yyeman leung This list makes it seem like if the singer can hit higher notes (even if they aren’t supported and don’t have an resonance), then they’re automatically a better vocalist. And I’m not hating on Yeonjung because she’s a great singer. But if we’re talking about technical aspects, then Sejeong is overall the better vocalist. The reason she can’t hit really high notes is because that’s not her range and she knows that. So when she sings, she stays within her range and supports everything. With Yeonjung, although she’s a higher range, she doesn’t support which is why sometimes it almost feels as if she’s screaming out her notes.
JAD Entertainment What does training at SM have to do with vocal abilities? Plenty of artists have been rejected from SM, that’s a fact. But just because you train at SM, doesn’t mean that you’re automatically a better singer compared to someone who didn’t train at SM. I’m not saying that Yeonjung is a bad vocalist, because she’s not. But because her range is on the higher side, she’s often belting out her high notes, which aren’t always supported. Sometimes they sound strained, like she’s pushing so much out just to get to that note. And sometimes her high notes seem more like screams than anything. She doesn’t have the best control right now and with practice, I’m sure she’ll fix that. But being in SM doesn’t automatically mean someone is a more superior vocalist. Many people got rejected from SM and are much better vocalists than some of the ones in SM currently.
Lolli Polli01 thank you, someone finally said it!! People especially like to view vocalists as bad if they aren’t “stable”, but that doesn’t have to do with technique and how good a vocalist is. Both Sejeong and Yeonjung are not very far apart from each other, but Sejeong has a healthier technique and does not belt far from her vocal range. Although I think Yeonjung’s vibrato is more controlled and sustainable with her good breath but it does sound throaty at times.
@yeji ponytail No I'm not, got my ears checked and everything seems to be clear. :) Also, if we're talking about belting high notes, then Yeonjung would obviously have the HIGHER note. Duh, it's because she has the higher range. But if we're talking about TECHNIQUE, then Sejeong is superior in that sense. While both females are exceptional vocalists, Sejeong has more control over her voice. She supports most, if not all, of her "high notes". Yeonjung has the higher range, which means she's most likely to get the high notes at the climax of a song. However, Yeonjung lacks the stability when SOMETIMES belts out her notes. For the most part, she can support her high notes, but I've seen instances where her notes are not supported well. They sound strained and make it seem like she's "shouting" her notes, rather than singing them. Just because you have the higher range, doesn't mean you have the better technique. Sejeong has more control mainly because her optimal range is around the middle.
Meanie I agree with both of you. I had some hope for Somi after Whatta Man, but with the release of Very Very Very, I'm back to finding myself dreading her voice. I get her appeal, but I'm not a fan of her voice.
IMO THE VOCAL ROYALE 1. Yeunjung (ofc) 2. Sejeong (yep. but i like the quality of her voice.) THE LEADS 3. Somi (no doubt, but the gap betweem her amd the top two is too big. 4. Pinky //i thought she was Jeiqiong? [lol sorry i spelled it wrong]// (she was supposed to be 5th but her short high belts brought her a step higher.) 5. Chungha- (stable af, i like her voice. It's thick but doesn't have proper breathing. I like her vibrato tho) 6. Doyeon- (it can be Yoojung, but oh well.. Yoojung fits rapping... or not...just fuck it. She's here because i want to.) THE WEAK VOCALISTS 7. Oh fucking wait. There's Yoojung- (She's a good vocalist so no way for her to land in the area below her) OR LET'S JUST CALL IT THE RAPPERS LINE 8. Chaeyeon- Yeah.. she's here. 9. Mina- She just fits rapping more, she can fucking sing in gugudan and barbie theme songs. But not in Immortal Songs or stuff. But DAMN! She raps like eminem (that's too exaggerated but i like her voice when rapping) 10.) Nayoung- RAPRAPRAPRAPRAPRAP 11.) Sohye- ..so..yeeaah.. let's leave it at that.
It's quite difficult to compare between Yeunjung and Sejung because of their different singing styles. I prefer Yeunjung but I can't deny that Sejung also sings very well and I can see her deep emotion which she puts into every emotional performance. In a word, I can rank both Yeunjung and Sejung in top 1
1. Sejeong (All around just great) 2. Yeunjung (Great with high notes, and stable) 3. Chungha (Her tone is really good and she's stable) 4. Somi (Not really a fan of her tone, but she is stable) 5. Yoojung, Pinky 6. Doyeon 7. Chaeyeon, Nayoung, Sohye (She just needs a confidence boost) 8. Mina (Just a little too cutesy, for my liking, at times, but definitely not bad)
I like SeJeong's expression, it's kinda…very touch ,with her strong vocal. Her vocal is not only high notes, it's very plump or something like she can sing low notes
Sejeong does have great tone and a great voice but when it comes to belting i have to give it to Yeonjung along with the husky voice. Yeunjung can just reach notes clearer and better and has really great breathing technique. Sejeong's voice is nice but she can get a little eary at times she also has great tone but 8/10 breathing technique. Overall they both have a same range only is that Yeonjung can reach higher and clearer while Sejeong voice is nicer to hear.
In my opinion 1. Yeunjung 2. Sejung 3. Chungha 4. Yoojung 5. Pinky 6. Somi 7. Doyeon 8. Nayoung 9. Mina 10. Chaeyeon 11. Sohye Still, how can you judge a B team vocal over an A team? Rap-wise, I think 1. Yoojung (she is the main rapper in Fantagio girlgroup anw), 2. Nayoung, 3. Maybe Chungha?, 4. Somi can pass as a rapper in this group
+Minh Huong Ngo judge a B team vocal over an A team.... do you think Dani singing better than Somi in Re-Evaluation pick me :)))) and Dani in B->A team because her legs pretty and dance may well ( her position rap better than singing) and rappers, dancers go to A team not just vocal only ( Kim Juna has a great vocal but dance not well so she not go to A team). General essessment of judges based on criteria consistent with an idol. :)))) I'm Ok with your rank ( Somi have to practice and improve her singing in future) but don't say " how can you judge a B team vocal over an A team". It's inelegant :((((
+Minh Huong Ngo I agree! Pinky is more stable than Somi and Pinky get high note. Nayoung is excelente like rapper, but do'nt have a great vocal. Chungha has a great vocal. I think the weeknes is Chaeyeon because Sohye no confidence in hersef. Somi is a good singer, dancer and face, but isn't excepcional in vocal and dance to be in top 3 of vocal or dance
Non bias opinion (I have no bias) In my opinion so far... 1. Yeunjung 2. Sejeong 3. Chungha (unexpectedly has a good tone/voice) 4. Yoojung (watch her Pick Me evaluation, very underrated singer) 5. Somi (sounds monotonous sometimes but stable) 6. Pinky 7. Doyeon 8. Nayoung 9-11 Chaeyeon, Mina and Sohye
Yes, yeonjung is a really good singer, she can make every performance powerful, she can hit those high notes more easily than sejeong. But the reason why I'm more drawn to sejeong is because of the sincerity that she gives to every song that she sings, the way that she portrays the emotions in the songs, even without hitting those high notes, she slays.
My ranking: 1. Yeonjung, Sejeong (Yeonjung voice is very powerful while Sejeong's is very emotional and I personally can't pick between the two) 2. Chungha (Her voice is pleasing to the ears and powerful as well) 3. Yoojung, Somi (They both have good tones while also being a bit powerful) 4. Doyeon, Nayoung, Kyulkyung (They have good tones though their voices are a bit softer and less powerful and I feel like if they do higher notes their voice can crack and become unstable) 5. Sohye, Chaeyeon, Mina (Their singing is not the best since their voices is unstable and weak but there can be rooms for improvements and their voices can have a lot of potential) *I'm not a vocal coach or trainer of any kinds I just wanted to express my thoughts about their singing and everyone has their own opinions.
Yoonjeung may have a greater vocal range but Sejeong has musicality. They're both equal in terms of technicalities but Sejeong's musicality and musicianship gives her the slight upper hand.
i feel like this isn't a vocal skills/depth list but rather who can sing higher than who which in most cases doesn't make you a better VOCALIST. i'm not even sejeong biased but she has my favorite tone in ioi. the other's voices are pretty girl group standard (that doesnt mean bad or worse, just expectable and more common) while sejeong's is more what you'd find in an experienced soloist. just my opinion.
Now people should seriously distinguish the difference between a vocal ranking (voice color, sincerity, technique, power) and a high note ranking. I agree with you, for me Sejeong's vocal is better
Based on my vocal analysis, a few of them are really similar. 11.Mina - no technique 10-9.Sohye - no confidence in her singing 9-10.Chaeyeon - nasal 8-7.Nayoung 7-8.Yoojung 6-5.Doyoung 5-6. Kyulkyung 4-3.Somi 3-4.Chungha 2-Sejung 1-Yeonjung
+baebae i personally feel like nasally tones are sometimes more interesting and doesn't necessarily mean worse vocals but other than that and the fact that i like sejung's full mid range voice more than yeunjung's high range voice my list is same as yours
Sejeong vocal is more well-developed in all register. her mixed voice is relatively better than the rest of IOIs. her lower and higher register are good. Yeunjung register are not really developed. her high note make her standout since her mixed voice is headier and not connected.
@@5642466deMG OP already said that Yeonjung's high notes are good. That doesn't mean her mixed voice nor her lower register is well developed. Just look at Yeonjung trying to sing Western Sky on Weekly Idol. She struggles a lot with lower notes
i kinda feel like the only edge yeonjung has over sejeong is that she has a wider vocal range but other than that, sejeong is better. yeonjung often strains her high notes and she lacks support, which results to her high notes often sounding like screams. sejeong on the other hand has support and has better technique and musicality, overall. always take note that high notes do not define who's the better vocalist :))
Although ppl say sejeong is capable of high notes too I think Yeunjung still pull them off better and her high pitch has more depth tbh Yeunjung reminds me of taeyeon while sejeong reminds me of eunji..
+aimee e. exactly. Sejeong is reeeaaaaally good, but high notes queen is without a doubt, Yeonjung. Plus, her voice is amazingly stable and very very powerful even when dancing.
Agree with everything except Yeonjung and Sejeong sharing the top spot. I think they are both incredibly vocalists, but I think Yeonjung is better. She's just gifted.
Personally I feel Sejeong should be number 1, because vocal ability incorporates more that being able to pull off high notes very well. I feel making an emotional connection vocally is what makes a singer more powerful. But, yeonjung is still relatively young and can still learn to add that to her already impressive vocal ability!
For me its: 1. yeunjung 2. Seojung 3. Chungha 4. Pinky, Yoojung, Somi 7. Doyeon 8. Nayoung 9. Mina, Chaeyon, Sohye, Sohye has really improved so i don't think she's worse than mina or Chaeyeon.
GirlFromSea Oh I think I agree with your idea. Pinky, Yoojung and Somi I can't judge who is better than others 2 haha, but I think Somi's voice is stronger and more unique than others 2.
i think i like yoojungs better....but then Pinky really impresses me in these newer songs...but then Somi also totally impresses me with each new song xD so...still tied hahahah
GirlFromSea I agree with Pinky, Yoojung, and Somi being on the same level; I think they can all hit the same notes, just depends on whose tone you prefer
(commented on another before, and this is in no particular order) Sejeong (Better support, plus better range doesn't mean better vocalist) Yeunjung (Awesome high notes but you can hear the evident strain :') ) Chungha (Has a nice tone, can even reach main vocalist level high notes as seen in Crush OT7 ver.) Yoojung (Nice tone, stable, one of my favorite timbres in I.O.I) Somi (Quite good for her age, able to do runs and high notes as well, just lacks emotion... But a nice and warm tone overall + Stable) Kyulkyung (Can sound a bit nasally at times, but a decent vocalist? Stable but lacks proper technique? She hits her high notes in Whatta Man with falsetto in lives) Doyeon (I personally don't like her tone, it sounds VERY nasally compared to Kyulkyung. Her falsettos are pleasant though.) Nayoung (I like her falsettos. Her normal singing voice is kinda... Eh. But then again, she's okay. Her high notes are hit with falsettos in lives as well, like Kyulkyung's) Sohye (Nice tone if trained properly. Lacks stability, but her falsettos are good for a non idol trainee. If she trains more I'm sure she'd rank quite high on the list.) Chaeyeon (Bland tone, not much stability... Weak vocalist. HOWEVER, if trained well, I think she can be a good lead vocal.) Mina (Nasally and no support at all. Is more suited for rap.) So... My ranking is: 1. Sejeong 2. Yeunjung 3. Chungha 4. Yoojung 5. Somi/Kyulkyung 6. Somi/Kyulkyung 7. Doyeon 8. Nayoung 9. Sohye 10. Chaeyeon 11. Mina
1. YeonJung( I love her highnote in Into the new world) 2. Sejeong (Her voice is very sweet) 3 Chungha (She can be main vocalist) 4 Pinky( I think she has a good voice) 5. Somi 6 Yoojung 7 Doyeon 8 Nayoung 9 Mina 10 Sohye 11 Chaeyeon
Sejeong sings so weelll (great technique/control) and singers who can put such raw emotions to a song is what make the song so beautiful... So sejeong is no. 1 for me (and I'm a Sesang hehe)
this is based on my opinion, 1. Sejeong (love her vocal soooo freakin much) 2. yeunjung (her high notes is very very amazing) 3. chungha (her voice is so sweet to hear) 4. yoojung (she is stable when singing and dancing) 5. somi (sometimes she is not stable but it's ok she's still so young) 6. pinky (she is rlly amazing) 7. doyeon (she has a good vocal) 8. nayoung (i love her rap so much) 9-11. mina chaeyeon sohye.
Even though this is not a favourable, I must say Sejeong has the best vocal skills among them. She has a better control with pleasant notes. Yeunjung's high notes are fine, but often she used too much power and overpushed her voice when hitting high notes (which people usually feel the notes sound 'stronger'?!). This will eventually hurt her voice... Plus her strength is limited to high notes, her lower register is not as good. No offense, just saying as someone who learns singing.
In My Opinion 1. Sejeong (I Like Sejeong Voice than Yeunjung) 2. Yeunjung (I Like Her High Note) 3. Somi 4. Chungha 5. Pinky 6. Yujeong 7. Doyeon 8. Nayoung 9. Chaeyeon 10. Mina 11. Sohye (She's The Weakest)
technical skill (vocal range/control) 1. yeunjung - her range and natural talent is unbelievable 2. sejeong - also amazing range and control 3. chungha - stable and if she really hit those high notes in bang bang, daaamn 4. nayoung - it's less about her range, but she has made very few if any mistakes, her breathing is stable; though her voice isn't naturally loud 5. somi - when I first got into pd101 I thought she was #1 bc of popularity, but she's actually very stable too 6. yoojung - stable w/ great control over her comfortable range, her vocal tone works with lots of genres 7. doyeon - wasn't too impressed with la cha ta and she didn't sing in bang bang or had many parts with ioi but she was great in itsp. I feel like she has a lot more to show 8. pinky - she's stable too but sometimes she strains a little? like she only uses her throat voice. but since she's not a native korean speaker, she is very impressively fluent (and her vocal tone is nice to listen to). she is in no way a bad singer 9. chaeyeon - for a vocalist, and a vocalist who's debuted, I felt that she was lacking. uh i think she needs to project her voice and work on her breathing? again, she hasn't had too many parts in ioi so I'd like to hear more of her 10. mina - she hasn't really stood out to me in terms of singing. with a bit more practice and more parts in songs, she'll definitely improve 11. sohye - well, of course she never was intended to become an idol and her improvement has been insane. I didn't think much of it during the show but in hip song and yum yum, she was a lot better than before. I hope ymc are giving her vocal training because it'd be a waste of her potential not to in terms of my personal preference, I loooove sejeong's performance of irony. sejeong in irony alone is my number 1 tbh. I also like somi, pinky and doyeon's vocal colours, so they'd be higher up. nayoung's lack of loudness is similar to chaeyeon's so she'd be lower down but the fact she's so high up even tho she's a rapper is amazing. people criticised the final lineup for being too full of visuals but I think the members have strong vocals too; if you think about it, only chaeyeon and sohye have never been ranked A. I just wish there were another rapper or two; cathy or either of the two soyeons would've fit in.
I think Sejeong deserves the top spot. I'm not biased, but based on how the judges evaluate her voice, she's got the range and the musicality. She can also adlibs at the right time... Also Yeonjung has that soft voice that's why it sounds slightly better. Still, just my opinion, Sejeong, for me, deserves the top spot.
Mine is 1. Yeunjung, her high note was just so WOW 2. Sejeong, her power vocal and her feel sometime make me got goosebump 3. Yoojung, no matter she's a good rapper, she also a good singer. As Ryan said, that Yoojung has a main vocal quality 4. Somi, her voice for me, is thick (?) like tiffany's voice, but just thinner than tiffany's. I confused for make her on the third or fourth place, but i choose in fourth place. 5. Pinky/Chungha, okay, i confused about them. Sometime Pinky is better than Chungha and sometime Chungha is better than Pinky. So i took them in the same place. 6. Chungha/Pinky 7. Sohye, she has improved so much than before. So i took her in the seventh place. 8. Doyeon, her voice is good 9. Nayoung, maybe she's a rapper, but her voice sometime can be so soft as a singer. 10. Mina, she's not good at sing, i think. Because her voice like a child(?). but her voice is good 11. Chaeyeon, her voice is good too.
this is my ranking: 1. Sejeong 2. YeunJung 3. Yoojung In my opinion, Yeun Jung can sing high notes, but Sejeong can too. Even Sejeong also expreses her ability of singing more perfect than Yeun jung. I believe that in the future, Sejeong will become a very famous main vocal, maybe even as Taeyeon. SEJEONG Hwaiting >
1.yeunjung 2.sejeong 3.chungha 4.yoojung 5.kyulkyeong 6.doyeon 7.somi (she has loads of time to improve shes only 15 and her voice hasnt even fully developed!!) 8.nayoung 9.sohye 10.chaeyeon 11.mina
For me is something like this 11- Mina (she just sing like someone cute in the karaoke) 10- Sohye (is afraid to make mistakes, no confidence in her singing) 9- Chaeyeon (I like her nasal voice but isn't too powerful) 8- Nayoung (idol's rap, nothing out of the ordinary) 7- Doyeon (she has a soft voice that insurance could be overcome with more training) 6- Pinky (she's my bias, but need more vocal training) 5- Yoojung (u should see the individual evaluation of "pick me" if you don't agree) 4- Somi 3- Chungah 2- Sejeong 1- Yeunjung
High notes are so overrated and is no indication that youre really great if u can pull put high notes. Its just that u have higher range. Sejeong #1 singing
To me Sejeong deserve the 1st place her low tone voice can be fitted to various styles song, such as kpop music(eg crush, Irony), slow or romantic music(eg When the cherry blossoms fade, Yanghwa Bridge) And her voice even suits rapping too Her voice has higher plasticity than yeonjung, Yeonjung is good at singing high notes but she always sings the same type of songs, I think the Rock n Roll music and rap are not suitable to her
For me the vocal ranking goes like this: 1. Sejeong (I prefer her voice more than Yeunjung's, it's just that Yeunjung is the one who keep hitting the high notes) 2. Yeunjung (her high notes: THUMBS UP) 3. Somi 4. Yoojung 5. Jieqiong 6. Chungha 7. Doyeon 8. Nayoung 9. Mina 10. Chaeyeon 11. Sohye
I can't distinguish between 1&2 becuz the one has a good technique and control in singing while the one is good with high note but for other ranking 3-10 , it is the same opinion !!!
***** I actually have changed my ranking from 3-11 after listening some more :) and yes for me Chungha and Yoojung are the best vocals after Sejeong and Yeunjung.
My ranking: 1. Yeunjung 2. Sejung 3. Pinky 4. Chungha 5. Somi 6. Yoojung 7. Doyeon 8. Nayoung 9. Mina 10. Chaeyeon 11. Sohye I feel like Pinky, Chungha, and Doyeon are so underrated in terms of their vocal abilities. I think most people just focus on Chungha's amazing dance abilities that they forget how stable she is. And Pinky and Doyeon are known for their visual, so people forget that they can actually sing.
Did you hear Sejeong singing "if I ain't got you"? ruclips.net/video/-J0utQ8ijJY/видео.html Her voice is so unique, stable and powerful! And more others such as "love the way you lie".... Yeonjung' voice is powerful on doing high note only, her voice is not special while singing coda, you can search the "IOI- hip song", then you will find Sejeong has a more recognizable voice@@
my list : 1-sejung (its good to hear for long time and my style ) 2-yeunjung (high note and super powerful voice ) 3-chungha 4-somi 5-yoojung 6-pinky 7-doyeon 8-nayoung 9-chayeon 10-mina 11-sohye
pinky is better than yoojung in terms in singing because pinky is stable and csn hit highnotes while yoojung is stable too but only in low register... but i love them both
+DramaQueen agreed. i actually find pinky and chungha on par because pinky is stable. but chungha's is towards adlib but weaker, (more towards subvocals) i would put yoojung after chungha because shes more balance but no adlib
1. Yeonjung 2. Sejeong 3. Chungha 4. Yoojung 5. Pinky 6. Doyeon 7. Somi 8. Nayoung 9-11 Mina/Sohye/Chaeyeon Clearly Doyeon > Somi. Anyone else wanna argue otherwise should first explain to me how Doyeon gets promoted to Group A during PD101 while Somi drops to Group B when *arguably* Somi's dance is better than Doyeon's.
FollowNRBH in the video for pick me evaluation, somi did not have energy in the starting that's why the instructor pulled her out. i think somi is more stable for sure. i think her vocals is better in Yum Yum as compared to Do Yeon in at the same place as Do Yeon breathing technique is not as good.
This is my opinion okay 😉💕 1. Yeonjung (this is obvious) 2. Sejeong (i love her voice) 3. Chungha (she is very stable) 4. Kyulkyung (she is not a korean but i love her pronounciation) 5. Yoojung (she is very stable) 6. Doyeon (she's also stable) 7. Somi (i don't know why people rank her so high but i'm sure she can improve 😉) 8. Nayoung (i love her rappp) 9. Sohye (she needs some training and i'm sure she will become a great singer) 10. Mina (she will improve one day ) 11. Chaeyeon (she's not stable but i'm sure she will improve) I am not being biased but this is just my opinion. If I'm being biased , I would put my Yoojung first 💕
Sejeong first for me! Tbh all yeong jung has is high notes I hear it everywhere in girl groups she lacks the mature sentiment that Sejeong has and I think that is more prize worthy. That's why yeong jung is more an idol singer and sejeong a musician quality.
+kimmo chia Yes! I mentioned this in my comment too, I find all of Yeunjungs notes sound the same (though they're amazing), whereas Sejeongs notes have a sort of flavour to them and always manage to give me chills
+suci purnamasari yeah exactly! Not that she isn't amazing because she is but I find Sejeongs high notes always sound different and have a depth to them I just can't find in the other girls
+Charlene Tan I never said Sejeong is BETTER of a singer? I said I prefer the way she carries herself and the way in which she uses her voice and vocal range while she's singing. I think you're getting the wrong impression
my preference will be 1) YeunJung 2) Sejeong 3) Somi 4) Pinky 5) Chungha 6) Yoojung 7) Nayoung 8)Doyeon 9)Chaeyeon 10)Mina 11)Sohye Sohye doesnt sound horrid, (watch Hip Song 2016 @ sugarman) its just because she is last though, its just more of preference of song genre. pinky's voice is stable but safe. Whereas Chungha is adlib but not strong enough like sejeong Yoojung rap is swag to be honest, she hasnt unleash her full strength.
FACTS 1. Produce 101 Position Eval. (VOCAL) Sejeong 406 votes Yeonjung 317 votes 2. I.O.I - All title tracks line distribution Sejeong ~131.5s / 17.5% Yeonjung ~104.6s / 13.9% 3. Best Solo Song Sejeong "Flower Way" took 1st place on all Korea charts , won MBC Show! Champion 7.4M+ views on dingo music's RUclips channel Yeonjung "Marry You“ 790K+ views on dingo music's RUclips channel 4. KpopVocalAnalysis Score Sejeong 3.0 Yeonjung 2.5 5. "The King of Mask Singer" Best Record Sejeong April 9, 2019: episode winner, one win away from the crown Yeonjung Jan 1, 2017: 2nd round ... and people still think Yeonjung is a better singer because "she sings better high notes" #facepalm
I prefer Sejeong's singing to Yeunjung's cuz I find it more emotional. But I think Mina sings well right? From the first episode, she always stands at the position of vocal. When I watched 24 hours, I was surprised by her power. Strong dancing and singing together but she still could control her voice so well.
i think sejeong voice is more soft and elegant, and her tone is thinner which makes her hit higher notes easier than yeonjung. yeonjung on the other hand, has a stronger tone as a thicker one, so her vocal is more powerful and loud. she too can hit high notes but is limited by the thick tone, but pulls it off really good! overall I think both girls are excellent singers and lets all support them in their future! :D
for me 1. Sejeong 2. Yeonjung 3. Chungha 4. Yoojung 5. Pinky or Somi 6. Somi or Pinky 7. Doyeon 8. Nayoung 9. Chaeyeon or Sohye (she just no confidence but she is pretty good) 10. Sohye or Chaeyeon 11. Mina
1. Sejeong 2. Yeunjung 10. Sohye 11. Mina Sohye can do meme rap (not the rap that CL or Hyuna doo more of Bora's the idol style meme rap) and still pretty decent in vocals in contrast of her being the worst. She actually has a good tone tbh good for singing a couple of verses and her tone is a Main Vocal material (just for highnote.) and she is pretty decent idol material. Sohye isn't really a burden in the group at all Mina? Her voice is too cute. Atleast she can dance. Minaaaaa! 💓💓
God Sejeong is surely number 1! As a sesang go and watch her performances, her high and low notes can all be emotional! I recommend the twenty five twenty one performance. Not saying that Yuenjung isn't good but up till today her high notes are sometimes still straining, I think she can find a vocal coach and practise more.
probably the only one here who don't like somi's voice...something about it just sound really shrill and unpleasant to me. anyway, i totally agree with the rest of this list (especially chungha, she really needs more recognition as a vocalist)
There's some idols voices which I dislike for no particular reason or at least one that I don't get and Somi is one of them.. I don't hate her I just find her vocal timbre annoying...
ok, for those whose comparing sejeong and yeonjung, maybe for me actually why yeonjung be the number 1, is bcs she can hit those high notes while dancing which we couldn't see from sejeong so far.. take notw that SINGING WHILE DANCING IS VERY HARD.. and for those who said yeunjung is lack of emotions, go search her vid when she was singing ballads in her school(?).. and don't get me wrong, I SUPPORT ALL OF THIS 11(ELEVEN) GIRLS SOMUUCH
actually i can feel the emotion of every song that yeunjung. it's just that maybe some cant feel it or don't really tell they can feel for the Haru2 singing simply cos many affected by her sulky face. i love that. yeunjung and juna made perfect combination, its beautiful. itnw is awesome. feel? same as if i watching someone bursting her passion on the stage. and in the same place. yeah... that song simply move me. but out of many performance during the show, im really touched and cried when the low ranked girl sing My Best. that is just.... god.. i got the chills from the beginning to the end. lol sorry for the incorporate comment. but yeah im on the same page as u. 😂
high notes aren't everything... and tone wise sejeong's sounds more experienced and emotional (not saying yeunjung completely LACKS it, just less) and her tone is warmer as well
My ranking: 1.SeJeong (I just like more her tone of voice than YeunJung) 2.YeunJung (high notes goddess hahah) 3. Somi 4. Pinky 5.ChungHa 6.YooJung 7.NaYoung 8.DoYeon 9.Mina 10.ChaeYeon 11.SoHye
1. Yeunjung - you cant really deny it 2. Sejeong - God Sejeonnggg❤ 3. Chungha - amazingly stable 4. Pinky - underrated and great 5. Yoojung - as shown in her pick me evaluation 6. Somi - nice clear tone 7. Nayeon - actually very good as the rapper 8. Doyeon - not that stable but good 9. Mina - needs more work but is doing well 10. Chaeyeon - her voice seems weak 11. Sohye - she may be trying but she is still the weakest
My opinion : 1.Sejeong - no comment 2.Yeunjung - no comment 3.Somi - she is so stable / Yoojung - people look her as cute girl, but she is so talented too :) (2 of them have everything! face, sing, rap, dance, and funny lol) 5.Chungha - she can do everything too! :) 6.Doyeon / Pinky - They are good BUT this group has too many talented girls so they got low ranking. 8.Nayoung - i think she is so average at sing but still better than 3 other girls (she is rapper, ok?) 9.Chaeyeon / Mina / Sohye - they just sing like average girls at karaoke. I think chaeyeon come with face (she is SO PRETTY but this group already have so many pretty girls so face is not enough.) Mina come with cuteness (actually, i don't see it) and popularity from jellyfish stan. Sohye come with popularity from mnet editing. P.S : I like chaeyeon, mina, and sohye BUT i think they need to train more.
I still cant believe Produce 101 is where Yeonjung vocal is at the best. She can support up to C5 in Produce 101 but after that i think she has lost it.
in my opinion: 1. sejeong (because can sing in many type of music) 2. yeunjung ( yea her high note very good) 3. Somi (she can sing high note too, n her voice is very unique) 4. yoojung (she not only can sing, but she can sing rap too) 5. nayoung 6. chungha 7. pinky 8. doyeon 9. chaeyeon 10. mina 11. sohye
to be honest... i think sohye's vocal is better than mina's... she just need to be more confident cuz she can sing and dance..and people called her untalented... i dont get it... if shes 'untalented', she wont even be able to sing and dance...zzzz
1. Yeonjung 2. Sejung 3. Somi 4. Chungha 5. Yoojung 6. Pinky 7. Nayoung 8. Doyeon 9. Mina 10. Chaeyeon 11. Sohye -For all y'all who aren't familiar with reading Hangul [tbh, I winged this lmaoo so someone correct me if I'm wrong], here is the names in..I guess English in case you want to agree with this commenter lmao :)
tbh yeunjung have the best vocal in IOI and Produce 101. sejeong is great too but yeunjung high note is better. no doubt, starship have the best vocalist. yoojung should be 3/4 too and in my opinion kim doyeon is good. her voice is kinda husky and i love her voice.
I think sejeong and yeonjung have different singing styles，it is hard to compare.
yyeman leung This list makes it seem like if the singer can hit higher notes (even if they aren’t supported and don’t have an resonance), then they’re automatically a better vocalist. And I’m not hating on Yeonjung because she’s a great singer. But if we’re talking about technical aspects, then Sejeong is overall the better vocalist. The reason she can’t hit really high notes is because that’s not her range and she knows that. So when she sings, she stays within her range and supports everything. With Yeonjung, although she’s a higher range, she doesn’t support which is why sometimes it almost feels as if she’s screaming out her notes.
Lolli Polli01 no yeonjung is and i mean she trained at sm ent for a reason
JAD Entertainment What does training at SM have to do with vocal abilities? Plenty of artists have been rejected from SM, that’s a fact. But just because you train at SM, doesn’t mean that you’re automatically a better singer compared to someone who didn’t train at SM. I’m not saying that Yeonjung is a bad vocalist, because she’s not. But because her range is on the higher side, she’s often belting out her high notes, which aren’t always supported. Sometimes they sound strained, like she’s pushing so much out just to get to that note. And sometimes her high notes seem more like screams than anything. She doesn’t have the best control right now and with practice, I’m sure she’ll fix that. But being in SM doesn’t automatically mean someone is a more superior vocalist. Many people got rejected from SM and are much better vocalists than some of the ones in SM currently.
Lolli Polli01 thank you, someone finally said it!! People especially like to view vocalists as bad if they aren’t “stable”, but that doesn’t have to do with technique and how good a vocalist is. Both Sejeong and Yeonjung are not very far apart from each other, but Sejeong has a healthier technique and does not belt far from her vocal range. Although I think Yeonjung’s vibrato is more controlled and sustainable with her good breath but it does sound throaty at times.
@yeji ponytail No I'm not, got my ears checked and everything seems to be clear. :)
Also, if we're talking about belting high notes, then Yeonjung would obviously have the HIGHER note. Duh, it's because she has the higher range. But if we're talking about TECHNIQUE, then Sejeong is superior in that sense. While both females are exceptional vocalists, Sejeong has more control over her voice. She supports most, if not all, of her "high notes". Yeonjung has the higher range, which means she's most likely to get the high notes at the climax of a song. However, Yeonjung lacks the stability when SOMETIMES belts out her notes. For the most part, she can support her high notes, but I've seen instances where her notes are not supported well. They sound strained and make it seem like she's "shouting" her notes, rather than singing them.
Just because you have the higher range, doesn't mean you have the better technique. Sejeong has more control mainly because her optimal range is around the middle.
Wow, Yeonjung in Into the New World really sounded like Taeyeon. I hope she will become really famous vocalist. Her voice is something)
She sounded nothing like taeyeon
+shiningsoshirankings You could just respect their opinion that Yeonjung carried the tune just as well as Taeyeon did…
+Christian Psalms didn't say I didn't respect the opinion. Just saying, to me, she didn't sound anything like Taeyeon.............
shiningsoshirankings ikr she didn’t
Лиза Нестеренко yes.. I thing also.. But in the other song not
I think Pinky and Yoojung sing better than Somi.......
Agreed. I don't take any list serious that puts Somi ahead of them, its pure Somi bias in effect.
Meanie I agree with both of you. I had some hope for Somi after Whatta Man, but with the release of Very Very Very, I'm back to finding myself dreading her voice. I get her appeal, but I'm not a fan of her voice.
Tiểu Meow Oh wow you're so good you're probably main vocalist of every group if you entered Produce101
Meanie I think around the same
Meanie true
IMO
THE VOCAL ROYALE
1. Yeunjung (ofc)
2. Sejeong (yep. but i like the quality of her voice.)
THE LEADS
3. Somi (no doubt, but the gap betweem her amd the top two is too big.
4. Pinky //i thought she was Jeiqiong? [lol sorry i spelled it wrong]// (she was supposed to be 5th but her short high belts brought her a step higher.)
5. Chungha- (stable af, i like her voice. It's thick but doesn't have proper breathing. I like her vibrato tho)
6. Doyeon- (it can be Yoojung, but oh well.. Yoojung fits rapping... or not...just fuck it. She's here because i want to.)
THE WEAK VOCALISTS 7. Oh fucking wait. There's Yoojung- (She's a good vocalist so no way for her to land in the area below her) OR LET'S JUST CALL IT THE RAPPERS LINE
8. Chaeyeon- Yeah.. she's here.
9. Mina- She just fits rapping more, she can fucking sing in gugudan and barbie theme songs. But not in Immortal Songs or stuff. But DAMN! She raps like eminem (that's too exaggerated but i like her voice when rapping)
10.) Nayoung- RAPRAPRAPRAPRAPRAP
11.) Sohye- ..so..yeeaah.. let's leave it at that.
It's quite difficult to compare between Yeunjung and Sejung because of their different singing styles. I prefer Yeunjung but I can't deny that Sejung also sings very well and I can see her deep emotion which she puts into every emotional performance. In a word, I can rank both Yeunjung and Sejung in top 1
IDK why but Sejeong's voice sounds more pure and emotional to me. So she's my number 1
Sejeong is number one overall pitch quality tone range argh she's got it all ❤️
Awuuuu, biased amp
@@maxhiraeth5356 uta
@@maxhiraeth5356 tinuloy ko lng haha, sang ayon ako sayo
Yeonjeong is better
1. Sejeong (All around just great)
2. Yeunjung (Great with high notes, and stable)
3. Chungha (Her tone is really good and she's stable)
4. Somi (Not really a fan of her tone, but she is stable)
5. Yoojung, Pinky
6. Doyeon
7. Chaeyeon, Nayoung, Sohye (She just needs a confidence boost)
8. Mina (Just a little too cutesy, for my liking, at times, but definitely not bad)
I like SeJeong's expression, it's kinda…very touch ,with her strong vocal. Her vocal is not only high notes, it's very plump or something like she can sing low notes
Indeed
I mean Sejeong is really good, but Yeonjung is clearly better like sis-
Sejeong does have great tone and a great voice but when it comes to belting i have to give it to Yeonjung along with the husky voice. Yeunjung can just reach notes clearer and better and has really great breathing technique. Sejeong's voice is nice but she can get a little eary at times she also has great tone but 8/10 breathing technique. Overall they both have a same range only is that Yeonjung can reach higher and clearer while Sejeong voice is nicer to hear.
@@ariahri12 by range i don't think so, Sejeong sounds screamy when she hits her E5-F5 (yang hwa bridge) While Yeonjung has a clear headvoice on her F5
In my opinion
1. Yeunjung
2. Sejung
3. Chungha
4. Yoojung
5. Pinky
6. Somi
7. Doyeon
8. Nayoung
9. Mina
10. Chaeyeon
11. Sohye
Still, how can you judge a B team vocal over an A team?
Rap-wise, I think 1. Yoojung (she is the main rapper in Fantagio girlgroup anw), 2. Nayoung, 3. Maybe Chungha?, 4. Somi can pass as a rapper in this group
Agree
agree
+Minh Huong Ngo judge a B team vocal over an A team.... do you think Dani singing better than Somi in Re-Evaluation pick me :)))) and Dani in B->A team because her legs pretty and dance may well ( her position rap better than singing) and rappers, dancers go to A team not just vocal only ( Kim Juna has a great vocal but dance not well so she not go to A team). General essessment of judges based on criteria consistent with an idol. :)))) I'm Ok with your rank ( Somi have to practice and improve her singing in future) but don't say " how can you judge a B team vocal over an A team". It's inelegant :((((
+Minh Huong Ngo I agree! Pinky is more stable than Somi and Pinky get high note. Nayoung is excelente like rapper, but do'nt have a great vocal. Chungha has a great vocal. I think the weeknes is Chaeyeon because Sohye no confidence in hersef. Somi is a good singer, dancer and face, but isn't excepcional in vocal and dance to be in top 3 of vocal or dance
For me switch 1&2 and 6&7
Non bias opinion (I have no bias) In my opinion so far...
1. Yeunjung
2. Sejeong
3. Chungha (unexpectedly has a good tone/voice)
4. Yoojung (watch her Pick Me evaluation, very underrated singer)
5. Somi (sounds monotonous sometimes but stable)
6. Pinky
7. Doyeon
8. Nayoung
9-11 Chaeyeon, Mina and Sohye
Switch Yoojung with Chungha, then this list is legit.
Already did after watching them more these past 2 weeks ;)
Alex97s Oh kk. 8D
I agree with this list. I think chungha should be number 3
literally agree
Yes, yeonjung is a really good singer, she can make every performance powerful, she can hit those high notes more easily than sejeong. But the reason why I'm more drawn to sejeong is because of the sincerity that she gives to every song that she sings, the way that she portrays the emotions in the songs, even without hitting those high notes, she slays.
My ranking:
1. Yeonjung, Sejeong (Yeonjung voice is very powerful while Sejeong's is very emotional and I personally can't pick between the two)
2. Chungha (Her voice is pleasing to the ears and powerful as well)
3. Yoojung, Somi (They both have good tones while also being a bit powerful)
4. Doyeon, Nayoung, Kyulkyung (They have good tones though their voices are a bit softer and less powerful and I feel like if they do higher notes their voice can crack and become unstable)
5. Sohye, Chaeyeon, Mina (Their singing is not the best since their voices is unstable and weak but there can be rooms for improvements and their voices can have a lot of potential)
*I'm not a vocal coach or trainer of any kinds I just wanted to express my thoughts about their singing and everyone has their own opinions.
Yoonjeung may have a greater vocal range but Sejeong has musicality. They're both equal in terms of technicalities but Sejeong's musicality and musicianship gives her the slight upper hand.
Edi sejeong ka na. Bat di na lang kasi sila iappreciate ng pantay
@@maxhiraeth5356 Girl, na sa ranking vid ka what did you expect? Muntanga lang. And this was 4 years ago, move on.
HAKHAK GG
PILIPINONG ALIMASAG
@@maxhiraeth5356 Di mo ikinaganda kabiterran mo kay Sejeong. Mukha kang virus, Girl. ❤️
i feel like this isn't a vocal skills/depth list but rather who can sing higher than who which in most cases doesn't make you a better VOCALIST. i'm not even sejeong biased but she has my favorite tone in ioi. the other's voices are pretty girl group standard (that doesnt mean bad or worse, just expectable and more common) while sejeong's is more what you'd find in an experienced soloist. just my opinion.
good!!
Agree ! Sejeong has more control in tune and rhyme compare to yeunjung !!!!
+Hannah Đỗ Yunjeong has a really goodvoice, and she can hold some amazing high notes, but I agree with you Sejeong is overall a better singer.
Now people should seriously distinguish the difference between a vocal ranking (voice color, sincerity, technique, power) and a high note ranking. I agree with you, for me Sejeong's vocal is better
Yahhh the list just shows the ranking pf voice pitch dahell...
Based on my vocal analysis, a few of them are really similar.
11.Mina - no technique
10-9.Sohye - no confidence in her singing
9-10.Chaeyeon - nasal
8-7.Nayoung
7-8.Yoojung
6-5.Doyoung
5-6. Kyulkyung
4-3.Somi
3-4.Chungha
2-Sejung
1-Yeonjung
i agree with you completely except for yoojung, she deserves 5th imo
Agree
Doyoon** ^^
Doyeon*** lol cx
+baebae i personally feel like nasally tones are sometimes more interesting and doesn't necessarily mean worse vocals but other than that and the fact that i like sejung's full mid range voice more than yeunjung's high range voice my list is same as yours
1. Yu Yeonjung 💕
2. Kim Sejeong 💕
3. Kim Chungha 💕
4. Pinky(Joo Kyeolkyeong) 💕
5. Yoojung 💕
6. Doyeon 💕
7. Somi 💕
8. Nayoung 💕
9. Mina 💕
10. Chaeyeon 💕
11. Sohye 💕
Totally agreed
Agreed
Doyeon above Somi??
kpop gg fan yes
@@lisahan1043 that's strange.
1. Sejeong ( unique, emotional )- yeunjung ( strong (high notes) )
3. Somi ( unique, clear)- yoojung ( stable)- chungha ( stable)- pinky ( stable)
7. nayoung, doyeon (clear)
9. Chaeyeon, Mina, sohye ( cute)
Ppl need to look on more good sides than dissing
+apink soul like this comment
I agree
If you watch P101 YU YEUNGJONG GOT FIRST GOOD SINGER .
+Eriee Chan 1st? didn't she got the 11 place?
Sejeong vocal is more well-developed in all register. her mixed voice is relatively better than the rest of IOIs. her lower and higher register are good. Yeunjung register are not really developed. her high note make her standout since her mixed voice is headier and not connected.
I know Yeonjung supports up to B4 and some C5's were supported. But I'm not sure about Sejeong. You know that?
@@5642466deMG OP already said that Yeonjung's high notes are good. That doesn't mean her mixed voice nor her lower register is well developed. Just look at Yeonjung trying to sing Western Sky on Weekly Idol. She struggles a lot with lower notes
Now she has proved that she can be good at low notes in the same weekly idol if want u can watch it
i kinda feel like the only edge yeonjung has over sejeong is that she has a wider vocal range but other than that, sejeong is better. yeonjung often strains her high notes and she lacks support, which results to her high notes often sounding like screams. sejeong on the other hand has support and has better technique and musicality, overall. always take note that high notes do not define who's the better vocalist :))
Really agreed, also sejeong can resonance until B4.
Although ppl say sejeong is capable of high notes too I think Yeunjung still pull them off better and her high pitch has more depth tbh Yeunjung reminds me of taeyeon while sejeong reminds me of eunji..
i watched
Yea sure does have a higher pitch than Sejeong but its vocals that were talking here and not who hits the highest note
agree
Troll Face I am saying sejeong's vocal is not better than yeunjung, you can say equivalent.
+aimee e. exactly. Sejeong is reeeaaaaally good, but high notes queen is without a doubt, Yeonjung. Plus, her voice is amazingly stable and very very powerful even when dancing.
1.Yeonjung/Sejeong
2.Chungha
3.Yoojung/Kyulkyung
4.Doyeon/Somi
5.Nayoung
6.Mina
7.Chaeyeon
8.Sohye
AGREE
Agree with everything except Yeonjung and Sejeong sharing the top spot. I think they are both incredibly vocalists, but I think Yeonjung is better. She's just gifted.
YAAAAAS.
Mina 1(twice)
And
Mina2(ioi)
вотафак ауе ты русский ура
Personally I feel Sejeong should be number 1, because vocal ability incorporates more that being able to pull off high notes very well. I feel making an emotional connection vocally is what makes a singer more powerful. But, yeonjung is still relatively young and can still learn to add that to her already impressive vocal ability!
my i.o.i vocal ranking! ✨
1. sejeong
2. yeonjung
3. chungha
4. yoojung
5. somi
6. pinky
7. nayoung
8. doyeon
9. mina
10. chaeyeon
11. sohye
Agree but I think Yeunjung is better
I think Pinky sings better than somi
For me its:
1. yeunjung
2. Seojung
3. Chungha
4. Pinky, Yoojung, Somi
7. Doyeon
8. Nayoung
9. Mina, Chaeyon, Sohye, Sohye has really improved so i don't think she's worse than mina or Chaeyeon.
GirlFromSea Oh I think I agree with your idea. Pinky, Yoojung and Somi I can't judge who is better than others 2 haha, but I think Somi's voice is stronger and more unique than others 2.
i think i like yoojungs better....but then Pinky really impresses me in these newer songs...but then Somi also totally impresses me with each new song xD so...still tied hahahah
GirlFromSea I agree with Pinky, Yoojung, and Somi being on the same level; I think they can all hit the same notes, just depends on whose tone you prefer
1Yeunjung
2Sejeong
3Doyeon
4Chaeyeon
5Chungha
6Somi
7Yoojung
8Pinky
9Nayoung
10Sohye
11Mina
our yeunjung has powerful and sweet honey voice. melting~
(commented on another before, and this is in no particular order)
Sejeong (Better support, plus better range doesn't mean better vocalist)
Yeunjung (Awesome high notes but you can hear the evident strain :') )
Chungha (Has a nice tone, can even reach main vocalist level high notes as seen in Crush OT7 ver.)
Yoojung (Nice tone, stable, one of my favorite timbres in I.O.I)
Somi (Quite good for her age, able to do runs and high notes as well, just lacks emotion... But a nice and warm tone overall + Stable)
Kyulkyung (Can sound a bit nasally at times, but a decent vocalist? Stable but lacks proper technique? She hits her high notes in Whatta Man with falsetto in lives)
Doyeon (I personally don't like her tone, it sounds VERY nasally compared to Kyulkyung. Her falsettos are pleasant though.)
Nayoung (I like her falsettos. Her normal singing voice is kinda... Eh. But then again, she's okay. Her high notes are hit with falsettos in lives as well, like Kyulkyung's)
Sohye (Nice tone if trained properly. Lacks stability, but her falsettos are good for a non idol trainee. If she trains more I'm sure she'd rank quite high on the list.)
Chaeyeon (Bland tone, not much stability... Weak vocalist. HOWEVER, if trained well, I think she can be a good lead vocal.)
Mina (Nasally and no support at all. Is more suited for rap.)
So... My ranking is:
1. Sejeong
2. Yeunjung
3. Chungha
4. Yoojung
5. Somi/Kyulkyung
6. Somi/Kyulkyung
7. Doyeon
8. Nayoung
9. Sohye
10. Chaeyeon
11. Mina
Trueeee
Your ranking is surprisingly accurate
Perfect
Sejeong biased kasi eh hays
but i think doyeon changed her tone
1. YeonJung( I love her highnote in Into the new world)
2. Sejeong (Her voice is very sweet)
3 Chungha (She can be main vocalist)
4 Pinky( I think she has a good voice)
5. Somi
6 Yoojung
7 Doyeon
8 Nayoung
9 Mina
10 Sohye
11 Chaeyeon
Sejeong sings so weelll (great technique/control) and singers who can put such raw emotions to a song is what make the song so beautiful... So sejeong is no. 1 for me (and I'm a Sesang hehe)
doyeon should be a lil bit higher
agree
ikr
totally agree
Mariz Castañeda doyeon my bae
Agree
this is based on my opinion,
1. Sejeong (love her vocal soooo freakin much)
2. yeunjung (her high notes is very very amazing)
3. chungha (her voice is so sweet to hear)
4. yoojung (she is stable when singing and dancing)
5. somi (sometimes she is not stable but it's ok she's still so young)
6. pinky (she is rlly amazing)
7. doyeon (she has a good vocal)
8. nayoung (i love her rap so much)
9-11. mina chaeyeon sohye.
Sinta Rizki Agustin same
Sinta Rizki Agustin i my opinion pinky and yoojung are about the same
Even though this is not a favourable, I must say Sejeong has the best vocal skills among them. She has a better control with pleasant notes. Yeunjung's high notes are fine, but often she used too much power and overpushed her voice when hitting high notes (which people usually feel the notes sound 'stronger'?!). This will eventually hurt her voice... Plus her strength is limited to high notes, her lower register is not as good. No offense, just saying as someone who learns singing.
In My Opinion
1. Sejeong (I Like Sejeong Voice than Yeunjung)
2. Yeunjung (I Like Her High Note)
3. Somi
4. Chungha
5. Pinky
6. Yujeong
7. Doyeon
8. Nayoung
9. Chaeyeon
10. Mina
11. Sohye (She's The Weakest)
sohye can rap now
+Aina Izzaty I Think She Can't Rap Sorry
I Think Park/Jeon Soyeon Should Be A Part of IOI Instead Sohye
+Ananda Rizky Cannot agree with this more
agree
agree
technical skill (vocal range/control)
1. yeunjung - her range and natural talent is unbelievable
2. sejeong - also amazing range and control
3. chungha - stable and if she really hit those high notes in bang bang, daaamn
4. nayoung - it's less about her range, but she has made very few if any mistakes, her breathing is stable; though her voice isn't naturally loud
5. somi - when I first got into pd101 I thought she was #1 bc of popularity, but she's actually very stable too
6. yoojung - stable w/ great control over her comfortable range, her vocal tone works with lots of genres
7. doyeon - wasn't too impressed with la cha ta and she didn't sing in bang bang or had many parts with ioi but she was great in itsp. I feel like she has a lot more to show
8. pinky - she's stable too but sometimes she strains a little? like she only uses her throat voice. but since she's not a native korean speaker, she is very impressively fluent (and her vocal tone is nice to listen to). she is in no way a bad singer
9. chaeyeon - for a vocalist, and a vocalist who's debuted, I felt that she was lacking. uh i think she needs to project her voice and work on her breathing? again, she hasn't had too many parts in ioi so I'd like to hear more of her
10. mina - she hasn't really stood out to me in terms of singing. with a bit more practice and more parts in songs, she'll definitely improve
11. sohye - well, of course she never was intended to become an idol and her improvement has been insane. I didn't think much of it during the show but in hip song and yum yum, she was a lot better than before. I hope ymc are giving her vocal training because it'd be a waste of her potential not to
in terms of my personal preference, I loooove sejeong's performance of irony. sejeong in irony alone is my number 1 tbh. I also like somi, pinky and doyeon's vocal colours, so they'd be higher up. nayoung's lack of loudness is similar to chaeyeon's so she'd be lower down but the fact she's so high up even tho she's a rapper is amazing.
people criticised the final lineup for being too full of visuals but I think the members have strong vocals too; if you think about it, only chaeyeon and sohye have never been ranked A. I just wish there were another rapper or two; cathy or either of the two soyeons would've fit in.
I think Sejeong deserves the top spot. I'm not biased, but based on how the judges evaluate her voice, she's got the range and the musicality. She can also adlibs at the right time... Also Yeonjung has that soft voice that's why it sounds slightly better. Still, just my opinion, Sejeong, for me, deserves the top spot.
Sejeong is better than Yeunjung for me. But I also like Yeunjung's voice that much. I feel like Sejeong's voice is something..
ikr
1. yeunjung 2. sejeong 3. somi 4. pinky 5. yoojung 6. chungha 7. doyeon 8. nayoung 9. mina 10. chaeyeon 11. sohye
Mine is
1. Yeunjung, her high note was just so WOW
2. Sejeong, her power vocal and her feel sometime make me got goosebump
3. Yoojung, no matter she's a good rapper, she also a good singer. As Ryan said, that Yoojung has a main vocal quality
4. Somi, her voice for me, is thick (?) like tiffany's voice, but just thinner than tiffany's. I confused for make her on the third or fourth place, but i choose in fourth place.
5. Pinky/Chungha, okay, i confused about them. Sometime Pinky is better than Chungha and sometime Chungha is better than Pinky. So i took them in the same place.
6. Chungha/Pinky
7. Sohye, she has improved so much than before. So i took her in the seventh place.
8. Doyeon, her voice is good
9. Nayoung, maybe she's a rapper, but her voice sometime can be so soft as a singer.
10. Mina, she's not good at sing, i think. Because her voice like a child(?). but her voice is good
11. Chaeyeon, her voice is good too.
I'm not a fan but i think no.1 is sejeong i love her voice it's so high and beautiful 😊
I got goosebump when sejeong part 🥺🥺 eomma
this is my ranking:
1. Sejeong
2. YeunJung
3. Yoojung
In my opinion, Yeun Jung can sing high notes, but Sejeong can too. Even Sejeong also expreses her ability of singing more perfect than Yeun jung. I believe that in the future, Sejeong will become a very famous main vocal, maybe even as Taeyeon.
SEJEONG Hwaiting >
1.yeunjung
2.sejeong
3.chungha
4.yoojung
5.kyulkyeong
6.doyeon
7.somi (she has loads of time to improve shes only 15 and her voice hasnt even fully developed!!)
8.nayoung
9.sohye
10.chaeyeon
11.mina
I think Kim se Jeong is the best like my opinion
For me is something like this
11- Mina (she just sing like someone cute in the karaoke)
10- Sohye (is afraid to make mistakes, no confidence in her singing)
9- Chaeyeon (I like her nasal voice but isn't too powerful)
8- Nayoung (idol's rap, nothing out of the ordinary)
7- Doyeon (she has a soft voice that insurance could be overcome with more training)
6- Pinky (she's my bias, but need more vocal training)
5- Yoojung (u should see the individual evaluation of "pick me" if you don't agree)
4- Somi
3- Chungah
2- Sejeong
1- Yeunjung
Chungha 5
Yoojung 4
Somi 3
I'm somi stan but i have to say chungha vocal better than somi :)))
+Karla Chingu nono Chungha is main in the IOI unit. She is good at singing!!!!!
agree!
Cury Schulz omg i totally agree with you!!)
For me
1. Sejeong
2. Yeonjung
3. Chungha
4. Yoojung/Pinky
5. Somi/Doyeon
6. Nayoung
7. Sohye
8. Chaeyeon
9. Mina
High notes are so overrated and is no indication that youre really great if u can pull put high notes. Its just that u have higher range.
Sejeong #1 singing
To me Sejeong deserve the 1st place
her low tone voice can be fitted to various styles song, such as
kpop music(eg crush, Irony),
slow or romantic music(eg When the cherry blossoms fade, Yanghwa Bridge)
And her voice even suits rapping too
Her voice has higher plasticity than yeonjung,
Yeonjung is good at singing high notes but she always sings the same type of songs, I think the Rock n Roll music and rap are not suitable to her
Yeonjung has a limit voice while Sejeong can sing mostly e everything.
💖
My ranking:
1. Sejeong 💖
2. Yeonjung
3. Chungha
4. Kyulkyung/Pinky
5. Yoojung
6. Somi
7. Nayoung
8. Doyeon
9. Chaeyeon
10. Sohye
11. Mina
yep
For me the vocal ranking goes like this:
1. Sejeong (I prefer her voice more than Yeunjung's, it's just that Yeunjung is the one who keep hitting the high notes)
2. Yeunjung (her high notes: THUMBS UP)
3. Somi
4. Yoojung
5. Jieqiong
6. Chungha
7. Doyeon
8. Nayoung
9. Mina
10. Chaeyeon
11. Sohye
I feel the same!!! This is my ranking exactly
me too!@
I can't distinguish between 1&2 becuz the one has a good technique and control in singing while the one is good with high note but for other ranking 3-10 , it is the same opinion !!!
Sejeong !!
***** I actually have changed my ranking from 3-11 after listening some more :) and yes for me Chungha and Yoojung are the best vocals after Sejeong and Yeunjung.
1.Yeonjung
2.Sejeong
3.Chungha
4.Yoojung
5.Pinky
6.Somi
7.Doyeon
8.Nayoung
9.Chaeyeon
10.Mina
11.Sohye
i'm into this more than the one you mentioned
My ranking:
1. Yeunjung
2. Sejung
3. Pinky
4. Chungha
5. Somi
6. Yoojung
7. Doyeon
8. Nayoung
9. Mina
10. Chaeyeon
11. Sohye
I feel like Pinky, Chungha, and Doyeon are so underrated in terms of their vocal abilities. I think most people just focus on Chungha's amazing dance abilities that they forget how stable she is. And Pinky and Doyeon are known for their visual, so people forget that they can actually sing.
Did you hear Sejeong singing "if I ain't got you"?
ruclips.net/video/-J0utQ8ijJY/видео.html
Her voice is so unique, stable and powerful!
And more others such as "love the way you lie"....
Yeonjung' voice is powerful on doing high note only, her voice is not special while singing coda, you can search the "IOI- hip song", then you will find Sejeong has a more recognizable voice@@
my list :
1-sejung (its good to hear for long time and my style )
2-yeunjung (high note and super powerful voice )
3-chungha
4-somi
5-yoojung
6-pinky
7-doyeon
8-nayoung
9-chayeon
10-mina
11-sohye
For me:
1. YeunJung "hightnote- Main vocal"
2. Sejeong "bass note
- Main vocal"
3. Somi "Lead vocalist"
4. Chungha "Lead vocalist"
5. Pinky "cute"
6. YooJung "Lead vocalist" but she sings very "DRY"
7. Nayoung "Vocalist"
8. Doyeon "Vocalist"
9. Mina "Vocalist"
10. Chaeyeon "Vocalist"
11.Sohye "vocalist"
Lol no. Sejeong can't hit bass.
bass is like too low. lol. how can she hit bass? i can barely hit a bass note and im a guy.
I agree but I think Chungha is three
agree. somi 3
+the Visionary I think he/she is saying that she's the lower main vocal
1. Yeunjung
2. Sejeong
3. Chungha
4. Kyulkyung, Yoojung, Somi
5. Doyeon, Nayoung
6. Mina, Sohye, Chaeyeon
My opinion
1.Yeunjung
2.Sejung
3.Somi
4.Yoojung
5.Pinky
6.Chungha
7.Nayoung
8.Doyeon
9.Mina
10.Chaeyeon
11.Sohye
Agree
pinky is better than yoojung in terms in singing because pinky is stable and csn hit highnotes while yoojung is stable too but only in low register... but i love them both
+DramaQueen agreed. i actually find pinky and chungha on par because pinky is stable. but chungha's is towards adlib but weaker, (more towards subvocals) i would put yoojung after chungha because shes more balance but no adlib
I agree!
agree..
for me
1.sejeong 2.yeunjung 3.yoojung 4.somi 5.chungha 6.pinky 7.doyeon 8.chaeyeon 9.nayoung 10.mina 11.sohye
1. Yeonjung
2. Sejeong
3. Chungha
4. Yoojung
5. Pinky
6. Doyeon
7. Somi
8. Nayoung
9-11 Mina/Sohye/Chaeyeon
Clearly Doyeon > Somi. Anyone else wanna argue otherwise should first explain to me how Doyeon gets promoted to Group A during PD101 while Somi drops to Group B when *arguably* Somi's dance is better than Doyeon's.
FollowNRBH in the video for pick me evaluation, somi did not have energy in the starting that's why the instructor pulled her out. i think somi is more stable for sure. i think her vocals is better in Yum Yum as compared to Do Yeon in at the same place as Do Yeon breathing technique is not as good.
I like the sound of Doyeon's voice better, but Somi is more stable and fluid
AGREEEEE SUPER AGREE
This is my opinion okay 😉💕
1. Yeonjung (this is obvious)
2. Sejeong (i love her voice)
3. Chungha (she is very stable)
4. Kyulkyung (she is not a korean but i love her pronounciation)
5. Yoojung (she is very stable)
6. Doyeon (she's also stable)
7. Somi (i don't know why people rank her so high but i'm sure she can improve 😉)
8. Nayoung (i love her rappp)
9. Sohye (she needs some training and i'm sure she will become a great singer)
10. Mina (she will improve one day )
11. Chaeyeon (she's not stable but i'm sure she will improve)
I am not being biased but this is just my opinion. If I'm being biased , I would put my Yoojung first 💕
MY OPINION:
1) Yeonjung
2) Sejeong
3) Chungha
4) Yoojung
5) Pinky
6) Nayoung
7) Doyeon
8) Somi
9) Mina
10) Chaeyeon
11) Sohye
In my opinion
1. Yeunjung
2. Sejeong
3. Chungha
4. Pinky
5. Somi
6. Yoojung
7. Doyeon
8. Nayoung
9. Mina
10. Chaeyeon
11. Sohye
Sejeong first for me! Tbh all yeong jung has is high notes I hear it everywhere in girl groups she lacks the mature sentiment that Sejeong has and I think that is more prize worthy. That's why yeong jung is more an idol singer and sejeong a musician quality.
+kimmo chia Yes! I mentioned this in my comment too, I find all of Yeunjungs notes sound the same (though they're amazing), whereas Sejeongs notes have a sort of flavour to them and always manage to give me chills
+kimmo chia really agree with you, Sejeong has that emotion , but i dont feel the same with yeongjung voice
+suci purnamasari yeah exactly! Not that she isn't amazing because she is but I find Sejeongs high notes always sound different and have a depth to them I just can't find in the other girls
+Charlene Tan is that not what I'm saying? Because I'm pretty sure that's what we're implying
+Charlene Tan I never said Sejeong is BETTER of a singer? I said I prefer the way she carries herself and the way in which she uses her voice and vocal range while she's singing. I think you're getting the wrong impression
my preference will be
1) YeunJung
2) Sejeong
3) Somi
4) Pinky
5) Chungha
6) Yoojung
7) Nayoung
8)Doyeon
9)Chaeyeon
10)Mina
11)Sohye
Sohye doesnt sound horrid, (watch Hip Song 2016 @ sugarman) its just because she is last though, its just more of preference of song genre.
pinky's voice is stable but safe. Whereas Chungha is adlib but not strong enough like sejeong
Yoojung rap is swag to be honest, she hasnt unleash her full strength.
FACTS
1. Produce 101 Position Eval. (VOCAL)
Sejeong 406 votes
Yeonjung 317 votes
2. I.O.I - All title tracks line distribution
Sejeong ~131.5s / 17.5%
Yeonjung ~104.6s / 13.9%
3. Best Solo Song
Sejeong
"Flower Way" took 1st place on all Korea charts , won MBC Show! Champion
7.4M+ views on dingo music's RUclips channel
Yeonjung
"Marry You“
790K+ views on dingo music's RUclips channel
4. KpopVocalAnalysis Score
Sejeong 3.0
Yeonjung 2.5
5. "The King of Mask Singer" Best Record
Sejeong
April 9, 2019: episode winner, one win away from the crown
Yeonjung
Jan 1, 2017: 2nd round
... and people still think Yeonjung is a better singer because "she sings better high notes" #facepalm
PEOPLE STILL USE THE TERM SEJEONG BIASED IFYOU PREFER HER LMAO
@@nvm1648 so true then they would listen if you explain about this cause they only believe what they want to believe. 🤣🤣
I love Yeonjung 💕
I prefer Sejeong's singing to Yeunjung's cuz I find it more emotional. But I think Mina sings well right? From the first episode, she always stands at the position of vocal. When I watched 24 hours, I was surprised by her power. Strong dancing and singing together but she still could control her voice so well.
i think sejeong voice is more soft and elegant, and her tone is thinner which makes her hit higher notes easier than yeonjung. yeonjung on the other hand, has a stronger tone as a thicker one, so her vocal is more powerful and loud. she too can hit high notes but is limited by the thick tone, but pulls it off really good! overall I think both girls are excellent singers and lets all support them in their future! :D
vocal:
1. sejeong & yeonjung
2. chungha
3. yoojung
4. doyeon & pinky
5. nayoung
6. somi
7. mina & chaeyeon
8. sohye
for me
1. Sejeong
2. Yeonjung
3. Chungha
4. Yoojung
5. Pinky or Somi
6. Somi or Pinky
7. Doyeon
8. Nayoung
9. Chaeyeon or Sohye (she just no confidence but she is pretty good)
10. Sohye or Chaeyeon
11. Mina
Agreeeee
I think yeonjung is the best singer, but i prefer sejeongs voice
1. Sejeong
2. Yeunjung
10. Sohye
11. Mina
Sohye can do meme rap (not the rap that CL or Hyuna doo more of Bora's the idol style meme rap) and still pretty decent in vocals in contrast of her being the worst. She actually has a good tone tbh good for singing a couple of verses and her tone is a Main Vocal material (just for highnote.) and she is pretty decent idol material. Sohye isn't really a burden in the group at all
Mina? Her voice is too cute. Atleast she can dance. Minaaaaa! 💓💓
good
I think 1. Yeunjung!!! She's vocal so stable!
Loyal Penguin I agree. it's just Sohye isn't confident in singing
God Sejeong is surely number 1! As a sesang go and watch her performances, her high and low notes can all be emotional! I recommend the twenty five twenty one performance. Not saying that Yuenjung isn't good but up till today her high notes are sometimes still straining, I think she can find a vocal coach and practise more.
1. SEJEONG
probably the only one here who don't like somi's voice...something about it just sound really shrill and unpleasant to me. anyway, i totally agree with the rest of this list (especially chungha, she really needs more recognition as a vocalist)
Her voice reminds me of justin bieber " Baby". I dont like her voice, it makes me feel uncomfortable.
+HongAnh Jung LOL I DIDNT THINK OF THIS BEFORE U SAID IT
It's because she's 15yo, she sounds like how a child would sound.
There's some idols voices which I dislike for no particular reason or at least one that I don't get and Somi is one of them.. I don't hate her I just find her vocal timbre annoying...
yeonjung is better as a singer objectively but i like sejeong's tone/voice a lot more
I think is:
1. Yeunjung
2. Sejeong
3. Chungha
4. Somi
5. Yoojung
6. Pinky
7. Nayoung
8. Doyeon
9. Mina
10. Chaeyon
11. Sohye
But that's just my opinion 😄
Suci Fitriani Totally agree
i agree for the ranking at that point but three years later doyeon has improved a lot and i would put her between kyulkyung and yoojung now
1-Yeonjung
2-Sejeong
3-Chungha
4-Somi
5-Pinky
6-Yoojung
7-Doyeon
8-Nayoung
9-mina,chaeyon,sohye
1. YeunJung
2. SeJeong
3. ChungHa
4. Somi
5. YooJung
6. DoYeon
7. Pinky
8. NaYoung
9. Mina
10. ChaeYeon
11. SoHye
Just my opinion😂
Not to be dramatic but Yeonjung invented singing
gosh .... Taeyeon + Tiffany = Yeunjung .... hmmmm :/
*Yeonjung No.1* ❤
For me:
Yeonjung
Sejeong
Chungha
Yoojung
Somi
Pinky
Doyeon
Nayoung
Mina
Chayeon
Sohye
Just "my" opinion
1. Yeonjung
2. Sejeong
3. chungha
4. Yoojung
5. Somi
6. Pinky
7. Doyeon
8. Nayoung
9. Mina
10. Chaeyeon
11. Sohye
Sejeong's irony fancam 😍💜💜💜💜
for me it's
1. Yeonjung
2. Sejeong
3. Chungha
4. Yoojung & Kyulkyung
6. Somi
7. Doyeon & Mina
9. Chaeyeon & Nayoung
11. Sohye
ok, for those whose comparing sejeong and yeonjung, maybe for me actually why yeonjung be the number 1, is bcs she can hit those high notes while dancing which we couldn't see from sejeong so far.. take notw that SINGING WHILE DANCING IS VERY HARD.. and for those who said yeunjung is lack of emotions, go search her vid when she was singing ballads in her school(?)..
and don't get me wrong, I SUPPORT ALL OF THIS 11(ELEVEN) GIRLS SOMUUCH
actually i can feel the emotion of every song that yeunjung. it's just that maybe some cant feel it or don't really tell they can feel for the Haru2 singing simply cos many affected by her sulky face. i love that. yeunjung and juna made perfect combination, its beautiful. itnw is awesome. feel? same as if i watching someone bursting her passion on the stage. and in the same place. yeah... that song simply move me. but out of many performance during the show, im really touched and cried when the low ranked girl sing My Best. that is just.... god.. i got the chills from the beginning to the end. lol sorry for the incorporate comment.
but yeah im on the same page as u. 😂
agree
high notes aren't everything... and tone wise sejeong's sounds more experienced and emotional (not saying yeunjung completely LACKS it, just less) and her tone is warmer as well
I
Agree
My ranking:
1.SeJeong (I just like more her tone of voice than YeunJung)
2.YeunJung (high notes goddess hahah)
3. Somi
4. Pinky
5.ChungHa
6.YooJung
7.NaYoung
8.DoYeon
9.Mina
10.ChaeYeon
11.SoHye
1. Yeonjung
2. Sejeong(bias)
3. Chungha
4. Yoojung
5. Kyulkyung
6. Doyeon
7. Somi (bias)
8. Nayoung
9. Sohye
10. Mina
11. Chaeyeon
1. Yeunjung - you cant really deny it
2. Sejeong - God Sejeonnggg❤
3. Chungha - amazingly stable
4. Pinky - underrated and great
5. Yoojung - as shown in her pick me evaluation
6. Somi - nice clear tone
7. Nayeon - actually very good as the rapper
8. Doyeon - not that stable but good
9. Mina - needs more work but is doing well
10. Chaeyeon - her voice seems weak
11. Sohye - she may be trying but she is still the weakest
My opinion :
1.Sejeong - no comment
2.Yeunjung - no comment
3.Somi - she is so stable / Yoojung - people look her as cute girl, but she is so talented too :) (2 of them have everything! face, sing, rap, dance, and funny lol)
5.Chungha - she can do everything too! :)
6.Doyeon / Pinky - They are good BUT this group has too many talented girls so they got low ranking.
8.Nayoung - i think she is so average at sing but still better than 3 other girls (she is rapper, ok?)
9.Chaeyeon / Mina / Sohye - they just sing like average girls at karaoke.
I think chaeyeon come with face (she is SO PRETTY but this group already have so many pretty girls so face is not enough.)
Mina come with cuteness (actually, i don't see it) and popularity from jellyfish stan.
Sohye come with popularity from mnet editing.
P.S : I like chaeyeon, mina, and sohye BUT i think they need to train more.
WHAT? Somi & Yoojung are better than Chungha? Lol
I still cant believe Produce 101 is where Yeonjung vocal is at the best.
She can support up to C5 in Produce 101 but after that i think she has lost it.
in my opinion:
1. sejeong (because can sing in many type of music)
2. yeunjung ( yea her high note very good)
3. Somi (she can sing high note too, n her voice is very unique)
4. yoojung (she not only can sing, but she can sing rap too)
5. nayoung
6. chungha
7. pinky
8. doyeon
9. chaeyeon
10. mina
11. sohye
to be honest... i think sohye's vocal is better than mina's... she just need to be more confident cuz she can sing and dance..and people called her untalented... i dont get it... if shes 'untalented', she wont even be able to sing and dance...zzzz
The top 3 are Yeonjung,Sejung and Chungha,it is obvious...
it's really hard to pick between sejeong and yeunjung
1.유연정
2.김세정
3.전소미
4.김청하
5.최유정
6.주결경
7.임나영
8.김도연
9.강미나
10.정채연
11.김소혜
1. Yeonjung
2. Sejung
3. Somi
4. Chungha
5. Yoojung
6. Pinky
7. Nayoung
8. Doyeon
9. Mina
10. Chaeyeon
11. Sohye
-For all y'all who aren't familiar with reading Hangul [tbh, I winged this lmaoo so someone correct me if I'm wrong], here is the names in..I guess English in case you want to agree with this commenter lmao :)
tbh yeunjung have the best vocal in IOI and Produce 101. sejeong is great too but yeunjung high note is better. no doubt, starship have the best vocalist. yoojung should be 3/4 too and in my opinion kim doyeon is good. her voice is kinda husky and i love her voice.
My opinion
1.yeonjung
2.sejeong
3.chungha
4.somi
5.yoojung
6.jieqiong
7.doyeon
8.nayoung
9.mina
10.chaeyeon
11.sohye
제 의견일 뿐입니당
1.연정
2.세정
3.유정
4.청하
5.소미
6.결경
7.나영
8.도연
9.미나
10.채연
11.소혜
1. Sejeong
2. Yeonjung
3. Chungha
4. Yoojung
5. Pinky
6. Doyeon
7. Somi
8. Nayoung
9. Chaeyeon
10. Sohye
11. Mina