The Qur'an vs Zakir Naik: Is Music Allowed in Islam?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 19 окт 2024

Комментарии • 36

  • @denizucar3947
    @denizucar3947 18 дней назад +2

    In my humble opinion, the reason why it is said that music is haram, are the frequences and words that can influence your mind. But at the other side, there are books like the Communist Manifesto from Marx, which caused horror like nothing. Movies can influence you. Tales can influence you. Now is reading a book haram? Is watching a movie haram?

  • @mehdimouhmy1882
    @mehdimouhmy1882 25 дней назад

    Subhan Allah, thanks for sharing Jazak Allahu khair ❤

  • @dushonhare262
    @dushonhare262 Месяц назад +3

    I don’t question the holy Quran, if Allah doesn’t say that music is forbidden . Than I’m good, I know not to listen to certain types of music.

  • @heididickens9924
    @heididickens9924 Месяц назад +2

    Ok, so if music is not allowed why is the tambourine allowed? They are talking from both sides of their mouths. Yup hypocrites.

  • @truthseeker545
    @truthseeker545 Месяц назад +1

    There is no mention of Music or Instruments in the Quran, The Adhan is music, the ways of Recitation is also music. Nice Job Brother.

    • @miriamllamas224
      @miriamllamas224 15 дней назад

      That's what I was thinking. The intonation in the recitations sounds to me like music and helps me to remember the surahs better.

  • @questioneverything7011
    @questioneverything7011 20 дней назад

    The Hadiths on music contradict each other. One says musical instruments aren’t allowed.. then the other the prophet allowed these two girls play the tamborines lol

  • @xack-t1s
    @xack-t1s Месяц назад

    MIND is trapping also in RECREATION AFTER DISSOLUTION.. A trap for those who are waiting waiting and waiting..
    For real GOD EVERYTHING IS NOW

  • @xack-t1s
    @xack-t1s Месяц назад

    Those going deeper to understand the real Speech of GOD the sounds, will usually get s involve in the beauty of music..usually Sufis.. MIND is the preventer, preventing us from going forward to understand deeper knowledge on sounds n melodies

  • @elbowstancenow1519
    @elbowstancenow1519 Месяц назад +2

    Unfortunately, this millioaire Doctor Bozo was given a PR status in my country after he ecaped India.

  • @xack-t1s
    @xack-t1s Месяц назад

    Ibnu TAIMIYYAH was the first that mention that real Speech of GOD was SOUNDS.. Those having this strength in their revealations are the king. The 5 sounds

  • @mounsalif6213
    @mounsalif6213 23 дня назад

    As salam how do you offer your salah without the authentic sayings of the prophet sallalahu alayhi wa salam

    • @SaidMirza
      @SaidMirza  23 дня назад

      ruclips.net/video/WUaYWzJ2VNQ/видео.htmlsi=LdYkhyKNn4ZPxJJk

    • @mounsalif6213
      @mounsalif6213 23 дня назад

      ​@@SaidMirza Are you telling me you are more knowledgeable about the deen of Allah than the scholars or are you of the opinion that they are deviant. We should be really careful about what we believe and promote to people, we only got one chance at life. “Indeed in the Messenger of Allah Muhammad (Peace be upon him), you have a good example to follow.”Qur'an 33:21. How can you and I who didn't live at his time truely follow him (SAW) without the preserved sayings and actions (Saheeh Hadeeth).
      "O believers! Obey Allah and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. Should you disagree on anything, then refer it to Allah and His Messenger, if you ˹truly˺ believe in Allah and the Last Day. This is the best and fairest resolution." Qur'an 4:59. May Allah guide you and I to the truth and keep us firm upon it ameen.

    • @nadiamahmoud4496
      @nadiamahmoud4496 17 дней назад

      اذن الله فرط فى الكتاب

  • @xack-t1s
    @xack-t1s Месяц назад

    Kun faya kun is creativity of MIND tied to time n space only

  • @xack-t1s
    @xack-t1s Месяц назад

    UBNU TAIMIYYAH DID MENTIONED SPEECH OF GOD ARE SOUNDS

  • @sumbals
    @sumbals Месяц назад

    For the matters we face in these times only have to use common sense those were not the issues faced by people in times of prophets i find it strange and stupid at the same time reading questions like applying nail color or music etc Quran opens up our thinking process upgrades makes you independent yet we are kept away from this Book … conspirators played their role well

  • @highendcustomdesigncaraudi1777
    @highendcustomdesigncaraudi1777 20 дней назад

    Zakirnaik knows very well about allhas punishment. Just for the money.

  • @mashrafi157
    @mashrafi157 Месяц назад

    Not much is forbidden by God really

  • @xack-t1s
    @xack-t1s Месяц назад

    You can t understand creation n dissolution tru kun faya kun, it s limit s you to time n space only.
    Creation is tru real names, the 100th names, dissolution is also tru this names.

  • @birolsay1410
    @birolsay1410 Месяц назад

    👌🏻

  • @xack-t1s
    @xack-t1s Месяц назад

    THE 100TH NAMES ACTUALLY ARE BOUT SOUNDS AND MELODIES, THE 5 SOUNDS.. BUT THE 100TH NAMES NOT REVEALED IN QURAN.. GOD S REAL SPEECH ARE SOUNDS..
    ISLAM IS MIND NOTHING ELSE.. THE ENTITY THAT IS PREVENTING US TO GO NEAR THE DEEPER KNOWLEDGE OF SOUNDS, IS THE MIND

  • @xack-t1s
    @xack-t1s Месяц назад

    MIND IS PREVENTING US TO GO NEAR TO UNDERSTAND DEEPER ON SOUNDS, THE REAL MANIFESTATIONS OF REAL GOD

  • @NedimTabakovic
    @NedimTabakovic Месяц назад

    Cool