WHAT IF ERWIN had the COLOSSAL Titan? | Attack on Titan
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 сен 2024
- This video explains what would've happened if Erwin Smith inherited the Colossal Titan in Attack on Titan (instead of Armin). The Colossal Titan is one of 9 titan shifters in AOT. This video is PART 1 of a series of videos exploring this alternate timeline!
ERWIN COLOSSAL PART 3! - t.co/MzNSJfb5BA
OTHER VIDEOS:
All COLOSSAL TITANS Explained! - • All COLOSSAL TITANS in...
All FOUNDING TITANS Explained! - • All FOUNDING TITANS in...
All ARMORED TITANS Explained! - • All ARMORED TITANS in ...
All BEAST TITANS Explained! - • All BEAST TITANS in Hi...
All ATTACK TITANS Explained! - • All ATTACK TITANS in H...
All WARHAMMER TITANS Explained! - • All WARHAMMER TITANS i... All
All JAW TITANS Explained! - • All JAW TITANS in Hist...
All CART TITANS - • All CART TITANS in His...
#aot #attackontitan #attackontitanthefinalseason
ERWIN FUNKO COMPETITION RULES:
1. To enter, you must (1) be subscribed to Turtle Quirk on RUclips and (2) leave at least one comment on this video
2. Winner will be selected at random using commentpicker....
3. Draw will take place 10th of October 2021
4. Turtle Quirk will reply to the winning comment once the draw is complete!
5. Winner will be publicly announced during ‘What If Erwin got the Colossal (Part 2)’, which will be released sometime in October 2021.
6. There is no limitation on country, however delivery time may vary depending on where you live.
7. IMPORTANT: Every username gets only 1 entry regardless of how many comments they make
Join TurtleQuirk DISCORD: / discord
Stay updated on INSTAGRAM: / turtle.quirk
SUPPORT ON PATREON: / turtlequirk
FOLLOW ON TWITTER: / turtlequirk
ART
AOT Colored iceburst stone panel: / scnk_official
Tags:
Talking titan
abnormal titans
Attack on Titan the final season
AOT
AOT S4
Eren Yeaeger
Coordinate
Rumbling
Ancient founding titan
AOT final season
AOT Season 4
According to Kenny Ackerman all humans need a dream to chase after or else there’d be no reason to keep on living and for Erwin his goal was to avenge his fathers death by uncovering the truth about the world outside the walls. let’s just say Levi no longer hesitates at the crucial moment and turns the commander into a pure titan like he intended. Following that Erwin would wake up on top of wall Maria many hours later having eaten Bertolt and the first thing he’d notice is the brand new right arm that would’ve grown while he was asleep. This arm was bitten of by a random titan in season 2 but with it returning Erwin would immediately realise that he’s become a titan shifter. As with most people who inherit these abilities the commander would have no memory of the events surrounding it, so for all he knows he could be the new beast titan, armoured titan or even the new cart titan; he’d just genuinely have no idea. Levi would be the one to fill him in on everything that happened and once that’s explained they’d set out to find the Yaeger family basement, with mikasa and eren leading the way. While Eren would be severely depressed about Armin’s death Mikasa in the past has shown composure when it comes to processing these kinds of things, so I feel like she’d be able to calm him down and refocus on him on the task at hand. Obviously you could argue she wasn’t that composed a few Horus earlier but with Armin now being actually dead, Mikasa would accept there’s nothing they can do to bring him back. After searching the basement long enough they’d eventually find the 3 hidden notebooks left behind by grisha Yeager and this discovery would be the culmination of Erwin’s dream. As he said he had to be when they learn the truth about the world and now having learnt that truth he realises their enemy is huge nation that wants to steal the founding titan. Because Marley failed in their mission Erwin would know they will return to try and capture eren at some point, so strengthening the islands defence becomes his next top priority.
Previously Hanji had said the commander was already the symbol of hope for humanity, so with these new developments such as him having the colossal titan, I’m sure most ordinary people would think of him as the closest thing they have to a God. Over the next few days Nile Dok would apologise to Erwin for never taking his theory seriously when they were younger, while separately Eren and Mikasa would still be made to serve a short jail sentence for trying to give Armin the injection. The time would then come for the leaders of Paradis to decide what they should do with Grisha’s notebooks and of course this is a perfect opportunity for Erwin to give one of his classic speeches, something about how the truth needs to be made public or else all those deaths would be for nothi
Thanks for watching! If you want to see how this alternate timeline continues, check out:
*PART 2* -
ruclips.net/video/J36tW5OtsoE/видео.html
*PART 3* - ruclips.net/video/iPNonogS2lI/видео.html
*PART 4* -
ruclips.net/video/vOmGLFWLq2s/видео.html
*PART 5* -
ruclips.net/video/8jDqw3OZldE/видео.html
I want the funko pop
I’m in
I'm in
U sound like donibobes
I’m in I been subed for 7 months
Just imagine being a Marley Marine soldier and just hearing "SHINZO SASAGEYO" and a nuke going of right next to you
lol
I’d burst out in intense laughter
Ebb
Ha
It was that time that he know he f.......
Bertholdt's Colossal: Mad
Armin's Colossal: Sad
Erwin's Colossal: Chad
soo true
Eren Colossal: Devilish look
@@blueheaddude2065
Eren's Colossal: Model For Pantene Conditioner
@@projectblade82 Change angry to Mad
, so that it rhymes
Armin's pure titan looks so depressed
The biggest difference is Erwin could see people's true motives and would act accordingly. The only reason Eren got so far was because his best friends ran the army and refused to acknowledge how crazy he had become
SO TRUE, Erwin would still not trust zeke or eren fully.
👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾well said
True. Erwin is also very good at politics and negotiation, which are crucial when dealing with Marley. Along with the leadership, the survey corps wouldn't split. He is also considered 'crazy' so he might understand Eren more than others did
you cooked. he was able to figure out so much with limited information in the earlier seasons. no shot eren would get that far if he was alive, probably one of the reasons eren chose armin.
I dont blame Eren, his useless friends spend 4 years doing nothing, i guess Armin was too busy nutting on annie´s cristal. Erwin would never waste time like this , sadly Eren have a weak spot for his friends even when they are unreliable.
Armin was responsible for seeing details and discovering secrets that made the main characters win along the series, but I doubt Erwin would let the wine trap happen- I think he would be so paranoid about every move of everyone from Marley.
He would destroy Marley not like cold hearted Armin
He would try and get as many titans as he could, he would've still sent Eren to Marley in case they declare war and still the war hammer titan. He would've kepted Eren in check he had a way to push Eren in the right direction, he would've tried to tech up parody Island tried to export the gas, he would've figured a way to make titans obsolete. He would've tried to support a civil war in Marley with zeke. He was paranoid enough he would always prepare for invasion but the thing is. Historia and zeke are the only 2 royals, and zeke was always going to try and control the founder. Eren only got the power by his love for mikicusa. He would have to figure away around the problem and I can't see how.
@Sam Thomas
Facts, Erwin should've lived
@Sam Thomas Yea, but to be fair, Eren WOULD HAVE achieved freedom for Paradis if Armin and co didn't stop him
@@suryadragon Why tf should Erwin be a psychopath to kill people and feel no remorse? Erwin would most likely feel the same shit Armin felt, like any other rational human would.
It still saddens me that Erwin was right about everything and was so close to seeing it but he died right before they found out.
I mean they pretty much knew for certain that humanity existed outside the walls just didnt have any concrete evidence.
I know right
Erwin cannot be transformed into a Titan right ?
Why? Because his ancestors were aisan ..
@@kumarharsh837 Ackermans can't transform into titans, but asians probably can
But he also sacrificed countless people. He couldn't escape that karma
To be honest, I always thought about Erwin getting the armoured titan while Armin got the colossal titan. They could've maybe split the spinal fluid to both of them. So I always imagine if Zeke and the cart titan never recovered Reiner that they would've captured them both.
Yeah I always thought that he get the armoured titan
I think if they split it they would both be abnormal titans. Idk tho
now he would literally have balls of steel
They could force feed the shifters to the titans. Rod Reiss was an abnormal and they did make a choice of whether or not to feed Eren to Rod. It’s probably possible. And easier with a shifter on your side.
Somebody said it. I know, right! It could have been split in half.
*Eren wrecking the entire world*
Armin: "ah crap, what am I gonna do, Erwin please guide me!"
Erwin in heaven: "I missed the part where that's my problem."
bully erwin.
"You'll get your advice when you fix this damn door!!!"
@@Idunnobutstill lol when he finds out the basement door is locked
😄😄😄😄
Spiderman everywhere
The first thing Ervin will do as a Colossal Titan is to transform and watch the military exercises from the best possible angle. This alone will increase his efficiency as a strategist by 300%. Also, now they would be able to attack in winter, since they will have a portable heat generator walking/riding with them an all times xD
"portable heat generator" lmao. it makes him sound useful and yet so useless at the same time
Wow that would actually be a very cool scene. Seeing the two armies approaching each other and then Erwin transforming and blocking out the sun. He stands their looming over the scene watching and relaying orders as both armies fight in his shadow.
U are a fucknig Genius
he wouldn't transform after he saw bertolt's memories of the big ass nuke.
@@saltypotatoes827 When you take someones titan you dont get all their memories dumped onto you instantly. Some of them take years before they show up. manga spoilers below!
This is why as the series progresses Eren becomes more and more different and warped mentally. He has the memories of hundreds of previous founding titan users slowly trickling into his mind. PLUS since he also has the attack titan, whos memories can travel both backwards and forward through time between users, he essentially has all these different peoples memories traveling across time all converging into his own mind. All those peoples dreams, memories, goals, love, hate, emotions, everything all slowly mixing into his own mind to the point where he almost completely losses himself to them. This is why he not only starts the rumbling, but also in a last effort of will that he can truely call his own leaves an opening for his allies to kill him if THEY want to. Because he knows that he can no longer trust his own mind, but can always count on his friends to do what they think is right. put simply, Eren no longer knew right from wrong, but he knew that the friends he trusts did, so he bets everything on them. Which of course all stems from what Levi told him in the woods while the Female Titan was chasing them.
Erwin is my favourite character. Mysterious, Smart and Decisive, The way he was written as an excellent leader and strategist is just genius
Erwin getting colossal titan
Marley - *NUKES ARE EVERY WHERE WHO IS THAT THICC EYEBRO TITAN*
Erwin really got me into AoT. Learning that this show was hella political and about combating other people blew my mind
Erwin x Annie if that happens so basically he will get arrested
As bertholdt likes Annie and it's. Passed down to Armin
If Erwin ate bertholdt that meanssss
@@glitchbeyz armin liked annie before he became a titan shifter
@@quackitygotwavesdoe8763 and he liked her even more after
The thing is that Armin's unique instances of tactical brilliance all but dry up after the injection. Aside from the recovery plan of Eren in Marley, there was nothing that made me say "oh yeah, it's hard to say which was the right choice." Armin is a tactician, Erwin is a strategist, and strategy is what Paradis needed most. Ah well.
Armin was kinda wasted in Season 4.
@@crabcrab3048 ngl kinda agree, although hes good from a narrative standpoint due to his connection with Eren, he didn't really use his head all that much in s4. legit most other people could have probably taken up his spot as the colossal titan and paradis wouldn't have done worse by much
Erwins leadership and speeches would've also been useless after getting 99% of the scouts turned into paste by his stupid ass plans that usually don't work.
I guess Bert’s memories made Armin kinda dumber 😂😅. Probably because of his sympathetic side. Erwin on the other hand might not suffer from that. Probably due to him not minding having some sacrifices happening in the middle of his plans.
it didn't really matter what Paradis needed, Eren was going to do the Rumbling no matter what
I'm pretty confident that in the boat scene erwin would've shouted "shinzo sasageyo" before nuking the entire fleet
Lol
💀
Even better, he'd yell it while in his colossal titan form
Dandy he'd break everyone's ears
Man, even the death glare he gave when he first fought Levi would be enough
I think that emotionally speaking Armin the best chose would be to put him out of his misery but strategically speaking Erwin is way better at strategising and has way more knowledge and experience.
Erwin was prepared to die and would feel immense guilt, probably ruining him.
@@blorblin No he already had guilt, he led hundred of scouts to death to ensure victory. But he attoned for it in the end by sacrificing himself and his dream. If he got another chance he could lead the scouts and probably find a better solution with Eren about Marley...
@@DECENTcrew If he didn't go insane from the fact that he survived the charge when everyone except himself and Floch didn't.
Erwin wanted to die. He was sick of living in such a terrible world, so much so that in the manga, he's seen smiling just a bit as a rock rips through him.
@@wakandaforever2401 well yeah I rather die because who want to live in a world with Titan killing human
@@DECENTcrew completely agree
I always thought Erwin was the right choice. Even Armin agrees. Plus we'd get to see his right arm again...
I love how Erwin has so many layers, in the sense he isn't the kind, truthful, caring leader, but super ambitious, never revealing his true intentions.
That’s hard to do. And something we should learn
He is still truthful and obviously kind and caring. He just does what’s needs to be done. He’s a military leader not leading a firm
I completely forgot Erwin would get his arm back. That'd be pretty badass
Best Comment
It been a year daddy
While I believe Armin definitely has the potential to become a good strategist at the time of Erwins death he didn't have the confidence, experience and knowledge needed especially in such a cramped time frame with Marley lurking. Erwin was prepared and experienced already and thus in my opinion would have been better
Yeah and s4 pretty much confirms it. Armin didn't really do much and the things he did could honestly have been done by others. Prior to s3 Eren and Armin were basically equals. Each had their thing they specialized in, but that became less in s4 as Eren showed more intelligence and whatnot. Their ties are also too close. Erwin doesn't have that connection with Eren and he'd be more mature about things
Erwin is literally one of my favorite characters ever. His mind and determination is what makes him pop out from the rest. He showed the idea of being selfish to be selfless. I gained a new perspective on world matters and fell in love with how Aot depicts real life issues in a fictional and interesting way were people can relate.
Anyways amazing vid, hope to win... Fingers crossed
I wish aot did a what if series just like marvel is doing because it's so fun seeing differences compared to the original.
Yeah like if eren touched historia once during the cadet training
Absolutely, like what if Marcel was never eaten by Ymir (pure titan)
And what if porco become the armored titan instead of reiner.
Also what If Eren had all 9 titan shifters
@@levizagursky7806 yeesss
I like this “what if?” Series your doing, one I have thought about though :
What if Ymir (Jaw Titan before Porco) decided to side with Eldia instead of going back to Marley?
I’d love to see your thoughts on it
ngl if that happened Paradis would have a much better handle on dealing with titans due to her info (even if it is 60 years too late) and her titan powers but all the tension of the narrative would just be gone.
If Ymir stayed then Eren wouldn’t get the Warhammer 🤷♂️
@@Binks129 why do u think that? I’m curious
@@Mikey-jf3nx Because if the Jaw Titan didn’t go back to Marley, Galliard wouldn’t be able to have it. Eren needs his favorite lil nutcracker 🤷♂️
@@Binks129 or Ymir could assist eren fighing warammer and could get her anyway.
I Fucking love these theory videos. Its literally like AOT’s “What if” series from marvel
yes ps. nice job for having 69 likes
Ikr I really want to see MUCH more from this
“what if” comes from star wars/dbz from me
One of the greatest failings of Armin was treating Eren like a friend until it was too late. Erwin would not. He would see Eren as the liability that he was and plan, or even act, in accordanc; i.e. say, arrange for the founding Titan to be in someone who doesn't suffer from murderous impulses or an enormous ego, someone reliable and stable, like Hange.
Hange is too much of an asset in the long term. He wouldn't dream of making her a titan if he knew it would cut off her lifespan.
Her technological improvements to the military were way too important, especially with the marleyan technology she could spend hours figuring out how to reverse-engineer.
She would he brilliant as a titan, but burn out way too fast.
As for how he'd go about selecting the next attack founding titan, I can't say. I can only think of who he wouldn't want to lose.
@@DandyZero Giga Chad Erwin becomes the attack colossal founding titan. Collect all the titans like infinity stones.
@@Mister100Percent Seeing all the titan powers under the control of Erwins strategic mind, as he juggernauts his way against literally everybody to destroy the world except for Paradis would be metal as fuck.
@@DandyZero Nah Erwin would big brain it so that he doesn’t even need to kill the entire world. My man would whip out the charter of humanity to prove that Eldians just want peace and devastate anyone who attacks out of self defense.
maybe
I cried so much during the scene in which they had to choose between Armin or Erwin, Erwin was my favorite character and seeing Levi cry thinking of losing the only person that he was loyal to and treated him right after his hard life broke me, we're used to seeing a badass Levi but we had never seen a sensitive one. I understood and rooted for him each time he let his anger out on Zeke for what happened to Erwin.
Imagined if, bertholdt memories managed to influenced Erwin to liking Annie lol.
That wasn't a true thing though
@@thelordraj5412 wait wasn’t it?
@@tengkuhafiz4174 i think armin already liked annie, bertholdts memories were just a bonus. I think I haven't fully read the manga.
Lol
The dude was like 40 she was teenager...
Honestly... Why couldn't this be what really happened? Erwin was a great character, with an amazing ability to find solutions to absolutely absurd problems
Too OP, lol.
Zeke might be fodder if that happens
On one side it's because Armin was one of the main trio so he had that plot armor. On the other side it would be pretty epic and emotionally crushing to see Armin die.
AkumaTsumi, this shows that plot armour really is the best shield you can ever possess.
The show need a reboot for this what if scnerio
I'm wondering considering that Historia's dad became a titan even with just a lick from the broken syringe. What if they were able to divide the dose into two parts and with the use of a spinal tap, they extract 2 doses of Bertholt's spinal fluid and give it to Armin and Erwin. I wonder if that'll make 2 Colossal titans...
It wouldn't work, unless they managed to keep Reiner captured and make Erwin gets the Armored while Armin still gets the Colossal...
It doesn’t matter whether Erwin or armin dies it still hurts like man why are you making me choose between my fave characters
EXACTLY. PEOPLE FORGET THIS.
I'M HERE WONDERING HOW PEOPLE HAVE THE HUMANITY TO SAY A CERTAIN PERSON/CHARACTER IS "USELESS"
BRO?
@@daniellemcclain1613 because they aren't human.lol.humanity your ass
Armin sucks
@@luciuspowerhouse3125 Without Armin everyone would of been in deepshit
@@luciuspowerhouse3125 No. Your just wrong. He sucked in season 4 but in every other season he has some of the best development and overall character in the series.
This just goes to show that Erwin should’ve got the Colossal titan. I like Hanji but she is no commander or brilliant strategist.
Yeah, she's more like a scientist.
I mean she is the scouts main scientist for a reason.
I was actually rooting for Erwin
Well, Armin is the actual successor.
It’s confirmed that she is tied with zeke as the smartest characters in the aot universe, tho I agree this doesn’t necessarily mean she’s the best leader
I also believe that Erwin was a better choice. His experience and charisma is something Armin does not have. If not for Erwin they would not have the support they needed to retake wall Maria. He planned the damn coup because Erwin realized that they cannot move forward with their fight against the titans if they don't change their own system. He's a great planner and strategist.
all u hear is " SHINZOU WO SASAGEYO " when he transforms
Instead of self injury, that quote is his trigger
@@Gralde15 lmao
And what the fuck does that mean?
@@danielfenton1686 calm down
-What if the sun exploded?
Me: I sleep
-What if Erwin got the Colossal titan?
Me: *I CLICK*
Wow, this just makes me miss Erwin even more 😭
Survey fleet docking into Marley: “get that small fish…”
Erwin: “LAY DOWN YOUR LIVES FOR HUMANITY”
😂😂😂
Erwin's one of my favorite characters in AoT, he has some of the most memorable lines and moments in the show.
I'd love if Isayama, now that he's finished with the story; decided to give us official alternate history novels for AoT. (If Erwin survived, If Hannes fought Dina's Titan the first time, If Reiner got eaten instead of Marcel, etc.)
and of course the ultimate aot au which has godzilla in it
*DELTARUNE*
So basically Isayama’s version of “What if?”
@@eulogioalejando3137, Yeah, that would be a cool idea.
What if zeke followed Grihsas plans for him to become a restorationist
Marcel have a lot of room for characterization. Since he was probably the leader, he was probably very clever. What if he pulled a zeke-like 180, and side with paradis? Maybe kidnap his own family to further push a plan to destroy marley? All that while still disguising as a loyal warrior?
Just me, of course.
I have thought about this, I think Erwin would have gotten depressed after figuring out the truth about the world and become inefficient. The story suggests as much, that is the dream he was drunk on. He wasn't interested in freeing Eldians or saving humanity or ensuring his nation could survive the world. He wanted to learn the truth, once he learned it his life would lose purpose and it would take a couple years for him to find another purpose; years he wouldn't have in the story.
I agree. I think they would be forced to pass on the Colossal in this case.
Yeah sadly Erwin had reached his breaking point.
a cowardice achieved their dream people have another life does not end there but begins from there
Fully agree with this. Erwin's arc in the main story demonstrates that his entire drive was on the idea of finding out the truth, and when he'd realise there is little that Paradis could do about the outside world, he would perhaps stop being as effective as a leader as when he was once determined to find the truth behind his father's death. Instead, he died a man that sacrificed himself for humanity rather than a self-motivated leader (that he essentially was before the Beast Titan fight). One can argue Levi almost foresaw this reality when he chose to revive Armin instead- Levi was giving Erwin a chance to die for a good cause, and this is a form of "mercy", rather than living a purposeless life after discovering the contents of the basement.
When he transforms, there is no lightning, its just a giant sword that falls from the sky that reveals his titan and anybody within 25 kilometers just hears "SHINZOU WO SASAGEYO"
This really shows that Erwin's tactical genius was unparalleled. If only there had been two syringes
But if both erwin and armin got injected one of them has to inherit the colossal titan
@@dark_fire2549 true perhaps if they were able to secure the armour titan
I mean they could have divided it but one would become just a normal titan
@@dark_fire2549 split the fluid
@@Arugma how though the titan transformation will not be complete
This is actually... pretty good, man. I love the theory. People usually make tiny changes eventually concluding that it is irrelevant, who got injected.
I know alot of ppl are saying that Erwin is their favorite character, but same. He's just so cool and badass, especially when he says SHINZOU SASAGEYO. It would've been rlly cool as well if he was the one who became the colossal.
I think one other reason Levi didnt pick Erwin. Was because he could see his old friend trio, (that we saw in the ova) in Armin, Eren and Mikasa's friend trio.
I didn't think about that.
I don't think Levi cared about that when he made his decision. He was thinking about Kenny's words more in that moment than anything else. \
@@christiansanchez1785 Kenny's words? which ones?
he has big ears unlike admins to hear his enemies screaming
His attack on Marley would be next level👀
👀👀👀
I feel like Erwin definitely would’ve been more bad ass as the colossal
bro would have carried the whole squad and wiped the whole marleyan squad with his strategies. armin m's colossal titan was just saddening and disappointing
erwin was so powerful that isayama had to nerf the legend🔥
@@JIREN972 collosal titan isn’t really for Erwin, he fits the cart titan.
Cart titan requires strategies and fast thinking and etc (said in the anime) pieck was chosen because she was the smartest student in Marley, and Annie were top at combatant.
@@JIREN972 and also. If Erwin got the titan, he would use it agaisnt the scouts. He would be an yeagrist and protect eren at aall cost.
@@anderson_abigail3322 Nah bro erwin isnt gonna be holding some guns while they aim.Bro with colossal he can do wayyy more
I think it bears mentioning that no Armin means a much more heartless Mikasa, and who knows how this'd affect Eren and Mikasa's relationship.
Actually had the same idea of having two open spots on Erwin's colossal titan form, so that when it release smoke from the forehead it will form something looking a devil's horn.
There's also a very large possibility that Erwin's character would completely change if he had gotten the injection. Because he had planned to die during the charge, the guilt he would've faced afterwards would have been incredibly strong. He most likely would've dropped commandership completely.
I doubt he would drop the commandership because he would have dishonoured his people because he is a great leader that could save their people
Erwin had already killed hundreds of scouts before the charge. I doubt he'd suddenly start to regret it
At best he'd take a break, but he'll see that his successors aren't as capable as him
And he'll take on the demon-mantle again to make sure that their comrades sacrificed their lives for a good reason
So u think Erwin disrespects his fallen scouts & ran away from his job...
naw erwin is stronger than that
Erwin is a chad commander. He is responsible so there is no way he would suddenly become a coward and leave everything behind after having the injection. The things you said sounds like what Armin is doing right now.
Erwin would definitely be the best choice. Not only would he be looking to make alliances with other countries. I think he use the Eldians in the interment zone. Potentially creating civil unrest with the Marley government and the Marley Eldians when Marley is faced with a war on multiple fronts. I also think that Erwin would have Eren undo Annie’s hardening and have someone else inherit the Female Titan giving Paradise another shifter in their arsenal.
I actually wrote a what if of this story myself. Here it is:
The whole group would be devastated about Armin, with Eren the most upset. The group would still go to find the basement, but Erwin was with the group. The following events continue the same, with everyone finding out that there is a world outside the walls, but Erwin is happy to know his father was right all along, and sheds a tear. Eren continues to see memories of his past, with Erwin taking the place of Armin and further understanding Grisha's motives and the rules of the Titans. The ceremony also continues the same, with a depressed Eren seeing his future memories. However, after losing Armin, Eren is more determined to ensure that none of his friends die. The following events continue the same.
1 Year later, the Marleyan survey fleet arrives, and events continue the same. This time, however, Erwin takes the place of Hange, and is more stern towards Yelena when they are talking in the tent. Of course, Erwin is highly suspicious of the Volunteers, but understands that if the island is to survive against the rest of the world, they need to carry out Zeke's plan. Zeke is also in favor of Zeke's plan to use the Founding Titan to release the rumbling.
During this time, everyone else was pleading with Erwin to try to make peace before using the Rumbling. After time, Erwin understood that it would be best to try to make peace with the enemy before using the Rumbling, but knew that if peace became impossible, they would use the rumbling. Also during this time, Eren would continue to tell Floch about his true plan, knowing that Erwin would never allow the entire world to be destroyed. Events would continue the same, with the group going to Marley in hopes of brokering peace.
After the 4 year timeskip, events continue the same. Eren attacks Marley, Erwin uses the Colossal to nuke the harbor, and events continue the same. Essentially, Erwin would replace Hange's role in the rest of the series, with Hange just sticking by Erwin. Events continue to follow the same route, up to the point of the final confrontation between Eren. Erwin is captured by the Pig Titan, and confronts Zeke in the Titan Realm. However, instead of telling Zeke the meaning of life like Armin did, Erwin instead tells Zeke of the sacrifices and gambles he's made over the years. He talks about the fellow comrades he's lost, and how their sacrifices got them this far. He thinks to his father's dream, and how he finally got to prove him right and see the basement.
Finally, he tells Zeke that those people died because they believed in the cause, and that they entrusted the rest of the work to their comrades. This causes Zeke to think back to Tom, who died entrusting their euthanization plan to Zeke. He stands up, with Tom and Grisha appearing to him. He thanks Tom for trusting in him, and that while he won't be able to carry out their euthanization plan, he can still save the world, and asks for his and Grisha's help. Erwin looks to Bertold, and tells him that he's sorry for taking his life, but asks for his help in defeating Eren. Also, Marcel, Porco, and Ymir were also listening to Erwin's words, and all decided to help. Events then continue the same, with Erwin being freed, the others helping the Alliance to stop the past Titans, and Erwin using the Colossal to blow up Eren.
The final battle stays the same, with Erwin fighting a Colossal Eren, Mikasa decapitating Eren, resulting in him dying. Like the rest of his friends, Erwin also has a moment with Eren. Erwin understands what Eren has to do, and apologizes for putting Eren in that position, along with being chosen instead of his friend. Erwin then ends by saying that it looks like Eren finally made a gamble of his own, and he hopes it will pay off. Later, after 3 years, the Alliance are heading back to Paradis to make peace with the world. The group asks Erwin if he thinks they can make peace, with Erwin saying it will just have to be another gamble.
For those interested, I created a blog for my what if stories like the one above. Because RUclips won't let me post the link, I posted it in three replies below. Just type in all three replies to get the url
Your efforts writing this are appreciated
@@Rui-mika-001 Yeah I wrote it on another site but it was marked as spam so I thought I'd never get to use it
im sorry but I don’t have the mental capacity to process all those words
This is genuinely amazing. I love how you included Erwin into the story but kept true to the author’s story. You deserve every like you get. Continue writing too you’re good at it
Agent X keep writing it. I love reading this comment
The thing I love about aot is that there is enough character development and lore that people can literally make theories about alternate timelines.
That's the sign of great storytelling.
Hell yeah
I don’t think Erwin would’ve been good after they learned the secrets to the outside world. Like Erwin said himself, the only thing that made him want to keep living was to find the secrets that were being hidden. After that he might lose his edge.
This series seems like it's gonna be a lot of fun, just like Marvel's What If. Can't wait to see your work!
I have another what if idea about this.
What if Erwin AND Armin survived?
The story goes like this: The titan spinal fluid was injected into Armin, but they also had some more in the box so they could have given it to both. Yes, only 1 would have gone back to human, but the other didn't die. So the journey of Eldia was to catch another titanshifter for that person. Whether it was Armin they wanted to give Berthold or Erwin is up to your own thoughts. But it'd be cool to see the end of it being that Armin/Erwin come back after months or years or whatever amount of time as a titan. And so both could stay alive
so What if they got 2 injections armin eats reiner and Erwin eats the collosal
@@rx8856 there were, when Kenny gave the injection bottle to Levi there was some more in a different bottle
@@khaiwhitley1122 or eren wouldn't have eaten Lara Tybur and Armin)
/Erwin had
@@ny2354 so what if they had 3 injections and eren listened to the survey corps to being the war hammer to be eaten but armin had ate reiner and Erwin had ate the colossal who would get the warhammer
@@khaiwhitley1122 you choose ;)
Erwin is all about striking first. So he would've been totally down with attacking Marlay also he would see it's their best option. He would first try to find some allies of course. Frankly Erwin would probably go to Marlay on his own if he had to.
He would’ve been really happy,
After showing The Paradis Devils that there is humanity outside the walls.
Fun fact: Erwin didn’t take the serum because he didn’t want to fall in love with Annie
(This a joke btw 💀)
Fbi open up
Ladies and gentlemen... we got him
FBI OPEN UP!
this is a cursed comment
@@dontlikethiscomment but I liked anyway ;)
"...made Armin fall in love with a crystal" that got me lol
Erwin is my favorite character from AOT! The possibilities are almost endless if Levi gave him the injection. Erwin always seemed determined and sure of his decisions in front of most people. I think that’s why Hange and Armin had a hard time with Eldians in general getting behind them (plus neither could really handle the pressure of following Erwin’s footsteps). I think with his resolve and amazing tactical thinking it could’ve changed a few things. However it’s difficult when the whole world hates your race.
I always thought erwin would join eren in attacking marley as he could see marley partially being responsible for his dads death. Erwin could argue to save paradis the world must burn.
But they aren't, if they aren't dirrctly the ones responsible they didn't kill him, the paradise government did, erwin only goes by truths
Yess
I'm not surprised at all when Levi chose Armin. From a storytelling perspective, Armin is the better choice because that choice could generate so many potential for character development.
Yet, Isayama couldn't bring the full potential.
Manga was rushed..
I like Erwin but most of his strategies involve a ton of casualties or a huge gamble. Whereas Armin will always try to reduce casualties no matter his own life being in danger.
soon enough one person will argue about this
I mean, death is inevitable, no matter how much u try, erwin knew that so he had to do what he had to do
Yeah, but Armin not taking risks or not even willing to make gambles at all is what leads to his indecisiveness, and that can be just as catastrophic as Erwin's plans, except at least Erwin would get closer to his goal in the end
@@Darkthebest He said "reduce" casualties. People are still going to die but there will be less casualties.
@@thalmoragent9344 Except Armin always goes through with his plans no matter how indecisive was. And his plans never failed, no matter which one he chose
Whoever drew up the Titan form of Erwin, deserves so much praise! It looks so freakin' good! :O
Erwin’s titan: CAN YOU FEEL MY HEART 🎶🎶
as much as i love armin and his form of the colossal, it honestly just would have made more sense for erwin to inherit it, but i dont think i couldve handled not having armin so im happy with the outcome, nice video as always !
Erwin is my favorite character. His death made me cry like a baby, and even now I'm still heartbroken :/
1 thing is obvious - Erwin wouldn't be tricked with the Wine or by Yelena. He would take her words, but he would also be cautious.
Honestly, Attack On Titan is such a unique story, I myself have wondered about several possibilities about how the story could have turned out differently (Though it could be argued that it was always fated to happen this way). Still, I can't help but ponder... What if?
"In the main timeline we saw how Bernand's influence made Armin fall in love with a crystal", This has been in my head for 2 years but I didn't know how to put it but then my man Turtle Quirk came to the rescue
As soon as I read the title I continued with “ I’d be disappointed”
You could do a what If on if Eren was eaten by Historia
GOOD IDEA 👍 👍
She would have been like her descendants. She would have let Paradis be destroyed because she would have had the king's ideology since she is of royal blood
Yeah, everyone is gonna be fucked.
Expect the rest of the world
Bye Bye Paradis 👋
I imagine Erwin having a good hold or grip on Eren. Feel like Eren possibly wouldn’t go out from Erwins orders but that’s just me.
Eren probably goes Dr Strange with founding titan power and realise they are fucked anyhow so he puts matters into his own hands
Erwin would nuke both eren's feet so that he can't keep moving forward
@@hashyyrz673 nah Erwin would probably be on team ereh the dude sacrificed a 1000 people including himself so they could just see what’s in a basement now we’re talking the ultimate freedom of the planet for eldians the plot of stay the same except 100 percent of life outside the walls would’ve died
@@hashyyrz673 this is taking me out helpp
Haha freedom goes brrrrr. Eren does what he wants. Period. He don’t take orders from NOBODY now.
A Mid-East parternship would've been cool to see. "Have some giant ass Anti-TItan Cannon tech. And a train with extra cannons."
I don't care if I have to wait for another month. I'm definitely gonna wait for Part 2. I've always wanted to imagine this possible topic ever since I saw season 3 episode 19.
Jesus christ Erwin's collosal titans forehead is massive
I mean he is super smart so
@@alanlowstuter9698 he looks ridiculous but I kinda like it
Genuinely I have suddenly become addicted to this type of attack on Titan alternate universes
I’d like to see a version of aot as a show just like Mavels what if it’d be sooo good
Ooh what if eren [MANGA SPOILER] never destroyed 80% of the world and mikasa stopped the rumbling
@@trigaashy2502 why would you do that 😭
@@MidnightNachos yessir
@@trigaashy2502 ngl i think eren made up the fact he destroyed 80 percent of hummanity like how did they get advance enough to develop stealth bombers and attack eldia its pretty much not adding up
@@Alien_From_Another_Universe He did destroy 80% and the attack on eldia happened 200 years later.
This actually sounds more entertaining than the original timeline tbh.
Fr. At least Erwin actually got somewhere. I know it was made clear that Armin couldn’t replace Erwin entirely, but Armin’s sort of mentality didn’t make him a good leader to move everyone forward that much during the war. It fell all on Hange, who did an amazing job despite everything but they were no Erwin.
@@vchapa22 yeah, like tf did armin really do other than point out hints. Erwin could’ve also blown up those ships
@@nineotindo4563 those ships and all of Marley if he was feeling inspired enough
There is a fanfiction called *Attack on Titan: The Devil We Need* and it's a really cool professionally written story (for me anyway) about what would've happened if Erwin got the Colossal Titan ability, I'm not going to spoil shit just look it up, you will not be disappointed :)
I see that pfp you have on. Classic
Where can I read it on?! It sounds really good!
RIP ERWIN! You were and will always be the best commander attack on attack has ever had.
How did you get those emojis
Attack on attack
Nobody fucking dabs or sais Savage anymore bro
@@NaturalRevenger plenty of people still do it bro, tf you on about?
@@sheluvsbilly5393 that shit is from 2018 and was done by Roblox and Fortnite squeaker kids that beg to use their grandma's credit card to get robux, Honestly even if you are right then that's just sad and I have little respect for those people
Erwin was honestly the best character in the series, such a inspiration of an individual
I still think that Isayama had to kill him cause after the events of return to Shiganshina arc the premise of the series changed a lot, I mean the plot changed drastically and Erwin was just to smart that his presence would have made things way more interesting but also way to complicated
I wish someone makes a manga on this theory. It will be dope seeing Erwin again 💀🤯
This is the biggest question I've had in the whole of AOT. I loved Erwin so much and I definitely think that him and armin were a hard choice to choose. Both were extremely smart, willing to sacrifice themselves, and had dreams Beyond what most people inside the walls have. It's sad, Armin would've never seen the ocean or Erwin would have never known the truth and that his question about humans outside the walls was actually true. This scene would have had no good ending. Someone had to be sacrificed and this was definitely a tough decision
The tumbnail of Erwins collosal titan just looks like handsome squidward or the chad meme to me
I cried when Erwin died all he wanted to do was confirm his dads theory :(
Imagine if, bertholdt memories managed to influenced Erwin to liking Annie lol.
Erwin: i would like to do some research on annie crystal
Erwin isn't a pedophile
ive been ur fan for a really long time and i just love all ur videos .. I always watch ur videos after watching the episodes and trust me when i tell you you revise better than the teachers at my school .. Trying to win the challenge may also be one of my motives while writting this comment. Anyway keep up the good work and keep rocking..
0:35 to be fair, Armin was also a clever plan guy It’s just that after season 3 ended he suddenly got retconned to be a passive dumbass. So it’s plausible that Erwin would have been retconned to be a passive dumbass too.
It said in anime that Armin planned this crazy plan to attack Marly.
New Titan Shifters
Beast Titan: Jean - Horse
Jaw Titan: Sasha
Cart Titan: Connie
Armor Titan: Hanji
Switch Sasha and Jean. Sasha is a marksman so very accurate with range attacks. Jean as cart cuz *H O R S E*
@@countchompula1896 but what animal would be good for Sasha since I chose the Jaw Titan for her with that bread scene with Historia in mind
@@countchompula1896 she might not have a long range titan like zeke
Colossal Erwin meeting Beast Zeke like "Wanna play some baseball now?"
You forgot to mention how Erwin was pretty much done being a leader by the time of his death. You said that his truest motivation was proving his dad right and saving humanity was next. I personally think that Erwin was so beat down and so depressed that he wouldn’t be capable of making that many well thought out decisions. Also the island not being perfectly protected wasnt Eren’s only motivation for the rumbling. That won’t change the fact that Eren is a troubled individual. I think Armin meant too much to Eren, and Erwin was too distraught to be a leader anymore. You really think Eren would be okay knowing Armin never got to see the ocean?
Thanks for reading this comment
Yeah, like Eren was a wild card. Imagine if Armin did die. (;;;*_*)
As if Erwin would just give up after the sacrifices everyone made so that he could live and see the basement.
@:D In fact he'd probably be more motivated knowing that everything he thought to be real and true, was. He'll still kinda be like Levi a bit after leading so many to their deaths
If he gave up it would mean the sacrifices of all his comrades would be for nothing. Erwin never would’ve given up if he still had a chance to live. Depressed or not, he was the demon commander of the scouts. The only thing that keeps him down is death itself. No amount of despair, guilt, or wounds would be enough to stop him.
Erwin creative battle tactics were amazing and the way he was willing to make sacrifices was incredible. Erwin was truly a devil for his enemies!!!!
Honestly, I think that Erwin, Eren, Mikasa, Floch, and a few other Scouts would have a disagreement with the Paradis higher-ups. I believe that Erwin would want to go undercover and observe the Marleyans to spot useful weaknesses, but the higher ups wouldn’t want to risk losing a potential ally. Erwin would argue that the Marleyans wouldn’t want to ally with the people they just tried to kill. Erwin would be caught starting a secret mission to invade Marley quietly and he would get arrested.
Erwin could have facilitated the release of the Eldian population from the other countries too. Increasing the population and fighting force of Paradise Island. The information from the different countries would also propel their countries medicine, math, and science forward.
Erwin would have kept everything together.
I wonder how some of the scenes involving Armin and his colossal would differ with Erwin
That epic speech before his death would be devalued if he came back
Hey um What If there's a 10th titan shifter where everytime he shouts, it could make any titans numb including titan shifter within range?
Where a titan suddenly falls down to its knees after hearing the roar/shout including the titan shifters
Armin's ability to think quickly and make plans was pretty hindered by Bert's being slow to take action, so it might affect Erwin's strategy making too
No, where?
I honestly think it would’ve been tough if Erwin was revived. Eren would’ve been pissed and probably left the survey corp anyway, and Mikasa would follow him wherever he went. Erwin might try to talk to him like Hange did and may manage to have a better conversation? maybe then, they come up with a better plan anyway?