Anakin would have either turned to the darkside after a few months or ended up becoming a replica of Luminara. A bleak personality, who is driven with the dogmatic Jedi code mindset. No emotion, no ingenuity.
Luminara, like Ki Adi Mundi, would be a terrible choice for Anakin. The master necessary for Anakin is one who understands the Dark Side and why it affects Anakin differently than those raised in the Jedi Temple. Anakin, frankly, needed psychological therapy to deal with his trauma. The Jedi way was to repress and ignore rather than engage, deal, and use. Great job, as always.
Luminara could've been different, to the point of understanding Anakin's inner turmoil. But her emotions being closed off intentionally is what's holding the poor old Mirialan back. I feel bad for her. :(
@@zondrabarth4508 I read your comment when you first posted, but I waited a few days to respond. I feel no sympathy for Luminara, partially based off of what you said. She INTENTIONALLY acted the way she did. She could have chosen otherwise, but she chose not to do so. She doesn't deserve sympathy, but derision. I have sympathy for people with mental illness who cannot choose otherwise. She is the very embodiment of the failure of the Jedi in that she adhered to an idea rather than people. The exact analogy is someone who practices a religion without considering how it applies in the world or with people. The argument that the Jedi code promotes love is obscured by not applying it to the practitioners and then outward.
@@krismikewill You didn't have to wait before responding, I'm not here looking to negatively argue with anyone, as much as I defend poor Luminara. But I'm sorry you feel that way towards an understandably hated character. If she could just get some backstory to explain why she is the way she is, it could help make her a better character to view. Let me ask you this: why is Luminara the only Jedi out of all the Prequel Order to not have any origin story? Is she that bad a character that no one can write anything good about her? Literally, if Luminara Unduli had her own Jedi Master before Episode 1, he or she was probably the one who instilled this behavior within her and couldn't help but take it to heart. Like she had no choice but to become the embodiment of the Jedi Order's failure cause it was all she knew. I mean, even though she intentionally acted secluded and emotionless, the Clone Wars showed Luminara giving emotion, even if it wasn't real emotion, I believe it was. But because being bound to the Jedi Code like glue was all she knew and understood, she couldn't express more than a frown. She almost always had a sad expression on her face. I think that truly means something. And I get that you still don't have sympathy for Luminara, but I can't help but do cause I believe her story is deeper than that and needs to be told to help cut her some slack, get the sour taste out of people's mouths. :'(
@@zondrabarth4508 I apologize if my statement sounded like an attack on you. That was not my intention. By saying that I waited to respond, I mean to say that I attempted to think longer and reach a nuanced conclusion on the character. I was not able to do so. Your statement stressing the intentionality of her approach was actually correct, and I extrapolated additional information from your claim.
Called it! I knew she'd drive him towards the dark side faster! After learning about how strict her race is, and then just how much stricter she was, I just knew it would mean disaster. Just wasn't expecting what happened after that.
I wouldn’t say it’s her entire race, I mean barris wasn’t that strict and she came from the same race. Luminara was just awful with people and didn’t understand kids have feelings too.
On a reaction point of this video, I like that fact that Luminara would be a Master that would Fail Anakin. It makes a lot of sense after all when you consider the type of Jedi she is. Would definitely like to see more of which Jedi Master would succeed or fail Anakin as a Master. So far from these videos, my favorites are Sinube and Shaak Ti.
Luminara's Temple-raised Padawan turned to the Dark Side during the Clone Wars, so it seems inevitable that Anakin would turn much easier. Like you, I really like PPSW's take on Shaak Ti as his master.
My Favorite Jedi is Kit Fisto because when i first saw clone wars (season 4) i saw Kit Fisto being a absolute badass and i placed him as my favorite jedi
This version of Anakin was intriguing. Now I wonder what'd have happened had he managed to survive. Say, Anakin manages to escape, but he loses his arm in the process like canon and maybe gets his scar. Learning from his rashness, he seeks another way to oppose his master, now on the run. While not fully light, he doesn't seem fully in the dark either, might end up meeting the Mandalorian Obi-Wan and teaming up with him.
I really like Obi-Wan clearly recognize the problem of training Anakin like a tradition Jedi when he wasn't the teacher. It really goes to show that people usually know what bad steps to avoid when they're spectators.
I would like you to make another of this particular story! One where Anakin embraces Luminara's teaching, worships the force, observes the Code, and masters Force Healing under her tutelage. This would be a very intriguing alternative story I think.
What if Dooku trained Anakin? What if Obi-Wan didn’t follow Padme to mustafar? What if Padme agreed to rule the galaxy by Anakin / Vader’s side? What if Obi-Wan died in the rescue attempt at the start of ROTS? What if Anakin quit the Jedi Order and started his own order on Naboo with Padme and the kids?
The dooku one a good idea, because depending on lore. Legends, after qui gon death he initial set out to destroy the sith. So he's at a Tipping point and could go either way. Canon dooku is already sinking into the dark side and really close to being lost before his quest against the sith
1. Interesting. But would Anakin work well under a hard, disciplined master like Dooku? 2. Padme would've died. -Anakin was about to snap even before he noticed Obi Wan. -He thought Obi Wan tries to turn Padme against him. -Padme was heart broken and didn't recocnize him anymore, which enraged Anakin even more. -Anakin thought Padme could not following him because of Obi Wan. -Padme wanted Anakin to stop and return to her. If Obi Wan wouldn't be there Anakin would've accused her of betraying him with Obi Wan and starts choking her. 3. Absolutely unlikely because this would go against everything Padme stands for. 4. Sidious would stop that from happening. He would find a way to kill Padme and/or the kids somehow blackmailing anyone and leading Anakin down the dark path.
@@danmarusan2878 True, but Dooku was also open minded and independent, I think that’s the kind of master Anakin needed. Anakin only accused Padme of supporting Obi-Wan because Obi-Wan literally showed himself at the worst possible time though. Even if Anakin had started choking Padme (which I don’t think he would without Obi-Wan being there), he would have let her go before he killed her. It takes several minutes to choke someone to death, and I think Anakin would have realized what he was doing before that. I think he would be horrified by his actions as he still loved and cared for Padme, and possibly would reconsider running away with her. I agree Padme joining Anakin would be unlikely in the canon universe, but it’s not hard to imagine an alternate reality where she loved him enough to be willing to give up everything to be by his side. Similar to how in the previous scenario, Anakin loved Padme enough to leave behind Sidious’s manipulations. I think it would be interesting to think about if nothing else. The thing is, with Anakin out of the order, Sidious loses a lot of his leverage. Even if he decides to kill Anakin’s family, he can’t exactly pin that on the Jedi. Best case for Palpatine, Anakin becomes a disillusioned grey force user, but I doubt he would become Palpatine’s apprentice and slaughter the Jedi Order as he did in the normal timeline.
Luminara as Anakin's master, is a big mistake for Luminara wouldn't care about Anakin's needs. It would be more strict towards him instead of showing him compassion and patience like Tera Sinbue and someone warm and compassionate like Shaaki Ti giving Anakin the hope he needed and someone who could understand him. This is Luminara's fault for Anakin running away from the Jedi Order and going off-world from Coroscunant. I believe Luminara wouldn't care what would happen if Anakin might get lost in space and showed no accountability for his treatment, and Anakin is now with Palpatine, who happens to be the Dark Lord of The Sith. What I like about this What-if video is that Palpatine loves Anakin as a son; even when he kills, he feels remorse, which actually breaks his heart. I could tell both Palpatine and Anakin both had similar hobbies and did gain a bond like Father and Son. For I can tell they know what it's like not have someone care, unlike Palpatine, who had never had his parents' affection which leads to becoming cruel himself and abuses Maul since he doesn't know how to love him, but Anakin he something in the boy as a younger himself. Anakin, meanwhile, does not have a father since he was created by the force of both Palpatine and Plagueis, but he has a mother ( even if she is an enslaved person) who loves him, cares for him, and would do anything for his needs and wants for her son to be happy. However, it was sad when Shimi and people took her to Bothaway. And died result of the Separatist invasion, leading Anakin to duel Palpatine, which ended for him tragically. On the other hand, Palpatine did mourn for killing the son he never had and someone he truly cared about. This is a Shakespeare tragedy version of Star Wars with both people dying. Anakin and Padme were killed, and the Jedi Order was wiped out in the face of the galaxy; the Galatic Empire ruled the universe widespread for millennia with Palpatine as Emperor and Dooku as second in command. Now imagine Obi-Wan heard about Anakin's death, and this would drive him to grief because he couldn't save him and would lament that both failed Qui-Gon and Anakin. Wow, this Anakin is more mature than his other incarnation in your what-if videos. He has a political atmosphere around and knows Galtaic dialects and connections to many different people very well. Also, you have seen my last comment on the what-if idea about What if Anakin had left the Jedi Order as Padwawn but was taken in by Mandalorians? Do you know which group would be best for Anakin? I did mention it in the previous video on "What If Plo Koon trained Ashoka," and do you have the links I sent you, or was that too much? What about Mandalorain royal titles? Which titles would be best for Anakin; Duke of Mandalore or Prince of Mandalore? If not, do you want Anakin to become a Prince of Tatooine, Duke of Tatooine, or even King of Tatooine? In my story, Anakin tries to free the enslaved people since he feels guilty for living a luxurious lifestyle while many innocent people were living slavery in Tatooine and being treated with low respect and degrading under by the criminal families and by the Hutts. Here Anakin would get help from Bo-Katan, and her friends would help a rebel leader revolt against Jabba Hutt and his croons and successfully free all enslaved people in Tatooine. But unfortunately, Jabba and his minions were killed by Anakin, Bo-Katan, and her Mandalorian friends. I'm giving a choice on what type of government would Tatooine should be. Should Tatooine either be a democracy, a republic, or a monarchy? Which one would the people want kind of government would want? I believe Anakin would ask people what they really want for Tatooine and what type of government they will be comfortable with since he has a heart of gold but needs to let the people decide. Because of Anakin's and his friends' heroic actions in helping the rebellious formerly enslaved people, freeing all the enslaved people on the dusty planet. However, Anakin's action inspired many people across the Outer Rim and Mid Rim systems to unite against their oppressors. This Alliance is called The Outro-Metric Alliance, with Tattooine leading the movement, for they successfully liberated many planets without causing civilian casualties. For they did rescue civilians and transported them to systems that are safe havens for those who want refuge, and those who are former associates with the Republic and former Jedi take refugees after seeing how flawed the Jedi Order is. Not only are Jedi leaving the Jedi Order, but their force users did run away from the Jedi due lack of compassionate teachers and a support system, and former dark-side forced users did join as well to be balanced. Both sides' significant support and reputation for giving refugees to civilians who wanted to be involved in this crusade. The Outro-Metric Alliance was victorious, and they seized control of Nal Hutta, the homeworld of the Hutts; with the Hutt, Empire was diminished, and the Outro-Metric Alliance won the war. But the fun part begins with the Hutts and other criminal empires under tyrannical rules of elites, autocrats, warlords, crime lords, and corrupt mega CEOS being out of the picture. The Outro-Metric Alliance had formed a new government called The United Stars Systems of Tetunotic ( USST). The United System Stars Systems would be a hybrid of a republic and a democracy, but a true democracy with star systems and planets could have representative seats. The Executive Branches would be similar to the Galatic Republic and the United States but more moderate and liberal. They would have senators who would fight for their people by gaining their trust and had to swear an oath to the people they were elected from. The Head of State would be an Eques Mangus. ( meaning Grand-Knight in Latin) and don't let this device you, this position is actually a democratic role similar to President and Chancellor, but the Eques Mangus had applied by the laws and have to make a decision and had been elected by the people. What do you think of the USST? Do you think it would be a good government, what do you like about it, and what do you dislike about it? Is there anything you want to change to it? Anyways this is an excellent what-if story, my friend. This is the best one you ever uploaded and has some dark twist that made it really good. I love how you made Palpatine care for Anakin and made him somewhat a decent human being; who does some conflict within in for killing the son he would never have and making Anakin more mature but a political philosopher and debater. Having Obi-Wan yield the dark saber and become co-ruler of Mandalore with Satine. Very well done, and this is an excellent work of story you did there; keep up the fantastic job, and may the force be with you!!
My theory is Anakin's going to turn to the dark side even quicker Luminara will literally sacrifice anyone especially her own padawan for the greater good edit: oh my gosh 70 likes in 18 hours thx to everyone.
Considering how her neglect and mismanagement turned Barris from a kind, polite young girl into what she became by the end of the clone wars series, yeah.
It's a good story but I'm pretty sure that Palpatine would be smart enough to get Shmi off world before attacking Bothweigh. Or having her protected on the planet while it was being attacked. Also, I don't think he's dumb enough to order a hit on Padme on an unsecure com-channel. Lastly, I don't think Palpatine would kill Anakin here. Because he knows his potential. I think Palpy would maim the fk out of him and knock him out. Then take Anakin somewhere that's more Sith adjacent. And then Palpy would begin Anakin's true Sith training, just saiyan.
Well like mentioned at the start, the Sith kill their masters eventually. If Anakin could kill him, his father figure then Palpatine would be satisfied. Anakin now filled with the dark side(as a sith) and with Padme by his side(as a father). Wouldn't be surprised if Sideous knew this could happen.
This was an enjoyable "what if" theory and I am glad you stayed true to Luminara's character. While I think the story was good and I did enjoy it, but I do have to offer some constructive criticism. I think Palpatine was far more calculating and would have used Shmee to further manipulate Anakin and I don't think he would have made a move to eliminate her that Anakin would associate with him. I believe he would have found a way to eliminate Shmee and Padme in a way that would make Anakin hate the Jedi even more, like them failing to protect Padme from an assassination attempt and Shmee as collateral damage from the Jedi searching for Anakin, not that they directly killed either, but due to carelessness and over confidence and while Palpatine would have treated Anakin kinder than he did Maul, I don't think he would have been as kind to him as you portrayed. Like I said I enjoyed the story you presented, but I share these things because I want to see more and better stories and I think you can use the ideas I shared in a future story. Speaking of that, what if Tarkin found and raised Anakin or brought him to Palpatine before the Jedi found him, or something along those lines.
One of the coolest "what ifs" so far. You're so talented! The buildup was insane, I wish you could do the ending a little more elaborate. For ex Obi Wan finding Anakin while he challenged his master. It just felt that the whole story related to Obi Wan and Dooku was abandoned, even though it looked so promising. But still, a fantastic experience!
What if Barriss Offee didn't frame Ahsoka Tano for the Jedi Temple bombing? What if Asajj Ventress defected to the Republic after Count Dooku's betrayal? What if Maul and Savage Opress killed Darth Sidious?
1. Than she would frame someone else. 2. She would be met with distrust. Maybe she would be rejected imediately. She would be a loner. An outcast. 3. It's painfully obvious that none of them was a threat for Sidious and that he played with them the entire fight. That's like C-3PO winning a boxing match against Chewbacca.
This story was definitely interesting, and Luminara is a favorite Jedi Master of mine, but I definitely see and understand how her training would fail for a unique student like Anakin. Loved this
PPSW more ideas to do. 1. What if Windu killed Dooku on Genosis? 2. What if the invisible hand exploded over Corusant with Palatine onboard captured? 3. What if Dirge was hired to kill Palpatine?
Share and Subscribe and You Could Win a Sideshow Collectible!! GIVEAWAY: docs.google.com/document/d/1NgKrcL1DSoVbBZLHCGyNk_xi2p6tCW4rIguh626dmz0/edit Support the Channel: www.patreon.com/ppsw Community Discord: discord.gg/RdBUUrKRJT Twitch Account: www.twitch.tv/pentepatrol
Luminara failed during Barriss training exposing her to trauma, and directing her to the dark side with Anakin would be similar The worst example of a master for anyone Anakin required understanding and compassion Luminara, as seen in the Clone Wars, was picked up by Bariss You can compare Anakin who bonds with Ashoka as if she were his sister Luminara, on the other hand, approached Bariss without feeling or emotion Anakin would only hasten his path to darkness
What if anikan didnt feel alone or had friends during his early training at the temple with the other younglings in his early years....i could see him becoming friends with the twins tiplar and tiplee, since they i believe would be around a similiar age range, perhaps a bit older
What if Darth Vader founded Revan's Sith Holocron? What if Satele Shan was in the Clone Wars? What if Darth Bane was in the Clone Wars? What if Darth Zannah was in the Clone Wars? What if there was a Descendant of Revan in the Clone Wars? What if Darth Bane was in the Galactic Civil War? What if Darth Zannah was in the Galactic Civil War? What if Anakin was discovered by the Order of Revan/Revanites instead of the Jedi Order?
What If The Entire Jedi Council Members Episode 1 Discover Sidious And Plagueis In The Phantom Menace, Members Of The Council Are Eeth Koth, Depa Billaba, Adi Gallia, Mace Windu, Yoda, Saesee Tiin, Yaddle, Yarael Poof, Oppo Rancisis, Even Piell, Plo Koon
What if Shaak Ti trained Starkiller. What if Darth Maul killed both Obi-Wan and Qui Gon and then took Anakin as an apprentice. What if Ahsoka joined Maul.
What if Pong Krell trained Anakin? (Second attemp) Imagine the score of Anakin's war crimes LOL What if Quilan Voss trained Luke? (Perhaps between E4-E5) What if Dooku (Jedi) trained Anakin?
Dooku training Anakin would be interesting. Dooku loved Qui Gon and hearing his old apprentice's request to train Anakin be turned down by the council after he left... Would be pretty cool.
Oh nice, someone else suggested Dooku training Anakin. I was really hoping there would be more videos on this theory but there seem to be surprisingly few. Dooku, like Qui-Gon, was an independent thinker and would have been less likely to judge Anakin for being “different” or having attachments. And Dooku had already trained multiple students before, so he was more than qualified to take on Anakin’s training, which Obi-Wan honestly wasn’t. I would love to see a long fanfic video on this topic, it would be really interesting to see where it goes. Edit: I love your user name too, by the way. Fellow ATLA fan :)
There was also course of Voss taking anakin as an apprentice. He was already doing missions on planet in episode one. It be a cool what if of anakin being jedi sentinel
@@haydenfowle7576 eh I think his slave background would make him more empathic. Like in jedi fallen order... scary thing is clones were same age as cal. So they could bound on mutal life to become a warrior. The clones only saw them as fighters for most part instead of warrior philosophers
Man when I subbed 6 months ago I had no idea about the talent I was listening to! Your videos are complete and very well written! And I think when I subbed you were under 10k and it has been a pleasure to see someone who deserves success become successful!
thank you for your storys it like you do so many so often makes me happy keep up the great works i cant support with anything but watching your vids but if i could i would.
This was a really pleasant fanfiction, but honestly Anakin dying was quite strange as it would reduce the prophecy of the chosen one into a joke. Also, as a Ukrainian, i do know that being in a war zone doesn't always mean death. Shmi would most likely survived, because a single invasion can't kill THAT many people, especially considering that droids aren't humans and they won't commit war crimes for no reason. Nonetheless, the video was great. Can't wait for more! Thank you for your great work!
What if bariss was trained by anakin. I think this could be wild, because bove had problems with the jedi and this could turn out really bad. Or what if he was found by a mandalorian or bounty hunter.
Bariss was actually a very nice and respectful girl in the early clone wars episodes. I think the problem was just that Luminara was a terrible master for her. Anakin training her would be interesting. I think the two would actually get along great, and the fact that they’re both independent thinkers could get them in trouble, but also gives them something to bond over.
What if Anakin was found by the Jedi and trained since birth What if Anakin was the descendant of Darrh Malgus What if Luke was trained earlier What if Palpatine found Ankain
Here's one, what if Anakin hears the story of Zayne Carrick. And get's inspired to curb some of his more brash personalities. Just think it would be interesting to hear a story about a guy who barely even qualified as a jedi but manage to be more jedi like in regards to the rest of order. Then we have Anakin a extremely powerful force user, who despite having an overly structured upbringing in the temple is still very unsure of the future.
Thats a very sweet thought. And interesting because I always felt that when Ahsoka left the order, Anakin had this kind of desperation to keep her that reminded me of a father not wanting his daughter to leave home.
@@tommyl.dayandtherunaways820 And personally I think padme would be the perfect mother, she is so caring and affectionate towards ahsoka, This is a mother-daughter relationship that must happen ASAP
@@slenderfan-101j.g.4 Yeah Padme would have been a great mother, no doubt. If only Anakin would have left the order and settled down on Naboo with Padme. They could have found Ahsoka and brought her with them.
random idea - what if anakin received teaching from all the jedi masters? Yoda, Windu, Shak Ti, etc. Sort of like how the avatar traveling the world in AtlA
I think only Yoda could have saved Anakin, but only if he knew what Palps was telling him behind the scenes. If he would have told even Obi-Wan they would have realized he was the Sith master before order 66 could happen.
I find myself looking forward to youre new story like its a holiday lol im telling all my freinds about your channel hopefully they all subscribe. Let get that goal met!!! Keep up the hard work.
hi PPSW can't wait for this video and the next one your content is the best keep up the good work a what if I would really like to see is what if maul fell in love with ventress when they first encountered each other.
You could make a continuation of this by say idk having palps save anikin aka his son but knowing full well Ani would try and kill him and not wanting to kill his son again he would have Ani frozen in Carbonite and stored somewhere safe but having him found later by the rebellion
What if anakin's mother was born mandolrian. What if anakin was the distant cousin of duchess satine. What if anakin was discovered by Qui gon jinn and obi-wan kanobi on mandalore just before the mission to naboo to negotiate with the trade federation.
Didn't Luminara train the legendary jedi Barris Offee? How could this happen 😱? But seriously, it's kind of funny how the five minutes Anikin spent with Unduli made him hate the jedi order.
Oh my good that truly was a twist to hearing sidious killing anikan truly another amazing video now it makes me wonder a What if oppo ransis trained anikan I could imagine her train him as a wise strategist
I believe if Luminara is his master he would runaway like you explain but also When he, Anakin is taken into Palatine custody well he not only increase his abilities and his skills, he would also poison Anakin feelings for Padme, not into a dark burning rage or hate but into something ai soft of dislike to unease
Palpatine: "Padme could have freed Shmi. She met Shmi. She ate at her table. But Padme's purpose was to get off of Tattooine, and she never gave Shmi a second thought after achieving her goals."
@@0predaking0 Yeah, I always saw that relationship as easily prevented, though Lucas' intention was for Palpatine to promote it in order to drive Anakin away from the Jedi.
What if Obi-wan Kenobi is the Chosen One Obi-wan Become Darth Vader Anakin Skywalker raise Obi-wan and Satine's Child to become a Jedi or a Mandalorian Anakin Skywalker talking to Qui-Gon Jinn about Obi-wan Turning to the Darkside
I was just thinking about a darker themed episode and this didn't disappoint. Good twist at the end. I was wondering if you'd do an alternate ending where Obi one and Anakin reunite shortly after that other planets annihilation, you from there you can either have them return to the good or stay with me here on this one, take out dooku grievous and palpatine to be the empire.
What what if the Jedi were actually evil and the sith were good, like the Jedi used their influence and power to install control (they are very controlling, they take children even if you want to argue it’s voluntary it really isn’t as how do you help a kid space wizard, if you fail your are thrown out with no way to survive no life experiences, it happened to Ahsoka and almost to Obi wan, etc)
She is totally not a good teacher I would never ever have placed him with her, scary with Palpatine teaching Anakin. Glad to see how balance he became in the light and dark. Not surprised Anakin was killed by that bastard
I was wondering if you could come up with a way it wouldn’t turn into a train wreck, but then again the two are about as different as you can get. I couldn’t see any way they could work out.
I can't wait to see it. I also hope these are a few you will consider to make What if Anakin was trained by yoda What if Darth maul was a Jedi What if order 66 failed
What if Depa trained Anakin? What if Obi-Wan & Luminara fell in love? What if Anakin & Barriss fell in love? What if Barriss was the Chosen One? What if youngling Katooni was the Chosen One? What if Galen & Anakin were brothers? What if Luminara trained Galen Marek? What if Skyguy trained Katooni? What if Ani & Shmi were slavers? What if Starkiller grew up on Malachor V, instead of Vader's under construction flagship ?
"JEDI DID I JUST CATCH YOU HAVING FUN!?"-Luminara
I wonder if being green would give her the N-word pass
Anakin would have either turned to the darkside after a few months or ended up becoming a replica of Luminara. A bleak personality, who is driven with the dogmatic Jedi code mindset. No emotion, no ingenuity.
Luminara, like Ki Adi Mundi, would be a terrible choice for Anakin.
The master necessary for Anakin is one who understands the Dark Side and why it affects Anakin differently than those raised in the Jedi Temple. Anakin, frankly, needed psychological therapy to deal with his trauma. The Jedi way was to repress and ignore rather than engage, deal, and use.
Great job, as always.
Luminara could've been different, to the point of understanding Anakin's inner turmoil. But her emotions being closed off intentionally is what's holding the poor old Mirialan back. I feel bad for her. :(
@@zondrabarth4508 I read your comment when you first posted, but I waited a few days to respond.
I feel no sympathy for Luminara, partially based off of what you said. She INTENTIONALLY acted the way she did. She could have chosen otherwise, but she chose not to do so. She doesn't deserve sympathy, but derision. I have sympathy for people with mental illness who cannot choose otherwise.
She is the very embodiment of the failure of the Jedi in that she adhered to an idea rather than people. The exact analogy is someone who practices a religion without considering how it applies in the world or with people. The argument that the Jedi code promotes love is obscured by not applying it to the practitioners and then outward.
@ALPHA Yes, Windu was a much better choice. He understood his darkness and how to deal with it. Luminara promoted suppression.
@@krismikewill You didn't have to wait before responding, I'm not here looking to negatively argue with anyone, as much as I defend poor Luminara. But I'm sorry you feel that way towards an understandably hated character. If she could just get some backstory to explain why she is the way she is, it could help make her a better character to view.
Let me ask you this: why is Luminara the only Jedi out of all the Prequel Order to not have any origin story? Is she that bad a character that no one can write anything good about her? Literally, if Luminara Unduli had her own Jedi Master before Episode 1, he or she was probably the one who instilled this behavior within her and couldn't help but take it to heart. Like she had no choice but to become the embodiment of the Jedi Order's failure cause it was all she knew.
I mean, even though she intentionally acted secluded and emotionless, the Clone Wars showed Luminara giving emotion, even if it wasn't real emotion, I believe it was. But because being bound to the Jedi Code like glue was all she knew and understood, she couldn't express more than a frown. She almost always had a sad expression on her face. I think that truly means something. And I get that you still don't have sympathy for Luminara, but I can't help but do cause I believe her story is deeper than that and needs to be told to help cut her some slack, get the sour taste out of people's mouths. :'(
@@zondrabarth4508 I apologize if my statement sounded like an attack on you. That was not my intention. By saying that I waited to respond, I mean to say that I attempted to think longer and reach a nuanced conclusion on the character. I was not able to do so. Your statement stressing the intentionality of her approach was actually correct, and I extrapolated additional information from your claim.
Called it! I knew she'd drive him towards the dark side faster! After learning about how strict her race is, and then just how much stricter she was, I just knew it would mean disaster. Just wasn't expecting what happened after that.
I was thinking he would go in to the temple and kill everyone and save her for last
Anakin Skywalker needed a father figure to balance him out.
Shaak ti could do so aswell
I saw that title and was like, "I can't wait to see this trainwreck of a master/apprentice relationship"
I wouldn’t say it’s her entire race, I mean barris wasn’t that strict and she came from the same race. Luminara was just awful with people and didn’t understand kids have feelings too.
Oh No! Anakin's going to bomb the Jedi Temple!!!
On a reaction point of this video, I like that fact that Luminara would be a Master that would Fail Anakin. It makes a lot of sense after all when you consider the type of Jedi she is. Would definitely like to see more of which Jedi Master would succeed or fail Anakin as a Master. So far from these videos, my favorites are Sinube and Shaak Ti.
Luminara's Temple-raised Padawan turned to the Dark Side during the Clone Wars, so it seems inevitable that Anakin would turn much easier.
Like you, I really like PPSW's take on Shaak Ti as his master.
Just ask bariss lol 😂
My Favorite Jedi is Kit Fisto because when i first saw clone wars (season 4) i saw Kit Fisto being a absolute badass and i placed him as my favorite jedi
What if Anakin got adopted by a Mandolorian. That'd be very interesting to see.
Yes
Yessir
Y e s please
Yes.
I think saying that saying that it would be very interesting is a huge understatement.
This version of Anakin was intriguing. Now I wonder what'd have happened had he managed to survive. Say, Anakin manages to escape, but he loses his arm in the process like canon and maybe gets his scar. Learning from his rashness, he seeks another way to oppose his master, now on the run. While not fully light, he doesn't seem fully in the dark either, might end up meeting the Mandalorian Obi-Wan and teaming up with him.
Yeah I wanted him to survive
I really like Obi-Wan clearly recognize the problem of training Anakin like a tradition Jedi when he wasn't the teacher. It really goes to show that people usually know what bad steps to avoid when they're spectators.
I would like you to make another of this particular story! One where Anakin embraces Luminara's teaching, worships the force, observes the Code, and masters Force Healing under her tutelage. This would be a very intriguing alternative story I think.
I agree
What if Anakin fell in love with Dutchess Satine and what if Anakin was trained by master Yoda
Yes to Yoda
Obi be fighting Anakin for Satine
Ohh yes obi wan would have a field day with him
Anakin is married bro lol
@@soularprimestudios5930 yeah but his saying what if he didn’t love padme and instead satine
What if Dooku trained Anakin?
What if Obi-Wan didn’t follow Padme to mustafar?
What if Padme agreed to rule the galaxy by Anakin / Vader’s side?
What if Obi-Wan died in the rescue attempt at the start of ROTS?
What if Anakin quit the Jedi Order and started his own order on Naboo with Padme and the kids?
The dooku one a good idea, because depending on lore. Legends, after qui gon death he initial set out to destroy the sith. So he's at a Tipping point and could go either way.
Canon dooku is already sinking into the dark side and really close to being lost before his quest against the sith
1. Interesting. But would Anakin work well under a hard, disciplined master like Dooku?
2. Padme would've died.
-Anakin was about to snap even before he noticed Obi Wan.
-He thought Obi Wan tries to turn Padme against him.
-Padme was heart broken and didn't recocnize him anymore, which enraged Anakin even more.
-Anakin thought Padme could not following him because of Obi Wan.
-Padme wanted Anakin to stop and return to her.
If Obi Wan wouldn't be there Anakin would've accused her of betraying him with Obi Wan and starts choking her.
3. Absolutely unlikely because this would go against everything Padme stands for.
4. Sidious would stop that from happening. He would find a way to kill Padme and/or the kids somehow blackmailing anyone and leading Anakin down the dark path.
@@danmarusan2878 True, but Dooku was also open minded and independent, I think that’s the kind of master Anakin needed.
Anakin only accused Padme of supporting Obi-Wan because Obi-Wan literally showed himself at the worst possible time though. Even if Anakin had started choking Padme (which I don’t think he would without Obi-Wan being there), he would have let her go before he killed her. It takes several minutes to choke someone to death, and I think Anakin would have realized what he was doing before that. I think he would be horrified by his actions as he still loved and cared for Padme, and possibly would reconsider running away with her.
I agree Padme joining Anakin would be unlikely in the canon universe, but it’s not hard to imagine an alternate reality where she loved him enough to be willing to give up everything to be by his side. Similar to how in the previous scenario, Anakin loved Padme enough to leave behind Sidious’s manipulations. I think it would be interesting to think about if nothing else.
The thing is, with Anakin out of the order, Sidious loses a lot of his leverage. Even if he decides to kill Anakin’s family, he can’t exactly pin that on the Jedi. Best case for Palpatine, Anakin becomes a disillusioned grey force user, but I doubt he would become Palpatine’s apprentice and slaughter the Jedi Order as he did in the normal timeline.
Luminara as Anakin's master, is a big mistake for Luminara wouldn't care about Anakin's needs. It would be more strict towards him instead of showing him compassion and patience like Tera Sinbue and someone warm and compassionate like Shaaki Ti giving Anakin the hope he needed and someone who could understand him. This is Luminara's fault for Anakin running away from the Jedi Order and going off-world from Coroscunant. I believe Luminara wouldn't care what would happen if Anakin might get lost in space and showed no accountability for his treatment, and Anakin is now with Palpatine, who happens to be the Dark Lord of The Sith. What I like about this What-if video is that Palpatine loves Anakin as a son; even when he kills, he feels remorse, which actually breaks his heart.
I could tell both Palpatine and Anakin both had similar hobbies and did gain a bond like Father and Son. For I can tell they know what it's like not have someone care, unlike Palpatine, who had never had his parents' affection which leads to becoming cruel himself and abuses Maul since he doesn't know how to love him, but Anakin he something in the boy as a younger himself. Anakin, meanwhile, does not have a father since he was created by the force of both Palpatine and Plagueis, but he has a mother ( even if she is an enslaved person) who loves him, cares for him, and would do anything for his needs and wants for her son to be happy. However, it was sad when Shimi and people took her to Bothaway. And died result of the Separatist invasion, leading Anakin to duel Palpatine, which ended for him tragically.
On the other hand, Palpatine did mourn for killing the son he never had and someone he truly cared about. This is a Shakespeare tragedy version of Star Wars with both people dying. Anakin and Padme were killed, and the Jedi Order was wiped out in the face of the galaxy; the Galatic Empire ruled the universe widespread for millennia with Palpatine as Emperor and Dooku as second in command. Now imagine Obi-Wan heard about Anakin's death, and this would drive him to grief because he couldn't save him and would lament that both failed Qui-Gon and Anakin.
Wow, this Anakin is more mature than his other incarnation in your what-if videos. He has a political atmosphere around and knows Galtaic dialects and connections to many different people very well.
Also, you have seen my last comment on the what-if idea about What if Anakin had left the Jedi Order as Padwawn but was taken in by Mandalorians? Do you know which group would be best for Anakin? I did mention it in the previous video on "What If Plo Koon trained Ashoka," and do you have the links I sent you, or was that too much? What about Mandalorain royal titles? Which titles would be best for Anakin; Duke of Mandalore or Prince of Mandalore? If not, do you want Anakin to become a Prince of Tatooine, Duke of Tatooine, or even King of Tatooine?
In my story, Anakin tries to free the enslaved people since he feels guilty for living a luxurious lifestyle while many innocent people were living slavery in Tatooine and being treated with low respect and degrading under by the criminal families and by the Hutts. Here Anakin would get help from Bo-Katan, and her friends would help a rebel leader revolt against Jabba Hutt and his croons and successfully free all enslaved people in Tatooine. But unfortunately, Jabba and his minions were killed by Anakin, Bo-Katan, and her Mandalorian friends. I'm giving a choice on what type of government would Tatooine should be. Should Tatooine either be a democracy, a republic, or a monarchy? Which one would the people want kind of government would want? I believe Anakin would ask people what they really want for Tatooine and what type of government they will be comfortable with since he has a heart of gold but needs to let the people decide. Because of Anakin's and his friends' heroic actions in helping the rebellious formerly enslaved people, freeing all the enslaved people on the dusty planet.
However, Anakin's action inspired many people across the Outer Rim and Mid Rim systems to unite against their oppressors. This Alliance is called The Outro-Metric Alliance, with Tattooine leading the movement, for they successfully liberated many planets without causing civilian casualties. For they did rescue civilians and transported them to systems that are safe havens for those who want refuge, and those who are former associates with the Republic and former Jedi take refugees after seeing how flawed the Jedi Order is. Not only are Jedi leaving the Jedi Order, but their force users did run away from the Jedi due lack of compassionate teachers and a support system, and former dark-side forced users did join as well to be balanced. Both sides' significant support and reputation for giving refugees to civilians who wanted to be involved in this crusade. The Outro-Metric Alliance was victorious, and they seized control of Nal Hutta, the homeworld of the Hutts; with the Hutt, Empire was diminished, and the Outro-Metric Alliance won the war.
But the fun part begins with the Hutts and other criminal empires under tyrannical rules of elites, autocrats, warlords, crime lords, and corrupt mega CEOS being out of the picture. The Outro-Metric Alliance had formed a new government called The United Stars Systems of Tetunotic ( USST). The United System Stars Systems would be a hybrid of a republic and a democracy, but a true democracy with star systems and planets could have representative seats. The Executive Branches would be similar to the Galatic Republic and the United States but more moderate and liberal. They would have senators who would fight for their people by gaining their trust and had to swear an oath to the people they were elected from. The Head of State would be an Eques Mangus.
( meaning Grand-Knight in Latin) and don't let this device you, this position is actually a democratic role similar to President and Chancellor, but the Eques Mangus had applied by the laws and have to make a decision and had been elected by the people.
What do you think of the USST? Do you think it would be a good government, what do you like about it, and what do you dislike about it? Is there anything you want to change to it?
Anyways this is an excellent what-if story, my friend. This is the best one you ever uploaded and has some dark twist that made it really good. I love how you made Palpatine care for Anakin and made him somewhat a decent human being; who does some conflict within in for killing the son he would never have and making Anakin more mature but a political philosopher and debater. Having Obi-Wan yield the dark saber and become co-ruler of Mandalore with Satine. Very well done, and this is an excellent work of story you did there; keep up the fantastic job, and may the force be with you!!
My theory is Anakin's going to turn to the dark side even quicker Luminara will literally sacrifice anyone especially her own padawan for the greater good edit: oh my gosh 70 likes in 18 hours thx to everyone.
I am her clone commander and she only really did it if it was necessary
@@greegree2373 i suppose still her views on attachments and the fact that she sticks to the code anakin would be better of with obi wan
She is evil
She isn't mundi
Considering how her neglect and mismanagement turned Barris from a kind, polite young girl into what she became by the end of the clone wars series, yeah.
It's a good story but I'm pretty sure that Palpatine would be smart enough to get Shmi off world before attacking Bothweigh. Or having her protected on the planet while it was being attacked. Also, I don't think he's dumb enough to order a hit on Padme on an unsecure com-channel. Lastly, I don't think Palpatine would kill Anakin here. Because he knows his potential.
I think Palpy would maim the fk out of him and knock him out. Then take Anakin somewhere that's more Sith adjacent. And then Palpy would begin Anakin's true Sith training, just saiyan.
Well like mentioned at the start, the Sith kill their masters eventually. If Anakin could kill him, his father figure then Palpatine would be satisfied. Anakin now filled with the dark side(as a sith) and with Padme by his side(as a father).
Wouldn't be surprised if Sideous knew this could happen.
This was an enjoyable "what if" theory and I am glad you stayed true to Luminara's character. While I think the story was good and I did enjoy it, but I do have to offer some constructive criticism. I think Palpatine was far more calculating and would have used Shmee to further manipulate Anakin and I don't think he would have made a move to eliminate her that Anakin would associate with him. I believe he would have found a way to eliminate Shmee and Padme in a way that would make Anakin hate the Jedi even more, like them failing to protect Padme from an assassination attempt and Shmee as collateral damage from the Jedi searching for Anakin, not that they directly killed either, but due to carelessness and over confidence and while Palpatine would have treated Anakin kinder than he did Maul, I don't think he would have been as kind to him as you portrayed. Like I said I enjoyed the story you presented, but I share these things because I want to see more and better stories and I think you can use the ideas I shared in a future story. Speaking of that, what if Tarkin found and raised Anakin or brought him to Palpatine before the Jedi found him, or something along those lines.
Lumanara is my favorite Jedi of all time so this is such w
One of the coolest "what ifs" so far. You're so talented! The buildup was insane, I wish you could do the ending a little more elaborate. For ex Obi Wan finding Anakin while he challenged his master. It just felt that the whole story related to Obi Wan and Dooku was abandoned, even though it looked so promising. But still, a fantastic experience!
Thank you so much!
What if Barriss Offee didn't frame Ahsoka Tano for the Jedi Temple bombing?
What if Asajj Ventress defected to the Republic after Count Dooku's betrayal?
What if Maul and Savage Opress killed Darth Sidious?
1. Than she would frame someone else.
2. She would be met with distrust. Maybe she would be rejected imediately. She would be a loner. An outcast.
3. It's painfully obvious that none of them was a threat for Sidious and that he played with them the entire fight. That's like C-3PO winning a boxing match against Chewbacca.
This story was definitely interesting, and Luminara is a favorite Jedi Master of mine, but I definitely see and understand how her training would fail for a unique student like Anakin. Loved this
PPSW more ideas to do.
1. What if Windu killed Dooku on Genosis?
2. What if the invisible hand exploded over Corusant with Palatine onboard captured?
3. What if Dirge was hired to kill Palpatine?
Share and Subscribe and You Could Win a Sideshow Collectible!!
GIVEAWAY: docs.google.com/document/d/1NgKrcL1DSoVbBZLHCGyNk_xi2p6tCW4rIguh626dmz0/edit
Support the Channel: www.patreon.com/ppsw
Community Discord: discord.gg/RdBUUrKRJT
Twitch Account: www.twitch.tv/pentepatrol
Ok
You! You turned me into this! You pushed me to the dark side!…*sneering with disgust* master…
as soon as i saw Luminara was gonna be his master, i KNEW it was gonna go downhill. Luminara is the most by the books Jedi there is
🤔 very interesting. This went together very well 👍🏽
Luminara failed during Barriss training exposing her to trauma, and directing her to the dark side with Anakin would be similar
The worst example of a master for anyone
Anakin required understanding and compassion
Luminara, as seen in the Clone Wars, was picked up by Bariss
You can compare Anakin who bonds with Ashoka as if she were his sister
Luminara, on the other hand, approached Bariss without feeling or emotion
Anakin would only hasten his path to darkness
What if anikan didnt feel alone or had friends during his early training at the temple with the other younglings in his early years....i could see him becoming friends with the twins tiplar and tiplee, since they i believe would be around a similiar age range, perhaps a bit older
Anakin would have gotten Mirialan Geometric Tattoos. Including a small rhomboid diamond on his mind's eye
What if Darth Vader founded Revan's Sith Holocron?
What if Satele Shan was in the Clone Wars?
What if Darth Bane was in the Clone Wars?
What if Darth Zannah was in the Clone Wars?
What if there was a Descendant of Revan in the Clone Wars?
What if Darth Bane was in the Galactic Civil War?
What if Darth Zannah was in the Galactic Civil War?
What if Anakin was discovered by the Order of Revan/Revanites instead of the Jedi Order?
I like the last one
@@DarthRevan-96 of course, Lord Revan.
I like Darth Bane In Civil War
You do realize that Darth Bane destroyed Darth Revan's holocron after using it don't you? How can Anakin find a holocron that doesn't exist anymore?
What If The Entire Jedi Council Members Episode 1 Discover Sidious And Plagueis In The Phantom Menace, Members Of The Council Are Eeth Koth, Depa Billaba, Adi Gallia, Mace Windu, Yoda, Saesee Tiin, Yaddle, Yarael Poof, Oppo Rancisis, Even Piell, Plo Koon
I had a feeling that Unduli would probably be bad for Anakin.
What if Anakin had left the Jedi Order after Geonosis to marry Padme?
What if Shaak Ti trained Starkiller.
What if Darth Maul killed both Obi-Wan and Qui Gon and then took Anakin as an apprentice.
What if Ahsoka joined Maul.
What if Pong Krell trained Anakin? (Second attemp) Imagine the score of Anakin's war crimes LOL
What if Quilan Voss trained Luke? (Perhaps between E4-E5)
What if Dooku (Jedi) trained Anakin?
Dooku training Anakin would be interesting. Dooku loved Qui Gon and hearing his old apprentice's request to train Anakin be turned down by the council after he left... Would be pretty cool.
Oh nice, someone else suggested Dooku training Anakin. I was really hoping there would be more videos on this theory but there seem to be surprisingly few. Dooku, like Qui-Gon, was an independent thinker and would have been less likely to judge Anakin for being “different” or having attachments. And Dooku had already trained multiple students before, so he was more than qualified to take on Anakin’s training, which Obi-Wan honestly wasn’t. I would love to see a long fanfic video on this topic, it would be really interesting to see where it goes.
Edit: I love your user name too, by the way. Fellow ATLA fan :)
There was also course of Voss taking anakin as an apprentice. He was already doing missions on planet in episode one. It be a cool what if of anakin being jedi sentinel
Krell would teach Anakin to be an asshole to Clones but Anakin refuses to let Clones die needlessly
@@haydenfowle7576 eh I think his slave background would make him more empathic. Like in jedi fallen order... scary thing is clones were same age as cal. So they could bound on mutal life to become a warrior. The clones only saw them as fighters for most part instead of warrior philosophers
Man when I subbed 6 months ago I had no idea about the talent I was listening to! Your videos are complete and very well written! And I think when I subbed you were under 10k and it has been a pleasure to see someone who deserves success become successful!
Thank you so much!
What if Anakin fell in love with Pre-TCW Barris Offee
This
thank you for your storys it like you do so many so often makes me happy keep up the great works i cant support with anything but watching your vids but if i could i would.
What is this “saport” you speak of?
@@michaelrousopoulos1098 support =)
This was a really pleasant fanfiction, but honestly Anakin dying was quite strange as it would reduce the prophecy of the chosen one into a joke. Also, as a Ukrainian, i do know that being in a war zone doesn't always mean death. Shmi would most likely survived, because a single invasion can't kill THAT many people, especially considering that droids aren't humans and they won't commit war crimes for no reason. Nonetheless, the video was great. Can't wait for more! Thank you for your great work!
He would struggle a little because it's hard for him to let go she knows how to let go of attachments.He would feel trapped also.
What if bariss was trained by anakin. I think this could be wild, because bove had problems with the jedi and this could turn out really bad. Or what if he was found by a mandalorian or bounty hunter.
Bariss was actually a very nice and respectful girl in the early clone wars episodes. I think the problem was just that Luminara was a terrible master for her. Anakin training her would be interesting. I think the two would actually get along great, and the fact that they’re both independent thinkers could get them in trouble, but also gives them something to bond over.
I think it'd be interesting but Barris is only 1 year younger than Anakin
@@PentePatrolStarWars wow i never noticed that in cw she looks as old as ahsoka or one or two years older
What if Anakin was found by the Jedi and trained since birth
What if Anakin was the descendant of Darrh Malgus
What if Luke was trained earlier
What if Palpatine found Ankain
I truly loved your work it helps me relax after work
Here's one, what if Anakin hears the story of Zayne Carrick. And get's inspired to curb some of his more brash personalities. Just think it would be interesting to hear a story about a guy who barely even qualified as a jedi but manage to be more jedi like in regards to the rest of order. Then we have Anakin a extremely powerful force user, who despite having an overly structured upbringing in the temple is still very unsure of the future.
Idk why this made me cry
Barris is not a good teacher, teachers are patient, kind and understanding luminara wasn’t those things.
What IF Anakin and padme adopted ahsoka (as their daughter) after she left the Jedi order
I love that idea...
Thats a very sweet thought. And interesting because I always felt that when Ahsoka left the order, Anakin had this kind of desperation to keep her that reminded me of a father not wanting his daughter to leave home.
@@tommyl.dayandtherunaways820
And personally I think padme would be the perfect mother, she is so caring and affectionate towards ahsoka,
This is a mother-daughter relationship that must happen ASAP
@@slenderfan-101j.g.4 Yeah Padme would have been a great mother, no doubt. If only Anakin would have left the order and settled down on Naboo with Padme. They could have found Ahsoka and brought her with them.
random idea - what if anakin received teaching from all the jedi masters? Yoda, Windu, Shak Ti, etc. Sort of like how the avatar traveling the world in AtlA
by the will of the force make -a what if general grievous and kenobi fell in love
I think only Yoda could have saved Anakin, but only if he knew what Palps was telling him behind the scenes. If he would have told even Obi-Wan they would have realized he was the Sith master before order 66 could happen.
I find myself looking forward to youre new story like its a holiday lol im telling all my freinds about your channel hopefully they all subscribe. Let get that goal met!!! Keep up the hard work.
hi PPSW can't wait for this video and the next one your content is the best keep up the good work a what if I would really like to see is what if maul fell in love with ventress when they first encountered each other.
Would love to see a "what if rex was killed by the sniper droid)
What if Lando had force abilities........(The things he'd do on the Sabatt table)
What if Anakin found HK-47
Statement: greetings meatbags 😂
awesome story once again you always make me smile your so talented dude your amazing 🤩☺️
Thank you so much!
Aniken was trained by adi gallia
What if Satele shan used the world between worlds too travel to the future and train Anakin Skywalker
You could make a continuation of this by say idk having palps save anikin aka his son but knowing full well Ani would try and kill him and not wanting to kill his son again he would have Ani frozen in Carbonite and stored somewhere safe but having him found later by the rebellion
Haven't watched yet but given what happened to her apprentice he still would have fallen to the Dark Side
What if anakin's mother was born mandolrian.
What if anakin was the distant cousin of duchess satine.
What if anakin was discovered by Qui gon jinn and obi-wan kanobi on mandalore just before the mission to naboo to negotiate with the trade federation.
Didn't Luminara train the legendary jedi Barris Offee? How could this happen 😱?
But seriously, it's kind of funny how the five minutes Anikin spent with Unduli made him hate the jedi order.
This duo might actually work out considering Anakins history with dominant older women ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Also, really good scenario! Love to see more like this!
Thank you so much!
This fan fiction was basecly what if palpatine trained anakin.
What if the emperor's wrath returned during the clone wars
Oh my good that truly was a twist to hearing sidious killing anikan truly another amazing video now it makes me wonder a What if oppo ransis trained anikan I could imagine her train him as a wise strategist
Day 20 of asking what if Luminara trained Ezra as Kannan originally wanted in Star Wars Rebels
No wonder Barris had became emotionally isolated by Luminara from "Barris fell in love with Anakin."😢
What if the Ghost Crew did rescue Luminara in season 1 of Rebels?
What if obi wan gave up anakin realizing he couldnt be a master, maybe Yoda or Mace
What if YOU wrote the whole Star Wars Sequels Trilogy? Would like to see the direction you'd take the original story after Return of the Jedi
What if Anakin go to mustafar but not to jedi temple. That'd be very interesting to see.
What if Anikin became a bounty hunter sounds cool
Great story! Love this channel!
Thank you so much!
I believe if Luminara is his master he would runaway like you explain but also When he, Anakin is taken into Palatine custody well he not only increase his abilities and his skills, he would also poison Anakin feelings for Padme, not into a dark burning rage or hate but into something ai soft of dislike to unease
Palpatine: "Padme could have freed Shmi. She met Shmi. She ate at her table. But Padme's purpose was to get off of Tattooine, and she never gave Shmi a second thought after achieving her goals."
@@krismikewill exactly!!!
@@0predaking0 Yeah, I always saw that relationship as easily prevented, though Lucas' intention was for Palpatine to promote it in order to drive Anakin away from the Jedi.
What if Ezra used the world between worlds too go back and try to save the Jedi order
What if the Jedi council refused to let Anakin to become a Jedi and obi wan left the order to train Anakin and taught both sides of the force
What if Obi-wan Kenobi is the Chosen One Obi-wan Become Darth Vader Anakin Skywalker raise Obi-wan and Satine's Child to become a Jedi or a Mandalorian Anakin Skywalker talking to Qui-Gon Jinn about Obi-wan Turning to the Darkside
Definitely didn't see that ending coming
I was just thinking about a darker themed episode and this didn't disappoint. Good twist at the end.
I was wondering if you'd do an alternate ending where Obi one and Anakin reunite shortly after that other planets annihilation, you from there you can either have them return to the good or stay with me here on this one, take out dooku grievous and palpatine to be the empire.
He won't even need palpatine's nudges
What if Anakin trained Obi-Wan? And yes I mean without swapping their ages and lives
What if Sherlock Holmes was a jedi raised by master Sinube?
What if barriss offee was anakin padawan?
what if luke (legends prime) traveld back in time to the clone wars.
Was not excepting that ending damn
What if Anakin help the Jedi during order 66
This goes back to the old EU, but could you do one where Anakin was trained by Siri Tachi? Preferably a happy one lol.
What if anakin and ashoka were siblings
What if obi wan turned to the dark side during episode 3
What if anakin was a gray Jedi
What If Anakin Had The Spirit Of Darth Revan In Him
here's a story idea. it will probably be a short story but what if the father son and daughter raised anakin
Ok this is good but it can be a bit better but I like it and keep up the good work
What what if the Jedi were actually evil and the sith were good, like the Jedi used their influence and power to install control (they are very controlling, they take children even if you want to argue it’s voluntary it really isn’t as how do you help a kid space wizard, if you fail your are thrown out with no way to survive no life experiences, it happened to Ahsoka and almost to Obi wan, etc)
What if Vader was a Fulcrum agent?
She is totally not a good teacher I would never ever have placed him with her, scary with Palpatine teaching Anakin. Glad to see how balance he became in the light and dark. Not surprised Anakin was killed by that bastard
I was wondering if you could come up with a way it wouldn’t turn into a train wreck, but then again the two are about as different as you can get. I couldn’t see any way they could work out.
this vidio is more like what if palpatine trained anykan
What if Mace windu or Yoda trained Ahsoka?
What if Yaddle trained Anakin? (She would still live)
what if Obi actually got ahsoka?
@@Fl3XeR4 Ahsoka would be the perfect padawan for Obi Wan.
I can't wait to see it. I also hope these are a few you will consider to make
What if Anakin was trained by yoda
What if Darth maul was a Jedi
What if order 66 failed
A lot of clone would be alive
Omg yes please!!!!
@@michaelrousopoulos1098 thanks I didn't think people would actually like these
What if Palpatine was in such a hurry that he accidentally activated order 65.
What if the Clones were able to resist Order 66?
What if Depa trained Anakin?
What if Obi-Wan & Luminara fell in love?
What if Anakin & Barriss fell in love?
What if Barriss was the Chosen One?
What if youngling Katooni was the Chosen One?
What if Galen & Anakin were brothers?
What if Luminara trained Galen Marek?
What if Skyguy trained Katooni?
What if Ani & Shmi were slavers?
What if Starkiller grew up on Malachor V, instead of Vader's under construction flagship ?
Barriss and Anakin falling in love would be very interesting I have to admit. Especially if Anakin was training her.
@@tommyl.dayandtherunaways820 Anakin training Barriss wouldn't work because both are roughly the same age and both were padawans during episode II.