I would love to see SEES finish their story. As much as I love the phantom thieves…they don’t have much left to tell unless it’s joker and Kasumi. Kasumi because it would be interesting to see her readjust to life as Sumire. For joker…I know people are interested on what his life is like at home such as parents and if he has any significant other back there.
@@pn2294I'd like to see them do something with Elizabeth atleast, did they just bestow her with the fool (or world i don't quite remember) arcana just for nothing?
I think they should save returning characters for spin-offs only like in PQ or P4AU. The good thing about each game is the diverse cast in each game that you grow to respect over the game and why limit that aspect in favor of fan service.
One thing I’d love to see is all five of the remaining Wild Cards (yes including Akechi) teaming up, saving Makoto Yuki, and taking on something bigger than any of them faced before.
If I had to put in a character from Persona 4 appearing in Persona 6 it would have to be Nanako Dojima the cousin of the Yu Narukami. Nanako could easily have development as a character since she also went through an experience in Persona 4 that would have given her a higher chance of developing a Persona even if it is later in life.
5:10 Eternal Punishment and Persona 3 Vanilla's sales numbers are very close to each other, so this statement is incorrect. The reason Atlus was on the verge of bankruptcy was due to their ambitious games, like Nocturne and especially Digital Devil Saga, not performing well. They brought back an already finished series simply because it consistently had good numbers, and one of them was the second most sold atlus title at the time
10k difference in japanese sales only including worldwide, itll be like a 70k difference but the localization of P2EP was limited to the USA, which is very unfair
*SPOILERS* *SPOILERS* *SPOILERS* I dont think we need returning characters, royal and strikers finished the story of P5 nicely, P4 unless theres a murder case or the Sagiri decide to come back somehow, wont really need to show up. If we do get a returning character please be Elizabeth the P4A ending has so much potencial and maybe even makoto reviving.
I don't think it's good to have returning characters play a big role in the main story because they'll probably outshine the main cast but it'll be ok if they make it a side confidant and for the phantom thieves I wanna see them but as a fun detail in the background for p5 players seeing them meet each other after years including sumi if they want to continue on the royal storyline
Well i do remember that there was an announcement for like the theme of Persona 6 and it was based on art and off the top of my head, I immediately thought of Yusuke returning. Maybe not as a party user anymore, but as a professor or a teacher. Second person that comes to mind is Rise, maybe Yukari too and probably Kanji too.
Honestly... I don't care either way. I'd like to see them return as a camio like how the Investigation team with to Tatsumi Port Island on a feild trip in P4, or the poster of Rise from P5. Little things like this that says "Yes while these stories are separate they still exist in the same universe." It helps with the world building and I find it awesome. Tho if they do being back characters from past games and want them to have story relevents I'd like to see them more as a mentor role, you know sort of passing the tourch to the next generation of Persona Users.
As much as I’d love to see a character like akihiko, misturu or junpei return I’d love it if it was Ken Amada. It’d really showcase the eras passing by through each game and really give more for the character as probably one of the most experienced persona user starting at such a young age and gaining an evolutionary persona
I loved the way P4 and P3P are interconnected. And it makes me sad that P5 ditched this. I want to be rewarded for playing previous games with more straightforward references and cameos. Sure, new characters must NOT be overshadowed by veterans, however, a side quest or mini story arc would definitely not hurt.
a game about the shadow operatives would be cool imo, maybe it wouldn't be a persona 6 but i think having a big story to tell with the shadow operatives (maybe interacting with the IT and PT) could be a good middle ground
Ok hear me out. What if the phantom thieves stumble upon the great seal and figure out away to get makoto back by going into the palaces of the p3 cast. This would let them Finnish sees’s character arc and also shows us the consequences of defending yaldaboth and letting people long for the fall again
I just realised, if atlus didn't come up with a group of highschool friends that joined together to fight the shadows, we will not have the investigation team and the phantom thieves group
I’m assuming there were less complaints about Makoto being an optional boss battle in Royal since, at that time he was far less overexposed than Joker is since Makoto didn’t star in a Dynasty Warriors spin-off or in a tactical RPG.
One day I hope to see a persona reload version of persona Q3 so Yu and Rens team can fight together and of Course SEES to personally I wanna See Yu come back again so I can relive the big bro lil bros scene from Q2
Then what about Elizabeth's arc in Arena? Will it be resolved in P6 or a spinoff? Actually that's something i want to know from u, what do u think of the idea of Makoto (Yuki not Niijima) could or possibly returning in a future game? Some would say that it could happen in P6 or a spinoff game. And yes many are against that because it would ruin the theme of P3 and what Elizabeth could meant is to free him and not revive him but for him to go to the afterlife instead because of her supposed love for him. (And it seems that Elizabeth is P3's canon love interest besides Yukari) Maybe u should make a video topic about that, how u feel about P3 protagonist being revived in a future game whether a numbered or spinoff?
If there is somebody who should return, it's the S.E.E.S team. Im thinking a new journey will befall on them with what Elizabeth revealed in persona 4 arena ultimax
Imagine if they bring some back just to show them or dead dying of old age. Imagine if Elizabeth finally brings makoto back just before the kast sees member dies or old age. PS how long do dogs live?
yes but not really. we would see and hear about them in small places irrelevant for anything going on (like the examples in the start). a TV show with/about officer Makoto, a news magazine/post of idol/model Ann, maybe you gamble about who wins the next running competition and Riyuji is often a contender, hell at most i see an Okumora food's shop/part time job you can work in
Will we ever see returning? No I don't think so but I do love to have older characters reappear as Social Link High school Nanako can still be for Justice Arcana or Maiko in her college year as Hanged arcana
Did we see the SEES team in Persona 4? Did we see the SEES team/Investigation team in Persona 5? So it is damn sure the Phantom Thieves of Hearts will not be on Persona 6.
As a long time Persona fan myself, in direct response to the question on the thumbnail: GOD I HOPE NOT. P5 is too saturated, either bring back the OG Detective Prince, a Cameo that would make a lot of sense, or bring back the group from Persona 2: Innocent Sin, the cult classic that's been ignored. I'm not kidding, when I say every time I hear Phantom Thieves coming back, I get sick. Too much of a good thing is BAD.
That is just a mechanic in all modern persona games, the difference is that morgana is the one telling you that, if he wasn’t there it would happen either way
I would love to see SEES finish their story. As much as I love the phantom thieves…they don’t have much left to tell unless it’s joker and Kasumi. Kasumi because it would be interesting to see her readjust to life as Sumire. For joker…I know people are interested on what his life is like at home such as parents and if he has any significant other back there.
Idk I think it’s different now since the Phantom thieves are actually famous unlike the other casts
@@Max-qb5ui I’d love to see them reveal their identity to the little girl from strikers. She’s their biggest fan
What are you talking about? Their story is already finished.
@@pn2294I'd like to see them do something with Elizabeth atleast, did they just bestow her with the fool (or world i don't quite remember) arcana just for nothing?
I think they should save returning characters for spin-offs only like in PQ or P4AU. The good thing about each game is the diverse cast in each game that you grow to respect over the game and why limit that aspect in favor of fan service.
Unless they create another Persona 5 Royal spin-off with P4AU gameplay and story wise.
I can see the Velvet Room attendants in Persona 6 being mentioned or José, since his character is pretty interesting.
One thing I’d love to see is all five of the remaining Wild Cards (yes including Akechi) teaming up, saving Makoto Yuki, and taking on something bigger than any of them faced before.
If I had to put in a character from Persona 4 appearing in Persona 6 it would have to be Nanako Dojima the cousin of the Yu Narukami. Nanako could easily have development as a character since she also went through an experience in Persona 4 that would have given her a higher chance of developing a Persona even if it is later in life.
She was in the early persona 5 beta files so they definitely thought about it
5:10 Eternal Punishment and Persona 3 Vanilla's sales numbers are very close to each other, so this statement is incorrect.
The reason Atlus was on the verge of bankruptcy was due to their ambitious games, like Nocturne and especially Digital Devil Saga, not performing well.
They brought back an already finished series simply because it consistently had good numbers, and one of them was the second most sold atlus title at the time
10k difference in japanese sales only
including worldwide, itll be like a 70k difference but the localization of P2EP was limited to the USA, which is very unfair
*SPOILERS*
*SPOILERS*
*SPOILERS*
I dont think we need returning characters, royal and strikers finished the story of P5 nicely, P4 unless theres a murder case or the Sagiri decide to come back somehow, wont really need to show up.
If we do get a returning character please be Elizabeth the P4A ending has so much potencial and maybe even makoto reviving.
They can also create a DLC story expansion where the P3 and P6 characters work together for a shared goal
they would be in their 30s during p6
anyone but p3 cast
@@DeathByAnvilnah p3 goates
@@quandaledingleofficial6that's better actually since they're experienced enough to teach the persona 6 characters on what to do
@@theadmiral4157 nah i'd prefer yuki guiding the p6 cast like philemon
I don't think it's good to have returning characters play a big role in the main story because they'll probably outshine the main cast but it'll be ok if they make it a side confidant and for the phantom thieves I wanna see them but as a fun detail in the background for p5 players seeing them meet each other after years including sumi if they want to continue on the royal storyline
Well i do remember that there was an announcement for like the theme of Persona 6 and it was based on art and off the top of my head, I immediately thought of Yusuke returning. Maybe not as a party user anymore, but as a professor or a teacher. Second person that comes to mind is Rise, maybe Yukari too and probably Kanji too.
Honestly... I don't care either way. I'd like to see them return as a camio like how the Investigation team with to Tatsumi Port Island on a feild trip in P4, or the poster of Rise from P5. Little things like this that says "Yes while these stories are separate they still exist in the same universe." It helps with the world building and I find it awesome.
Tho if they do being back characters from past games and want them to have story relevents I'd like to see them more as a mentor role, you know sort of passing the tourch to the next generation of Persona Users.
I suspect it will be similar to when in p3p they had the characters take a field trip to inaba in a filler event
I'd kill for Aigis to return someday, although IDK how likely that is especially due to haven't playing The Answer yet. 🤷♂️
aigis and elizabeth would be cool!
As much as I’d love to see a character like akihiko, misturu or junpei return I’d love it if it was Ken Amada. It’d really showcase the eras passing by through each game and really give more for the character as probably one of the most experienced persona user starting at such a young age and gaining an evolutionary persona
I loved the way P4 and P3P are interconnected. And it makes me sad that P5 ditched this. I want to be rewarded for playing previous games with more straightforward references and cameos.
Sure, new characters must NOT be overshadowed by veterans, however, a side quest or mini story arc would definitely not hurt.
I haven’t seen this idea brought up much but I would love to see Nanako as a party member in P6.
a game about the shadow operatives would be cool imo, maybe it wouldn't be a persona 6 but i think having a big story to tell with the shadow operatives (maybe interacting with the IT and PT) could be a good middle ground
Ok hear me out. What if the phantom thieves stumble upon the great seal and figure out away to get makoto back by going into the palaces of the p3 cast. This would let them Finnish sees’s character arc and also shows us the consequences of defending yaldaboth and letting people long for the fall again
0:43 so …. How to we tell him
You know the character lives in the Royal ending right?
I just realised, if atlus didn't come up with a group of highschool friends that joined together to fight the shadows, we will not have the investigation team and the phantom thieves group
I’m assuming there were less complaints about Makoto being an optional boss battle in Royal since, at that time he was far less overexposed than Joker is since Makoto didn’t star in a Dynasty Warriors spin-off or in a tactical RPG.
I wouldn't be surprised if it was only a confident who returned someone like Hifumi
Love to see the cameo
A return to St. Hermelin would be very welcome
One day I hope to see a persona reload version of persona Q3 so Yu and Rens team can fight together and of Course SEES to personally I wanna See Yu come back again so I can relive the big bro lil bros scene from Q2
Then what about Elizabeth's arc in Arena? Will it be resolved in P6 or a spinoff?
Actually that's something i want to know from u, what do u think of the idea of Makoto (Yuki not Niijima) could or possibly returning in a future game? Some would say that it could happen in P6 or a spinoff game. And yes many are against that because it would ruin the theme of P3 and what Elizabeth could meant is to free him and not revive him but for him to go to the afterlife instead because of her supposed love for him. (And it seems that Elizabeth is P3's canon love interest besides Yukari)
Maybe u should make a video topic about that, how u feel about P3 protagonist being revived in a future game whether a numbered or spinoff?
If there is somebody who should return, it's the S.E.E.S team. Im thinking a new journey will befall on them with what Elizabeth revealed in persona 4 arena ultimax
Imagine if they bring some back just to show them or dead dying of old age. Imagine if Elizabeth finally brings makoto back just before the kast sees member dies or old age. PS how long do dogs live?
Pretty sure koromaru would be dead by the time persona 6 comes out cause iirc dogs only have lifespan of 20 years
yes but not really.
we would see and hear about them in small places irrelevant for anything going on (like the examples in the start).
a TV show with/about officer Makoto, a news magazine/post of idol/model Ann, maybe you gamble about who wins the next running competition and Riyuji is often a contender, hell at most i see an Okumora food's shop/part time job you can work in
I hope the phantom thieves come back I miss them
wasnt it leaked at some point that atlust is working on a big persona crossover game?
well they did have persona q, so that past mc interact with new mc
Will we ever see returning? No I don't think so
but I do love to have older characters reappear as Social Link
High school Nanako can still be for Justice Arcana or Maiko in her college year as Hanged arcana
I can 100% say Joker will appear I don't need to be a fortune teller to see that due to him now having obtained in lore Demi-Fiend status for Persona
Returning characters could be possible since Nanako has a unused adult 3D model in the games files.
I don’t wanna hear or see nothing about phantom thieves we’ve done see them too much
Did we see the SEES team in Persona 4?
Did we see the SEES team/Investigation team in Persona 5?
So it is damn sure the Phantom Thieves of Hearts will not be on Persona 6.
Imma expect tanaka that mf to make a return tbh
It would be cool
To me most returning characters should be at most cameos or the like
makoto yuki and thats it
As a long time Persona fan myself, in direct response to the question on the thumbnail: GOD I HOPE NOT.
P5 is too saturated, either bring back the OG Detective Prince, a Cameo that would make a lot of sense, or bring back the group from Persona 2: Innocent Sin, the cult classic that's been ignored.
I'm not kidding, when I say every time I hear Phantom Thieves coming back, I get sick.
Too much of a good thing is BAD.
N A N A K O .
I don't care if we see the old characters or not
you had me until "imagine if we saw Akechi again". eeww no!!
He’s factually a fan favorite character here in Japan and there in the west, most people woudl like it
Omfg that damn cat is annoying. I hope they really stop with the forced "you can't do this at night/day". Morgana was infuriating
That happens in spite of Mona. It literally happened in P4
That is just a mechanic in all modern persona games, the difference is that morgana is the one telling you that, if he wasn’t there it would happen either way