@@Jay2012jan02Film is an art. A form of entertainment and sending a message to society. Not just to fool. Fooling is what magicians do. Understand basic things and then act smart.
कडी मेहनत करके ये रिपोट आप ने बनाया । बहुत चालाकी से अनेक फिल्मों के छोटे छोटे कहानियों को जोडकर एक पुरे सोले फिल्म बनाया गया था । ये जानकार मुझे बहुत अच्छा लगा । इस के लिए आप को बहुत धन्यवाद ।
Even if it is inspired from 25 films, I don't mind, that they have created an Epic. I Wish any other writer, let him take inspiration from another 50 films and create another Epic as good as Sholay. Regarding this film not only author, but director, music director also inspired from others. Anyway it is a great Indian Film. Thanks for the makers of this video also. They have done Good work and identified so many things.
Sholay is movie, where i find similarities to western films, i thankul for that, and even Sergio Leon's "dollars trilogy " inspired by a Japanese film " Yojimbo " , i was shocked again then i start see Japanese cinema 😂
complete sholay is remake of ramesh sippy's fathers *khote sikay* amitabh role was danny's, dharmendra do ke ranjit, villain ajit, tagore role independent feroz khan, constable role modified to asrani as jailer. but sholay's direction, screenplay, camera, music and casting and acting were magnificent
Copying from other movies & blend it to suit Indian platter is also an art . One such example is of Firoz Khan's Dharmatma which is made from The Godfather .
Inspired or Copied...If it's Sholay then it's inspired...If it's any of the Priyadarshan Movies...then it's Copied...When Taliban fought the Russians..They were called as Freedom Fighters but when the same Taliban fought against the Americans...they were called as Terrorists
Bollywood has been copying Hollywood and other countries films for about 70 years, I used to watch Hindi movies when I was young, they were decent family dramas not now.I stopped watching Bollywood films about 45 years ago, but people in India will never go forward and stop watching these rubbish films, Bollywood actors know these uneducated Morans will continue to make them Rich for years to come.
Very good research. As soon as I saw the first part I couldn't wait to get to the second one. As a fan of western I got to know more about that I have yet to watch.
IT IS COMMON KNOWLEDGE THAT WRITERS AND FILMMAKERS TAKE IDEAS FROM EVERYWHERE TO CREATE A SCRIPT AND MAKE A MOVIE STILL NO MATTER WHAT THE SCRIPT OF SHOLAY WAS NOT A EASY TASK SALIM JAVED PROVED THAT THEY CAN DO IT BETTER AND ALSO WITHOUT DHARMENDRA SHOLAY WAS NOT POSSIBLE
The scenes were copied but what I liked about it that copy was done to make a masterclass for Indian audience. The way all scenes from different movies are in-cooperated was itself class. Magnificent Seven came in 1960 was the foundation of story line on which everything was placed to solve a puzzle.
Its not new for us, our film, songs, music, our fashion industry, our tv serials, most of them copied from here and there, its not a big deal sab chalta h
एक और फिल्म तुम भूल गए। सूरमा भोपाली का एक शॉट दिलीप कुमार की मधुमती से लिया गया था। जहां सूरमा भोपाली जय वीरू को पकड़ने की डींगे हाँकता है, और वो पीछे खड़े सुन रहे होते हैं। 😂
Film Sholey ka aik aur dabang scene hai, jis me Gabbar Singh ka mash'hur dialogue "Kitne aadmi the Sambha .... tera kya ho ga Kaaliya? Ye poora scene Pakistan ki aik Punjabi movie ka copied scene hai.
The coin tossing (Sikka uchalneka scene) "the professional" movie ja copy hai...infact mera gaon mera Desh movie too copied that scene from "the professional"....
jinko janata ne sir pe utha liya tha.. woh sab chor he.. chor.. they are not artist by far... you can say they are clever /shrewd businessmen. inhe artist maanane ki galati na kare... baat yeh he ki uss waqt aisi chori karana aasan tha.. logonko world cinema ya regional cinema ki jaanakari nahi thee.
sholey is better than all these english movies.have you seen hindi movie hamraj of boby devol that also copy of english movie perfect murder yet hamraj is better than that.
Yes, It was originally from Alfred Hitchcock Dial M for murder (1954) before that it was Broadway play, 1) Dial m for murder was - straight suspens Thriller 2) a perfect murder was - dramatic with 90s thriller style 3) Hanraz was more like melodramatic with Abbas mastan style All of them have improvisation
The seven samurai by Akira Kurosawa is the grandfather of all these movies 😎
Salim Javed had access to world cinema and have fooled many Indians. Even now his kids make mash up of many movies and create a hindi cinema...
Acha? Hollywood khud European cinema copy krta h
Whole movie business is to fool, just fool, not aimed at who is fooled....
Ridley Scott copied from Satyajit Ray. His flim Alien. Get full knowledge kid. Then come to comment.
@@Jay2012jan02Then why you get fooled? Don't watch movies.
@@Jay2012jan02Film is an art. A form of entertainment and sending a message to society. Not just to fool. Fooling is what magicians do. Understand basic things and then act smart.
कडी मेहनत करके ये रिपोट आप ने बनाया । बहुत चालाकी से अनेक फिल्मों के छोटे छोटे कहानियों को जोडकर एक पुरे सोले फिल्म बनाया गया था । ये जानकार मुझे बहुत अच्छा लगा । इस के लिए आप को बहुत धन्यवाद ।
Thanks for posting and connecting the dots!
Even if it is inspired from 25 films, I don't mind, that they have created an Epic. I Wish any other writer, let him take inspiration from another 50 films and create another Epic as good as Sholay.
Regarding this film not only author, but director, music director also inspired from others. Anyway it is a great Indian Film.
Thanks for the makers of this video also. They have done Good work and identified so many things.
Don't conflate plagiarism with inspiration. Sholay is ,sadly, shamelessly copied movie.
@@vinay249they should have mentioned the names of the originals in their credits. Shows their lack of class.
Epics are those which are original...at max you can say that they have arranged the copied pieces well to create a good movie for Indian audiences
I must add that the concept of Double-headed coin was from 'A Man Called Amen'
I think in all India no one of creative movie writer all indian film industry are making copies movies. 😂😂
I think you haven't heard of Satyajit Ray, Shyam Benegal etc. Typical chuutiyas of Pakistan 🤣🤣
Sholey is fusion all old English
Classic cowboys movies.
Sholay is movie, where i find similarities to western films, i thankul for that, and even Sergio Leon's "dollars trilogy " inspired by a Japanese film " Yojimbo " , i was shocked again then i start see Japanese cinema 😂
complete sholay is remake of ramesh sippy's fathers *khote sikay* amitabh role was danny's, dharmendra do ke ranjit, villain ajit, tagore role independent feroz khan, constable role modified to asrani as jailer. but sholay's direction, screenplay, camera, music and casting and acting were magnificent
Copying from other movies & blend it to suit Indian platter is also an art . One such example is of Firoz Khan's Dharmatma which is made from The Godfather .
😀😃😄😁😆😅🤣😂😋😛😜🤪😝🤑
और मन्दिर वाला शॉट, जहां धर्मेन्द्र शिव जी की मूर्ति के पीछे खड़े होकर बात करता है, वो दिलीप कुमार की गोपी फिल्म से लिया गया था।
Good job to expose copy pasters...
Magnificent 7 was copped from 7 samurai.
How did you get all the various scenes? Compliments
Watching these movies and finding some videos
By copying others
Whole bollywood is full of copy remakes. Including from South Indian movies.
Well, i cant agree more with you
Inspired or Copied...If it's Sholay then it's inspired...If it's any of the Priyadarshan Movies...then it's Copied...When Taliban fought the Russians..They were called as Freedom Fighters but when the same Taliban fought against the Americans...they were called as Terrorists
Bollywood has been copying Hollywood and other countries films for about 70 years, I used to watch Hindi movies when I was young, they were decent family dramas not now.I stopped watching Bollywood films about 45 years ago, but people in India will never go forward and stop watching these rubbish films, Bollywood actors know these uneducated Morans will continue to make them Rich for years to come.
morons*
Even the maker of film Ranga Khush claimed that role of Ghaber was copied from his movie
Once upon a time in the West - from 1960s Western Spaghatti era
Gawar se soorma bhopali ka seen ..Gopi se mandir wala seen..sab chori Kiya inhone
Very good research. As soon as I saw the first part I couldn't wait to get to the second one. As a fan of western I got to know more about that I have yet to watch.
Then why did you see SHOLAY? I LOVE IT AND WILL ALWAYS LOVE IT.
The Magnificent Seven, was released in 1960.
Love you bhai
Background music is original
Sabne hame fool banaya hai music, story, direction copy paste Bollywood ka dusra naam hai
IT IS COMMON KNOWLEDGE THAT WRITERS AND FILMMAKERS TAKE IDEAS FROM EVERYWHERE TO CREATE A SCRIPT AND MAKE A MOVIE STILL NO MATTER WHAT THE SCRIPT OF SHOLAY WAS NOT A EASY TASK SALIM JAVED PROVED THAT THEY CAN DO IT BETTER AND ALSO WITHOUT DHARMENDRA SHOLAY WAS NOT POSSIBLE
to ap bhi bana dijiye na sholay
100% copy hai lekin phir bhi achchi hai.😊
You missed Akira Kurusova’s film Seven Samurai which inspired all the movies you compared with Sholay
Songs also Copied.
Before Sholay mera Gaon mera Desh and Khotey Sikkay came
Javed Akhtar ka gyan suna hai?
Gyan nahi bakchodi
Magnificent Seven, is of 1960, not 1980.
Perfect
The scenes were copied but what I liked about it that copy was done to make a masterclass for Indian audience. The way all scenes from different movies are in-cooperated was itself class.
Magnificent Seven came in 1960 was the foundation of story line on which everything was placed to solve a puzzle.
Its not new for us, our film, songs, music, our fashion industry, our tv serials, most of them copied from here and there, its not a big deal sab chalta h
One director who agrees that nothing is original and he copied including BGM is Ramgopal Varma.
Jay and viru was from buchbcassidy and sun danve kid
Thanks 😊😊😊😊😊
Amazing Sholay maker with Amazing scenes from 12 Hollywood movies copied by GP Sippy & Ramesh Sippy...
एक और फिल्म तुम भूल गए।
सूरमा भोपाली का एक शॉट दिलीप कुमार की मधुमती से लिया गया था। जहां सूरमा भोपाली जय वीरू को पकड़ने की डींगे हाँकता है, और वो पीछे खड़े सुन रहे होते हैं। 😂
1979 mien jab mai kuwait mien tha tab sholay copy hai Hollywood filmo ki kaha tha lekin ketne filmo ki yeh sabit nahin kar sakah
Sholay is copy of Mera Gaon Mera Desh ...
😢😮😅
The magnificent sevan 1980 meain release huni thi ...sholey 1975 main release huin thi
It's 1960 increase video quality sir
Magnificent seven has been remade several times. Please do your research.
Maine lagbhag sare orinigal seen dekhe hai par relgadi ki race wala kahi nahi mila
O sab thik hai ..dobara Sholay jaisi film q nahi bani. Na banegi ..❤
Jag deep comedy was from Ganga jamna
12 movie ka ek mai hi jugad kar liya
Sholay jaise movie na kadhi bani na kabhi banega
Film Sholey ka aik aur dabang scene hai, jis me Gabbar Singh ka mash'hur dialogue "Kitne aadmi the Sambha .... tera kya ho ga Kaaliya? Ye poora scene Pakistan ki aik Punjabi movie ka copied scene hai.
Movie ka naam kya hai
Best copy ever
Sholey nahi copypestoley hai, new name hai😊
The coin tossing (Sikka uchalneka scene) "the professional" movie ja copy hai...infact mera gaon mera Desh movie too copied that scene from "the professional"....
That scene was origilay from scarface 1933
Sholay1975
Magnificent 7 is 1980????
1960
नकल के लिए भी अकल की ज़रूरत होती है.
Sholay is superior to all
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣Sholay is easily the worst amongst all. Tried to copy these incredible films and failed miserably
But Sholay directed was better even acting was better....
No thats what you thinks over daatic acting is not acting 😂
Yes.. becz we r new to see dis type of characters and story...
Sholay is copy of Mera Goan Mera desh is correct
Some copied OO7 that was all.
Can’t beat English movies
Maa baap ko pyar
Darr bhi asi film hai
Naqal karne ke liye Aqal bhi chahiye.
Bolly directors ko creative aqal nahi hai..tabhi naqal karke viewers ko fool banete hai
jinko janata ne sir pe utha liya tha.. woh sab chor he.. chor.. they are not artist by far... you can say they are clever /shrewd businessmen. inhe artist maanane ki galati na kare... baat yeh he ki uss waqt aisi chori karana aasan tha.. logonko world cinema ya regional cinema ki jaanakari nahi thee.
You know who is your father
Ones upon time in the west 1988 bata rhe ho aur sholay to 1975 me bani thi.
It's 1968
This is true Bollywood copied movie's Shure and more indion movie's copied Pakistani movies and songs and Hollywood and others
Sholay is copied from hindi movie Mera gaon mera desh.
Inspired nahi chorays hai,
Don't post ❤❤❤ bro-because its my big B MOVIE
so what!!!%is this supposed to put me off Sholay?%never
Many thanks to info ab m sbko batunga salo kaha kaha se copy krke hutiya banaya h
YOU ARE EDUCATED BY COPYING GUIDES AND OTHERS
Indian movies har movie copy
He karta he
Also copied from macennas gold
sholey is better than all these english movies.have you seen hindi movie hamraj of boby devol that also copy of english movie perfect murder yet hamraj is better than that.
Yes, It was originally from Alfred Hitchcock Dial M for murder (1954) before that it was Broadway play,
1) Dial m for murder was - straight suspens Thriller
2) a perfect murder was - dramatic with 90s thriller style
3) Hanraz was more like melodramatic with Abbas mastan style
All of them have improvisation
Salim Javed dono chori Kiya aur bade bade baatein kartey hai
চুড়ি করা গল্পঃ
Never Mind. Copying ideas to make a better movie is good. Copying the whole movie is totally wrong. SHOLAY IS A MASTERPIECE!
Most of the films 🎥 songs 🎵 etc copied from Hollywood world 🌎 movies 🎬 yesterday today and tomorrow 😀 😄 only copy cats 😅😂