what Batswana think of South Africans and Zimbabweans, what they think of SADC as one country
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
- i asked Batswana what they think of borderless Africa? ,i asked them what they think of united Africa, i asked them what they think of united southern Africa as one country, this is what they had to say, i hope you enjoy the video and conversations about our diversity,
we are here to promote love amongst Africans..it doesn't matter where you are in Africa we are all brothers and sisters.
we should promote free movement of goods in Africa ,we should promote free movement of people Africa.
Batswana must protect their country by all means
@@Jazz-fg2dm Influx of foreigners claiming they are their brothers and sisters only to do their criminality in their country
@@Jazz-fg2dm they have built a country from scratch 💓 they must really look after themselves their numbers are very small any influx it's over..
@@Jazz-fg2dm which country is owned by black??🙏
@@Jazz-fg2dm Zim are servants in south Africa their leader went to European hospitals 🤣 black African countries 😭 all being independent since 1960 the freedom is already a pensioner no results it's a shame keep on beliefs... You don't get merits within 2 years at least 10 years on growth and stability ..
@@Jazz-fg2dm mali Niger and burkino faso how long 3 months of freedom 😭 it's too early to celebrate south Africa is 30 years these countries are already 60 years don't be in Rush you hear..
We as Zimbabweans must drop this Pan African concept immediately.We need to focus more on our Zimbabwe put Zimbabwe first
And stay in Zimbabwe
We, who? Not all Zims are pan African.
You’re correct
@@tendaifushai5651neither did he say that!
I agree with you my G👍
And people think Zimbabwe is so bad as if its some war zone ,we are okah here in Zimbabwe
The first guy talks intelligently, he speaks the fact about African concerning one Africa
Borders less will be a big disaster especially for South Africans ,,,we will suffer ,,,if this young star from Botswana can see that open borders won't work ,,,,so how stupid is Malema and his EFF who don't see that,,,,,
@arcapidiaH.thuwarh it is about economic integration. You are confusing illegal immigration with open border policy. Malema is right.
@Qhawe_Jameson. Open border policy will encourage an influx of immigrants to the countries that are considered developed like in the southern part of africa those countries are South Africa, Botswana and Namibia
@Marysmmiiith Eswatini is the 2nd most industrialized country in Sub Saharan Africa after South Africa 5th in Africa. Lesotho and Eswatini are above average African countries. Namibia is the 10th most industrialized country in Africa, followed by Botswana, which is number 17. With the SACU states( Botswana, Eswatini, South Africa, Lesotho, and Namibia), we already have an open borders arrangement. We are just not allowed to work but free movement of goods (trade), and people are already in place.
@LLEntertainment yes they do. They are the only countries in Africa with a fully functional customs union. Duty free trade. Free trade in this context means the elimination of tarrif duties and quantitative restrictions on importation and importation. This needs to extend to the entire African continent, especially black African countries.
@@Qhawe_Jameson. We are tired of this discussion that seems to lecture South Africans about history, economic,borders, migration, forced integration, forced unity and fake one Africa that are even expected to be achieved at the expense of SA. People who want to remove their oqwn countries borders are free to do so but they should leave SA out of their dream of fake one Africa
Boders must not be removed otherwise it will be a disaster for South Africa
@@ThatoMnisi-ol2cg You are mistaken ,just say keep SA borders and leave SA out.Borders can be removed elsewhere.Simple.
@@skhoemalele9715 critical thinking✅✅✅✅
For South Africa? How? You think South Africa is the best country?
@@FrankTiwadzaneChinembiri it is indeed one of the best countries in the world although we have our own problems I wouldn't move elsewhere I love it here
You are extremely misguided and u lack exposure bcoz most probably u never set foot outside sa.Many African nations have resources such that if we combine it can be spread across the spectrum.
South Africa, Botswana, Namibia Lesotho and Swaziland are culturally similar and well run. These can be one country. The rest should stay where they are and fix their countries.
I disagree with you, Botswana and Namibia thyr not like South Africa, Lesotho n Swaziland,these 2 countries still 60% innocent, but South Africa, Lesotho n Swaziland thy belong together, thyr from the same mother,cut from the same cloth.Botswana n Namibia don't belong to this group
But Botswana people share the same DNA with SA people they are many of them who are blood relaxed with SAns .. most surnames found in 🇧🇼 are found in 🇿🇦 and they usually visit each other
@@pinkCulture. I know all that,in plainly, am saying America n South Africa are like blood sisters ,this why I regrouped your list,I don't watch news but I know that In SA each year something must happen,it is now famous than Hollywood. That's why Namibia n Botswana can not be grouped with mzansi even thyr related, let's just say The whole mama Africana is related it's not just thru languages only.
Why do people always think of South Africa when it comes to immigration? Like Namibia has a small population and the economy is better the living conditions as well but, South Africa is the go to country for immigrants?
As Motswana (Morolong) from South Africa I don't mind open borders with Botswana, Namibia, Lesotho & Eswatini for now. Other countries must sort out their internal affairs then we can talk about open borders. Look at all those black Islamist countries. There's always wars look at Mozambique now. Zim the problem is their government
In Botswana, we control the number of tourists who come here every year to prevent overcrowding and ensure easier management
ao mma...come on guys dont lie...how do you control tourists
As a South african, I only love the Africans that stay in their Countries and proud of building Africa From where they were born…..otherwise l hate intruders we suffering period!!
@@nazikay1340 being one afirca does not people will migrate to your country onlt that we will have one big country for blacks as america and china. One trade process all the resource in africa and all the food produced to be sold in africa imagine you in south africa producing milk for 1.3b people and zimbabwe producin grain for all 1.3b how much money qould each state generate. Thinking as ondividuals will make us very backward and thinking as 1.3b will make africa a super power. PS there in nothing special in south africa which is not found in Africa.
@@paulmhindo7951 Then you won't mind having the other 53 countries unite without us
One Africa is unrealistic but South Africa, Lesotho, Eswatini, Namibia and Botswana should be one country.
11:07 I agree with the lady, this is the main reason why we didn't vote for EFF of Julius Malema.
The problem people they don't want to tell their leaders the truth
Borderless is ok, but only after all countries are economically more or less equal. I remember a time when Zimboz would come to Botswana to just shop and go back home. The zim dollar was 1 is to 4 pula. So if all sadc countries were good in their countries and borderless was just to avoid hassles of immigration then thats GOOD.
SO THERE IS NOTHING MORE IMPORTANT TO DISCUSS THAN THIS?
HOW ABOUT BALCK UNITY , EMPOWERMENT AND REMOVING THE DISPARITY CREATED BY NON AFRICANS
So according to you asking Africans what they think of united Africa or borderless Africa is not empowering or worth discussing by Africans ?
AS AMA-ZULU WE WANT MORE DIVISIONS MP, KZN, EASTERN FREESTATE INCLUDING JOHANNESBURG
NORTH-WEST, WESTERN FREESTATE, TSHWANA METROPOLITANS
EASTERN CAPE, WESTERN CAPE
COUNTRIES THAT CAN 🇿🇦🇱🇸🇧🇼🇳🇦🇸🇿🇦🇴USOTHOE FEDERATION
THESE SHOULD UNITE 🇿🇼🇿🇲🇲🇿🇲🇼 ZAMBEZIA
THESE ALSO 🇹🇿🇰🇪🇪🇹🇺🇬AZANIA
Congo Brazzaville, DRC CONGO, C.A.R,CHAD SOUTH SUDAN
Where is Nambia?how did you separate Angola and Mozambique ?these are the only two countries that are somewhat similar ,they don’t speak English they speak Portuguese …
@@Fambeautyy it's not about the languages it's about safe economy and development, Angola is with us because of Fuel,
Mozambique is with ZAMBEZIA because of fuels and electricity
ECONOMIC STRATEGIC POINTS
As a South African, I will never agree with this Idea of one big Africa, we already struggling because of Crime and drugs.
It's sad that everyone sees the potential of Africa except Africans. That's how we got colonized because we fragmented. That's why South Africa will always be controlled by the few families and markets.
@@Qhawe_Jameson. we live in reality on this fiction of a one world order. We all know black people don’t like seeing and preserving good things. Always trying to cut corners and take advantage of the next person
@@Qhawe_Jameson.We need common understanding as Africans to achieve the " one Africa " dream, also need South Africans and why they reject the idea not voted 4 Malema, otherwise South Africans will continue to with xenophobic attitudes
You never agree until your country is in shit. I know that sounds like an insult but it's a fact. If your house is not burning you don't care who else is homeless. The day your house burns down you will be looking around asking people hoe they can be so heartless.
The problem in SA is people still think everything lasts forever.
No your are wrong. Stop spreading unfounded narratives. Let's just fir once appreciate the fact that there's a crime pandemic in this country. And some foreigners are also found complicit in that. A great number of them might I add. And the employment statics are not fairly reflective. That's were the anger comes from. Not hatred. In
As a South African its a Big No from me
@@kagimanye1757 @nazikay1340 being one afirca does not people will migrate to your country onlt that we will have one big country for blacks as america and china. One trade process all the resource in africa and all the food produced to be sold in africa imagine you in south africa producing milk for 1.3b people and zimbabwe producin grain for all 1.3b how much money qould each state generate. Thinking as ondividuals will make us very backward and thinking as 1.3b will make africa a super power. PS there in nothing special in south africa which is not found in Africa.
@@paulmhindo7951 we hosted fellow Africans and many other new ethnic groups. We have the experience. We are not here to try and convince you. We know the negative effects of hosting illegals. They all come in peace then once they flock in numbers. They tend to demand social benefits that are meant for the citizens. They destroy alot of peace and bring trauma to my people. We are not going to negotiate our peace. We demand our peace back. Since 1994, we have trialed and test this stupid theory, now we are left with millions of lazy undocumented, toxic people . They do crime and run to human rights when they get caught. We don't want dictatorship. It is time to clean up. Every nationality must go home to fix their problems
@@paulmhindo7951 I and the rest of South Africa do not take advice from embiciles. People who want to give instructions to us. People who Think their opinion matters while we are making valid complaints. When we complain we are no talking Too foreigners,we are addressing Our leaders. You will keep quiet and keep your advice for your Leaders in Your country
@@kagimanye1757 remember no black person is a foreigner in Africa and this decision is not for your leaders but the whole of african countries & its citizens. the way we africans hate each other is now being reflected from your comment.
As a Motswana I can say the interviewees also neglected to mention the issue of Crime, a great factor to determining a boarderless Africa, issues such as policies also play into the mix, Botswana executes/hangs some convicted murderers... while other countries don't, Botswana has not yet legalised homosexuality nor abortion. We would def clash, the brother mentioned Governance, that would also be a huge determinant, Political instability and most important Security status, Borderless Africa would probably threaten our security big time
homosexuality is very legal in Botswana. ask please. you are talking
It's mostly people from countries that are not managing their affairs right that want borderless countries. Freedom of movements of goods between African countries without paying tarrifs is important but not borderless Africa.
South Africa has never managed its stuff right bra.youve never actually governed yourself.Thanks to white minority capital.i can imagine an SA without white people and other African countries,you guys would be doomed
I am a SA I like Botswana people and culture I do
like Zimbabweans but they need to be documented
Reading the comments I just want to say Zimbabwean people don’t be discouraged bethuna I love you Sothos Ndebeles Xhosa Tswanas khalanga shanganis shona etc I LOVE YOU I KNOW ITS NOT EAZY ZIHLOBO ZAMI if unkulunkulu engowethu lathi
ELETHU ITHUBA LIZOFIKA
We love you from SA ❤
Hahaha by now we love all the hate we get but thank you so much rea leboga. Ngelinye ilanga kuzolunga ngempela
very encouraging Lora
By loving each other only.God will shower us with blessings. Nomater our differences,No to burning a human being;no stealing and hatred,Luv u all
This concept might be good for other African Countries but Only South Africa will suffer since other countries are no trying to put their countries in order. I wouldn't mind Borderless between South Africa, Botswana, Namibia and Swaziland
And Lesotho
New Subscriber here, the boy/gent you interviewed is very smart, critical thinker. 👌 mad respect for homie🇧🇼
I m zulu plz people must stay in their countries in south Africa we full of you guys asifune muntu la
😂😂😂
Abahambe
Uniting a well managed country with a corrupt backward country won't work. It's like putting fresh food and rotten food in the same container. The rot will infest the fresh food because these are countries with different socioeconomic idealogies. You can imagine if Botswana institutions are taken over by Zimbabweans, systems will fall apart and service delivery will suffer due to corruption.
As a south african, it's a no from me!
You need to learn to think outside the box. You trapped.
@@Qhawe_Jameson. and you need to wake up your little dream and live in reality
@simba8665 Nah, ending apartheid was once a little dream as well. You've been put in a little box, and you choose to remain there. You are the one who needs to wake up.
@@Qhawe_Jameson.I would rather have South Africa, Botswana , Namibia , Lesotho and Eswatini be one country the rest it's a no for me
@ThatoMnisi-ol2cg I agree I will add bulawayo of zimbabwe because, of basotho, tswanas, vendas, ndebeles, San and xhosa people in that city.
Pinky botswana is in the top 10 most visited country in africa.
SADC is more realistic
Because of drugs it's a big no to border less
Young Ithuteng is spitting nun but facts. These struggling countries must uplift themselves and be assisted to do so as well where possible. Everyone just needs to improve border policies and share critical resources appropriately without weirdly feeling entitled to other countries’ wealth. No one really wants to permanently stay in another country anyways.
@@actuallywhatthehellissouthA @nazikay1340 being one afirca does not people will migrate to your country onlt that we will have one big country for blacks as america and china. One trade process all the resource in africa and all the food produced to be sold in africa imagine you in south africa producing milk for 1.3b people and zimbabwe producin grain for all 1.3b how much money qould each state generate. Thinking as ondividuals will make us very backward and thinking as 1.3b will make africa a super power. PS there in nothing special in south africa which is not found in Africa.
There's never going to be a borderless Africa as long as other countries are not pulling their weight. All African countries need to fix their problems first before we can be like that.
Its better to not have a child 🤰🏾 than have many and not take care of them so I agree with Ithuteng.There are many men not taking care of their children 🤰🏾🤰🏽.Some are homeless running 🏃🏿♂️ away from supporting.I also don't agree with a UNITED 🤝🏾 AFRICA 🌍 because here in South Africa 🇿🇦 there were 4 Provinces from 1860-1994 that's why the whole medium sized country has 3 MAJOR CITIES, JOHANNESBURG, CAPE TOWN AND DURBAN which is far apart.Then some Provinces like North West Province have absolutely no city, completely rural.Only in 2010 the 2 ✌🏽 towns in North West Rustenburg and Klerksdorp got classified as Cities but in Rustenburg the development is outside the CBD inside the CBD nothing 🙌🏻 has changed.What more if its whole CONTINENT other areas with LOTS OF POTENTIAL won't develop and during Apartheid South Africans 🇿🇦 ran to neighbouring countries even those inside South Africa 🇿🇦 like Lesotho 🇱🇸 and Swatini 🇸🇿. Imagine 🤔if they were under RSA 🇿🇦 then.Already Western Cape is planning to leave RSA 🇿🇦 and be independent and there is a Whites Only town in Northern Cape called Orania which fighting for independence from South Africa 🇿🇦 so this US Africa 🌍, won't work I disagree 🙌🏿.
@@HleketaFela eish stress
That's why Batswana and South Africans connect in many levels, we have the same logic/ideologies. The kid who wants McDonald doesn't know it's really not all that😅
I am so glad one person mentioned the kids …they really wanted to be in the video …I was hoping they would get more shout outs …thanks for this😍
I don't like united Africa because we are suffering already in SA
So Africa must not unite?
@@thembisibanyoni4435what's wrong to unite without us
Misleading subject nothing said about Zimbabwe and South Africa
It’s not misleading …maybe sa and zim are not the centre of the show ….did you watch the video?when the guy was explaining his disproval for united sadc he mentioned one the reason being mismanagement of gold in Zimbabwe and to certain extent SA
He didn't watch @@pinkCulture.
As a South African I'd love to see Africans live without Colonialists, but then I don't have a problem with borders since Africa is demographically and geographically too big
As a young African man, I find this content very important. Thank you my sister.
LOOK AT THE EUROPEAN UNION.....ONE MARKET...ONE CURRENCY...SEPERATE COUNTRIES...AFRICA HAS TO BE LIKE THAT... ONE UNION ..ONE MARKET..ONE CURRENCY...VERY POWERFUL ECONOMY TO LIFT OUR PEOPLE OUT OF POVERTY.... THANK YOU SISTER PINK...
@@iam_bantu-eh3bz thats very true if only knew how boarders divided us even our languages and cultures where disrupted buy we all believed and lived as on
Well done my sister. 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥❤🔥❤🔥❤🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
That girl just said imagine bringing 60million south Africans to Botswana with limited resources, like really??? At point she's using a South African Bank to withdraw money she get from one South African family that owns their country 😂
You comparing Apples with Oranges. FNB is a BANK. It offers services. You can't compare excessive Immigration with a service offered by a country.
I’m zim boy, stay in your country no such thing as United Africa
Have you ever heard something called "president of Europe? Or president of Asia or president of America or president of Middle East??? I think this united Africa is just thinking out of emotions than using logic. Africa is continent NOT a country. Stop with stupid conversations
It's true, all our resources in Zim are completely mismanaged😭. It's horrible being a Zim citizen knowing just how much the gvt benefits from our resources and we don't see any of that wealth trickling down. I do think Bostwana has some of the best governance in the region. I'd lowkey be open to a united sadc with the Tswana gvt controlling everything lol. The second girl was worried about people coming to Botswana to take their resources but it's the opposite. I imagine we'd all still stay where we are, but then they would then be able to benefit from us, their resource rich neighbours. We'd all share the pot, and let the strengths of each nation balance out the weaknesses of others. Eg, Zimbabwe's weakness is gvt corruption, but we have hella minerals, and also very educated and hard-working Zimbabweans scattered across the world. With better governance, Zim talent would return to the region and work to contribute to its' progress, and our resources would go towards enriching citizens instead of enriching certain individuals like it is now. I'm all for a united sadc if that's how we'll finally be able to get rid of our corrupt zim leaders lol
Hello brother, I'm from Botswana but have Zimbabwe links. The cartels in Zimbabwe would never allow that and the white monopoly capital from South Africa would never allow such. Remember they rape in these countries and control everything. Nothing happens without their approval
Work on developing your country and after that you can push for the idea of united africa
@@Marysmmiiith lol, okay Mary.
Love you from SA ❤
That worked in Europe cause they were all almost the same level zimbos need to fix zim first
@pink, borderless Africa is not practical. That's like saying you want a "borderless house".
@@fixnamibia6221 so we should continue Applying for visas to visit each other as Africans ???atleast they should make it easy for us to obtain visa or enter African countries
The problem is that some foreigners come to SA to commit crimes. Just last week there were 14 criminals who have been kidnapping tourists and businessmen for ransom, 4 were Zambians, 2 Taiwanese, 4 Nigerians, Chinese, Pakistanis and Somalians if I remember well.
Yes SA is the most developed country in Africa yet it’s still a developing country. Most people want to experience SA but some come with bad intentions. A one Africa will never work until other countries fix themselves. People must not come to SA to milk SA or endanger us, they must come to help develop it by investing in it. But the most important thing is for them to develop their own countries. Look at what’s happening in West Africa with endless coup, imagine how that will be resolved if we were “one country”. Look at Nigeria with that Boko Haram stunts, and even now in Nigeria they are deliberately targeting Dangote’s oil refinery he even wants to sell it. We cannot be having such issues, I think trade wise we don’t have to complicate things… make it easier but for immigration it’s an issue.
The SACU partners, Botswana, South Africa, Namibia,Lesotho and Eswatini can maybe, try this borderless thing amongst themselves. The rest NO NO NO
People must stay in their country plz
Well it looks like this lady has not in been her country 😂 she traveled the whole Africa, makes it makes sense 😂🤔
No one africa for me sis pinky. Nigerians, shonas,Ghanaians,west ,east central africans no no no,people must stay in their countries. I love my culture and language .andibafuni aba bantu.
Uyanya stop your hatred
@@Chamangweza you over populating southern Africa (you shona people) ..you shona people are not from southern Africa, you look west, east and central africa.
Ifika izolo la usukwazi ukunya@@Chamangweza
@@Chamangweza to like someone is a choice 🙏😭 you sound Shona typical 🙆😭
Ndezvako
Great video with excellent insights Pinks! The idea of a borderless Africa is truly fascinating and deserves extensive discussion.🗺The gentleman you interviewed is remarkably astute; the discussion was very engaging!❤It would be highly beneficial for you to conduct such interviews with individuals from various African nations, particularly the younger generation.🤔 I loved it.🌍👊
The theme of the content🇿🇦was supposed to be🇿🇦the opinion about SADC🇿🇦and Africa but because you want viewers you had to mention South Africa 😂😂😂😂anyway we love you guys
But she is a South African visiting Botswana ..
As South african its a no for me too... for us to even consider removing the borders, we should be at the same level, economically etc. We already know where every other African will go to...
Batswana🤔
Bringing 60million of South African but u using South African Bank are u ok in your mind sister lol
We don't United State of Africa why u guys are obsessed with boadeless Africa
I don't see a problem in uniting Africa provided there is absolute agreement and leaders accept 1 president and laws are made and respected by everyone.
Opening borders is the main key to make business go very quickly, and that makes currency very strong, but this idea works very well after we all use same currency at the same time.
VISA free travelling between countries is a MUST but borderless countries, NEVER.
@@multifaceteddoall oh I thought that’s what borderless Africa is about ?I thought it meant being able to visit each other ‘s country without visa?
Start by redefining the colonial boundaries to have as many countries as possible converging. Angola to stretch to quad boundaries of Namibia, Botswana, Zim and Zambia. Automatically we shall have movement of people and trade from Angola to Mozambique. Integration of passport and IDs on government databases on people, joint policing and after years break down the countries to semi autonomous states with same currency and flag just like USA.
𝘞𝘪𝘵𝘩 𝘢 𝘎𝘰𝘰𝘥 𝘦𝘤𝘰𝘯𝘰𝘮𝘺 𝘡𝘪𝘮 𝘱𝘦𝘰𝘱𝘭𝘦 𝘸𝘰𝘯'𝘵 𝘴𝘱𝘦𝘯𝘥 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘪𝘳 𝘦𝘯𝘦𝘳𝘨𝘺 𝘮𝘪𝘨𝘳𝘢𝘵𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘧𝘰𝘳 𝘸𝘩𝘢𝘵 ? 𝘚𝘰𝘶𝘵𝘩𝘈𝘧𝘳𝘪𝘤𝘢𝘯𝘴 𝘢𝘳𝘦 𝘮𝘢𝘬𝘪𝘯𝘨 𝘯𝘰𝘪𝘴𝘦 𝘢𝘴 𝘪𝘧 𝘡𝘪𝘮𝘣𝘢𝘣𝘸𝘦 𝘩𝘢𝘥 𝘯𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳 𝘧𝘪𝘯𝘦 𝘫𝘶𝘴𝘵 𝘸𝘪𝘴𝘩 𝘡𝘪𝘮 𝘤𝘢𝘯 𝘣𝘦 𝘧𝘪𝘯𝘦 𝘭𝘪𝘬𝘦 𝘣𝘦𝘧𝘰𝘳𝘦 𝘸𝘩𝘦𝘯 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘪𝘳 𝘥𝘰𝘭𝘭𝘢𝘳 𝘸𝘢𝘴 𝘦𝘲𝘶𝘢𝘭 𝘵𝘰 𝘱𝘰𝘶𝘯𝘥
Ithuteng, I'm a fan already
For southern Africa it can be easy ,we have things that are common in southern side, but other parts of Africa its a no ,that can bring wars
Look at the European Union. Individual countries have lost their sovereignty. Voting is just a formality. The rules are made in Brussels. Look at what the centralization of the government is doing in S.A. if we have borderless Africa, we will lose our Individuality and our voice will be drowned by the AU. Unfortunately, that is where we are going. We are governed by collectivests on both sides.
That's a lie bro.how to they do it in the USA , California has its own governance and yet never drowned by othe 49 states,You are making no sense.
great interview
Africa should be one country. If you know who divided it into many countries it will answer you all . One Africa One currency One constitution One president. Boarders must fall.
Before they came to divide it, we were not united still. We were fighting amongst each other. One Tribe against the other fighting for territory
Stay in your country
His points are good in a way.
Namibia for Namibians fuii stop.
Mswatini, Botswana, Lesotho and Namibia....hardly have a combined population of 10million...
Does it make any sence...and also Botswana are to small for any further Development....and doesn't have a Sea ⛵ port, mostly rely on South Africa....and South Africa business operating in Botswana....
Botswana is working hard to reduce its dependence on South Africa! 🇧🇼 They're also relying on Namibia for their sea-transported goods. 🇳🇦 Oh, and they've stopped importing veggies and fruits from South Africa
@@pinkCulture.That's great..however Let's engage on this topic...Namibia itself there are still outstanding issues , that still connect South West (Namibia) to South Africa....We need to understand what damage this Boarders did to families even the boarder between South Africa and Botswana...between Namibia and Namibia there was a free movement of people and still have family members on both sides....
Sorry i mean Between South Africa and Namibia there was a free movement of people...without producing any passport...Let's engage...
These Boarders didn't do any justice especially to these 4Countries...in the Regine...The boarder between Botswana and SA Ncape ....there were also a free movement of people... between the 2 Countries...
I just want to date a gorgeous lady from Botswana🇧🇼 honestly 😂no kidding
@@Pacer362 🤣🤣🤣 good luck My bro just visit Bots🇧🇼 you will never know if you don’t try
If we were not governed by selfish idiots, I would support this idea 💯 %, because it would be implemented based on analytical data of performances of each country, so you would have a base of countries that at the same level in terms of good commerce and good governance, then they go into each country and get that country to perform at the same level and when it does they incorporate it them move to the next country until all of them are in one body. But the current league of African governments is full of sellouts and greedy mafia operators who don’t consider think thinking about the future Africans is important. As a South African, that’s what I think about this idea.
Thank you my sister, for asking good questions
A human being is self centered by nature, so its very difficult for human beings to coexist. Thats is why there is so much chaos and problems in the world. A borderless africa is almost next to impossible to implement because there is little peace in africa.
Only poor african cointries who dont hold their leaders accountable want one Africa. Instead of making thwir countries livable, they'd rather exploit the rest of africa😢
Let's think broader. One Africa means eqaual life quality and opportunities in every region . There won't be "giants" and "small countries ". That will limit movement of people looking for greener pastures because opportunities are at your door steps. People think opening borders will bring every one to SA but it is actually the opposite, people will actually stay put because what they're looking for is just close by.
I am a south African but I don't think there must be a borderless because this will affect South Africa more us South Africans majority of us we don't migrate to other African countries we stay in our country South Africa is rare to find a south African in other African countries
Hey Pinky, What's your home language?
Sotho ..I heard her on another video she said she speaks Sesotho .
@@moengele7560 Ohh that's cool, she understand Setswana then ...
@@moengele7560 Ohh that's cool, she understand Setswana then ...
First tell the current Leaders not to suppress their people as a result people they leave their country go to other countries
I find it not a good idea, we need to learn to be competitive in our small circles. What will change if we make a big country
Zambia and Zimbabwe can be one
As a Zimbabwean Sotho woman myself from umthwakazi omuhle and I love my people
Although this could be best for our region One thing I can tell you this we don’t have UBUNTU in Southern Africa a group of people are criminals majority of the Zimbabweans are hard working trying ukuphila uyazi
This scar of us being treated like this and being burnt treated like shit uyazi uzizwe engathi awusomuntu it’s heartbreaking and to have someone who speak the same language like yours burn you all in the name of makwerekwe yah 😭😭😭😭I cry when I think about it how can a Zulu burn a Ndebele how can a Xhosa burn a Xhosa from zim how can a Sotho kill a zim Sotho how can a Venda hate zim shona like I will never understand
Stop generalising everyone hayii so much hate individualism it’s each man for himself so Mina hayii ANGAZI THIS SADC One COUNTRY THING WE DONT HAVE UBUNTU
My heart is broken after reading this 😭
What’s Zimbabwean Sotho?
@@sekoaib education is important yabona we have 16 or more tribes in Zimbabwe
Every tribe you find in Southern Africa it’s possible youl find it in zim
Hence I am a Zimbabwean who is from Sesotho /Sotho tribe
@@Lorakind but you sounds like Ndebele 🤔 please educate some of us because I'm also Sotho from SA I want to learn about those tribe please
@@ChrisMaifo-fd5lt HISTORY na ke mosadi wa mosotho if you go to zim you will hear about Mthwakazi nation or Matebeleland these are tribes that came together that’s why you find Sotho speaking Ndebele oh both read more about king Mzilikazi aswell
It’s just that we are a minority in zim that’s why maybe people don’t know much about us le rona ha re bue haholo ka setso sa rona
We have our own Beautiful history too
That’s why am against this whole hating each other like we are blood related to each other in Southern Africa but hayiii some groups don’t want to realise that
and it’s sad to think a stranger /visitor separated us without knowing that they where relatives on the other side of the river
Great work hope to collaborate with you on RUclips one day ❤❤❤❤Namibia 🇳🇦
Thanks might come to Namibia a after winter hope we get to meet
Definitely not everyone will like United Africa mostly the stable economies tend to think they are better off
Bad and foolish idea and it will never happen
I wish the rest of Africa can unite and leave us alone down South, they take Zimbabwe and Mozambique with them.
Yes true thanks 😂
As a Zambian that's my DREAM. Silly South Africans should NOT be part of United States of Africa. And STRICT laws should be put in place for y'all to stay right where you are.
Uyanya
Why mention Zimbabwe and Mozambique?
@@isaacshoko1895 Zimbabwe specially has many faces advocating for United africa - Robert Mugabe, Arikana Chihombori , Joshua Maponga , Brain Kagoro the list is endless. lf Zimbabwe focuses on itself and forget the ideology lm sure those minds can be of better use to the country.
A United SADC means Zimbabwean people will go to Botswana and other countries they chose to go to same goes to Botswana and any other country. Where you go you will be permitted to use the resources the same way as you would do in your country of origin. Stop being small in minds people... America is doing well in the similar setup... Whats wrong with Africans? So small in mind.
Go to America then.
Africa can be united but not in SouthAfrica
That's why we invest on a GoPro
All must unite and leave our Zimbabwe alone
Bro, no one wants you
Thank you beautiful people Botswana we are suffering right now because of our kindness .stay in your countries and thrive there
Batswana?
8:30 its because Botswana are not marketing themselves and their natural resources whilst the others in the North do plenty marketing to make people know about visiting their desert.
We don't want to unite with people we don't share nothing in common with.
@@TshumuKokgalagadi Wait a minute , what exactly does uniting with anybody or anything have to do with marketing? Marketing is simply using media to make people aware of products and services. Also theres brand building.
This has nothing to do with uniting . Its only about $, full stop
Botswana we do like respect
and you guys reciprocate the same respect
There is nothing much happening in botswana, only 1% 0f south african will want to go to there.. we wont mind visiting but not to stay there.
So now you speaking for the whole country 😂
People are funny 😂
@ChrisMaifo-fd5lt I've been to that country numerous times. It's dry it's one of the depressing countries in Africa.
And we will have an influx of them coming here.😢
@@nelzg5819 influx sebono sa mmago
Interesting opinion
It's so funny that za tswana wouldn't mind uniting but they can't unite with zw tswanas
Za sothos call each other one people but sothos in zw aren't this is double standards
@@kulhemhlongo how many batswana in Zimbabwe maybe 1% ?so not much is known about them can they even speak which dealect ke ba eng barolong??bakgatla??.
@@dineomolapo9934 so what %s qualifies a community to be counted in? go to Mpoengs area you'll find tswana speaking there percentage i don't have stats but yhe fact that tswana is oficial that tells you there's a community.
@@kulhemhlongo my dear Zim Sotho and Tswana have assimilated 🙏 you might not know there are Nguni in Lesotho many they have assimilated they are Basotho 🙏unlike the xhosa in Zimbabwe they still have their community xhosa radio station umhlobo wenene went to pay them a visit and show love..
@@dineomolapo9934big up to uMhlobo wenene for showing ❤
I think the problem is the line of questioning. Borderless does not mean countries lose their independence. Of course if it's put that way people will be against it. Borderless Africa simply means every country is it's own sovereign state with its own governing body and laws but there is free movement of people and goods. Obviously it does not make sense to maintain borders made by colonialists in this day and age.
I see what you mean …but I thought writing questions at the beginning of the video and asking about borderless Africa ,while talking about sadc as one country and one Africa …I thought people were gonna pick it up that this question was the only question about countries not losing their sovereignty but just easing movement of goods and people,cs the questions that followed were about countries Eg sadc losing sovereignty for one country or one Africa…..
I need to work on my questioning skills
@@pinkCulture. Yes but it's clear in the video your intention was lost in the line of questioning. Kudos to you for embracing such a tough topic and opening up discussion in countries affected by countries with rogue, poor functioning governments. I see lots of xenophobic comments here and I assume most come from people who are fed up with the toll mismanagement is taking on their countries. A borderless Africa will benefit all Africans including those that think it means mass migration to their countries.
@@pinkCulture. And what you have said is very true. The problem is Africans in the so-called good countries for the most part do not travel so their view is very narrow, of course based on their immediate proximity as they do not know or see outside of their vecinty. Well traveled people see that all of this fear they have is just a farce, by large misplaced and thays why it's called a phobia. Interesting that the hate is always black on black. You'll never see white or black Namibians or South Africans attacking white Zimbabweans in their countries meaning there's a much deeper issues which cannot be called xenophobia.
With regard to the expensive nature of travel in Africa and putting pressure on African governments, this is exactly what a united Africa will do. But first we need a complete cleansing. Out with the old, in with the new with a carefully constructed plan to increase each country's GDP and therefore value. I'm happy to see South Africa has taken the first step with it's unity government because inasmuch as we can blame, for example, the Zimbabwean people for not booting out the Zimbabwean government, we have countries like South Africa, Botswana, Namibia and Mozambique that are allies to the rogue Zimbabwean government and help keep them in power due to their liberation ties which makes the plight of the Zimbabwean people even worse.
@pinkCulture. YOU DID great job asking this tough and 😅 divisive question.
Those who want a borderless ( free movement of people and goods ) should work on educating africans first because it is clear to see how misinformed people are , especially those who are originally from the so called developed or rich african countries, they have this superiority complex believing that borderless Africa = to a huge influx of other african countries to theirs for greener pasture.
@@pinkCulture. Not sure why my responses got deleted.
I personally think that it wouldn't hurt to see if we, as Africans, could gain more from a united and boarderless Africa, just like European countries prosper from their unity. The discussion was interesting and the guy from Botswana made good points.
you are obviously coming fron one of those long long liberated African failed countries anbd too desperate to be in SA
You cannot compare Europe to Africa, the challenges are totally different.
The other problem with South Africa 🇿🇦 is that we so many people that’s why rand is so weak and we consume more than we can produce and that in a way does affect our economy and currency over populated countries are likely not to have good economic growth and job opportunities unlike less populated countries because they can cater their own citizens.
The problem with people who says they don’t want bordersless Africa when they are benefiting but if their government start to struggle they will see as opportunity to become bordersless. Let Botswana 🇧🇼 struggle you will see how they going to see how beneficial is being united but now they are benefiting they are doing well but let them struggle they will see as benefiting.
We know struggle, Botswana u see now is not the same as 80s and 90s we built this country without bothering you people.