and teach you something new.
@kasparwirz5032 try googling that. Quebec doesn't get the rebates.
Right on.... Or not.
Drop the carbon tax. Save Canada 🇨🇦 ❤
Drop Turdeau and his whole Lieberal cabinet 😂
. What a Lib tool Vassy is.
Vassy, just give it up already .
Vassy went to bat too much for the carbon tax on this one, no one is fooled by Trudeau's carbon tax anymore, especialy when it goes up in a month.
Looking forward to the activists crying about that.
Scott Moe keep your stand on this. Alberta will support you all the way.
How is alberta going to do that?
Bravo Premier Moe . Thank you for your common sense
I love that your common sense is breaking the law. Can't understand what society you think you are a part of...
@@VideoGameMarimbist Not a law actually. It is an offer to contract which, Sask has refused to honour
@@VideoGameMarimbist.. funny how these laws only apply to certain parts of the country and not others
@@antiprogpragmatist859You mean the parts of the country that haven't already implemented their own carbon tax programs? Yeah, it's funny how much influence big oil's lobbying garners them in the face of the common sense being advocated by all of our universities.
The law is non-sensical.
I'm from saskatchewan. The feds can shove their rebate. This is a similar approach to the covid restrictions from Ottawa. Comply or else. Kick rocks
💯
Guilbeault is beyond immoral
Based on?
The goofy way he looks is enough for a start.@@Method9
@@Flavor_FlavHow about you stop using fossil fuels and pay none?
Vassy, you seem thick skulled in this interview. Asking the same question and receiving great responses. And she still doesn’t understand why Scott Moe broke the law. Yet liberal politicians break the law all the time and no one calls them out on it. Not even the RCMP. Weak!!!
Her handlers are paid well for her to pretend she doesn't understand.
She's Paid to destroy anyone against the immoral establishment.
Carbon tax is not the solution, but only creates more problems. I hope that other provinces join SK.
Based on what data? Your feelings?
Nah, the largest ever study on carbon pricing proves that it works at lowering fossil fuel emissions growth rates. Conservatives refuse to acknowledge the threat that climate change poses.
@@lizliz4186Pfff and where's the data that a tax would influence the climate in any way?
Have any alternative plans to the carbon tax been offered as solutions? No? Nobody has any plans to replace it with anything. If we don't implement a market solution then we'll need to implement actual bans on the harmful combustions.
@Method9 the carbon tax is not a solution. it doesn't change the fact that I need toheat my home inorder to survive the harsh Canadian winter. and that I'm going to use natural gas (one if the cleanest burning fuels avaliable) to do so. We are being taxed too extreme levels and life is nearly unaffordable
You’re absolutely right Preimer Scott Moe. Guilbeault has no grounds to accuse you of anything as he himself has committed immoral acts
Guilbeault did nothing immoral, what are you talking about?
Right, so someone else did wrong so he can do wrong?
What a messed up way to justify doing wrong.
@@Method9Really? He has a criminal record and is applying his ideology on Canadians! The Liberal motto is we are doing what Canadians want? No Canadians didnt want or need a carbon tax period!
No, just stupid and juvenile.@@Method9
@@Method9 Taxes are immoral. Unless you are a parasite and use other peoples hard earned currency to further your pathetic life. ie: Gov't services
"But you're breaking the law!"
An unjust law that's not applied equally across the country shouldn't be adhered too. Everyone forgets about QC paying squat.
Guilbeault calling someone else immoral lol
Guibeault has worn orange suit twice, so who's he to jail anybody.
Yeah, pot...kettle..
Hey vassy. How come you dont get trudeau on and interrogate him on the numerous crimes he's committed? I can think of a couple reasons why you would never do that.
Thank you Premier Moe!
Saskatchewan did not break the carbon tax contract that was applied nationally! Apparently Quebec BC, and then the Maritimes were all given special circumstances. It was already broken when Saskatchewan decided not to collect it anymore on behalf of the feds.
Trudeau has broken so many laws, makes Moe look like a king.
Who bought the studies she quotes and who is paying her to try and discredit any counter tactic against lunacy and tierany
Ignore this clueless bought-out reporter... way to go Scott Moe.. FJT
Nice to see someone standing up to Trudeau.😊
Would be nice if all other Provinces got on board with this.
Axe the tax
Yeah, just straight ban combusted oil and gas products ASAP.
Axe it and then what? Unmitigated climate damages for the whole country! How responsible.
@@Method9 the liberals haven’t reached any climate targets. The carbon tax was a big oil scheme so they wouldn’t solely taxed. The average person doesn’t produce much carbon it’s industry and wealthy ppl who produce the most carbon and military. Do research
It is a federally "ordered" tax.
It is NOT a law.
"I will not comply."-Scott Moe
@@Viewpoint11good luck with that. Maybe Vassy will interview you as CRA carts your stuff away.
Hey Vassey. Play fair
Danielle Smith needs to do this in Alberta
She can't. We don't have our energy as a crown corporation.
I hope she does so that we can lock her up before she steals all Canadians' CPP
@@Viewpoint11Alberta has to pay money to subsidize Manitoba and other have not provinces some how, can’t afford to drop their income tax rates.
@@shanereese3935 exactly. she even unfroze the tax at the pump then turned around and blamed the feds. I'm not for JT at all but i can see she and Moe for that mater are doing things that hurt their province then they blame JT for it. Something he has no control over and Smith, Moe and Pierre's base is blind to it. their hatred for JT is blinding them to what actually is going on within their own provinces
Guilbeaut is very familiar with breaking laws
and with being held accountable for his actions.
@@Method9 And becomes more of a martyr for "the cause" every time he is, in his overheated mind anyway.
@@freddexta3363Guilbeault has been approving fossil fuel expansion while he has been working for the liberals. I don't think he's a martyr in anyone's mind, not anymore, least of all his own.
😊 well done Scott Moe!!!
Great job Scott Moe!
If Federal government do not treat fairly , let all go for independence .
How’s the weather in Russia comrade.
@@Flavor_FlavOnly someone wishing ill will on Canada would wish for separation. Russia comes to mind when I think of a regime that would love to see that. Da!
@@peters9401Russia? The USA is a republic, their states have more power in each state than does the whitehouse where tax and rights and freedoms are concerned...that's why New York and California are like different countries from Texas & Florida on tax, firearms and other important laws....in Russia every square inch of the country has identical laws....like Canada...turns out you're the comrad, comrad.
@peters9401 if the Laurentians elect the Liberals again, the West wants out, and I’m from Saskatchewan.
You clearly don’t understand or even know what Western Alienation is.
Vassy clearly got marching orders on this one. Moe is doing the right thing.
Go ask the PM about all the laws he's broken, time and time again.
Respectfully Vassy, I would have thought you would have supported Saskatchewan on this issue.
Scott Moe is on the right side of this argument.
Lol, yah, breaking the law is a solid place to be. Glad to see conservatives show their true colours
Nothing like a provincial premiere picking and choosing which laws apply to him. Hmmm now why would a neocon politician want immunity from prosecutions?
@@77feyonx how many ethic laws have JT lieberal broken so far? oh not to mention unconstitutional invocation of emergency act
@@Method9 LMAO. "Before" this Premier "picked and choosed" which law appled to him your boy "picked and choosed" which Canadians would have taxes on their home heating and which ones wouldn't.
@@77feyonxNo mention of the continuous and serious law breaking going on in Ottawa like illegally imposing martial law on Canadian's..
A robust democracy needs a opposition....glad to see you are sticking with your boy.
Adding a fee and gst on top of that to heating your home in canadian winters is criminal!
The Liberal government is criminal.
Too bad Doug Ford is Trudeau's bestie, Ontario could use strong leadership like Alberta and Saskatchewan have.
Ford is a shitlib in a blue shirt
Doug Ford can not collect taxes from private companies. Ontario's power generation is not owned by the province therefore those companies will pay carbon tax directly to the government.
@@maryjeanjones7569 All Ford needs to do is be vocal and start hammering Ottawa's unfair Carbon tax rules and zero results.
@@furiousstormrage927 He already started. It's been on the news.
"To be fair..' you always know an insane spin question is coming next.
Bank of Canada actually said CT has impacted inflation..common sense..rising taxes on transportation & agriculture impacts costs on everything & everyone
Yah, but just like 0.15%, small. Not like what Moe and other Connies like you implying that it's big to scare ppl.
A tenth of a percent while we continue to print our money as debt and climate damages from continuing to simp for oil climb into the billions each year
Why is that no one is bringing up the fact that the carbon tax is not having any effect on carbon. Which also begs the question, why take money on one hand and return it via a rebate on the other hand. All that is doing is creating a new breaurocracy that the government has to finance. It sounds to be like a lose-lose proposition with no end in sight.
Money laundering within the gov't. It's like a cup game.
Why it is so hard to understand?
Increase in production cost = increase in retail price....
Basic economics.
Soon as vassy fired in with a reply starting with "I get that BUT" I knew where she stood , she likes the carbon tax. I don't understand how no one can do the math, literally get a note pad and write down every single dollar you pay in carbon tax until your next rebate, I can guarantee the number on the note pad will be vastly larger than the rebate amount. It's that simple but vassy doesn't do math she just doesn't like scott moe or resistance to the carbon tax.
This woman reporter is obviously talking the federal side. What is she talking about?? I don’t get any carbon tax rebate. She cares nothing about the enormous hardship this carbon tax is causing. She should be fired.
Way to go moe👍🏼
Time for Wab Canoe to grow a spine and stand up to our immoral liberal/ndp coalition as well!
I doubt it. He’s Turdeau’s buddy
He already suspended our fuel tax which clearly helped.
@@trigremlinhow is it right that a have not province lowers taxes in his province but still receives tax dollars from other provinces to subsidize them?
Bite the hand? Lol he won't
Break the law? Just get your own "special rappoteur" to say it is OK!
Citizens and leaders must disobey immoral baseless laws. Endless tax if theft. We can’t keep giving more and more to the government who gives it away to other countries, wars, and themselves.
Scott great job. I totally support what you’re doing. 8 don’t support Vassy near as much. (Winnipeg)
Lucky for her, she's not a politician and doesn't need your support!
But, to be fair, you're supporting her by watching this video. So.. great job!
@@stratford374lol that’s right, all vassey needs is just is Trudy’s tax dollars
Funny she doesn’t drill the sitting federal government like that
Vassy. 100% on the wrong side of this.
YO! Vassy!! If you are soooooooooooooo upset that Saskatchewan is "Breaking the law", then call the cops. Go on! What are you waiting for?
She is interrogating and not interviewing. Be a journalist not a Liberal stooge. You could play a drinking game with the amount of times she says 'breaking the law'.
Law breakers don’t like being told that they're breaking the law.
She did same to Trudeau's ministers.
I don't like all her questions to Moe, but still want to know his answers.
@@ewal36100%
Wonder were Doug Ford is for standing up for Ontario. We sure need a Danielle Smith, in Ontario.
Doug Ford doesn’t even stand up while he pees. What makes you think he’s gonna stand up for his province?
Sorry, she's taken. But Ford might yet grow a spine, who knows. We can only hope..
You guys in Ontario should push Ford, either make him another Moe or Smith, or kick him out next time.
How many laws have the Federal Government broke Vassy??
Exactly!
Sorry it is only an hour long program so not enough time to go through the list.
Way to go Moe!!!
Where is the accountability of the Federal government. The stones on this Liberal cheerleader.
I payed 24.00 on my gas bill this month to heat my home. Bill was 110.00. carbon tax is going up x4. What damage Trudeau and his liberals and NDP are doing to Canada
The law is not valid in my opinion.
Great job Mr. Moe
I didn't know that Vassey was the Law....
You have a guy who has a record that is trying to make laws that suit him and that the tv lady is sticking up for him she should be fired also
Seen this reporter in many interviews. You can tell she is also fed up with the federal government and I love it.
What a joke….Equating the GST with the carbon tax is like equating apples and oranges.
What about expecting the premiere to remove his own provincial sales tax on home heating before expecting the feds to do it?
It's Saskatchewans choice , they can do what they want in their province ,
"Screw the West win the rest" said theTrudeaus
It is about time politicians stand up to unfair treatment for Canadians. Too bad more premiers stood up to this ridiculous tax.
Im in Nova Scotia and the home heating oil fuel price change is a joke it was supposed to drop 14 cents/liter but it didnt. . im paying 6 cents/liter less which is nothing concidering im paying $1.62 to $1.72 with fluctuating weekly prices.
Scott Moe is a Canadian hero standing up to the criminals in Ottawa and refusing to be a victim of political extortion
The bank of canada analysis was superficial at best. Why they don't understand ?
Go Moe!👍
if he's worried about the carbon tax, remove the provincial carbon tax on fuel. it'll cut the pumps 13-15 cents a litre. Sask collects the highest provincial carbon tax for fuel in Canada. usually Scott Moe follows whatever Alberta does....well they removed that a long time ago, same with Manitoba.
Because that benefits everyone, he's really only trying to help the farmers not everyone.
@@lizliz4186 Huh? Everyone uses heating fuel, not just farmers. In fact plenty of farmers use woodstoves because they make economic sense and so many are less impacted by the carbon tax. Also, Alberta brought the provincial tax on clear road fuel back again since beginning of January as per the law that the tax is only reduced or taken off when the price of oil is above a certain level. And at the moment oil is too low for that to happen
Different issue, but yes, that should be cut as well.
I find this discussion confusing. The federal Ctax reg syas that the feds can never use revenues collected in one province to fund rebates in another province. Any rebates allocated in Sask have to come, 100%, from Ctaxes collected in Sask. It is not possible for the feds to rebate more than they collect in any gicen province, unless they are breaking the federal Ctax rule.
Let’s vote 🎉
Flush it
Liberals NDP let it make skid marks on the way out.
I’m 100% to vote ☑️ Poilievre!!
What is the point of collecting a tax and then givint out rebates anyway?
Shes in JTs pocket 😂
I don't agree. Have you watched her other interviews with Liberal ministers? It's her job to ask challenging questions and question politician's accountability.
Let’s go Moe!
Federal taxes need to be applied evenly, all across the country.
Canada has changed in the last 8 years. And Trudeau is pitting east versus west.
In Ontario, the mortgage delinquency rate is up 135.2 per cent compared with a year ago, and B.C.’s rate rose by 62.2 per cent.
Vassy serns frustrated with his answers, yet he's parroting most of what she's been saying and complaining about
She's trying to argue that this isn't just a benefit for Atlantic Canada yet that's what she's been saying for months.
Come on vassy.
The carbon tax should be illegal
Because you don't believe in climate change?
Because how do taxes collected change the weather?@@Method9
Why are Quebec getting rebates, when not paying??
Don't these reporters do any homework before interviewing guests. She certainly didn't look like someone who was up to speed on the issue. It's downright embarrassing or at least it should be for them.
Go Moe!
We have your Back! Do not remit!🇨🇦💙💪
Way to go Scott - If all the premiers of Canada would follow his example maybe Trudeau and his Liberal/NDP partnership would get the hint and stop punishing Canadians.
Right on Moe I guess the feds broke the law to when the carved out Atlantic Canada!
She says he didn't answer the question, but he did, a few times. 45% of rural residents are going to get double the carbon rebate. They also pay more than that in carbon tax. The carbon tax is affecting ALL of our purchases. Look at shipping bills. You are paying shipping and carbon tax! It doesn't get any more factual than that.
The carbon tax is indeed a wealth redistribution policy.
Great questions Vassy. I like the fact that when politicians dont answer your questions, you call them out.
The other way to stand up against the fraud from the feds, the provinces no longer remit GST, Carbon Tax, etc for the feds. Therefore if provinces do collect taxes, keep in province
He only scrapped it on home heating (natural gas), and he is going to drop it on electricity too. But we still pay a carbon tax on everything. You would be amazed if you realized that alot of ppl don't know this. Lol 🤦♂️ 🤦♂️
Scott Moe is such a badass!!!!! 😂
Thanks for standing up to unfairness!
You go Scott Moe keep representing Our Province 👍😊
I have to think that CTV's host and CBC's host will both be fired after the next election because they are so partisan. What happened to responsible reporting?
Vassy who is in your ear?
we all pay more than we get back, gezuz christ
Why does natural gas cost four times as much in Halifax than anywhere else in the country?
NS pays enormous amounts for heat and electricity, and the highest taxes in the country.
That what you get for voting for tr