Whisky vs CrossOver: Which is BEST for Windows gaming on Mac?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 145

  • @tomluptowski
    @tomluptowski 19 дней назад +244

    apple should purchase crossover, incorporate it into the os and make it transparent to just run windows apps and games

    • @teachingwithipad
      @teachingwithipad 19 дней назад +31

      they won’t they want metal api as a standard

    • @Nik.leonard
      @Nik.leonard 19 дней назад +28

      Please NO. Crossover collaborate a lot with the Wine project, and apple will kill that.

    • @ZaberfangX
      @ZaberfangX 19 дней назад +10

      apple can do what valve is doing giving support

    • @RobertMayfair
      @RobertMayfair 19 дней назад +2

      They should just have a consumer level program based on GPTK that does this

    • @Nik.leonard
      @Nik.leonard 19 дней назад +5

      @@ZaberfangX But they will not do that. They insist on wanting developers to develop macOS native games for selling them in the Apple Store, not in another store like Steam or Epic.

  • @wileysneak
    @wileysneak 19 дней назад +23

    i think its important to shout out Whisky. people will try Whisky to run their programs, if it doesn't work, they may try crossover (if its within their $ means) -- i think by not talking about Whisky to try and drive traffic/sales to CrossOver, with the intention of supporting the development of wine is a noble goal, but I think you'd see better results from getting more people on Macs gaming using Whisky, then seeing those people switch to CrossOver as/when they need to. basically i think whisky is a valid sales pipeline to crossover
    i personally use both crossover and whisky for different programs - but not everyone can afford a license and we shouldn't keep secrets! :)

    • @zerominuseleven
      @zerominuseleven 19 дней назад +2

      Great point. For some whisky can be the gateway drug

    • @wileysneak
      @wileysneak 19 дней назад +2

      @@zerominuseleven this is a far more elegant way of saying what i'm getting at, yes!

    • @gamerinsaan1794
      @gamerinsaan1794 7 дней назад +1

      i just cracked crossover

    • @wileysneak
      @wileysneak 7 дней назад

      @@gamerinsaan1794 this is a great reason to use whisky instead, when you run cracked software you're running unofficial code that could theoretically be doing anything - unless you go massively out your way to vet it

    • @hollymolly394
      @hollymolly394 2 дня назад

      How much CrossOver costs?

  • @latrellebrown7916
    @latrellebrown7916 18 дней назад +11

    You sold me on CrossOver. Honestly. Mechanical Engineer here, and also I am a programmer. Why you sold me on CrossOver, although I am a person who will not pay for movies, I torrent, I pay for games, I like to support those that help build them, and I hope to keep them employed. Whiskey, at first, was more of what I was looking for, I want to be able to play the games I like to play on my desktop, on my Mac. Why should I have to pay to be able to do this? As a programmer, I want things to just work, not sort of work, but.... just work. Sometimes that comes at a cost. I also like to support those that help me achieve this. While whiskey seems like it gets me close enough, and I could easily just ignore the games that don't work on it, efficiency(time), and overall sweeping effort applied by the team with CrossOver is preferable. Time is money. That is meant in both ways, saving me time on the back end, but also the CrossOver team spending the time to make these things work and keep up that effort. I would also add, I like to support my torrenting community as well. I am about to pick this one up, and now that I have purchased a Macbook, I honestly think when it comes to laptops, this may be my go to for the future, I plan to do reviews, edit videos and coding. I love PC's, and that will never change for gaming, but a Macbook will also be in my repertoire.

  • @RiccardoMerloVegan
    @RiccardoMerloVegan 19 дней назад +45

    Well said, we need to support CrossOver

    • @stephanemignot100
      @stephanemignot100 19 дней назад +1

      They make money with Valve no?

    • @RiccardoMerloVegan
      @RiccardoMerloVegan 19 дней назад +2

      @ who? Ho invest time to code needs to be paid, especially if their work is beneficial to all.

    • @stephanemignot100
      @stephanemignot100 19 дней назад +1

      @@RiccardoMerloVegan They make money with Proton, I bought it once, I did my part

  • @andreanastro6189
    @andreanastro6189 19 дней назад +10

    MacBook Air m3 8/256 here, tested with Dragon Ball Sparking Zero and Whisky performs way better, with zero stuttering and 4-5 fps more consistently with standard configuration. Still, the answer is always to have crossover and whisky both installed and try the game you want on both, and then use every game on the app where it works better.

  • @nikodunk
    @nikodunk 19 дней назад +7

    Hey! I didn’t know Crossover helped support Wine! I’ve been using and enjoying Whisky for a year, and didn’t know that I was using an older Wine version, either! I’ll buy a crossover license then!

  • @OGTechh
    @OGTechh 19 дней назад +42

    Ahh, wait, I thought CrossOver is a subscription? Like, I pay 60 euros for one year, and after that year, I can’t use CrossOver anymore. But as I understand it, I have the latest version of CrossOver released during that year forever?

    • @wileysneak
      @wileysneak 19 дней назад +9

      you can find it less for 60 euros by using aff links, but yes you get a year of updates and get to keep the last version you updated to within that year, forever

    • @andreaslassak2111
      @andreaslassak2111 19 дней назад +1

      Mno. You had to pay every year. Like me.

    • @shock9616
      @shock9616 19 дней назад +18

      What you're paying for with CrossOver is support, not the app itself. When you pay for a license, you get 1 year of updates, following which you will not be able to use future versions until you purchase a new license, but you CAN continue using the latest version that you had while your license was active.
      For example, if you bought a license last year that expired today, you could continue using version 24.0.5 forever, but you would not be able to upgrade past that until you paid for another license.

    • @mario.crn_
      @mario.crn_ 17 дней назад +1

      ​@@wileysneak where can I find these links? Are they safe tho ?

    • @wileysneak
      @wileysneak 16 дней назад

      @@mario.crn_ andrew himself has done crossover promotions in the past with % off deals

  • @MikaMoupondo
    @MikaMoupondo 14 дней назад +1

    If you are a Mac user and want to keep the adventure going, you have to support the community. If you don't have the money I can understand, but these guys are putting in work to make our struggle possible. I bought crossover after learning more about the company. When I had no money, if I am honest... I still was using crossover through different means. I ended up buying and paying my respect when I could. Save 10 dollars here and there and in no time, you can buy it.

  • @dogoku
    @dogoku 19 дней назад +11

    Codeweavers are good guys, they offer lifetime licences.

    • @merbudd
      @merbudd 14 дней назад +1

      For almost FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS. that's like if I bought a mac mini then bought a whole another one just to play games. just pirate it.

  • @mannkeithc
    @mannkeithc 16 дней назад

    I agree, I am CrossOver fan and subscriber and appreciate the work they do. I am especially thankful for the new CrossOver preview releases that allows you to experience what's being worked on for the next stable release. The preview version has increased the number of Windows games you can run on your Mac and made it simpler to install and improve the way some existing games run, such as Elite Dangerous, without the need for manually installing fixes / workarounds and resolved launcher issues.

    • @gianlucagrasso4349
      @gianlucagrasso4349 15 дней назад

      Hi @mannkeithc, I'm interested in what you're saying about Elite Dangerous. Are you saying that _today_ you're able to play it (the Odyssey version) through CrossOver? This could be (literally) a game changer :)

    • @mannkeithc
      @mannkeithc 15 дней назад

      @@gianlucagrasso4349 Yes, but I am currently running it using the latest version of CrossOver Preview. You install a Steam bottle, log in to Steam and install Elite Dangerous. It is an "out of the box" install, so no additional patches / fixes required. Plus the launcher is fully functional, so you can select which of the game you want to run but it defaults to Odyssey. I enabled Metal graphics support and Msync in CrossOver, but you need to disable Steam Input for the controller to work when Metal graphics is enabled. Shader precompiling is much faster with Metal graphics enabled, plus cockpit details, like red lights in cross bar are fully rendered.

  • @chandra12816
    @chandra12816 17 дней назад

    Every time I think about wanting a comparison or a game, this guy delivers amazing content the very next day! Keep up the awesome work!

  • @frogsty1764
    @frogsty1764 17 дней назад +3

    This video being secretly sponsored by crossover

  • @daniahmed
    @daniahmed 16 дней назад +2

    I would love to see the same comparison, but between crossover and parallels desktop.

  • @mvaneijgen
    @mvaneijgen 18 дней назад +1

    In one of your Whisky streams you'd mentioned installing your games outside of the bottle, I'm really intrigued by this. Did you ever make a guide about this? BTW your point are great about CrossOver going to make the jump soon. Keep up the good work!

  • @OliviaFel
    @OliviaFel 19 дней назад +3

    I love CrossOver, have purchased a license before, want to support the devs, but the yearly license model is extremely off putting in a landscape of everything being a subscription. It's just really expensive for a lifetime subscription so I completely understand why folks would use Whisky instead. Not sure what the solution is but I think a lot of folks see the "$500 for a *real* license" and get pushed away. It's a tough problem.

    • @nathanross4036
      @nathanross4036 19 дней назад +1

      Right I think $300 would be an easier sell by far. Nobody that cares about money wants a subscription license

  • @sweetasbloodredjam
    @sweetasbloodredjam 17 дней назад

    I’ve been happily paying for crossover to support wine for about six years now. Usually I do catch the Black Friday Sale, but I‘ve also payed the full price on occasion.

  • @aame6643
    @aame6643 10 дней назад

    I am a whisky user, I play 1-2 games and launch them once every few days, I appreciate what CodeWeavers do for the community and all but I think 60$ a year is a big ask, if it were 20-30$ I wouldn't think twice

  • @nieznaszmnie00
    @nieznaszmnie00 18 дней назад

    I think for many people the problem is that with new versions of macOS older versions of crossovers might stop to work and then the version purchased with 1 year license might become useless after that. If they would be sure that it at least works as before (but just do not have new features/performance improvements) in few next macOS versions then probably more people would buy it. Also I think that more people would purchase it if it was available through the app store.

  • @kenormsby6702
    @kenormsby6702 9 дней назад +1

    Wait, I am using Whiskey on my Mac mini 4 today with Steam and just played HL2 & Portal 2

  • @mba2808
    @mba2808 18 дней назад +2

    4:45 - I wouldn't. Because gaming on mac is too unstable anyway. That's kinda bad news, for CodeWeivers, but I'm unemployed so don't have money to spend on emulators lol.

  • @Cienistosc
    @Cienistosc 19 дней назад

    I play only one and only specific game (The Isle - with dinosaurs, legacy version) and when I tested it with Crossover around one year ago it didint work. Few weeks ago I tested it with Whisky and it worked quite nice. It sometimes crushes, but fortunately not that often and is playable. Thanks for letting us know about the sales that sometimes happens - I might consider buying crossover in the future. The regular price was too high for me but that huge discount makes it easier.

  • @MB-ix6rc
    @MB-ix6rc 18 дней назад

    Thanks, I’m a lock for Crossover now

  • @dpwright32
    @dpwright32 10 дней назад

    One thing I was surprised to learn, if you pay for a 1 year subscription to crossover, and then never resubscribe, you can use the version of crossover at the end of that year beyond that date, i think forever, obviously with no new updates. Perhaps then you skip a year subscribing then resubscribe when your version when you need it.

  • @MrLocsei
    @MrLocsei 19 дней назад

    Good points. For what I am concerned, I use both Crossover (paid license of course) and Whisky. Would be interesting to see where DXVK is heading, as for the time being I don't have any games that I would choose it over GPTK/D3DMetal.

  • @OfficialYamiYam
    @OfficialYamiYam 19 дней назад

    Im sold, I'll go ahead and support crossover

  • @31samu
    @31samu 9 дней назад

    A lot of what you said makes sense, but by "restricting" the use of wine to crossover that kind of defeats the purpose of the whole open source motto. It is great that codeweavers contribute this much, but having only one company distributing the newest wine release, even if that company is very responsible, is never a good thing. What's the point of making it open source, if only you are supposed to use it. (I know there are like a thousand asterisks, but I think you know what I mean.)
    And of course supporting the development of wine as a whole is a great thing for the community, so don't get me wrong guys

  • @GeorgeSpringer-c4l
    @GeorgeSpringer-c4l 15 дней назад

    I have Crossover 22 from when I bought it years ago and recently found out about Whisky. Need some help deciding, should I use the older Crossover 22 for gaming, or newer Whisky?

  • @monkeyfish227
    @monkeyfish227 19 дней назад +1

    after watching so many videos from you about crossover, I will wait for cybermonday, it's the cheapest time to get it right?

  • @karvarousk
    @karvarousk 19 дней назад

    I wish CrossOver would have better subscription plans for those who don't have budged. Maybe a Lite version with $3 a month, where you could buy on-demand updates when you need actually need them.

  • @linglingstar
    @linglingstar 18 дней назад

    Diablo 4: MBA M2 / 8 Core CPU / 8GB RAM / CrossOver / 30-60fps depending on your settings.
    Beware: 16GB Ram recommended. Changing places on the map with teleportation, or after a while visiting a few dongeons, it becomes unplayable. 10GB swap on the SSD. So I regularly close the game and reopen to clear RAM and Swap on SSD. Finally able to play D4!

    • @linglingstar
      @linglingstar 18 дней назад

      I forgot to mention: in order to avoid throttling, I added thermal pads internally. Then externally I am using a very simply 10$ cpu cooler from StarTech 478 with 3pin fan. Added 3 pin to USB adapter and now everything works like a charm! MBA doesn‘t heat up at all anymore

  • @coderpro5481
    @coderpro5481 19 дней назад

    you forgot something you could have mentioned in the video, as native games come to mace crossover and wishkey will be history

  • @The_LilViking
    @The_LilViking 19 дней назад +7

    You can get Parallels for like $80 forever it actually runs windows and every game that you can run on windows will work

    • @bryce7289
      @bryce7289 19 дней назад +3

      parallels is slow and is trash at emulating games

    • @The_LilViking
      @The_LilViking 19 дней назад +1

      @ i have had not a single issue with it over the last 2 years

    • @bryce7289
      @bryce7289 19 дней назад

      @@The_LilViking imo crossover is a better option

    • @The_LilViking
      @The_LilViking 19 дней назад

      @@bryce7289is it cheaper?

    • @fujinshu
      @fujinshu 17 дней назад

      Nah, try VMWare Fusion, both can run DX11 games, and Fusion doesn't have the limitations of Parallels Lifetime.

  • @sichan1263
    @sichan1263 17 дней назад

    I don’t believe either CrossOver or Whisky are particularly good solutions to Windows gaming on a Mac. The number of games that actually run bug free, or even run at all, is very small, and seemingly completely random. It’s not just that games won’t run if they are particularly intensive in the graphics department (Cyberpunk 2077, Jedi Fallen Order, and Shadow Warriors 2 all seem to work fine), but it’s not like you can just download all your non-Mac native games and play them with only a hit to frame rate compared to playing them on a similarly specced Windows PC. Games like Dishonored, Bioshock Infinite, Mass Effect Trilogy just won’t work. Also, any game that has a 32-bit binary (which is most games released before around 2015) won’t make use of Apple’s GPTK so even if they do run, performance will be abysmal. There’s no comprehensive list of games that will work fine, so for most people, this will mean a lot of downloading, testing, and deleting of incompatible games; and who has time for that?
    The future of Mac gaming on Apple Silicon is really looking like a Frankenstein’s monster of different solutions, combining Native ARM, Sourceports, Rosetta 2 translation of 64-bit Mac intel, CrossOver (for some 64-bit Windows games), Wine (usually using PaulTheTall’s The Portingkit for some older 32-bit Windows games from GOG), and Asahi Linux (for any game that has a Linux port, and a whole bunch more Windows games). Between these multiple solutions, we can maybe get around 70% of existing games running acceptably well.

  • @stephanemignot100
    @stephanemignot100 19 дней назад +4

    Wineskin for me, the lifetime crossover version is 500€, I'd rather build a PC and use Bazzite

  • @gullrock6810
    @gullrock6810 19 дней назад

    Your videos are very useful, thanks mate!
    Got a question: some games won't start using Whisky and this error message shows up: "Cannot stream required archive data. Please check your network connection." Any idea how to fix it?

  • @sromankov6102
    @sromankov6102 8 дней назад

    what do you think about parallels ?

  • @lesterduck2242
    @lesterduck2242 2 часа назад

    for crossover when i installed elden ring i couldn't play because there was an error and it did not atomatic run the offline for fme

  • @marcosscriven
    @marcosscriven 11 дней назад

    How do both of these compare to Asahi + Proton?

  • @mal-avcisi9783
    @mal-avcisi9783 18 дней назад +1

    Why the performance is so horrible and stuttery on Mac ?

  • @jessevstheworld5087
    @jessevstheworld5087 17 дней назад

    Rivals of Aeather 2 runs fine on Whiskey with no setting changes but is unplayable on crossover

  • @Uomodargilla
    @Uomodargilla 18 дней назад

    Is it possible to play with an Xbox controller on a steam game through crossover without issues?

  • @eveliojosegarcialeon
    @eveliojosegarcialeon 19 дней назад +1

    If they want more support, they need to lower their prices

  • @daiesison
    @daiesison 19 дней назад

    Does SteamVR work with crossover or whiskey? I’m wondering if I can stream it to the Apple Vision Pro. Also random does age of empires for play on whiskey or crossover?

  • @lowell_
    @lowell_ 19 дней назад +18

    Mac gamers: having a $2k+ Mac but not able to "afford" a Crossover license 🤨

    • @alexele9121
      @alexele9121 19 дней назад +3

      A lot of kids get them as gifts from family + if you can why not save money

    • @destructodisk9074
      @destructodisk9074 19 дней назад +1

      Damn kids getting a single $2000 gift these days. That is wild. I don’t think it could be that common though. Better argument would probably be college students who can get a laptop through their student loan, but wouldn’t be allowed to spend that money on a game compatibility layer.

    • @gameworkerty
      @gameworkerty 19 дней назад

      Because this stuff only exists if you support the developers ​@@alexele9121

    • @lowell_
      @lowell_ 19 дней назад

      @@destructodisk9074 Would certainly be interesting to see a demographic breakdown on the Mac gaming community.

    • @killfee
      @killfee 19 дней назад

      I own $3k Mac beacuse I know how to save money

  • @sarangkp3508
    @sarangkp3508 19 дней назад

    I wanted to ask something, can crossover run Softwares like Xilinix and such

  • @rickkarrer8370
    @rickkarrer8370 18 дней назад

    Thanks.

  • @abdelrhmanislam
    @abdelrhmanislam 17 дней назад

    How to run Revit or AutoDisk windows version on Mac (the easiest option)

  • @x7amaan
    @x7amaan День назад

    why can't I get similar Elden ring performance with crossover ? I get maximum 40 fps

  • @duncanwallace7760
    @duncanwallace7760 15 дней назад

    I think anyone who can afford a Mac that can run games, can probably afford to buy Crossover.

  • @eveliojosegarcialeon
    @eveliojosegarcialeon 19 дней назад +4

    They need to allow devs to create games for Mac natively AND DISYTIBUTE THEM OUT OF THE APPSTORE! They too greedy for money

  • @SlickEdge
    @SlickEdge 19 дней назад +3

    Apple should reach out to Rockstar & have a native GTA VI release in time for their M5 chips.

  • @joseph-montanez
    @joseph-montanez 19 дней назад

    Thank you for the discount code ^_________^

  • @mitsublinger-id7tg
    @mitsublinger-id7tg 19 дней назад

    What about Mythic? There’s a game that has some issues with Crossover and Whisky but runs great with Mythic: Coral Island
    Plus for some reason I always had issues with Crossover, or apps don’t run or have bad performance. I have a Mac Studio M1 Max.

    • @EverRusting
      @EverRusting 19 дней назад

      What are you talking about? Mythic's own web page says it's powered by Whisky...

    • @mitsublinger-id7tg
      @mitsublinger-id7tg 19 дней назад

      @@EverRusting even being based on whisky would be nice to know if it’s worth. Like if it’s better and differences

    • @fulvioleo8271
      @fulvioleo8271 19 дней назад

      MythicEngine is a fork of Whisky-App/wine

    • @MrAndyisReal
      @MrAndyisReal 19 дней назад

      @@mitsublinger-id7tg It literally can't be better. The whole benefit of Crossover is there's an entire team dedicated towards improving mac gaming. They are the ones pushing Wine forward. Think of it as the bleeding edge while all other options are just older versions of Wine.

  • @CeKurosu
    @CeKurosu 18 дней назад

    Anyone who says they can't afford crossover while owning a MAC... really...?

  • @BigYella
    @BigYella 18 дней назад

    I just subbed. I appreciate the content. Do you know if Crossover is working to integrate the Xbox launcher? They usually have console ready versions of those games which may run better with the workarounds.

  • @andreaslassak2111
    @andreaslassak2111 19 дней назад

    Why not parallels? One time payment.

  • @ProgrammingRainbow
    @ProgrammingRainbow 16 дней назад

    Amazing advertisement for crossover. They don't pay you enough for all those mental gymnastics you took us through. If there is no one paying for crossover, then wine will spiral. Cool story. Like if no one pays for linux, oh way that BS.

  • @mithrandir2978
    @mithrandir2978 19 дней назад +1

    Which one is free?

  • @bokudayo_ae
    @bokudayo_ae 19 дней назад +2

    I download Crossover for free lol

    • @toastonastick9381
      @toastonastick9381 19 дней назад

      Fr. this video is actually mad biased

    • @Nsfwstar
      @Nsfwstar 19 дней назад

      Crossover have a free trial ​@@toastonastick9381

  • @giridharpavan1592
    @giridharpavan1592 19 дней назад

    should've compared fps

  • @AbdAlgani1999
    @AbdAlgani1999 19 дней назад +13

    comparing free app with paid one is not fair

    • @RiccardoMerloVegan
      @RiccardoMerloVegan 19 дней назад +5

      Why? We know one is free but we are talking about compatibility and performance. Indeed a a paid solution could have an advantage here.

    • @oyski
      @oyski 19 дней назад +2

      In this particular case it is. The main discussion is about the future of mac gaming not only compatibility. Buying CrossOver means participating in this „macgaming project” but of course it is not obligatory. That’s why Whisky is so popular.

    • @spyder2041
      @spyder2041 19 дней назад

      Dumbest comment of the day

    • @KicksonAcapulco13-no5rd
      @KicksonAcapulco13-no5rd 19 дней назад +1

      Yes and no - Apple Game Porting Toolkit is based on CrossOver (plus tweks from Apple). I've bought CrossOver some time ago and think, it works better than Whisky. I was little dissapointed that my games mostly not work on Whisky. Under CrossOver, maybe it's a placebo, most of my Steam library is working.

    • @stephanemignot100
      @stephanemignot100 19 дней назад +4

      @@oyski I bought it once, I hate subscription model so I'll use the free options from now on

  • @brianroberts6554
    @brianroberts6554 19 дней назад +6

    If someone tells you that their software is open source, but it is locked behind a paywall, they are lying to you! Period. Even CodeWeavers.

    • @kravislagando
      @kravislagando 19 дней назад +2

      I feel like they’re being genuine, they do have a family to support and translating windows games is not exactly an easy task, if it were they’d have a lot more competitors

    • @destructodisk9074
      @destructodisk9074 19 дней назад

      From what I can see on their website, they aren’t saying CrossOver is open source. They say CrossOver uses WINE which is open source and money from CrossOver goes into WINE.
      That being said, finances have nothing to do with “open source”. That is why the community has the term “free ‘and’ open source software” or foss, to denote that it is both free financially and open source.
      It is perfectly acceptable for a creator of open source software to sell their build. Open source≠FOSS

    • @Beryesa.
      @Beryesa. 18 дней назад +2

      Libre software doesn't need to be gratis.
      Though they'd better say open core for crossover

    • @zzzyyyxxx
      @zzzyyyxxx 17 дней назад

      CrossOver isn't just wrapping WINE, they make lots of modifications on top that aren't open source