Inside the Mind of an Australian Criminal | Full Episode

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 дек 2018
  • This chilling CIA episode details the long and difficult investigation which began with the disappearance of 18-year-old secretary Sarah Spiers from a night club in the up-market Perth suburb of Claremont on Australia Day, 1996.
    ----
    Hosted by respected journalist, Steve Liebmann, CIA uncovers the true stories behind these cases through chilling re-enactments and access to the key detectives, family members and witnesses involved.
    ----
    Welcome to Banijay Crime, the ultimate destination for true crime fans! Our RUclips channel features the best true crime documentaries and crime series from around the world, including the UK's top crime documentary series.
    Our channel provides a captivating insight into true crime stories, offering a wide range of crime documentaries and murder documentaries for your viewing pleasure. Whether you're a die-hard fan of the true crime TV genre or simply looking for the best crime series to watch, we've got you covered. Our collection of true crime documentary series features some of the most intriguing cases from around the globe, including the UK's most notorious murder cases.
    So, if you're looking for the best crime documentary series, look no further than Banijay Crime. Subscribe to our channel today and be the first to watch the most gripping true crime stories from the UK and beyond. Don't miss out on the best crime documentaries and murder documentaries - click on this link www.youtube.com/@BanijayCrime... to subscribe now!
    #truecrime #crimedocumentary #crimeinvestigation
  • РазвлеченияРазвлечения

Комментарии • 925

  • @joeytribbianicore
    @joeytribbianicore 4 года назад +175

    That lady who stayed with her body made me cry. What a beautiful and simple way to show humanity and love.

    • @alittlebitofeverything2968
      @alittlebitofeverything2968 3 года назад +4

      @@stevechristie2569 I would say NO Bc as much as you would want to say that she should stay with her anyone who has worked in law enforcement or has any clue of forensic evidence would know that they are contaminating the crime scene. Which this was probably the secondary scene.

    • @jaymonte3972
      @jaymonte3972 3 года назад +2

      @@alittlebitofeverything2968 The lady who stayed with the body would have been in danger if the killer returned.

    • @alittlebitofeverything2968
      @alittlebitofeverything2968 3 года назад +2

      @@jaymonte3972 true. I was looking at it from an investigative stand point

    • @alittlebitofeverything2968
      @alittlebitofeverything2968 3 года назад +2

      @@stevechristie2569 when I made the account I’m 30 now

    • @alittlebitofeverything2968
      @alittlebitofeverything2968 3 года назад +4

      @@jaymonte3972 dang u deleted u comment quick lol I was working couldn’t respond

  • @Twinkie989
    @Twinkie989 5 лет назад +525

    The young men who wanted to protect her that first night and the woman who guarded her body... restoring my faith in humanity.

    • @robincharles7057
      @robincharles7057 5 лет назад +71

      Christina Reynolds The sorry at the end is kinda pointless and meaningless. If you were sorry you could of just hit backspace and cleared the crappy comment instead of being a dick.

    • @thekylehiltonband6087
      @thekylehiltonband6087 4 года назад +58

      The young man that suggested going back should have listened to his gut.
      That feeling you have that something
      Isn't right, that you can't quite put your finger on..
      That's your subconscious picking up on subtle clues, that you may not be able to explain, or quantify..
      The way the car moved, or even just negative energy..
      Always listen to your gut.

    • @HerrMikael
      @HerrMikael 4 года назад +19

      @Christina Reynolds You might be right in your criticism, but you're being a bit rude. Haven't gotten any for a while, have you?

    • @poposo7651
      @poposo7651 4 года назад +25

      @Christina Reynolds your entitled to have your own opinions....but please no need to be rude or insult others...

    • @jenisbetzke6228
      @jenisbetzke6228 4 года назад +2

      ...wanted to...as in too uncomfortable to really do it, you mean? you're a cheap catch then!

  • @lburns7952
    @lburns7952 5 лет назад +444

    Number one rule .....We came together, we leave together. Never split up. They left her alone by bars and hotel's. If she was my friend I'd probably say something along the line; 'You want to hang out alone? Get your butt in this taxi with us. What are you crazy? Let's go'. Growing up in NYC you had to always be aware when you went out.

    • @lk4429
      @lk4429 5 лет назад +34

      You are a good wise friend, wish you were my friend, even though I don't go to bars or clubs anymore. God bless you!

    • @lburns7952
      @lburns7952 5 лет назад +13

      @@lk4429 Awww how sweet :) I don't go to bars and all that anymore either. xo

    • @lk4429
      @lk4429 5 лет назад +10

      @@lburns7952 be safe, real humans beings are like you!

    • @CC-qg6zl
      @CC-qg6zl 4 года назад +25

      Oh absolutely.
      My friend went home without telling us one night. Us three remaining girls had the whole bar searching for her, plus the security staff. When we phoned her home she was there eating scrambled eggs. It's the golden rule. Together till the bitter end.

    • @johnzelenak9432
      @johnzelenak9432 4 года назад +6

      BLIND DATE SET UP PICKED HER UP AT HER HOUSE PLAYED POOL LOOK OVER I THINK OK NOT INTERESTED IN ME! WALKED UP SAID LETS GO! SHE SAID WHY? I SAID LOOK YOU WANT TOO HOOK UP WITH HIM FINE BUT I PICKED YOU UP AT YOUR MOTHERS I TAKE YOU BACK THEIR! SHE SAID I WAS BEING POLITE! I TURNED AND SAID OK BUDDY YOU CAN GO SIT ELSEWHERE OR I OWE LEE A B AR WINDOW! HE MOVED WINDOW WAS 2X2! SHE SAID I DON'T NEED ANYONE I STOPPED HER SAID NOT MY INTENT MY INTENT WAS A FRIEND SET US UP AND I HAVE MORALS! 1IS SAFE&SOUND EVENING! NOT SURE HOW SHE TOOK IT! GAVE HER MY # TOLD HER I LIKE HER BUT SHE WANTS TOO SEE ME AGAIN SHE'LL CALL! IF NOT I HAD A GREAT TIME TILL NOW!

  • @chelseagreer6264
    @chelseagreer6264 5 лет назад +715

    Girls....when you go on a night out with friends stay with friends. Dont ever leave one or two alone.

    • @kodimacneil4037
      @kodimacneil4037 5 лет назад +2

      People go missing all the time

    • @ingeposch8091
      @ingeposch8091 5 лет назад +49

      i have a better piece of advise for a girl on her own, Chelsea...
      have a canister of deodorant or pepper spray with you and a brick in your handbag, so you can give anyone that wants to hurt you the hell they deserve.
      i often go home alone after a night out, albeit that i use a bicycle as means of transportation. in Alkmaar (the Netherlands) we had a bike path assaulter some 20 years ago, he always struck in the same place at the end of a bicycle tunnel in a park. lots of girls and women avoided that tunnel in the weekends, i didn't for i hate detours...
      the idiot jumped on the cycle path in front of me, but instead of hitting the brakes i rode on full speed and parked the front wheel of the bicycle between his legs. when he laid throwing up on the path i kicked him senseless some more, picked up my bicycle on rode on.
      after that there were no more incidents on that cycle path...

    • @lyndsaysrebornnurseryoffib4241
      @lyndsaysrebornnurseryoffib4241 5 лет назад +23

      chelsea greer I agree! Real friends would of never left her alone especially late at night!

    • @evangelene12
      @evangelene12 5 лет назад +40

      However nicely this comment is meant, it still falls into the category of telling girls how to behave, what to do and how to dress. Why not try giving advice to regulate the behaviour of guys instead?

    • @catherinehpn3613
      @catherinehpn3613 5 лет назад +9

      chelsea greer Yoh know chellsa, what saddens me most is that it’s not a given. Women need to protect and support each other..

  • @CC-qg6zl
    @CC-qg6zl 4 года назад +55

    Impressed with the local boys always looking out for the local girls.

  • @LisaMaryification
    @LisaMaryification 4 года назад +384

    I don't know why but I really like the host's voice. It's interesting but calming. Kind of like Forensic Files.

    • @keshaponso2034
      @keshaponso2034 4 года назад +26

      He's a famous Australian news presenter. Awesome voice.

    • @lisalee3401
      @lisalee3401 4 года назад +16

      I like his voice too! I also, love Australians accents. I have a southern accent.

    • @jazura2
      @jazura2 4 года назад +7

      I agree

    • @rachelstarkey4170
      @rachelstarkey4170 4 года назад +20

      The forensic files guy host sadly passed away may he rip he's voice is so sleepy ))

    • @Miss1Ginger
      @Miss1Ginger 4 года назад +4

      Yes I like it too

  • @chuvaam
    @chuvaam 3 года назад +215

    Those "psychics" preying on desperate family members for money is just vile.

    • @adamhilmersson4735
      @adamhilmersson4735 3 года назад +4

      Indeed. There's laws against "perverting the course of justice". I believe there should be a law for people who pervert peoples grieving.

    • @angeldougan9334
      @angeldougan9334 3 года назад +3

      agreed. Being psychic is a gift that few people legit have. As such it should be used to help others, NOT for personal gain in this kind of situation.

    • @mrsash4714
      @mrsash4714 3 года назад +2

      That just made it so much worse for them - awful

    • @elderxemo92
      @elderxemo92 3 года назад +11

      Psychics are just fakes.

  • @tinahernandez9374
    @tinahernandez9374 4 года назад +42

    The lady unable to leave Janes body was a lovely lady. I cried for the lovely young ladies and the loss of their lives when they were just beginning. My heart goes out to their families and friends who are sentenced to a life of unrealized dreams. He was caught in 2016-trial started Jan 2020

  • @fredajordan5704
    @fredajordan5704 3 года назад +17

    I simply don`t know how parents of a murdered child can go on. Even the thought to me is deeply disturbing and painful. RIP young girls.

  • @romankatz982
    @romankatz982 3 года назад +47

    2 a.m. walking around at night alone waiting for a taxi. So scary. I just don't understand it.

    • @marciloni12
      @marciloni12 3 года назад +2

      I’d make sure I’m not in that situation.

    • @Bantsuperbear
      @Bantsuperbear 3 года назад +2

      I did that once In Taiwan with an impression that the neighbourhood was safe. After watching this, I think back to that night and just realized how risky that situation was for me and now I'm scared. I'd never do that ever again.

    • @kristinsreese
      @kristinsreese 2 года назад

      And even though they were walking alone, there were still plenty of people out and about - none of the woman were grabbed kicking and screaming, which is probably why nobody really paid much attention to the car these woman willingly got into.

    • @camillebrowns552
      @camillebrowns552 2 года назад +1

      Australia is very safe country, I walk home from bar or nightclub 3, 4, 5 in the morning , all hours , never scare. But it depends on the area you live in too. I was in Melbourne.

    • @mateblack4722
      @mateblack4722 2 года назад +1

      Prostitutes for sure.

  • @sharlawilliamson9609
    @sharlawilliamson9609 3 года назад +47

    when the mom who found her said she wouldn't leave Jane by herself.... just made me cry. You become a mom to that poor girl in that moment. Doing what you can so that she isn't alone. Even though she has passed, I'm sure you become maternal and protective in any way that you can.

  • @bobjolly7795
    @bobjolly7795 3 года назад +7

    I love this host...I’m from the US but this guy is better than anyone I can think of over here

    • @mdee8784
      @mdee8784 5 месяцев назад

      Steve Liebmann is kinda like the Dan Rather of Australian tv.
      A highly respected and much loved Australian journalist.

  • @paulahislop222
    @paulahislop222 3 года назад +16

    Bradley Robert Edward was sentenced last year to at least 40 years for doing this, some closure for the families

    • @melaniepemberton2882
      @melaniepemberton2882 2 месяца назад

      Found not guilty of murdering Sarah though and her body has never been found. 😢

  • @jazzman5652
    @jazzman5652 5 лет назад +35

    Ladies please don't walk alone at night no matter how safe the neighborhood is.I would be scared standing at the intersection at night myself. This applies to men too there is safety in numbers. By the way that was a long and lonely walk to the phone booth.

    • @susannwambugu4939
      @susannwambugu4939 3 года назад

      ikr?

    • @nomadpurple6154
      @nomadpurple6154 2 года назад +1

      Victim blaming - let's all wear burkhas and stay home , just in case the one in million event happens.

  • @arielwiderburg113
    @arielwiderburg113 4 года назад +32

    My friends left me...it didn't turn out well either...but luckily it wasn't deadly for me.

    • @jamesluis1767
      @jamesluis1767 2 года назад

      How you doing gorgeous, I'm sorry for infringing on your nice comment and beautiful profile. do you mind friendship?

  • @robertajohnson7088
    @robertajohnson7088 4 года назад +85

    Stay with your friends...come together always leave together!!!

    • @David-pq4of
      @David-pq4of 3 года назад +1

      100% correct

    • @Ir0nMa1d3n
      @Ir0nMa1d3n 3 года назад +3

      A friend should have stayed back with her or have her share that taxi. Should a would a could of. It's just sad.

    • @oliviashafer1435
      @oliviashafer1435 3 года назад +2

      You would think females would of most definitely started thinking this way after a 2nd body was found. Knowing the killer wasn’t caught from the first victim should of raised females senses to never walk alone in that area.

    • @nomadpurple6154
      @nomadpurple6154 2 года назад

      Because not all friend groups live in the same direction so HAVE to split up to go home.
      You're statement is naive at best, victim blaming at worst.

  • @redrumtruecrime
    @redrumtruecrime 4 года назад +43

    12 years is way too long to ask people to identify mystery man, jeeze I wouldn't be able to recognise myself after 12 years off old CCTV. Its a crazy request and not realistic.

    • @redrumtruecrime
      @redrumtruecrime 4 года назад +7

      @Kentucky Mama It was the fact that the Police didn't release the CCTV footage asking for witnesses for 12 years. That's the problem, they sat on it all that time!

  • @lmiyagishima6527
    @lmiyagishima6527 3 года назад +11

    I do not understand why the girl walked to get a cab waited on the corner, does not make sense, Why not get the cab to pick you up at the hotel or bar and wait with the doorman.

  • @tporchia7751
    @tporchia7751 5 лет назад +95

    They were quick to notice a serial killer. I also noticed that twice there were three men who saw the victims.

    • @changeintheair9648
      @changeintheair9648 5 лет назад +3

      This show is amiss to call the perp a serial killer when at that point there was only 1 murder.

    • @ImRyll
      @ImRyll 4 года назад +1

      Maybe those 3 are the killers? Lol

    • @GotMoreCakes
      @GotMoreCakes 4 года назад

      @@ImRyll Bradley Robert Edwards

    • @1977Suspiria
      @1977Suspiria 4 года назад +1

      So? Were they the same three men in both instances, no, so what does it matter? Are you trying to suggest two separate trios of men murdered these girls because that's pretty far-fetched. Just like girls, guys go on nights out in groups generally, shock horror.

    • @yasminreyes957
      @yasminreyes957 4 года назад

      Men stays together...but women don't...

  • @pinkyblinders7352
    @pinkyblinders7352 5 лет назад +163

    It annoys me when they go on about female victims physical attractiveness. It's irrelevant! It doesn't matter what she looked like, she shouldn't have been killed.
    And I can't fathom why Jane wanted to stay to hang out on the curb by herself ?

    • @francescacaplan9129
      @francescacaplan9129 5 лет назад +20

      it's not only iirelevant, it's dangerous. it distorts the investigation and the perception of both victims and perpetrator

    • @bonnielee7134
      @bonnielee7134 5 лет назад +12

      Perhaps she was meeting someone there. She was looking at her watch.

    • @Velocitygrl34
      @Velocitygrl34 5 лет назад +19

      Dame Lia Sorelle I thought the same thing ... the one guy says he was concerned because she was a GOOD-LOOKING woman standing alone in the street!!?? Evil doesn’t discriminate ...

    • @spacecase7566
      @spacecase7566 5 лет назад +35

      We might not want to admit it but attractiveness does play into the media’s interest about murder victims. Also, that gentleman noticed her because she was attractive. It’s the truth.

    • @edwardteach6681
      @edwardteach6681 5 лет назад +18

      it sucks to say but it does matter. I think it is the sick as*&^e who did it attracted to her and SpaceCase is also correct that it helps with the news. Is it right? no! Fair? No! Can the world be an amazingly unfair and cruel world? Yes.

  • @HopelessSinner
    @HopelessSinner 4 года назад +33

    How could you just leave your friend behind on her own??!
    Doesn't matter how much they protest, there is no way you should EVER separate from friends on a night out!!

    • @jamesluis1767
      @jamesluis1767 2 года назад

      How you doing gorgeous, I'm sorry for infringing on your nice comment and beautiful profile. do you mind friendship?

  • @Luna.3.3.3
    @Luna.3.3.3 2 года назад +10

    It's 2021, and I'm sure evil still lurks all around the world.
    Ladies AND gentlemen - PLEASE never leave your friend alone on the streets, esp. at night! Friends shouldn't leave friends to be alone.

    • @wexfordrob
      @wexfordrob 2 года назад

      What if your travelling alone! 😱

    • @Luna.3.3.3
      @Luna.3.3.3 2 года назад +2

      @@wexfordrob Take extra precautions, perhaps. Pepper spray, loud whistle etc. Nothing's bullet proof, but it's better than nothing.If I were a frequent solo traveler, I'd DEF. take some self defense classes. Even when I've walked through a parking lot alone at night, I keep my keys with one sticking out btw. my fingers. It's not much, but it's something.

  • @bcfb2989
    @bcfb2989 2 года назад +7

    Those three guys no doubt regret not turning around to check on her after speaking about, then contemplating and then noticing the second car never got on the highway.
    Poor family.

  • @claudineannschultz9726
    @claudineannschultz9726 5 лет назад +17

    Mr. Liebman, love your presentation, excellent job!

  • @nittygritty9418
    @nittygritty9418 4 года назад +21

    Jane stayed behind because she was waiting for someone, why else would she just be standing there.

    • @iCynnie
      @iCynnie 4 года назад

      I was thinking maybe she was waiting for a guy to talk to her so she can get a free drink

    • @iCynnie
      @iCynnie 4 года назад +1

      her friend mentioned that too

  • @archonsouthpaw8690
    @archonsouthpaw8690 4 года назад +42

    43:47 this guy's mustache is a crime worthy of its own episode

  • @BlackPanther-qo2tv
    @BlackPanther-qo2tv 3 года назад +8

    Stop walking around in the night by yourself! Always go with someone or stay in a busy area.

  • @kathleenoconnor4440
    @kathleenoconnor4440 5 лет назад +59

    They arrested someone in 2016 who will stand trial this year!

    • @Ainaes-Feline
      @Ainaes-Feline 3 года назад +3

      Kathleen O'Connor Bradley Robert Edwards

  • @TheDarkDresser
    @TheDarkDresser 4 года назад +21

    I can never understand how young women who are aware of young women going missing, or being murdered in their area, yet decide to walk alone late at night, when they don't have to.
    It's really baffling.

    • @terimorris6394
      @terimorris6394 Год назад +1

      Once drinks have been drank all precautions go out of the window, they feel brave indestructible

  • @JW-vd4il
    @JW-vd4il 5 лет назад +87

    WHY did they not release that video for TWELVE years?!
    I can understand for a month or so, in case you find "mystery man" and he's a suspect you want to hold it back from.
    But then release it! He could've been an innocent guy that had more info to help, since he was the last person to talk to her.
    I'm also angry the "review" said everything was done well.
    I'm in the US but we see a lot of this same BS here.
    I know there are a lot of of people really trying to solve crimes.
    But when you see these obvious flaws and the people who are supposed to review giving it a pass, ridiculous.

    • @JW-vd4il
      @JW-vd4il 5 лет назад +7

      @Jonathan Harkovich I'm SISTER, bro. ha ha. But I appreciate your reply and sentiment.
      I'm dizzy with law enforcement in in the US these days. Had such a mix of great and terrible cops, police officers, just in my own personal experiencs, that I don't even know what to think any more or how to fix the problem.

    • @juliecooper3989
      @juliecooper3989 5 лет назад +3

      He's probably a cop.

    • @lynkent677
      @lynkent677 5 лет назад +1

      COP!...maybe it was a cop?..dont shot me...just saying the only thing that makes sense???

    • @maverickstclare3756
      @maverickstclare3756 4 года назад +2

      Even worse, that was the guy they eventually arrested for it.

    • @darkknight1340
      @darkknight1340 2 года назад +1

      Police standards in many countries appear to have gone way downhill recently,it's like that here in the UK too.

  • @MartyCostello
    @MartyCostello 5 лет назад +63

    I feel so for the parents, especially the father. She had her father's eyes. When he speaks of her, his eyes just lit up, it made me tear up. I worry when my cat isn't in the house by 5p, I couldn't imagine how I would be if I had a child. My significant other and I often speak about adopting, but after watching these shows, I would have to have her/he tagged as I had done with all of our rescue pets. The "hubby" just brought home another kitten two weeks ago. Prayers and Blessings to all parents of the earth, may you find yourselves all home, happy and together. It's 10pm do you know where your children are? Remember that on Channel 11 in NYC? My mom would shout back at the telly and say, "They better all be doing their homework or getting ready for bed!" up the stairs. And we would shout back, "Yes, ma'am!"

    • @KM-nq7ez
      @KM-nq7ez 5 лет назад +5

      Marty Costello sounds like you had a great mum❤️

    • @wheelervette
      @wheelervette 4 года назад +3

      Pls keep ur cat indoors SAFE

    • @anneperry9014
      @anneperry9014 4 года назад +1

      Well said love!!

  • @afcwfcwfc
    @afcwfcwfc 3 года назад +7

    Bradley Robert Edwards , Convicted 24th September 2020.
    Two counts Guilty, one count not guilty.

  • @justiceLaw0123
    @justiceLaw0123 4 года назад +18

    All three of them started the night out with friends and ended the night alone and murdered. Makes no sense.

  • @queinnam3464
    @queinnam3464 5 лет назад +132

    I hate to watch crime document that is still remains unsolved. Its such a frustration. All the watching throught only to know its still cold case.

    • @alysononoahu8702
      @alysononoahu8702 5 лет назад +2

      Arrested the man

    • @ggurks
      @ggurks 5 лет назад +5

      The case may be solved now, the suspect however still awaits trial

    • @ggurks
      @ggurks 5 лет назад +6

      @LI .B I don't really get the smiley, not sure what you mean

    • @omennemo8844
      @omennemo8844 5 лет назад +11

      It's like you were in my head. I feel the same way. I usually go through the comments before I start because this show sometimes show unsolved cases. I like the show but I hate be left hanging. I want that be able to watch that person got caught. I watch these programs to see what happened and what justice was done. I get involved in the story and I don't like it when there isn't closure as the families usually say.

    • @d.dedrick7991
      @d.dedrick7991 5 лет назад +2

      @LI .B Mucho, el stupido, overcompensating, MICRO-PENIS‼️🖕😀🖕

  • @cazpk6840
    @cazpk6840 3 года назад +6

    I have been to Claremont and Shenton Park. I used to love to hang out at Claremont and have been along Stirling Highway to catch cabs home. This is chilling. These areas seemed so harmless and i used to love to walk the gardens alone.

  • @carolefreeman2544
    @carolefreeman2544 5 лет назад +39

    It looks like the female, Jane Rimmer was actually waiting to meet a particular person and that is why she is looking at her watch on the video

  • @documentaries51214
    @documentaries51214 5 лет назад +3

    good work

  • @pauldrake4295
    @pauldrake4295 5 лет назад +234

    another case of brilliant Australian detectives trying to solve a crime. These genius' want the killer to come forward and identify himself-wow, what a plan.

    • @tumiimokoena9962
      @tumiimokoena9962 5 лет назад +5

      paul Drake lol 😂😂😂

    • @tjd2286
      @tjd2286 5 лет назад +9

      They have a guy in jail for it. He is expected to go to trial this year. Could be worse....

    • @spacecase7566
      @spacecase7566 5 лет назад +9

      He’s on trial now.

    • @birdyelke775
      @birdyelke775 5 лет назад +3

      Marvellous!! Paul! in'it?

    • @Retroscoop
      @Retroscoop 5 лет назад +11

      It was not clear whether that was actually the killer, or just an innocent bystander, who could tell more about what the victim's plans were for that night. Maybe he asked her if she wanted to go somewhere, and she told him, nay, I'm waiting for X or something like that. So that in itself is not the problem. The problem is that these images were released far too long after events took place. That is a choice that policemen all over the world have to make, show or not show, and both choices can have very negative consequences. It's not rocket sciences. This hasn't anything to do with Aussies this or Kiwi's that or Pommies this AND that. The world is a bit more complex than Paul Drake seems to think. May wisdom come with the years.

  • @guilhermefilho1730
    @guilhermefilho1730 3 года назад +30

    They caught him! His name is Bradley Robert Edwards.

    • @noongourfain
      @noongourfain 3 года назад +1

      Was he "mystery man"?

    • @fraser_mr2009
      @fraser_mr2009 3 года назад +1

      @@noongourfain yes. got to remember that a decade had passed so he's gunna look older.

  • @elobee6147
    @elobee6147 5 лет назад +58

    I'm shocked people were still going out to this area especially that hotel. Makes me think the police were not sufficiently warning people until the 3rd woman went missing.

    • @warshipsatin8764
      @warshipsatin8764 5 лет назад +13

      people just think itll never happen to them

    • @keshaponso2034
      @keshaponso2034 4 года назад +9

      Oh. The whole of Australia knew. It was a huge thing at the time after the second girl went missing. People just always think that they are impervious to harm. The "I'm smarter than that".. the "It wont happen to me" mentality.

    • @cazpk6840
      @cazpk6840 3 года назад +1

      no warnings. I was still visiting the area until 1999 - had no clue.

    • @Ainaes-Feline
      @Ainaes-Feline 3 года назад +5

      Caz PK What were you DEAF and BLIND? At the time I lived in Wellard and in 97 moved to the Hills we had it on the news, radio and EVERYONE was always talking about it. And I lived both 80 km down-South and 80 km East from Claremont and no matter where we still knew all about it.
      Well one of the girls was found at the end of our street in Wellard which was bizarre to say the least. He must have known the area you don't just stumble on that particular road behind a horse farm in the middle of nowhere.

  • @jennfaire8726
    @jennfaire8726 4 года назад +25

    Why didn't she call from the bar and wait there for the cab

    • @cazpk6840
      @cazpk6840 3 года назад +2

      Maybe they did not allow the use of their phones. Remember in 1996 people had pages but not mobiles.

    • @littleblackpistol
      @littleblackpistol 3 года назад +3

      NO phones and no-one had cellphones in 1996/7. You used call boxes.

    • @jennfaire8726
      @jennfaire8726 3 года назад +1

      @@littleblackpistol Bars call cabs for their patrons back in 96 if they ask.

    • @peacelovincriminal7488
      @peacelovincriminal7488 3 года назад +1

      The question should be why do such thing's? it's perfectly normal to want to clear your head after a drink or two. It's sad to say but the fact is they're a product of this wrong system we have manifested.

    • @HopelessSinner
      @HopelessSinner 3 года назад

      @@littleblackpistol
      People *did* have cell phones in 1996 although not as prevalent as they are nowadays.

  • @lou_isse1938
    @lou_isse1938 3 года назад +4

    I remember this show!!!!! The Bodies in the Barrel, the kidnapped teenage boys where the suspect would chop them up and scatter them around, and the couple who kills women (I remember one victim suddenly sprang up) all gave me nightmares when I was still a kid. I was disgusted but super fascinated because the way they did the re-enactments were so on point. It's one of the shows that made me like Investigation shows.

  • @UKEbikers
    @UKEbikers 4 года назад +22

    They caught him, family man with kids

  • @slinkiegirl2001
    @slinkiegirl2001 5 лет назад +50

    update a man called bradley edwards has been charged

    • @dawg4lifeb712
      @dawg4lifeb712 4 года назад +2

      Was he the mystery man?

    • @ediebaxter4653
      @ediebaxter4653 4 года назад +1

      My understanding one lady was never found. That was the 18 yr old. The guy was married twice.

    • @miarena111
      @miarena111 4 года назад +6

      update, he pleated guilty

    • @miarena111
      @miarena111 4 года назад +1

      @@dawg4lifeb712 yes

    • @alysononoahu8702
      @alysononoahu8702 3 года назад

      BRADLEY EDWARDS???
      PLEADED GUILTY IN 2019

  • @truecrime_and_everything_else
    @truecrime_and_everything_else 2 года назад +4

    They caught the guy through DNA... He got 40 years! He wasn't a taxi driver...

  • @kathrynmacmillan1361
    @kathrynmacmillan1361 3 года назад +11

    Imagine referring to your husband as “THE husband”.

    • @Kyra_of_Kerkyra
      @Kyra_of_Kerkyra 3 года назад +1

      It did surprise me, too 😆

    • @nerdynellie4729
      @nerdynellie4729 3 года назад +3

      lol I'm from the South (USA) and I do that sometimes, as does He, in reference to me..lol My grandparents did that too.
      I guess I never considered it weird, but I guess I could seem that way .lol

    • @johnf1059
      @johnf1059 2 года назад

      Yea I thought the way she said it that they must of had a bad break up…

  • @HazelandLulu
    @HazelandLulu 4 года назад +5

    There is a fantastic pod cast on the Claremont Killings running at the moment. Day by day analysis of the trial and explanation of how the killer was caught and the evidence explained in great detail. Well worth a listen.

    • @dawnsully88
      @dawnsully88 3 года назад

      Do you know the name?

    • @HazelandLulu
      @HazelandLulu 3 года назад

      It’s called Claremont The Trial.

    • @dawnsully88
      @dawnsully88 3 года назад

      @@HazelandLulu awesome thank you! I've been wanting to know what happened and why it took so long to catch him

  • @tfny100
    @tfny100 4 года назад +27

    All they have to do is get an undercover female cop to walk down the same street. Perth should set up undercover sting.

    • @keshaponso2034
      @keshaponso2034 4 года назад +3

      They did this in the 90's. As a result a prime suspect emerged who was offering lone girls lifts home. His name was Lance Williams and he was persued for years with undercover operatives following him full-time for two years everywhere he went. There was no evidence that linked him what so ever, however the media caught wind of him and he was hounded for over a decade. In the end he was found to be an awkward person who was genuinely concerned about the safety of girls being by themselves at night. He died in 2018 from cancer and was never apologized to. The Macro Taskforce was criticized for having tunnel vision when it came to him based on no evidence.

    • @proudmilitarybrat76
      @proudmilitarybrat76 4 года назад +3

      @@keshaponso2034 that's horrible. That poor man. I hope he is resting in peace

  • @munamazen2632
    @munamazen2632 4 года назад +6

    The world is so cruel 😢

  • @mogbaba
    @mogbaba 5 лет назад +7

    Very strange way to book a taxi!!!
    I cannot understand why people have no problems paying high for a dinner out but they try to save on driving home.
    In this case, she could stay at her address, book thwe taxi, pay high and come safe home. Why she booked the taxi for an intersection?

    • @laurids2007
      @laurids2007 5 лет назад +2

      Exactly. I completely agree with you.

  • @dragoncult666
    @dragoncult666 2 года назад +1

    Can't believe they sat on cctv footage for 12 flipping years! Ridiculous!

  • @hayden7884
    @hayden7884 5 лет назад +15

    Glad they caught the monster who did this. He just kept denying it.
    Horrible what happened to the victims and sad that their bodies were never found :( poor families.

  • @buggiebuild1
    @buggiebuild1 4 года назад +7

    Man goosebumps, she was horrified I'm sure, but angry, and stayed with Jane, I'd like to think I would do that, I sure hope I never find anything of that nature, That's a strong woman ,senseless, youth snubbed out

  • @watershedbarbie9685
    @watershedbarbie9685 4 года назад +11

    There are some really nice young men in the world. They just really need to learn that they need to don their superhero vests.

  • @B1TKZH47
    @B1TKZH47 3 года назад +2

    Police: "We want the perpetrator to come forward.”
    Killer: Why didn’t you say so earlier? Sure mate, I’ll be right over!

    • @WideAwakeHuman
      @WideAwakeHuman 3 года назад +1

      Oddly enough you'd probably be surprised at how many people actually turn themselves in after a short period... Running from the law isn't as easy as it looks on TV

    • @B1TKZH47
      @B1TKZH47 3 года назад +1

      @@WideAwakeHuman Goog point.

  • @katekay634
    @katekay634 4 года назад +11

    Women need to wise up and never ever stay alone at night nowhere....

  • @Ainaes-Feline
    @Ainaes-Feline 3 года назад +3

    The murderer is Bradley Robert Edwards. He has been found guilty on 2 of the murders they didn’t have enough to get him on his final victim.

    • @m.valenvox7381
      @m.valenvox7381 3 года назад

      Thankyou , got really bummed towards the end thinking this was left unsolved

  • @jazzman5652
    @jazzman5652 5 лет назад +18

    most people can't remember what they had for the breakfast and you want them to remember someone they saw 20yrs ago for a few minutes? way to go coppers.

    • @itiswhatitis9069
      @itiswhatitis9069 4 года назад +1

      Don't be mean. You should be able to express your opinion without being that way.

  • @aridyaacob3172
    @aridyaacob3172 3 года назад

    Love series that do not have ads.

  • @feliciabosch8110
    @feliciabosch8110 Год назад +1

    Humans can be so evil all for nothing it's just sad

  • @nancyoleksy
    @nancyoleksy 4 года назад +7

    It sounds like they were all at a place that they could have used a phone there to call a cab and wait at the restaurant or whatever until it came. That way you are with people and your friends. Why do these girls walk by themselves late at night?

  • @afrojakhan4199
    @afrojakhan4199 5 лет назад +8

    Killer is in Hotel Continental

  • @inayromasdiary6972
    @inayromasdiary6972 4 года назад +2

    Stay together and stay as a group!
    Nobody will leave behind!

  • @stephanierichards6190
    @stephanierichards6190 2 года назад +1

    Rule number 1 never leave your friends alone!

  • @violagentsch
    @violagentsch 4 года назад +5

    Either the 3 guys lying about the mysterious car. The taxi driver that says she wasn't there.

  • @chellesama8256
    @chellesama8256 4 года назад +3

    Rat-bag is excellent and I'm going to adopt it.

  • @beez5338
    @beez5338 3 года назад +1

    Police know they should have shown the CCTV footage of the unidentified man or given a description of him to the public sooner

  • @KitsunenoHibi
    @KitsunenoHibi 5 лет назад +7

    People; be you a man or woman, NEVER wander alone at night, especially in area with lots of night activity. I'm not saying that you'll come to harm, or should be afraid of your community.... but don't be foolish either!! There's safety in numbers! If Miss Kira had listened to the young men who warned her, or if those young men had trusted their guts and kept an eye on her, she may have been saved. If you must be out at night, stick to groups! Even if you don't know the others well, find people heading your direction and round up a group. It could just save your life.

  • @charmainkilloran9476
    @charmainkilloran9476 3 года назад +11

    Young girls or women of any age are crazy if they are walking streets in the early hours of the morning on their own. That one young girl who didn't want to go home in the taxi with her friends looked like she was waiting for someone she had arranged to meet on the sly. Thats why she wouldn't tell her friends, knowing they possibly wouldn't approve.

    • @nomadpurple6154
      @nomadpurple6154 2 года назад

      Classic Victim Blaming - you're vile

    • @maxwellhatkow6209
      @maxwellhatkow6209 2 года назад

      @@nomadpurple6154 Not victim blaming. Hes absolutely correct most likely.

  • @Sayerdify
    @Sayerdify 4 года назад +8

    I'm a bit bothered by how casual and nonchalant that one sister talked about her missing sister just after she went missing. I didn't see even a twitch or hint of sadness or concern on her face. I know she isn't the killer but it still bothers me.

    • @scifisuede
      @scifisuede 3 года назад +4

      I think there's a hint of sadness in her eyes, but yes she seemed rather nonchalant about it. I guess different people cope differently and we don't really know how their relationship was.

  • @heatherbowlan9822
    @heatherbowlan9822 4 года назад +2

    I think we should all take a note from Britain, and there should be CTV CAMERAS everywhere in every town and inner rule areas , those cameras are the greatest idea, helps so much in fighting crime! ❤️🙏🏽🇨🇦

    • @wickedlee664
      @wickedlee664 2 года назад

      :(. It’s heartbreaking to hear you say that. You don’t even know that it sounds crazy.

  • @LisaMaryification
    @LisaMaryification 5 лет назад +2

    How many women are raped and murdered by these sociopaths? Instead of spending money and time after the fact we should be spending it on hiring good decent teachers who care for and respect both boys and girls in their classes. The same should be said for parents and society as a whole. We need to stop raising these sociopathic men! Our society is obviously doing something wrong where these men grow up to be so stunted or damaged that they are attacking and killing women. Let's examine why instead of blaming the victims!

  • @ylliameti2318
    @ylliameti2318 4 года назад +4

    Has anyone noticed that all the victims in reality they were prettier then actors, at the hotel CONTINENTAL that's where the investigation should of focused,

  • @Norishigecherry0711
    @Norishigecherry0711 5 лет назад +4

    No police patrol in the place in same time omg poor job to police in 12 years where is justice in Australia

  • @saoirseL
    @saoirseL 3 года назад +1

    shame on those 'clairvoyants' .. they should also do prison time for putting the families through so much torture

  • @deuceph
    @deuceph 3 года назад +1

    Narrators are a big factor if I watch a show or not, I like this one.

    • @mdee8784
      @mdee8784 5 месяцев назад

      Steve Liebmann is a consummate Australian journalist

  • @robertwarren3039
    @robertwarren3039 3 года назад +4

    In the video Jane was waiting for someone. She's looking towards the road and checking the time. Two men would be involved.

  • @techno.science
    @techno.science Год назад +3

    The killer was convicted in 2020, his name is Bradley Robert Edwards

  • @xarzneimittel8220
    @xarzneimittel8220 3 года назад +33

    Don't blame her for going alone. Or her friends for letting her do so. I understand the point but it is wrong.
    The only one to blame here is the killer.
    Stop telling women how to behave.
    Start by telling your friends to stop whenever they lay with a drunker girl who can't consent.
    Start by teaching kids what "no" means.
    Start by teaching people what a mental illness is and how to deal with it.
    And if someone is sick, don't leave them alone in the city. Don't let killers free. Don't let rapists free.
    We shouldn't b afraid to walk alone in the dark.
    Criminals should be scared to commit crimes at any time.

    • @JFskeezix
      @JFskeezix 3 года назад +6

      You can't change the world into a safe place. But you can teach men and women to avoid dangerous situations. This world is a sick place so don't be ignorant and think you can walk at night alone. For both men and women it's not a wise thing to do, but of those two women risk the most.

    • @boogygottsmann4728
      @boogygottsmann4728 3 года назад +2

      Everyone should be allowed to walk around freely & safely...unfortunately there are far too many evil people out there...

    • @tammyrang7796
      @tammyrang7796 3 года назад

      m on
      m my

    • @JFskeezix
      @JFskeezix 3 года назад +1

      @@boogygottsmann4728 Indeed, everyone wishes for a safe world where there is no risk and everybody is happy. But reality shows you need to take your own responsibility first before blaming others. Of course it is wrong that people do evil, but that's not the point here. The point is these women went outside in the streets alone at night which makes them easy prey for predators. Just use your brain and never leave your group in those kind of situations. Even men can get robbed walking alone at night. But women are obviously more vulnerable and likely to be attacked.

    • @boogygottsmann4728
      @boogygottsmann4728 3 года назад +3

      @@JFskeezix I agree. But I remember back in the 80's I used to walk/roam the streets of Hillbrow, in Johannesburg, South Africa & this was at all times of the day & night. Hillbrow was one of the only places in South Africa which was open 24/7...There were things to look out for especially predator-men, but I never felt threatened or unsafe....Nowadays it is extremely dangerous even during daytime hours.. just driving through is dangerous...Understandably, women have a far greater chance of being accosted...I have great empathy for the street-walkers plying their trade...P.S. My wife is Thai & I cannot let her out without myself or a trusted friend as she is small in stature, very pretty & at 51yrs still looks like a woman half the age...being Asian she is considered by many men to be 'an 'easy woman willing to give happy endings'...sadly the way so many of them think...take care out there, luv 'n respect

  • @onangelswings3763
    @onangelswings3763 3 года назад +1

    He will NOT come forth, you have too search for him. There might be a Coworker, family friend, School mate or a family member??? Search for these people, these young woman families deserve JUSTICE!

  • @1972dsrai
    @1972dsrai 5 лет назад +13

    Case solved. The killer was finally caught last year.

  • @terririckert7069
    @terririckert7069 5 лет назад +15

    What is it going to take to for women NOT to walk alone at NIGHT ANYWHERE?

    • @socialmedia1276
      @socialmedia1276 5 лет назад +2

      It's just not possible. I tried to think of an answer but there is so many situations that have led me to needing to be out walking at night. If only people weren't so terrible.

    • @terririckert7069
      @terririckert7069 5 лет назад +1

      @@socialmedia1276 I know that it is NOT right that women can't walk alone at night and even worse that we live in a world that people are so disgusting and selfish. But it is a decision that women need to make EVERY time they want to or need to walk alone at night. Is my life worth walking. And it is naive, delusional and irresponsible so say it is just a short walk & NOTHING will happen to me. It won't be the young woman that suffers long term she will be dead, it is her family that will suffer for the rest of their lives..

    • @liliesrnice
      @liliesrnice 5 лет назад +6

      @@terririckert7069 What is it going to take for men not to kidnap and murder women at night?? Stop blaming women and start teaching men that women are not property they are entitled to. And shame on you for saying this.

    • @terririckert7069
      @terririckert7069 5 лет назад +1

      @@liliesrnice I would never blame a women. I just believe for our own safety we need to take precautions. My daughter is very petit, & stunning, olive skin Hazel eyes & blonde hair to her bottom. She started TV commercials at 16 yrs old. From the time she was abt 10 years old. I drilled into "perceive the danger" because women NEED to protect themselves. As unfair as it is. The option is either protect yourself or be at risk of something happening.. I don't even know if women will ever be 100% safe alone walking at night. I hope that it will happen soon for my Grand-daughters who are getting close to dating age.

    • @asmashareef9680
      @asmashareef9680 4 года назад +3

      Guess men should be off road at nite s we can roam for no reason at nite

  • @willwong1234
    @willwong1234 4 года назад +2

    Have the cops investigated the security guard/doorman/bouncer who Sarah Spiers talked to and revealed that she was about to take a cab? The abductor, abductors, or the accomplice to the crimes for sure knew that the girls would soon be standing on the street waiting for a car to pick them up so the Ocean Beach Hotel must have had someone there who either committed or aided and abetted the abductions.

  • @judith1564
    @judith1564 3 года назад +2

    12 YEARS! It's taken the police 12 years to show this cctv footage publicly? I can understa the need for care when investigating, and keeping certain facts hidden from the public, but to keep this footage from the public for over a decade is ridiculous. The oyher point is about these "psychics" - they shold be prosecuted for something - I don't care what. but they should be ashamed of themselves.

  • @marcususa
    @marcususa 4 года назад +6

    14:53 "What I want is the occupants of that vehicle to come forward and identify themselves." That's how it works in Australia? You just ask for them to contact you, not hide like OJ Simpson or Scott Peterson?

    • @truebluewonderful1139
      @truebluewonderful1139 3 года назад +1

      Happens in my Western European country also. On tv police asks for certain witnesses, also from streetcamera's, to come forward. Because maybe they have helpful information. I've become used to it.

    • @elizabethsohler2410
      @elizabethsohler2410 3 года назад +1

      If the person has nothing to hide no reason not to come forward.

  • @cavid8066
    @cavid8066 4 года назад +3

    I am surprised that in a country like Australie there should exist a "flourishing" illegal taxi industry.

  • @jocelynjohnston8257
    @jocelynjohnston8257 3 года назад

    This was a horrible injustice. I can't believe this is my home town.

  • @barbarapalmer8224
    @barbarapalmer8224 4 года назад +2

    Shame on those young men who did not see if that poor girl was OK.. One young man did want to make her safe.

  • @michillene
    @michillene 3 года назад +10

    Why a woman would walk late at night...knowing that other women have been killed..is beyond crazy...I just will never understand it.

  • @alexandraestrada738
    @alexandraestrada738 5 лет назад +6

    I am convinced that the taxis have something to do with it. I mean it's an area where women go out to party, it basically is the perfect spot for a serial killer to go if they are looking for an easy prey. Especially intoxicated women (which by the way isn't an excuse to kill them) i just don't get why someone would trust a stranger unless it is a taxi driver.

    • @laurids2007
      @laurids2007 5 лет назад +3

      I would never trust a taxi driver, especially Uber, at night.
      Seriously.
      A woman must be mad to trust so blindly a driver alone...

  • @mateblack4722
    @mateblack4722 2 года назад +1

    The guy either died or moved to another country... Or disabled in a way.. Serial killers do not stop it's need that he has to satisfy
    Useless police now get some innocent guy and frame him .

  • @christinafan4476
    @christinafan4476 Год назад

    Being alone at 2am on a deserted st is a magnet for criminals

  • @tinaharris4082
    @tinaharris4082 3 года назад +3

    My mum always said to me and my siblings if you all go out together you all come back together and you don't come back until you're all together or you'll get a right bollocking and my older sisters always did get a bollocking.

    • @stevechristie2569
      @stevechristie2569 3 года назад

      Miss Harris are you 23-37?

    • @tinaharris4082
      @tinaharris4082 3 года назад +1

      @@stevechristie2569 26 why?

    • @stevechristie2569
      @stevechristie2569 3 года назад

      @@tinaharris4082 The sort of lady who uses the word siblings is my kind of lady

    • @tinaharris4082
      @tinaharris4082 3 года назад +1

      @@stevechristie2569 is it now 😉

  • @freedomofspeech766
    @freedomofspeech766 5 лет назад +5

    That's why I never venture out without my German Shepherd. Even the most hardened looking guys cross over to the other side of the street when they see me walking down the street late at night.

    • @marleen6507
      @marleen6507 5 лет назад +1

      Me too I have a German Shep also. She would take a bullet for me.

    • @Elly3121
      @Elly3121 4 года назад

      If the guys have gun, they would put both of you down! Just dont go out at nights

  • @oliviawebber8181
    @oliviawebber8181 3 года назад +2

    Why would her friends allow her to leave the club alone ??? My friends aren’t even allowed to go to the bathroom alone while we are out. You come with me , you leave with me. I will sit on the phone with you til u make it through the house door. Evil lerks everywhere, you can never be too careful.

  • @brucetoo3294
    @brucetoo3294 2 года назад +1

    the girl in front of the bar checking her watch--definitely looks like she's waiting for someone in particular--not just random 'hanging out'

  • @manohar2864
    @manohar2864 4 года назад +6

    It is sad that still they have not found the criminal

    • @steffyrae222
      @steffyrae222 4 года назад

      @@agems56 Edward Wayne Edwards was an American serial killer.

  • @davoodzaeri223
    @davoodzaeri223 4 года назад +6

    I think my old Nokia 1100 camera had better quality than these security cameras.

  • @emmas1082
    @emmas1082 2 года назад +1

    It looks like he may have spoken to her in the club and asked her to meet him outside and then he went and got his car and picked her up.

  • @angeldaniel7360
    @angeldaniel7360 2 года назад +1

    The Claremont serial killings is the name given by the media to a case involving the disappearance of an Australian woman, aged 18, and the killings of two others, aged 23 and 27, in 1996-1997. After attending night spots in Claremont, a wealthy western suburb of Perth, Western Australia, all three women disappeared in similar circumstances leading police to suspect that an unidentified serial killer was the offender