Congratulations Carla! Besides being an excellent teacher you have the best standard European Portuguese pronunciation that I have heard in a long time. Your British accent is also very pleasant and clear. I vote that your way of speaking become the standard worldwide versions for Portuguese and English. The other day I noticed that you pronounced "frio" in a manner that I did not expect but that I had heard before. This lesson seems to support the most common alternative pronunciation. You may be correct and normally I would not have noticed it, except that nowadays I listen critically to Portuguese in an attempt to restore my former purist knowledge. Only for me. I am fine with Brazilian Portuguese and in many ways it is a more pleasant sounding version of Portuguese. I admit to being biased but no other language is as pleasant, to my ears, as standard European Portuguese when spoken by a good speaker. Keep up the good work!
I have watched almost 3 of your videos and have subscribed to your channel. Your lessons are unique and well-detailed. I really love this. You are a blessing to me. Am grateful.😊
This is amazingly helpful! Have been studying Portuguese at home for some time now and was a bit afraid I would never be able to pronounce it correctly since I'm learning it from a book and not from a teacher. Muito obrigada!
Happy to know it helps you, Nadia 🤗 our podcasts may be of help too, especially when it comes to pronunciation! You can find them all here: Portuguesewithcarla.com/podcasts
So clear and well explained. I was always curious about why Portuguese lyrics of songs appeared/sounded so different from what was written. I'm subscribing so I can learn more. I want to ask you about you accent in English: It sounds like UK Midlands, but with traces of Australian. Which is it?
Olá Frank, thank you for subscribing 😊 To find out where our English accent comes from watch this video: ruclips.net/video/UEwwZ2tfI-o/видео.html but I’ll just say that you’re guess is not bad at all 😉
Hello Carla, found your channel and decided to watch it all the way. We will be visiting Portugal in October for the first time. Looking forward to visiting your beautiful country. Thanks for the lesson! Oh, I just subscribed too.
This video explained it really clearly! That was awesome! I was looking for something like this. Also, for some reason I thought it was really funny when you said the word "fazem" with the wrong emphasis. I literally laughed out loud!
Carla, is a great thing to keep all these suggestions in mind! Obrigado pelo empenho e paciência! É um grande prazer ouvir-te! 😉 Keep the good work! 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
For me this is where language starts very important thank you very much Carla. Anymore on the Portuguese IPA would be greatly appreciated. After which if it's possible incorporating verb/noun phrases with these sounds to learn the sound & vocabulary. Sorry I'm needy. Then the little bits that are often used...joining words, pronoun, positioning etc to make sense of the sentence. Maybe you've already done this or maybe this is part of a paid course.. I realize your time is valuable. TY again.
Olá William, we’re glad you’ve enjoyed this video 🙂 most of what you’ve mention is included in our members only program, The Journey. You can learn more about it here: portuguesewithcarla.com/start
Ola Carla I am new to your channel still not getting my reading in order. This video is a big help and if you can do something with more examples will be amazing
Olá 😊 I’m glad this video has helped you a little. This lesson is actually part of our members only program called The Journey. I think our podcasts might be of further help to you. You can find them all here: portuguesewithcarla.com/podcasts/
Oh really? That is funny 😄 I generally hear it it being pronounced they way I did, even in the north of the country. Saying that, you’re way also sounds ok to me 👍🏽
I wish you all the best with your English learning, Célio ☺️ you just need to make sure you have plenty of exposure to the language and try to practice regularly (daily, if possible!)👌🏽
Thanks Carla for your amazing videos. I´m a big beginner, new to Portugal, only 3 months. And I really need to learn this language. I have started learning on youtube but I need to have people to speak with. would somebody like to meet and practice sometimes? Carla, if I want you to teach me, is it possible in person (I am in Lisbon) or you only have online classes?
Olá 👋🏽 muito obrigada 🥰 I’d would be happy to teach you, but I don’t live in Portugal and even for the online 1-1 lessons I’m not taking on any new students as we’ve been focusing more on our online course The Journey which many feel is very personalised. If you wish to receive more info on that go to: portuguesewithcarla.com and register your interest (bottom of the page).
Como professor e nortenho, considero que chamar o Português do norte de Portugal um "não standard" é um overstatement... mas se for pela quantidade de pessoas que o fala, então sim, podemos considerar que o sotaque do Centro-Lisboa-Sul é mais standardizado porque mais pessoas o têm.
Olá Bonnie and thank you for your comment 🙂 I guess I didn’t think of it because that was not the element of the language I was trying to teach, but I agree it would help you even more. Saying that, you could create an exercise from it as it’s going to have an even greater impact on your memory if you yourself write a list of the words (nouns) mentioned here; look them up on infopedia.pt, look for “masc.” (masculine) and “fem” (feminine) and then add the correct article to each one of them 🙂
There are exceptions to the diacritics rule: àquela, àquele, àquilo or àqueloutro and their declensions are still stressed in the antepenultimate syllable.
@@portuguesewithcarla One can argue that these are not exceptions as àquela, àquele, etc are simply contractions of "a aquela, a aquele , etc". This is the only way to reproduce the sound of what would happen in spoken Portuguese. Just a thought.
Co-meu has 2 syllables and because the “u” is at the end we put emphasis on the “meu” part which counts as one syllable. For instance the masculine word for “my” is “meu” and that’s a 1 syllable word (em Portuguese: palavra monossilábica) 👍🏽
Do Portuguese speakers think of these rules when speaking or do they most often just pronounce the word the way they have heard it pronounced? The rules are useful when a person encounters a word that he or she has not seen before. It reminds me of the idiots who think children learn to read with phonics. People use phonics when they encounter a word they have not seen before, otherwise people use the "look, say" method. Thanks for the video and the rules.
@@ogator8642 I am a Portuguese native speaker. Portuguese is second nature to me. I don't think about the rules while I am speaking. For instance, I pronounce the word " Economia" a bit different than Carla. I pronounce the two oo like u Good- like those oo. Do you think of these rules when you speak in your native language?
@@Theyoutuberpolyglot Até em português, digo uma palavra como a ouvi ser dita. Às vezes, acho que todo mundo tem seu português. Acho que os portugueses começaram a fazer isso para enlouquecer os espanhóis.
@@ogator8642 Ninguém enlouquece a ninguém. Cada lingua é diferente. Dentro de cada lingua há sotaques e dialetos. Em portugal, todos falamos mais ou menos da mesma maneira, embora haja algumas diferencas na gramática, vocabulario ou até mesmo na pronuncia. Eu tenho o meu português, eu uso o vós com muita frequencia. Para alguns portugueses, os do norte do país, falam uma linguagem arcaica. Em espanhol há duas letras que tornam malucos/as a qualquer aprendente que quer aprender o espanhol. Essas letras são B e v, há duas mais que soam igual até certo ponto. C e z- Zoo, cereza. A c de casa é diferente a essa c de cerveza. O chino é muito mais dificil que a minha lingua, já que eles usam tons. Por não falar da lingua arabe. Eles não falam a lingua oficial. Em cada cidade fala-se duma maneira muito diferente. Os dialetos amendrontam-me
@@ogator8642 obrigada eu por assistires ao vídeo e partilhares a tua opinião. No, the Portuguese don’t think of these rules when they’re speaking, even because we learn to speak before we learn to read. However as they learn to read and, as you say, encounter words for the first time in the written form, then they may have to pause for a sec and refer back to these rules, even if they don’t actually and consciously know them, the unconscious brain should have a pretty good idea. As for those learning to read Portuguese as a foreign language, the tendency, and especially when seen for the first time, is to subconsciously apply the rules of their mother tongue to the reading of words in the target language. Hence the reason for this video 🙂 And thanks again for commenting 👍🏽
Olá amiga! Tenho dificuldades de pronunciar as palavras em português de Portugal. No nosso caso nós Timor-Leste temos muitos dialetos por isso dificulata- nos a pronunciar. Sou timorense, nosso país fica localizado no Sudeste asiatico e nosso país eis colônia portuguesa. Pode me passar o seu IG. Queria melhoras o meu português com Amiga.
Olá, Sebastião 🙂 se tem dificuldade com a pronúncia, então os nossos podcasts poderão ser úteis: ruclips.net/p/PL14iWyw1DOrHzJKgVHtIQXuss2KyFbga7 Bons estudos! 😊
I've never heard this explained so clearly. Thank you Carla.
Very helpful! Thanks Carla! 🥰Blessings from South Australia💕🐨
Congratulations Carla! Besides being an excellent teacher you have the best standard European Portuguese pronunciation that I have heard in a long time. Your British accent is also very pleasant and clear. I vote that your way of speaking become the standard worldwide versions for Portuguese and English.
The other day I noticed that you pronounced "frio" in a manner that I did not expect but that I had heard before. This lesson seems to support the most common alternative pronunciation. You may be correct and normally I would not have noticed it, except that nowadays I listen critically to Portuguese in an attempt to restore my former purist knowledge. Only for me. I am fine with Brazilian Portuguese and in many ways it is a more pleasant sounding version of Portuguese. I admit to being biased but no other language is as pleasant, to my ears, as standard European Portuguese when spoken by a good speaker. Keep up the good work!
I really appreciate your comment 🥰Obrigada, Carlos!
Muito obrigato voce es excellent teacher! DEAO DE TAIWAN
🤗
I have watched almost 3 of your videos and have subscribed to your channel. Your lessons are unique and well-detailed. I really love this. You are a blessing to me. Am grateful.😊
@@grayjulius2265 im glad you’re finding our content beneficial to you 🤗
É muito bom ouvir o português corretamente. Parabéns 👏
☺️
This is unbelievably useful! I’ve only just started Portuguese today and the pronunciation is a little bit overwhelming so far.
Pronouncing Portuguese words can be tricky.. 😅 but I’m super glad to know you found the info in this video helpful 😊
So helpfull, i did not know till i watch your video how to pronaunce. That will take time to give up my bad habits by reading. Muito obrigado
We're glad the video was helpful! Keep practicing, and we're sure you can continue improving. 😉Muito obrigado 🥰
Like the way you approach the subject. Just enough but not too much analysis, makes it pretty easy to understand and remember.
I’m pleased to hear you find my teaching easy to follow 🥰
Thanks
Obrigada pela vídeo que é tão útil mostrar aos alunos e ser usado numa aula de português! Obrigada, Carla! Abraço desde Macau!
This is amazingly helpful! Have been studying Portuguese at home for some time now and was a bit afraid I would never be able to pronounce it correctly since I'm learning it from a book and not from a teacher.
Muito obrigada!
Happy to know it helps you, Nadia 🤗 our podcasts may be of help too, especially when it comes to pronunciation! You can find them all here:
Portuguesewithcarla.com/podcasts
I am very happy to be in touch with the class! and I've been learning many things. God bless you!
Im really pleased to hear that and wish you all the best with your learning journey 🤗
Thanks so much!
So clear and well explained. I was always curious about why Portuguese lyrics of songs appeared/sounded so different from what was written. I'm subscribing so I can learn more.
I want to ask you about you accent in English: It sounds like UK Midlands, but with traces of Australian. Which is it?
Olá Frank, thank you for subscribing 😊
To find out where our English accent comes from watch this video: ruclips.net/video/UEwwZ2tfI-o/видео.html but I’ll just say that you’re guess is not bad at all 😉
Wooow,this is so so so clear ,Never understood this till now, thanks alot,I feel like I know have a strong base after this video
Muito obrigado Carla! I love everything about this video: the clear explanation, the examples, the pace, your voice. Top quality content 👍👍👍
Thanks so much, Collin 🥰
Thank you!! So tough such a beautiful language
Little and often and it will get easier 😉
i love your work
.
Really helpful! Great video as usual! Obrigada Clara!
Carla, parabéns pelo teu canal!
Thank you so much for making this video!!!!
Hello Carla, found your channel and decided to watch it all the way. We will be visiting Portugal in October for the first time. Looking forward to visiting your beautiful country. Thanks for the lesson! Oh, I just subscribed too.
Olá 😊 thanks for subscribing! And very happy to hear you’re watching all our videos - I’m sure this will help you a lot with your trip to Portugal 🤗
Muito obrigado Carla. Eu estou a aprender e moro na Califórnia USA.
This video explained it really clearly! That was awesome! I was looking for something like this. Also, for some reason I thought it was really funny when you said the word "fazem" with the wrong emphasis. I literally laughed out loud!
Obrigada 😊😁
Carla, is a great thing to keep all these suggestions in mind! Obrigado pelo empenho e paciência! É um grande prazer ouvir-te! 😉 Keep the good work! 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
De nada ☺️ e obrigada 😊
Es linda........Muito obrigato
Boy this was a great video. The explanation is very clear. Thank you!
Thanks, Ivan 😊
Thanks. Great presentation
For me this is where language starts very important thank you very much Carla. Anymore on the Portuguese IPA would be greatly appreciated. After which if it's possible incorporating verb/noun phrases with these sounds to learn the sound & vocabulary. Sorry I'm needy. Then the little bits that are often used...joining words, pronoun, positioning etc to make sense of the sentence. Maybe you've already done this or maybe this is part of a paid course.. I realize your time is valuable. TY again.
Olá William, we’re glad you’ve enjoyed this video 🙂 most of what you’ve mention is included in our members only program, The Journey. You can learn more about it here: portuguesewithcarla.com/start
dear Carla really good explain and great teaching style thank you so much
De nada, Suji ☺️
That was fantanstic
and smile remarkable......bonita
That’s very kind of you ☺️
Absolutely great video, Carla! Thank you. I have subscribed to enjoy and benefit from your teaching. :)
Thanks a lot 😊 how are you getting on with the other videos?
Muito obrigado Carla pela licao util! 👍
Ola Carla
I am new to your channel still not getting my reading in order. This video is a big help and if you can do something with more examples will be amazing
Olá 😊 I’m glad this video has helped you a little. This lesson is actually part of our members only program called The Journey.
I think our podcasts might be of further help to you. You can find them all here:
portuguesewithcarla.com/podcasts/
First video and I love your personality #subscribed
🥰
2:08 it's funny the way you pronounce " Economia". I pronounce the two oo like u.
Oh really? That is funny 😄 I generally hear it it being pronounced they way I did, even in the north of the country. Saying that, you’re way also sounds ok to me 👍🏽
@@portuguesewithcarla Eu pronuncio essa palavra desta maneira “ Ecunumia” - Economia- um bocadinho diferente a tua pronúncia.
@@Theyoutuberpolyglot sim, eu percebi 😉
I love you so
Good teaching. Suppose it'll be more helpful to demonstrate how the strong syllable reads, or sounds, in a sentence.
HI! My name is Celio. I'm from Brazil, I'm learning English and I need to speak English native with from USA.
I wish you all the best with your English learning, Célio ☺️ you just need to make sure you have plenty of exposure to the language and try to practice regularly (daily, if possible!)👌🏽
Thanks Carla for your amazing videos.
I´m a big beginner, new to Portugal, only 3 months. And I really need to learn this language.
I have started learning on youtube but I need to have people to speak with.
would somebody like to meet and practice sometimes?
Carla, if I want you to teach me, is it possible in person (I am in Lisbon) or you only have online classes?
Olá 👋🏽 muito obrigada 🥰 I’d would be happy to teach you, but I don’t live in Portugal and even for the online 1-1 lessons I’m not taking on any new students as we’ve been focusing more on our online course The Journey which many feel is very personalised. If you wish to receive more info on that go to: portuguesewithcarla.com and register your interest (bottom of the page).
Como professor e nortenho, considero que chamar o Português do norte de Portugal um "não standard" é um overstatement... mas se for pela quantidade de pessoas que o fala, então sim, podemos considerar que o sotaque do Centro-Lisboa-Sul é mais standardizado porque mais pessoas o têm.
Na escola primária a minha professora ensinou nos a descobrir qual a silaba tónica se gritasse mos a palavra
Acho que tivemos a mesma professora 😁
Can i say R as you said RR in spain to speak in portugal sound more like RR not like EKH?0
It is a great help but it will be better if you put the article of each word too.
Olá Bonnie and thank you for your comment 🙂 I guess I didn’t think of it because that was not the element of the language I was trying to teach, but I agree it would help you even more. Saying that, you could create an exercise from it as it’s going to have an even greater impact on your memory if you yourself write a list of the words (nouns) mentioned here; look them up on infopedia.pt, look for “masc.” (masculine) and “fem” (feminine) and then add the correct article to each one of them 🙂
There are exceptions to the diacritics rule: àquela, àquele, àquilo or àqueloutro and their declensions are still stressed in the antepenultimate syllable.
Just as they say: there are no rules without exceptions! Thanks for pointing that out 👍🏽
@@portuguesewithcarla One can argue that these are not exceptions as àquela, àquele, etc are simply contractions of "a aquela, a aquele , etc". This is the only way to reproduce the sound of what would happen in spoken Portuguese. Just a thought.
Could "comeu" be considered as having three syllables, with the accent on the"e"?
Co-meu has 2 syllables and because the “u” is at the end we put emphasis on the “meu” part which counts as one syllable. For instance the masculine word for “my” is “meu” and that’s a 1 syllable word (em Portuguese: palavra monossilábica) 👍🏽
@@portuguesewithcarla Muito obrigado!
Nice video. If they overrule all other pronunciation rules, should have started the lesson with the diacritics!
Obrigada 🙂 since most words do not have diacritics I decided to start the lesson with those!
Is this Portuguese from Brazil?.
It’s Portuguese from Portugal 🙂
Can you take closer look video of your face so that we can see clearly of your face and mouth movement when you speak. ?
Do Portuguese speakers think of these rules when speaking or do they most often just pronounce the word the way they have heard it pronounced? The rules are useful when a person encounters a word that he or she has not seen before. It reminds me of the idiots who think children learn to read with phonics. People use phonics when they encounter a word they have not seen before, otherwise people use the "look, say" method. Thanks for the video and the rules.
@@ogator8642 I am a Portuguese native speaker. Portuguese is second nature to me.
I don't think about the rules while I am speaking.
For instance, I pronounce the word " Economia" a bit different than Carla. I pronounce the two oo like u
Good- like those oo.
Do you think of these rules when you speak in your native language?
@@Theyoutuberpolyglot Até em português, digo uma palavra como a ouvi ser dita. Às vezes, acho que todo mundo tem seu português. Acho que os portugueses começaram a fazer isso para enlouquecer os espanhóis.
@@ogator8642 Ninguém enlouquece a ninguém. Cada lingua é diferente.
Dentro de cada lingua há sotaques e dialetos.
Em portugal, todos falamos mais ou menos da mesma maneira, embora haja algumas diferencas na gramática, vocabulario ou até mesmo na pronuncia. Eu tenho o meu português, eu uso o vós com muita frequencia.
Para alguns portugueses, os do norte do país, falam uma linguagem arcaica. Em espanhol há duas letras que tornam malucos/as a qualquer aprendente que quer aprender o espanhol. Essas letras são B e v, há duas mais que soam igual até certo ponto.
C e z- Zoo, cereza. A c de casa é diferente a essa c de cerveza. O chino é muito mais dificil que a minha lingua, já que eles usam tons.
Por não falar da lingua arabe. Eles não falam a lingua oficial. Em cada cidade fala-se duma maneira muito diferente.
Os dialetos amendrontam-me
@@ogator8642 obrigada eu por assistires ao vídeo e partilhares a tua opinião.
No, the Portuguese don’t think of these rules when they’re speaking, even because we learn to speak before we learn to read. However as they learn to read and, as you say, encounter words for the first time in the written form, then they may have to pause for a sec and refer back to these rules, even if they don’t actually and consciously know them, the unconscious brain should have a pretty good idea.
As for those learning to read Portuguese as a foreign language, the tendency, and especially when seen for the first time, is to subconsciously apply the rules of their mother tongue to the reading of words in the target language. Hence the reason for this video 🙂 And thanks again for commenting 👍🏽
Take upper part of your body video including your hands movement wiii be good enough.
This was so Brilliantly done that I think I have hope. Thanks a lot Carla.
😀 De nada!
Olá amiga! Tenho dificuldades de pronunciar as palavras em português de Portugal. No nosso caso nós Timor-Leste temos muitos dialetos por isso dificulata- nos a pronunciar. Sou timorense, nosso país fica localizado no Sudeste asiatico e nosso país eis colônia portuguesa. Pode me passar o seu IG. Queria melhoras o meu português com Amiga.
Olá, Sebastião 🙂 se tem dificuldade com a pronúncia, então os nossos podcasts poderão ser úteis: ruclips.net/p/PL14iWyw1DOrHzJKgVHtIQXuss2KyFbga7
Bons estudos! 😊
@@portuguesewithcarla Queria melhorar isso
@@portuguesewithcarla pode me passar o seu IG?
@@sebastiaodacosta2161 do you mean my Instagram? If so, it’s “portuguesewithcarla”.