Having both the surfshark promotion and the patreon/utreon/etc promotion in the same video, with an awkwardly short gap of regular content inbetween them, feels awkward. I would stick to either one promo per video, splitting the promos between very beginning and very end of the video, or both promos being at the beginning.
I'm inclined towards a leaf shaped hewing spear with wings. 18"-24"/45cm-61cm blade with at least 6"-8"/15cm-20cm of a socket. That would double for a Gladius/Archer's Sword. And if you haft it on anything between 1m-1.5m you end up with a demi-spear that suffices as a long sword as well. And let us NEVER forget, some big-stick engery, eh Shad? Three weapons out of one weapons-system. And even somewhat concealable with the blade sheathed under some clothing and the haft as a walking stick.
@@VidelxSpopovichI agree though I refuse to use the term bastard sword. Instead I just call it hand and a half. The reason being is historically a bastard sword was any sword where the maker was not known
Honestly considering the high quality of the content and the fact that the channel already has 1.6 million subscribers, it's kinda surprising how few views they're getting.
@@Petrosman No, they are activists not pacifists. They don't want >you< to have a weapon, mainly because they don't believe in reasonable people hence they despise freedom. Big difference.
Support asked support offered. The Shadiversity channel has provided hours of entertaining content! Keep up the good works, and remember the real european katana - the Swiss Saber!
I am proud to say I finally got a RUclips membership to support you guys. I’ve been watching for a few years and the content created has just gotten better and better. Long live Shadiversity!
Keep up the good work man! I just got your audio book and it's so well done! I'm trying to write my own book and I keep rewriting and restarting so hopefully one day I'll finish it!
I just subscribed. You guys make great content and I am proud to support your work. Your break out book shadow of the conqueror is fantastic. Great work, keep it up.
Their videos are very similar. Wasn't surprised at all he prefers the long sword and. it was just him rambling would have been better as an Award ceremony or some interesting format.
Personally I'd say it's the bastard (or hand-and-a-half) sword that is king. It has all the same qualities that make the longsword great but I think the slight decrease in range is more than made up for in the ability to effectively wield it single- or two-handed. The versatility of using a shield or a partying dagger or switching forms from one to two handed mid fight to throw off your opponent elevates the bastard sword over the longsword
Thank you for helping me on my journey to become an educated fantasy/medieval nerd! You've taught me and so many others so many interesting and important things about swords and other fantasy elements, I'm more than willing to give back!
Same here, bastard swords have a shorter handle but mostly almost equal length blade as a longsword. Meaning they are easier to carry and can still be manipulated with both hands for stronger blows if needed.
Hello Shadiversity, I've been a subscriber for a while now. I been a big fan just as long too. I'm sorry you all are struggling right now and I hope it's gets better for you all. I also had an idea for you, the main reason I subscribed in the first place was because of your Conan Exiles Castle builds, you know Castle Vanberg, that one castle that on the very top of the mountain, and this one castle that was separated into three buildings atop these rocks that had "Great Defensive Capabilities". And I really really enjoyed those and told a few friends about it. They stopped watching because there weren't any more videos like that so, maybe bring those kind of videos back?
Just subscribed on Patreon. The value I've found in this channel goes so far above and beyond just "swords cool". You've been a major part of my interest in medieval history and I would hate to see the channel go.
@@shadiversity Hi Shad. I want to support you but im not sure what platform to choose. I know i dont want to give money to RUclips but im not sure if i should use Subscribestar or Playeur. Can you help me decide? What are the key differences between the two, beyond just the look of the interace?
To be entirely honest. Here lately I've become super biased towards the Flamberge. When I was younger and first learned what a Flamberge looked like, I thought it looked stupid because it was wavy. But as I've learned more about it and what it has been used for, not to mention just how Beasty and scary it looks, I've grown really attached to it
I agree. A flamberge or zweihander, in most ways just seems like a bigger longsword so of course it's better. If we allow shields then one handed swords get a proper chance because most of them would be used with one but still.
Hate to tell you guys this, but the flamberge, like the bastard sword, IS A LONG SWORD. So you're agreeing. And I agree too that the flamberge is the best long hand and a half sword.
While longsword is a "two" handed sword, it's often light enough to be comfortably wielded 1 handed, providing it the versatility to be used with a shield where a greatsword would often be too heavy to be comfortably wielded 1 handed. I think I agree with your assessment that the Longsword is likely the most versatile sword type while also being immensely useful in most typical sword use cases. That said, I personally prefer hand and a half swords at ren faires because i'm less likely to hit peoples ankles when I turn around. :P
I feel like we have to take into account context though. Are we talking about a battlefield, dueling, self-defense? Longsword isn't the most ideal in most of those situations. Shields are pretty necessary on the battlefield, so one-handed swords are gonna be more favored as backup weapons to spears. Rapiers are by far the most dominating dueling weapon. Longswords are pretty cumbersome as a self-defense weapon.
@@andrewli6606 didn’t the rapier came as a counter to fullplate as time reached early renaissance? What other weapon would be used in the battlefield against a 16th century full body plate of a heavy knight/cavalry?
I don't know where the one-handed use comes from. Yes, they are able to be "used" one-handed. They're awful at it though. Cuts always are overswung and the point is so long that accuracy goes down the drain. While I find they can be somewhat used one-handed, it's as useful as saying a rifle can be used one handed. Hand-and-a-half swords really are the largest end of single-handed use. I would say unless you use the longsword like a rapier, an arming sword will beat a longsword in one-handed combat most of the time/
I sometimes I wish you guys would test more types of weapons such as blunt weapons, like a flail, or sling, or create some tests with more unique weapons such as the flamebladed sword (or wavy sword). You guys are doing awesome work, keep it up.
Here is my comment to combat the algorithm! I've been watching this channel for goodness knows how long, and it's nice to have a video that hearkens back to the days when Shad would just chat about a specific topic. Don't get me wrong, Nate and Tyranth are both wonderful people and watching them and their antics always bring a smile to my face; and I understand that times and needs also change. But I kinda miss the "armchair chats" Shad used to have. It'd be nice to have one of those again every now and then. Anyways, that's my two cents, can't wait for the next video!
I agree with you, I’ve been watching since 2017 and I love all the content, but I din’t think it’s necessary for Shad to move away from armchair chats. I love the outdoors stuff even more! Of course I want him doing it! But the armchair chats have always been fun too. It’s like a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. You don’t want it all the time, but it’s the og, and it’s nice to have every now and then.
The best sword, just like the best gun, is the one you have on you when you need it. Not really relevant those days, but certainly true from a historical standpoint.
i have a Leatherman multitool. it's not the most comfortable or easy to use tool, but when I need a screwdriver or pliers, its right there on my belt and not scattered across half the place in twenty different possible locations.
My go to is a hand and a half. When I was doing reenactment, I found there were a lot of circumstances where I needed a free hand. Usually for a shield. But a lantern and grappling also came up a lot. I preferred to have a sword that I could comfortably use with one hand, but still had room to put both hands on it comfortably. That being said though, I have long arms and could usually at reach someone with a proper longsword, or at least match them.
Oh no you're entirely right. I have sword arms and use a hand and a half. There's a reason knights used them as well. It was the longest length handle that didn't interfere when riding that could easily be used one or two handed.
I've not seen the video yet but here's my prediction; the best sword is whichever you're most comfortable with using. For shad that seems to be the longsword. Edit: I was half right.
Agreed, or would put it "the one your trained to use". I am ok with a Longsword, but much prefer my Schiavona or Rapier, as have trained with them for much longer.
I'd have to agree on your comfort point. Mostly because out of the limited experience I have trying longswords. I've had issues wielding them because of the grip being to bulky for me to hold onto properly
I've been watching your channel for quite a while but like a year and a half ago you dissapeared from my feed and I thought you closed it or something, but recently I was reminded of it bacause of your shorts: if not for them I wouldn't even know that you were still very much alive. I guess I have a lot of backlog to watch through now XD. It is really a shame that RUclips hates channels about weapons and history and shodowbans them - I've noticed the thing that happened to you also happened to other channels I've been following. Please keep making great content!!!
That's really true. Your channel is really evolved and got better in time. With you present team you make really good videos to keep up with the big competition that there is in the content creation sector now. Good luck!
Honestly Shad, your videos help me so much with my projects, mostly the comic I'm working on rn. When I'm able to I fully intend to help support your guys
I genuinely wish I had a good job so I could support you guys on Patreon, I really love you guy’s content… Anyway; I haven’t seen the video yet but my money is on the kriegsmesser
@@jeremiahsmith7924 you must be willfully ignorant of how YT is screwing it's content creators. In particular those that deal with anything that's not woke
@@jeremiahsmith7924 You seem to not be aware of something rather important. Weapons are bad! And clearly the public don't need to see videos about weapons, because they are bad! And thus, the YT algorithm decides that people invested in history, don't get to see content like shads. They decide that it is not suitable for a lot of advertisers, so the ammount of ads on these videos is limited. No ads on a video? no money for shad to pay his staff a living wage. Which means shad, who is very much not healthy, would need to work second jobs, as would his employees. Meaning less content. Meaning the YT algorithim hates his content even more. See the problem here?
@@jeremiahsmith7924 Wow dude… accusing them of greed just for asking for support? Tell me your stingy without telling me your stingy. You’re literally complaining about someone who makes these videos for free. You literally don’t have to give them any money yet you’re still bitching about it. Seriously dude, I hope you don’t take money from your relatives for Christmas because that must be real greed in your eyes 🙄
great work Shad! i'd love to see a similar video, but pertaining to fantasy swords/weapons. things like the Doom Crucible sword, the blade of Arendil (idk, the one used by Aragorn), the sword from Final Fantasy, lightsabers, etc. also. my completely serious, 100% not a joke belief... is that the best sword... is the nunchuck
definitely agree! Most longswords are light enough (and if made properly) to be used with one hand. most are long enough to keep a good distance from an opponent but can also be used pretty close. I think indoors in a small room would be an issue though. Unless the blade is about arming sword length. while I know this is not a video about LARP, it is probably the best LARP sword as well.
Yeah arming swords are better for indoors, but you can use half swording with longswords, on the other hand, longswords are much better, though definitely not the best, in battlefields and outdoors on their own.
With the quality of content here just getting better and better, I just had to become a member. Love this channel, I respect the hustle from the whole team
There's also the point of half-swording, longsword having the right length and width to be used pretty decently in close quarters, either to thrust, punch or as a tool for grappling. My thoughts is that, though not being the most optimal weapon in all situations, it always offer pretty decent means to deal with oponents provided you have the skills and training. It's a weapon for adaptable and creative fighters, and I love that about it.
Wifey gave me a receipt for my birthday last month. A Lockwood XVI longsword is currently on order and being crafted. My first real sword, and I'm sooo looking forward to it.
Very very well supported points about your choice! Been watching all kinds of your videos for a few months now and I feel thoroughly educated as well as entertained by your content, not gonna lie. You've earned by subscription!
Now, this may branch out into another video, but running in agreement with _aaaalmost_ everything you say here, I still love arming sword+buckler. It's analogical in the sense that it goes for the most sword and most shield you can carry in most circumstances, a criterion I really like for this kind of evaluation. Great video!!!
I personally really like the gladius sword and Viking sword, as they are small and are useful in a lot of situations, whether it be fighting, thievery, defending, hunting or whatever. It’s not the best sword, but it is a nice sword
Really historically there's no "viking sword" it was a common one handed sword or arming sword if that's the term you prefer. I really hate the 1950s sword classification system
I think the longsword is more powerful due to longer reach and better defense, but not very cumbersome like the more powerful weapons like the greatsword.
You genuinely are making some of the best content you have ever made Shad. If my solo gardening business was going well enough to help I certainly would because I get endless enjoyment from your videos. Keep it up Shad and the gang we all love you from all over the world.
I'm crunching on hours at work to afford some things that I want/need, and I definitely look forward to helping yall out anyway I can. Hang in there Shad!
This channel has been one of the most valuable resources for my research, while designing the combat and equipment rules for my "crunchy" TTRPG that has realistic combat and survival rules. I owe Shad and the team more than I could ever count. Thank you for all of the years of information and entertainment.
I have always had hand-and-a-half swords close to the heart due to their versatility. Keep up the good work. I really do hope the best for your channel!
I will contribute the moment that I can my good Sir. I have been obsessed with swords since I was able to sit up and reach for things. I love your channel and your personage.
Shad, I must confess. That longsword you used in this video, for years now I envy you because of that sword. My God that's a beautiful sword, sometimes I even stop paying attention to what you are saying and I just stare at that sword. To think that I mock weebs for falling in love with fictional characters and now I find myself in love with a sword. Every time I dream of the slaughter of my enemies, I can only see myself with that sword. I may let go of this envy but God help that one day I can buy a sword like that.
Hey Shad, Thanks for the years of great content. I want to support you and the team, but I want to do it in the way that benefits you the most. Could you make a ranking (you don't need to put the exact numbers) of which platforms that you're on take the lowest cut?
Hi Shad. If you want more than an art as a proof that spring steel existed in medieval Europe (for those who say that it was impossible): Adam Savage on Tested was in Metropolitan Museum of Art's Arms and Armor conservation lab, and they showed a sword from late 14th-early 15th cntury that was clearly very flexible, you can find it on his youtube channel, currently under a title: "Adam Savage Meets Real Ancient Swords!"
Shad every day you look more and more like a well aged fantasy hero especially with that hair. Your videos are always great and I share them every chance I get. Keep up the good work.
Love you Shad, wish I could support you, but I can't right now. Hoping this comment helps you in your struggles against the algorithm. Great video as always, my friend
Dear @shadiversity I visited oldest Castle in Finland, Turku Castle, I was astonished when i heard there used to Be Bears Part of the Castles defence. They guarded The Gate House
The best sword is the one that doesn't break. Doesn't have to hold an edge longer, doesn't have to cut cleaner, doesn't have to be folded more times, doesn't have to be longer/shorter/fatter/skinnier, it just has to not break.
No, the best sword is the one available to you when you need it. It doesn't matter how strong or How good your sword is, you don't have it when you need it, your sword is useless.
Ah you almost got me. Saved the best part of the longsword for last. Ye olde murder stroke. I’m like. “Is he gonna mention that bit?” And boom you did. Love the content Shad. While I disagree with some of the points you make in your videos I enjoy your content and a lot of the points you make are spot on. And you make these points with caveats in mind, knowing there’s always an exception to the rule whether it be a design difference or the quality of the weapon/armor in question.
I was half-expecting the bastard sword. Very functional as an arming sword but also allows for better leverage when two-handed. Much better than the longsword when used one-handed and somewhat more convenient carry to boot!
On the last video I was really impressed at how good the longsword was able to penetrate the chain mail armor. Given that, along with its incredible versatility, I think the longsword is perhaps the best overall. BTW, does anybody know the exact design of that chain mail piercing longsword from the last video? I know it was based off of Blackfyre, but I don't know if there is a specific name beyond that.
The sword is based on Blackfyre from House of the Dragon, but I think Shad said that it was discontinued. If you mean the blade type, the show's version of Blackfyre seems to be some mix between a type 18c and a type 20a longsword.
I'd absolutely love it if you could do a functional fandom video on the various incarnations of FromSoft's Moonlit Greatsword across all their different games!
I'd argue the Gladius and/or Spatha. Stabbing weapons have always proven to be far more deadly than slicing weapons (just by the nature of how hard a stab is to treat instead of a slice), place on top of that how effective and long-used they were in (arguably) the most effective military in history. And I think it deserves to be in the conversation, if not the undisputed best. Even besides deadliness it's shorter width makes it excellent for group fights, and it's more broad blade also gives it enough reliability to parry and hold up from direct hits and attacks on hard surfaces. And most importantly the blade itself is actually small enough that it's still in relatively common use today as an alternative to home defense and machate-uses (as shown by one of your own previous sponsors). The fact is the average person being able to own and wield a Gladius is a much greater sign as it's effectiveness and use than compared to how someone may own a longsword, katana, etc. but not use it outside of specific situations. Really the most overall generalist weapon with no real flaws or downsides to it's use outside of perhaps blade size and an underwhelming slice potential when compared to other blades.
you raise good arguments however the gladius became obsolete by the second century and the spatha became obsolete by the 6th century. id think they would of remained prominent for longer if they were truly the best. sword evolution took the path that it did for a reason
@@trolltalwar Obsolete by whose standards? They weren't fit for the less rigid warfare that came afterwards or the gunpowder after that yes, but that's by no means their fault or a sign of them being "obsolete". That's like saying "The Katana became obsolete the second they were introduced to the European longsword", you're judging them based off of use, but their use is much like a culture, it is dependent on the time, place, and people who wield them. Besides by that logic the Longsword, katana, etc. all these weapons are now obsolete due to use today, but the Gladius is not because it is currently in use by militaries and private use. (although much smaller than their original design). Which would still make their argument for being the best stronger, not weaker.
@@victorro8760 As it's called by name the gladius, they are technically handheld machetes now, but are still traditional Gladius' by nature. Shad even had one as a sponsor at one point.
Absolutely love the design of the kopis, but the versatility of a bastard sword is hard to beat. One or two hands , light, good range, good for stabbing, good for chopping. It doesn’t excel at anything but it’s great in lots of areas
Longsword is great, if you have the requisite skill and the space to use one. For most people, including anyone with a day job, and anyone in tight spaces (ie. indoors) a cutlass/falchion/shortsword would probably be more useful. Same way a handgun is primarily a defensive weapon in the modern world. While a rifle is what you choose when you intend to go on the offense.
I think the increased ease of cutting effectively with a single-edged sword shouldn't be understated. You can call it a skill issue, since with perfect edge alignment and technique you can cut just as effectively with a double edged sword, but it's a whole lot simpler to execute a technique with perfect edge alignment and form when you're cutting tatami mats or bottles than it is when you're trying to cut a moving opponent who's also trying to attack you with a weapon. If you parry an opponent's sword and deliver a counterstroke, it might not even be humanly possible to strike with perfect edge alignment, because your blade is still vibrating from the shock of the blade clash. A more rigid blade will help minimize the extent to which your cutting capacity may be reduced in live fighting even with perfect form. That's not to say that double-edged swords don't have real advantages in combat, but we shouldn't minimize the assets of single-edged ones by looking only at the advantages they have in test cutting either.
I have always liked longswords, in fact it was one of your much, much older videos that made me think longswords were specifically a good choice for me. Though I have recently taken a deep dive into broadswords (the scottish basket hilt broadsword, since "broadsword" gets thrown around a lot) tons of different versatile designs. Can have incredible range, cutting and thrusting power, you can even have a backsword with the a double edge at the tip, so its got increased strength for cutting in addition to being able to strike with the false edge in a back cut, and it's got full hand protection, in addition to being usable with a shield, without sacrificing much in reach. The big downside is, they require a bit more strength to wield, but as saber was what I trained in in my younger years, a lot of the techniques transfer over really well.
The best sword is totally dependent on the wielder. For someone who is five foot tall, a short sword might be the best since they will be able to use it better than the bigger swords. Meanwhile a claymore would be great for a giant of a man since he can use it similar to a longsword on a normal person, plus the reach and momentum would be incredibly hard to counter for most opponents.
As a giant person, you’re not wrong, but if you give a large, strong man a weapon which is lightish and nimble like a rapier, we can be absolutely terrifying to face also if we’ve been trained properly… Moral of the story: if you’re a smaller person, opt for the polearm!
hey Shad! i dont know anything about swords. I did some Kendo / Iaido stuff when i was younger - but it was because it was the only martial arts in my area i had access to. Just curious - you added the "everyday" or "duel" or "self Defense" caveat several times in your video - would your analysis change in a battlefield? Personally - i would think that a shield and a single handed sword might be better? Both because the shorter blade would allow you to thrust whilst in close proximity to other people. and the added protection of a shield? Though at least in the western world i would also think the sword would maybe be a bit of a "sidearm"? not sure. id think some type of hammer or pick, or spear would be a better primary. anyway! thanks for the vid!
I love how surprising Shad's conclusion is! Who could have predicted that he'd pick the longsword as the best type of sword in the world? It's such an out-of-left-field conclusion that I'm quite frankly delighted. Imagine how boring it would have been if he'd picked a type of sword that he constantly gushes over and collects more and more versions of, and tests and compares with other more specialized swords to demonstrate how it's just plain superior for being a jack of all trades, and quite possibly jerks himself off to the thought of it on a regular basis? The longsword truly is the most versatile bladed weapon ever, there's nothing it cannot do well. It can even beat a dead horse!
Lol well said sir! I was also extremely surpriswd to discover he picked the longsword... thought for sure the title would go to the katana, so color me shocked.
My Zanpaktou is a Viking sword the length of a short sword with a long handle, maybe three hands long? That can grow into a zwiehander. For ultra CQB, I’m going with two karambits, and also an old ram hunting knife to do survival things. Great question, Shad!
Awesome video! My friend and I have been also arguing what sword/ weapon combination is the best. We have always agreed that the best is the classic sword and shield.
My personal favorite is arming sword. It's a mini alexandria sword and I'm short so it's perfect for my size. I also like khopesh and falchion a lot for their design.
Summarized my conclusion regarding the [hand-and-half] *bastard sword* and why it's what I consider the overall 'best' sword. Also my second favorite sword of all time. My preference on top of that is single edge; having that hefty spine just seems more preferable for given, alternate situations, and a thicker handguard and bigger pommel; strikes with my handle seem to be a go-to for me for some reason.
Get an exclusive Surfshark deal! Enter promo code SHADIVERSITY for an extra 3 months free at surfshark.deals/SHADIVERSITY
For the algo
Having both the surfshark promotion and the patreon/utreon/etc promotion in the same video, with an awkwardly short gap of regular content inbetween them, feels awkward. I would stick to either one promo per video, splitting the promos between very beginning and very end of the video, or both promos being at the beginning.
Hey Shad, are you watching the Rurouni Kenshin remake?
I'm inclined towards a leaf shaped hewing spear with wings. 18"-24"/45cm-61cm blade with at least 6"-8"/15cm-20cm of a socket. That would double for a Gladius/Archer's Sword. And if you haft it on anything between 1m-1.5m you end up with a demi-spear that suffices as a long sword as well. And let us NEVER forget, some big-stick engery, eh Shad? Three weapons out of one weapons-system. And even somewhat concealable with the blade sheathed under some clothing and the haft as a walking stick.
I prefer the cutlass, good hand protection, short blade for confined spaces, can hold it in mouth, can use the hand guard as a knuckle duster
Now let’s have a part 2 where you decide which type of long sword is the best long sword in the world.
LMAO yeah its just 4 hours of him going through the 12billion different types of longswords and throwing them in a tier list
It’s gonna be the bastard sword.
@@jordanezell5132 I came here just to say that. The bastard sword is amazing.
@@Rocco_lifts😂😂
@@VidelxSpopovichI agree though I refuse to use the term bastard sword. Instead I just call it hand and a half. The reason being is historically a bastard sword was any sword where the maker was not known
Honestly considering the high quality of the content and the fact that the channel already has 1.6 million subscribers, it's kinda surprising how few views they're getting.
RUclips doesn't like channels talking about history, especially weapons. Apparently. Pacifists...
@@Petrosman "Pacifists", no. That's not quite it.
@@Petrosman No, they are activists not pacifists. They don't want >you< to have a weapon, mainly because they don't believe in reasonable people hence they despise freedom. Big difference.
He averaging 100K viewers, that's good !!
@@wutangshaolin4503 For his subscriber count it is not.
Next video idea: what's the best STICK?
Easy answer: it's the Goedendag, also known as "the polite STICK", or the "I SAID GOOD DAY SIR"
Nunchucks
The tally stick. Better than a VPN.
Shileilagh vs Bo staff
@@royjenkins2293are you trying to get yourself KILLED?!
Support asked support offered. The Shadiversity channel has provided hours of entertaining content! Keep up the good works, and remember the real european katana - the Swiss Saber!
I could also use some support fam wanna paypal me?
Based
There is only one true Katana 🥷🥷😅
Thanks for helping make this awesomeness possible.
@@Grandwigg what
I am proud to say I finally got a RUclips membership to support you guys. I’ve been watching for a few years and the content created has just gotten better and better. Long live Shadiversity!
The support means so much, thank you!
Member gang!
@@jeremiahsmith7924 there are costs involved as well
I actually did the same thing I hope you can continue to make content even if it's not on the same channel
Keep up the good work man! I just got your audio book and it's so well done! I'm trying to write my own book and I keep rewriting and restarting so hopefully one day I'll finish it!
I just subscribed. You guys make great content and I am proud to support your work. Your break out book shadow of the conqueror is fantastic. Great work, keep it up.
Their videos are very similar. Wasn't surprised at all he prefers the long sword and. it was just him rambling would have been better as an Award ceremony or some interesting format.
@@ChickenWire it's the authenticity in the passion for the work that I appreciate when I watch Shad and company.
Personally I'd say it's the bastard (or hand-and-a-half) sword that is king. It has all the same qualities that make the longsword great but I think the slight decrease in range is more than made up for in the ability to effectively wield it single- or two-handed. The versatility of using a shield or a partying dagger or switching forms from one to two handed mid fight to throw off your opponent elevates the bastard sword over the longsword
Well considering that bastard sword is a type of longsword I approve.
It's also easy to draw in self defense or bodyguard situations.
To paraphrase Revy from Black Lagoon "If you can hit your target, pretty much any sword will do the trick."
Thank you for helping me on my journey to become an educated fantasy/medieval nerd! You've taught me and so many others so many interesting and important things about swords and other fantasy elements, I'm more than willing to give back!
It will never be enough for all the entertainment we have been enjoying over the years
Bastard sword gets my vote! :) Thanks for the great content, Shad and company!
Gotta agree with you there. Bastard sword is better in my eyes.
Technically a bastard sword is a type of long sword. It is also my favorite and my preferred choice.
Same here, bastard swords have a shorter handle but mostly almost equal length blade as a longsword. Meaning they are easier to carry and can still be manipulated with both hands for stronger blows if needed.
Same dude, not only does it give one handed and two handed capabilities, it's also double edged!
Out of the swords in the longsword category, it’s probably the best.
Keep up the good work Shad !
Hello Shadiversity, I've been a subscriber for a while now. I been a big fan just as long too. I'm sorry you all are struggling right now and I hope it's gets better for you all. I also had an idea for you, the main reason I subscribed in the first place was because of your Conan Exiles Castle builds, you know Castle Vanberg, that one castle that on the very top of the mountain, and this one castle that was separated into three buildings atop these rocks that had "Great Defensive Capabilities". And I really really enjoyed those and told a few friends about it. They stopped watching because there weren't any more videos like that so, maybe bring those kind of videos back?
Just subscribed on Patreon. The value I've found in this channel goes so far above and beyond just "swords cool". You've been a major part of my interest in medieval history and I would hate to see the channel go.
Thank you so much for the support!
@@shadiversity Hi Shad. I want to support you but im not sure what platform to choose. I know i dont want to give money to RUclips but im not sure if i should use Subscribestar or Playeur. Can you help me decide? What are the key differences between the two, beyond just the look of the interace?
It's hard to overlook the versatility of longswords. Plus I prefer how they look over most other swords
To be entirely honest. Here lately I've become super biased towards the Flamberge. When I was younger and first learned what a Flamberge looked like, I thought it looked stupid because it was wavy. But as I've learned more about it and what it has been used for, not to mention just how Beasty and scary it looks, I've grown really attached to it
This man Landsknechts
I agree. A flamberge or zweihander, in most ways just seems like a bigger longsword so of course it's better. If we allow shields then one handed swords get a proper chance because most of them would be used with one but still.
It was my main weapon in Dark Souls 3 for most of the game
It is definitely a more powerful weapon than a long sword, but is much harder to carry around.
Hate to tell you guys this, but the flamberge, like the bastard sword, IS A LONG SWORD. So you're agreeing. And I agree too that the flamberge is the best long hand and a half sword.
While longsword is a "two" handed sword, it's often light enough to be comfortably wielded 1 handed, providing it the versatility to be used with a shield where a greatsword would often be too heavy to be comfortably wielded 1 handed. I think I agree with your assessment that the Longsword is likely the most versatile sword type while also being immensely useful in most typical sword use cases. That said, I personally prefer hand and a half swords at ren faires because i'm less likely to hit peoples ankles when I turn around. :P
Where the bastard sword fit then?
I feel like we have to take into account context though. Are we talking about a battlefield, dueling, self-defense? Longsword isn't the most ideal in most of those situations. Shields are pretty necessary on the battlefield, so one-handed swords are gonna be more favored as backup weapons to spears. Rapiers are by far the most dominating dueling weapon. Longswords are pretty cumbersome as a self-defense weapon.
@@andrewli6606 didn’t the rapier came as a counter to fullplate as time reached early renaissance? What other weapon would be used in the battlefield against a 16th century full body plate of a heavy knight/cavalry?
I don't know where the one-handed use comes from. Yes, they are able to be "used" one-handed. They're awful at it though. Cuts always are overswung and the point is so long that accuracy goes down the drain. While I find they can be somewhat used one-handed, it's as useful as saying a rifle can be used one handed.
Hand-and-a-half swords really are the largest end of single-handed use.
I would say unless you use the longsword like a rapier, an arming sword will beat a longsword in one-handed combat most of the time/
can be used one handed, not comfortably though
I sometimes I wish you guys would test more types of weapons such as blunt weapons, like a flail, or sling, or create some tests with more unique weapons such as the flamebladed sword (or wavy sword). You guys are doing awesome work, keep it up.
Here is my comment to combat the algorithm! I've been watching this channel for goodness knows how long, and it's nice to have a video that hearkens back to the days when Shad would just chat about a specific topic. Don't get me wrong, Nate and Tyranth are both wonderful people and watching them and their antics always bring a smile to my face; and I understand that times and needs also change. But I kinda miss the "armchair chats" Shad used to have. It'd be nice to have one of those again every now and then. Anyways, that's my two cents, can't wait for the next video!
I agree with you, I’ve been watching since 2017 and I love all the content, but I din’t think it’s necessary for Shad to move away from armchair chats. I love the outdoors stuff even more! Of course I want him doing it! But the armchair chats have always been fun too. It’s like a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. You don’t want it all the time, but it’s the og, and it’s nice to have every now and then.
The best sword, just like the best gun, is the one you have on you when you need it. Not really relevant those days, but certainly true from a historical standpoint.
i have a Leatherman multitool. it's not the most comfortable or easy to use tool, but when I need a screwdriver or pliers, its right there on my belt and not scattered across half the place in twenty different possible locations.
Just wait a couple years 😉
I carry a sword with me almost every day of the week.
I concur with this message 👌
I agree. For this reason, I feel that the cost of the blade, it's durability and wearability are also important considerations on which is best.
best sword happens to be gun with a knife on the end
You got my membership! Love your vids! Thank you for all the info!
It’s awesome to see topics that were covered previously on here be covered again! Always happy to hear the same facts and some new ones from y’all!
Your content quality really sky rocketed recently, from 7 to 15 out of ten. It is why I decided to chip in on Patreon. Keep up the good job lads.
Thank you so much!
@@shadiversity can I get your autograph if I donate some money?
My go to is a hand and a half. When I was doing reenactment, I found there were a lot of circumstances where I needed a free hand. Usually for a shield. But a lantern and grappling also came up a lot. I preferred to have a sword that I could comfortably use with one hand, but still had room to put both hands on it comfortably. That being said though, I have long arms and could usually at reach someone with a proper longsword, or at least match them.
Oh no you're entirely right. I have sword arms and use a hand and a half. There's a reason knights used them as well. It was the longest length handle that didn't interfere when riding that could easily be used one or two handed.
I've not seen the video yet but here's my prediction; the best sword is whichever you're most comfortable with using. For shad that seems to be the longsword.
Edit: I was half right.
Agreed, or would put it "the one your trained to use". I am ok with a Longsword, but much prefer my Schiavona or Rapier, as have trained with them for much longer.
Which half? The Long or the Sword?
I'd have to agree on your comfort point. Mostly because out of the limited experience I have trying longswords. I've had issues wielding them because of the grip being to bulky for me to hold onto properly
I can’t afford to support you atm but I wish you well your my favorite youtuber you and your team are amazing
I've been watching your channel for quite a while but like a year and a half ago you dissapeared from my feed and I thought you closed it or something, but recently I was reminded of it bacause of your shorts: if not for them I wouldn't even know that you were still very much alive. I guess I have a lot of backlog to watch through now XD.
It is really a shame that RUclips hates channels about weapons and history and shodowbans them - I've noticed the thing that happened to you also happened to other channels I've been following.
Please keep making great content!!!
Shad's hair looks extra majestic in this video
Pretty soon he'll be Jason Kingsley levels of majestic flowing locks of hair.
That's really true. Your channel is really evolved and got better in time. With you present team you make really good videos to keep up with the big competition that there is in the content creation sector now. Good luck!
Lightsaber! And they are more common than you think, for example, shad pointed out one in prince Caspian in the shape of an arrow
Honestly Shad, your videos help me so much with my projects, mostly the comic I'm working on rn. When I'm able to I fully intend to help support your guys
I genuinely wish I had a good job so I could support you guys on Patreon, I really love you guy’s content…
Anyway; I haven’t seen the video yet but my money is on the kriegsmesser
Shad loves double edges too much(
@@jeremiahsmith7924 well, i can see why, but since i know how YT is known for screwing up people who critiques it => i dodge the annoyance.
@@jeremiahsmith7924 you must be willfully ignorant of how YT is screwing it's content creators. In particular those that deal with anything that's not woke
@@jeremiahsmith7924 You seem to not be aware of something rather important. Weapons are bad! And clearly the public don't need to see videos about weapons, because they are bad! And thus, the YT algorithm decides that people invested in history, don't get to see content like shads. They decide that it is not suitable for a lot of advertisers, so the ammount of ads on these videos is limited. No ads on a video? no money for shad to pay his staff a living wage. Which means shad, who is very much not healthy, would need to work second jobs, as would his employees. Meaning less content. Meaning the YT algorithim hates his content even more. See the problem here?
@@jeremiahsmith7924 Wow dude… accusing them of greed just for asking for support? Tell me your stingy without telling me your stingy. You’re literally complaining about someone who makes these videos for free. You literally don’t have to give them any money yet you’re still bitching about it. Seriously dude, I hope you don’t take money from your relatives for Christmas because that must be real greed in your eyes 🙄
Just joined to support! Love this content even though I will likely never sword fight 😂
great work Shad! i'd love to see a similar video, but pertaining to fantasy swords/weapons. things like the Doom Crucible sword, the blade of Arendil (idk, the one used by Aragorn), the sword from Final Fantasy, lightsabers, etc.
also. my completely serious, 100% not a joke belief... is that the best sword... is the nunchuck
Which sword from final fantasy?
As I read once, the long sword is not a master at one particular thing, it is a jack of all trades.
definitely agree! Most longswords are light enough (and if made properly) to be used with one hand. most are long enough to keep a good distance from an opponent but can also be used pretty close. I think indoors in a small room would be an issue though. Unless the blade is about arming sword length.
while I know this is not a video about LARP, it is probably the best LARP sword as well.
Yeah arming swords are better for indoors, but you can use half swording with longswords, on the other hand, longswords are much better, though definitely not the best, in battlefields and outdoors on their own.
With the quality of content here just getting better and better, I just had to become a member. Love this channel, I respect the hustle from the whole team
I hope you guys can keep making videos!
There's also the point of half-swording, longsword having the right length and width to be used pretty decently in close quarters, either to thrust, punch or as a tool for grappling.
My thoughts is that, though not being the most optimal weapon in all situations, it always offer pretty decent means to deal with oponents provided you have the skills and training. It's a weapon for adaptable and creative fighters, and I love that about it.
I do agree, and I do not think there is any weapon that is the most optimal for even more than one situation, let alone all situations.
Great Video!Also I believe the Longman would approve of you choosing that particular blade Sir Shad.
Wifey gave me a receipt for my birthday last month. A Lockwood XVI longsword is currently on order and being crafted. My first real sword, and I'm sooo looking forward to it.
Very very well supported points about your choice! Been watching all kinds of your videos for a few months now and I feel thoroughly educated as well as entertained by your content, not gonna lie. You've earned by subscription!
Thanks for this video, Shad. That specific sword is my favorite from the channel. Great to see it again.
Thanks!
Now, this may branch out into another video, but running in agreement with _aaaalmost_ everything you say here, I still love arming sword+buckler. It's analogical in the sense that it goes for the most sword and most shield you can carry in most circumstances, a criterion I really like for this kind of evaluation.
Great video!!!
I personally really like the gladius sword and Viking sword, as they are small and are useful in a lot of situations, whether it be fighting, thievery, defending, hunting or whatever. It’s not the best sword, but it is a nice sword
Really historically there's no "viking sword" it was a common one handed sword or arming sword if that's the term you prefer. I really hate the 1950s sword classification system
Those two are nice. I agree. I prefer arming sword. They are slightly shorter than the viking sword and I like their design
I think the longsword is more powerful due to longer reach and better defense, but not very cumbersome like the more powerful weapons like the greatsword.
I really like these professor Shad classes
You genuinely are making some of the best content you have ever made Shad. If my solo gardening business was going well enough to help I certainly would because I get endless enjoyment from your videos. Keep it up Shad and the gang we all love you from all over the world.
I'm crunching on hours at work to afford some things that I want/need, and I definitely look forward to helping yall out anyway I can. Hang in there Shad!
You're so going to hear from Skallagrim, Metatron, and Scoalgladiatoria! Can't wait for the debate!
Probably why he's made this video lol
I love how Shad still uses one of Skalgrim’s sword as an example still
This channel has been one of the most valuable resources for my research, while designing the combat and equipment rules for my "crunchy" TTRPG that has realistic combat and survival rules.
I owe Shad and the team more than I could ever count.
Thank you for all of the years of information and entertainment.
The sword is an extension of one's self.
I have always had hand-and-a-half swords close to the heart due to their versatility. Keep up the good work. I really do hope the best for your channel!
I just really like Falchions. They’re just so cool. Though longswords are definitely more versatile.
The algorithm better do its job soon cause the channel deserves a lot more views and revenue.. that's for sure.
Amazing content as always I hope RUclips realizes that as well
I will contribute the moment that I can my good Sir.
I have been obsessed with swords since I was able to sit up and reach for things. I love your channel and your personage.
Shad, I must confess. That longsword you used in this video, for years now I envy you because of that sword. My God that's a beautiful sword, sometimes I even stop paying attention to what you are saying and I just stare at that sword. To think that I mock weebs for falling in love with fictional characters and now I find myself in love with a sword. Every time I dream of the slaughter of my enemies, I can only see myself with that sword. I may let go of this envy but God help that one day I can buy a sword like that.
Saw the short for this and now I know I'll be stuck here binging for the foreseeable future 😂
Please do your own line of practical swords! I'd buy a Shad approved longsword.
You the man Shad.
I go with Adolin's concept of swords. 'Who doesn't like a cool sword?"
Hey Shad,
Thanks for the years of great content.
I want to support you and the team, but I want to do it in the way that benefits you the most. Could you make a ranking (you don't need to put the exact numbers) of which platforms that you're on take the lowest cut?
Easy: The Best Sword is the one you started with.
Don't you mean the one you ended the fight with?
A stick?
Hi Shad.
If you want more than an art as a proof that spring steel existed in medieval Europe (for those who say that it was impossible):
Adam Savage on Tested was in Metropolitan Museum of Art's Arms and Armor conservation lab, and they showed a sword from late 14th-early 15th cntury that was clearly very flexible, you can find it on his youtube channel, currently under a title: "Adam Savage Meets Real Ancient Swords!"
Shad every day you look more and more like a well aged fantasy hero especially with that hair. Your videos are always great and I share them every chance I get. Keep up the good work.
The metal pipe! Whaddya mean it's not a sword?
Love you Shad, wish I could support you, but I can't right now. Hoping this comment helps you in your struggles against the algorithm. Great video as always, my friend
Dear @shadiversity
I visited oldest Castle in Finland, Turku Castle, I was astonished when i heard there used to Be Bears Part of the Castles defence. They guarded The Gate House
The best sword is the one that doesn't break. Doesn't have to hold an edge longer, doesn't have to cut cleaner, doesn't have to be folded more times, doesn't have to be longer/shorter/fatter/skinnier, it just has to not break.
So, the best sword is a solid metal club?
@@ImminDragon Guts sword confirmed for best design.
@@ImminDragon Wow thats a messy cut. lol
I read that to the tune of I Want Aa New Drug by Huey Lewis and the News
No, the best sword is the one available to you when you need it.
It doesn't matter how strong or How good your sword is, you don't have it when you need it, your sword is useless.
Ah you almost got me. Saved the best part of the longsword for last. Ye olde murder stroke.
I’m like. “Is he gonna mention that bit?” And boom you did.
Love the content Shad. While I disagree with some of the points you make in your videos I enjoy your content and a lot of the points you make are spot on. And you make these points with caveats in mind, knowing there’s always an exception to the rule whether it be a design difference or the quality of the weapon/armor in question.
We all know it’s the Long Sword and youtube is a sunken ship stay strong bro
Longsword isn’t a very specific term tho 😂
@@alvinleonardo1263 Its the LONG one.
@@Merilirem really? Well I prefer the sharp one 🤣
@@alvinleonardo1263 it’s what he says first too lol
I was half-expecting the bastard sword. Very functional as an arming sword but also allows for better leverage when two-handed. Much better than the longsword when used one-handed and somewhat more convenient carry to boot!
On the last video I was really impressed at how good the longsword was able to penetrate the chain mail armor. Given that, along with its incredible versatility, I think the longsword is perhaps the best overall. BTW, does anybody know the exact design of that chain mail piercing longsword from the last video? I know it was based off of Blackfyre, but I don't know if there is a specific name beyond that.
The sword is based on Blackfyre from House of the Dragon, but I think Shad said that it was discontinued. If you mean the blade type, the show's version of Blackfyre seems to be some mix between a type 18c and a type 20a longsword.
@@whoswoo9070 Blade type, yes, didn't know the terminology! Thanks, much appreciated!
Longswords were the medieval equivalent to pistol-caliber carbines.
I wish I had the funds to donate 500$ a month. I love this channel.
I'd absolutely love it if you could do a functional fandom video on the various incarnations of FromSoft's Moonlit Greatsword across all their different games!
I'd argue the Gladius and/or Spatha. Stabbing weapons have always proven to be far more deadly than slicing weapons (just by the nature of how hard a stab is to treat instead of a slice), place on top of that how effective and long-used they were in (arguably) the most effective military in history. And I think it deserves to be in the conversation, if not the undisputed best.
Even besides deadliness it's shorter width makes it excellent for group fights, and it's more broad blade also gives it enough reliability to parry and hold up from direct hits and attacks on hard surfaces.
And most importantly the blade itself is actually small enough that it's still in relatively common use today as an alternative to home defense and machate-uses (as shown by one of your own previous sponsors). The fact is the average person being able to own and wield a Gladius is a much greater sign as it's effectiveness and use than compared to how someone may own a longsword, katana, etc. but not use it outside of specific situations.
Really the most overall generalist weapon with no real flaws or downsides to it's use outside of perhaps blade size and an underwhelming slice potential when compared to other blades.
you raise good arguments however the gladius became obsolete by the second century and the spatha became obsolete by the 6th century. id think they would of remained prominent for longer if they were truly the best. sword evolution took the path that it did for a reason
@@trolltalwar Obsolete by whose standards? They weren't fit for the less rigid warfare that came afterwards or the gunpowder after that yes, but that's by no means their fault or a sign of them being "obsolete". That's like saying "The Katana became obsolete the second they were introduced to the European longsword", you're judging them based off of use, but their use is much like a culture, it is dependent on the time, place, and people who wield them.
Besides by that logic the Longsword, katana, etc. all these weapons are now obsolete due to use today, but the Gladius is not because it is currently in use by militaries and private use. (although much smaller than their original design). Which would still make their argument for being the best stronger, not weaker.
@@boodstain What sword are you referring to that's used today and is similar to a gladius?
@@victorro8760 As it's called by name the gladius, they are technically handheld machetes now, but are still traditional Gladius' by nature. Shad even had one as a sponsor at one point.
@@boodstain I can't find what you're referring to.
I gotta say, reasonable conclusion... now I just to up my edc so I can carry three swords easily and I'm gtg.
as a weeb you know the best sword award will have to go to
The Greek Kopis
Absolutely love the design of the kopis, but the versatility of a bastard sword is hard to beat. One or two hands , light, good range, good for stabbing, good for chopping. It doesn’t excel at anything but it’s great in lots of areas
Longsword is great, if you have the requisite skill and the space to use one. For most people, including anyone with a day job, and anyone in tight spaces (ie. indoors) a cutlass/falchion/shortsword would probably be more useful. Same way a handgun is primarily a defensive weapon in the modern world. While a rifle is what you choose when you intend to go on the offense.
Longswords are far better for battlefields on their own though.
I think the increased ease of cutting effectively with a single-edged sword shouldn't be understated. You can call it a skill issue, since with perfect edge alignment and technique you can cut just as effectively with a double edged sword, but it's a whole lot simpler to execute a technique with perfect edge alignment and form when you're cutting tatami mats or bottles than it is when you're trying to cut a moving opponent who's also trying to attack you with a weapon.
If you parry an opponent's sword and deliver a counterstroke, it might not even be humanly possible to strike with perfect edge alignment, because your blade is still vibrating from the shock of the blade clash. A more rigid blade will help minimize the extent to which your cutting capacity may be reduced in live fighting even with perfect form.
That's not to say that double-edged swords don't have real advantages in combat, but we shouldn't minimize the assets of single-edged ones by looking only at the advantages they have in test cutting either.
I agree! versatility and modularity typically went out.
At this point youtube is anti creator
I have always liked longswords, in fact it was one of your much, much older videos that made me think longswords were specifically a good choice for me. Though I have recently taken a deep dive into broadswords (the scottish basket hilt broadsword, since "broadsword" gets thrown around a lot) tons of different versatile designs. Can have incredible range, cutting and thrusting power, you can even have a backsword with the a double edge at the tip, so its got increased strength for cutting in addition to being able to strike with the false edge in a back cut, and it's got full hand protection, in addition to being usable with a shield, without sacrificing much in reach. The big downside is, they require a bit more strength to wield, but as saber was what I trained in in my younger years, a lot of the techniques transfer over really well.
I’ve watched enough anime and Braveheart to tell you it is obviously the katana or Great Sword. 🤓
The best sword is the nunchaku
Don't forget Deadpool, team katana 🤪
As an all rounder longswords are the most rounded out for sure. I'm so happy the Alexandrian longsword got a mention, by far my favourite sword
The best sword is totally dependent on the wielder. For someone who is five foot tall, a short sword might be the best since they will be able to use it better than the bigger swords. Meanwhile a claymore would be great for a giant of a man since he can use it similar to a longsword on a normal person, plus the reach and momentum would be incredibly hard to counter for most opponents.
No the correct answer is Buster sword. Try again.
So just a longsword that's sized to the person?
Actually, a shorter person would need the reach advantage a longer sword would provide for them.
As a giant person, you’re not wrong, but if you give a large, strong man a weapon which is lightish and nimble like a rapier, we can be absolutely terrifying to face also if we’ve been trained properly…
Moral of the story: if you’re a smaller person, opt for the polearm!
hey Shad! i dont know anything about swords. I did some Kendo / Iaido stuff when i was younger - but it was because it was the only martial arts in my area i had access to. Just curious - you added the "everyday" or "duel" or "self Defense" caveat several times in your video - would your analysis change in a battlefield? Personally - i would think that a shield and a single handed sword might be better? Both because the shorter blade would allow you to thrust whilst in close proximity to other people. and the added protection of a shield? Though at least in the western world i would also think the sword would maybe be a bit of a "sidearm"? not sure. id think some type of hammer or pick, or spear would be a better primary. anyway! thanks for the vid!
I love how surprising Shad's conclusion is! Who could have predicted that he'd pick the longsword as the best type of sword in the world? It's such an out-of-left-field conclusion that I'm quite frankly delighted. Imagine how boring it would have been if he'd picked a type of sword that he constantly gushes over and collects more and more versions of, and tests and compares with other more specialized swords to demonstrate how it's just plain superior for being a jack of all trades, and quite possibly jerks himself off to the thought of it on a regular basis? The longsword truly is the most versatile bladed weapon ever, there's nothing it cannot do well. It can even beat a dead horse!
Lol well said sir! I was also extremely surpriswd to discover he picked the longsword... thought for sure the title would go to the katana, so color me shocked.
Interesting - never seen the discussion framed this way. Very nice 🙂
My Zanpaktou is a Viking sword the length of a short sword with a long handle, maybe three hands long?
That can grow into a zwiehander.
For ultra CQB, I’m going with two karambits, and also an old ram hunting knife to do survival things.
Great question, Shad!
Awesome video! My friend and I have been also arguing what sword/ weapon combination is the best. We have always agreed that the best is the classic sword and shield.
My personal favorite is arming sword. It's a mini alexandria sword and I'm short so it's perfect for my size.
I also like khopesh and falchion a lot for their design.
God Bless you Shad
Summarized my conclusion regarding the [hand-and-half] *bastard sword* and why it's what I consider the overall 'best' sword. Also my second favorite sword of all time.
My preference on top of that is single edge; having that hefty spine just seems more preferable for given, alternate situations, and a thicker handguard and bigger pommel; strikes with my handle seem to be a go-to for me for some reason.
This is kind of like working a gun shop and the customer asks what the best carry gun is.
"Probably what is on my hip."