Very touching and well made music production. I started crying at the very beginning when the Horse-Head string came in. Tengeri (Teng'Ge'Er) is definitely one of the best Mongolian vocalists, you can even call him one of the best Chinese national vocal virtuosos. When listening to the song with my eyes closed, I can already get an image of him singing at and to the grand grassland in Mongolia(Inner), but with my eyes open, especially with the visual of him smiling while singing, I can just feel him, his emotion, his love and his sincerity to his hometown as he calls it heaven. As I just came back from Inner Mongolia, I was able to relate more, not only to this kind of music production and also particularly this song. I really wish people out there can have more opportunities to be exposed in oriental culture and art. That should not engage any national/political boundaries nor bias. 柯桑德, thank you very much for making this kind of videos. You have built and shared a very good platform/bridge to link the 2 sides. let the world have more chances to see Chinese music art and to hear from both side or even all sides. How lovely this is. P.S. Followed you on bilibili as well, hehe
👍👍 This is one of my favourites. Tears come to my eyes every time I hear it because it evokes my homesickness. Also, the most profound love everyone has for the land they were born and grew up in.
This song was written by the singer for his daughter who passed away. It looks like talking about a beautiful homeland, but actually a dream place he wished his daughter lived in heaven. You can feel his missing and heartbroken inside his voice.
The homeland remembrance/appreciation is true though, that is the original intention of the lyrics. But some years ago his daughter passed away (whom he had a nickname "heaven" given to her daughter too), after that he changed a little bit lyrics of this song by adding "my little girl" to it. Since then the song became a remembrance for both his homeland and his daughter.
That weyyyyy~~~is called throat singing, a very skillful and tradtional way of singing. The instrument is called morin khuur (horsehead fiddle). And Tengri costumes a Mongolian robe of modern design. COOL!!! I love all these traditional elements in his performance! And I love your reaction. Thanks!
这是一首来自中国的蒙古族著名歌唱家腾格尔的《天堂》。鄂尔多斯这块地方堪称是民歌的海洋，腾格尔自幼浸泡在这海洋里，他不用刻意学，大人唱他便跟着唱，很快就会了。他的父亲在家乡知道的民歌之多是数一数二的，音正腔圆，调准、词准，而他的母亲和父亲截然不同，性格刚烈，管教时不仅动口，还动手用鞭子抽，尽管儿时没少挨抽，但他还是深爱母亲。创作歌曲时，家乡草原上的植被破坏得很厉害，草原沙漠化严重，他想通过歌曲来唤醒人们热爱自然、保护草原的意识，同时也怀念儿时记忆中家乡的景象。正是怀着这样的心情，草原，我的根，家，我的天堂，腾格尔写下了《天堂》。 这首歌曲属于中国民歌，腾格尔老师的个人风格在这首歌里表现的非常明显。看着歌词去理解他的艺术表现，才能最好的理解他的感情。欢迎大家来到中国内蒙古，这是世界上最美的草原。 This is "Heaven" by Tengger, a famous Mongolian singer from China. Ordos is an ocean of folk songs. Tengger has been immersed in this ocean since he was a child. He doesn't need to deliberately learn it. If the adults sing, he will sing along, and he will soon. His father knew one of the best folk songs in his hometown. The sound was round, the tunes were accurate, and the words were accurate. His mother and father were very different and had a strong personality. When disciplined, he not only used his mouth, but also used a whip. When he was a child, he was often smoked, but he still loved his mother deeply. When composing the song, the vegetation on the grassland in his hometown was severely destroyed and the grassland desertification was serious. He wanted to use the song to awaken people's awareness of loving nature and protecting the grassland, and at the same time miss the sight of his hometown in his childhood memories. It is with this feeling that the grassland, my roots, home, and my paradise, Tengger wrote "Heaven". This song is a Chinese folk song, and teacher Tengger’s personal style is very obvious in this song. Only by looking at the lyrics to understand his artistic performance can he understand his feelings best. Welcome to Inner Mongolia, China, this is the most beautiful grassland in the world. 歌词： 蓝蓝的天空I see a blue sky, 清清的湖水Over a green lake, 绿绿的草原Vast is the grassland, 这是我的家This is my homeland. 奔驰的骏马Horses running wild there, 洁白的羊群Sheep as white as snow, 还有你姑娘Girl wait for me, 这是我的家Where my heart's at home. 我爱你 我的家I love you, my homeland, 我的家 我的天堂My homeland, my heaven. 我爱你 我的家I miss you, my homeland, 我的家 我的天堂My homeland, my heaven. 蓝蓝的天空I see a blue sky, 清清的湖水Over a green lake, 绿绿的草原Vast is the grassland, 这是我的家This is my homeland. 我爱你 我的家I love you, my homeland, 我的家 我的天堂My homeland, my heaven. 我爱你 我的家I miss you, my homeland, 我的家 我的天堂My homeland, my heaven.
It's one of the few performances that makes me cry every time. It's full of raw emotion and great control. The story behind this song makes it even more touching. Thanks for recommending it to Joe_creator. 😊🙏
Joe_creator was great, the music selection was a killer. Lovin how you picked each music video. it's not just like any other videos but these singers has their own personality and vibe. Makes the who reaction/ review so individual and unique. loving the content!! 666~
This song expresses the voice from a true wolf in its views about its paradise hometown of Mongolian terrain prairie with the blue sky in its blue eyes. Wolf's song.
Morin Hor （Mongolian） Mǎ Tóu Qín （Mandarin） The Horse Head String Instrument （English translation） There is a carved horse's head on the head of the harp.
作为一个纯正的内蒙古人要给普及一下了，首先那个乐器叫马头琴，其次两个乐手吟唱的是呼麦，是一种远比约德尔唱法难的多的发声方式，约德尔唱法只是快速的真假声变换，而呼麦是要求演唱者纯粹用自己的发声器官，在同一时间里唱出两个声部。呼麦声部关系的基本结构为一个持续低音和它上面流动的旋律相结合。又可以分为“泛音呼麦”、“震音呼麦”、“复合呼麦”等。在中国各民族民歌中，它是独一无二的。
多谢科普。 我只去过内蒙一次，但应该是我此生最值得回味的一次旅行。 在大草原上住了蒙古包， 吃了烤全羊，看了那达姆 大会。。。。。。
@@joeyh5325 那达慕大会
我也是内蒙的啊。哈哈哈。每次在国外听到草原歌曲都会沉浸一会，什么都不做，思念一下内蒙的家乡。第一次看到腾老再唱歌的时候真的是又高兴又心疼。能看到又有新的音乐理解，但是是真的老了，虽然还是很强，但是唱功还是不比当年了。
谢谢科普 🙏
@@musahariri4068 哈哈😄多谢指正。在那达慕大会欣赏到了赛马，套马……..
騰格爾唱這首歌時 我眼睛眼淚都噴出來了
不是內蒙古人的我 都感受到他內心的澎湃
非常惊喜意外，你会做这种少数民族的音乐，听得我热泪盈眶，现在这种灵魂艺术创作越来越少，取代的都是商业音乐，现在的很多音乐都不是音乐，更不能称之为艺术，而是噪音！！！感谢你让更多的人看到知道这些很棒的作品，我不想给它加上国籍，真正的艺术是无国界的，感谢你的分享！！！感谢你分享美与爱！只有内心有爱的人，才演绎创作的出来这样的艺术作品！事隔多年，重溫這首歌，让我们再次连结到了他演唱的那片净土和每个人内心的那片净土，虽然他已年过花甲，我也满了三十，听到后彷佛回到了童年，那时第一次听到这首歌，我还不知曲中意，只彷彿看到蓝天白云和一望无际的草原⋯以及奔驰的骏马⋯⋯（其实不是说少数民族的就一定是艺术，但他们的环境让他们保留了更多的纯真，所以更容易创作表达出这种真挚深层次的情感，现在很多歌手唱的，都是无病呻吟，没有美感可言⋯⋯）
说得太美了！！！赞同❤❤❤
每次听腾格尔的这首歌都让我难以控制自己的眼泪和情绪。他的歌声发自肺腑震撼人心，使我想念故乡和亲人😭
Thank you! I do not know much about Chinese instruments but I am learning!
U do well bro. The song is amazing. But when hear ur comments, i learn more about music knowledge und know more about the music its own
Your analysis is great. Thank you very much for sharing your understanding of music. Salute from Malaysia.
This song is for his daughter in heaven.
腾格尔 is a top level Chinese singer. Truly amazing performance ! Perfect singing and perfect voice.
马头琴，蒙古族的传统民族乐器。歌手穿的衣服不是民族服饰，但是旁边拉马头琴的那两位穿的是蒙古族民族服饰。开头的唱法叫“呼麦”。内蒙古民族唱法，有点像B-BOX，非常秀的一种口技
死亡金属起源于蒙古，历史悠久，其标志唱腔叫水嗓，古称呼麦。
呼麦是阿尔泰山周围地区诸多民族的一种歌唱方式，并不是我们蒙古族所独有的唱法。
别把呼麦叫口技～呼麦表演者通过控制声带跟口腔肌肉可以做到同时发出两个音。算唱法。而且除了上面评论的阿尔泰地区，北美原住民中的一些也会这种唱法
@@Jademoist 从没有见过北美原住民使用过呼麦唱法，倒是知道他们会口弦
@@johnpeng5543 韩国人坐不住了😏
真的，远在异国的我，听到最后眼泪都掉下来了，太感动了！腾格尔就是大师！
Very touching and well made music production. I started crying at the very beginning when the Horse-Head string came in. Tengeri (Teng'Ge'Er) is definitely one of the best Mongolian vocalists, you can even call him one of the best Chinese national vocal virtuosos. When listening to the song with my eyes closed, I can already get an image of him singing at and to the grand grassland in Mongolia(Inner), but with my eyes open, especially with the visual of him smiling while singing, I can just feel him, his emotion, his love and his sincerity to his hometown as he calls it heaven. As I just came back from Inner Mongolia, I was able to relate more, not only to this kind of music production and also particularly this song. I really wish people out there can have more opportunities to be exposed in oriental culture and art. That should not engage any national/political boundaries nor bias. 柯桑德, thank you very much for making this kind of videos. You have built and shared a very good platform/bridge to link the 2 sides. let the world have more chances to see Chinese music art and to hear from both side or even all sides. How lovely this is. P.S. Followed you on bilibili as well, hehe
非常非常感谢你和你的朋友帮助我们更深的了解中国名族歌曲，特别是腾格尔的天堂，这首歌我听过很多遍，但是都没有像今天这样的感受。非常非常感谢你和你的朋友。
这首歌之于他，是一个极为特别的存在。我记得在访谈里他自己说过，其实创作这首歌的时候他并没有给与太多的情绪，只是想表达一个很简单的情感和展示一个很简单的长调而已。但是第一重特别的意味，在于他的名字腾格尔（Tengri），在信奉萨满教诸族语言里，意思就是“天”。汉语对应译为“长生天”，也就是天堂（天神）；二则，在经历了一系列人生变故之后，这首歌寄寓了他对彼世的幻想。就如同某些奇幻文学里面关于兽人对其灵魂归宿“大草原”或者“大丛林”的向往一样。地点不重要，重要的是，会遇见的人。他脸上的笑也是因为此。
技术层面的话，腾格尔的技术绝对不能单纯从民族唱法的角度来解释（这个迷思同样适用于动力火车）。这个人的本钱是逆天般的存在，如同是华语乐坛的迈克尔波顿，换一个人搞这么大的动态声带早就废了。他在极强端的处理，处在一个“在失控边缘极为精确的控制”的境地，近十年出现的歌手在这一点上只有梁博拥有（过？）类似的能力。他年轻的时候到处都是这么唱的歌手，所谓的西北风，所谓的“就是往破了唱呗”（见达康书记和郭达的早期小品《大米红高粱》），但是像他这么几十年过去了还能这么唱，声压几乎爆掉湖南卫视的顶级现场录音设备，近乎孤例。内蒙的男歌手，腾格尔跟韩磊算是玄冥二老，一个是本钱的极端，一个是技术的极端。想看这老哥俩合唱……
呼麦的话，其实基本原理在于，用喉发出一个低音，同时用同一股气流驱动双唇或者舌尖/上腭发出一个尖锐的泛音。我记得在youtube上看过一位（白人）女士表演过稳定住一端，用另一端唱旋律的视频。
如果Joe没听够的话，推荐另一个类似的表演--谭维维的《乌兰巴托的夜》，不仅风格，立意也是类似的
因为这首歌的主题就是他的女儿，哪个已经在天堂里的爱女，他唱得太棒了！
原來是這樣.....
👍👍 This is one of my favourites. Tears come to my eyes every time I hear it because it evokes my homesickness. Also, the most profound love everyone has for the land they were born and grew up in.
以前聽騰格爾的天堂，還沒這麼有感觸。這次直接聽哭了，真神奇。
Joe還是這麼專業！
听一次落泪一次，amzing，意境感太强烈了，想起小时候的草地和牛羊。。。。。。
我想看《忐忑》🤣
我也想家了，海外的呼伦贝尔人。
作为一个蒙古族，这次现场他唱的确实太棒了！ 想到自己的故乡，自己民族的世界观，有太多东西无法用语言描绘出来……
我们都是苍生天的孩子～
蒙古人， 不是蒙古族。我们都是人， 不是什么族。
不管是蒙古人还是汉人，生活在中国这片土地上的人们都是中国人
@@hsyerwin 已经没什么用了。
长生天
This song was written by the singer for his daughter who passed away. It looks like talking about a beautiful homeland, but actually a dream place he wished his daughter lived in heaven. You can feel his missing and heartbroken inside his voice.
The homeland remembrance/appreciation is true though, that is the original intention of the lyrics. But some years ago his daughter passed away (whom he had a nickname "heaven" given to her daughter too), after that he changed a little bit lyrics of this song by adding "my little girl" to it. Since then the song became a remembrance for both his homeland and his daughter.
音乐转调部分的伴奏引用了蒙古族歌曲《草原上升起不落的太阳》的一句旋律！真的真的听哭了！再评测下腾格尔的《父亲的草原母亲的河》吧，也是腾格尔再《歌手》上演唱的！感谢您能够分享我家乡的音乐。
迄今为止，最棒的一次选歌。建议下一次选择谭维维的《乌兰巴托的夜》或者杭盖乐队的《轮回》，都是类似的非常具有代表性的乐曲。Highly recommeded
杭盖的轮回确实好听。单曲循环很久
你的头像让我以为毛掉屏幕里面去了
去听听一个外蒙古的乐队the hu 太牛逼了
我他媽一直撥一直撥
可惡的頭髮
腾格尔，中国蒙古族殿堂级音乐大师，天堂此曲作词旋律都不复杂，但唯独腾格尔能把这首歌唱得出神入化，无人可比。
腾格尔真的自己就是最好的乐器，太棒了。真的艺术家。
謝謝你分享我們蒙古族的歌唱家腾格尔的歌。歌声表达的故事是深切而不可言表的对家乡的眷戀与赞誉
错！这首歌是他写给逝去的女儿的！🙏
你把歌詞裡所有出現的『家』替換成『女兒』，藍天是髮絲，靜靜湖水是眼睛，就知道為什麼結尾時為什麼會有很多ohohahah 的吶喊，那是因為思念女兒的吶喊，最割人心的是ohohahah最後突然有了歌詞，意思是順其自然。
看beyond和这个都看哭了，你的剪辑和解释也很棒！
That weyyyyy~~~is called throat singing, a very skillful and tradtional way of singing. The instrument is called morin khuur (horsehead fiddle). And Tengri costumes a Mongolian robe of modern design. COOL!!! I love all these traditional elements in his performance! And I love your reaction. Thanks!
GODlike ... singer!
GODlike ... vocal!
Kept echoing in one's mind ... for a long long time! Very soulful!
It's a horsehead fiddle 马头琴啊！哈哈. 腾格尔是我的老朋友！他穿的衣服不是民间服。特喜欢他这首！！我在北京外国人演唱中国歌比赛唱得一首蒙古歌得了一等奖。谢谢你分享了这首歌让我飘回内蒙去。我唱得跟他无法比。但我穿的是传统蒙古袍啊。呵呵。ruclips.net/video/fcSsDiJ56GY/видео.html
厉害。
这太厉害了
Wow
你年轻的时候好可爱哦。☺️
内蒙人狂喜，草原歌曲是内蒙人心中的魂，不论什么时候时候听到总有深深的共鸣，不论是天堂这种描绘草原壮阔美景的还是鸿雁这种描绘内心比较细腻情感的歌曲，都会在心中有强烈的共鸣。也不知道是歌曲感染力强还是内蒙这个独特的地方给人造成的影响。
是啊，有时候单曲循环很久
这是一首来自中国的蒙古族著名歌唱家腾格尔的《天堂》。鄂尔多斯这块地方堪称是民歌的海洋，腾格尔自幼浸泡在这海洋里，他不用刻意学，大人唱他便跟着唱，很快就会了。他的父亲在家乡知道的民歌之多是数一数二的，音正腔圆，调准、词准，而他的母亲和父亲截然不同，性格刚烈，管教时不仅动口，还动手用鞭子抽，尽管儿时没少挨抽，但他还是深爱母亲。创作歌曲时，家乡草原上的植被破坏得很厉害，草原沙漠化严重，他想通过歌曲来唤醒人们热爱自然、保护草原的意识，同时也怀念儿时记忆中家乡的景象。正是怀着这样的心情，草原，我的根，家，我的天堂，腾格尔写下了《天堂》。
这首歌曲属于中国民歌，腾格尔老师的个人风格在这首歌里表现的非常明显。看着歌词去理解他的艺术表现，才能最好的理解他的感情。欢迎大家来到中国内蒙古，这是世界上最美的草原。
This is "Heaven" by Tengger, a famous Mongolian singer from China. Ordos is an ocean of folk songs. Tengger has been immersed in this ocean since he was a child. He doesn't need to deliberately learn it. If the adults sing, he will sing along, and he will soon. His father knew one of the best folk songs in his hometown. The sound was round, the tunes were accurate, and the words were accurate. His mother and father were very different and had a strong personality. When disciplined, he not only used his mouth, but also used a whip. When he was a child, he was often smoked, but he still loved his mother deeply. When composing the song, the vegetation on the grassland in his hometown was severely destroyed and the grassland desertification was serious. He wanted to use the song to awaken people's awareness of loving nature and protecting the grassland, and at the same time miss the sight of his hometown in his childhood memories. It is with this feeling that the grassland, my roots, home, and my paradise, Tengger wrote "Heaven".
This song is a Chinese folk song, and teacher Tengger’s personal style is very obvious in this song. Only by looking at the lyrics to understand his artistic performance can he understand his feelings best. Welcome to Inner Mongolia, China, this is the most beautiful grassland in the world.
歌词：
蓝蓝的天空I see a blue sky,
清清的湖水Over a green lake,
绿绿的草原Vast is the grassland,
这是我的家This is my homeland.
奔驰的骏马Horses running wild there,
洁白的羊群Sheep as white as snow,
还有你姑娘Girl wait for me,
这是我的家Where my heart's at home.
我爱你 我的家I love you, my homeland,
我的家 我的天堂My homeland, my heaven.
我爱你 我的家I miss you, my homeland,
我的家 我的天堂My homeland, my heaven.
蓝蓝的天空I see a blue sky,
清清的湖水Over a green lake,
绿绿的草原Vast is the grassland,
这是我的家This is my homeland.
我爱你 我的家I love you, my homeland,
我的家 我的天堂My homeland, my heaven.
我爱你 我的家I miss you, my homeland,
我的家 我的天堂My homeland, my heaven.
是的，我有大学同学是鄂尔多斯长大的，随便开口唱歌嗓音就非常嘹亮好听
之前去内蒙古旅游，当地人说唱得像腾格尔这样的人很多。真是多才多艺的民族。
实力派的歌手的演唱总能扣动人心弦，虽然我不懂音乐，但能真实的感受到那种无法形容的感觉！
作为一个在内蒙古出生的人， 从小到大都听蒙古风格的歌。腾格尔就是神一样的存在。
Joe, you are awesome! 👍👍👍
Without reading the lyrics you can felt the meaning of the song was about hometown. Such a great sense.
It's one of the few performances that makes me cry every time. It's full of raw emotion and great control. The story behind this song makes it even more touching. Thanks for recommending it to Joe_creator. 😊🙏
举重诺轻，厚积薄发，腾格尔音乐的力量，听这样的歌曲就是比比一般的流行乐爽太多。
哇靠 柯桑德😂 沒有你我也許不太可能會聽到這首歌 ！ 我看完這段片 再去聽一次天堂 ，之後又再回來聽9爺見解，之後又再去聽一次天堂，感覺自己都要上天堂了🤣🤣太震撼啦！！我對騰格爾的印象只有戀愛循環 學貓叫😅😅好崩壞的印象。。但是因為你一直保持作品品質所以即便我對這位大神有很崩壞的印象也毫不猶豫地點進來看 ，謝謝你讓我接觸到這首歌☺
谭维维翻唱的蒙古族歌曲《乌兰巴托的夜》也超级震撼的，可以让国外老哥评测下！
真的找到战友了！那首无限循环ing
+10086
这首一定要做!期待Joe的点评
Joe_creator was great, the music selection was a killer.
Lovin how you picked each music video.
it's not just like any other videos but these singers has their own personality and vibe.
Makes the who reaction/ review so individual and unique.
loving the content!! 666~
❤️你的反应真的完全是中国人！都在点儿上↑ 看得出来你也是很感性善良的人，这首《天堂》你真的听进心里去了，很感动的感觉～
我每次听到这首歌，都是哭的。。。老师唱得我心里去。。。唱到我思念我13岁就失去父亲的记忆，感谢腾老师
以前一直笑话腾格尔是在用最大的力气发最小的声，作为一个身在国外的内蒙人，出国后才听懂他所表达的东西
腾格尔老师在气息强弱的掌握上可是大师级别的，这不是我说的，而是很多国外评测过他演唱的专业歌者讲的。
从小就喜欢他的歌
像一个大茶壶的蒸汽从小壶嘴出来
@@mogugao6209 这种力量可以切开钢铁
控制力的最高水准
唱的我毛骨悚然，热泪盈眶！ 老艺术家，牛逼！
你那句白漂了呀，我去~~太神髓了！！没把我笑死🤣🤣🤣
简单的不能再简单的歌词，轻柔有有力的演唱，真的非常非常棒的歌曲。
桑德，谢谢你！我是蒙古族，你的节目让我想家了。想发弹幕，但是不会。只能写在评论里，腾格尔的这首歌里有自己逝去的女儿的身影，歌曲委婉，爱恋，悲亢。蒙古族以前是游牧民族，音乐里有着宽广的天空，有着惆怅的情绪。
RUclips应该是不能发弹幕的。博主一直提到弹幕，是因为他的视频也会发在一个叫哔哩哔哩的视频网站上，那个网站能发弹幕。
@@xianerbing 谢谢你！
我爱听也爱唱，可从没有这么细细品过！谢谢你带我好好感受她了解她！喜欢你的视频！好棒！
我是一位海外华裔，在澳大利亚长大。从小就听过父母听这首歌。音乐是无边境的。希望能分享给更多人。
這首歌是紀念他深愛過世的女兒去了天堂。所以天堂的女兒就是他的家
这个最开始单纯的对大草原的爱，歌曲出现时，他女儿还没出生，最初的版本和现在的版本有点差别，应该是把对女儿的思念加了进去。
听到这首歌,我都哭了！从这首歌就能听出,腾格尔老师对他女儿的爱有多大,多想！真的是用尽了感情去唱,不是纯粹的去唱！
不是纯粹为了唱而去唱！
我喜欢这个live版，比唱片的版本更有feel，更有power
Vey nice analysis……Keep the good job……
有没有同款
每次听这个版本的天堂，眼泪都会止不住的流。
说不出的情绪，莫名其妙的的流出来。
两行泪轻轻滑落，回想家乡与故人，渴望与饱含深情
When I was a student in middle school, I bought his CD and played the song named heaven(天堂) again and again. And now, I still love his music.
哇joe太棒了一种遇到知音的感觉让人激动以致热泪盈眶
每次聽這首，都會不知不覺地流出眼淚
hi!this is the first time i came across your channel.wow great job man thank you
騰格爾(Tengri)的另外一首名曲是八千裡路雲和月
Morin Quur 就是馬頭琴的英文
一个国家有56个民族能够和平相处 几千年 那不是一般国家一般人能做得到的 一定需要很强大的文化根基才能既有强大的国家做中流砥柱 还有强大的胸怀去容纳四周各民族 。
所以如果能够看懂滕格尔这种很具有内蒙古民族特色唱法的人能够在现代化社会自然和自由的歌唱的人 就是能够读懂中华文化那种海纳百川的强大文化底蕴。
在这里感谢视频里的人能够欣赏滕格尔的民族特色歌唱 。
人类需要互相包容和平共处 。
你确定是和平相处几千年？
@@Nemo-hu7qr 确定的是中华文明包容了一切
@@Nemo-hu7qr 人类社会的进化总是伴随着相爱相杀，最后达到天下大同，不管曾经我们这片土地上发生过什么，现在，我们都是相亲相爱的中国人
@@hsyerwin 有千里投毒的，有宁可华夏遍地坟的，有留岛不留人的…就是没几个想拿大陆绿卡的
对和平有不同观点的人，人类史还长，争取灭绝前还是一家人，行吗？
滕格尔目前是中国人民喜爱和欣赏的蒙古民族特色唱法的歌唱家。他在中国有大量的粉丝拥护他。他是以歌唱为生存职业的歌唱家。
以前小时候不懂的时候我只觉得这个歌咋咋呼呼的，现在40岁了，只听了第一句眼泪就飙出来了。。。真的艺术家是能达到内心的
看你的頻道結果變成Joe的fans ❤️有機會多介紹一下Joe。
腾格尔中间那段真的太太太太牛了吧，就真的绝！Joe分析得很真的很仔细
哇！上次留言的歌竟然这么快就安排上了！爱你，赞你，转发！！！！
听到这首歌我太感动，我爸爸以前在内蒙工作，他很喜欢腾格尔。让我回想起和爸爸在一起的点滴。。。
應該給Joe普及一下背後的故事，他肯定會有新的領悟。其實歌詞很簡單，騰格爾只是想在家鄉的草原上看著自己的女兒……對大多數家庭來說很簡單的一件事，在他看來就是天堂……那般美好卻也觸不可及
真是让人感伤
对，歌里真情实感想念自己的女儿
理解不了歌词背后的感情，所以Joe没法感同身受
了解滕老師的故事，感覺他每個時期表達的都不一樣。最後這一版是對女兒的思念吧，淚目
马头琴。
腾格尔的“我爱你,我的家...”感染力让人泪涌。
龚琳娜老师的作品也非常值得点评啊！ 忐忑...
感觉如果不理解京剧很难理解忐忑
她的小河淌水也很赞，或者走西口
求生欲强啊，内容好，满足要求点赞了
歌曲一开始的人声演唱是呼麦，一个歌手同一时间唱出两个声部。
节目做的太棒了👏会一直关注你
据我所知，滕格尔这种蒙古特色唱法是来源于他的母亲自小耳濡目染而成。滕格尔曾经带着他的母亲上台一起歌唱这种风格的歌曲，并且腾格尔自己在台上介绍，他母亲是荣获中国政府嘉奖的原生态传承歌唱家，受国家保护。
这是我两年前在RUclips上看到的视频。
專業人士畢竟是專業人士，評價得很棒。
“呼麦”在西方有个专业术语叫“over Tongue singing“
腾格尔女人意外过世，他把头发剃光，这首重新编曲的 天堂 记录他对女儿的思念
馬頭琴 is the musical instrument. The wooo singing style called 呼麥
请评价一下韩磊：等待。谢谢！
看了好多這首的reaction, Joe 最棒😂
爱S你了，谢谢推荐，现在就去看纯享版！🥰🥰🥰
国庆听这个太有感触了。。多谢up主
Can you make a video about lim zi xiang
柯桑德，我非常喜欢你这个系列，每一集我都有看，《天堂》这首歌我听得非常震撼，也非常喜欢蒙古歌曲，还有一首蒙古歌曲也非常的震撼，希望你能让JOY点评一下，就是《鸿雁》谢谢。
推荐 杭盖乐队，蒙古族传统音乐和摇滚的结合。腾格尔的演唱和歌词其实是更照顾非蒙古族的汉族人，杭盖经常是全蒙古语的演唱。
喜欢杭盖
超爱杭盖啊！想听带劲的还可以听九宝乐队！超级上头！
SUPERB VOCAL, VERY DETAIL EXPERESS, VERY DYNAMIC
啥时候做龚琳娜老师的
博主很棒，继续加油
整首曲子呈現出一望無際草原穹蒼的風光 好震撼 好感動！
可以做一期，韩磊.
这也是我最爱的一首歌，震撼人心！
第一次刷到，哇哦 太喜欢了 订阅了
This song expresses the voice from a true wolf in its views about its paradise hometown of Mongolian terrain prairie with the blue sky in its blue eyes. Wolf's song.
有机会可不可以换个风格 让他评价一下崔健 窦唯
建议下次能在开头或者最后完整的播放一遍歌手的演唱
一开头拉的琴叫马头琴，是蒙古族人特有的古乐器，它可以发出嘎嘎声音好像是模仿马奔跑声，这是我个人感觉。
he use one sing to shock my whole life. really, really like him
即使不知道這歌的內容，也被感動得流淚了，是歌聲中細緻又巨大的感情，本是澎湃的但卻像怕傷着嚇着那打心底愛着的，於是不得不細細流露的感覺，到後來再也忍不住真情澎湃洶湧而出，最後回歸平靜。
眼淚真止不住啊。。
蒙古传统唱法真是天生的摇滚vibe啊！太酷了
蒙语歌超级帅的！ 下回做 希拉草原 的reaction 吧！
Joe is great! figuring out all the lyrics....
This song show the power of music, that's all I can say
Morin Hor （Mongolian）
Mǎ Tóu Qín （Mandarin）
The Horse Head String Instrument （English translation）
There is a carved horse's head on the head of the harp.
歌如其名，仿佛看到了天堂，感受到了祥和。
超想知道《滄海一聲笑》這首會是什麼評價？感覺這首歌中國人才能懂😊
GAI的《沧海一声笑》
@Molan Dao 我就聽這騰格爾跟林子祥一個味兒
而且是電影粵語版本，是黃沾唱第一段、許冠傑唱第三段的版本。
網上很難找，音質不好，只有那個一大段情節、其中一小段唱歌、後來開始打鬥的頻道。
只有中国才有江湖 看到黃沾就看到江湖
这歌超多外国人爱的 在美国现场UFC上张伟丽出场时播过