To The Point: Manmohan Singh Speaks About Kalam
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 июн 2024
- Former Prime Minister, Dr. Manmohan Singh has finally decided to break his silence post the end of his tenure of PM. In this interview with Karan Thapar, Singh speaks about former President A. P. J. Abdul Kalam.
Follow us:
RUclips: / @indiatoday
Twitter: / indiatoday
Facebook: / indiatoday
History will judge him more fairly than present generation a great man a well mannered,a well educated great economist and intellectual
@Abhishek Chhillar nope....he will be forgetton as narishama rao whose histories was buried....fake gandhis would make sure this happen
@@colddaniel4266 Narashima rao will never be forgotten. indian communities abroad or atleast the telugu folk remember him every year on his birthday. not everything is in fake gandhis. why are we bothered so much even after they dont matter in current affairs
@@vijaykumaruba totally agreed sir
Ahhaa I found you on RUclips. Exciting
Never Compare jumlebaaz Modi with such a Respected personality like Manmohan Singh.
100%
Agree with you
True. But manmohan singh was puppet to gandhi family
@@circleoflife3749 But that's a whole different issue.
He's corrupt. That was the biggest problem with him.
words " I served him for 3 years as prime minister " that show everything about Sir Manmohan Singh..take a bow
Who says he doesn't speak..
He speaks when needed
When ordered.
kmc yasaswi Tu chutia hae 😂😂😂😂
He hasn't eny feeling while he says.
@@kmcyasaswi243 but legends speak only facing teleprompter
I get a impression that the he speaks or share his views in meeting and not a dramebaaz in front of public unlike current regime of tadipar/hitler.
He must have done something right for sure that why we have 8+ % gdp in most of his tenure unlike the government before or after him
Times when we had Dr. Singh as PM and Dr. Kalam as President!
Miss those peaceful days😑
true man, we were the best.
Miss those days when Atalji was our pm and Kalam sir was our President....
Manmohan Singh is nowhere in front of Atalji❤️🇮🇳
@@benzene1933 hahahahaha ....... Similarly bhagva rang ki tattti se nikla modi is nothing in front of Dr. MANMOHAN SINGH
@@benzene1933 atleast better than modi
An economist PM was the pride of India. His silence saved India from the great economic disaster of the from 2008to 2011. He is a great nation builder. Nation is indebted to him.
A mess and poor country he saved, that could really be broken by financial crises! He is better cuz no one in his position could do anywhere near him even if they caught all corrupt aasholes and etc... The end result, stabelity and prosperity couldn't reach his level!
@Dust screen you're right that's better.
True.. actually the 2008 recession was massive... just like how Obama saved US but nobody gave him the credit here no Modians are giving him credit for the Herculean task he did so that the common man didn't have to face the true girth of the recession. True there were failures from his part... but there is not much humans can do for it... we are not Gods to be flawless.
I recently only got to know about economics and how important Manmohan Singh and Kalam was for India. I am not against BJP they too ve some good things done.. but BJP has no right to even point a finger let alone use mouth against Manmohan Singh jee.. such a pure and decent man who only wished to save India every second here is on earth
Nation can't be indebted to a citizen.
yeah civilians can be but not nation.
Fact✍️😊📜
Jai Ram
my Indian beloved brothers
he was the best Finance minister from 1990-1996 and he is great and intellectual PM from 2004-2014, he was the great visioner for India ever seen
Can you please give me some insight about his great vision for India and the actions he took in that direction.
@@anujkhanna2428 read budgets he has presented during his stint as FM. Analyse his decision during that period and their impact on the economy. Check the foreign exchange reserve of India after 1990. You will know atleast something.
@@anujkhanna2428it's astonishing that you aren't acquainted with what Dr Manmohan Singh has done for this country. He is the one who was leading the committee for economic liberalisation in India 1991. When India was under heap of debt, he helped economy to overcome from debt of IMF. He was finance minister at that time.
His family elders got butchered in partition riots when he came from West Punjab in 1947 bare handed, yet he decided to study and reach new heights, his determination and willingness to learn never stopped.
His name got globally acknowledged when Oxford University itself launched scholarship on his name to honour him.
Mr Singh also got invitations from several international well known top tier universities to become professor of economics. He declined all offers and preferred to serve India.
Before the enactment of liberalisation policy, there was no MNC operating in India. So without any doubt, you can say that silicon valley and BPO hub of Pune and Gurgaon respectively are gift of his policy to youth of this nation.
If you find any information dubious, check international sources and Wikipedia.
Thanks
@@shaktiman5102 I have writen and elaborate reply to Mr.Kuljit,where I have put forward the facts that show the atrocities india had to face due to him.
If you are really interested in having a debate based of facts then please do read it.
Otherwise your wish,you life.
I will pray for your happiness.
@@anujkhanna2428 ACTUALLY MR. ANUJ DOES NOT KNOW THAT IN 1991-92 OUR COUNTRY WAS IN VERY BAD ECONOMICS ANX ALMOST LOST , VERY HEAVY DEBTS, WHEN MR. SINGH GOT THE CHARGE HE STARTED OPEN TRADE AND, HE PASSED THE BILL TO ANY INDIAN CAN BRING 5 KG GOLD FROM ANY COUNTRY WITHOUT CUSTOM DUTY , IN THIS WAY LOT OF BLACK MONEY ACCESSED AND LOT OF GOLD IN OUR COUNTRY AND OUR ECONOMY STARTED TO GOJNG FOR RECOVERY VERY FARSTLY OK THIS IS WAY OF QUALIFIED PERSON AND NOW CHAIWALA MODI AND TADIPAAR HOME MINISTER OK BABY WHAT U EXPECT FROM BJP
1st time ever Karan was so respectful to anyone never heard single word stressed by him. Also such deep intellect n knowledge of Mr. Singh. No doubt he is one of Most humble person in hot seat.
I was thinking the same he is so impatient and interrupts always but when true intellect in front of him he has to listen
Very true
Pretty sure Modi won't even understand what Karan asks. Manmohan Jii.. very sorry that we the people couldn't support your true faith and cause. We fell for false promises, we fell for baits even while you tried to warn us. Again I m still not saying our current Government is bad.. but as the leader of a Nation Manmohan ji.. your silence was way too meaningful that we petty fools couldn't grasp it
Singly he is good & his loyality to dynasty family is not good to us. So Congress cannot run without. Dynasty we need without dynasty, we given him as he can work like P.V. Narsimha Rao, how he showed his Loyality to country. But this gentle man showed his loyality to dynasty so we has to leave him.
I grew my respect towards Dr. Manmohan Singh, he is a statesman.
He's a states man not a politician
we can’t even compare that notanki modi with this great guy.......one of the best prime minister for our country a well educated man and with lot of knowledge and sincerity salute from 🇦🇺
Honorable Anureet ji, it's a bad luck from indian educational teachers they started teaching with comparison and unfortunately ends our life with comparison. No one told how to use this comparison as tool for knowledge but it has used as tool to criticize other for establishing their own egoistic image in front of others mentality. Hope God bless you madamji.
For me, Dr. Singh was the most educated PM India had seen till date.
He was the most qualified prime minister or president of any country in the world other than APJ.
Absulaty right
more than nehru ?
@@ssachdeva31 @@ssachdeva31 obviously
manmohan qualifications:
Panjab University (BA, MA) University of Cambridge (BA) University of Oxford (DPhil)
nehru qualification:
Nehru went to Trinity College, Cambridge, in October 1907 and graduated with an honours degree in natural science in 1910. During this period, he studied politics, economics, history and literature with little interest
lol nehru's education ended in 1910
when syllabus was fucking easy
and cheating in exams was like daily routine.
manmohan was way more educated than nehru.
i still wish subhas chandra bose was india's first pm
Subhas Chandra Bose studied in Calcutta (Kolkata) at the Presidency College and the Scottish Churches College. His parents then sent him to the University of Cambridge in England to prepare for the Indian Civil Service. He passed the civil service examination but resigned his candidacy and returned to India after hearing of nationalist turmoils there.
netaji subhas chandra bose way more educated than 70 percent indians and 98 percent politicians in india.
if netaji subhas chandra bose was india's first pm
india would have been superpower today
way more stronger than usa russia and kuwait combined.
india has one of the most powerful weapon in world
parmanu nuclear bomb
if netaji subhas chandra bose was india's first pm
he would have made multiple nuclear boms way more powerful than parmanu he would have run multiple nuclear tests
he would have showcased world and countries like usa and russia
the power of the India
India would have been strongest country in the fucking world
still today we have parmanu what has the ruling goverment done of it???
nothing
they have just stored it and decorated it beautifully in a fucking military base.
wtf
we have one of the best gold mine in the fucking world - kolar gold mine(kgf)
and what have we done of it??
closed the mine
wow man wow
salute to ruling party and indian goverment wow
if netaji subhas chandra bose was india's first pm
he would have used the gold mines in india
and extracted gold
export to powerful country in world
like usa and russia
and would have earned trillions
he would have made india's gdp
highest gdp in the fucking world.
then
1 INR= 4 KWD
1 INR= 80 USD
if netaji subhas chandra bose was india's first pm
india will not be on 50th rank in democracy
india would have been no.1 democratic country in the fucking world.
if netaji subhas chandra bose was alive and india's first pm
india today
would have
the world's richest country
the world's best democratic country
even if netaji bose was first pm of india
he would have mainted hygene at all over india and one of the 7 wonders in world taj mahal.
india would have been
the world's best tourist country
the world's best gold exporter
THE WORLD'S MOST POWERFUL COUNTRY.
For everyone honestly
A great soul Manmohanji. He neither had any greed for power nor had he any desire of Self-Publicity. We will be fortunate to get a PM like him in future. G Madhab Choudhury.
Number one prime minster I see in my life down to earth good human being
Those who say he is not sardar. First need to know that he is a true sikh more sikh than other sikh politicians in todays age.
He has done tremendous work all his life for growth of indian people and economy.
Loud words not necessarily represent Good.
May god give him good health and more service to the nation.
Nobody said he's not a sardar.
Are you idiot ??
Why you think he is not Sikh.
Get on some real issues bro, get out of religion and focus on real life
Look at his answering skills..this should be way.. very articulate not more not less..just perfect!! Respect him..he maintained the diginity of a PM!!and now look at modi..just ruined a whole lot of things!!
I m 100% at one with u. Gopi Madhab Choudhury.
The crisp answers he was giving for questions were amazing. These skills are really very important for UPSC interviews.
When we lost our love then we realize his importance in our life.... Manmohan singh ji like our lost love.... India needs like Manmohan singh ji people's
@Dust screen italian??? we thought she is Indian bahu n wife of Rajiv gandi ji n she won the p.m seat but gave her seat to great economist n most educated person well bahaved person Shri manmohan Singh ji 🙏please do some research Italian never entered in politics on her own we people grabbed her forcefully she was never interested in politics nor p.m seat I beg u to watch Sonia gandi ji biography in study iq please I'm not requesting you to like her but if u know some truth of her it will be worth talking as we belongs to Indian good culture I hope you don't mind🙏
Respects to Sir Manmohan Singh
Only PM who constantly spoke about Spirituality in so many places .. it shows your true Spiritual side sir 🙏🙏🙏🙏
The golden era of India's Democracy and Institutions.
Those golden days when we had Dr.Kalam as President and Dr.Manmohan Singh as Prime Minister...
one of the finest pm of india.
he gave so much power to common ppl.
Agreed!
@@anujp7554 Unfortunately he had to listen to Sonia still he did his best,
The best President ever of all times and the great Prime Minister we all Indians should feel proud of. I can never forget President Kalam sitting on the floor having mid-day meals with underprivileged scool children in Bangalore.
We realize the true value of a person only when we lose them and when out of power..
Now we have jhumla pm and vote bank emphasised president
I m 100% at one with u. gopi Madhab Choudhury.
Does ur species still exist??
I thought u were extinct in India.
kmc yasaswi when ur species ( species of Godse ) can exist then why can’t Gandhi
incredible PM. kalam+monmohan was the best combination
Yes exactly
Haven't been a weak PM, history will be kinder to me: Manmohan Singh
Dr. Manmohan Singh & Dr. Kalam are evergreen icons!!
always enlightened listening to an intellectual personality like Manmohan singh.
manmohan singh is honest true and bst pm of our country
I still respect this man.....he is a right man in wrong profession or may be right profession in wrong country
plank god......... Absolutely right
Right profession in wrong country brother
@Big Foot oky
I wholeheartedly feel that Dr. Manmohan Singh rightly deserves Bharat Ratna. After serving India for so many long years ( more than 40 yrs, as public figure) and steering our country to developmental path he truly deserves.
He didn't won't use any hard words to make allegations on BJP. He just advised and will advise the govt to do like this or this way will be a success. He just being a teacher. He won't scold anyone. He kept respect and advise when BJP did wrong . He is really a great person ever. The world's best INTELLCTUAL PM is our MANMOHAN SINGH. Indian mother knows u Sir. U r the best son of Our BHARAT MATA who cared her well. U r the son Who cared and treated everyone( hindu, Muslim, Christian, Sikh, Buddhist) equally . U r one and only great human being ever in the world. Miss u sir 😓😓😓😓😓😓
Dr APJ Abdul Kalam and Dr Manmohan Singh both well educated, civilised, mannerly and their mutual trust is a living symbol of secularism.
See his atticates manners way of talking.....evergreen historic great PM of our country .....may god give him long and healthy life
i love u sir.....frm uttarakhand........god bless u.....sir
Great respect for this humble and highly intellectual personality. India needs people like Dr. Abdul Kalam n Dr. Manmohan singh
His words when losing 2014 people will remember my contribution that’s true ! Only gentle man will understand who’s is best Modi or Manmohan
superb interview.thanx karan for letting living legend speak about another legend who is no more now.pranams manohan sir.thank u for being our PM.
sir you are great even I am part of south India .
Greatest pm India ever had ...love from 🇬🇧
All hails to Dr. Manmohan Singh ♥️
What a gem of a person
MMS really balanced person. Love to hear him.
How humble and respectable Dr Singh is, is clearly reflected in the body language of an interviewer like Karan Thapar who can roast anyone any time he wants to
Wao, Such a Great Leader with Great Memories! India will Miss Such Leadership Forever
pm singh is just always motivational most respected man in world
What an amazing elegant speaker the former PM of India is wow amazing interview
now thats an interview ...not scripted ...statesman like ...he was the best thing happened to our country ...history do is very kind to him, deservedly
Indian must realize the fact that not all politicians are not be playing politics. He is the greatest Economic scientist ever, would have got better respect and life if we're outside the country.
No one can be as great as Dr.Singh,
yes this man is a legend
but whatever little he managed to do with his hands tied behind. ... the nation should have the respect for him... he did mange to put the economy in the right direction
Great econamist . when he was giving speech hole world will look at manmohan. In hard times he manage our econamics ,1990 period
We r missing u sir as pm.. Love and respect to dr. Singh and late Mr. Abdul kalam sir
Dr Abdul Kalam
less spoken of course par bande mein dumm tha without him our country would have not been a emerging power in 1991
We want leaders like dr. Manmohan singh and dr.apj abdul kalam
such a great personality..
Incredible prime minister.
Sorry Dr Manmohan Sir.
We were fools.
The best time India ever had was when it had the best PM Dr. Manmohan Singh, and Dr. Kalam as the best President. Both down to earth, honest, intellectual personalities, and striving truly to make India a developed nation. A BIG SALUTE and HUGE RESPECT to both!
History is kinder to you MR SINGH 🙏
This Singh is real king... He was calm composed pm... A school boy bully image does not mean a strong pm.. He character also portrays that he was too a strong personality.. Visionary Modi has a different image than him... Both are having equal strength of leading this country in their own way.
Best period for JK IN 2009-2014
Its difficult to believe that once great people like Dr Singh and Dr Kalam were power India and built nation at great high...
You are an iconic legend to be saluted forever sir ..lots of 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏health and wishes with tons of respect 🙏🙏🙏🙏
He speaks less but he speaks correct and logic
When median don't follow the script to interview PM. Those days were great....
grt dr singh...u rescued india frm grt economic recession durng 1991,_92👌
Saat janm me bhi modi inke jaisa gyani, well spoken, deserving prime minister nai ban sakte.
Ghinn aati hai modi par jo inka mazak udaate the udaate hain woh.....
Indeed history has been kinder to you😔
what a downfall from MMS to Modi
I feel sorry for having judged him so harshly because of a certain party's IT cell fabricated propaganda
Ur great Sir
From Darjeeling
La Jawaab personality.
Manmohan Ji, Good one! other politicians should learn how to answer the controversial questions! very wise !
koi insan k chup rehne ki bs do wjh ho skti hai. ya to wo bht jaanta hai, ya phir wo kuch nai jaanta hai... manmohansingh ko maine ab jaana h
11:33 I can't disclose that because I sworn secrecy oath.
Peter Mundackal: A man of few words, Mr Singh, unlike several politicians of the day, speaks to the point. Of course, he is not a politician of the usual type.
Whenever I watch Karan Thapar's show then one sentence comes in my mind "dosti bani rahe" 😁😁😁😅
I came here to listen “aam kaise khate ho” ... totally disappointed...😀😀😀
Copryt ajyega modiji se
He only speaks when require. Modi made fun of him many times even didn't know about his work he did for our nation. He was great PM. If he'll come back in elections then modi will lose. Rahul can't do anything.
Great respect to the best prime minister of India.
An educated pm of india who was not always running after camera all the day, never gave big talks, never tried to get cheap publicity, always tried to listen common men "man ki baat".....we miss you sir 😭
Perfect prime minster!
He is such a gentleman
....... Luv u sir
Time will remember him as a great personality not of India only but whole of the world I think.
Jai Hind
Salute to you all 🙏
Such a humble human being
Hail Manmohan, Holy Singh, Amen,🙏🏻
Thorough gentleman& a professional
Dr. SINGH : Real spirit of Indian Economy
Modi : faku , illiterate PM
History would’ be kind to him! One of the best PMs and the architect of modern India !!!
Both Dr Kalam and Dr Singh are the true diamonds of India.
miss u sir
Dr. Manmohan. Ji. Very. Lucky. Of india. And. Very. Minded.
why not congress done marketing in contradiction of present govt. to win the heart of people of india like NDA does(fekna, jumla, promises, wrong history etc)can congress govt do?
because they belive in gandhi and nehru ideology...they won't endorse what they have done in clear cut way..only few things they will do it..and they adopted welfarism policy and they can't ignore it...
@@chprashanth4216 may be
He was the best prime minister of India.
Jatan Singh really
Shajajh Bshdhdh duhhhh bhakt, stop listening to Arnab and paid media and use ur brain cells, hopefully u will realise
Modi is no where near intellectual level of manmohan singh and choice of words he has in his vocab
What result have been yeiĺded from Bofors, 2G, colgat , vadra land scam? These ate only propoganda to maline congress- What are happening now? Adani .. Ambani, Nirab Modi, Bank scams, Demonitisation, Raffle deals, and many others?
Sarabjeet Singh u r really correct...
To be honest, Manmohan Singh ji is an incomparable person.....
Ya but modi at least not puppet of any queen. He is man of his own destiny.
sadly that is not enough to run a country.
Dr MMS class and modi crass
One of the best PM those who say he did not speak dare to read 6 volume book changing india by dr singh
Great people always Salam