Trek Madone Gen 7 vs. Specialized Tarmac SL8
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 ноя 2024
- Shop Online - www.thebicycle...
Sorry about the editing error. Tunnel of trees should be segment two. But here are links to the two rides.
Hill Climb
www.strava.com...
Tunnel of Trees Flat segment
www.strava.com...
Follow us on Instagram!
Shop - / thebicyclestation
Jeffersonville - / thebicyclestation_jeff
Jesse - / jesse_bicyclestation
Chase - / chase_opecycling
Trey - / treyshepard1
Grace - / gracewashburn
Jimmy - / thejimmyryan
eBay - www.ebay.com/u...
PinkBike - www.pinkbike.c...
Email - sales@thebicyclestation.com
Great video because you didn't focus on the data and measurements like many YT videos do, and instead had a free rolling conversation about the *feel of the bikes* under different circumstances... which is exactly how the rest of us think (rather than w/kg, wind tunnels etc.). Thank you.
Thanks!
I've watched so many videos trying to get a sense of how these bikes ride and always end up with the "it feels stiff, it feels fast" answer, but this video finally described it in ways I could understand.
Glad we can help! Feel free to reach out if you have more questions
I currently ride a Tarmac SL 6. I think the Madone looks amazing, and if I were in the market for a new bike, I’d probably switch. Great video!
I picked up a Madone gen 7 SL7 Ultegra with the RSL bars as an upgrade to my current gen Emonda and I could instantly tell why most guys riding the TDF for Lidl-Trek stuck with the Madone even in the mountain stages. It's a faster, better bike despite the weight
I got my 2023/24 madone slr gen7 down to 16.6lbs with ultegra and tpu inner tubes..it feels faster than my 2022 sworks tarmac sl7..the bontrager aeolus saddle is sooooo comfortable compared to my power pro mirror saddle..
@@LOGICAL-JAY❤
Madone looks better and from the test seems also has better performance and comfort.. thanks for the video!
Spesh dropped the ball on that stem/spacer/HT area. Wonder who greenlighted that design.
Also, appreciate the honest review. 👍
Finally..lol..i swapped frames yesterday..i gave up my 2022 s-works tarmac sl7(blue lagoon w stripes) for my new madone SLR gen7 in all matte black..i really didnt want to give up my tarmac but it beats me up after 40miles..i needed more comfort with the speed..plus this is my 4th tarmac..😅
Bonjour, j'ai un Tarmac S-Works SL6 en Dura-Ace freins patins et voudrais peut-être passer sur un Madone SLR aussi avec Dura-Ace. Il paraît que le confort est encore meilleur ! Pouvez-vous me confirmer que le Madone est aussi bon en montée ? Mon S-Works est à 6,8kg ...
I think that difference might come down to the difference of the rolling resistance of the tires, I noticed that the madone has a gp5000 str on it, which the tire itself has a way lower rolling resistance compared to the one on the tarmac, so that may be the reason why the madone was slightly faster? Kinda funny to see how bike frame itself doesn't really make that much of a difference while changing the tire could change alot.
Pogacar said the same thing! He rode in TdF on GP 5000 TT which is lighter still but more prone to punctures.
It is conti 5000 str and difference to sworks tires is nearly 7w so tarmac s quicker
Great test and review, Madone 👍
Being from Wisconsin i'm partial to Trek and would love a Madone! To be fair though I honestly feel Trek and specialized are the top two in the game at the moment and hard to go wrong with a Specialized as well. Looking forward to more videos like this.
Yea honestly I think the Madone kinda exceeded my expectations a bit and the Tarmac is as good as you’d expect it to be haha.
Brainwashed by american marketing
What do you mean by that?
I started riding during Covid, after my research Trek won. Domane sl5 to sl6, hopefully my next bike in 2024 is the Madone. First time watching your channel thank you 👍🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👑kRT
First time I've watched this channel...loved your approach and report. Uber useful as I own the 2023 SLR 7 gen 7 and i have a number of friends on the SL 8: They've been asking about ride quality and you don't know what you don't know, so it nice to get a review that tells me in real time the subjective details of that experience. Also, I've owned my new madone for 4 months (came from a madone sl 6) and without fail, every 5min or greater segment is conquered 5% faster with 5% less watts...amazing! Can't explain it except what they tell us in the marketing
Tried my friend Domane, became a Trek fan. When we meet up, the first thing I do is reach for his Trek. It’s so comfortable. Trek is comfortable
I have to give kudos to you guys for a great and honest review. Most reviwers out there are guided by bias, commercial interest, promotions, etc. You just told us the absolute truth and by the way, you were spot on your opinions. I just has the oportunity to test ride both of these bikes and I agree with you for the most part, the Tarmac is a great bike but it is not the most comfortable (shock absorbing) bike out there and it is a bit "nervous" in the descents and even that it is lighter and stiffer that the Madone or my current bike (Colnago C59) I never fekt that I was going stronger or faster than the other ones. The Madone is a bit heavier but is so much more shock absorbent than the Tarmac and even than my trusted Colnago, climbs and descents well. So I am going to be looking for one !
Love the look of the madone ♥️
Love this format. Awesome video guys!
I can see from the video, that the Madone has a Continental GP5000 (top tyres), and Tarmac hasn’t the same.
That could explain the difference time and confort.. what do you think about?
It is exactly 6w difference so probably tarmac is faster.you can check it on roling resistance test.conti 5000 str vs sworks tires
around 3:40 when you display comparison data, you should keep the data overlay on the left so that the data can be viewed side by side, without having to go back a few seconds to see the other bike's data.
really looking at the madone SL6 gen 7. like the look and always looking for comfort and speed.
Do the Scott foil!! Also do the canyon aeroad!!
good video, surprised to hear the comfort comment. i have a gen 6 Madone SLR which is very comfortable but climbs like a dog (or feels that way at least). i had been pondering a Tarmac for the more snappy ride but reflecting on that a bit now.
is dog climbing fast or slow? haha.. some dogs are fast
@@twowheelsandcroissant i’m powering it, so more English Bulldog than Greyhound for sure! Lol
What a great video…. I don’t often sit through longer videos but this one had me captivated. Full of interesting content, well done guys…. subscribed 😀😀👍
the tarmac alone has looked great to me... but having them side by side, wow the Madone wins the beauty contest ... that speed snoz w the skinny dropped seat stays, gotta be the worst looking tarmac yet!.. AND less aero? lol more character? for the the bike you already know everyone's going to have next season... yall sold me on the madone
Tough choice! Both fantastic bikes. I'm an aero boy, though, so Madone for me.
At 4% gradient aerodynamics is more important than weight. This could be why the madone is faster than the sl8. Also, tire rolling resistance. Another key point is how big is the rider. If you are a light smaller dude, weight is everything climbing, watts per kilo, but if you are big, like me, 2 pounds is not noticeable in 4-6% climbs
I just bought a SL8 to be good on those hills and this video kills my dreams 😂
It honestly made me mad. Rest assured that you have the better climbing bike lol.
@@bicyclestation listen I chance my Aethos thinking on what they say about the Turmalet test, so idk now if cry or get Trek haha
@@denisaraujo86dude! You’ll have the Roval cockpit on yours? in your size, slip on some Vitoria corsa pro’s 28mm, the SL8 will blow your mind! Comfort, speed, agility! The handling is sublime! Let me know how long it takes on your 1st ride before you laugh out loud at how good it is! (10 mins max) 🥂
Just keep whispering under your breath: I think I can, I think I can - I know I can
please do a comparison Trek Madone Gen 7 vs Cervelo S5
Which one is more durable in terms of speed?
I've just changed S-Works SL6 to Spesh Tarmac SL7, what a difference, bike is heavier by ~800g but way stiffer and direct (feels better and it's faster on climbs), already done 212km gran fondo and a few >150km rides.
If you end up comparing the Madone to the S5 perhaps use a longer flat to rolling course; 3-5 miles with turns.
great video and the results are interesting. If you run these comparisons in the future, I for one would prefer to see comparisons with the same wheels/tires swapped between the bikes. I understand the logic of wanting to show more stock setups, but the wheel/tire combo has far too much impact on the comfort, climbing speed and flat speed to not eliminte these differences by using equal tire/wheel setups.
I just swapped my Parlee for the Madone SL Gen 8. Incredible ride.
The Madone definitely looks more aero. So it should win the flat. On the climb the speed was over 13mph and it wasn't steep at all at 4.5%. I think that the speed of the climb allowed the aero advantage to win over the weight penalty. I have seen a video stating that you start getting aero gains at 15Km/H, they just didn't say how much those gains were. They obviously increase with speed. I take it that is why even on the steep climbs in the Grand Tours they alwasy have a leadout as they are getting some drafting even if it is only a very small percantage of energy saved.
Will you test the super six evo?
By the way excellent constructive realistic comparison.
Thank you
Got the SLR 7 as a crash replacement. I have to look at my wheels periodically to make sure I'm not flat because of how buttery it rides.
I'm riding tarmac sl8 in the same color. I can't believe tarmac was beaten on uphill regardless of the ride feeling. Maybe 4.5% hill climb isn't steep enough for the lightweight, snappy bike to shine, and madone have an edge over tarmac on that moderate uphill?
Different tires totally badly done test.tires make a huge difference
Did the SL8 have the stock 26c tires? Sounds like it would benefit from a set of 28s or maybe even 28 FR, 30 RR. Would like to see longer segments for the testing if possible, maybe like a rolling terrain vs flat terrain but more like 20 or 30 minute segments, most of the brands talk about savings over an hour, even then its often only a few seconds. Sure you could extrapolate things out but when the differences are so small, wonder if its a margin of error, rather than an actual difference.
Both bikes used 28mm tubeless tires pumped to the same pressure
@@treyshepard1717 not the same tires, way different rolling resistance. smh
Cool vidya, interesting results! You know you're digging for critiques when the worst that can be said about a bike is that it makes whooshy noises 😂
Interested in the wheelset ID/ tire pressure on both bikes during testing. I'm sure they were run fairly close but it could remove a variable from the mix.
Beauty is in the eye of beholder. To me, there is no comparison when putting SL8 side by side with the Madone. The madone is so much more sexy then the sl8. It is like comparing a lamborghini with a subaru wrx. Both are very fast car, but boy, they are world apart when come to look. I think specialized need to hire some italian designer to design their next sl9.
Its more like lambo vs audi or porsche. I think most people like simpler bikes, the madone will look weird in a few years.
Awesome video, I trust the science! 😂 I have the Trek Madone SLR 6 AXS Gen 7, in Fighter Jet Silver. The looks I get from the soccer moms are worth it 😂. Great balls of 🔥 Iceman!
I am not concerned about which bike is faster, as the difference is only a matter of seconds. Ultimately, I prefer the Madone because it looks better, thanks to its more aerodynamic frame.
The PEOPLE have spoken. We say “MADONE”🚴🏻♂️🚴🏻♂️🚴🏻♂️🚴🏻♂️
Both bikes look great! Curious, have you ever built a Trek Domane RSL? Yes, the RSL race version and not the SLR….wonder how it would compare to those 2 bikes?
Yes. I think it’s so sick.
I just went from a Tarmac SL7 to Madone SLR 7 Gen 7. The difference is jaw dropping for me. I never bought into the hype of the different type of bikes making THAT much of a difference. Boy was I wrong. The Madone is definitely like riding a Ferrari. Plus mine is also that Ferrari red! 🏎️
The difference is so small, it could come down to powermeter differences.
I think that’s the real take away. Both bikes are amazing.
A great reason why Trek bikes are amazing machines to ride with 💪
I don't care about the results... I'll choose madone over any other bike on the planet because of how gorgeous it looks...❤ The madone looks like a proper superbike thanks to the aerodynamics(tbh somewhat similar to the ALR system used in Lambos lol)
It really is beautiful
Pretty much, refuse to drop that kind of cash on a boring bike, I'll make up for any speed deficits in the weight room and cop that Madone, that Venge, that Foil, that Ostro Vam
I hate it to be honest lol. But not judging cause it seems majority of the people love the looks of the madone. Just not for me I guess.
Then again I don't like SL8 either 🤣
Madone looks like a real aero bike and the blue with black top tube sweet
I put a set of new bora ultra wto c23 on my madone slr. Feels even smoother and faster. Still interested in adding a tarmac sl8 in my collection but do you guys think it’s a good idea?
The Madone is missing the aero-shaped spacers on the steerer. 🤔
Bike shops hate Canyon... but Canyon Aeroad CF SLX versus that Madone. This is a great matchup in terms of both aero performance and comfort.
Canyon is interesting. The company does a lot to slow their sales so it doesn’t bother me too much. Honestly I think trek and specialized should let me ship complete bikes directly also and then everyone would be on equal footing.
If we had one I’d 100% make a video about it. The channel isn’t big enough to justify purchasing a bike we don’t sell currently but hopefully that changes in the future
I wish you can repeat this test in a higher gradient.
This was a very useful practical (and goofy/funny) video. Thanks
Please repeat the test on longer and steeper climbs
We live in Indiana idk how we’d accomplish that lol.
My 2019 S5 is comfortable and fast. But I've only ever ridden it and my Fuji lol .
Wow!! The Entry Level Madone Gen7 wins against the S-Works!! What if you compare the Madone SLR 9 with the same price against the Specialized??
That is an slr 9
I have the new Madone SL7 Gen 8. It’s friggin awesome. Fastest bike I’ve ever ridden
I like the Madone way better. The way you describe the ride of the Tarmac sounds like my TCR. I like the bike, but it is a bit chattery on any road imperfections.
Looking good on both bikes....
The RSL 62 are not at all meant for slope climbs and hence would be more sluggish.
I think if we tried the Madone SLR gen 7 with Duraace Di2 9270 with the RSL 37s, the bike would feel different
and perhaps livelier when compared to the SL8 - Rovals.
Believe the SL8 is a really taut bike from what I have read from feedback / reviews and possibly SWorks' best
iteration yet but taut bikes generally are less comfortable for long haul rides for us enthusiasts - old news they are meant
to go fast but lose out a little on the comfort.
I've owned and ridden the various iterations of Trek's top end Madones through 12 years now and they may
not be the last word in tautness and responsiveness compared to SWorks, but they strike an excellent balance
for their 5th to 7th Generation Madone SLRs in terms of speed AND long haul riding comfort. Still can't be beat so far.
I never found the need to buy another make since I was happy riding my Madones.
Your channel is excellent
Interesting test though, both Tarmac and Madone came with a newly developed integrated aero handlebar and I'm wondering why you guys didn't use them
Because they don’t make sizes that fit treys position. We talk about that in the tarmac review video a bit
For real, I think Specualized fazed out the Venge to save on manufacturing cost, was never convinced that the SL8 is faster, no siree
To be fair, 4% grade isn’t much of a climb. I think all the math nerds will say weight starts playing a bigger role at 6%+. If you’re gonna measure the impact of weight, prob could try a steeper hill
I can already see the comments about how this is not fair because the Madone comes with a narrower bar which affects body position which affects aero. That’s true, and if specialized want to claim “aero is everything” they shouldn’t spec truck sized bars on their “fastest tarmac ever”
We point that out in the tarmac review. It’s kinda an old school bar shape.
@@bicyclestationI have old school 42cm bars on my other bike and they feel unnatural after only a few hundred miles on the Madone. Did a 3:45 ride on the Madone yesterday 65 miles and 5200ft and no discomfort with the stiff frame or narrow bars AND beat a lot of my climbing PRs by a good margin. It’s a winner!
Trey here! We didn’t mention it in the video but we had both bikes specd with 380mm bars, just from two different brands.
@@treyshepard1717I guess there’s no excuses for spesh now 🤡
Can I just ask where you guys are located ? That looked a lovely part of the world to live and cycle.
Southern IN
One store in Columbus and one store in Jeffersonville
Love the Madone. Supersix Evo next?
“Similar in that the cables hang out the bottom and they aren’t that cool looking” 😂
Madone has never won in terms of data, but has never lost in actual evaluations. It is definitely one of the best bicycles on the market, which makes me even more convinced that Trek doesn't need to pay for advertising to those data evaluation companies.🤣
Nice video! What's the size of the tires on the Madone?
We used 28mm tires on both bikes!
try same test with aethos s works pls
What was the tire setup -brand/tube/psi etc? for each?
Guys gone are the days when we could afford to buy a great bike and ride it like it was a perfect fit and comfortable that we could ride it all day long. All this fancy way overpriced bikes are a real buzz kill! Thank God I bought my Cervelo R3 and trek Madone when they were affordable! They are 10 years old and still loads of fun to ride for miles and miles…. The industry needs to give us great comfortable bikes at least $1 to $3k again.
That was very enjoyable
love this do more with other top tier brands please.
could you do another test with isoflow taped on ?
Is the seat thingy on the trek breaking a thing? Saw it broke when they first released it.
I see so many Tarmac’s in Colorado, but very few Madone’s. I’ve often wondered why Trek doesn’t seem to appeal to racer community??
If the Madone got rid of that clear weak point at the base of the seat post, I’d be in.
My 2022 Litespeed T1sl will run circles around both of these bikes on all levels in all ways
Make a video comparing them!
Both bikes are fully, fully capable, so probably comes down to a couple personal preferences. I love your honest takes on both bikes. Great unique vid!
I own a Madone, so may be biased... but is that a live railway track you're standing on buddy?
Call the train cops
I'd like to see the system six vs bmc time machine
I would have thought the S-works would have won the climb...after seeing the Madone even beat it on the climb, I knew it was over. The Madone wasn't going to lose on flats or descents.
It would if they had a same tires
Am I The only one doubting on the value of strava numbers? No wahoo/Garmin nrs available?
but nice vid!
What are wahoo/garmin nrs?
Can you advise what colour the Madone was?
If that's an SLR, What happened to the stock handlebar?
They don’t make one that works for treys bike fit
As Shoddy Dave would say, that was a fooking shoddy. test... but it's as good as you're gonna get. 🤣 Seriously though, it was perfect.
Haha yea we know. We are bike salesmen and mechanics, not scientists. Still a really fun video to make
Why no aero Cockpit on the Madone!
They don’t make the correct size for treys bike fit so he doesn’t have them on either bike.
I ride a Domane every day, EVERY DAY, and it's the only bike I can see doing that on at 46yo. Any others?
I would choose the tarmac because it is easier to resell it on the market when I want to get a new bike. The trek really looks good, but it doesn't seem worth money. The over $5000 sl model is still over 8kg.
Yes we probably should have touched on that. The used market is flooded with Madones its kinda funny.
How does this compare to cervelo s5
what size was that madone
Both bikes are 58s
mega vid, but wish you had put in timestamps for this. keep killing it guys!
Ive never tried to do that before. Well look into adding them!
I think overall it's a good thing, sure there might be some downside to it. It would give a great overview and a small notch up giving the vid a pro look, and also a person who are looking into buying one of these bikes, would want to be able to go back and forth in timestamps to rewatch parts to help further them in the decision process @@bicyclestation
LoL… “your moms house” … 😂 this review is pure. 🤓🤘🏻🤘🏻👍🏻💯🔥
Specialized folks gone be mad about this one 😂
madone all day, comfort and speed.
What is the size of the Madone frame? Tks.
58
How tall are you riding the 58? Im 5'10 thinking i need a 56@bicyclestation
Trey has super long legs. That’s why he’s one a 58. I ride a 56 at 5 11
@@bicyclestationwhat height is trey exactly?
Wheel Specs, Tires & Air Pressures?
Wheel specs were mentioned in the video and both bikes were running 28mm tires at around 70psi
Did not hear internal & external widths of the wheels? - Same tire brands? Thanks for size & psi
Isn't that an SL7 on the video? :D
It’s an sl8?
@@bicyclestation With an old cockpit? It has separate stem and handlebar.
so 4 min 30 sec is 270 sec, and 3 sec faster is ~1% - you never thought of imputting a possible error of measurements into your test process?
The Tarmac !!! Only and for ever Tarmac !!!