Manila Dialogue on the South China Sea: Should the world care about the rule of law?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 ноя 2024

Комментарии •

  • @rhodeldalit6931
    @rhodeldalit6931 10 дней назад +12

    God is with us Filipinos

  • @gokongweirobin7920
    @gokongweirobin7920 10 дней назад +19

    Ma'am Professor Lei, I think everything would be settled if China just follow the rule of law.

  • @PDVlog473
    @PDVlog473 12 дней назад +17

    Nice sharing Mam your vlogs very much appreciated 👍 enjoy ako thanks thanks again MR. PRESIDENT MARCOS FOREVER MARCOS LIFE TIME ❤❤❤🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭🙏

    • @Minnie--ru2ew
      @Minnie--ru2ew 9 дней назад +2

      I hope you don’t mean that Marcos will be a “lifetime president”. Coz if so, then that is a mindset that turns a democratic republic to a dictatorship. You don’t want to go there. Analyze your statement. This is why the Philippines can’t move forward.

    • @maggieeugenio9848
      @maggieeugenio9848 9 дней назад

      ​​@@Minnie--ru2ewit depends on who is ruling, another term for PBBM is pretty much appreciated because i believed he's doing good in his position. I don't mind at all just so he could be able to finish his jobs to satisfaction. Mind my grammar thanks! 😘

  • @juanpedrosantiago
    @juanpedrosantiago 12 дней назад +20

    I am surprised with presentaion of Lei. Its out of logic, zero understsnding of fhe international law, no account of what her country is doing, total ignorance of what she is saying, blind follower

  • @leonidesjocsoncasibo7872
    @leonidesjocsoncasibo7872 14 дней назад +27

    Laws were agreed by all nations (UNCLOS) every nations has its own EEZ. China bends these rules to assert its interest.

    • @hitthedeck4115
      @hitthedeck4115 14 дней назад +3

      Yes, and there's unfortunately no world police or world government to reprimand China, so the law of the jungle applies.

    • @TuanTran-h5f
      @TuanTran-h5f 13 дней назад

      ​@@hitthedeck4115do you apply your critique on all countries or do you just cherry pick which countries to criticize? I'm guessing some countries are immune from being criticize from you even if they were committing genocide or complicit in genocide. That's the kind of person you are. Lol

    • @hitthedeck4115
      @hitthedeck4115 13 дней назад

      @@TuanTran-h5f What I said is a matter of fact and you probably got it wrong. It means that you can only respond with force to China since it can do anything it wants.

    • @besarlim781
      @besarlim781 12 дней назад +2

      There is EEZ and there is territorial claims. The PCA could not resolve this.

    • @vlogsfavorsphileco8788
      @vlogsfavorsphileco8788 10 дней назад

      ​@@TuanTran-h5fso that is the doctrine CCP Injected in your brain and made yo like having a modified mentality than normal..that you don't listen to fair reasonings but to CCP !

  • @MrSamurailanx
    @MrSamurailanx 13 дней назад +13

    Prof Lei are you really a professor. It seems you don't unders international law.

  • @nashrodriguez6114
    @nashrodriguez6114 9 дней назад +6

    She mentioned about agreement. I think she's talking about the chinese draft with which the Philippines did not agree because they were demanding for the removal BRP Sierra Madre from the shoal. There was nothing agreed when one of the parties disagree with the proposal

  • @juanpedrosantiago
    @juanpedrosantiago 12 дней назад +9

    March 2021: The Philippines filed several diplomatic protests regarding the presence of Chinese maritime militia vessels at Julian Felipe Reef (Whitsun Reef), asserting its rights over this area within its EEZ.
    May 2023: Protests were filed over Chinese vessels’ actions at Ayungin Shoal (Second Thomas Shoal) to block and harass Philippine supply boats.

  • @EmmanTorino
    @EmmanTorino 10 дней назад +9

    why not change the existing name of South China Sea to SouthEast Asia Sea?

  • @ameenatalabucon1727
    @ameenatalabucon1727 9 дней назад +2

    Be blessed Philippines 🇵🇭🌍🙏🏻✨✨✨💥💥💥🌈🌈🌈🕊️🕊️🕊️🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

  • @bienvenidojr.calauod7910
    @bienvenidojr.calauod7910 8 дней назад +4

    The problem about china sea is the greedyness of china,greed is the most dangerous sin.ph eez or WPS is for the Philippines.

  • @gerardodemesa6936
    @gerardodemesa6936 10 дней назад +7

    Why china doing that to the phil. Like water canon rashing chip that is not there tiretory.

  • @1371jerald
    @1371jerald 9 дней назад +7

    Shame on you CCP China 😁😆🤣

  • @teddycanonoy5202
    @teddycanonoy5202 7 дней назад

    A dialogue should be among and between nations involved in the south china sea issue.

  • @RogerCuenzaJr
    @RogerCuenzaJr 9 дней назад +8

    Professor Lei, no wonder you family name is lei... It means you are a lei... We are talking here international law!!! What are you talking about??? Your out of context!!!

    • @Minnie--ru2ew
      @Minnie--ru2ew 9 дней назад

      Lei lied.

    • @jimNavz3154
      @jimNavz3154 9 дней назад +1

      Lei if ur name is rumbled , it will become Lie and liars will go to hell 😅

    • @Anitwynne
      @Anitwynne 8 дней назад

      Ha ha it resonated 😅

  • @melchorfranco8659
    @melchorfranco8659 9 дней назад +2

    It's not a collision, co llision means two ships collide but the Chinese coastguard rammed the Philippines coastguard vessel intentionally.

  • @EduardoLayug
    @EduardoLayug 8 дней назад +1

    Rules based international, sustaine rule-governed interaction among sovereign states and non-states actors in their pursuit of individual and collective goals

  • @antoniopornea6531
    @antoniopornea6531 8 дней назад +1

    Is prof Lei knowledgeable and objective enough to annswer complicated questions involving the dynamics of geopolitics in the China sea.? I think shes not an expert in international law and has no business being present in this forum .

  • @titof7191
    @titof7191 9 дней назад

    I don’t care if y know the International law or fisherfolk, who supports the EEZ of the Philippines, our economy and citizens is supered for this matter.

  • @Minnie--ru2ew
    @Minnie--ru2ew 9 дней назад +1

    Are you crazy Lei?! You won’t allow those Filipinos to supply their military in the grounded ship?! “China exercised restraint”. Restraint?! By restraint, do you mean attacking these men in their boats within their EEZ?! Are you thinking it right?! Boy! Sounds like talking to a wall, here. 🙄

  • @TheresaParrott-ew9yp
    @TheresaParrott-ew9yp 8 дней назад

    Miss Professor Lei , china coast guard,
    Is stopping Filipino fisherman and
    Philippine Coast Guard.
    But that is inside the Philippines.

  • @bienvenidojr.calauod7910
    @bienvenidojr.calauod7910 9 дней назад

    Unclos must take actions,not only the Philippines who was awarded by that law,

  • @Minnie--ru2ew
    @Minnie--ru2ew 9 дней назад

    I agree with Indonesian speaker questioning the chinese speaker regarding her “data” on Bermuda.

  • @hubertkilat
    @hubertkilat 14 дней назад

    Try is a must.

  • @anncaballes
    @anncaballes 7 дней назад

    China follow the international law and everything will be in order.....

  • @erlindagloriamangabat1485
    @erlindagloriamangabat1485 8 дней назад

    How come there was no representative from the Philippines?

  • @Trust_me_bros
    @Trust_me_bros 14 дней назад

    Rule is for the weak😆😆 the old system has fallen.The new age will be shaped by big countries with military might..reunifications ,reclaimations and annexations ftw✊️✊️

  • @Jaguar-lr7jq
    @Jaguar-lr7jq 9 дней назад

    Isnt rappler anti america?

  • @JunGarate-sy4cv
    @JunGarate-sy4cv 11 дней назад +7

    Chinese Urguements about jurisdiction and your talking about 10 dashline is a big lie . Talking trush. Claiming is a big shiit...i suggest to you Chinese govt stop claiming

  • @beausky4100
    @beausky4100 7 дней назад

    This is a Global issue. go back to the first issue on why did China established a based over these islands, this is because of their self proclaimed Territorial Sovereignty (historical) claim, the 9 or 10 dash-line South China Sea demarcation. This was also the reason that China never appeared on the hearings and Arbitral Award in Hague, Netherlands because it was based on UNCLOS not their Historical claims. The issue here is whether or not to Internationally/Globally recognized China's territorial Sovereignty claims to be legal and binding. In the absence of this resolution, China will never respect nor honor UNCLOS and the Arbitral Ruling.

  • @rjvel542
    @rjvel542 10 дней назад +1

    this prof lei is know your place where is wps is and scs is.

    • @168lwk
      @168lwk 9 дней назад

      No such thing as a west Philippians don't invent lies

    • @168lwk
      @168lwk 9 дней назад

      No such thing as a west Philippines sea

  • @AmMixDog
    @AmMixDog 10 дней назад

    Blah blah blah.

  • @lv9657
    @lv9657 14 дней назад +2

    when the Philippines were colonized (that include all the other South East Asia countries - SEA), the colonizers didn't occupy nor include those islands in the South China Sea (SCS) as part of their territories. When these countries obtained independence they inherited the territories of their former colonial masters. China for thousand of years their fishermen has been occupied these island & when the Republic of China (ROC) was established in 1912, the then government officially declared their sovereignty on these islands via a map published which was then recognised by all the western colonial powers. That's how the 11 & now the 9 dash lines came about. RoC now administrating the Taiwan province, whereas the mainland China is by the People's Republic of China (PRC) which is the legitimate government of China.

    • @Pilipinoako763
      @Pilipinoako763 14 дней назад

      THAT 9 DASH LINE ONLY DRAWN BY KINDERGARTEN CHILD..WITHOUT COORDINATE...

    • @yanidilag8407
      @yanidilag8407 14 дней назад +4

      How about Vladivostok and the Russian Far East Military District that was part of the Ming dynasty?

    • @JunBermz
      @JunBermz 14 дней назад +10

      Never in the history of China that shows the Spratlys is theirs. Chinese people are not known as fishermen. Astronesians are the people occupying the Southeast Asia and its waters.

    • @JayMadayag-vd3je
      @JayMadayag-vd3je 13 дней назад +13

      Lol, we have map since 1700s and in that same yr the last territory of china is hainan.

    • @Minnie--ru2ew
      @Minnie--ru2ew 9 дней назад +1

      @@JayMadayag-vd3jeEXACTLY!

  • @GuillermoMartinez-y4b
    @GuillermoMartinez-y4b 13 дней назад

    U.S manipulating with printed monopoly money against China, U.S lecturing others of international laws that U.S do not respect but wants to force others to😅

    • @juanpedrosantiago
      @juanpedrosantiago 12 дней назад +6

      You just summarized what china is doing to the Philippines

    • @GuillermoMartinez-y4b
      @GuillermoMartinez-y4b 12 дней назад

      @juanpedrosantiago getting Philippine ship boats "wet"!?

    • @juanpedrosantiago
      @juanpedrosantiago 12 дней назад

      @@GuillermoMartinez-y4b let me summarize in case you just decided today to involve yourself in this issue:
      Here are some of the main issues:
      1. Nine-Dash Line: China claims nearly the entire South China Sea within a so-called "Nine-Dash Line," a boundary that extends far beyond China's mainland coast and into the exclusive economic zones (EEZs) of the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia, Brunei, and Indonesia. This line, which has no clear basis in international law, overlaps with waters and resources that international law designates as within these nations' sovereign rights.
      2. Claim to Philippine-occupied Features: China asserts sovereignty over features that the Philippines controls, such as Pag-asa Island (Thitu Island) and Panatag Shoal (Scarborough Shoal). These islands and shoals lie well within the Philippines’ EEZ, as per the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). This encroachment has led to confrontations, particularly around Scarborough Shoal, where Chinese Coast Guard vessels have blocked Filipino fishing boats.
      3. Construction of Artificial Islands: China has built artificial islands in the Spratly Islands, including Fiery Cross Reef, Subi Reef, and Mischief Reef, and militarized these structures with airstrips, radar systems, and missile defenses. Notably, Mischief Reef lies within the Philippines’ EEZ, but China has fortified it as if it were sovereign Chinese territory.
      4. 2016 Arbitral Tribunal Ruling: In 2016, the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) in The Hague ruled in favor of the Philippines, affirming that China’s claims within the Nine-Dash Line have no legal basis under UNCLOS. The ruling also declared that Mischief Reef, among others, lies within the Philippines' EEZ. China has dismissed the ruling, calling it "null and void," and has continued to assert control over the disputed areas.
      5. Harassment of Philippine Vessels: China’s maritime militia and Coast Guard have frequently harassed Philippine vessels, including Navy, Coast Guard, and fishing boats, within Philippine waters. Chinese ships have used water cannons, blocked Philippine supply boats, and conducted maneuvers that endanger Filipino personnel. This aggressive conduct aims to assert de facto control over the contested areas.
      6. Control Over Resources: By maintaining control over these regions, China has denied the Philippines access to its own resources, including rich fishing grounds like those around Scarborough Shoal and potential oil and gas deposits in the Reed Bank area. This denies the Philippines economic benefits from its natural resources within its EEZ.

  • @johnC2537
    @johnC2537 11 дней назад

    Yes

  • @RosalindaCubangbang
    @RosalindaCubangbang 9 дней назад +1

    Lei is out of logic and understanding!

    • @Minnie--ru2ew
      @Minnie--ru2ew 9 дней назад

      She’s a by-product of a dictatorial and communistic government. A puppet, no less. And she’s being put on a “reality orientation” by the other like-minded speakers. She’s out-of-touch with reality. She’s just staying in her office and mouths what she’s been spoon fed. Lei, your chinese boats are the ones ramming those small resupply boats.

  • @jimNavz3154
    @jimNavz3154 9 дней назад

    Miss Lei its because ur chinese u automatically counts the west philippines sea is ur territory ur absolutely wrong!