Walk The Talk with Dr Manmohan Singh
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 сен 2024
- In this week's episode, Shekhar Gupta speaks to Dr. Manmohan Singh who reminisces about his years spent at the Delhi School of Economics and how the alumni had influenced India's economic policies. He also talks about his ideas for fuelling the country's economic progress by solving various issues plaguing India's middle class, tackling rising inflation and removing poverty from the society. He also envisions an India that is a global power that nurtures talent and develops skills, hence supplying the growing economy with skilled labour.
Watch more videos: www.ndtv.com/vi...
You'll never hear Dr. Singh interrupt the reporter even once. Pure Class right there.
the reverse is not true - Shekhar Gupta frequently cuts shorts Dr. Singh
@@architdubey5196 No it is not.
One who is not of many knowledge blabbers more, Modi ji it's true on you you are too shrewd only help your friends, who can pay you in name of party funds
आप बहुत ही चतुर हैं केवल अपने दोस्तों की मदद करते हैं, जो आपको पार्टी फंड के नाम पर भुगतान कर सकते हैं
@Shan Blues How you know me I just came to the comments and I saw your comment.
@ he seems to be saying a lot in this video.
"We are democracy. But we are also undisciplined democracy." Manmohan Singh. Now the people sitting in the power can't even admit the weaknesses.
indisciplined
what weaknesses? can you elaborate?
@@HonestFeedback-gy8hu I think he meant weaknesses to maintain democracy,
I myself consider India as Autocratic.
He was a ocean of talent..
Not jus shouting and boasting..it ws pure economics..hats off to u sir
Dr.Manmohan Singh was once in a century intellectual.
We did not give respect to such a great person.
We love you Sardaar ji
"History would judge me wisely" - Dr. Manmohan Singh
+sumo WTF are you talking , he helped stabilize india's economy , you are ignorant
i dont like khatri but love manmohan kohli
Exactly..!! Also I too remember what he said.. if Modi becomes PM than it would be a disaster.. This is very much getting True.
“History would judge me wisely” Dr. Manmohan Singh
@@narayansinghbajwa1741 Why you hate Khatris , for their success .
India will never get such an intelligent and intellectual Prime Minister. I wish to meet him once in life ❤
Raghu ram rajan is also suitable for prime minister
Me too
i m AMAZED after watching this interview.....manmohan was really an eligible pm..
He was an eligible PM but proved to be most incompetent and ineligible.
@@chyaila have tea 🍵
but still he chose to be a puppet
1991 crisis
Dr. Manmohan Singh - "We will convert these crisis into an opportunity".
Isliye to 1991 me india ka currency ko 25 devalue krwa diya tha
And india ka gold girwi rakha tb jakr economy thik hua tha wo to normal person bhi india ka gold ko girwi krwa de and inr ko devakue krwa de economy pehle se behtar ho jaega
@Rohit Madhale shi kha
@Rohit Madhale baat ye hai young log beete 2-4 saalo mein news aur politics pr dhyaan dene lge hai.. aur media mein modi modi ki lehar hai..
aur population bhi unhi age group ki jayda hai.. 😕
hmesha.. hindu - muslim dharam, rahul gandhi mazak, 70 saal -70 saal bolte rehte hai sambit patra ki tarah😆
now u understand why politicians need education, not votes
Very true...
No they need votes also..... But they need to pay heed to educated experts....
And if educated experts can also get votes, then nothing like it.....
Its because Dr. Singh was not a politician that his legacy is not remembered for what it was. He should have never taken up prime ministership.
oh really?????????? 😂😂
Manmohan singh is best pm because i was in england in 2008 everybody lost job in england include me but that time india done verygood job becuese of educateted pm
he is great economist and policymaker...
Only professional people like Manmohan singh can run this great country and not politicians
and a great puppet also
@@HonestFeedback-gy8huwhy are you seeking attention everywhere
When the real economist took care of our country. There was no drama no crying worked hard behind the camera ensured interest of the country was placed above everything else. Respect.
he is the person who saved India from going to be bankrupt India could only sustain for 2-3 weeks
Fully agree
Agreed 👍
It was PV Rao who saved us at that time. Manmohan's role is often inflated to justify his appointment as prime minister.
Then what about 2G scam
Hey bhai bankruptcy ak individual ya firms ya company ki hoti😂😂😂 India Crisis se save kiya ye kaho
We need more PM and leaders like him who believe in working instead of making rhetoric statements. He is very well aware about real India and understand its economy.
😂😂
This is the first time I heard Dr Manmohan in an interview. He is so brilliant and OMG he is so eloquent. The difference between a very highly experienced gentleman and the oter who is just a entertainer for large crowds is very evident. Thanks NDTV for this interview.
6:03 Cameraman is literally going between reporter and Dr. Singh 🤣🤣
Welcome to the real world.
Watch his more videos u learn more and more
Even humble too
@@swapnilmasurekar5431No it is drone camera and zoom till Singh face. You didn't understand it
I never liked him much as a Prime minister because of my foolish limited knowledge. But Now I will cry if he leaves us.
You are really foolish
@@ankitk1455 Good riddance to Jaitley, making the DEMONetization plan, the biggest fuckup ever since Nehru gave away Pakistan!
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
agree
You watch his videos nd u will learn more and more
One of the most powerful and significant episodes of Walk the Talk show. This short 15 minutes sums up the success story of the liberalization of India and the great economic power that India has since become. Here MMS details the difficult decisions that had to be taken and the fierce opposition that they feared. MMS has had the privilege of having a rare perspective of the Indian economy because of his having risen from the ranks of bureaucracy. When he took over the reins of the finance ministry, he had already had the experience of heading the Reserve Bank as its governor. Thus a perfect blend of the executive, legislature and the political office was found in the personality of MMS. The snippet from 08:25 to 13:15 details how tough decisions were taken and also proves the power of executive action circumventing the unjust intervention of the parliament. How much can be achieved by the executive backed by a sympathetic bureaucracy ! A minority government, an unsympathetic parliament and a looming economic disaster - a perfect recipe for disaster. But then how the tables were turned! This proves that an effective executive backed by an efficient bureaucracy can with tact and quiet, firm actions overcome an unrelenting public opinion and the disadvantages of a minority government. But here a caveat is in place. Such firm actions should only be taken during an emergency which threatens national interests and not for political gains and as a means of preserving an unpopular government. This clearly establishes the PVN led government with MMS as its backbone as one of the most successful that independent India has produced- at least in the economic context . PVN could be called the second best prime minister next only to Nehru, who was another architect who shaped India's economic future in a different era and as a response to the economic compulsions of his times. But how beautifully the two sets of decisions taken in two entirely different contexts worked together in the end to produce stunning results. It is like reading a fiction where all the elements of a great story are woven together to produce a classic , only that in this case the story is one of the future of a nation consisting of one billion people. One could only hope that this miracle continues under the present Namo government and at the least , the present Namo government does not disrupt the well run,well oiled economic machinery for getting short sighted political gains. The future governments should continue this success story by timely responses to the ground realities and far sighted actions. Though it could be said that the decisions were thrust upon the PVN government of the 1990s by the stark economic realities of the times , but still a lesser government could have easily prevaricated and pushed India into an economic abyss. But that did not happen and an economic disaster was averted : Thanks to the bold actions of the PVN-MMS genius partnership.
sonny19xx Thank you so much for beautifully summarising the content of the video.
Dr.Manmohan Singh deserves Bharat ratna...Honest and hard working man...
Dr. Manmohan Singh is a genius, I used to hate him vehemently. now I ashamed of myself
Same here
Modi is good leader.
But his parties IT cell is marketing lies very effectively so manmohans image got bad
same here bro :(
it was that sonia who didnt let him work
That's y bro rightly said by IMAM ALI(a s) jiz chiz ko jaante nahi aap Oz k dusham hote Hain jab jaane lagoge toh dushmani dosti mein badal jaaye ge....yahi aap k Saath hova haa .
Such a smart and knowledgable person , I wish we had someone like him in finance ministry in times of this grave crisis , God please bless India with people with his acumen
You got 15 degree's for all over the world for economic
Like world bank, RBI, finance secretary/Minister and so on.
I am proud of you as you were the PM of India.
After the suffering of 4 years in the hands of few thugs.. .Today I realised the true value of this person... 🙏
@A GBecause a renowned economist is better than a renowned poet.
Really brdr ❤❤
even his own party never valued him and you value him?? irony 😂😂😂😂
SINGH SAHAAB THE GREAT WE ALL LOVE YOU SIR AND RESPECT YOUR KNOWLEDGE ,........LOVE YOU SIR
"Wise men speak because they have something to say; Fools because they have to say something. " --- Plato
Every country has a destiny.Our destiny led us to Dr.Singh.That was a fortunate time and what is happening now is also part of Destiny,up then down now all part of the game,although I felt pride back then now am ashamed of the snake ruling our PMO
natascha sharma is this your real picture? You look like an actress
U r right
😂
Ab Ladkiyon ko bhi samajh a raha hai kaun Achche Hain Kaun Nahi.
He is CLASS, we are currently living in a society where politicians blabber about religion, spreading fake information, misinforming own citizen, even covid curing papads; we miss people like him - with vision and class. Whatever politics says education and real mastery stands out rather mango peeling interviews
"We are living in a Indisciplined democracy" 🙏🙏🙏 well said.
Dr monmohan Singh was the great prime minister and he was educated person salute to him
This man worked 18 hours a day taking re 1 as salary! This man is a patriot when he could have been an CEO of any multinational bank.
Exactly. And currently we have a fucked up snake who I also supported. I learnt my lesson. Never any bjp rss ppl ever again
@A G basically he never do caste religion politics that Bjp and everyone is doing
@Gayatri Sahu hahaha
@A G Get well soon !
Ok...he is good but now your comments are on the blind faith side.
He is one of the best PM's India ever had...
Educated down to earth,had foresight....
And now.........
Koi burey din hi lauta do.....I remember the burey din when petrol was cheap.gas cylinders were cheap,people had jobs,people had money,people could buy things,we could change jobs at will....😭
Bhart Ka abh tak ka sabh se shareef or imaandar PM......
@
Yes
Intelligent With Economicist forever's too
@Kaliprasanna Pattnaik gandhi also was good # did some mistake but efficiency of performance was good
Pr politics sareefon ka kaam nhi h bhidu. Not a huge modi fan but a realistic person.
He also came from a very poor family. But he don't do marketing to get votes.
Bhai or bhehnoo I'm a tea seller
Yes he was a refugee from pakistani punjab during partition
Ye talent sirf ek hi person k pass h 🙄 (in his own voice) 🤭
The most spineless and chutiya PM of india...the one and only MMS
Modi had done good work too in Gujrat.. and MMS did his own work too.. and private media did business with political parties too 😅
salute to the man who added another one trillion dollar in just a period of 10 years and took out 140 million people out of poverty......hats off sir....u are the one of greatest man we have till date
273 million Indians were raised above poverty World Bank and IMF said. Just to clear
yes but pakistan is still poor country.
I'm sorry to my former pm and thankful to our present pm to make us realise the importance of our former pm
The intensity with which some people hate MMS amazes me. Is it because they know he is the greatest Indian leader.
"Some people" = BJP and Modi supporters.
It is law of nature, quality is always less.
One act of saving Indian economy still does not justify allowing rampant corruption. It is as if he saved Indian economy so he got a license to let it destroy.
One act? the most important act . The act that if it had failed could have brought the whole country to its knees... And what rampant corruption are you talking about.. the 2G scam where only Anil Ambani made money and is still making money hand over feast with special access to PM where ever he goes. I think rampant corruption is happening after 2014 with Demo and all the deals that are done without following due process.
@@chyaila all those scams are propaganda of BJP.
Read the history of those scams u ll understand
What have we done for ourselves!
History will be very much kinder to you sir.
I am sorry Mr prime minister for opposing your policies on social media in past
you never did because your love for congress is known , do not post comments
I'm also Firoz
@@bharalinipon2 अखिर कर हमारी मेहनत सफ़ल हुई, हमने खोज ही लिया चतुर चओक़ीदार प्रधान मंत्री जनता को दिन दिहाड़े मूर्ख बना के जनता को लूटने वाला
m also
History will be kinder to me than the media❣❣❣M.singh
I still Remember his word when he departure from prime ministership "History will kind to me"....My One of the great leader
He also said Modi will be a disaster
I would like to say only one word about him Mr Honest
I thought Manmohan ji very shy to talk.... but watching this interview that I'm wrong....great to see you sir
such a wise, humble man who rose from a very simple background, long live Sir....
One thing is for sure that only well educated and humble person can run economy in leaps and bounds. Dr. Manmohan Singh was one and only one intellectual person who retained and maintained economy in true terms. Salute to you Sir for your selfless services. GBU.
great economist of his time. He was able to bring economic reforms in 1992. Public and private investment in India is due to him till date. I have a great regret for this.
He is my teacher 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
I still remember how generous and patient he was with the students 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏..
How fortunate you are
U r extremely fortunate sir !! 😊
Great 👍.
You must have learned good economic
Nice joke
I am stunned by the speed of words coming out of his mouth ... wowww
Don't Blame Others for your Years of Sleep.
Romi Buzz definition of typical indian politician
That's all it took?
+Varun Gupta its 11 years old interview 2004. Its not recent
+Varun Gupta Well I don't know your qualification, but posting comment about MMS , some times ignorance is a bliss.God bless you in your lifes journey.
A great leader, educator and economist. We need more leaders like MMS in India today!! 😎
Father of Modern Indian economic reform.
who said that ?
Missing such brilliant people in Indian politics for 7 years now. Dr.Singh was truly a man with a brain and heart.
Mr. Shekhar Gupta...Would you please learn to listen? He's your Daddy..Let him speak...
Dr Manmohan Singh is Gene
True
Sir he is Gupta you know he is DO YOU REMEMBER ANY GUPTA PARTY? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Seriously!
Here after 2%gdp fall,as his prediction,true gem
Great Respect for the great economist Dr. Manmohan Singh.
Man with uncommon knowledge, now everyone realising his worth!
BJP government should take opinion from manmohan singhji for economic crisis they are facing.
Toshir Shende agreed...
Toshir Shende totally agreed, India must tap in it's economics intelligentsia like Prof Manmohan singh and Prof. Amartya sen, god even Raghuram rajan was a very able and deserving economist❤
BJP during the time of XPM Atal Bihari ji he appreciated and followed all decisions taken by him
And India would be a better place. But then their ego..
I agree with you @Toshir
I am proud that he was my PM but now I am ashamed that Modi is my PM Modi has no level in front of this man
Hearing about 1991, is really interesting. P V Narsimharao, should be remembered more often for the turn around.
1991 reforms were the brain child of Manmohan Singh.
Narasimha Rao made these reforms a reality. In short, formulated by Singh and effectively implemented by Rao.
Shikhar Srivastava Dr singh is the one who came up with....... Maybe he was ruling PM @ that time but I think Man behind was Mr. Singh having larger goals for economy.....!
Seriously i came on RUclips for views of Economist over Demonetisation ....
Assainar V ! You changed the order. It is - formulated by Rao and effectively implemented by Singh.
And this man
When u ask him about politics he keep his mouth shut when u ask him about knowledge he can't stop talking.he know politics is dirty..legend
I am filled with emotions, bitter and sweet, while watching this talk. Here is one of the finest economists, scholars, teachers of India. The only thing that prevented him from being the finest prime minister was Sonia Gandhi. If only he was allowed to make all the decisions during his time. I despise the congress leadership of today for forsaking talent and the country for petty interests. The congress, as it exists today, needs to perish. This is not the congress which pandit nehru or patel ji were a part of. This is not the party which provided the administrative setup for us to achieve independence. This is a bunch of incompetent politicians concerned only with their petty interests.
True, poor Manmohan had to take all the blame of Sonia and Rahul's misdeeds.
girlfromsmalltowndel yup Manmohan presented a bill which could have prevented criminal case candidate from contesting elections but Rahul teared that bill
girlfromsmalltowndel
I like your comments but I would like to tell you that it is soniya gandhi who offered prime minister seat to Honourable dr manmohan singh
It was Sonia Gandhi who offered him the top job. Sonia Gandhi could have easily become the prime minister. It was her generosity. Do you think a man of the stature of Dr Manmohan Singh would be under pressure from Sonia Gandhi? If that was the case, he could have resigned any time.
Its our duty to elect competent politicians. Don't be so pesimist becuase in a multiparty democracy we seldom get majority of competent people in a single party. Its better to start from our own constituency which will help parliament to do it right when it comes to chose the leader. It might take some time but it needs to happen this way. Thank you.
His politeness though😇😇😇his voice is so soft👳🏼♂️👳🏼♂️👳🏼♂️
No one like Dr Manmohan Singh! Salute 👏
Vipashayana Tanwar who is your 'no one'?
khas kar dangha BABU....
Because people Love him
What an amazing person is your ex pm! Respect from Bangladesh.
Today my mam told me to see walk and talk with manmohan singh so let me tell u I'm amazed by this person really respect 🙏🙏🙏
Great. Name of hr teacher plz?
Who's watching it after India's economy is destroyed
I know, right. From an annual GDP growth rate of 8.3% in 2017, India's economic growth rate in the first quarter (Jan-Mar) of 2020, has almost gotten halved, down to 4.2%. This downwards trend has continued for the past 3 years, but to no avail.
The Govt. & Media are totally silent on this.
@@amanshukla8758 ye buddy can't do anything now...just wait for more 4 years I guess..sucks
While countries like Vietnam & Bangladesh grew with rates of 7% and 8% respectively in 2019, India has been slowing consistently, being at 5% in 2019.
India is also running out of time, because our economic growth window ends in 2050, and so the more time we lose, the lesser we will be able to develop at the end of it.
@@amanshukla8758 yep..I know ..beleive in the system and just keep working
People of India really need to stop squabbling about useless issues like Hindu-Muslim or Mandir-Masjid etc. but should rather focus on the economy, development, education & healthcare.
Back in 1990, the economies of both India & China were roughly in the same condition, around 350 Billion USD each, but now, in 2020, China's economy is a whopping 14 Trillion USD, while India's economy is a mere 3 Trillion USD. (I used "mere" since look at this figure relative to population)
learned man, fine person,great economist, futuristic thinker. proud of you sir...... best pm. salute you sir.
History has indeed been kinder to him
Undoubtedly
We need honest PM like You sir 🥺 , extremely disappointed that we underestimated you 😭!
Ohh my god🌼 listening his words is like a breath of fresh air to me !!
Such a talented, educated person 🌼
India needs you sir😭
Bless you sir !!
We really want a prime minister like Shri Manmohan Singh again
What a Gentleman !!! Sorry Dr.Singh !! Glti shaid humse hui khi !! Apki toh ek ek bat sch ho rhi hai !!
Chaiwala, see what he has got in his head. He is a gem. What are you? Destroyed the economy. Dr Singh Ji, please come back. You are the forever thrust to India. Historians will bow down to your frameworks and policies which made India a global player. You will be in the good books of India forever and ever.
Genius. India needs him more than ever now.
The best and most educated, talented PM in the world....
I miss him very much.. those days were soo peaceful
World Best economists and Honest Person. Salute you Sir .
Dr.manmohan singh is genius , educated and positive mind person
Slowly and steadily, people will realize that he was best.
Surinder Singh The people realised this long ago. I realised my mistake of voting for the snake oil salesman in 2017 itself.
Really miss him today. 😭😭😭
wow! such an intelligent person! because of him today India is the 5th largest economy in the world! salute to you sir, you made India proud internationally!
The immense contribution of Dr. Singh to India’s economic acceleration is unmatchable. His understanding and commitment to a fledgling economy, lack of bitterness to adversaries always reflected his greatness. Even today his understanding of India and it’s complexities and solutions are the best!
What a class person....why indians replaced him..i want a person like him again as my pm
Gandhi family made him look clown..
BJP has a massive propaganda machinery! And people are morons!
@@RoNसिंह true
Modi handling the camera, wants to see an educated man from every angle.
😂
🤣
wah bete mauj kr di
Best comment
Lol
Modi ji atleast better than fool manmohan you people are blindly following you master you andhmullas manmohan would anyways carry the camera wherever Modi ji would go on a foreign trip 😂
the classroom and the surroundings are very different now..!!!it is my classroom....!!!!!!
The more I have know about Dr. Manmohan Singh, more respect I have for him. It seems the Biggest issue with India at hand is Uneducated Arrogant People. Such people who have an abstract or no definite perspective of the world around them, they're sheep who follow bigots. It's their collective feebleness that has led to days in which Bharat has been the lowest.
I agree Modi is arrogant but Gujrat developed in his rule , wou can't deny that and manmohan singh was not working independently , sonia gandhi was pressuring him and he doesn't spoke against corruptions in his regime . Also foreign policy was weak .
World got the msg here comes the government, despite being the minority government , it is capable of taking the toughest decision. Hats off to pvm rao and mms
+Gaurav Jain still this MOdi Gov cant do anything for India.
agree or not Modi is nothing compared to dr. Manmohan singh's level of intelligence
That's debatable. Depends on how one defines intelligence. I have huge respect for PM Manmohan Singh, as the PM, economist and as a human being. But the comparison you make is flawed.
the cameraman is drunk
ha ha ha
ha ha really true
😂😂😂😂😂
yes bro
You got it bro
So humble..so intelligent and dedicated to his nation..salute you sir
When i was too young and fool , i used to dislike Dr. Manmohan Singh , called him corrupt . I am ashamed of my ignorance.
The morons who abuse Dr. Singh should read about his contribution in 1991 liberarlilzation
hats off to mr. manmohan singh as best pm till date.
what a great genius. The copy cat chaiwalla is no match to this great man. Its all right, every dog has his day.
pragasam ramaswamy In trying to acknowledge Dr. Singh, don't disrespect ur PM..
Looks as if u have very less respect to give to other...
Taking equal amount from Mr. MODI and giving it to Dr. Singh.
Hey, dont insult dogs.
stuff your respect where the sun don't shine. this mindless 'respect' has destroyed the country.
Mind your language.....don't insult dogs...
My thought about monmohan sigh had been changed after listening his immensely conversation with this reporter
Looking India from abroad Dr Manmohan Singh made India a place to invest, his polices and action made India what it is today the growth and development of today is due to his government opening up to foreign investment opportunities.
Such a well spoken guy----wish Indians give him his rightful due
Finally heard his voice... My life is fulfilled....
I always Respect Dr. Manmohan Singh Sir as he was not just a Great Finance and Prime Minister but also a Decent and Kind Personality who used to accept the criticism of his policies and consider changes in it. He was the transformer of India in terms of Economic and Financial Development which results that he was Strong Prime Minister of India as he did the most Press Conferences in his ten year term which non of the Prime Ministers did. For him Country's Development was more important than his party.
Manmohan Singh is the 'Artist of Modern India'.
People who hate him needlessly should see his work before uttering the words against him.
Look at the class of this man
Just look at his quotations and mentions through out the interview. Every point he made was logical. Its sad people made fun of him. He was a great teacher and some students are now well established because of him
😭😭😭 Dr Manmohan Singh is real gem 💎 & I vote against him I feel ashame for what I have done
Manmohan is great he should have joined other party..congress ruined him ..he is great economist
2019 if Manmohan sir is ready to join as finance minister then this is the only chance congress wins. He is genius
He saved our countrys economy in 1990 ,1991-1996 ,1996-1998 ,2004-2014 in different roles in government. He should get Bharat ratna for the economic achievement country. He is the greatest finance minister india ever had .