A Short Introduction to the Byzantine Empire - A Crusader Kings III Documentary

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 июл 2024
  • We sat down with Professor Anthony Kaldellis from the University of Chicago to talk about the Byzantine Empire, the medieval incarnation of the Roman Empire and the inspiration behind our upcoming expansion for Crusader Kings III: Roads to Power.
    Learn more about the history, system of government, and religions of one of history's greatest empires!
    00:00 - Introduction
    01:49 - Constantinople
    02:29 - A Shared Agenda
    03:31 - A Proper State
    04:29 - The Government
    05:09 - Dynasties
    06:17 - The Emperor
    07:43 - Names
    08:06 - The Army
    09:19 - Aristocracy
    10:11 - The Pronoia
    10:41 - The Church
    11:25 - The Byzantine Legacy
    __________
    #CK3 #CrusaderKingsIII #ParadoxInteractive
    Links:
    ✔ www.paradoxinteractive.com/
    ✔ / discord
    ✔ / crusaderkings
    ✔ / crusaderkings
    ✔ / paradoxinteractive
    RUclips Network:
    ✔ / @paradoxgrandstrategy
    ✔ / @citiesskylines
    ✔ / @stellarisofficial
    ✔ / @lifebyyou
    ✔ / @ageofwondersofficial
    ✔ / @worldofdarkness
    ✔ / @millenniagame
    ✔ / @heartsofironofficial
  • ИгрыИгры

Комментарии • 301

  • @sreckom92
    @sreckom92 11 дней назад +620

    "Medieval cities come in three categories. There's un-walled cities. There's walled cities. And there's Constantinople."
    Very well said. xD

    • @PerfectAlibi1
      @PerfectAlibi1 10 дней назад +5

      Didn't Rome itself also have pretty solid walls?

    • @sreckom92
      @sreckom92 10 дней назад +40

      @@PerfectAlibi1 Yes, Aurelian Walls were pretty formidable, even in Middle Ages. However, Theodosian Walls in Constantinople were still a different beast. Not only they were large in size, but also multi-layered, and with a huge garrison. Walls in Rome were also huge, but the city itself was a shadow of it's former self, meaning it's defenders could not muster nowhere near as powerful siege defense as Constantinople.

    • @robertc8425
      @robertc8425 9 дней назад +8

      @@PerfectAlibi1 Put it this way, imagine you are an invader, and you BERLY got up on the walls who are well defended, just to see you have 2 more walls to cross, i bet your moral will be 0 and everyone would flee.

    • @heatherwilliams6752
      @heatherwilliams6752 8 дней назад +1

      @@sreckom92 Very True that Rome was a shadow of its former self. it fell from like 1.2 Million people down to a measly 20,000 by the 1000's

    • @berkanefeyldrm8814
      @berkanefeyldrm8814 6 дней назад

      And then there is turks 😂

  • @ExtradaemonYT
    @ExtradaemonYT 11 дней назад +1389

    Funny how this video talks about how crucial a strong fleet was for defending Constantinople... for a game that doesn't include naval battles of any kind.

    • @CameronAB122
      @CameronAB122 11 дней назад +134

      Hopefully someday, with trade and maybe republics!

    • @giddyspiderboy
      @giddyspiderboy 11 дней назад +54

      It might be coming next year with republics (hopefully?)

    • @CameronAB122
      @CameronAB122 11 дней назад +44

      @@giddyspiderboy honestly I think Republic Mods are gonna be 1000% better than before just using Administrative as a base

    • @davidcohen4518
      @davidcohen4518 11 дней назад +3

      why would a medieval game include naval battles lmao

    • @ExtradaemonYT
      @ExtradaemonYT 11 дней назад +75

      @@davidcohen4518 Bro watch the documentary

  • @mathy4605
    @mathy4605 10 дней назад +248

    Very glad to see Julius Caesar himself explain the New Rome to us.

    • @ambarcraft4476
      @ambarcraft4476 5 дней назад +2

      Haha you are right, I didnt notice that before I read this comment.

    • @jeoffryfool5550
      @jeoffryfool5550 День назад

      In fact, the official name bestowed by Constantine was Nova Roma.
      Constantinou-polis ( a genitive/possessive City of Constantine) was the colloquial name attributed by the Greek speaking plebs, who were accustomed to naming thus Cities founded by powerful Generals/Military Leaders.

  • @Hunteromega
    @Hunteromega 11 дней назад +153

    Kaldellis rocking the Roman Fade haircut from the ruler designer

  • @kaloyanvankov8907
    @kaloyanvankov8907 11 дней назад +370

    Oh wow, I'm very happy to see Anthony Kaldellis here, honestly it gives me a lot of hope for the DLC

    • @filipefernandes870
      @filipefernandes870 11 дней назад +1

      same here!

    • @HansWurst1569
      @HansWurst1569 11 дней назад +7

      Why? Is he good at coding and comming up with game mechanics?

    • @philipbrening433
      @philipbrening433 11 дней назад +16

      ​@@HansWurst1569 he has a Medievalist podcast about Byzantium

    • @HansWurst1569
      @HansWurst1569 11 дней назад +3

      @@philipbrening433 what has him having a podcast to do with if the DLC will be good then?

    • @cadeturner2787
      @cadeturner2787 11 дней назад +35

      @@HansWurst1569 Essentially what I think he’s getting at is that paradox is doing its best to be true to Byzantine history and the way its society worked. Anthony Kaldellis is incredibly knowledgeable on the topic and sheds light on aspects of Byzantium earlier historians refuse to look at. So the mere fact that paradox includes him makes it seem that they are dedicated to produce something truly compelling

  • @Shadowfang1318
    @Shadowfang1318 11 дней назад +282

    Fire. Kaldellis and the Romans are a pair made in heaven

  • @enclavesoldier8893
    @enclavesoldier8893 11 дней назад +227

    “All political systems are based…” Too true, too true.

  • @aarengraves9962
    @aarengraves9962 11 дней назад +148

    Chad Greek historian explains Byzantium. WHAT ELSE DO YOU WANT?

    • @johntitor_ibm5100
      @johntitor_ibm5100 9 дней назад +14

      Chad Greek historian explaining Byzantium in period-accurate imperial regalia.

    • @user-cx6ku7zb1i
      @user-cx6ku7zb1i 7 дней назад +4

      a decent dlc that does not ripoff?

  • @cadeturner2787
    @cadeturner2787 11 дней назад +111

    Just seeing Kaldellis working with paradox made my hope for the dlc sky rocket

  • @nubnubdubdeh
    @nubnubdubdeh 11 дней назад +101

    THANK YOU FOR CALLING IT THE EASTERN ROMAN EMPIRE

    • @VoidLantadd
      @VoidLantadd 13 часов назад

      I'm honestly surprised they got Kaldellis to call them Byzantines at all lmao.

  • @Entropy114
    @Entropy114 11 дней назад +120

    I love this guy, I hope you have more from him in the future! He's very articulate and down-to-earth while tackling these really wide-spanning subjects. He clearly knows his stuff and I'd be interested to hear even deeper dives from him.

    • @CatastrophicDisease
      @CatastrophicDisease 11 дней назад +21

      He’s one of the most eminent scholars on Byzantium alive today.

    • @prazzlerazzle5565
      @prazzlerazzle5565 11 дней назад +8

      he has his own podcast where he interviews other historians!
      it is called Byzantium and Friends
      additionally he has done several interviews with The History of Byzantium podcast

    • @evanziavras7790
      @evanziavras7790 11 дней назад +2

      He's written multiple books including a recent complete history of Byzantium. I highly recommend them.

    • @Mingo_Slickgrin
      @Mingo_Slickgrin 9 дней назад +2

      I imagine he wanted to say even more but had his time managed. I would totally watch a three hour long version of this video if he brought the same energy throughout.

  • @bradley6357
    @bradley6357 11 дней назад +75

    Anthony Kaldellis wrote an amazing book on the Eastern Roman Empire!

    • @cathar1209
      @cathar1209 10 дней назад +12

      Actually, several books 😏

  • @matheus.bueno47
    @matheus.bueno47 11 дней назад +68

    The man himself, Anthony Kaldellis!

  • @byzantinetales
    @byzantinetales 9 дней назад +20

    Kaldellis is top! We are really glad and honored he has written book burbs in the back of our graphic novels. He's got a unique charisma to communicate history to a popular audience.

  • @GreenMarkoulis13
    @GreenMarkoulis13 9 дней назад +29

    God you brought Antony Kaldelis for this? You guys made the best decision that could be made, literally. Can’t wait for the expansion

  • @Fiaw1
    @Fiaw1 6 дней назад +8

    I hope this inspires people to read actual BOOKS on the Byzantine Empire.

  • @Henry-lv4uu
    @Henry-lv4uu 11 дней назад +32

    Seeing Kaldellis involved has made me very hopeful that the Romans will finally get the proper treatment. His books Romanland and the Byzantine Republic are A+

  • @heatherwilliams6752
    @heatherwilliams6752 8 дней назад +4

    One feature I love about ck3 that I bet hardly anyone else has looked back is how far back you can go when looking at the title of the eastern roman empire, you can even see Augustus and see all the traits he had if you want to design him and play as him and ruler designer, its awesome that you can go back that far.

  • @bergman22
    @bergman22 11 дней назад +30

    Prof Kaldellis! One of my favorite lecturers back at OSU, and a great writer and communicator. Glad to see him working with Paradox to give some history, nobody could be better!

  • @CaptainMyron
    @CaptainMyron 9 дней назад +20

    Μπράβο ρε Καλδέλλη. Είσαι μεγάλος μάγκας !

  • @TheDAWinz
    @TheDAWinz 11 дней назад +37

    the GOAT himself Anthony Kaldellis, fantastic video/collaberation

  • @jaylonhale5704
    @jaylonhale5704 6 дней назад +2

    God that ending picture sends chills such a glorious legacy

    • @Manuel-qu3tc
      @Manuel-qu3tc 6 дней назад

      DAMN I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE

  • @DarkSolace33
    @DarkSolace33 11 дней назад +13

    I LOVE HISTORY!

  • @timesnewlogan2032
    @timesnewlogan2032 2 часа назад

    I could listen to this guy talk about history all day.

  • @maxwellelkiss7039
    @maxwellelkiss7039 10 дней назад +17

    The Kaldellis-CK3 Collaboration is the highlight of this entire DLC. Please take my money, Paradox!

  • @lourencoxbfragoso
    @lourencoxbfragoso 11 дней назад +28

    Great to see Prof. Kaldellis! Nice work Paradox!

  • @dashwerm6181
    @dashwerm6181 9 дней назад +12

    Can we watch the full uncut interview somewhere? I can't get enough of listening to Anthony talk about Byzantium

  • @Ss97sand
    @Ss97sand 11 дней назад +29

    I went to a book shop to buy some books today, there was an infographic Ancient Rome book in the store. It looked amazing but I couldnt afford it.feelsbadman

    • @haristahir3472
      @haristahir3472 10 дней назад +2

      PIRATE IT!!.................................. then buy it when you have the money.

    • @sommmeguy
      @sommmeguy 2 дня назад

      Library?

  • @foswa6335
    @foswa6335 11 дней назад +7

    Beautiful video. Well made with amazing images.

  • @assisbisneto
    @assisbisneto 7 дней назад +1

    That is delightful. Thank you, paradox!

  • @rhysrphoto
    @rhysrphoto 8 дней назад +3

    Fantastic video, thanks.

  • @Daniel_Jones
    @Daniel_Jones 11 дней назад +18

    Seeing Anthony kaldellis is pretty cool. Been reading his new history of byzantium

  • @BaronVonMott
    @BaronVonMott 6 дней назад +4

    "I swear I'm not a Byzantophile."
    *3 drinks later:*

  • @Doc_Nick_
    @Doc_Nick_ 6 дней назад +2

    I love when you do these.

  • @McSnacks930
    @McSnacks930 3 дня назад

    I love this! More of these please!

  • @dogomog125
    @dogomog125 11 дней назад +13

    That's greek fire 🔥

    • @cyfix7295
      @cyfix7295 11 дней назад

      Jesus, The Greeks Even Claim That The Fire Is Greek .... 🤣Stop With The Irredentism PLS !!!

    • @dogomog125
      @dogomog125 11 дней назад +1

      @@cyfix7295 yes, This language is Greek, right? 🤣🤣🤣

  • @YarFeld
    @YarFeld 10 дней назад +1

    Really interesting! These sort of videos are a great addition to your content and hopefully show how much keeping to historical realism (as much as is possible in a game of course) is important to you guys as it is important to us players. Keep it up!

  • @maseola9091
    @maseola9091 11 дней назад +6

    유익한 영상이었습니다. 👍

  • @Doperwtje81
    @Doperwtje81 6 дней назад +1

    Being a huge fan of The History of Byzantium podcast, seeing Kaldellis in a CK3 vid is just wonderful!

  • @Muramasa1794
    @Muramasa1794 11 дней назад +4

    My God they got Anthony Kaldellis wow amazing

  • @Mingo_Slickgrin
    @Mingo_Slickgrin 9 дней назад +1

    awesome video!

  • @sommmeguy
    @sommmeguy 2 дня назад

    It's rare for a video game to inspire people to learn history. A great achievement by Paradox.

  • @rohitrai6187
    @rohitrai6187 День назад

    The music is so excellent
    Gives me goosebumps

  • @drakejameson3343
    @drakejameson3343 11 дней назад +1

    Great video guys, looking forward to the dlc

  • @thevoidlookspretty7079
    @thevoidlookspretty7079 10 дней назад +3

    Fun fact: I’m pretty sure every PDX dev and 3/4 of players could recite these facts offhand.

  • @MajorGore
    @MajorGore 11 дней назад +21

    Yes! Kaldellis!

  • @rexromanorum5767
    @rexromanorum5767 11 дней назад +7

    What an amazing video! It's the best 10-minute summary of the "Byzantine"/Roman Empire out there! Kaldellis is just magnificent!

  • @chaosspork
    @chaosspork 11 дней назад +16

    Nice! Kaldellis is probably my favorite historian! I love his books. I'm so glad you guys were able to get him for this.
    Was he one of the historians you got to consult on this expansion?

  • @roropiroro6425
    @roropiroro6425 10 дней назад +3

    There should be an artifact called "greek fire recipe" that allows the owner to recruit greek fire land units.
    The artifact would be hell expensive to maintain once reached its lifespan, as well the unit it provides, it would be hell expensive to recruit, upgrade, and maintain.
    Since it would be an artifact, pretty much any other character could plot to steal such a secret from you, and if the current owner decides to not maintain the artifact, then it is lost forever to the game.

  • @heatherwilliams6752
    @heatherwilliams6752 8 дней назад +1

    I can't wait for the DLC, seeing this and how accurate it was makes me very happy and in high hopes for how the DLC will turn out

  • @Marshal_Rock
    @Marshal_Rock 9 дней назад

    My god! What an awesome surprise!

  • @Nemenon
    @Nemenon 11 дней назад +10

    I'd love to see more of this guy, great video!

    • @twistedsteeltv6130
      @twistedsteeltv6130 11 дней назад +7

      He's got a new book out on the Byzantine Empire I recommend.

    • @kaloyanvankov8907
      @kaloyanvankov8907 11 дней назад +7

      He has a couple of great books on Byzantium, plus some good translations of primary sources and a fascinating podcast + he has appeared quite a bit on the "History of Byzantium" podcast. Great historian overall.

    • @prazzlerazzle5565
      @prazzlerazzle5565 11 дней назад +5

      he has a podcast where he interviews other historians
      Byzantium and Friends
      give it a listen

  • @thomasj3421
    @thomasj3421 5 дней назад +4

    Professor Anthony Kaldellis. Didn't expect this. Paradox is learning from the best.

  • @CarlosGomez-jl3jd
    @CarlosGomez-jl3jd 6 дней назад +2

    Dr. Kaldellis is is one of my great inspirations as a hopeful graduate student and its so cool to see him working with a game that I love. Bravo!

  • @alexanderhawk2659
    @alexanderhawk2659 9 дней назад +3

    Who is coming with me to liberate Constantinople?!

  • @Ricogator84
    @Ricogator84 6 дней назад +4

    Professor Kaldellis has some excellent books on Byzantium, and the History of Byzantium podcast by Robin Pierson is a well researched and incredibly thorough dive into the narrative of the Empire for those with a long commute :)

  • @thecritic860
    @thecritic860 6 дней назад +1

    Ahh, another Byzantine documentary, short it may be but I love it nonetheless, time to add it to the playlist XD.

  • @imhungryish8274
    @imhungryish8274 11 дней назад +2

    What's going on Big Tony! Good to see you're doing well.

  • @davidcoquelle3081
    @davidcoquelle3081 11 дней назад +4

    Ahh The lover of Manuel Komenos

  • @Proud2bGreek1
    @Proud2bGreek1 9 дней назад +1

    Let me forget about this... it's coming late September and I have to be reminded of the fact before July!

  • @command_unit7792
    @command_unit7792 11 дней назад +3

    Projection from Paradox...they need to release a documantery about the internal politics of Paradox Interactive now...

  • @georgewashington446
    @georgewashington446 4 часа назад

    love this video and this historian

  • @SignaturalHY
    @SignaturalHY День назад

    Byzantine Empire is the strongest playable faction in Crusader Kings III thanks to primogeniture and Constantinople, but rebellions, assassinations, and foreign invasions are so frequent that it's difficult for the family to maintain power.

  • @frankiecedeno3724
    @frankiecedeno3724 10 дней назад +1

    Man I really hope the Varangian Guard becomes interesting with the upcoming DLC

  • @Hazedfer
    @Hazedfer 6 дней назад

    PT BR CK3 !!!!!!

  • @kaanboztepe
    @kaanboztepe 11 дней назад

    more please

  • @Inderastein
    @Inderastein 11 дней назад +4

    First, also I wanna say: I wish that the game has this as a tutorial video for Byzantion.

  • @Maz97G
    @Maz97G 5 дней назад

    i would like to see a ceremony every time you get a new king and more

  • @ByzantineBob96
    @ByzantineBob96 11 дней назад +3

    omg they got Professor Kaldellis for this! Thats so awesome.

  • @ewbait
    @ewbait 6 дней назад +5

    You can tell how much Professor Kaldellis loves this! 🤣

  • @williamfogwell6799
    @williamfogwell6799 11 дней назад +1

    Just give me a working themata system! Kinda hope for that since they've mentioned the pronoia.

  • @surrog
    @surrog 6 дней назад

    Very interesting video :)
    But it's a bit weird to cut some image of him walking around or viewing him from the side, but drawings were really good.

  • @Imperial_Archives
    @Imperial_Archives 11 дней назад +1

    Very good video, can’t wait to play as the Romans in the new dlc!

  • @cathar1209
    @cathar1209 10 дней назад +3

    Well, well... Kaldellis is a staple of quality... now I'm intrigued.

  • @deathblades6257
    @deathblades6257 10 дней назад

    i would love to have that rug map on my king floor in ck 3

  • @jacobsummers2664
    @jacobsummers2664 День назад

    nice

  • @ShayGamerD3
    @ShayGamerD3 10 дней назад +1

    The guy is just fantastic. Good choice, Paradox!

  • @Onezy05
    @Onezy05 11 дней назад +1

    No way they got Kaldellis for this!

  • @solaraspect5255
    @solaraspect5255 6 дней назад

    My favorite guest on HoB. Is this this an omen of a redemption arch for CK3?

  • @stefanvas6984
    @stefanvas6984 11 дней назад +1

    As a die hard fan of the Byzantine Empire I can finally consider getting CK3. :)

  • @aqumuffins
    @aqumuffins 11 дней назад +3

    I love Kaldellis! Glad to see this collaboration. Read The New Roman Empire, it's a great book!

  • @NoeHernandezPe767
    @NoeHernandezPe767 11 дней назад +9

    Too bad Kaldellis, the contemporary authority on Romanía, wasn't consulted on the development of the thematic in-game system and it shows

    • @twistedsteeltv6130
      @twistedsteeltv6130 11 дней назад +6

      How would you do it or change the system they're implementing?

  • @1992zorro
    @1992zorro 11 дней назад +1

    hope they use the knowledge of this guy for game mechanics

  • @GeorgiosLeo
    @GeorgiosLeo 11 дней назад +3

    Great video!
    Finally a good analysis of Eastern Rome.

  • @monadsingleton9324
    @monadsingleton9324 10 дней назад +2

    *Babe, wake-up. Its time to restore the Roman Empire. In the Middle Ages. Again.*

  • @dr.gnomeson904
    @dr.gnomeson904 11 дней назад +8

    Kinda hard to believe that we had feudal Byzantium for 4 years

    • @steveng6721
      @steveng6721 10 дней назад +1

      Paradox is out here charging close to the price of full games for pretty much nothing but dlc flops

  • @Yoo-Kang
    @Yoo-Kang 11 дней назад +3

    You guys also do historical documentaries? as a gaming company????? sign me up

  • @BiesGorielyj
    @BiesGorielyj 11 дней назад +1

    Paradox, PLEASE hire Farya Faraji for the soundtrack!

  • @athanasiosmarkopoulos1128
    @athanasiosmarkopoulos1128 9 дней назад +2

    Ευχαριστώ ως ακροατής!

  • @Dustz92
    @Dustz92 11 дней назад +4

    11:07 I'm sure John II was great, but calling him jesus Christ may be a bit too much

  • @Natze13
    @Natze13 10 дней назад

    Can somebody tell me where I can find the last image of the emperor looking at the map of the Empire?

  • @RashidAli-fb3se
    @RashidAli-fb3se 5 дней назад

    the Byzantine empire did have nobility like noble titles of duke and count and Baron or Knight (more specifically a cataphract or some other name i don't now how to spell) and what not but when the title is referred to as a noble hereditary title it only has prestige and honor but when it is an office like comes and dux and there not hereditary there they give prestige and wealth but not hereditary and can be removed anytime by the emperor or for life if the emperor leaves them it is a bit similar China in which estates are granted sometimes but not for taxes but for renting like nobles renting their lands and maybe trade but without serfdom as in peasants can freely and easily move and they often did which is why rents where competitive and nobles did not charge a lot of rent as in comparison to other parts of feudal Europe even though farming and byzantine empire was more productive and advanced than in feudal Europe since they already used irrigation canals or methods and also the four field rotation system at that time even before England and many other info.

  • @eyepatchpirate7726
    @eyepatchpirate7726 8 дней назад +1

    I like the fact that they added the exact folio numbers and names of the manuscripts they used for the videos. As a Byzantinist, I must say this short doc is pretty epic. Props to Anthony.

  • @strategos5889
    @strategos5889 10 дней назад

    part 2 pls?

  • @giovannibraggs9223
    @giovannibraggs9223 9 дней назад +1

    Big fan of Dr. Kaldellis!
    Love his podcast.

  • @johnmavrakis2501
    @johnmavrakis2501 11 дней назад

    A small mistake in 11:06 the mosaic depicts Christ, the Virgin Mary and not other saints but the emperor John the second komnenos and his wife. They were never canonized as saints by the orthodox church

  • @yans4293
    @yans4293 10 дней назад +2

    Great to see the GOAT himself Kaldellis

  • @paulastalas8691
    @paulastalas8691 7 дней назад +1

    Robin Pierson when paradox?

  • @Kristaliorn
    @Kristaliorn 11 дней назад

    That was ace

  • @Ealdorman_of_Mercia
    @Ealdorman_of_Mercia 9 дней назад

    Can you make the music louder please, I think I could hear him a bit