Kohberger Gets Tough New Judge (9/27/2024 Hearing)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 сен 2024
- At Friday's hearing, Kohberger met his new judge -- and the new judge is tough.
Bryan Kohberger is accused of a heinous crime: murdering four University of Idaho college students as they slept. Kaylee Goncalves, Maddie Mogen, Xana Kernodle and Ethan Chapin were stabbed to death in the middle of the night in a home in Moscow, Idaho.
Kohberger pushed for a change of venue, claiming local Latah County jurors could not be fair. His Latah County judge, Judge Judge, moved the case to Ada, where it was assigned to a new judge, Steven Hippler.
#bryanKohberger #kohberger #truecrime #idaho4
#Idahofour
Enjoying the content? Join us by becoming a channel member!
/ @harvardlawyerlee
This channel was formerly known as the Harvard Lawyer Lee channel.
TWITTER: LawyerLeeW
MODERATORS: Many thanks to marlonmaastricht and mamapinks, the best mods anywhere.
OUTRO: by MarlonMaastricht
WHAT I USE TO STREAM: STREAMYARD. You can preload exhibits and video and it works for meetings as well as RUclips livestreams. Affiliate link: streamyard.com...
This Judge will Not Tolerate Games
I think He Will Do Fantastic 💙💯
Judge Hippler was the chief administrative judge for ADA county during the Daybell trial, so if anything, he knows how to manage a high-profile trial. He did an interview with Nate Eaton during the Daybell trial.
Thank you for this info! Just watched that short interview this hearing. He seems to be decisive which is my favorite quality in a judge. 🙏
Beautiful explaination, you like this judge dont you Lee? Im so glad your back Lee. You look and sound great. Love to you and your family.
I think I am going to like this Judge. My biggest concern is that he will be able to keep AT in line and from trying to run the Courtroom. I liked Judge Judge too, but I didn’t think he was able to control AT, I think she has a very big tendency to try and “brow beat” the Judge, like a dog with a 🍖 bone!! IMO, I felt that Judge Judge just gave in to her to shut her up. Hopefully, this Judge will have a strong enough personality to stand up to her.
If there's one component that I deem indispensable to a well-run courtroom is a judge who doesn't go for theatrics or distracting legal gymnastics. Thank you, dear Lawyer Lee, for this surprising, and very useful, Sunday video. ❤❤❤
It's about damn time! Judge Judge was sillier than silly.
I truly hope this judge will set the trial as soon as possible, the victims families have been waiting for the justice they all deserve! Remember those 4 beautiful victims!
It seems to me that if a juror can be swayed one way or the other by what the defendant is wearing, they shouldn’t be on the jury. 🤷🏼♀️
Agree. Thankfully the little schoolgirl outfits and haircut didn’t work with Carly Gregg’s case. A good jury looks right past the defense’s “theatrics.”
Nonetheless, many would see the defendant dressed in prison clothes during the trial.
Agree
Who is this uninformed fool of a host? Nevermind, nobody cares for illiterate wannabe influencer
I'm guessing you aren't a defense attorney. EVERY aspect (no matter how small) that associates the defendant with guilt is to be avoided. Remember the mandate? They are INNOCENT until proven otherwise. Why would you advertise your client in clothes that indicate guilt? It's a no-brainer.
I love this new Judge. Judge Judge was a bit too soft and allowed Anne Taylor to intimidate him, (I am NOT a fan of Anne Taylor) Imo. This Judge is a much better fit for this case.
I never thought Judge Judge was intimidated by AT; if anything he was too eager to respond to WT's theatrics, and bending over backwards to indulge the Prosecutor's reasons for delays, toletate and fail to criticize the FBI's intimidation tactics on the Defense's witness. WT is the one who has been withholding evidence, he's the one who got the judge to side with him over stopping that crucial survey which by the way clarified "untruths" that he didn't want revealed, and got JJ to actually stop that survey for two weeks, and want what WT wanted, to remove those few questions, and start over w/o them! One of which revealed there never was any evidence that BK stalked the victims, or anyone else (ooops, there goes the motive, right?) Now WT has to paint BK as an even more psychopathic homicidal maniac choosing offhand a very congested parking lot on a big weekend, w/people coming and going, all evening and early morning, avoiding a DD delivery, and carrying a huge 'weapon" in his hands to a house he's never been in or associated with in any way (and he loves dogs, too)....can this new judge NOT be better than one beholding to a tight UID community and it's insistence BK is the 1? This one may be a graduate of UID, or a parent of one, or somehow connected to it, but AT is just as smart and hardworking as the best of 'em; if he's intimidated it will be w/WT and his already weak presentation in front of him! Uh, I don't know, umm, Ms.?
(Assistant) should be able to speak to that..., is it all new or is it redundant? Referring to that huge amount of recently delivered ¥aπ∆ing 'evidence'? My bet is that there's nothing "new", and the theatrics are yet to come from his direction. Its2025 almost, even if the judge was 75 dealing with a smart, respectful woman in Idaho shouldn't be a problem, and perceiving a flimflam job easy to detect; if he hasn't already wondered at the improbable coincidences/missteps in that investigation WT was involved in leading haphazardly, but actually intentionally to this defendant.🤔
@nomadsca - Another armchair lay expert. Lol Never ceases to suck all the oxygen out of a room with half baked supposition though it’s clear you’ve no idea what you’re waxing ad nauseam about. Koo koo!
@@nomadscavenger absolutely!! Everyone seems to think Anne was “brow beating” JJ… I never ever saw or felt that way. The defense shouldn’t have to fill (so far) 18 to compel to get evidence.. it’s the state that’s delaying.. I guess people are watching a different case than we are.
Judge Judge requested a new judge be appointed when he moved the trial.
So far I am liking this judge.
I think this judge is a better fit for this case. He will stop the stalling tactics.
👍💯%He doesn't seem to suffer fools either. And it's been WT's tactic to stall, or create a mess so that it LOOKS like the Defense is stalling when WT throws his "mt.of evidence" in total disarray on AT's desk taking months to put it together, then just recently turning over an additional (?) 398 gigabytes of more of his evidence which he cannot attest to being new or already included in his first dump, withholding crucial evidence, losing/deleting others, and forgetting what happened to the video and transcript of BK's "exonerating" proof he gave in that one MPD interrogation of where he was that night, and it wasn't in Moscow. Oddly, everything that could prove he was someplace else, and the actual route he took that night has disappeared. But it's the Defense with a good many witnesses on his behalf, and her continued conviction he's innocent AFTER going through it all that's stunning. And it looks like there will be more witnesses to come for him. Just who is going to come forward for WT and that DP is the real mystery IMO.
lol yeah kohebergers team fucked up on the change of venue this judge is very different then the last
Yes they screwed. the pooch! I knew the odds of 2 pussy judges in a row like JJ were astronomical! He was the worst indecisive jurist - truly weak.
I thought he meant he didn't want to be there bc it was unfortunate that 4 young people died.
that is what I thought as well
@@TheHolliHolland I didn’t take it that way at all. But I think this Judge is gonna run a tight trial which I think is a good thing, considering how IMO, under Judge Judge, who I liked but I don’t think he had a strong enough personality to deal with AT. As a retired Paralegal, I definitely saw her just “brow beat” Judge Judge to get her way! It also seems to me Thompson has just checked out of this case altogether! Heard he was going to try to assign another Attorney to try the case, but that’s just a rumor going around!
No, it’s because of the inconvenience to him 👍
@@DonnaLynn73 “brow beat” for the evidence the State isn’t turning over to the defense that’s its entitled too?
Starting September runs into Thanksgiving, Christmas, first days of school…. Much better to start in May, imo.
You do a really good job summarizing the case which keeps me from having to watch court tv all day! I truly enjoy your channel and am amazed that you have kept your channel going even with what you have had to endure this year. I pray that the families gets justice even if he is found not guilty. All that any of us want is justice for victims.
This judge seems like the perfect fit for this case. He came out swinging! All his points are practical. Definitely not as easily charmed as Justice Judge sometimes was 😂.
The judge was changed because the last paragraph of the order granting change of venue quoted 21(c)(2)(B), which indicates that the judge does not wish to continue on the case.
"Kohberger's Motion to Change Venue is granted pursuant to Idaho Criminal Rule 21(a) and
21(b). Consistent with the language of Idaho Criminal Rule 21(c)(2)(B), this Court orders transfer
of venue "without specifying the new place of venue" and refers "the case to the administrative
director of the courts for assignment by the Supreme Court to court of proper venue in another
judicial district and assignment of specific judge to preside in the criminal proceeding."
Lawyers on other podcast agree….defense is pushing off trial date and there is no reason for continued delays.
No reason!!
@@terripetre8159 There is absolutely a reason for delays! Bill will not turn over evidence the defense is entitled to in order to defend their client.. There will be more motions to compel and this Judge will not tolerate Bills excuses.. or it simply won’t come into trial and that means reasonable doubt.
It’s time to stop all the favors Bryan has been given. No more delays, no street clothes, no more “I was star gazing, etc.
In the end it does not matter. Chad Daybell was allowed civil clothes before trial. It did not change anything. He was convicted to death anyway.
I'm glad he finally is in isolation without his own TV, and other ridiculous 'perks'!
I like this judge, he is seasoned
This case needed a tougher judge. This case has had so many stall tactics… as for his clothing.. there’s been countless high profile cases where the accused had to wear a prison jumpsuit.. why would kohlberger deserve special treatment? If that’s the new standard.. it should be allowed for all defendants otherwise the difference in treatment can also skew the public’s opinion. Kolberger wears a suit and Richard Allan is brought in with prison garb, dog collar, leg shackles, shock vest, hand restraints and 5 huge guards… how does that disparity affect public perception??
Exactly 💯
Be careful what you wish for ...
The Ann Taylor Grand Standing Revue has had its last performance with any luck. I want the judge to tell her be ready by May 2025 with all experts, unicorns, whatever!
Good afternoon from So. Cal!
I really like this new judge so far.
Aloha Lee! Always appreciate your measured analysis.
Here's an idea: he pleads guilty and gets life in prison, instead of wasting all of that time and all of Idaho's money on defending him. I hope the prosecution isn't holding out for the d. penalty and not accepting a plea deal. It's fine with me if he rots in prison for the rest of his life; he thinks he's smarter than everyone else in the room and he can think about that for the next fifty years.
@elizabeth
Jeeez...
Let's hope you or no one you care for is ever FALSELY arrested ehh...
You won't need a trial.
We'll just fling you in jail forever right.
Sheesh‼
His ego would not allow to confess. He wilö never confess. Even after 20 years in prison he will not reveal anything. He will enjoy all his fangirls. Everything just like Scott Peterson.
@@lilg2300
His ego...
Know him personally do you??..
He has barely said a word but you lot have him convicted already.
Yet say nothing about the 3 other male DNA at scene.
Just BC you WANT someone to be guilty, doesn't make it so.
There is zero evidence against this guy but you're out here with pitchforks in hand.
Sheesh‼
@@PlayMistie4MeFinding someone's DNA on a knife sheath at the scene of a stabbing would not normally be considered "zero evidence", and there is other evidence relating to car sightings and cellphone locations.
@@SloverOfTeuth
Like I say...
A spec of touch DNA is gonna be far more of a problem to the prosecution to explain.
You are listening to tabloid trash info as everyone in that town used the cell towers.
I'm guessing you didn't watch previous hearings that place BK elsewhere??..
Judge Judge back in Moscow was a joke. He let the defense walk all over him.
Did he really? I wonder if he didn’t want the case
@@godzillamanstreb524Who would!
Anne Taylor, May is not tomorrow
Was totally not prepared for this but what an awesome, early morning, surprise! ❤
As long as this judge is ethical I am happy. The Wilson vs Moscow law suit and the Giglio Brady law enforcement made an trial look iffy in Latah.
Lovely to see you.
I am disheartened with all the negative and derogatory comments about Anne Taylor. My good people, she is only doing her job. I don’t know if BK is innocent or not, but whatever the case he should receive vigorous counsel because for our system to come even close to working everyone should have access to competent counsel. Wishing that BK gets roughed up in prison, or that the new judge will sink his right to a defense is a ridiculous stance to take when there hasn’t been a trial. None of us right now know all the facts, and until we do I will withhold my personal judgement.
She needs to to her job, that's right. But she surely needs a judge that tells her sometimes what the rules are. The former judge did not do that.
You are absolutely correct. If I were accused I'd want her as my attorney.
@@lilg2300No the state need to turn over evidence and missed deadlines. Those are violations.. Brady violations.. Anne is a great lawyer.. if you think this is a slam dunk by the State you are sorely mistaken.. I cannot wait until this trial starts and all the guilters out there will be shocked when it comes back NOT GUIKTY, bc they didn’t do their homework/research on this case, who just assume LE got the right guy bc they said so..
Extremely well said. Spoken from a place of intelligence.
I disagree with you about the clothing issue. I mean I have several people make the statement that they couldn’t tell if the defendant was even in Court because it looked like BK was just another attorney sitting at the defense table. I also think AT is already trying to push the trial farther out!! Also, look at how long Sara Boone has been on jail before her trial and the defendant in the Delphi case. Charles Manson wasn’t “trussed” up like Richard Allen!!
These criminals have more GROUPIES today than a 70s Rock band.....it's sickening..... Richard Allen and Kohberger have so many apologists it's jaw dropping.....I pray the jury doesn't buy into the nonsensical conspiracy theories that all these true crime junkies eat up with a wooden spoon....
I agree with you to a point however here in Ireland every defendant is allowed to wear what they want plus they don’t have prison clothes every convicted criminal in Irish prison wear there own clothes makes no sense to me but that’s how messed up it is here
I was happy to see Bill Thompson sound confident and ready for trial.
Now like Sara Boone is he gonna requests professional hair and makeup?
Good evening from London
Good evening to you in London, England, Rich.
God bless the four victims and their families and friends. I pray this is resolved quickly. Too many games on behalf if the defense. Glad to see you again Lee! Hope you are doing well.
Thanks!
This judge compared to Judge Gull of the Richard Allen Delphi case...smh
The video evidence available to the public from the state isn't clear and doesn't actually prove anything.
Happy Sunday Lawyer Lee, you look beautiful and sound well ❤ Thank you for the video. I like this judge!!!!🎉
Hello, Denise Pelton! I wish you a happy Sunday evening. 😊
@@melstiller8561 Happy Sunday Evening to you too! I hope you had a great weekend ❤️
Thank you Lee...have a wonderful Sunday....❣
This judge is not playing.
Thanks for the update!! This judge seems very fair.
I don't think there is anywhere in America that people haven't heard about this case .
I'm in Colorado. I know plenty of people who know little or nothing about this case.
I’m sure most people know about the case but don’t know many details. Most of my family doesn’t know much about it and are not invested at all with this case as I am. We are in Cali…
Hi y’all 💕
Hi!
In a bigger town everyone knows everyone who "matters". Like Mayor Eric Adams, for instance. BK is well known by now.
Leeeeee, you are sorely missed!! Take care of yourself, get well soon!🙏 Things are heating up everywhere! We need your knowledge & expertise to navigate this law jungle.🙏💕
I really want to know why he did it. It's a mystery. Hopefully we will find out more about his personality and past history.
It was out of his jurisdiction and they have moved it to his jurisdiction and away from another judge. I understand how he feels.
Smashed the LIKE and thank you!
Thank you for the high level analysis Lawyer Lee! You look like you are definitely feeling better - thank you for traveling to Delphi for us !
Be careful what you ask for 😂
Good to see you
I agree about the civilian clothes. Thank you lawyer lee for your coverage.
Anne Taylor said in a hearing in Moscow some months ago that, for the mitigation during the penalty phase, her investigator has to go back THREE generations to get what is needed.
What does this mean?
That is what mitigation specialists do. They investigate the defendant's history to find anything that can mitigate the penalty phase.
"Because no person is able to recall, describe or even know all the ways in which they have been impacted, mitigation investigation relies on the collection of information from various sources including records, archives and subject research. Document collection spanning at least three generations of the client’s family is undertaken to make sure that patterns of behavior, medical conditions, generational trauma and other impacts can be seen and understood in the context of the client’s development."
I like this judge
This headline made me happy.
Me too…..only video I’ve watched on this heartbreaking case
Has this Judge only worked with Anne Taylor? You didnt say which lawyer and thats sus to me if it is her?
It sounded like he said it was Massoth, the defense attorney on Kohberger’s other side.
This Judge has worked with Elissa Massoth before.
:/ ..that Judges' comment causes concern because it might be a consequential comment for a mistrial. Nowadays defense attorneys are looking for any kind of comments etc.. for "mistrial". Especially in cases like this.
It does not, stay calm!
Thanks for sharing your impressions and insights🩷
A mitigation expert? Doesn't that imply the guilt of the defendant? I thought mitigation provided a reason for why the accused did what they did...
Yep, it's for the penalty phase, but they have to prepare for it now, even if he's not convicted.
Ha ha about time BK gets a judge to keep him in line
I think Judge John Judge resigned!!!?
This Judge is efficient and wants this trial to start ASAP- why does the defense keep dragging their feet with excuses ?
Yes I thought he invoke his right to a speedy trial???
Great video. Agree with your opinion, 25 defense experts are a lot. And length of trial seems excessive. Why is this trial so expensive? Already has cost more than Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell trials. AT needs to not be allowed to have such lengthy testimony from her "experts" as she did at hearings.
Does Ann Taylor expect a guilty verdict!? Is that why she’s asking for so much time for the penalty phase?
Thank you for this update.
The court doesn’t understand, the preparation for this trial will take longer than any other preparation that’s ever been prepared before, this case is more complicated than any case that’s ever existed before, and Brian is more innocent than any defendant that’s ever been tried before… Just let her prepare for trial till 2030, whenever she’s ready! We’ll all just wait!!
I don’t understand why they need more time when they have had 2 years!
They need more time bc the State is not turning over evidence for the defense to investigate, that’s why!
@@majestic7107 thank you!
There is a significant difference whether case is tried in May or September. Justice for surviving victims and victim families. Secondly, one expert already passed away waiting for a trial
IMO THEY NEED TO GET ON WITHTHIS TRIAL LOOK AT ALLTHE FAMILIES ARE GOING THROUGH 🙏🙏🙏 for the families
I thought what the judge said was unprofessional.
I'm sure he's completely destroyed by that.
Your dramatics aside, of course AT is prepping for a possible penalty phase. That's her job.
Also, you're acting like we never have multi-month trials. I can think of 3 recent ones that you personally covered.
Thank you. Lee
Informative and, as usual, a highly professional program. Thanks!
Is it really the prosecution's job to provide "contradictory precedent"? Surely not, that is the job of the defence. Else you may as well impose a Continental European system of justice where one lawyer acts for both plaintiff and defendant.
Seems opinions are very different amongst lawtubers. Did you notice how everyone held good posture once that judge started to state HIS rules. First lawyer that mentions BK likely could be a target? 25 experts? Joe Shmoe, suspected of murdering person X who also is presumed to be innocent I am sure won't get his 25 experts ...
This is my issue. Fairness applies both ways.
I'm bothered about the 'want, want, want...and then some, attitude of the defense? What tangeable have
So just consider 'but what if he did?'
And why be such an angry contrarion when we don't know all the facts and what evidence we will be shown.
Are the jurors going to be sequestered i missed that
The trials starts most probably next september. There are no jurors and they surely don't talk about jurors now.
If the jurors are going to be sequestered, that hasn’t been decided yet.
@@americanprincess851 thank you
Hi Lawyer Lee …another well defined video…..thanks for helping us understand the legal system ❤️❤️👍
I'm still absolutely convinced this will end with a plea agreement where the defendant pleads guilty in order to avoid the death penalty.
It’s his job !
Do you think it was odd that Bill Thompson could not answer questions without asking the Attorney General rep behind him for info?
Lee, I almost prefer your pre-recorded reviews.
I agree, I don't miss the acknowledgements of everyone in the chat.
Chad Daybell wore civilian clothes throughout his trial, I believe it was this same courthouse.
Good video
This Judge did not have to be reminded by mommy Ann that time padded quickly, I think we all know that.
I appreciate you educating us about all the procedures and making them understandable. Thank you.
Anne Taylor took on another death penalty case I think, no wonder she is all about delaying.
@@lilg2300 I'd like to know what she's been doing on the BK case these last two years other than whining and complaining about the evidence she and the two other lawyers on her team have to review.
She didn’t have a choice, it was assigned to her. She is a private lawyer now but she’s still on the list of lawyers that was death penalty certified public defenders that can be lead counsel on the case and she is the only one that serves the northern Idaho area.
this defendant should have been tried snd convictdd by now. what am i missing? our justice system is ridiculous.
Hippler? I wonder how many times he has had to tell people 'no, not with a "t" '😂
Let's hope this judge is not going to let him manipulate everyone in the court.
Sooooo, the taxpayers are paying for all the experts. Interesting.
This trial is going to be fascinating and heartbreaking. ❤️🩹
I can’t watch it, but will watch the guilty x 4 verdict
With so much sealed wow will never know the hows and whys
Love you, Lee!
Expert needs SIX MONTHS???
He's guilty and they want witnesses to forget about things.