Midjourney vs DALL·E 3 | Ultimate Comparison (Best AI Image Generator)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 июн 2024
- In this video we will compare best AI Image generators, DALLE 3 and Midjourney v5.2. We will create AI images with different artistic style using the same prompt for Midjourney and DALLE 3. Watch till the end to find out which AI Image generator is the best!
Blog post on our website with images and their prompts
catalystmedia.ai/dall-e-3-vs-...
DALLE 3 Full Guide
catalystmedia.ai/how-to-use-d...
00:00 Intro
00:20 Cartoon
01:28 Photorealism
02:52 Abstractionism
03:23 Pop Art
03:59 Pixel Art
04:38 Minimalism
05:26 Vintage
06:10 Hand-Drawn
06:42 Final Thoughts
I really hope Dall-e will improve realistic looking images as midjourney's images looks amazingly real.
Fr im so excited to see updates
I have been using DALLE for weeks and you can improve the images a little more if you put things like photo-realism or ultra detailed or cinematic style etc. ( in chatgpt plus version )
@@epopeyasantiguascan the chat gpt plus version create a image with consistent look to tell a story?
@@olayinkaolabode6159 i havent tried it but there are several tutorials about it on YT
yes by using the new addons @@olayinkaolabode6159
And deduct a point from DALLE for all its over zealous restrictions, censorship and rules. Add a point to Midjourney for its large number of tools.
This video is exactly what I was about to make. It is a good and fair comparison of the two. I am currently using both Midjourney and Dall E 3. Have been using them for a week now and I will say your assessment is accurate.
The biggest difference is that Midjourney is amazing at creating realistic faces, beautiful faces, sure. But is weak in terms of listening to your prompt. It's actually quite stupid. For example, my prompt says "a woman holding a spear." And it shows a woman holding swords or some deform weapon that is a combination of different weapons.
Dall E 3 would nail that no problem. But sometimes Dalle 3 would mess up the faces, the eyes, or blend different prompt into each other. In summary, Dalle 3 is definitely more accurate in listening to the details of your prompt for sure.
DALLE-3 cant make weapons because it thinks the images might cause harm or represent harm or violence.. so yeah....
The PopArt point goes to MidJourney. Just because DallE made everything look like a Lichtenstein litho doesn't qualify it as pop art. It showed limited range in the test subjects you provided. Also, the last one was up for grabs. I'd say there were about 50:50 and no clear winner. Thanks for this video, I've been looking for something like this for a while.
I totally agree with you. They each have their strengths. However I do NOT agree with this gentleman's picks!
The points given are entirely my opinion, you can ignore them and award your points based on the images and choose a winner. However, if we take human-made pop art as a basis, then DALLE 3 is much closer to this style and follows the prompt better. Also, I didn't get Midjourney's results on the first try, I regenerated the prompt 3-4 times because if it's not photorealism, it creates something completely unrelated. And you can still see those weird lips in the middle, the low-detail lipstick, and random shapes in the background.
Thank you very much for this video, it was really useful. Keep up the comparison of these 2 periodically as the programs evolve 🙏
Midjourney is good for photorealistic images. Dall-e (which is now integrated into chatgpt) is good for using normal language but then the results are a little bit weird and too stylistic.
I agree. I use both in the process of generating ideas for my architecture projects and I find midjourney to be more on the spot.
In the vintage photos category, I think Dall-E 3 was the clear winner. Midjourney looked more like modern photography with filters pretending to be vintage. Maybe that's what you want, but that's not what the category was supposed to measure.
I love this comparison!
I hope that Dalle 3 can improve its photorealistic capabilities in the future.
Enjoyed watching this. Good job
So im curious. Does Dalle learn to create better or more accurate images through people using it and trying to give more detailed prompts or is it just updated by the developers to gain more accuracy?
Prefer Midjourneys more subtle and photorealistic style.
again, this is art and very subjective.
Sorry for the dumb question. But is it possible to keep change details about the image you create? So you can slowly but steady correct the same image further and further?
Currently it is only possible with Midjourney. You can use the Variations or Inpainting feature for that purpose.
u r great, for story yt channel which one u advise, dall e or midjourney?
@@ai.catalyst
True! Midjourney style is conventional, no surprise it is very good with realistic images. I like DALL E 3 more because it is more experimental, and I get more ideas from it.
By me, mid is best.
I still think Midjourney is a better AI Art generator. I admit I may be biased, but if you want to up your AI art prompt game then Midjourney is better because it uses discord and even though you are using AI, you are still creating in a community amongst other artists and humans through channels and learning new techniques from other humans... It has that perfect balance between AI and human. As an AI generative artist you will learn, explore and improve your AI art prompts way faster with Midjourney than Dall-E3.
"Prompt game" for Midjourney is a myth. I've created over 6000 images with Midjourney, and I can say that it can create visually appealing images, but it completely ignores huge portions of your prompts, no matter how well you describe or phrase them by adding camera model names, artist names, shutter speed, and other unnecessary words alike. You may randomly get an image close to your prompt and think that you are now a “pro at the prompt game”, but this is pure luck and coincidence. Try to re-roll it and you will get completely different results. It only works well with short prompts. For me, an AI image generator should not be a slot machine. Its goal is to take every detail from the user's prompt and put them together in a clear and connected way in the final image. Midjourney only works well with short prompts and photorealistic images and is more like an image compiler than a true AI image generator. Although I agree that the community is great and you can learn and get inspiration from there.
Great summary actually. No fluff, just the information, and at an appropriate pacing. Even the music was decent.
If only Dalle did not have many restrictions. I cant edit my own face photos. Would be nice to edit a picture by changing to formal dress for example.
Dalle doesn't handle all text well. I've been encountering many spelling errors, repeated words, and mumbo jumbo. However, I'm sure it'll get better! Great vid!
Can I use midjourney for modification of my own pictures?
Are these apps or websites or both? How can know I'm downloading the correct apps ?
This was very well produced and presented!
Great comparison vid, thnks for this
And how about LimeWire (formerly Bluewillow), is the image quality comparable to Midjourney?
hello could this allow me to add one of my images to this avatar?
How's character consistency and art consistency?
So fukin cool DALL-E 3 Damn its crazy🔥
Mid Journey's ultra-realistic images are breathtaking
Dont forget that midjourney also has niji which can create anime art that looks like it was a screenshot
DALL E3 is def top tier atm as it is super precise when it comes to prompts, the only thing is its super restricted but there are many work arounds
Remember, that's where the Niji is.
I think Mid is more professional, in Mid we need to understand function setup and prompts.
I see your point, but I think DALLE 3 is more impressive in this regard. After creating over 6000 images with Midjourney, I've come to the conclusion that it can create visually appealing images, but sometimes it completely ignores huge portions of your prompts, no matter how well you describe or phrase them. For me, the main goal of an AI image generator is to take every detail from the user's prompt and put them together in a clear and connected way in the final image. Midjourney only works well with short prompts and photorealistic images, and is more like an image compiler than a true AI image generator. I think v6 will solve this problem, Midjourney already has a great visual component, they just need to make it more responsive to prompts and train it using more images with different art styles.
@@ai.catalyst I understand your point of view. Midjourney has "Midjourney faces". it is easy to generate good pictures with Midjourney, but they all look the same because of the strong AI correction. I always had to try to destroy the "Midjourney face" and create my original facial style.
On the other hand, DALLE3 has a strong language understanding, so I think the AI's interpretation is less likely to twist everything. So you are right.
It is an interesting comparison because the two AIs have different cores but the two converge.
P.S. Thanks for reply! Good discussion.
I am not a native English speaker, so please forgive my cheap English.
I'm using Limeware
Midjourney is just good for realism. Chat-GPT is a lot more accurate with the prompt input
DALLE-3 is great for amateurs and kids that want to create cartoons and cheap clip art.
I agree
Midjourney images seem spirited. As if theres a wise creative soul crafting them. Its wild. And spooky.
Great work, it's helpful as I'm wondering whether or not to resub to MJ.
DALL-E 3 won't do for photos of any kind. It always makes them look like CGI renders with exaggerated smoothing and lighting effects.
So what is the best at the moment?
I thought both were good... the Dalle is more 3D-type drawing, while the MidJourney is more realistic... so for me I like the realism more MidJourney is better.
😮😮
Dall-E's photorealistic photos look cartoonish around the eyes...and what on earth was with the first woman's jaw line?
Oops..!!! Page not found!
🎉
This is a strange comparison... DALL E will draw any style you ask for or it'll choose one at random for you
Logo Design - DALL-E is much better
Bing gives you like 4 pictures
Photo-realistic is 100 better in MidJourney!!!
Who likes Dall-e 3
👇
Any good image generator that supports nsfw side of things?
Two questions. 1) When I use Dall-E 3 in Chat GPT, it adds text to images but *constantly* makes spelling errors. It's so frustrating. How do you fix that? 2) I understand both take text prompts, but I thought MidJOurney takes photo prompts? Is that not true? Why wasn't that mentioned in your comparison? Thanks!
You can regenerate the images until it gets the text right , or shorten the text if it's too long. If you have Photoshop, you can use generative fill to correct spelling errors. In most cases, Photoshop recreates the font style perfectly and can replace the misspelled letters. Midjourney can take photo prompts but DALLE can't because Midjourney has more features which I mentioned near the end of the video. This comparison was specifically for text prompts.
I wonder if Dalle allows you to create more sexier women? Midjourney is so prudish.
Why you want sexy women
🤨
dall-e has more restrictions, i only wrote beautiful and it told me that it's against the policy. Yep......
Dall-e is not free.
Mid journey has much stronger atmosphere.
that is the problem in most ai image generation they look cartoon and shiny they cant beat midjourney
Dall-E is just cartoonish kids play, no matter how realistic you want, Dall-E can't deliver it, where Midjourney is a matured adult, which provides extremely good pictures. If you ask it it to be realistic pictures, it generates realistic, no fuss.
Its free tho, not 10 or 30 bucks a month
I never try Dalle 3, but Midyourney have huge problem with hands, teeth, jewerly around hands etc....
Nope. Have you tried it recently?
Ai replace please help me
yeah, no. Dall e-3 is being censored to hell and is not even funny anymore.
The biggest difference in dall e 3 is free
The video is good. Kindly add one more point which is probably the decider for a lot of stakeholders that AI image generator caters to. And that point is "RESOLUTION". Dall E 3 can only generate images on 1024X1024, whereas Midjourney can generate images at a given resolution. I already had Midjourney, after seeing this video I thought of trying Dall E 3, now I'm stuck with this "RESOLUTION" limitation which pretty much renders all the edge Dalle E had over Midjourney futile.
Mid journey is opposed with realism 😂😂😂
I guess i will cheat on you midjourney
GUYS GUYS u all are saying DALL E can’t do photo realism and while Midjouney is better, DALL E 3 can do VERY realistic images if you prompt it with like a simple “A dog” or tell chat gpt to prompt DALL E with “A dog” TRUST ME you will like the results. You can also use my custom GPT FutureFusion which can make better DALL E images!
Looks like realism is for midjourney and cartoon/abstract or any kind of art goes to Dall-E
biased bruh
I like Midjourney more but the Dall-3 images look more useable for a thumbnail.
All AI images are copied from photos and illustrations!
Although Dall-e was more accurate I think Midjourney is far more pleasing to the eye overall.
DALL-E 3 photorealism is not "nice". it's absolutely horrible.
DALL-E 3 is definitely photorealistic, but by no means realistic. As a matter of fact, this was a deliberate choice. DALL-E 2 was able to generate perfectly realistic photographs...
You are REALLY really biased towards Dall-E :D Even in the comments you reply to all people that disagree trying to argue your point! :D I would have give most points to MidJourney. The pop art by MidJourney was pretty bad though.
DALL E was definitely better than Midjourney when it came out. It's not just about the aesthetics of the images, but also how much of your prompt is actually used to create the image. Midjourney v5 felt more like an advanced search engine. Now that v6 is out and DALL E has been censored into oblivion, they are pretty much on the same level.
@@ai.catalyst And you are doing it again! :D hahahahaha Most people don't give a damn. The image you referenced where Midjourney apparently didn't add something you mentioned, I was so confused about what you even mean. The Midjourney picture looked 5x better, but you gave the point to Dall-E because of a prompt detail I was not even noticing.
It's like a woman waiting for her man to do something wrong so she can cheat. 😂😂 "I cheated because he cooked the pasta too long.. the relationship was wonderful but the pasta? That's a no go" Thats the level you are on with this. :D I want images that look good, if there are some details missing, I don't care as long as the overall image is good.
The logos looked 10x more professional on midjourney but you gave it a tie? lmao (that's me saying this after having a logo for one of my companies done by Dall-E 3)
You are looking for perfection rather than quality.
Award your personal points and feel free to use the image generator you need for your purposes. This is just a comparison and my opinion. My point is that it doesn't have to be a slot machine and you will feel the difference when it is your prompt/request and you don't see the details you need.
DALL-E 3 is not even in the same ballpark
disagree, at this comparison its a clear tie
As an artist there is just some special sauce in MJ that keeps it above others.
MJ is Coke, Dall-e is Pepsi...the rest are Mountain Dew. 😉
That special sauce is the stylize parameter. It basically ignores portions of your prompt and creates something that Midjourney knows it can create well. The result is beautiful and photorealistic, but if you analyze it further, you'll see that it's not exactly what you asked for. As long as Midjourney creates the best faces, it will be considered "the best" AI image generator. In addition, this may be due to the psychology of a “premium image generator”, that is, since you have to pay for it, it is the best.
But I like mountain dew